You formed a limited liability company in Delaware or Florida, put your French house inside it, and went back to your life in America. Then a letter arrives, or your French accountant calls: France wants 3 percent of the market value of the house, every single year, for as long as the company owns it. On a house worth 800,000 euros, that is 24,000 euros a year, due whether you rent the place out or not, whether the company makes a profit or not, and on top of every other French property tax you already pay.
This charge has a name, the taxe sur la valeur vénale des immeubles des entités juridiques, the annual tax on the market value of buildings owned by legal entities. It was created to stop anonymous foreign companies from holding French real estate behind layers of secrecy, and it works by a simple threat: either the company tells France every year exactly what it owns and who owns the company, or it pays 3 percent. American limited liability companies are caught more brutally than most, because of a mismatch at the heart of the system. In the United States your single-member LLC is normally invisible for income tax, a disregarded entity that the IRS treats as part of you. In France that same LLC is fully visible as a foreign legal entity, and it is taxed as one.
This article explains both sides in order. The first part shows why France charges the 3 percent, which American vehicles are caught, how the bill is computed, and what happens if you ignore it, with three recent decisions of the Cour de cassation, the highest French civil court, including one from September 2026. The second part shows the two ways out: the exemption route, where the LLC names its owners and leans on the France-United States tax treaty, and the restructuring route, where the family moves the house out of the LLC, with the French and American costs of each choice. Every French term is explained the first time it appears.
I. Does France Really Charge My US LLC 3 Percent of My French House Every Year?
A. Which American companies and trusts France catches, and what counts as a French house
The short answer is yes, if a legal entity sits between you and the house. Article 990 D of the General Tax Code, the Code général des impôts, states: “Les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits.” In plain English, any legal entity, a company, an organization, a trust, or anything comparable, that directly or through an intermediary owns one or more buildings in France, or holds real rights over them, owes an annual tax of 3 percent of the market value. The Cour de cassation reads this net as deliberately wide. In its decision of 10 May 2024, appeal number 21-11.230, concerning a Liechtenstein foundation, the court recalled that “selon l’article 990 D, alinéa 1er, du code général des impôts, toutes les entités juridiques, quelle que soit leur forme, qui possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits.” Every legal entity whatever its form: a Delaware LLC, a Florida corporation, a Nevada holding company, and, as a September 2026 decision confirms, a foreign trust, all fall inside.
Three features of the rule surprise American owners. First, hiding the house behind several layers changes nothing. The same Article 990 D provides that “est réputée posséder des biens ou droits immobiliers en France par entité interposée toute entité juridique qui détient une participation, quelles qu’en soient la forme et la quotité, dans une personne morale, un organisme, une fiducie ou une institution comparable, autre qu’une entité juridique visée aux 1°, a et b du 2° et a, b et c du 3° de l’article 990 E , qui est propriétaire de ces biens ou droits ou détenteur d’une participation dans une troisième personne morale, organisme, fiducie ou institution comparable lui-même propriétaire des biens ou droits ou interposé dans la chaîne des participations.” Any participation of any size, through any number of intermediaries, counts as owning through an intermediary. If your Wyoming LLC owns a Luxembourg company that owns a French SCI, a société civile immobilière, the French property company, which owns the villa, the tax still applies. The chain only breaks where an exempt entity sits in the middle, and the exemptions are listed in Article 990 E, examined in the second part.
Second, the base is the valeur vénale, the price the property would fetch on the open market between a willing buyer and a willing seller, not what you paid for it ten years ago and not the cadastral rental value used for other taxes. A house bought for 400,000 euros in 2012 and worth 800,000 today is taxed on 800,000. The tax office can challenge an undervalued declaration the same way it challenges any tax base, so the number on the return must be defensible with comparable sales. Third, the tax covers droits réels, real rights over the property, as well as full ownership. A bare ownership stripped of its usufruct, the lifelong right to use the property and take its income, or a long lease with ownership features can fall in. If your LLC holds only the nue-propriété, the bare ownership, of a house while a relative holds the usufruit, the usufruct, the LLC is still in the net for the rights it holds.
The tax is also strikingly indifferent to profit. It is due on the value of the building, not on rental income, not on capital gains, not on dividends. An LLC that leaves the house empty eleven months a year owes the same 3 percent as one that rents it steadily. And the charge is not déductible: Article 990 G of the same code states: “La taxe prévue à l’article 990 D n’est pas déductible pour l’assiette de l’impôt sur le revenu ou de l’impôt sur les sociétés.” It does not reduce French income tax or corporate tax. Work the arithmetic once and the stakes are clear. A Paris apartment worth 1,200,000 euros inside a US LLC costs 36,000 euros every year. A Provence farmhouse worth 500,000 euros costs 15,000 euros every year. Over ten years of passive ownership, the tax alone can exceed what the family paid in transfer duties when it bought the place.
A final trap concerns chains of ownership and who exactly owes the money. Article 990 F provides that “Lorsqu’il existe une chaîne de participations, la taxe est due par la ou les personnes morales qui, dans cette chaîne, sont les plus proches des immeubles ou droits immobiliers et qui ne sont pas exonérées en application du d ou e du 3° de l’article 990 E.” Only the entity closest to the property, if it is not exempt, is the legal debtor, while intermediaries higher up are jointly liable for payment. Two 2026 decisions of the Cour de cassation turned on exactly this point. On 28 May 2026, appeal number 24-18.404, the tax office had pursued a Luxembourg company, Satofi, while a French SCI called Bayit sat between it and the building. The court of appeal had thrown out the procedure because Bayit never received the follow-up documents. The Cour de cassation quashed that ruling: “En statuant ainsi, alors que l’administration fiscale n’était pas tenue de notifier à la société Bayit, personne morale interposée, les actes de la procédure suivant la proposition de rectification notifiée à la société Satofi, redevable de la taxe annuelle de 3 % sur la valeur vénale des immeubles, la cour d’appel a violé les textes susvisés.” Read the full decision on Legifrance, appeal 24-18.404. Four months later, on 16 September 2026, in appeal number 25-11.299, the same chamber applied the same notification rule to a Jersey-law trust, The Edwards Settlement, which held the building through two companies, Fimo Ltd and Top of The Cap. The appeal court had thrown out the assessment for lack of notification to those two companies; the Cour de cassation quashed that ruling, holding that the tax office owed no notification to companies merely interposed between the trust, the legal debtor of the tax, and the building, and sent the case back to Aix-en-Provence. The decision is still too recent to appear in the official bulletin index, so the lesson is stated here from the reasoning of the ruling rather than quoted. The lesson for an American structure is blunt. Stacking entities does not dilute the tax, and in a dispute the administration only has to run the procedure against the debtor closest to the house. The Liechtenstein foundation case, appeal 21-11.230, read on Legifrance, shows the other side of the same coin: foundations and trusts whose home state lacks the right treaty cannot escape by invoking European law, as the second part explains.
B. How the 3 percent is computed, when it is due, and what happens if you never file
The computation itself is simple, and the calendar is strict. Article 990 F states that “La taxe est due à raison des immeubles ou droits immobiliers possédés au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition, à l’exception des biens régulièrement inscrits dans les stocks des personnes morales qui exercent la profession de marchand de biens ou de promoteur-constructeur.” Whoever, through whatever chain, holds the French building on 1 January owes the whole year, except for professional dealers holding stock. Sell on 2 January and you still owe the full year. Buy on 31 December and the coming year is yours. Families timing a restructuring, examined below, should count days: a transfer signed in December instead of January can mean one full year of 3 percent saved or wasted.
The same Article 990 F continues: “Les redevables ainsi que les entités juridiques mentionnées aux d ou e du 3° de l’article 990 E doivent déclarer au plus tard le 15 mai de chaque année la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles et droits immobiliers en cause.” Every debtor, and every entity claiming the disclosure exemptions detailed below, must file by 15 May each year, describing the location, nature, and value of the buildings and rights. The official tax commentary, the Bulletin officiel des finances publiques, confirms the yearly rhythm: liable entities must file each year by 15 May, identifying the location, nature, and market value of the taxable buildings and rights held on 1 January. The return goes on official form n° 2746-SD (CERFA n° 11109), the return the administration puts online. That form is therefore the annual heartbeat of the system: value the property at 1 January, list it, pay with the return, every year, at the office designated by regulation, or with the large-business directorate for groups that report there. Read the full filing instructions in the official BOFiP commentary on the declaration, payment, control and penalties.
Ignoring the form does not make the tax go away. It makes it worse. The same commentary warns that failure to file lets the office assess the tax unilaterally under the official-assessment procedure, under Article L. 66 of the Tax Procedure Book, the Livre des procédures fiscales, after a formal demand giving thirty days to comply, under Article L. 67 of the same Procedure Book. An official assessment means the administration picks the market value, and the owner then fights uphill to reduce it. There is one narrow tolerance worth knowing. Entities that could have been exempt under the disclosure routes but forgot to file must be formally ordered to comply within thirty days, and the commentary grants a single second chance: entities that comply within those thirty days escape collection of the tax, except under the partial-exemption route, where the slice held through owners whose details were not disclosed still pays its proportional share, with no penalty added. But the text adds that this tolerance applies only once, for all years still within the recovery period, so it is a single second chance, not a yearly habit.
Two further consequences complete the picture. First, the 3 percent follows the property into a sale. When a company outside the European Union sells the building, the accredited representative, the représentant accrédité designated for the capital-gains levy, answers for the remaining tax, which is why buyers, notaires, and their representatives check the 3 percent history before releasing funds. The levy on nonresident sellers is organized by Article 244 bis A of the General Tax Code, and the 3 percent tail attaches to the same closing mechanics. Second, European law will not save a structure on its own. The Liechtenstein foundation argued discrimination and a breach of the free movement of capital, and the Cour de cassation rejected the argument outright in appeal 21-11.230: “c’est à bon droit que l’arrêt énonce que le dispositif instituant la taxe de 3 % ne porte pas atteinte au droit de l’Union et qu’il n’est pas en lui-même discriminatoire ni contraire au principe de libre circulation des capitaux, s’agissant des personnes morales ayant leur siège dans un Etat ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative ou un traité de non-discrimination, dès lors qu’il permet à ces personnes d’obtenir le bénéfice de l’exonération dans les conditions prévues à l’article 990 E, 3°, du code général des impôts, et retient que la taxation qui lui est appliquée est proportionnée à l’objectif poursuivi de lutte contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales.” The 3 percent survives because entities seated in treaty states can earn the exemption. Americans must therefore stop asking whether the tax is legal and start asking whether their LLC qualifies for that exemption, which is the entire subject of the second part.
II. How Americans Legally Escape the 3 Percent or Pay It Without Penalties
A. Can a Delaware or Florida LLC claim the exemption by naming its owners?
Yes, in principle, and the mechanism is disclosure plus treaty. Article 990 E lists the entities the tax simply does not hit. Small holdings are out: entities whose share of the French building is below 100,000 euros or below 5 percent of its market value. Pension vehicles and recognized charities are out. Then comes the provision that matters for Americans, the 3rd paragraph, which covers the entities described in Article 990 E, paragraph 3: “qui ont leur siège en France, dans un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou dans un pays ou territoire ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales ou dans un Etat ayant conclu avec la France un traité leur permettant de bénéficier du même traitement que les entités qui ont leur siège en France” An LLC seated in the United States can enter this door only if the United States, on 1 January of the year at issue, is bound to France by such an assistance convention or equal-treatment treaty. France and the United States signed a full income and wealth tax convention at Paris on 31 August 1994, as the official commentary on the France-United States convention records, and that convention contains a broad information-exchange clause. Its Article 27 on exchange of information requires each side to share information that may be relevant for applying the convention or for administering domestic laws on taxes of any kind, where the resulting taxation is not contrary to the convention. Read the consolidated treaty on the official impots.gouv.fr site. Because the exchange covers taxes of every kind, practitioners treat the United States as a qualifying state for the exemption door. Verify the point on the current published list before filing, because the administration keeps an annex of qualifying non-EU states for this exact article and lists move: the official commentary keeps an annex of qualifying non-EU states for this exact article, so check the live annex in the official BOFiP commentary on seat-conditioned exemptions for the year you file.
Passing the treaty door is only half the job. The LLC must then disclose. Subparagraph d) of Article 990 E exempts entities “qui déclarent chaque année, au plus tard le 15 mai, au lieu fixé par l’arrêté prévu à l’article 990 F du présent code, la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles possédés au 1er janvier, l’identité et l’adresse de l’ensemble des actionnaires, associés ou autres membres qui détiennent, à quelque titre que ce soit, plus de 1 % des actions, parts ou autres droits, ainsi que le nombre des actions, parts ou autres droits détenus par chacun d’eux” Every year by 15 May, the LLC files form 2746-SD and names every member holding more than 1 percent, with addresses and holdings. For a single-member Delaware LLC that means naming yourself. For a three-sibling Florida LLC it means naming all three. Subparagraph e) offers a softer variant for entities that only know some of their holders: they declare what they know, and the exemption applies pro rata, with the tax remaining due on the undisclosed slice, exactly as the tolerance passage quoted above describes. Bearer shares, nominee arrangements, and LLCs whose operating agreement hides the real decision-maker fail here by construction. If France cannot see the humans, France sends the bill.
American LLCs face three practical friction points on this road. First, the operating agreement must actually identify the members and their percentages, and the percentages on the French return must match the agreement and the IRS filings. A mismatch between the 2746-SD, the agreement, and the American return is an invitation to an audit on both sides of the Atlantic. Second, multi-layer structures force a choice of who discloses. Remember the Satofi and Edwards rulings: the debtor closest to the house files and pays, or claims the exemption, while upper-tier companies are only jointly liable. Map the chain before filing so the right entity signs the right form. Third, the foundation case is a warning about half-measures. The Beaux-Arts Stiftung invoked the exemption and lost because, in the court’s words, it simply did not meet the statutory conditions, with the court noting the judges had correctly concluded “que cette fondation ne remplissait pas les conditions édictées à l’article 990 E, 3°, du code général des impôts pour prétendre au bénéfice de l’exonération prévue à ce texte.” That is the holding of appeal 21-11.230, and its lesson is practical. Disclosure must be complete, yearly, and on time. A late, partial, or inconsistent filing is the same as no filing, except that it also proves you knew the rule.
One American reflex needs correcting here. Many owners assume that because the IRS ignores their single-member LLC, France should too. The IRS rule is the mirror image: for federal income tax, a single-member LLC is by default disregarded, treated as part of its owner, unless it files Form 8832 to elect corporate treatment. Read the IRS page on LLC classification. That transparency stops at the American border. France taxes the LLC as a foreign legal entity unless the exemption is earned, and no American election changes the French analysis. The treaty helps with double taxation of income, through its relief article, which your American preparer applies on the US return, but the 3 percent itself is a French wealth-type charge on the entity, not an American income tax, so expect no dollar-for-dollar US credit for it and budget it as a French cost.
B. Should you keep the LLC, move the house out, or sell, and when?
With the mechanics clear, the family decision reduces to three options: keep the LLC and comply every year, move the house out of the LLC into direct ownership or a French vehicle, or sell. Each has a French cost, an American cost, and a right moment.
Keeping the LLC is rational when the exemption is secure and the structure serves a real purpose, such as liability protection for a rental activity or a multi-member family arrangement that the operating agreement already governs. The yearly discipline is then non-negotiable: value the property at 1 January with comparable sales on file, file form 2746-SD by 15 May with the full member list, pay any residual slice under the partial route, and keep proof of filing forever. Calendar the two dates that govern everything: 1 January fixes the year, 15 May closes the filing. Miss the filing and the tolerance described above is your only parachute, usable once. Families who also own through a French SCI for other properties should keep the two regimes separate in their files: the SCI has its own formation, tax, and succession logic, explained in this guide to how an American family runs, taxes, and passes on shares in a French property company (SCI), and mixing the two sets of papers is how member lists drift out of date.
Moving the house out ends the 3 percent permanently but triggers its own French bill. A transfer from the LLC to yourselves, by sale or by contribution, passes through a French notaire, the public officer who authenticates deeds, and pays registration duties plus the notaire’s regulated fees, plus any capital-gains levy if the property appreciated, with the accredited-representative mechanics of Article 244 bis A for a non-EU seller. Compare that one-time cost against the 3 percent times the number of years you plan to hold: on a 600,000 euro house the tax is 18,000 euros a year, so a transfer costing 40,000 euros in duties and fees pays for itself in under three years. Sign before 1 January if you can, because whoever holds the building on New Year’s Day owes the whole coming year. And before moving anything, read the companion picture of yearly French property taxes Americans pay on a second home, since direct ownership swaps the 3 percent for the standard bundle of local taxes and wealth tax, which your budget must absorb instead.
Selling ends everything at once, and timing is the whole game. Sell and close in December and the buyer owns the 1 January problem, not you. Close in January and you owe the full year on a house you no longer own. Make the notaire confirm in writing that the 3 percent history is clean before funds are released, because the representative answers for arrears at closing. On the American side, a sale by a disregarded single-member LLC is your sale for US purposes, with gain measured under American basis rules, while a sale by an LLC that elected corporate treatment is a different animal entirely, so align the French closing date with the American tax year analysis your preparer runs, and keep the French assessment notices as proof of foreign taxes paid for the US file.
Choose with a simple decision tree. If the LLC has one member, the treaty door is open, and you can file cleanly every year, keep the LLC and file. If the member list cannot be disclosed, if layers make compliance fragile, or if the 3 percent over your holding horizon exceeds the transfer cost, move the house out before the next 1 January. If the family was going to sell within a few years anyway, sell in December and let the buyer inherit the calendar. Whichever branch you take, do not let the structure drift: an LLC formed for an American asset-protection reflex, forgotten in a drawer in Ohio while a villa sits in the Luberon, is how 24,000 euro surprises are born.
Conclusion
France does not care that your LLC is invisible back home. If an American company or trust stands between you and a French house on 1 January, France presumes 3 percent of the market value is owed, unless the entity proves, by 15 May on form 2746-SD, what it owns and who owns it, through a treaty door the France-United States convention keeps open. The Cour de cassation has now said it three times in three years: every legal entity whatever its form is caught, only the entity closest to the building is the true debtor, intermediaries cannot demand their own procedure, and European law does not excuse a structure that refuses transparency. Price the three options, keep the LLC and file, move the house before January, or sell in December, against the value of the house and the years you plan to hold it, and put the two dates, 1 January and 15 May, in writing where the whole family can see them. The 3 percent rewards owners who disclose and punishes owners who forget, and it never sends a reminder.