Your father owned a house in France and lived most of his later years between Paris and Florida. When he died, you learned from the French notaire — the public officer who settles successions, authenticates deeds, and collects the duties owed to the Treasury — that your brother had already received the house by a donation made years earlier, and that the American will your father signed in Miami leaves everything else to that same brother. You received nothing. Under the law of Florida, that outcome would stand: an American testator can generally disinherit an adult child. Under French law, it often does not stand, because France protects children through a forced share that no will and no lifetime gift can simply erase. This article explains, for an American heir with no background in French law, how much of a French estate the law guarantees you, why a United States will does not automatically defeat your claim, which lawsuit reclaims your share from the sibling who received too much, and which deadlines destroy your claim if you wait. Every French term is defined the first time it appears, every decisive rule is quoted from the statute or the court that stated it, and every computation is shown with numbers so you can test your own situation before you call anyone.
I. Can My Parent Really Leave Me Nothing? What French Law Guarantees Every Child
A. How Much of the French Estate Is Legally Yours: the Forced Share and the Disposable Portion
French succession law divides every estate into two slices. The first slice is the réserve héréditaire, the forced share: the portion of the property and succession rights that the law guarantees to certain heirs, called héritiers réservataires (forced heirs), when they are called to the succession and accept it. The second slice is the quotité disponible, the disposable portion: everything else, which the deceased was free to give away by lifetime gift (donation) or by will (testament). The statute states it exactly this way: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” Children are the primary forced heirs; when the deceased leaves no children, the surviving spouse becomes a forced heir instead. The official service-public.fr page confirms the practical consequence in plain terms: when French law governs the succession, a parent cannot disinherit children, and it publishes the exact table that follows (Peut-on déshériter ses enfants ?).
The size of your guaranteed slice depends only on how many children the deceased left. The rule, unchanged in substance since 1804 and restated by article 913 of the Civil Code, reads: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” In other words, lifetime gifts plus testamentary gifts combined cannot exceed one half of the property with one child, one third with two children, and one quarter with three or more. Mirror those ceilings and you get the forced share: one half for a single child, two thirds split between two children (one third each), three quarters split among three or more. If you are one of two children, your personal forced share equals one third of the legally recomputed estate — not one third of whatever happens to be left on the day of death, but one third of a larger reconstructed total, as the next paragraph shows.
That reconstruction is where most American families lose the thread, and where French law is most protective. Gifts your parent made years ago are not forgotten: they are fictitiously added back into the estate to test whether the disposable portion was exceeded. Article 922 commands: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.” The mechanism is called the réunion fictive, the fictitious reunion of lifetime gifts with the assets owned at death, after deducting debts. Take a concrete case. Your father died owning a Paris apartment worth 400,000 euros, but eight years earlier he had donated a Normandy house now worth 500,000 euros to your brother. The computation mass is 900,000 euros minus any debts. With two children, the disposable portion is one third of 900,000, or 300,000 euros. Your brother received 500,000 euros, which exceeds the disposable portion by 200,000 euros. That 200,000-euro excess is the amount your forced share can reclaim — and your personal forced share is one third of 900,000, or 300,000 euros, against which anything you personally received is credited. Debts reduce the mass, gifts made to strangers count the same as gifts made to a sibling, and property your brother later sold is counted at its value when sold. The Cour de cassation, France’s supreme court for civil matters, confirmed in a June 2026 decision that this fictitious reunion must be performed even when there is no undivided estate left to divide, because the compensation owed to the deprived heir is computed only after the disposable portion has been measured (Civ. 1, 10 June 2026, no. 24-10.363).
Two refinements matter for Americans. First, a child who renounces (renonce à) the succession is normally no longer counted when fixing the shares, unless that child is represented by their own descendants or must account for a gift under the reporting rules; article 845 nevertheless lets a renouncing heir keep a lifetime gift or claim a legacy up to the disposable portion. Renouncing to “simplify” matters therefore shrinks the estate’s protection for the remaining children and should never be signed at the notaire’s office without advice. Second, your sibling may answer that you signed away your rights in advance. French law does allow an advance waiver called the renonciation anticipée à l’action en réduction (RAAR), but it is valid only as a specific authentic instrument received by two notaires, signed separately by each waiving heir in the notaires’ presence alone, and stating its precise future legal consequences for each person (article 930). A letter, an email, a clause buried in an American document, or a signature obtained at a family meeting is not a RAAR. If your brother produces anything short of that two-notaire deed, the waiver argument fails at the threshold.
B. Why Your Parent’s American Will Does Not Automatically Defeat Your Claim
The objection every American heir hears first is that the deceased chose American law, so French forced heirship should not apply. Sometimes that objection is correct, often it is not, and the answer turns on a European regulation that American families rarely know exists. Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of 4 July 2012 on succession decides which country’s succession law governs an estate with cross-border elements. Its choice-of-law rule lets a person choose, as the law governing the succession as a whole, the law of the state of nationality held either when making the choice or at the time of death. This choice is called the professio juris, the professed choice of law. A dual French-American national, or an American national owning a house in France, can therefore designate United States law — in practice, the law of a specific state such as Florida or New York — to govern the succession as a whole. And the regulation gives that chosen law a wide scope: the chosen law governs the succession as a whole, including specifically the disposable portion, the reserved shares, and the other restrictions on giving property at death. When a valid American-law choice governs, there is no French forced share to enforce, because the applicable law itself defines the shares. The detailed mechanics of that choice — which American nationals can make it, how it must be written into the will, and what it changes for taxes — are explained in our guide to choosing American law for a French house, which also covers the treaty credit that prevents the same value from being taxed twice.
But three common situations leave the American heir fully protected by the French forced share. First, many American wills contain no choice of law at all. Without a valid designation, the regulation applies the law of the deceased’s habitual residence at death — so a parent who had genuinely settled in France dies under French succession law, forced share included, whatever the Miami will says. Second, even an explicit choice of Florida law in the will can fail on formal or substantive validity grounds, and the characterisation of lifetime gifts, joint accounts, or trust-funded acquisitions as succession or non-succession property can pull assets back inside the French computation. Third, and most important for American families, French statute provides a safety net when the applicable foreign law offers children no reserve mechanism at all. The second paragraph of article 913, introduced in 2021 after the Cour de cassation’s 2017 Jarno decisions, allows each child to levy compensatory recovery — the prélèvement compensatoire — against property located in France: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” Read each condition slowly. Either the deceased or at least one child must have been a European Union national or habitually resident in the Union when death occurred — a French-American dual-national parent satisfies this immediately, as does a child living in France. The foreign applicable law must allow no reserve-protecting mechanism for children, which is the normal case under the law of most American states. And the levy operates only against assets situated in France on the day of death, capped at the French forced-share rights. When those conditions are met, the sibling who took the French house under an American-law will can still be compelled to restore your share out of that French property.
The Cour de cassation’s June 2026 ruling adds the final piece of this picture, and American heirs should understand it before negotiating anything. When a will gives everything to one child, the deprived child’s remedy is in principle money, not the house itself. The Court states: “Il résulte des articles 924 et suivants du code civil qu’en principe, le legs est réductible en valeur et non en nature, de sorte qu’il n’existe aucune indivision entre le légataire universel et l’héritier réservataire.” A legacy is reducible in value, not in kind, so no co-ownership arises between the universal legatee and the forced heir. The sibling keeps the house and owes you an indemnity, computed — the Court continues — “d’après la valeur des biens donnés ou légués à l’époque de sa liquidation ou de leur aliénation par le gratifié”, at the value of the gifted or bequeathed property at the time of its liquidation or of its sale by the recipient. And the indemnity is fixed only after the disposable portion has been measured through the fictitious reunion of gifts, “même lorsqu’il n’existe aucune indivision successorale à partager”, even when no undivided estate remains to be shared (Civ. 1, 10 June 2026, no. 24-10.363). Practically, this means you cannot force a sale of the house merely by invoking your forced share, but your sibling cannot answer that there is “nothing to share” either: the fictitious mass is reconstructed, the excess is priced, and the difference is paid to you in money, with the valuation date working in your favor when French property has appreciated.
II. How You Actually Reclaim Your Share From the United States
A. The Reduction Lawsuit: Whom You Sue, in What Order, and What You Receive
The lawsuit that enforces the forced share is the action en réduction, the action for reduction of excessive gifts. Only the persons for whose benefit the law created the reserve — the forced heirs, their own heirs, or their successors in interest — may bring it. The statute is categorical: article 921 provides that “La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause : les donataires, les légataires, ni les créanciers du défunt ne pourront demander cette réduction, ni en profiter.” Neither the recipient of the gift, nor a legatee, nor a creditor of the deceased can demand reduction or benefit from it. As the disinherited child who accepts the succession, you are the paradigmatic plaintiff; your sibling, as donee or legatee, can defend but can never turn the action around against you. And you do not face this computation alone at the start: since 2021, when the notaire settling the succession observes that a forced heir’s reserved rights may have been impaired by the deceased’s gifts, the notaire must inform each known heir concerned, individually and where possible before any partition, of the right to demand reduction of the gifts exceeding the disposable portion. If the French notaire never sent you that information, say so in your first letter, because the file should document when you were warned.
The order of attack is fixed by law and dictates your litigation strategy. Testamentary gifts are reduced before lifetime donations are touched: article 923 states that “Il n’y aura jamais lieu à réduire les donations entre vifs, qu’après avoir épuisé la valeur de tous les biens compris dans les dispositions testamentaires ; et lorsqu’il y aura lieu à cette réduction, elle se fera en commençant par la dernière donation, et ainsi de suite en remontant des dernières aux plus anciennes.” Lifetime donations are therefore reduced starting with the most recent and working backward to the oldest. Among legacies themselves, article 926 orders reduction proportionally, au marc le franc — each legacy reduced in the same proportion — with no distinction between universal and particular legacies. Apply this to the classic American scenario. Your father’s Miami will leaves the French apartment to your brother, and a 2015 donation had already given him the Normandy house. You attack the legacy of the apartment first, proportionally with any other legacies; only if the apartment’s value does not fill your forced share do you reach back to the 2015 donation, and any earlier donation falls only if the later one is exhausted. A sibling who received several gifts over decades cannot hide the recent ones behind the old ones, and a parent cannot protect a favored child by multiplying instruments: each instrument is tested in its statutory rank.
What you receive is, as a rule, money measured at current values. Article 924 provides that “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” Whether the recipient is an heir or a stranger, they must compensate the forced heirs up to the excessive portion, whatever its size. Payment by a forced heir is made by taking less from the estate (en moins prenant), primarily by setoff against their own rights in the reserve. The recipient may, however, elect to return property in kind rather than pay money, but only within a strict framework: article 924-1 allows performance in kind only where the gifted or bequeathed property still belongs to the recipient and is free of charges and occupations that did not already burden it at the date of the gift, and the choice expires if not expressed within three months after a forced heir formally demands that the recipient take a position. Income follows the same logic: article 928 makes the donee return the rents and revenues (fruits) on the excessive portion from the day of the donor’s death when the reduction claim is filed within the year, otherwise from the day of the claim. A brother who collected Paris rents for three years while you were told there was nothing for you owes an accounting of those rents on the excessive share, not merely the capital value.
Proving the case from the United States is an exercise in paper, and the paper is obtainable. You will need the death certificate with an apostille for use in France, proof of your parent-child relationship (birth certificate, family record book or livret de famille if one exists), the American will with a certified translation, every French donation deed (acte de donation) which the notaire or the land registry (service de publicité foncière) holds, bank statements showing transfers that may conceal indirect gifts (donations déguisées) or transfers routed through intermediaries (donations par personne interposée), and a valuation of each French property at opening of the succession and today. French courts routinely appoint a judicial expert to reconstruct the fictitious mass and date the values; your role is to supply the leads — account numbers, approximate dates, addresses — that let the expert find what the file does not yet show. Start by writing to the notaire by registered letter asking for the complete list of gifts revealed by the succession file, the mortgage registry extracts, and the draft computation of the reserve; the notaire’s statutory information duty makes that request legitimate, and the answer fixes the starting point of every deadline discussed below.
B. The Deadlines That Destroy Claims: Five Years, Two Years, Ten Years
Time limits in this field are short, layered, and strictly enforced — and distance does not suspend them. Article 921 sets a triple clock: the reduction action is subject to a five-year limitations period running from the opening of the succession (the death), or to a two-year period running from the day the heirs learned of the impairment of their reserve, without ever exceeding ten years from the death. In practice, an American heir who knew from the funeral that the sibling received the house faces the five-year clock; an heir who discovered the excess only later — through a letter, a registry extract, or the notaire’s computation — benefits from the two-year clock measured from actual knowledge, but the ten-year ceiling from death caps everything. These are prescription periods (délais de prescription), not mere procedural orientations: once expired, the right itself is gone, and no court can revive it out of sympathy for an heir living abroad.
The Cour de cassation illustrated both the danger and the rescue available in a December 2025 decision every American heir should know. A sister attacked lifetime gifts made to her sibling — money and the bare ownership (nue-propriété, ownership stripped of the lifelong right of use called usufruit) of a property — but the courts below declared her reduction action time-barred. The supreme court restated the governing rule word for word: “Aux termes du premier de ces textes, le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” It then recalled the procedural lifeline: “la demande en justice, même en référé, interrompt le délai de prescription et la prescription est suspendue lorsque le juge accueille une demande de mesure d’instruction présentée avant tout procès.” A court application, even in summary référé proceedings, interrupts prescription, and prescription is suspended once the judge grants a pre-trial investigative measure such as appointing an expert. Because the courts below had failed to examine whether the sister’s 2010 summary application for an expert to reconstruct the estate assets had interrupted the five-year clock, and whether the clock had then been suspended from the May 2010 order until the expert’s report in September 2011, the ruling lacked a legal basis and was quashed (Civ. 1, 10 Dec. 2025, no. 23-20.674).
The lesson for an heir in America is operational. Do not wait until you have the full picture to act: file early, even for investigation. A petition to the president of the tribunal judiciaire (the ordinary civil court) sitting in summary proceedings, asking for a judicial expert to reconstruct the fictitious mass and value the French properties, both interrupts the running clock and suspends it while the expert works — exactly the sequence the Cour de cassation protected. Calendar three dates today: five years from the death, two years from each moment you concretely learned of an excessive gift (keep the letter, the email, the notaire’s statement that taught you), and ten years from the death as the absolute wall. Send the formal demand (mise en demeure) to your sibling within months, not years, because article 928 ties the recovery of rents to a claim brought within the year of death. And remember that accepting the succession “purely and simply” (acceptation pure et simple) exposes you to the estate’s debts, while acceptance “up to the net assets” (acceptation à concurrence de l’actif net) caps your liability — a separate declaration, made at the court or before the notaire, that should be weighed before you sue, since reduction litigation can take years and the estate’s creditors do not wait.
Conclusion
An American will that leaves you nothing does not end the inquiry when a French house is involved. French law guarantees each child a forced share measured against a reconstructed estate that adds lifetime gifts back in; a choice of American law in the will displaces that guarantee only when it is valid and effective, and even then the 2021 compensatory levy can restore your rights out of property situated in France; the reduction action converts the excess your sibling received into a money indemnity priced at current values, with rents accounted for; and the whole edifice stands or falls on three clocks — five years from death, two years from knowledge, ten years at most — that early summary proceedings for an expert can interrupt and suspend. Reconstruct the mass, date your knowledge, write to the notaire, and file before the clocks run: the forced share protects only the heir who claims it in time.