KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Fridman’s $16 Billion Claim Against Luxembourg: What Sanctions Arbitration Means for Frozen Assets in France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Fridman’s $16 Billion Claim Against Luxembourg: What Sanctions Arbitration Means for Frozen Assets in France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 22 September 2026, the Council of the European Union prolonged its individual Russia sanctions for an unprecedented 36 months, until 22 September 2029, covering more than 3,000 listed persons and entities. The same decision quietly dropped two of the most famous names on the list: metals tycoon Alisher Usmanov and Alfa Group co-founder Mikhail Fridman. Behind the second delisting stands a legal claim with no precedent: Fridman is suing Luxembourg for $16 billion before an arbitration tribunal in Hong Kong over the freezing of his Alfa Bank holding company and his LetterOne investment vehicle. It is, as the case monitors put it, the first known ISDS case against Luxembourg, brought under the Belgium-Luxembourg&ndash Russia bilateral investment treaty. Luxembourg's prime minister has publicly acknowledged that his government pushed for Fridman's removal from the EU list to avert harm to the country. This article explains, from a Paris practice perspective, how that arbitration works, why Brussels agreed to the delisting bargain, and what — concretely — changes for frozen bank accounts, creditors and court challenges in France.

The story matters in Paris for a simple reason. France is one of the places where EU sanctions bite hardest in practice: Paris banks freeze the accounts, the Treasury's Directorate General (Direction générale du Trésor) grants or refuses release authorisations, and the Paris enforcement judge (juge de l'exécution) decides whether a creditor can touch frozen money. When a listed billionaire sues the very state that froze his assets, every actor in that chain — banks, buyers, creditors, listed persons — needs to reassess its position. A companion analysis published on this site on 22 September 2026 covers the delisting deal itself in detail (EU Delists Usmanov and Fridman but Freezes Sanctions Until 2029); this piece takes the next step and dissects the $16 billion arbitration behind it.

I. How can a sanctioned billionaire sue Luxembourg for $16 billion over an EU freeze?

A. What is Fridman's Hong Kong arbitration case against Luxembourg really about?

Mikhail Fridman belongs to the first generation of Russian oligarchs. In the 1990s he built Alfa Group with his partner Petr Aven, founded Alfa Bank — which became Russia's largest private bank — bought a Siberian oil company, formed a joint venture with BP and eventually sold out to Rosneft. In the late 2000s he restructured a considerable part of his empire under a Luxembourg holding company, and in the 2010s he founded the investment company LetterOne, also headquartered in Luxembourg. When Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, the EU added Fridman and Aven to its individual sanctions list within days, on the ground — among others — that they were leading businesspersons providing a substantial source of revenue to the Russian government. In compliance with the EU measures, Luxembourg froze Fridman's assets in the country, including the holding company for Alfa Bank, much of the rest of his business empire and LetterOne.

Fridman's answer was not limited to the Luxembourg courts in which listed persons normally challenge their designation. He activated a second front: investor-State dispute settlement (ISDS) against Luxembourg itself. As the monitors of the case summarise, He is using ISDS to sue Luxembourg, which has frozen his assets – and demanding a gigantic $16 billion payout. The demand is denominated at $16 billion, roughly €14 billion. To grasp the scale: This is a preposterously large amount – equivalent to half Luxembourg's entire central government revenue. It is also only slightly above the $14.9 billion fortune Forbes attributed to Fridman in 2025 — in substance, the claim asks Luxembourg taxpayers to hand him back nearly his entire estimated wealth.

The legal vehicle is the bilateral investment treaty (BIT) between the Belgium-Luxembourg Economic Union and Russia. An investor protected by that treaty who considers that the host State has expropriated his investment without compensation can bring the State before an international arbitration tribunal instead of — or in parallel with — domestic courts. Fridman argues that freezing his Luxembourg holdings amounts to expropriation and calls the EU sanctions regime a witch-hunt against Russian businesspeople. The case is hosted at the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre (HKIAC), which does not publish information on its cases, so the public record depends on press reporting and leaks. One technical feature is already known and legally significant: the Belgium-Luxembourg–Russia treaty is relatively restrictive, so Fridman reportedly relies on its most-favoured-nation (MFN) clause — the mechanism by which an investor borrows a more favourable provision from another treaty signed by the same State — to open the tribunal's doors to this type of claim. Whether an MFN clause can import dispute-settlement consent for a sanctions dispute is one of the most contested questions in investment law, and the tribunal's answer will be read far beyond this file.

The political charge of the case is what makes it exceptional. ISDS routinely reviews environmental measures, mining permits or public-service regulation; here it is asked to review decisions taken on the ground of war and peace — the implementation of collective economic measures adopted in response to a war of aggression. If the claim succeeded, every EU Member State holding frozen Russian assets could face copycat claims, and the amounts would stack up quickly. That systemic risk explains why Luxembourg's attitude toward Fridman's EU listing changed so visibly in September 2026.

It also explains why Fridman's litigation runs on two parallel tracks that must not be confused. Before the EU courts in Luxembourg — the General Court — Fridman and Aven already won a first round: by judgments T-301/22 and T-304/22, the Court found that the reasons for the designations were not sufficiently substantiated and their inclusion on EU sanctions lists was not justified and annulled the acts that subjected Mr Fridman and Mr Aven to sanctions for the period from February 28, 2022 to March 15, 2023. But that victory covered only the initial listing period. Both men were relisted under Council Decision (CFSP) 2023/572 and Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/571 on partly different grounds, and their fresh challenges — Aven v Council (T-283/23) and Fridman v Council (T-296/23) — were still pending when the Council delisted Fridman politically in September 2026. The General Court track seeks annulment of the listing; the Hong Kong track seeks money from Luxembourg. Understanding that difference is the key to everything that follows.

B. Why did Luxembourg demand Fridman's EU delisting days before his lawsuit advances?

The delisting of 22 September 2026 was not a judicial finding that Fridman did nothing wrong. It was a political bargain struck under unanimity pressure, and Reuters' reporting — based on EU diplomats — describes the mechanics precisely. France opened the sequence by demanding the removal of Alisher Usmanov for what a French diplomat, quoted by the Financial Times, called a specific national security concern, adding that Paris wished to respond positively to international partners who had approached it about Usmanov. Three European diplomats told Reuters that the concern was Azerbaijan, where at least two French nationals are detained: Paris indicated in private that Baku was using Usmanov to blackmail it over the detainees, an assertion Baku rejects, while President Aliyev has long lobbied for Usmanov's delisting for reasons that remain unclear.

Luxembourg then demanded the same treatment for Fridman. The Grand Duchy's motive is documented on the record: the Luxembourg Times reports that Prime Minister Luc Frieden confirmed his government had advocated Fridman's removal to avert harm to the country, against the background of the $16 billion claim. Luxembourg had initially favoured renewing the list unchanged; the arbitration exposure changed its calculus. Latvia — which had previously gone to court to keep Fridman and his business partner Aven listed, and which stripped Aven of its highest civilian honour in 2022 — held out until the last hours, then abstained, which under the applicable voting logic allowed the deal through. The package was formally adopted by written procedure on 22 September, just before the midnight deadline (already extended once from 15 September). The price of the two delistings was steep for the listed world as a whole: instead of the usual six-month rollover, the measures against roughly 3,000 other individuals and entities were renewed for three full years.

The Council's official press release of 22 September 2026, issued at 18:45, confirms the structure of the decision. The Council prolonged the restrictive measures targeting those responsible for undermining Ukraine's territorial integrity until 22 September 2029, recalling that they include travel restrictions for natural persons, the freezing of assets, and a ban on making funds or other economic resources available to the listed individuals and entities. And it adds a sentence that tells the whole story of the night's negotiation: In the context of the sanctions' review, the Council also decided not to renew the listings of three individuals and one entity, as well as to remove three deceased persons from the list. The legal instruments remain Council Decision 2014/145/CFSP and Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 — only the annex of names changed.

Reactions were immediate. Ukraine's Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha wrote on X: The decision to delist Usmanov and Fridman is shameful and unjustifiable. Moscow is celebrating, and urged Member States to impose their own national restrictions on both men. Latvia's prime minister said Riga would examine national sanctions while accepting the EU outcome, and noted that France had agreed to open talks on Latvia joining a French nuclear-deterrence initiative — a side arrangement that shows how far the bargaining extended. The episode unfolded against a new political backdrop in Budapest, where a change of government removed the Hungarian veto that had routinely complicated renewals, only for Riga to take over the holdout role for one night.

Three legal consequences follow directly. First, delisting is prospective: it lifts the EU freeze for the future but decides nothing about the legality of the 2022–2026 freeze, so Fridman's damages claim survives intact — if anything, Luxembourg's lobbying to delist him reads as an implicit acknowledgement of how seriously it takes the $16 billion exposure. Second, the three-year renewal considerably raises the stakes of each future review for everyone who remains listed: fewer exit windows, longer damage periods, stronger incentives to litigate. Third, Kyiv's call for national restrictions opens the question examined in Part II: can a State keep a delisted person frozen under its own law, including in France?

II. What does the arbitration mean for frozen assets and court challenges in France?

A. How do you get a Paris bank to unfreeze funds after a Brussels delisting?

Start with the French enforcement chain, because it is there — in the compliance departments of Paris banks and in the orders of the Paris enforcement judge — that an EU delisting produces, or fails to produce, tangible effects. French freezing law sits in the Monetary and Financial Code (code monétaire et financier). Its definitions, set by Article L. 562-1, are deliberately broad: for the purposes of the freezing chapter, “funds” covers financial assets and economic benefits of any kind, from cash and deposits to insurance contracts, claims and financial instruments. The provision that matters most for EU Russia sanctions is Article L. 562-3: Le ministre chargé de l'économie peut décider, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques of persons designated under United Nations Chapter VII resolutions or acts adopted under Article 29 of the Treaty on European Union or Article 75 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. In other words, the French ministerial freeze is the national relay of the Brussels designation: when the EU name comes off the annex, the French legal basis falls with it, and the freeze must in principle be lifted.

In practice the lifting is not automatic at the counter. Article L. 562-4 provides that Sont tenus d'appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition — and to inform the economy minister immediately — all natural persons on national territory and, crucially, the institutions listed in Article L. 561-2 (banks, insurers, asset managers) as well as any legal person carrying out operations in France, including French-headquartered groups for their foreign activity. Mirror logic applies on release: banks de-freeze only against a verified legal basis, which means the delisting regulation published in the Official Journal of the EU, confirmation from the Directorate General of the Treasury, and — where a parallel national freeze exists — a national release decision. Article L. 562-5 states the prohibition that compliance officers live by: no making available, directly or indirectly, and no use of frozen funds for the benefit of designated persons. Breach is a criminal matter: Article L. 574-3 punishes evasion of freezing obligations with the penalties of the Customs Code and channels investigation and prosecution through customs enforcement channels. The message for any Paris bank holding formerly frozen funds is therefore caution first: verify the delisting act, verify that no national measure subsists, document the file, then release.

Where a freeze — EU or national — does subsist, French law offers a safety valve. Article L. 562-9 makes ministerial freezing decisions enforceable from publication in the Journal officiel, and Article L. 562-11 allows the ministers to authorise the release of part of the frozen funds si leur utilisation est compatible avec la sauvegarde de l'ordre public and, for EU-based freezes, with the decisions and acts behind the freeze — on the authorities' own initiative or at the request of the designated person or any third party with a right over the funds. Basic needs, legal fees, routine administration of frozen companies: these derogations are the daily practice of sanctions law in Paris, and any delisted person with residual frozen positions — for example under a national measure maintained after EU delisting — should apply through this channel rather than moving funds first and explaining later.

Creditors face the mirror image of the same discipline, and France's highest court has just restated it with unusual firmness. On 5 February 2026 the Second Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (pourvoi no. 23-15.936, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2026:C200121, published in the Bulletin) dismissed the appeal of a Kuwaiti company holding an arbitral award against Libya that had tried to attach, in the hands of Société Générale in Paris, sums held for the Libyan Investment Authority — an entity whose funds were frozen under EU Regulation 2016/44 on Libya. The creditor argued that the Regulation required Treasury authorisation only at the payment stage, after attachment. The Court rejected the argument entirely. Quoting the Regulation's purpose — preventing the threat posed by persons and entities holding misappropriated Libyan public funds — it held que ne peut être diligentée, sur des fonds ou des ressources économiques gelés, aucune mesure d'exécution qui aurait pour effet, non seulement de les faire sortir du patrimoine du débiteur, mais aussi de conférer au créancier poursuivant un simple droit de préférence, sans une autorisation préalable du directeur du Trésor, autorité nationale désignée en application de l'article 11, § 2, du règlement. It added, in terms every Paris practitioner should memorise, qu'à défaut d'autorisation préalable du directeur du Trésor, aucune mesure de saisie-attribution, laquelle emporte, à concurrence des sommes pour lesquelles elle est pratiquée, attribution immédiate au profit du saisissant de la créance saisie disponible entre les mains du tiers et de ses accessoires, ne peut être autorisée ou validée par le juge de l'exécution, saisi sur requête en application de l'article L. 111-1-1 du code des procédures civiles d'exécution, sur des fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l'objet d'une mesure de gel des avoirs en exécution du règlement n° 2016/44. The 2016 “Sapin 2” requirement of prior judicial authorisation for enforcement against foreign-State property does not remove the Treasury prerequisite — by primacy of EU law, the administrative authorisation must come first, and an enforcement judge who authorised attachment without it would itself violate the Regulation. The appeal was dismissed, with €3,000 awarded against the creditor under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The practical synthesis for Paris is therefore threefold. If you are delisted in Brussels, instruct your bank at once with the delisting act and seek written Treasury confirmation before moving funds, because the criminal risk of dealing in still-frozen assets sits with you and your bank. If you are a creditor eyeing frozen assets, apply to the Treasury before the enforcement judge, never after — the February 2026 ruling makes the sequence mandatory. And if you face a national freeze surviving an EU delisting, challenge the national act and request a release authorisation under Article L. 562-11 while preparing the court challenge, rather than treating the Brussels delisting as a self-executing green light.

B. Which court challenges remain open after the 22 September 2026 delisting?

Four litigation tracks now coexist around the same facts, and each answers a different question. The first is the General Court annulment track described above. Fridman's and Aven's 2022–2023 listings were annulled (T-301/22, T-304/22) because the Council's reasons were not sufficiently substantiated; the Council then relisted both men under the 2023 instruments, and the new challenges (T-283/23 for Aven, T-296/23 for Fridman) were pending at the time of the political delisting. Delisting does not automatically extinguish those cases: applicants routinely maintain an interest where past illegality caused recoverable loss or reputational harm, and where the Council could relist them at any review — a risk the new 36-month cycle, running until 22 September 2029, keeps alive for everyone who remains listed. For the thousands still on the annex, the lesson of the Fridman file is procedural, not personal: the Council must state precise, individualised, evidence-backed reasons at each renewal, and stale or generic reasoning loses, as the recent wave of Russian delisting judgments — from the Tokareva and Pumpyanskaya annulments of September 2026 to the Fridman-Aven precedent — keeps demonstrating.

The second track shows the Council also wins when its file is solid. On 18 September 2026, four days before the political delisting, the General Court dismissed Roman Trotsenko's challenge (T-459/24) to his 2024 designation under Articles 3(1)(f) and (g) of the Russia Regulation — the criteria covering leading businesspersons and persons supporting or benefiting from the Russian government. The contrast with the Fridman-Aven annulments is instructive: same court, same Regulation, opposite outcomes depending on the quality of the individual statement of reasons and supporting evidence. Any listed person preparing a challenge from France should therefore commission the full Council file — statement of reasons, underlying evidence bundle, renewal acts — before choosing between the fast political route (lobbying the designating State, as Luxembourg just demonstrated) and the slow judicial route (annulment within the two-month time limit, plus damages).

The third track is Fridman's Hong Kong damages claim, and it is the least predictable. Investment tribunals have rarely been asked whether an EU sanctions freeze is a compensable expropriation, and never against Luxembourg. The tribunal will have to decide its jurisdiction under the Belgium-Luxembourg–Russia BIT (including the MFN bridge), the standard of review owed to wartime security measures, the quantification of a $16 billion loss on operating businesses frozen for years, and — if Fridman prevails — the enforceability of such an award against a sovereign State's assets in third countries, including France, where State-immunity rules set strict conditions for attachment. Each of those questions could take years; HKIAC confidentiality means the public may learn the outcome only at the enforcement stage, when an award creditor surfaces before a national court — quite possibly in Paris — seeking to attach Luxembourg-owned assets. That enforcement scenario is precisely where the February 2026 Court of Cassation ruling and the Treasury-authorisation sequence would re-enter the picture, this time as Luxembourg's shield rather than its sword.

The fourth track is national law after EU delisting — the avenue Kyiv expressly invited. Nothing in the Council's 22 September decision prevents a Member State from freezing the same persons under its own legislation for conduct on its territory, as Latvia's prime minister foreshadowed and Ukraine's foreign minister requested. In France, an autonomous freeze would pass through Articles L. 562-2 or L. 562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code, published in the Journal officiel under Article L. 562-9 and challengeable before the French administrative courts, with release requests under Article L. 562-11. The measure would have to satisfy French and European fundamental-rights review — effectiveness of judicial protection, proportionality, rights of the defence — exactly the standards the General Court applies in Luxembourg. A national relisting built on the same stale file that failed in T-301/22 would therefore carry the same litigation risk at national level; a relisting built on fresh, specific evidence of sanctionable conduct in France would be a different matter. Banks holding the formerly frozen funds should consequently treat EU delisting as the end of the EU freeze, not as a guarantee against a subsequent national measure — and keep their monitoring in place.

For listed persons, creditors and banks operating in France, the period that opens now is thus paradoxical: the longest renewal in EU sanctions history coincides with the weakest moment of the Council's individual files, as courts from Luxembourg to Paris strike down poorly reasoned measures while upholding well-documented ones. The winning posture combines all four tracks: verify delisting acts immediately, secure Treasury positions in writing, preserve evidence for annulment and damages deadlines, and prepare — rather than assume — the national-law sequel. The Fridman file will be remembered either as the $16 billion warning that made the EU put its sanctions reasoning in order, or as the case that proved even the best-resourced claimant cannot turn a wartime freeze into a State-funded payout. The Hong Kong tribunal, the General Court and — at the enforcement stage — the Paris courts will each write one chapter of the answer.

Conclusion

The 22 September 2026 delisting of Mikhail Fridman was a transaction, not an acquittal: Luxembourg bought protection against a $16 billion arbitration claim, France bought room to manoeuvre over its nationals detained in Azerbaijan, and the price was a three-year renewal of the sanctions against everyone else, until 22 September 2029. The $16 billion question now moves to Hong Kong, where a confidential tribunal must decide whether implementing EU sanctions can count as expropriation under a 1990s investment treaty — while the General Court in Luxembourg keeps annulling listings whose reasons were not sufficiently substantiated and upholding those, like Trotsenko's, whose files hold together. In Paris, the discipline does not change: no enforcement on frozen funds without the Treasury's prior authorisation, as the Court of Cassation confirmed on 5 February 2026; no release of frozen money without verifying that no national measure has replaced the EU one; no challenge without the full Council file and respect for the two-month annulment deadline. Delisted in Brussels, sued in Hong Kong, potentially enforceable in Paris: the Fridman saga has made sanctions law a three-forum practice, and the forums have only just begun to answer.

📄 Official circular