KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Live in France and Want to Give Up My US Passport: the $450 Oath, the Expatriation Tax, and Why French Citizenship Must Come First

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Live in France and Want to Give Up My US Passport: the $450 Oath, the Expatriation Tax, and Why French Citizenship Must Come First

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have lived in France for years. You file a French tax return every spring, and then you file an American one too. Your French bank sends your account details to the IRS under FATCA, you declare the same accounts again on the FBAR, and your French life-insurance contract or your PEA is treated in America as a toxic tax trap. One evening you ask the obvious question: what if I simply gave up my American passport? The answer matters more than most expatriates think, because giving up an American passport is a two-country operation. On the American side, only a formal oath taken in person before a consular officer, followed by a Certificate of Loss of Nationality, ends your citizenship, and it can trigger an exit tax that treats everything you own as sold the day before you leave. On the French side, nothing changes by itself: you keep your French tax home, your French property and your French reporting duties, and if you renounce before you have secured French nationality, you can end up a foreigner in the country where you live. This guide walks through both halves in order. First, the American procedure that really works: the oath under section 349(a)(5) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, the two appointments, and the 450-dollar consular fee for the certificate. Second, the American tax exit: who counts as a covered expatriate, how the mark-to-market deemed sale works, and why five years of clean tax filings are the key to the whole building. Third, the French arrival: why naturalization by decree must come first, what the minister demands on language, work and residence, and what two 2026 rulings of the Nantes administrative court of appeal teach applicants. Finally, the French tax position after the oath: your domicile stays French, France has its own exit tax if you ever leave with company shares, and the treaty between France and the United States keeps allocating taxing rights over your house and your estate. Every French legal term is explained the first time it appears.

I. Giving Up the Passport: the American Procedure That Really Ends Citizenship

A. The In-Person Oath, the Interviews, and the 450-Dollar Certificate of Loss of Nationality

American citizenship does not end because you stop renewing your passport, because you vote in France, or because you tell your bank you are French now. It ends through one of the seven expatriating acts listed in section 349 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, and for Americans living in France the only practical route is paragraph (a)(5): a formal renunciation of nationality made before an American diplomatic or consular officer in a foreign country, in the form prescribed by the Secretary of State. In practice the Department approves a “Certificate of Loss of Nationality”, universally called the CLN, only if you took the oath voluntarily and with the intention of giving up American nationality. Voluntariness is presumed, but the presumption can be rebutted on the facts of your case, and the Department treats taking the oath as an unequivocal statement of intent to give up citizenship. The official rule carries the whole procedure in one requirement: the oath of renunciation must be taken in person, in the manner prescribed by the Department of State. No letter, no email, no agent, no video call can replace your physical presence.

In Paris, the road to that oath runs through the consular section of the American Embassy. You first complete an online questionnaire to request a loss-of-nationality appointment, then you attend a first interview where an officer reviews your file, your American passport, your French residence documents and a long questionnaire about your motives and your understanding of the consequences, and finally you return for a second appointment at which you sign the oath and the statement of understanding in person. Only applicants who live in France use Paris; Americans who live elsewhere must apply at the post responsible for their place of residence. Between the two appointments, weeks or months can pass, and the Embassy uses that time to verify that you act voluntarily and that you understand that renunciation is irrevocable. Once the oath is taken and the file is complete, Washington examines the case and, if everything is in order, issues the Certificate of Loss of Nationality. The CLN is the only document that proves you are no longer American: French banks, French notaries, known in France as the notaire, the public officer who handles conveyancing and estates, and the French tax administration all ask for it before they treat you as a former American.

The price of that certificate changed recently, and older guides still quote the wrong number. For years the consular fee for renunciation was 2,350 dollars, one of the highest administrative fees in the world. The State Department has since lowered it. The current fee, published by American consular posts, is exact: a “non-waivable” and “non-refundable” consular services fee of $450 for processing a Certificate of Loss of Nationality request. Read every word of that sentence. Non-waivable means no hardship exception. Non-refundable means that a denied request does not earn the money back. Pay only when you are certain you want to proceed, because the fee buys an administrative decision, not a guaranteed certificate.

Three warnings belong in this section because Americans discover them too late. First, the oath ends your citizenship going forward; it does not erase the past. Every American tax return, every FBAR, every Form 8938 and every Form 8621 you owed before the expatriation date remains owed, with penalties, and the IRS keeps full collection powers over those years. Second, renunciation can leave you stateless if you hold no other nationality, and while the United States does not formally require you to hold a second citizenship, consular officers probe this point hard at the interviews, precisely because France will then treat you as a stateless foreigner for residence purposes. This is why the second half of this guide insists that French naturalization come first. Third, renunciation is final. There is no cooling-off period, no administrative appeal that restores citizenship, and the rare cases of people who recovered American nationality after renouncing involved years of federal litigation. Treat the oath the way French law treats a decree: a sovereign act that closes a door behind you.

B. The Expatriation Tax: Covered Expatriates, the Deemed Sale, and Form 8854

The day after your oath, a second American administration takes over your file: the Internal Revenue Service. Sections 877 and 877A of the Internal Revenue Code impose a special expatriation tax regime on citizens who renounce and on long-term residents who end their American residence for federal tax purposes. For anyone who expatriates on or after June 17, 2008, section 877A applies, and everything turns on a single label: “covered expatriate”. If the label sticks to you, you pay an exit tax. If it does not, you generally walk away with only a final year of normal filings.

You become a covered expatriate if any one of three statutory tests is met, and the IRS lists them as alternatives: For those who expatriated on or after June 17, 2008, the newer section 877A rules apply whenever any one of the listed statements fits. The first test is wealth: a net worth of $2 million or more on the date of expatriation or termination of residency. Net worth means everything, worldwide, minus debts: your apartment in Paris or your house in the Dordogne at fair market value, your French bank accounts, your assurance-vie, a French life-insurance savings contract whose American tax treatment is already painful, your American retirement accounts, and your share of any company. Many France-settled Americans cross the two-million line on the Paris apartment alone without feeling wealthy, because the test ignores purchasing power and counts gross assets. The second test is compliance, and it is the trap for the careless: The second test is compliance: failing to certify on Form 8854 that you complied with all American federal tax obligations for the five years before expatriation. Five full years of returns, FBARs, and information forms, complete and accurate. Miss one FBAR from four years ago and you certify falsely or you fail to certify at all, and the statute makes you a “covered expatriate” automatically. One test out of the three is enough.

The consequence for covered expatriates is the mark-to-market regime, and its wording deserves a slow reading: Section 877A imposes a “mark-to-market regime”: all property of a covered expatriate is deemed sold for its fair market value on the day before the expatriation date. Deemed sold means the tax code pretends you sold your Paris apartment, your stock portfolio and your company shares the day before the oath, and it taxes the resulting gains in that final year despite any other provision of the Code. Losses count too, but only as the Code otherwise allows, and the wash-sale rules of section 1091 do not apply to the deemed sale. Concretely, an American who bought a Paris apartment decades ago and renounces as a covered expatriate can owe American tax on decades of Paris appreciation in a single year, on top of the French capital-gains bill that will arrive separately when the apartment is actually sold later. The statute provides an exclusion amount, adjusted yearly for inflation, that shelters part of the deemed gain, but the exclusion does not shelter everything, and retirement accounts and interests in trusts follow special deferred rules of their own. None of this touches non-covered expatriates, which is why tax preparation in the five years before the oath is the most valuable planning an applicant can buy: clean filings are what keep the deemed sale from ever happening.

The paperwork that proves your status is Form 8854, the Initial and Annual Expatriation Statement, filed with your final American return for the year of expatriation. On that form you certify the five years of compliance, you list your balance sheet for the net-worth test, and you compute the exit tax if you are covered. File it late or never, and the IRS treats you as a covered expatriate by default in many examination postures, so the form is not optional paperwork but the document that locks in non-covered treatment. Keep the CLN, the stamped Form 8854, and the proof of the five compliant years together: your French notaire will want the CLN when you later sell or transmit property as a non-American, and any future American examination starts with the 8854. One practical note for couples: each spouse is tested separately. A French-American couple in which only the American spouse renounces leaves the other spouse’s American obligations untouched, and jointly owned French property counts in the renouncing spouse’s balance sheet for his or her share.

II. After the Oath: Staying Fully French Without the American Half

A. Secure French Naturalization Before You Renounce Anything

The Americans who renounce safely from France almost all follow the same sequence: become French first, give up the American passport second. The reason is quite simple. Until your French decree is signed, you live in France as an American with a French residence permit. If you renounce first and the naturalization later fails, you live in France as a former American with no residence right of your own, no European Union citizenship, and no American passport to fall back on. France tolerates dual nationality with the United States without any difficulty, so there is no legal obstacle to holding both passports for as long as it takes to complete the French procedure. Use that tolerance. File for French nationality, wait for the decree, verify your French passport and national identity card, and only then book the consular oath. Readers tracing the other direction, proving a French nationality they already hold through a parent or grandparent, follow a different route explained in our guide on how Americans prove French citizenship by descent and win the nationality certificate; this section concerns adults who must acquire French nationality from scratch.

Acquisition by decision of the public authority, which is the legal name for what everyone calls naturalization, comes from article 21-15 of the Civil Code, the code civil, France’s main private-law code: “l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger” Three words matter: par décret, by decree. Naturalization is not a right you claim but a favor the government grants, signed by the Prime Minister on the proposal of the Minister of the Interior, after an investigation run by the prefecture of your home department. The conditions sit at three levels. First, residence. Article 21-16 states the rule in one sentence: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation.” The official Service Public guidance on naturalization by decree, the government information portal every applicant should read before hiring counsel, translates this into practice: you must reside in France when the decree is signed, meaning the center of your material interests, including professional ones, and your family ties must be in France. An American who keeps a professional life centered in New York while sleeping in Paris risks failing exactly this test. Second, duration. The same official page requires a minimum of five years of residence in France, with narrow reductions for studies, services rendered to France, or refugees. Third, assimilation to the French community, which article 21-24 defines: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française, notamment par une connaissance suffisante, selon sa condition, de la langue, de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises” In current practice that means a certified French level of at least B1 on the European scale, an individual interview at the prefecture covering history, values and daily life, and adhesion to the principles of the Republic sealed by signing the charter of rights and duties of the French citizen.

Professional integration is where settled Americans most often stumble, and the official wording is stricter than many expect: integration through work is an essential condition, meaning the applicant must show a “stable and sufficient income” supporting the household. Retirees living on American pensions, freelancers with irregular income, and trailing spouses without their own activity must document stability with particular care, because the minister enjoys, in the courts’ own words, “un large pouvoir d’appréciation,” a wide discretion, in nationality matters. The Nantes administrative court of appeal, the cour administrative d’appel de Nantes, which hears all appeals against nationality decisions in France, restated the rule on July 22, 2026, in decision number 25NT03094: “L’autorité administrative dispose, en matière de naturalisation ou de réintégration dans la nationalité française, d’un large pouvoir d’appréciation. Elle peut, dans l’exercice de ce pouvoir, prendre en considération notamment, pour apprécier l’intérêt que présenterait l’octroi de la nationalité française, l’insertion sociale et professionnelle de l’intéressé.” In that case a woman who had lived in France since 1989, held French architecture and urban-planning degrees, and raised two French children saw her two-year postponement upheld because her return to salaried work dated only from January 2023 on a fixed-term contract, still in its trial period when the minister decided. The full decision is published at CAA Nantes, 5th chamber, July 22, 2026, no. 25NT03094. The lesson for Americans: file when your professional situation is stable and documented, not during a gap year.

Language works the same way, and a second recent ruling shows that even serious medical excuses have limits. On March 20, 2026, the same court decided case number 25NT01434, concerning a hearing-impaired applicant who argued that her disability prevented her from learning French. The court recalled that disabled applicants are excused from producing the standard language diploma, then held that “une telle circonstance ne fait pas obstacle à ce que le niveau de connaissance de la langue française de ces personnes soit pris en compte pour apprécier l’opportunité de leur accorder la naturalisation,” meaning the administration may still assess their French during the individual interview. Because the applicant, resident since 2011, could neither understand simple questions about her own situation nor express herself in French, and could not show that her disability had made any learning impossible, the rejection stood. Read it at CAA Nantes, March 20, 2026, no. 25NT01434. For an American applicant the message is direct: prepare the language test early, keep every diploma and certificate, and never assume that long residence compensates for weak French. If the minister rejects or postpones your file, the remedy runs first to the Nantes administrative tribunal and then to the Nantes court of appeal, and both judges review the file as it stood on the day the minister decided, so a file completed after the decision cannot save it. Americans who prepare the naturalization file and the consular renunciation file together, with counsel checking each against the other, avoid the classic trap of renouncing while the French decree is still uncertain. Our office reviews both tracks side by side; Maître Hassan Kohen can be reached at +33 6 89 11 34 45 for that combined review.

B. Your French Tax Home Does Not Move With Your Passport

Many Americans imagine that giving up the passport moves their tax life to France the way changing a flag moves a ship. French tax law sees it differently: your American nationality never determined your French tax residence, so losing it does not change it. Article 4 A of the General Tax Code, the code général des impôts, sets the principle: “Les personnes qui ont en France leur domicile fiscal sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu en raison de l’ensemble de leurs revenus.” If your tax home, your domicile fiscal, is in France, France taxes your worldwide income; if it is abroad, France taxes only your French-source income. And article 4 B defines that home with three alternative tests, and persons fall inside the French tax home as soon as they meet any of them, starting with “Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal”; the other two are professional activity in France and the center of economic interests. Read the details on article 4 A of the General Tax Code and article 4 B of the General Tax Code. An American who lives, works and keeps family in France is French tax resident before the oath and French tax resident after it. The oath changes the American half of the equation only: no more worldwide American returns going forward, no more FBAR, no more Form 8938, no more PFIC regime on French funds, a subject detailed in our analysis of the PFIC trap on assurance-vie, PEA and ETFs. Everything French continues exactly as before, including the yearly declaration of foreign accounts that survives for any account you still hold abroad, a duty explained in our guide to French and American double reporting, form 3916 and FBAR deadlines.

The treaty between France and the United States keeps working after renunciation too, but its role narrows. The consolidated estate-and-gift treaty and the income-tax treaty allocate taxing rights between the two countries based on residence and on the location of property, not on the passport you hold, so a former American domiciled in France remains taxable in France on French real estate and in America only on American-source income under the treaty’s tie-breaker rules. The official consolidated text of the Franco-American estate treaty is published by the French tax administration at impots.gouv.fr, consolidated France-United States estate and gift treaty. One clause deserves attention from anyone who renounces and later inherits from American parents: the treaty’s credit mechanism still prevents the same estate from being fully taxed twice, but the former American is now purely a French resident heir for treaty purposes, which changes which country taxes first. Keep the treaty PDF with your estate file and show it to the notaire handling any succession.

Finally, France has its own exit tax, and former Americans discover it when they later leave France with company shares. Article 167 bis of the General Tax Code provides: “Les contribuables fiscalement domiciliés en France pendant au moins six des dix années précédant le transfert de leur domicile fiscal hors de France sont imposables lors de ce transfert au titre des plus-values latentes constatées” meaning that after at least six years of French tax residence out of the last ten, moving your tax home out of France triggers immediate taxation of unrealized gains on substantial shareholdings, with deferral mechanisms while you stay inside the European Union. Full text at article 167 bis of the General Tax Code. The symmetry is worth stating plainly. America taxes your worldwide gains the day before you stop being American; France taxes your latent share gains the day you stop being French tax resident. Renouncing the passport settles the first bill, not the second, so anyone who might later follow children back to America or retire elsewhere should map both exit taxes before taking either oath. And one last French nationality safeguard belongs here for readers with French ancestry: article 18 of the Civil Code provides that “Est français l’enfant dont l’un des parents au moins est français” while article 23-6 allows a court to record the loss of French nationality for French nationals by descent who never lived in France and whose family lost all French ties “depuis un demi-siècle,” for half a century. Renunciation of American citizenship never triggers those provisions, but Americans who let every French link lapse for generations can lose the very nationality they now seek, which is one more reason to anchor yourself in French civil status, French residence and French paperwork before you cut the American tie.

Conclusion

Giving up an American passport from France is a procedure, a tax event and a French naturalization strategy in that order, and each step has its own price for haste. The procedure demands your physical presence, two consular interviews, an irrevocable oath under section 349(a)(5), and a non-refundable 450-dollar fee that buys a decision, not a guaranteed certificate. The tax event turns on three tests, and the two that trap France-settled Americans are the two-million-dollar worldwide net worth, easily reached by a Paris apartment, and the five-year clean-filing certification on Form 8854, which fails on a single forgotten FBAR. Covered expatriates pay the mark-to-market tax on everything they own the day before the oath; non-covered expatriates file a final return and walk away. The French strategy reverses the instinct: become French first through naturalization by decree, with five years of residence, a stable professional situation, B1 French and a file strong enough to survive the minister’s wide discretion and the Nantes courts’ review, and only then renounce. After the oath, France still taxes your worldwide income as a French resident, the treaties still divide taxing rights with America, FATCA and the FBAR fall away, and France’s own exit tax waits for anyone who later leaves with shares. Done in that order, renunciation closes the American file without opening a French one.

📄 Official circular