KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
ICC Cuts Ties With French Insurer Axa Under US Sanctions Threat: What French and EU Law Say

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

ICC Cuts Ties With French Insurer Axa Under US Sanctions Threat: What French and EU Law Say

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 1 October 2026, the International Criminal Court announced that it had ended its health and life insurance contract with the French insurer Axa, with effect from the same day, and that it would move to a new health insurance provider. The Court gave no reason for the decision. Its spokesperson said only: The Court spoke only of a decision “by mutual agreement” to end the contractual relationship, as reported by Reuters. Axa did not immediately respond to the request for comment, and the new provider was not named.

What makes this short announcement a major cross-border legal story is its setting. Since February 2025, the Trump administration has run an escalating sanctions campaign against the Court: an executive order declaring ICC proceedings against American and allied personnel a national emergency, financial sanctions and visa bans against more than a dozen ICC judges and prosecutors, and, in late September 2026, reported preparations for measures that could strike the whole institution and cut its access to dollar transactions. The termination follows months of internal discussions between Axa and the Court about possible workarounds, discussions that, according to the Financial Times, failed for want of what the paper called a blocking statute.

For readers outside France, the French dimension is the sharpest part of this story. A Paris-based insurer stands caught between American extraterritorial sanctions on one side and, on the other, a European Union regulation — backed by a 1968 French criminal statute — that forbids European operators from complying with those very sanctions. This analysis sets out what happened in The Hague, why the dollar gives Washington such leverage over a court it does not recognise, and what French and EU law actually require of companies and individuals caught in the middle.

I. How American sanctions drove a French insurer out of The Hague

The facts, as reported by Reuters, the Financial Times and Al Jazeera on 1 October 2026, fit into a coercive sequence that began more than a year earlier. Each step raised the personal and commercial cost of doing business with the Court, until even a French insurance giant concluded that the risk had become unmanageable. Understanding that sequence is the first step, because the legal analysis turns on whether a European company ends a contract for ordinary commercial reasons or in order to comply with a foreign sanctions regime.

A. What happened between the ICC and Axa on 1 October 2026

On 1 October 2026, Reuters reported that the Hague-based court had ended its contract with Axa starting October 1 and would now use a new health insurance provider. The report, which picked up an exclusive first published by the Financial Times, stressed that the spokesperson gave no reason for the decision and declined to name the replacement insurer. The Financial Times, cited by Reuters, added the decisive detail: Axa pointed to the “extraterritorial application” of American sanctions and to an international environment described as increasingly tense and complex for businesses. The same reporting noted that Axa had held months of discussions internally and with the ICC about potential workarounds but had been unable to find a solution without a so-called blocking statute, meaning a European legal shield against the effects of third-country sanctions. Al Jazeera, summarising the Financial Times reporting, wrote that both sides feared looming sanctions would force the Paris-based insurer to stop serving the court.

That concern did not come out of nowhere. On 6 February 2025, the White House issued an executive order entitled Imposing Sanctions on the International Criminal Court. Its core mechanism is a classic American blocking measure: all property under American control belonging to targeted persons is frozen and can no longer be moved or dealt in The order covers ICC officials involved in investigations of American and allied personnel, anyone assisting them, and entities owned or controlled by designated persons. It adds that “tangible and significant consequences”, including asset freezes and the suspension of entry into the United States for ICC officials, staff, agents and their immediate families Entry into the United States of designated persons and ICC staff is suspended, donations and contributions of funds, goods or services to designated persons are restricted, and the Treasury is instructed to implement the regime with prior notice dispensed with where funds could move instantaneously.

Implementation followed. The Trump administration has already sanctioned more than a dozen ICC judges and prosecutors, including the ICC president in August. In September 2026, the Wall Street Journal reported that the White House was preparing sanctions against the Court as a whole, and President Trump publicly urged other countries to leave the ICC, calling it evil and a rogue institution. The ICC itself warned, according to the Wall Street Journal reporting relayed by Al Jazeera: the ICC warned that sanctions could cut its access to dollar transactions, according to Wall Street Journal reporting relayed by Al Jazeera. For an institution that pays staff, suppliers and insurers in normal commercial circuits, losing reliable dollar clearing is an operational threat, not a diplomatic slogan.

Two reservations matter at this stage, and this article keeps them in view throughout. First, neither the Court nor Axa has officially confirmed that American sanctions caused the termination; the sanctions explanation comes from Financial Times reporting, not from a published decision of either party, and the termination was presented as mutual. Second, at the date of writing, no American measure designating the Court as an institution, or Axa itself, has been published; the pressure described here operated largely by anticipation. Nothing in this article suggests wrongdoing by either side, and the contracts signed by the parties govern their relationship.

B. Why dollar transactions give Washington leverage over a Hague institution

The leverage does not depend on Washington having any authority over the Court. The ICC is a treaty body created by the Rome Statute, which neither the United States nor, for that matter, several other major states have ratified. American sanctions work instead through the private sector: any bank, insurer, asset manager or service company with assets, branches, clients or clearing activity in the United States must choose between its American footprint and the targeted relationship. Because international insurance, reinsurance and employee-benefit business is routinely priced, reserved and settled with dollar legs, and because correspondent banking for dollar payments clears through the United States, even a health and life policy for an international organisation seated in The Hague can carry American sanctions exposure.

The executive order widens that exposure deliberately. Beyond designated officials, it reaches anyone who has materially assisted, sponsored, or provided financial, material, or technological support for sanctioned activity, or goods or services in support of it, as well as entities owned or controlled by designated persons. A commercial insurer does not need to be named to feel the chill: the mere prospect of being characterised as a support provider, combined with the speed of asset freezes and the difficulty of obtaining licences, pushes compliance departments toward early exit. That anticipatory logic is exactly what the European Union blocking statute was written to counter, as the Court of Justice later confirmed when it held that listed American laws produce their effects through the mere threat of legal consequences, so that making the European prohibition conditional on a foreign order would strip it of any practical effect.

Insurers are particularly exposed for three practical reasons. First, large groups such as Axa hold substantial American assets, subsidiaries and policyholder relationships, so the cost of an American enforcement action dwarfs the margin on any single group policy. Second, insurance contracts renew annually and require continuous claims handling, premium flows and reinsurance placements, which means sanctions exposure is not a one-off payment but a daily operational risk. Third, replacing an insurer for an international institution is itself disruptive: medical networks, pending claims and coverage continuity must be preserved, which explains why the Court and Axa reportedly spent months looking for a workaround before accepting a mutual termination with an unnamed successor.

The result is a paradox worth stating plainly. The sanctions campaign aims to isolate the Court by raising the cost of servicing it, while European law aims to protect European operators by forbidding them to yield to that pressure. A Paris-based company serving a Hague-based court at the request of the international criminal justice system thus finds itself exactly where both regimes bite hardest. The next part examines what the European and French rules actually demand in that position.

II. What French and EU law say when Washington orders and Brussels forbids

Seen from Paris, the Axa episode is not primarily an American story. It is a European conflict-of-laws story, in which an EU operator must navigate two prohibitions pointing in opposite directions: do not serve the target, says Washington; do not comply with Washington, says Brussels, with Paris adding criminal penalties of its own. France brings three layers to the analysis: the EU blocking regulation, directly applicable in France; the French blocking law of 1968, which carries imprisonment and fines; and a dense domestic practice of surrendering suspects to international tribunals and of litigating frozen assets, which shows how French courts handle the sharp end of international coercion.

A. The EU blocking statute and the 1968 French blocking law forbid compliance with Washington

The European instrument is Council Regulation 2271/96, the EU blocking statute, which protects EU operators against the effects of the extraterritorial application of listed third-country laws, a list that has covered the American Iran and Cuba sanctions regimes and illustrates the mechanism now discussed for the ICC campaign. Its central prohibition is drafted in deliberately wide terms: no EU operator may comply, actively or by deliberate omission, with any requirement or prohibition flowing from the listed foreign laws, including foreign court orders Article 11 covers EU nationals, residents, companies incorporated in the Union, and business conducted within it, so a Paris-based insurer falls squarely inside. The other side of the instrument is a clawback right: an EU operator harmed by those foreign laws can claw back damages and legal costs from whoever caused them Member states must back the regime with penalties that are effective, proportional and dissuasive.

The Court of Justice gave this prohibition teeth in its Grand Chamber judgment of 21 December 2021 in Bank Melli Iran v Telekom Deutschland, Case C-124/20, the first ruling to interpret the blocking statute. The dispute concerned a German telecom operator that had ordinarily terminated contracts with an Iranian bank listed under American secondary sanctions, without giving reasons. The Court held that the prohibition applies even without a foreign order: the prohibition would lose all practical effect if it applied only once a foreign authority had issued an order, since listed American laws bite through the mere threat of consequences. The ban therefore covers anticipatory compliance. In other words, yielding in advance to the threat is already compliance. On remedies, the Court accepted that national judges may annul a termination effected to comply with listed foreign laws: the regulation allows national courts to annul a termination carried out to comply with listed foreign laws, even without a Commission authorisation, subject to proportionality. Annulment must still survive a proportionality review weighing the EU interest against the operator’s likely economic loss, and the Court noted pointedly that the operator in that case had weakened its own position by never seeking a Commission authorisation. The lesson for any EU company today is direct: ending a contract to get ahead of American sanctions can be unlawful under EU law, can be unwound by a court, and the safe route runs through a Commission authorisation showing that refusal would seriously damage its interests.

France then adds its own, older and criminally backed layer. The Law of 26 July 1968 on the communication of economic, commercial, industrial, financial or technical documents and information to foreign persons, the so-called French blocking law, remains in force and directly targets the situation of a French company pressed by a foreign authority. Article 1 provides: “Sous réserve des traités ou accords internationaux, il est interdit à toute personne physique de nationalité française ou résidant habituellement sur le territoire français et à tout dirigeant, représentant, agent ou préposé d’une personne morale y ayant son siège ou un établissement de communiquer par écrit, oralement ou sous toute autre forme, en quelque lieu que ce soit, à des autorités publiques étrangères, les documents ou les renseignements d’ordre économique, commercial, industriel, financier ou technique dont la communication est de nature à porter atteinte à la souveraineté, à la sécurité, aux intérêts économiques essentiels de la France ou à l’ordre public, précisés par l’autorité administrative en tant que de besoin.” Article 1 bis goes further and covers the gathering of evidence for foreign proceedings: “Sous réserve des traités ou accords internationaux et des lois et règlements en vigueur, il est interdit à toute personne de demander, de rechercher ou de communiquer, par écrit, oralement ou sous toute autre forme, des documents ou renseignements d’ordre économique, commercial, industriel, financier ou technique tendant à la constitution de preuves en vue de procédures judiciaires ou administratives étrangères ou dans le cadre de celles-ci.” The procedural reflex, under Article 2, is mandatory disclosure to Paris, not to the foreign authority: “Les personnes visées aux articles 1er et 1er bis sont tenues d’informer sans délai le ministre compétent lorsqu’elles se trouvent saisies de toute demande concernant de telles communications.” And breach is a criminal offence under Article 3: “Sans préjudice des peines plus lourdes prévues par la loi, toute infraction aux dispositions des articles 1er et 1er bis de la présente loi sera punie d’un emprisonnement de six mois et d’une amende de 18000 euros ou de l’une de ces deux peines seulement.” For a French insurer, the practical message is symmetrical to the EU one: cooperating too readily with a foreign sanctions apparatus can mean breaking French law at home.

Read together, the two layers explain why the reported Axa discussions kept returning to the missing blocking statute. An authorisation from the European Commission under the second paragraph of Article 5 of the EU regulation is the only clean exit door the European system offers: a company that shows that refusal would seriously damage its interests or those of the Union can be permitted to comply in whole or in part. Without that permission, a termination motivated by American sanctions exposure risks annulment before an EU court under Bank Melli, administrative penalties for breach of the regulation, and, where documents or information were handed to foreign authorities, French criminal exposure under the 1968 law. Presenting the ending of the relationship as genuinely mutual, ordinary and commercially grounded, rather than as compliance with the foreign regime, is therefore not cosmetic for the parties. It is the factual ground on which the whole European-law assessment turns, and it is presumably why both the Court and the insurer framed the outcome exactly that way. Whether a court seised of the matter would accept that framing would depend on evidence of motive, contemporaneous documents and the proportionality balance the Court of Justice requires, not on labels alone.

B. Surrender to international courts and frozen-asset challenges: the view from Paris

The insurance contract is only one thread in a wider fabric. France is one of the venues where international criminal justice becomes concrete: suspects are arrested on French soil, detention is ordered by French judges, and surrender to international jurisdictions is decided by the Paris chambre de l’instruction with review by the Cour de cassation. The Code of Criminal Procedure devotes a full subdivision to cooperation with the International Criminal Court, and its arrest-and-surrender mechanics show how seriously French procedure treats the liberty interests at stake. Article 627-5 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides: “Toute personne appréhendée en vertu d’une demande d’arrestation aux fins de remise doit être déférée dans les vingt-quatre heures au procureur de la République territorialement compétent.” Within that short window the person must be told, in a language she or he understands, that surrender is sought and that appearance before the prosecutor general at the Paris Court of Appeal will follow within days, with counsel of her or his choice or court-appointed counsel, an immediate confidential interview, and, where continued detention is sought, presentation to the liberty and detention judge with alternatives to custody available under the Rome Statute framework. Readers who want the ICC surrender mechanics in a concrete case can compare this procedural picture with the recent Bangui courtroom outcome and its French surrender implications examined in the analysis of the September 2026 Said verdict and what France does with ICC fugitives.

French appellate practice confirms that Paris routinely delivers suspects to international jurisdictions and that the Cour de cassation polices the procedure strictly. On 30 September 2020, the Criminal Chamber ruled: “REJET sur les pourvois formés par M. R… J… contre l’arrêt de la chambre de l’instruction de la cour d’appel de Paris, 5e section, en date du 3 juin 2020, qui, dans la procédure suivie contre lui, notamment, pour génocide et crimes contre l’humanité, a ordonné sa remise au Mécanisme pour les tribunaux pénaux internationaux.” The Paris investigating chamber had ordered surrender to the Mechanism for International Criminal Tribunals in a genocide and crimes-against-humanity case, and the Cour de cassation rejected the challenges, including detailed arguments on medical examination, interpretation, earlier custody records, searches, seizures and DNA identification. The message for an international audience is that France is a reliable cooperation venue for international tribunals, which is precisely why measures that degrade the Court’s support structures in Europe, from banking to insurance, matter operationally and not only symbolically.

At the same time, French courts set a high bar before surrender and keep every refusal ground under close review. In a 29 November 2022 ruling on a European Arrest Warrant double-criminality question, the Criminal Chamber held: “DIT N’Y AVOIR LIEU DE RENVOYER au Conseil constitutionnel la question prioritaire de constitutionnalité ;” The underlying debate concerned Article 695-23 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Court of Justice’s 14 July 2022 interpretation of double criminality, and the Cour de cassation refused to send the constitutional challenge onward, recalling that principles inherent in French constitutional identity cannot be invoked against legislation transposing the European Arrest Warrant framework as interpreted by the EU Court. Transposed to the ICC context, the parallel is instructive: surrender decisions obey treaty and statutory procedures interpreted uniformly, individual safeguards are real but narrowly framed, and political or diplomatic pressure from any side has no recognised place in the surrender test. Sanctions that squeeze the Court’s budget, staff cover or insurance do not change those tests, but they can slow the machinery they serve.

Insurance law itself adds a final French touch. Group health and life cover of the kind at issue here sits under the Insurance Code, whose Article L113-12 states: “La durée du contrat et les conditions de résiliation, particulièrement le droit pour l’assureur et l’assuré de résilier le contrat tous les ans, sont fixées par la police.” The same article gives the policyholder an annual termination right on notice, extends a symmetrical right to the insurer for professional-purpose contracts, and otherwise conditions the insurer’s annual termination on registered notice months before maturity, while expressly providing that its rules do not apply to life assurance. Annual-group health policies therefore end lawfully every year when notice and timing rules are respected, which is consistent with a clean mutual termination and equally consistent with a termination whose real motive a court might later have to assess under the blocking statute. Motive evidence, once again, decides.

For companies and listed persons facing the sanctions side of the picture from France, the practical routes are well trodden and entirely separate from the insurance question. EU restrictive measures are challenged before the EU courts in Luxembourg, where applicants contest the statement of reasons, the evidence and proportionality, and French judges handle the domestic consequences such as frozen bank accounts and blocked transactions. Readers concerned by that neighbouring problem will find the method set out step by step in the guide to challenging an EU listing or a frozen account from France after the recent annulment case law. The common thread is documentation: keep the designation instruments, the banks’ letters, the dates of each freeze, and every request for authorisation, because both delisting litigation and blocking-statute authorisation requests live or die on contemporaneous paper.

Conclusion

The ending of the ICC-Axa insurance relationship on 1 October 2026 looks, on the reported facts, like a textbook case of secondary pressure doing its work before any formal designation. No official source has confirmed that American sanctions caused the split; the Court and the insurer speak only of mutual agreement, and no published American measure names either of them. What is confirmed is the surrounding coercive sequence, from the February 2025 executive order through the summer 2026 designations of ICC judges and prosecutors to the September 2026 threats against the institution as a whole and its dollar transactions, and the reported failure of months of workaround talks for want of a European blocking shield.

The legal position from Paris is correspondingly two-sided and should be stated without exaggeration. Under the EU blocking statute as interpreted in Bank Melli, a European operator may not comply, even by anticipation, with listed foreign sanctions requirements, and a termination effected for that purpose can be annulled subject to proportionality, with a Commission authorisation as the only orderly way out. Under the French 1968 blocking law, passing sensitive economic or technical material to foreign authorities can be a criminal offence, and any such approach triggers a duty to inform the competent minister without delay. Under French surrender and insurance law, meanwhile, Paris remains a cooperation-friendly venue where international surrenders are ordered and reviewed under strict procedural safeguards, and where group cover ends lawfully on proper notice, whatever a later court might conclude about underlying motives.

No accident, no intrusion and no established liability of any kind has been found by any official source in this matter at the date of writing, and only a court seised of a concrete dispute could decide how these overlapping regimes apply to these particular contracts. Companies with American exposure and European seats should therefore treat the Axa precedent as a warning to prepare early: map dollar-touching flows, seek European authorisation before acting, notify where French law requires it, and build the documentary record that Luxembourg, Paris or an arbitral tribunal would demand. The sanctions campaign against the Court will continue to test every link in its support chain, and each link will now be examined under both American and European law at once.

📄 Official circular