Kohen Avocats · Paris law firm
—

Maître Hassan KOHEN assists English-speaking clients throughout France, including in urgent proceedings. Initial strategic review: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Attorney-client privilege · No commitment

Paris Bar Urgent defence & litigation Official CNB profile (avocat.fr)
Hassan Kohen, immigration lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney · Paris Bar

France Medical Residence Permit Refused After a Negative OFII Opinion? How to Challenge the Refusal and the OQTF (2026 Guide)

Speak with a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your application for a residence permit on health grounds has just been refused, and the same order tells you to leave France within thirty days. The refusal letter mentions a negative opinion from the medical college of the Office français de l’immigration et de l’intégration (French Office for Immigration and Integration, OFII), and you are now holding an obligation de quitter le territoire français (order to leave French territory, OQTF), sometimes with a ban on returning. This situation feels final, but it is not. French administrative courts annul this exact type of refusal every year — including in two very recent rulings from September 2025 — whenever the prefecture has misapplied the law or failed to verify whether treatment is genuinely available in your country of origin. This guide explains, step by step, why the refusal was issued, what the judge actually checks, and how to challenge both the refusal and the removal order before the deadlines expire.

It builds on our general guide to the medical residence permit in France, and focuses here on the litigation stage: the refusal, the OFII opinion behind it, and the appeal. Because each medical file is different, the points below describe the legal framework and the courts’ method — they do not predict the outcome of any individual case.

I. Why the Prefecture Refused: The OFII Medical Opinion Decides Almost Everything

To understand the refusal, you must understand the two cumulative conditions of the statute and the central role played by a body of doctors you never meet: the OFII medical college. The prefect does not assess your illness personally; the prefect follows — or claims to follow — that college’s opinion. Every successful appeal therefore starts with dissecting that opinion.

A. The Two Cumulative Conditions of Article L. 425-9

The étranger malade (ill foreign national) permit is governed by a single key provision, Article L. 425-9 of the Code de l’entrée et du séjour des étrangers et du droit d’asile (Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreign Nationals and the Right of Asylum, CESEDA). The statute provides:

« L’étranger, résidant habituellement en France, dont l’état de santé nécessite une prise en charge médicale dont le défaut pourrait avoir pour lui des conséquences d’une exceptionnelle gravité et qui, eu égard à l’offre de soins et aux caractéristiques du système de santé dans le pays dont il est originaire, ne pourrait pas y bénéficier effectivement d’un traitement approprié, se voit délivrer une carte de séjour temporaire portant la mention ” vie privée et familiale ” d’une durée d’un an. »

In plain English, this single sentence contains two conditions that must both be met. First, your state of health must require medical care whose absence could have consequences of exceptional gravity for you — in practice, a threat to your life, your physical integrity, or a major bodily function. Second, given the healthcare available and the characteristics of the health system in your country of origin, you must be unable to receive appropriate treatment effectively there. If either condition fails, the prefect refuses the permit.

Three practical points follow directly from the text. First, the resulting card is a one-year temporary carte de séjour temporaire (temporary residence card) marked vie privée et familiale (private and family life), which means it must be renewed every year with a fresh medical examination — a refusal can therefore strike at first application or at renewal, as it did for the eighty-eight-year-old woman in the Douai case discussed below, who had held the card for five years before the prefecture refused to renew it. Second, the standard entry condition of Article L. 412-1 cannot be held against you: the statute expressly says so, which means even a person who entered France irregularly or without the normally required visa may still qualify. Third, the same health test protects you against removal itself: Article L. 611-3 of the CESEDA shields from an OQTF any étranger résidant habituellement en France (foreign national habitually residing in France) whose health requires care whose absence could have exceptionally serious consequences — « L’étranger mineur de dix-huit ans ne peut faire l’objet d’une décision portant obligation de quitter le territoire français. » is only the opening sentence of that article, which then lists the protected categories including the seriously ill foreign national. When the prefect refuses the permit and issues an OQTF in the same order, both decisions therefore stand or fall on the same medical assessment, and the court reviews them together.

The refusal of the permit itself automatically exposes you to removal. Article L. 611-1 of the CESEDA allows the administration to order a foreign national to leave France in several situations, expressly including the case where « L’étranger s’est vu refuser la délivrance d’un titre de séjour, le renouvellement du titre de séjour, du document provisoire délivré à l’occasion d’une demande de titre de séjour ou de l’autorisation provisoire de séjour qui lui avait été délivré ou s’est vu retirer un de ces documents ; » In English: a foreign national who has been refused a residence permit, its renewal, or the provisional document issued while the application was pending may be ordered to leave. That is why the refusal and the OQTF almost always arrive together in a single arrêté (prefectoral order), frequently accompanied by a one-year interdiction de retour sur le territoire français (ban on returning to French territory, IRTF). The good news is procedural: Article L. 614-1 provides that « La décision portant obligation de quitter le territoire français ainsi que la décision relative au séjour, la décision relative au délai de départ volontaire et l’interdiction de retour sur le territoire français qui l’accompagnent, le cas échéant, peuvent être contestées devant le tribunal administratif selon la procédure prévue à l’article L. 911-1. » In other words, the removal order, the residence refusal, the voluntary departure period, and any entry ban can all be challenged together before the tribunal administratif (administrative court), which may also order the prefecture to issue the permit. One appeal, one judge, all four decisions.

B. The OFII Medical College Opinion and Its Weight Before the Judge

The decisive document in your file is not written by the prefect but by three doctors you will never see. Article R. 425-11 of the CESEDA provides that « Pour l’application de l’article L. 425-9, le préfet délivre la carte de séjour temporaire portant la mention ” vie privée et familiale ” au vu d’un avis émis par un collège de médecins à compétence nationale de l’Office français de l’immigration et de l’intégration. » In English: the prefect issues the card on the basis of an opinion from a national-level college of OFII doctors, formed after a report by an OFII physician and in light of the information available about treatment options in your country of origin. The procedure is strictly paper-based and covered by medical confidentiality: you send your medical certificates to the OFII doctor in a sealed envelope, the prefect never sees their content, and only the college’s conclusion — favourable or unfavourable, with a few boxes ticked — is transmitted to the prefecture.

The college answers two questions in sequence. First, does your condition require care whose absence could have exceptionally serious consequences? The Health Ministry’s general guidance defines this through three combined criteria — the degree of seriousness (threat to life or to a major function), the probability, and the expected timeframe — and chronic progressive illnesses are assessed by looking at what interrupting the treatment currently received in France would do to you. If the answer to this first question is negative, the college stops there: it does not even need to examine whether treatment exists in your country. That is exactly what happened in the Nancy case below, where the college found that physiotherapy and botulinum toxin injections did not meet the gravity threshold, so the question of care in Albania never arose. Second, if the gravity threshold is met, the college examines whether appropriate treatment is effectively available in your country of origin — and it must also say whether your condition allows you to travel there without risk.

Before the court, that opinion carries great but not conclusive weight. The administrative courts apply a settled burden-of-proof mechanism, restated for example by the Nancy court of appeal in April 2024 (CAA Nancy, 30 April 2024, No. 23NC00418):

« La partie qui justifie d’un avis du collège des médecins de l’Office français de l’immigration et de l’intégration (OFII) qui lui est favorable doit être regardée comme apportant des éléments de fait susceptibles de faire présumer l’existence ou l’absence d’un état de santé de nature à justifier la délivrance ou le refus d’un titre de séjour. »

In English: whichever side can rely on a favourable OFII college opinion is presumed to have the facts on its side, and it is then up to the other side — while respecting medical confidentiality — to produce evidence rebutting it. The judge forms their conviction from this adversarial exchange, and in case of doubt may order further investigation such as an expert medical assessment. Concretely, this means a negative OFII opinion is a serious obstacle but never the end of the story: the judge, not the college, has the last word, and recent rulings show refusals annulled precisely because the applicant managed to contradict the college with solid country-of-origin evidence. The prefect, for their part, may simply adopt the college’s assessment in the refusal order — but if the college’s reasoning was thin or its country analysis wrong, the court will set the whole order aside.

II. How to Overturn the Refusal and the OQTF: Evidence, Deadlines and the Judge’s Powers

Winning means proving one of two things: either the college was wrong about the gravity of your condition or the effective availability of treatment back home, or — as a fallback — that removing you would disproportionately harm your private and family life. This second part explains what evidence persuades judges, which additional legal grounds to raise, and how the court procedure works in practice, including the strict time limits that make speed essential.

A. Proving That Treatment Is Not Effectively Available in Your Country of Origin

Court experience shows that most winnable cases turn on the second condition: effective access to appropriate treatment in the country of origin. The administration often argues in the abstract — the drug exists there, the specialty exists there — while the applicant must show the concrete reality: cost, distance, waiting lists, exclusion from coverage, or techniques that are simply not practised. Two September 2025 and October 2024 rulings illustrate both sides of this battle and the exact type of proof that makes the difference.

The strongest recent example for applicants is the Nantes ruling of September 2025 (CAA Nantes, 12 September 2025, No. 24NT02848). The case concerned a young Georgian man suffering from paraplegia caused by a complex spinal cord condition, who had undergone highly specialised neurosurgery at the Caen university hospital and depended on twice-yearly bladder injections of botulinum toxin. The OFII college had acknowledged the exceptional gravity but concluded that appropriate treatment was available in Georgia. The court disagreed, relying on three layers of concrete evidence the applicant had produced: a hospital certificate stating that

” l’interruption des injections de toxine botulique dans la vessie exposerait le patient à des complications telles que pyélonéphrites, insuffisance rénale pouvant engager le pronostic vital “

meaning that stopping the bladder injections would expose him to kidney infections and kidney failure capable of threatening his life; an apostilled document from the Georgian Health Ministry itself stating that bladder botulinum toxin injections were not performed in Georgia; and country reports showing that adult neuro-rehabilitation was underdeveloped, largely paid out of pocket, and — under a programme created in 2022 — reserved for conditions that appeared within the previous twenty-four months, which excluded him. Faced with this file, the court held that the applicant had shown the adapted care was not effectively accessible in his country, annulled the prefect’s refusal with its OQTF, and the prefect’s appeal against that annulment was dismissed. The lesson is practical: official documents from your own country’s health authorities, dated and authenticated, outweigh generic OFII statements about availability, and country reports from recognised sources carry real weight.

The mirror image is the Toulouse ruling of October 2024 (CAA Toulouse, 1 October 2024, No. 23TL01713), where the refusal was upheld. A Moroccan woman with ischaemic heart disease and insulin-dependent diabetes argued that she could not effectively access care in Morocco because of cost and isolation. The court rejected this because she proved neither that she lacked Moroccan compulsory health insurance or other coverage, nor that she could not turn to the medical assistance scheme for the economically disadvantaged, which offers the same basket of care in public hospitals. The comparison between the two cases is instructive: general claims about expense or solitude fail, while precise, sourced, personalised proof succeeds. If you argue cost, produce your insurance situation, income, and the actual price of the treatment; if you argue unavailability, produce ministry documents, authenticated correspondence with hospitals, or up-to-date country medical reports — not press articles alone.

The Nancy ruling of April 2024 (CAA Nancy, 30 April 2024, No. 23NC00418) shows the harder scenario: losing on the first condition, gravity itself. An Albanian man with congenital hydrocephalus, lower-limb spasticity, and physiotherapy plus botulinum toxin treatment could not show that missing these sessions would threaten his life, physical integrity, or significantly worsen his mobility, and a 2019 hospital certificate saying he could not be detained or flown home was too old — more than two years before the refusal — to rebut the college’s finding that he could travel without risk. Two warnings follow: file recent medical certificates, ideally less than a few months old at the date of the prefect’s decision, because the judge assesses your health as of that date; and ask your doctors to describe precisely, in clinical terms, what would happen without treatment and within what timeframe, since the gravity test turns on probability and horizon, not on the diagnosis label alone. Certificates that merely name the illness, without explaining the consequences of interrupting care, rarely move the court.

A second line of defence should always be raised alongside the medical argument: private and family life. The Douai ruling of September 2025 (CAA Douai, 17 September 2025, No. 24DA00287) annulled a non-renewal on both grounds at once. The applicant, an eighty-eight-year-old Gabonese woman with insulin-dependent diabetes who had held the medical card since 2017, faced a refusal based on an OFII opinion conceding gravity but asserting that treatment was available in Gabon. The court first held that

« l’intéressée est fondée à soutenir que le préfet du Nord a méconnu les dispositions de l’article L. 425-9 du code de l’entrée et du séjour des étrangers et du droit d’asile en refusant de lui délivrer un titre de séjour pour soins. »

which means the court found the prefect had misapplied the medical-permit statute, given her advanced age, increased vulnerability, and inability to access care autonomously. It then added an Article 8 fallback: living in France continuously since 2004, hosted by her French nursing-assistant daughter, surrounded by French grandchildren and a great-grandchild, with no remaining family ties in Gabon, she could also claim a disproportionate interference with her private and family life. Either ground alone would have sufficed; together they made the annulment inevitable, and the OQTF fell automatically with the refusal it depended on. The practical message is to always plead Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Article L. 423-23 of the CESEDA in addition to L. 425-9 — length of stay, French family members, caregiving roles, and integration evidence all belong in the file, and our team at our Paris immigration practice routinely structures medical files around this dual-track approach.

B. Deadlines, the Tribunal and the Injunction: Acting Within Days, Not Weeks

The procedure rewards speed and punishes delay, because an OQTF carries short, variable challenge periods and can in some configurations be enforced quickly. The cardinal rule is simple: read the voies et délais de recours (available remedies and time limits) printed at the foot of the order on the day you receive it, and treat the shortest indicated period as your real deadline. The general framework is set by Article R. 614-3 of the CESEDA, which provides that « Les délais de recours et de jugement contre les décisions mentionnées à l’article L. 614-1 sont ceux prévus à l’article R. 911-1 . » — in practice, these periods differ sharply depending on whether the OQTF grants a voluntary departure period, is combined with detention or house arrest, or is issued without any departure delay, and some configurations require action within days. Never assume you have two months: verify the exact category of your order immediately.

Most medical-refusal OQTFs grant a thirty-day délai de départ volontaire (voluntary departure period), as in all four cases discussed here. That configuration is the most favourable for litigation: the order cannot be forcibly executed before the period expires, which leaves time to prepare a complete appeal. Note two related mechanisms. First, the administration may terminate the voluntary departure period early under Article L. 612-5 if a statutory ground appears, so do not treat the thirty days as unconditional. Second, staying beyond the period without leaving exposes you to an entry ban: Article L. 612-7 allows the prefect to add an IRTF when the foreign national has remained irregularly after the departure deadline. Filing the court appeal in time is therefore also how you freeze the escalation toward a multi-year ban.

The appeal itself is filed before the tribunal administratif of your place of residence, and it must attack every decision contained in the order: the residence refusal, the OQTF, the country of destination, and any entry ban. Because Article L. 614-1 joins them in a single procedure, the annulment of the refusal automatically entails the annulment of the OQTF built upon it — the Douai court expressly drew this consequence. Your petition should combine four layers of arguments: insufficient reasoning or lack of a genuine personal examination where the order is a template decision; misapplication of Article L. 425-9 with your medical and country evidence attached; violation of Article 8 and Article L. 423-23 on private and family life; and, where relevant, the L. 611-3 protection against removal of seriously ill persons. Always add a claim for an injonction (court order to the administration): under Article L. 911-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, when annulment necessarily implies a specific enforcement measure, the court orders the prefecture to take it — in Douai, the court ordered the prefect to issue a vie privée et familiale card within two months; in the Caen judgment confirmed by the Nantes court, within one month. Without that request, you may win the annulment but wait months for the prefecture to re-examine the file.

Finally, organise the evidence file the way judges read it. Put recent, detailed hospital certificates first — diagnosis, treatment, dosage and frequency, and crucially the clinical consequences of interruption with their timeframe. Then the country evidence: ministry documents, authenticated hospital correspondence, coverage and cost proof, and recognised country medical reports, all dated and, where foreign-language, translated. Then the private-life evidence: proof of continuous presence, family members’ identity and status, attestations of daily support, and any caregiving role you play. Keep the sealed medical envelope procedure in mind for renewals, respond to any OFII summons, and never ignore correspondence from the prefecture. An application handled carefully at the administrative stage produces the record on which the court case is won — and where the medical picture is genuinely doubtful, the judge can order an expert assessment rather than simply deferring to the OFII, which is one more reason to file an appeal that is documented rather than merely declarative.

Conclusion

A refused medical residence permit is the beginning of a court case, not the end of your right to stay. The law gives you a full judicial review of both the OFII college’s medical assessment and the proportionality of your removal: the Nantes and Douai courts of 2025 annulled refusals where applicants proved, with official and personalised evidence, that appropriate treatment was not effectively accessible in their country or that removal would shatter decades of family life, while the Nancy and Toulouse rulings show that old certificates and generic cost arguments do not suffice. Check the appeal deadline on your order immediately, challenge every decision it contains before the administrative court, request an injunction to obtain the card rather than a mere re-examination, and plead the medical ground together with private and family life. Built this way, the file gives the judge everything needed to substitute a lawful decision for an unlawful refusal.

📄 Official document

Our data comes from the Cour de cassation (Judilibre), the Conseil d'État, the DILA, the Court of Justice of the European Union and the European Court of Human Rights.

Legal database search

Find a decision, a text or an analysis

More than 100,000 decisions annotated by our artificial intelligence, indexed in real time.

    Search powered by Meilisearch on kohenavocats.com.

    What our clients say

    4,885 Google reviews
    Share your review
    Contact Mobile
    3 weeks ago

    Very satisfied! I would like to thank Maître Esther Cornu here, who managed to resolve a very complicated dispute in a divorce and family law matter...Thanks to Maître Cornu, a judgment was handed down in my favour even though it was far from a foregone conclusion...So I recommend this law firm

    Google review translated from French

    Claude Frasson
    3 weeks ago

    A precise and concrete analysis and an immediate response. Excellent.

    Google review translated from French

    Basel Alali
    3 weeks ago

    I highly recommend this lawyer for his professionalism, honesty, and transparency. He helped me successfully and guided me through the process with great care and expertise. What I particularly appreciated was his honest approach and the fact that he recommended practical, cost-effective options instead of immediately pushing for the most expensive solution. He genuinely focused on finding the right approach for my situation. I’m very grateful for his support and would definitely recommend him to anyone looking for a trustworthy and professional lawyer in France.

    beatrice lefevre
    3 weeks ago

    Thank you for this detailed, precise help, with a proposal at the end on whether or not to continue (very quick response as well)

    Google review translated from French

    Jean-pierre Steinmetz
    1 month ago

    Very good advice given by Maître Cornu during our meeting on 16 October.

    Google review translated from French

    John Roberts
    1 month ago

    Very professional and responsive service. The lawyer quickly and carefully checked the validity of my wife’s residence permit in light of a specific legal regime. His work gave us clarity, whereas the usual administrative procedures were long and ambiguous. I appreciated his efficiency and professionalism, and I recommend his services.

    Google review translated from French

    Jean-François PAPA
    1 month ago

    I would like to warmly thank Maître Esther Cornu for her professionalism, her availability and the quality of her support. In a case of particular importance for my professional future, she showed great responsiveness, rigour and a gift for explaining things, taking the time to answer my questions precisely and to explain the various legal steps to me. I particularly appreciate the clarity of her analyses, her seriousness and her commitment in following up my case. Many thanks to Maître Esther Cornu for listening and for her support. I highly recommend!

    Google review translated from French

    Sandra Imbert
    1 month ago

    A huge thank you to Maître Esther Cornu from Kohen Avocats for her support during a particularly difficult time. Her attentiveness, empathy, and humanity touched me deeply. She was able to answer my questions with clarity and sensitivity, while demonstrating great professionalism and fully respecting the confidentiality of the case. Beyond her professional qualities, I met a deeply humane lawyer whose support made a real difference. I sincerely recommend her.

    Google review translated from French

    Djamel Haddouche
    1 month ago

    I am facing a dispute with my employer, and the support provided by Maître Hassan COHEN as well as Maître Esther Cornu is excellent. The answers are clear and well-thought-out, they genuinely listen, and interactions are very pleasant. Thank you again, I highly recommend.

    Google review translated from French

    Nima Sdc
    1 month ago

    A law firm that is attentive to its clients. Maître Kohen and his team are very, very professional and truly master their field.

    Google review translated from French

    jules p
    1 month ago

    I highly recommend Cabinet Kohen, and particularly Maître Esther Cornu, who supported me throughout my case. She skillfully combined attentiveness and expertise to guide me through these difficult and stressful times. She was always available to answer all my questions with precision and responsiveness. Thanks to her preparation work, I was able to approach the situation with much greater peace of mind. Her kindness and humanity made me feel at ease throughout our exchanges. I am very grateful to her for her support and professionalism. You can trust her with your eyes closed.

    Google review translated from French

    Jocelyne Chassard
    2 months ago

    I have just spoken on the phone with Monsieur Chahdi from your law firm: I wanted to congratulate you on your online article regarding order no. 519225 of the Conseil d’État dated August 30, 2026. You clearly explained the content of this order, which does not grant prefectures a general blank check to replace a demonstration ban with a restrictive receipt modifying one or more circumstances of a demonstration, but which, in a specific case, held that the applicants had not sufficiently demonstrated a serious and disproportionate infringement on the fundamental freedom to publicly express opinions. As I told Mr. Chahdi, I am facing this restrictive receipt issue in Reims for a demonstration scheduled for tomorrow afternoon in front of the judicial court: the organizer has just filed an urgent fundamental freedom petition (référé-liberté) before the Châlons-en-Champagne Administrative Court. Monsieur Chahdi initially seemed surprised by the call from an 'ordinary citizen', but he listened to me and answered with courtesy.

    Google review translated from French

    Menah'em
    3 months ago

    I would like to express my gratitude to the Kohen Avocats law firm and especially to Maître Chahdi. From our very first phone call, Maître Chahdi was available, attentive, and offered remarkable advice. The firm's reception and follow-up reflect a very high level of standards and expertise. Many thanks to the entire team for their support and impeccable professionalism.

    Google review translated from French

    Мария Двирник
    3 weeks ago
    Moula Brahimi
    3 weeks ago

    Good experience. And good work, thank you for everything.

    Google review translated from French

    Faiza Traduction
    1 month ago
    Alain Arsaut
    1 month ago

    Saw Hassan on the TV news

    Google review translated from French

    TOULEIMAT HACHEM
    1 month ago
    emilie lepicard
    1 month ago
    إبراهيم عيسى
    1 month ago
    Monique Firmin
    2 months ago

    Excellent phone reception. Great professionalism.

    Google review translated from French

    Louna Sisi
    2 months ago

    Excellent

    Google review translated from French

    Sophie Lascar
    3 months ago
    Solal Gaillard
    3 months ago
    Preliminary case review

    Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

    Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

    • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
    • Personal reply within 24 working hours
    • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
    • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
    80 €TTC

    Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

    • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
    • Secure payment, no card details stored
    • Terms and fee agreement

    Cliquez or drag your files here
    All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

    Sending...

    Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
    Terms · Privacy policy.

    Free legal AI

    A question of French law? Ask Judith.

    Judith searches the French codes, the Constitution, the European Convention on Human Rights and the courts’ decisions, then shows you the texts and the passages of rulings that may answer your question, with their official source. Free, no account; she writes nothing for you. Questions and results are in French. Discover Judith, the firm’s free legal AI.

    Three searches a day. Your question is recorded and reviewed by the firm to improve the tool: do not enter names or sensitive information.