KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
US Sanctions the ICC Itself Hours After the Pillay Nobel: Grace Period, Surrender Duties and What France Must Do

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

US Sanctions the ICC Itself Hours After the Pillay Nobel: Grace Period, Surrender Duties and What France Must Do

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 9 October 2026, hours after the Norwegian Nobel Committee awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to former International Criminal Court judge Navanethem Pillay, the United States imposed sanctions on the Court itself. Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced that Washington would ban transactions with the tribunal, which he called a rogue court, with the stated aim of cutting off its resources and crippling its ability to operate. The Court answered the same day that the measure was an assault on the rule of law and called on its 125 States Parties to defend it. Between those two statements lies a six-month grace period, a set of carve-outs, and a direct collision with the legal duties of France, a founding State Party to the Rome Statute, which must keep arresting and surrendering suspects to The Hague while refusing to give any effect at home to the American measures. This article explains what Washington actually decided, how the countdown works, and what French courts, banks, insurers, software vendors and counsel must do while it runs.

The timing was unmistakable. The Nobel Committee said it was honouring Pillay, who sat on the ICC Appeals Chamber from 2003 to 2008 and now sits on the International Court of Justice, at a moment when judges and institutions of international law are under political attack. Within hours, the United States answered with the most far-reaching step ever taken against an international court: not sanctions on individual prosecutors or judges, as in previous rounds, but sanctions on the institution created by treaty in 1998. The Treasury structured the package with an initial six-month grace period and exemptions for telecoms, software, pensions and detainee-related transactions, while Rubio warned the measures would be adjusted if American demands were not met. The European Union’s foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas replied that the six-month window offers a moment for dialogue but that the bloc has options to keep the Court working, and Belgium’s foreign minister publicly called for the EU blocking statute to be activated to protect it.

For readers in France, the stakes are concrete rather than abstract. France must continue to execute ICC arrest warrants on its territory through the specialised procedure of the Code of criminal procedure, and French companies that cut ties with the Court to please Washington expose themselves to European and French blocking rules that prohibit exactly that kind of compliance. A French lawyer’s view of this file is therefore practical: how a surrender to The Hague runs step by step before the Paris courts, where the American sanctions stop at the French border, and what to do during the six months before the grace period expires.

I. Washington Puts the Court Itself on the Sanctions List: What Changed on 9 October 2026

A. From Thirteen Judges and Prosecutors to the Institution: How Far the New Designations Go

American hostility to the Court is not new, but its target changed on 9 October 2026. During his first term, President Trump had already imposed targeted sanctions on Court officials, measures later rescinded under President Biden; days after returning to office in January 2025, the new administration issued an executive order creating a standing framework for ICC-related sanctions, published in the Federal Register as Imposing Sanctions on the International Criminal Court. Successive rounds followed, including designations in August 2026 that reached the Court’s presidency, and, in the Court’s own words, a series of designations against thirteen independent judges and prosecutors serving the cause of justice. Each of those steps raised the cost of working for the tribunal. None of them touched the institution as such.

The 9 October package crosses that line. According to Reuters, which first published Rubio’s statement, the United States is now sanctioning the International Criminal Court as an organisation, potentially punishing companies that provide services to the Court itself. In the American sanctions technique, that means US persons are barred from transactions with the designated entity, and non-American companies that continue to deal with it face the threat of secondary measures: banks close accounts, insurers terminate coverage, software editors suspend licences. Court officials had been preparing for this scenario for months, shifting office computers from Microsoft software to open-source equivalents and making new arrangements for banking and health insurance. The scenario is no longer theoretical, and its first commercial victim in France has already been described on this site: a French insurer pushed out of its ICC coverage by the American measures, a case analysed in our account of how US sanctions forced a French insurer out of the ICC and what the blocking statute changes.

The political justification given by Washington has two limbs. The administration denounces the arrest warrants issued for Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and the investigation into the actions of American soldiers in Afghanistan, even though the Court says that file is deprioritised. Rubio added that the sanctions respond to calls by outside experts for the ICC to prosecute American service members, border agents and elected leaders, steps the Court has not taken. The Court’s deputy prosecutor, Nazhat Shameem Khan, herself under American sanctions, told Reuters the measures are intended to undermine the international rule of law and the work of an independent judicial institution, adding that the work will continue across all situations, investigations and prosecutions. France is directly concerned by that docket: the warrants now exceed seventy, covering figures from the Sudan, Libya, Russia and Palestine files, and the question of what happens when a wanted person crosses French airspace or territory was litigated in Paris only weeks ago, as explained in our analysis of the Netanyahu overflight episode and the ICC warrant in Paris.

The Nobel timing gives the designations a resonance Washington cannot control. The official Nobel press release states that the Committee decided to award the Nobel Peace Prize for 2026 to Navanethem Pillay for her efforts to promote peace and international law, recalls that she served as a judge on the High Court in South Africa, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and the International Criminal Court, as United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and as chair of the UN inquiry on the occupied Palestinian territory, and notes that today Navi Pillay is a judge on the International Court of Justice in the case where Myanmar stands accused of genocide. The Committee then makes the link explicit: at a time when the system of international law is under tremendous pressure, and while these same judges are sanctioned and their institutions attacked, courage and determination of the kind Pillay shows on the bench are needed. Sanctioning the judges’ own institution on the very day that citation was published turns a legal measures file into a test of credibility for every State Party, France included.

B. How the Six-Month Grace Period and Its Carve-Outs Work Before Any Hard Cut-Off

The Treasury did not pull the plug immediately. The designations were announced with an initial six-month grace period, accompanied by exemptions that keep flowing some transactions for telecoms, software, the payment of pensions and transactions related to detainees. In sanctions practice, a wind-down period of this kind serves two purposes: it lets service providers disengage without instant breach, and it gives the target and its member states time to negotiate before the restrictions bite in full. Rubio said so openly, explaining that the sanctions were structured to give the Court and its member states an opportunity to address American concerns, and that they would be adjusted if those demands were not met. The grace period is therefore a countdown with a negotiating window inside it, not a suspension of the policy.

Each carve-out tells its own story about what a total cut-off would break. Telecoms and software keep the Court’s communications and case systems alive during the talks; pensions protect former staff and judges whose retirement benefits transit through the international banking system; detainee-related transactions cover the detention centre in The Hague, where the Court holds accused persons whose rights to food, medical care and counsel cannot be interrupted by a sanctions programme without violating the very standards the Court applies. Anyone advising a vendor in these sectors should read the general licences narrowly: an exemption for telecoms does not cover adjacent IT services, and an exemption for pensions does not cover active payroll. The commercial habit of over-complying, dropping the client at the first mention of sanctions, is precisely what the European blocking rules discussed below are designed to punish.

Europe’s first reactions sketch the negotiation battlefield. Kallas said the six-month period offers a window for dialogue while insisting the bloc has options to ensure the Court can continue its vital work, language that covers everything from political shielding to financial workarounds and retaliatory instruments. Belgium, the Court’s host-state neighbour and a State Party with judges and staff on its soil, went further by calling for activation of the EU blocking statute to protect the tribunal. The Court itself, through its president Tomoko Akane, stated that it will continue to fully discharge its mandate, with independence and impartiality, acting only on the basis of the law and the evidence, for the sake of the countless victims of grave crimes, while warning that it cannot stand alone and that its fate now rests also in the hands of the States that created it. That warning is addressed first to capitals like Paris, which must decide within months whether their banks, insurers and software editors keep serving the Court, and whether their police and courts keep delivering suspects to it.

The calendar matters as much as the substance. Six months from 9 October 2026 runs to early April 2027, with the adjustment threat hanging over every step: escalation if Washington judges its demands unmet, possible easing if the Court narrows investigations Washington contests. For counsel, the period divides into three tasks: audit every contract linking a French client to the Court or to listed Court officials, secure the applicable exemptions in writing before acting, and prepare the blocking-statute posture so that no provider can invoke American law as an excuse to walk away. The next part shows why, during those same six months, France’s duty to cooperate with the Court does not pause for a single day.

II. What France Must Still Do: Cooperate With the Court and Refuse the Sanctions Effect at Home

A. Arrest and Surrender Anyway: How an ICC Warrant Runs Through the Paris Courts

France is not a bystander to the Rome Statute system; it is one of its builders, and its domestic procedure makes cooperation with the Court a judicial routine rather than a diplomatic favour. Requests for assistance from the Court are addressed to the competent authorities under article 87 of the Statute, in original or certified copy with supporting documents, and article 627-1 of the Code of criminal procedure provides that these documents are transmitted to the national antiterrorism prosecutor, who gives them all useful follow-up, with a direct emergency channel to that magistrate by any means. Once seized, the requests are executed, depending on the case, by the national antiterrorism prosecutor or by the Paris investigating judge, acting across the whole national territory, in the presence where applicable of the ICC prosecutor or representative, as article 627-2 of the Code of criminal procedure states. In other words, an ICC file lands in Paris, not in a ministry, and it moves through judges from the first hour.

The arrest phase is fenced with short, hard deadlines that American sanctions cannot extend. Article 627-5 of the Code of criminal procedure requires that any person apprehended under an arrest request for surrender be brought within twenty-four hours before the territorially competent public prosecutor, who verifies identity, informs the person in a language they understand of the surrender request and of the coming appearance before the prosecutor general at the Paris Court of Appeal within five days, and guarantees immediate access to chosen or appointed counsel. If the person is not left at liberty, a liberty and custody judge orders detention, or alternatively judicial supervision or electronically monitored house arrest where appearance at every step seems sufficiently guaranteed under article 59 of the Rome Statute. Article 627-6 of the Code of criminal procedure then orders transfer to the Paris Court of Appeal’s remand prison within five days of presentation to the prosecutor, failing which the person is immediately released by order of the president of the investigating chamber, unless transfer was delayed by insurmountable circumstances. The prosecutor general notifies the surrender request and the charges in a language the person understands, counsel may consult the file at once, and the person’s statements are received after warning that they are free to say nothing.

The decision itself belongs to the investigating chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal, and its effects are notified directly to the Court: article 627-10 of the Code of criminal procedure provides that the chamber’s ruling, and where applicable the place and date of surrender and the duration of detention served towards it, are brought to the knowledge of the International Criminal Court by any means. The surrender must then occur within one month from the day the decision becomes final, failing which the person is immediately released, again save insurmountable circumstances. Liberty can be sought at any time: article 627-9 of the Code of criminal procedure allows applications for release or variation of judicial supervision or monitored residence to the Paris investigating chamber, ruling in accordance with article 59 of the Statute and the procedure of articles 148-1 and following. And the money follows the judgment: article 627-17 of the Code of criminal procedure channels fines and confiscated property or sale proceeds to the Court or to the victims’ fund as the Court decides, a bridge to the reparations litigation followed on this site in our coverage of the Yekatom and Ngaissona reparations hearing and French enforcement.

Two recent rulings of the Cour de cassation frame how Paris judges handle the hard cases this docket produces. First, surrender decisions can be conditional: on 23 November 2022, the criminal chamber upheld a chamber that ordered surrender to the British authorities while subordinating it to an undertaking to apply the specialty protection of the post-Brexit cooperation agreement, a technique French courts use whenever surrender must not become a blank cheque (Cass. crim., 23 November 2022, no. 22-86.162). The method travels directly to ICC surrenders, where conditions on detention, specialty and return routinely accompany the transfer order. Second, and more dramatically, the full court settled the immunity question for sitting leaders on 25 July 2025: the Assemblée plénière held that personal immunity is opposable before national courts, covers only the sitting head of State, head of government and foreign minister, for all acts private or official, and, as a manifest procedural bar, must be examined by the judge of their own motion. In the Court’s own words: “Elle s’applique devant les juridictions nationales. Le principe de l’immunité ne peut être opposé devant les juridictions internationales, dont les statuts écartent expressément toute immunité, et qui agissent au nom de la communauté internationale.” And: “L’immunité personnelle, distincte de l’immunité fonctionnelle, est reconnue aux seuls chef d’État, chef du gouvernement et ministre des affaires étrangères, en exercice. Elle concerne tous les actes accomplis, tant à titre privé qu’à titre officiel.” And: “Constituant ainsi un obstacle procédural manifeste à l’exercice de sa compétence par une juridiction nationale, l’immunité personnelle doit être examinée d’office par le juge.” The ruling annulled the 2023 Paris arrest warrant against the then Syrian president (Ass. plén., 25 July 2025, no. 24-84.393), while preserving future warrants after loss of office. The contrast is exactly the point: what a French judge cannot do against a sitting head of State, the ICC, whose statute expressly discards immunity, can do, and France must then cooperate in the arrest.

The substantive definitions behind those warrants are written into French law. Article 212-1 of the Criminal Code defines crimes against humanity as one of the listed acts, from wilful killing to extermination, enslavement, deportation, imprisonment and other grave deprivations of liberty, committed in execution of a concerted plan against a civilian population group within a generalised or systematic attack, punishable by life imprisonment. French prosecutors and investigating judges therefore work with the same categories as The Hague, and the pôle crimes contre l’humanité at the Paris tribunal applies them daily. None of this machinery contains an American-sanctions exception: no article of the cooperation title suspends surrender because Washington listed the requesting institution, and any attempt to read such an exception into the procedure would collide with both the Statute and the Code.

B. Give No Effect to the American Measures at Home: The EU Blocking Statute and the French Blocking Law

On the commercial side, European law reverses the polarity: where Washington orders disengagement, Brussels orders continued performance. Council Regulation 2271/96, the EU blocking statute, whose consolidated text is published on EUR-Lex, prohibits EU operators from complying with the listed third-country sanctions instruments, nullifies foreign judgments giving them effect, and lets EU victims recover damages caused by their application. Its annexes can be extended to new American instruments, which is precisely what Belgium’s foreign minister demanded for the ICC package. A French bank that closes the Court’s accounts, an insurer that terminates its policies, or a software editor that suspends its licences at Washington’s request is therefore not being prudent; it is potentially breaching EU law on EU territory, and the six-month American grace period does not authorise a single anticipatory termination under European law.

France adds its own older shield, the law of 26 July 1968 on the communication of economic, commercial, industrial, financial or technical documents and information to foreign persons, whose official text is published on Légifrance. The statute forbids transmitting to foreign authorities documents or information whose disclosure would harm France’s sovereignty, security or essential economic interests or violate French law, outside international treaties and specific procedures, and it backs the prohibition with criminal penalties, reinforced by the 2022 implementing reforms. In an ICC-sanctions scenario, its message to general counsel is blunt: do not hand over client files, transaction records or compliance analyses to satisfy an American sanctions investigation without going through the lawful channels, and do not implement a foreign boycott of the Court as if it were French law. Combined with the EU regulation, the 1968 law turns the American demand to stop serving the Court into a French offence to obey.

Practice during the grace period should follow from that hierarchy. First, map every exposure: accounts, policies, licences, hosting, payroll and pension flows touching the Court, its organs or the previously listed judges and prosecutors, distinguishing what falls under an American general licence from what does not. Second, freeze any termination plan that cites only the American designations, and replace it with a blocking-statute memorandum explaining to the counterparty why performance continues under EU and French law. Third, where a licence or authorisation is genuinely needed, apply for it on both sides of the Atlantic rather than self-sanctioning, and keep the paper trail: regulators on each side punish undocumented improvisation more harshly than good-faith applications. Fourth, for litigation risk, remember that American judgments or arbitral pressure giving effect to the ICC sanctions are unenforceable in France to the extent the blocking instruments cover them, while French courts remain fully competent to order a bank or insurer to perform. The firms that suffered most from earlier American extraterritorial campaigns were rarely those that complied early; they were those that complied messily, without a consistent position across jurisdictions.

None of this requires minimising the pressure Washington can apply. Secondary sanctions have real teeth against groups with American assets, dollar clearing or US licences, and some providers will lawfully restructure their ICC exposure through non-American subsidiaries or seek specific licences rather than fight head-on. What the blocking framework forbids is the quiet route: invoking the American measures as a contractual excuse, hiding behind force majeure clauses drafted for other embargoes, or pre-empting the April 2027 deadline by cutting services during the negotiation window. Kallas’s promise of options and Belgium’s call for activation signal that Brussels will watch provider behaviour during the grace period, and the Commission has already shown in earlier files that it can update the annex faster than providers can terminate. Counsel should therefore treat every disengagement letter received since 9 October as a document to answer, not as a fate to accept.

Conclusion

The images of 9 October 2026 will stay paired: a Nobel medal for a judge who spent her life enlarging international law, and a sanctions designation against the very institution where she once sat on appeal. The Court’s answer, that no one stands above the law and that history will judge this moment, is not rhetoric for anniversaries; it is the operating instruction for the months ahead. France’s part in that instruction is written down and immediately enforceable: keep executing ICC requests through the antiterrorism prosecutor, the Paris investigating judge and the investigating chamber within their twenty-four-hour, five-day and one-month deadlines; keep surrendering, conditionally where needed, as the Cour de cassation allows; keep fines and confiscations flowing to the Court and its victims’ fund; and give no domestic effect to the American ban, under the EU blocking statute and the 1968 French blocking law. The six-month grace period is a negotiation window, not a permission to drift. When it closes in the spring of 2027, the question will not be whether Washington meant its sanctions, but whether Paris meant its signature.

📄 Official circular