KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My American Parent Died Owning a House in France: French 12-Month Succession Return, House Valuation, and the 1978 Treaty Credit That Prevents Double Tax

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My American Parent Died Owning a House in France: French 12-Month Succession Return, House Valuation, and the 1978 Treaty Credit That Prevents Double Tax

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your mother lived in Ohio all her life, never held a French passport, and never paid French income tax. But she kept the stone house in the Dordogne she bought in the 1990s, spent every summer there, and still owned it on the day she died in Columbus. Now a French notaire (a public legal officer who alone can transfer French real estate after death) writes to you that a French succession return is due, that the house must be valued at its market price on the date of death, and that French transfer tax may be owed even though your parent never lived in France. At the same time, your American CPA asks whether the same house must be reported on a United States estate tax return. Both are right to ask, and the answer is organized by two layers of rules: French domestic law, which taxes the French house because it sits in France, and the France-United States convention of November 24, 1978 against double taxation on estates and gifts, which decides which country taxes what and grants a credit so the same value is not fully taxed twice.

This guide explains, for American children and spouses of a United States-domiciled parent who owned a house in France, what France demands and when, how France values the house and computes each heir’s tax, what the United States taxes on the same death, and how the 1978 treaty credit works in practice. Every French term is explained at first use. All controlling French provisions are cited to their official texts, and the two court decisions discussed below are quoted exactly as the Cour de cassation (France’s highest civil court) wrote them.

I. What France Demands When an American Dies Owning a French House

A. When and Where Do American Heirs File the French Succession Return?

French law starts from a simple territorial rule. Droits de mutation à titre gratuit means the French transfer tax on gifts and inheritances, and the déclaration de succession is the detailed estate return the heirs must file. Article 750 ter of the French General Tax Code provides that “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit” certain categories of property, and its second paragraph covers precisely your situation: French real estate, whether held directly or indirectly, is subject to the French tax even “lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France” (when the donor or the deceased was not fiscally domiciled in France). In plain terms, the location of the house alone brings it into the French succession tax net. The domicile of your parent in Ohio, Florida, or California does not remove the Dordogne, Provence, or Paris house from French taxation.

The same article extends the rule to indirect holdings. It states that any building is deemed held indirectly when it belongs to companies or entities in which the deceased, alone or with close family, held more than half the shares or rights, and that the value of indirectly held buildings follows the proportion of those assets in the entity. American families who placed the French house in a French société civile immobilière (SCI, a non-trading property company) or who hold it through a United States LLC should therefore assume the French administration looks through the structure to the bricks underneath. The treaty confirms this approach for property-rich entities, as explained in Part II.

Once the tax net is established, the clock starts. Article 641 of the General Tax Code sets the filing deadlines for the returns “que les héritiers, donataires ou légataires ont à souscrire des biens à eux échus ou transmis par décès” (that heirs, donees, and legatees must file for property received by death): six months from the date of death when the deceased died in metropolitan France, and “D’une année, dans tous les autres cas” (one year, in all other cases). An American parent who died in the United States falls squarely in the second branch. The official public guidance says the same thing in plain language: for a death abroad, the return must be filed within 12 months from the date of death (see service-public.fr, Droits de succession – Declaration). Count twelve calendar months from the death certificate date, not from the day you learned about the French requirement or from the day the Ohio probate opened.

In practice the return is usually prepared and filed by the French notaire handling the succession, because only the notaire can publish the attestation immobilière (the land-registry deed that transfers registered title to the heirs) and because the return requires a detailed valuation, a family tree, prior-gift disclosures, and supporting civil-status documents with apostilles and certified translations. For nonresident heirs and nonresident decedents, the return and payment go to the specialized nonresident tax office, and the notaire corresponds with that office on your behalf under a French power of attorney. If you act without a notaire, you still owe the same return on the same deadline.

Do not count on an exemption from filing. Article 800 of the General Tax Code provides that “En sont dispensés : 1° Les ayants cause en ligne directe” (are exempt: direct-line successors) only “lorsque l’actif brut successoral est inférieur […] à la condition que ces personnes n’aient pas bénéficié antérieurement, de la part du défunt, d’une donation ou d’un don manuel non enregistré ou non déclaré” (when the gross estate is below 50,000 euros and on condition that they previously received no unregistered gift from the deceased). A French house is almost always worth more than 50,000 euros gross, so the dispensation does not apply to a house case. File the full detailed return even if, after allowances and rates, some child ends up owing little or no tax.

A related timing rule surprises many American families: French heirs are saisis (vested by operation of law) immediately at death. Article 724 of the Civil Code states that “Les héritiers désignés par la loi sont saisis de plein droit des biens, droits et actions du défunt” (heirs designated by law are vested by operation of law in the property, rights, and claims of the deceased). You own the French house with your siblings in indivision (co-ownership without division) from the date of death, even before any deed is signed. But you cannot sell, mortgage, or keep the buyer’s funds securely until the notaire establishes who the heirs are (the acte de notoriété, or heirship deed), files the succession return, pays or secures the tax, and publishes the transfer at the land registry. The vesting rule explains why French banks freeze accounts and why the land registry rejects a sale signed only by one sibling: ownership passed to all heirs at once, and the paper trail must catch up.

Missing the twelve-month deadline costs money. Late filing draws late interest and penalties under French tax collection rules, and the administration can issue an assessment based on its own valuation if no return arrives. If you discover the house late, after the anniversary has passed, file as soon as possible, pay the principal, and address interest and penalties separately rather than waiting for a complete file. Keep proof of every payment abroad and in France, because the United States credit described in Part II requires proof that the French tax was definitively assessed and paid.

B. How Does France Value the House and Compute the Tax Each Child Pays?

France taxes each heir on what that heir personally receives, not on the estate as a whole. Three steps decide the bill for an American child: value the house, subtract only the allowances the statute grants, then apply the progressive table to each net share.

First, the value. Article 761 of the General Tax Code requires that “les immeubles, quelle que soit leur nature, sont estimés d’après leur valeur vénale réelle à la date de la transmission, d’après la déclaration détaillée et estimative des parties, sans distraction des charges” (buildings, whatever their nature, are appraised at their real market value on the date of transfer, according to the detailed estimated declaration of the parties, without deduction of encumbrances). Valeur vénale reelle means the price a willing buyer would actually pay on the open market on the date of death, not the purchase price decades ago, not the assessed value for local property tax, and not a sentimental family estimate. Sans distraction des charges means you do not subtract the remaining mortgage or other debts from the house value at this stage; debts of the estate are handled through a separate liabilities mechanism and, where ownership is split between usufruit (a lifetime right to use the property and take its income) and nue-propriété (bare ownership without current use), through apportionment rules discussed below. Support the declared value with recent comparable sales, a written opinion from a local agent, and, for distinctive or high-value houses, an independent appraisal dated near the death. The tax office routinely checks Paris, Riviera, and Dordogne values against its own comparable-sales database, and an unsupported low figure invites reassessment.

Second, the allowances. Article 779 of the General Tax Code provides that “il est effectué un abattement […] sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation” (an allowance of 100,000 euros is applied to the share of each ascendant and to the share of each living child or child represented because of predecease or renunciation). Abattement means a fixed sum subtracted from the taxable share before rates apply. Each American child therefore subtracts 100,000 euros from what that child receives from the parent. A surviving spouse married to the deceased pays no French succession tax on what the spouse receives, under the spouse exemption, but children have no equivalent full exemption: they have the 100,000-euro allowance each and then pay the progressive rates below. Brothers, sisters, nephews, and unrelated beneficiaries face different allowances and much higher rates, which is why the exact family link stated in the return matters.

Third, the rates. Article 777 of the General Tax Code states that “Les droits de mutation à titre gratuit sont fixés aux taux indiqués dans les tableaux ci-après, pour la part nette revenant à chaque ayant droit” (transfer duties are set at the rates shown in the tables below, on the net share reverting to each beneficiary). In the direct line between parents and children, the table runs from 5 percent on the slice up to 8,072 euros, 10 percent from 8,072 to 12,109 euros, 15 percent from 12,109 to 15,932 euros, 20 percent from 15,932 to 552,324 euros, 30 percent from 552,324 to 902,838 euros, 40 percent from 902,838 to 1,805,677 euros, and 45 percent above 1,805,677 euros. Take a concrete illustration the notaire will recognize: a Dordogne house valued at 420,000 euros at death, left equally to two American children, with no prior gifts and no deductible liabilities affecting the base. Each child receives 210,000 euros, subtracts the 100,000-euro allowance, and applies the table to 110,000 euros. The arithmetic per child is roughly 8,072 euros at 5 percent, plus the 8,072-to-12,109 slice at 10 percent, plus the 12,109-to-15,932 slice at 15 percent, plus the remainder up to 110,000 euros at 20 percent, for a bill near 20,000 euros per child. Double it for the two shares, and the family sees why an accurate valuation and a correct allowance claim decide tens of thousands of euros. Prior gifts change the math because of the recall rule below.

Prior gifts must be disclosed and can push the current share into higher brackets. Article 784 of the General Tax Code provides that “Les parties sont tenues de faire connaître, dans tout acte constatant une transmission entre vifs à titre gratuit et dans toute déclaration de succession, s’il existe ou non des donations antérieures consenties à un titre et sous une forme quelconque par le donateur ou le défunt aux donataires, héritiers ou légataires” (the parties must state, in any deed recording a gratuitous lifetime transfer and in any succession return, whether prior gifts in any form were made by the donor or the deceased to the donees, heirs, or legatees). This is the rappel fiscal des donations, the fiscal recall of prior gifts: gifts made within the statutory recall period are added back to the current share to determine the applicable bracket, with credit for tax already paid on the earlier gift. An American parent who wired 80,000 euros to a child a few years before death to renovate the French house, or who gave a share of the house by a French gift deed, must have that history stated in the succession return with dates, amounts, and the officiating notaire. Omitting it exposes the heir to reassessment, while disclosing it correctly often only moves part of the share into the next bracket rather than creating a second full tax.

Two judicial warnings matter before you sign anything. The first concerns split ownership. Many American wills give the surviving spouse a lifetime interest and the children the remainder, which French practice reads as usufruit for the spouse and nue-propriété for the children. The Cour de cassation held on April 2, 2025, appeal No. 23-22.537, under visas including Article 777 of the General Tax Code, that “les droits de mutation à titre gratuit sont fixés, pour la part nette revenant à chaque ayant droit, aux taux indiqués dans le tableau figurant à cet article” (transfer duties are fixed, for the net share reverting to each beneficiary, at the rates shown in the table in that article), and that “pour la liquidation des droits d’enregistrement et de la taxe de publicité foncière, la valeur de la nue-propriété et de l’usufruit est déterminée par une quotité de la valeur de la propriété entière, conformément au barème qu’il fixe” (for assessment of registration duties, the value of bare ownership and of the usufruct is determined as a fraction of full ownership under the statutory scale). Where the estate carries debts and the rights are split, the Court requires the debt to be allocated between the usufructuary and the bare owner according to that statutory scale to fix each person’s net share, rather than loading all liabilities onto one side. Practically, do not let a return value the spouse’s lifetime right at zero or at an invented percentage: the tax office applies the age-based statutory fractions, and the Cour de cassation enforces that method.

The second warning concerns trusts and trustee paperwork. An American revocable living trust does not transfer French real estate by itself, and French tax law does not treat trust interests as a French démembrement (split between usufruct and bare ownership). In Commercial Chamber, November 18, 2020, appeal No. 18-14.242, the Court described the file as follows: “W… I…, résidente américaine, a, par acte du 10 décembre 1964, constitué un trust révocable […] aux fins de gestion” (W… I…, an American resident, by an instrument of December 10, 1964, created a revocable trust in which she placed financial assets entrusted to a trustee for management). The Versailles court of appeal had treated the daughter as a mere usufructuary and the grandson as bare owner, so that reuniting the two at death owed no tax. The Cour de cassation rejected that analysis and held: “CASSE ET ANNULE, en toutes ses dispositions, l’arrêt rendu le 12 janvier 2018, entre les parties, par la cour d’appel de Versailles” (quashes and annuls, in all its provisions, the judgment of January 12, 2018 of the Versailles court of appeal). The lesson for a French house is direct: present the trust deed, the funding history, and the death certificates to the notaire, expect France to tax the real economic transfer at death under Article 750 ter, and do not assume that calling an interest an usufruct under American vocabulary makes it one under French tax law.

Finally, an American will cannot simply erase the children’s protected shares in French real estate. Réserve héréditaire is the forced share the statute secures to certain heirs, and quotité disponible is the disposable remainder. Article 912 of the Civil Code defines them exactly: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent” (the forced share is the portion of the estate that statute secures, clear of charges, to certain heirs called forced heirs, if they are called to the succession and accept it). Article 913 of the Civil Code sets the fractions: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre” (gifts and wills may not exceed half the property if one child survives, one-third if two children survive, one-quarter if three or more survive). A will signed in Texas or New York that leaves the entire French house to the surviving spouse, or to one child only, can be challenged by the omitted American child through the action en reduction (the clawback suit that restores the forced share), and European succession rules on the applicable law add a further layer the notaire examines file by file. Raise the will, its codicils, and any spousal election with the notaire at the opening of the file, not after the return is filed.

II. How America Taxes the Same Death and How the 1978 Treaty Prevents Paying Twice

A. What Does the IRS Tax When a US Person Dies Owning French Real Estate?

The United States taxes its citizens and domiciliaries on worldwide assets at death, including a house in France. The federal estate tax return, filed on behalf of the decedent’s estate, reports the fair market value of all property owned at death, wherever situated, and the French house enters that base at its dollar value on the date of death. Because the exemption threshold is high, many middle-class families owe no federal estate tax after the exemption and deductions, but the reporting question still matters: the estate representative must inventory the French house, convert the euro value with a defensible exchange rate, attach the French heirship and valuation papers, and keep the file consistent with what the French notaire declared. Inconsistency between the dollar value reported to the Internal Revenue Service and the euro valeur vénale declared in France is one of the first things an examiner questions.

The treaty defines whose death it covers and where each person was domiciled. Its first article states that it applies to estates of persons domiciled in France and to estates of persons subject to United States tax because of domicile there or American citizenship at death (see the consolidated Franco-American convention of November 24, 1978, as amended, also published by the Internal Revenue Service treaty collection). An American citizen who died domiciled in Ohio therefore falls within the treaty even though the house sits in France. Where both countries claim domicile, domicile fiscal (fiscal domicile) follows a cascade: the treaty looks first to a permanent home, then to the center of vital interests, then to habitual presence, then to citizenship, and finally to mutual agreement between the authorities. Keep the evidence that proves daily life: voter registration, driver’s license, Medicare and Social Security records, the location of the primary physician and bank accounts, flight records showing how many nights were spent in each country, and where the decedent filed income tax as a resident. A parent who spent six months a year in the Dordogne but kept an Ohio home, Ohio doctors, and Ohio tax residence will usually still be treated as United States-domiciled under the cascade, but the file must prove it.

The situs rule for the house itself is unconditional. Article 5 of the 1978 convention, titled in French “Biens immobiliers” (real property), provides that real property is taxable by the Contracting State where it is situated. The same article adds that the term has the meaning given by the law of the country where the property sits, that it always includes accessories, the usufruct of real property, and rights to mineral payments, and that it also covers shares and interests in a company or entity whose assets consist at least one-half of real estate, which are then deemed situated where the buildings sit. Read plainly: France may tax the Dordogne house because it sits in France; the United States may also tax the worldwide estate of its citizen or domiciliary, including that house; and shares in a property company whose assets are mostly French real estate are treated as French real estate for treaty purposes. No private letter, trustee certificate, or LLC operating agreement overrides that situs rule.

Two related United States questions deserve early attention. First, lifetime transfers of the French house, such as adding a child to the deed or funding an irrevocable trust with French property, can trigger United States gift tax reporting and French gift duties under the same convention, with its own valuation and credit mechanics. Second, French bank accounts, life-insurance envelopes, and retirement rights attached to the same succession follow different treaty articles than the house and may carry separate French levies and United States information returns. Treat the house file, the bank file, and any trust file as three parallel tracks from the first meeting, so the French return, the American return, and the treaty credit claim tell one consistent story.

B. How Does the Treaty Credit Work and When Must You Claim It?

The treaty does not exempt the French house in either country. It lets each country apply its own law and then grants a credit for the other country’s tax on the same property, within limits. The French text calls this mechanism exonérations et crédits (exemptions and credits). For American families the direction that matters most is the United States credit for French tax: both countries tax the house, France because it sits there under Article 5, the United States because the decedent was its citizen or domiciliary, and then the United States credits the French tax paid on that house against the United States tax attributable to it.

The operative rule for that direction is that when each Contracting State levies tax on property taxable by France under Article 5 and related articles, the United States grants a credit equal to the French tax levied on that property. The mirror rule covers the reverse case where the decedent was domiciled in France: France taxes the whole estate and then grants, against that tax, a deduction equal to the tax paid in the United States on property taxable in the United States under the convention, capped at the French tax attributable to that property (“la quote-part de l’impôt français”). In both directions the credit never exceeds the home country’s tax on the same property. If France collected 20,000 euros on a child’s share and the United States tax attributable to that share is lower, the credit wipes out the United States tax on that share but generates no refund of the difference. If the United States tax is higher, the credit reduces it and the balance remains payable in the United States.

Sequence therefore decides success. Pay and document the French tax first, then claim the United States credit with definitive proof. The practical order that works is: obtain an IRS employer identification number for the estate, complete the French valuation and family-tree file, file the French succession return within the twelve-month window and pay the French duties, secure the French tax assessment notice and stamped payment receipts showing the amount allocable to the house, then prepare the United States estate tax return or related claim reflecting the gross French value, the French tax paid, and the treaty credit computation. Attach certified English translations of the French assessment, the heirship deed, the land-registry transfer, and the bank wires. A credit claimed without proof of definitive assessment and payment will be held up, and exchange-rate sourcing should be stated on the face of the computation.

Deadlines for the credit claim are longer than the French filing deadline but they are strict. Article 13 of the convention, on time limits for credit and refund claims, requires that any treaty-based credit or refund claim be made before the longest of the following periods expires: the domestic refund period of the country where the claim is made, five years from the date of death, or one year after the final determination and payment of the tax for which credit is sought, provided that determination and payment occur within ten years after death. No interest is paid on treaty-based refunds. Concretely, an American child whose mother died in 2025 should have the French return filed by the 2026 anniversary, the French assessment and payment documented promptly, and the United States credit position prepared well before the five-year treaty window closes, while also watching the shorter domestic limitations period that may apply to the specific United States return. A mutual-agreement procedure between the two tax administrations exists for cases where each country characterizes the property or the domicile differently, but that request runs on the same Article 13 clock, so it must be raised early rather than after years of correspondence.

Three recurring mistakes destroy otherwise valid credits. The first is inconsistent values: declaring 380,000 euros in France and 520,000 dollars in the United States for the same house on the same date without explaining renovations, exchange rates, or appraisal dates. The second is missing paper: claiming a United States credit with only a notaire’s estimate and no French assessment notice or payment receipt. The third is misreading the cap: assuming every euro paid in France automatically reduces United States tax euro for euro, when the treaty limits the credit to the home-country tax attributable to the same property. A short reconciliation schedule prevents all three: one line per heir, euro value declared in France, dollar value reported in the United States with the exchange rate and date, French tax assessed and paid with receipt references, United States tax attributable to the house, and credit claimed within the cap. For background on assessment practice, the tax administration’s published doctrine on successions and territoriality (BOI-ENR-DMTG) and the BOI-ENR-DMTG-10-10-30 guidance on succession taxation explain how the offices apply these code articles in daily files.

American families sometimes ask whether owning through a company or a trust avoids this two-country process. It does not. The treaty expressly treats shares in an entity whose assets are at least half French real estate as French real estate, and the Cour de cassation decision on trusts quoted in Part I shows that relabeling an economic transfer does not remove it from French transfer tax. Disclose the SCI, the LLC, or the trust, file on the underlying house value, pay the French tax on time, and then use the treaty credit on the American side. That order preserves cash, paper, and credibility in both countries. Families with a surviving spouse holding lifetime rights should add the age-based apportionment computation from the April 2025 decision to the file, so the French assessment already reflects the correct split before the American credit is calculated. Where domicile itself is disputed, assemble the Article 4 cascade evidence before either return is filed, because the credit direction and the scope of each country’s base depend on that threshold answer.

Conclusion

When an American parent dies owning a house in France, France taxes the house because it sits in France, on a twelve-month return clock, at market value on the date of death, with a 100,000-euro allowance per child and progressive rates on each net share. The United States taxes the same death on worldwide assets when the decedent was its citizen or domiciliary. The 1978 convention resolves the overlap by situs, taxing the house in France under its real-property article and granting a credit in the other country capped at that country’s tax on the same property, claimed within the treaty’s five-year and related windows with proof of assessment and payment. File the French return on time with a supported valuation and full gift history, respect forced-share limits on the American will, document any usufruct split and any trust or company with the methods the Cour de cassation requires, then carry the French assessment into the American return through the treaty credit. Related French-house questions, from choosing the governing law in a will to checking the notaire’s succession bill, are addressed in companion guides on this site, including how Americans choose United States law in a will for French property.

📄 Official circular