I Live in France as an American: How to Choose United States Law in Your Will Under EU Regulation 650/2012, What It Changes for Your French House, and How to Challenge a Notaire Who Ignores It
You are an American citizen living in France. You own a house outside Paris, a bank account in Lyon, and a brokerage account back in Ohio. Your California will leaves everything to your surviving spouse. One day your children walk into a French notaire’s office and learn that the will does not do what you thought it did. The notaire applies French law, sets aside a fixed share of your estate for each child, and tells your spouse that the California document cannot disinherit them. This outcome surprises many Americans, but it is the normal starting point of French succession law. The good news is that European law gives you a tool to change it, if you use it correctly while you are alive.
The notaire is the French legal officer who settles estates, draws up deeds, and issues the certificate of heirs. The reserve hereditaire, translated here as the forced share, is the portion of your estate that French law reserves for your children. The quotite disponible, translated here as the freely disposable portion, is the remainder that you may leave to anyone you wish. Habitual residence means the country where you actually live your daily life at the time of death, not the passport you hold. A professio juris clause, meaning a choice-of-law clause, is a sentence in your will that selects which country’s law governs your whole succession. This article explains how that clause works for an American resident in France, what it can and cannot achieve for your French house, and what to do when a notaire refuses to apply it.
I. Without a Choice-of-Law Clause, French Law Decides Who Gets Your French House
A. Habitual Residence in France Triggers French Succession Law and the Forced Share for Your Children
Since August 17, 2015, one European text governs which law applies to cross-border successions in France and in most European Union member states. That text is Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of July 4, 2012. Denmark and Ireland do not apply it, but France does, and the United States is treated as a third state whose nationals can still benefit from its choice-of-law rule. The general rule sits in Article 21: “Sauf disposition contraire du présent règlement, la loi applicable à l’ensemble d’une succession est celle de l’État dans lequel le défunt avait sa résidence habituelle au moment de son décès.” In English, the law of the country of habitual residence at death governs the whole succession. The official text is available on EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 21. An American who retires to the Dordogne, rents an apartment in Paris for years, enrolls children in a French school, and sees a French doctor has strong ties pointing to habitual residence in France. Courts look at the full picture: length and regularity of presence, family life, work, tax filings, property, and stated plans. A winter rental alone does not always create habitual residence, but a settled life in France usually does.
Once French law governs, the forced share applies. Article 912 of the French Civil Code states: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 912. In plain terms, your children are called reserved heirs. If they accept the succession, the law guarantees them a minimum portion of your estate, free of conditions. Your spouse is not a reserved heir when you leave children, although the spouse holds separate statutory rights that are discussed below.
The size of that guaranteed portion is fixed by Article 913: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 913. The arithmetic follows directly. With one child, the forced share is one half and the freely disposable portion is one half. With two children, the forced share is two thirds, meaning one third per child, and the freely disposable portion is one third. With three or more children, the forced share is three quarters divided equally among them, and the freely disposable portion is one quarter. A California will that leaves one hundred percent of a French house to the surviving spouse therefore exceeds the freely disposable portion whenever the deceased leaves children who accept the succession.
American readers sometimes ask whether a lifetime gift made years earlier escapes this calculation. It does not. Article 922 provides: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur.” The full computation rule is in the French Civil Code, Article 922. The notaire builds a fictional mass: assets on hand at death, minus debts, plus lifetime gifts reunited fictitiously at their value on the day of death according to their condition at the time of the gift. The forced share and the freely disposable portion are then computed on that total. A large gift to one child or to a new spouse can therefore still infringe the share of the other children, even if the bank transfer happened a decade before death.
The remedy for the injured child is the action en reduction, meaning the court action to reduce excessive gifts. Article 921 states: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 921. Only the reserved heir, or that heir’s own heirs, can bring this action. Neither the legatee nor the creditors of the deceased can demand it. Since 2021 the notaire who sees a possible infringement must warn each affected heir individually, where possible before any partition. The sanction is no longer seizure of the house itself in most cases. Article 924 provides: “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 924. The overpaid beneficiary pays money compensation, called an indemnity of reduction, rather than returning the bricks.
The order of heirs matters as well. Article 734 ranks them: “En l’absence de conjoint successible, les parents sont appelés à succéder ainsi qu’il suit : 1° Les enfants et leurs descendants ; 2° Les père et mère ; les frères et soeurs et les descendants de ces derniers ; 3° Les ascendants autres que les père et mère ; 4° Les collatéraux autres que les frères et soeurs et les descendants de ces derniers.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 734. Children therefore come first and exclude parents, siblings, and more distant relatives. An American with no children faces a different analysis, and the surviving spouse’s position becomes central, but for parents the message is simple: under default French law, your children cannot be written out of your French estate by a standard American will that leaves everything to your spouse.
B. What an American Will Without a Choice-of-Law Clause Triggers: Reduction Claims, the Compensatory Levy, and a Notaire Who Sets Your Will Aside
Consider a concrete case. Robert, a United States citizen domiciled in France for twelve years, owns a house near Bordeaux worth 600,000 euros and leaves two children. His Texas will leaves everything to his second wife. The notaire computes the mass at 600,000 euros. The freely disposable portion is one third, or 200,000 euros. The bequest to the wife is 600,000 euros. The excess is 400,000 euros. Each child can demand 200,000 euros in reduction indemnity from the wife under Article 924. The wife keeps the house only if she can pay or offset those sums. Many surviving spouses discover this arithmetic for the first time at the notaire’s desk, months after the funeral, when refinancing is difficult and emotions run high.
A second trap concerns children who were left out by a foreign-law will before the 2021 reform. The French legislature created a safety net in the second paragraph of Article 913 for cases where the deceased or at least one child was a European Union citizen or habitually resident in a member state at death, and the applicable foreign law offered children no reserved-share mechanism at all. In that situation, “chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” That sentence is part of the same official French Civil Code, Article 913. The prelevement compensatoire, translated here as the compensatory levy, lets the disinherited child take French-situs assets up to the French forced share. For background on how American children use this levy against a California will, see our analysis of how American children reclaim their forced share of the French house through the compensatory levy. The levy does not apply to every disappointment. It requires the European connection described in the statute and a foreign applicable law with no reserved-share device of its own. United States state laws generally have no forced share for children, only elective-share or pretermitted-heir protections for spouses and omitted children, so the condition is often met in Franco-American cases, but each file must be checked individually.
French courts have a long history of protecting the forced share against foreign wills, although the legal reasoning has evolved. Under the old conflict rule that applied before the European regulation, French courts treated the forced share as a domestic public-policy rule for French real estate. In a 2018 decision concerning a Moroccan will covering French buildings, the Court of Cassation held that “ceux-ci sont soumis, par application de la règle de conflit édictée à l’article 3, alinéa 2, du code civil, à la loi française” and that “que la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire, laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel” The full official decision is on Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, July 4, 2018, No. 17-16.515. That case applied the pre-2015 dualist system, where French real estate followed French law directly, so it must not be quoted as the current rule for post-2015 deaths. It remains useful for one point: French judges take the forced share seriously and will set aside foreign testamentary dispositions that ignore it when French law governs the property.
Jurisdiction follows a related logic. In an April 2021 decision about a foreign donation of a French building, the Court of Cassation recalled that “les tribunaux français sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession mobilière lorsque le défunt avait son domicile en France. Ils sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession immobilière pour les immeubles situés en France.” It added that “La nature de l’action successorale est déterminée selon la loi du for.” The full official decision is on Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, April 14, 2021, No. 19-24.773. That case also concerned a succession opened before the European regulation, so the exact jurisdictional regime for deaths on or after August 17, 2015 now sits in Chapter II of the regulation. The practical lesson survives: disputes about a French house are heard in France, under the law designated by the regulation, and a child who sues in reduction sues in France.
Put together, the default path looks like this for an American habitually resident in France who dies with a standard United States will and no choice-of-law clause. French law governs the whole succession under Article 21. The notaire computes the forced share under Articles 912, 913, and 922. Gifts that exceed the freely disposable portion are reduced to money indemnities under Articles 921 and 924. Children connected to Europe may also invoke the compensatory levy on French assets under the second paragraph of Article 913. The surviving spouse keeps statutory options described in the next part, but the spouse does not defeat the children’s forced share. The only way to change this default while respecting French law is a valid choice of United States law, made in the correct form, within the limits examined below.
II. How Americans Living in France Choose United States Law and Make the Choice Stick
A. How to Draft a Valid Article 22 Choice of United States Law, Which Will Form to Use, and How Dual Wills Affect Your French House
Article 22 of the regulation opens the door. It states: “Une personne peut choisir comme loi régissant l’ensemble de sa succession la loi de l’État dont elle possède la nationalité au moment où elle fait ce choix ou au moment de son décès. Une personne ayant plusieurs nationalités peut choisir la loi de tout État dont elle possède la nationalité au moment où elle fait ce choix ou au moment de son décès.” In English, you may choose the law of any country whose nationality you hold, whether at the time of the choice or at death. The official text is on EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 22. An American citizen therefore qualifies by nationality alone, even after decades of life in France. A dual French-American citizen qualifies as well and may select either law. The choice covers the succession as a whole, meaning it cannot be limited to the French house while leaving the Ohio brokerage account to another law. That single-law principle is confirmed by Article 23, which lists what the chosen law governs, including “la quotité disponible, les réserves héréditaires et les autres restrictions à la liberté de disposer à cause de mort” meaning the freely disposable portion, the forced shares, and the other limits on death dispositions. The official text is on EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 23. Choosing the law of your American state of nationality connection therefore displaces the French forced-share computation for the entire estate, subject to the public-policy and levy limits in the next section.
Form is where many choices fail. Article 22 continues: “Le choix est formulé de manière expresse dans une déclaration revêtant la forme d’une disposition à cause de mort ou résulte des termes d’une telle disposition.” In English, the choice must be express in a will-type declaration or clearly shown by its terms. The same official EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 22 adds that any later change or revocation must meet the formal requirements for changing or revoking a will. A vague sentence suggesting that American law should apply merely because you are American is risky. The safest wording names the choice expressly, for example by stating pursuant to Article 22 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 that you choose the law of your American state, such as New York, California, or Texas, being a state of your nationality, to govern your succession as a whole. For a dual citizen choosing French law instead, mirror language naming France should be used. Because the United States has fifty state succession regimes, naming the specific state avoids later debate about which American internal law applies. The regulation sends multi-state questions to Article 36, but spelling out the state in the will saves your heirs a costly interpretive fight.
The will itself must also satisfy French formal requirements for the French assets. Two forms dominate. The holographic will, or testament olographe, is the handwritten will. Article 970 states: “Le testament olographe ne sera point valable s’il n’est écrit en entier, daté et signé de la main du testateur : il n’est assujetti à aucune autre forme.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 970. Every word must be in your hand, with a date and a signature. A typed page that you merely sign is void as a holographic will. Typed American wills with two witnesses therefore fail this form, although they may still be probated as foreign wills through other channels at greater cost and delay. The public will, or testament par acte public, is the notarial will. Article 971 states: “Le testament par acte public est reçu par deux notaires ou par un notaire assisté de deux témoins.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 971. For an American with a French house, the notarial will containing an express Article 22 clause is usually the strongest vehicle: it is drafted by the French officer who will later settle the estate, stored in the national wills file, and difficult to challenge on formal grounds.
Many Americans hold two wills: a United States will for American assets and a French will for French assets. Dual wills are permitted, but they must be coordinated. Each will should state that it revokes only prior dispositions concerning the assets it covers, not all prior wills worldwide. A standard American revocation clause reading “I revoke all prior wills” can accidentally revoke the French will signed a year earlier. The order of signatures matters, and the Article 22 choice should appear in both documents with identical wording selecting the same state law, or the French will should contain the choice while the American will defers to it. An executor nomination, called an executeur testamentaire in French, helps bridge the two systems. Article 1025 provides that “Le testateur peut nommer un ou plusieurs exécuteurs testamentaires jouissant de la pleine capacité civile pour veiller ou procéder à l’exécution de ses volontés.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 1025. Note that French executors hold narrower powers than American executors or trustees, especially over French real estate, so the clause should be drafted with both roles in mind.
The universal legacy deserves a final drafting note. Article 1003 defines it: “Le legs universel est la disposition testamentaire par laquelle le testateur donne à une ou plusieurs personnes l’universalité des biens qu’il laissera à son décès.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 1003. Article 1006 adds: “Lorsqu’au décès du testateur il n’y aura pas d’héritiers auxquels une quotité de ses biens soit réservée par la loi, le légataire universel sera saisi de plein droit par la mort du testateur, sans être tenu de demander la délivrance.” The official text is in the French Civil Code, Article 1006. When United States law validly governs and no forced heir takes under that law, the surviving spouse named as universal legatee is seized of the estate directly. When French law governs and children take as forced heirs, the same legatee must instead request delivery, called delivrance, from the reserved heirs before selling or mortgaging the house. Your choice-of-law clause therefore changes not only shares but also the mechanics of taking possession.
B. The Three Limits on Your Choice, the Taxes It Does Not Fix, and How to Answer a Notaire Who Refuses to Apply United States Law
A valid Article 22 choice is powerful, but it is not absolute. Three limits must be understood before anyone signs.
The first limit is French international public policy. Article 35 of the regulation states: “L’application d’une disposition de la loi d’un État désignée par le présent règlement ne peut être écartée que si cette application est manifestement incompatible avec l’ordre public du for.” In English, a designated foreign provision is set aside only for manifest incompatibility with French public policy. The official text is on EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 35. The word manifestly sets a high bar. Ordinary differences between French and American succession law do not trigger it. A United States will that leaves the freely disposable economics intact while disinheriting children entirely has generated extensive litigation, and French courts historically protected children through domestic public policy for pre-2015 deaths. For deaths governed by the regulation, courts apply Article 35 directly and examine whether the concrete result, not the foreign rule in the abstract, shocks French fundamental values, taking into account factors such as the children’s need, prior gifts, and available maintenance claims under the chosen American law. No responsible adviser can promise that every disinheritance survives. The clause should therefore be paired with lifetime planning, such as suitable gifts, insurance designations, or support arrangements, rather than presented as a guarantee that children receive nothing.
The second limit is the compensatory levy itself. Even where United States law governs under a valid Article 22 choice, the second paragraph of Article 913 may still allow a child connected to Europe to levy French-situs assets up to the French forced share where the chosen American law offers no reserved-share mechanism. The levy sits in the same official French Civil Code, Article 913 and operates as a substantive French corrective, not as a conflict rule your clause can switch off. Its conditions are cumulative: at death, the deceased or at least one child must be a European Union citizen or habitually resident in a member state, the foreign applicable law must provide no reserved-share protection for children, and the levy is capped at French forced-share rights and taken only from assets located in France. Litigation continues over its compatibility with the regulation’s single-law principle, but notaires apply it in practice and children invoke it. Anyone choosing United States law should therefore map which French assets would remain exposed to a levy claim and consider whether targeted lifetime gifts, a French-compliant insurance structure, or a negotiated family arrangement reduces that exposure.
The third limit is tax. A choice-of-law clause changes the civil law of succession, not the tax law. French inheritance tax still applies to French real estate regardless of the chosen succession law, and the 1978 France-United States estate and gift tax treaty allocates taxing rights without following your Article 22 designation. French real property remains taxable in France, with a United States credit available under treaty limits, and French tax returns and payment deadlines run independently of the American probate calendar. For the French filing mechanics, deadlines, and treaty-credit method, see our guide on how American heirs file the French inheritance tax return and claim the treaty credit. Your will should never contain a sentence suggesting that choosing United States law exempts the estate from French death tax. It does not.
When a notaire refuses to apply a will containing an Article 22 clause, American heirs should proceed in stages. First, ask for the refusal in writing with reasons: missing express clause, formal defect, alleged public-policy conflict, or asserted levy claim. Vague oral statements such as “we always apply French law here” are not a legal analysis. Second, supply the missing proof rather than arguing abstractly: the will with the express clause, evidence of United States nationality at the time of the choice or death, the applicable state statute showing what protection, if any, it gives children and spouses, and any prior gifts relevant to the levy computation. Third, request a second notarial review or a written consultation from a French succession specialist that engages with Articles 21, 22, 23, and 35 and the second paragraph of Article 913. Many files settle at this stage once the notaire sees an express clause in a formally valid will and a reasoned memorandum.
If the blockage persists, judicial tools exist. Heirs can petition the guardianship or civil judge for authorizations needed to preserve the property, sue in reduction or in delivery before the judicial court of the place where the French building sits, and seek a declaratory judgment on the applicable law. Limitation periods are strict: the five-year, two-year-knowledge, and ten-year-long-stop regime of Article 921 governs reduction claims, so waiting for family consensus can destroy rights. Evidence should be assembled early from the United States: certified copies of the will and any codicils, apostilled birth and marriage records, nationality certificates, the state probate file, valuations of lifetime gifts, and bank records tracing transfers. For the French side, obtain the title deed, the land-registry extract, the housing-tax and property-tax notices, the building insurance policy, and any occupancy agreements. A child who suspects concealment of gifts or accounts should also review our analysis of how American heirs prove concealment and reclaim diverted French assets, because a choice-of-law dispute often travels with an evidentiary dispute.
Two final cautions protect the whole plan. Review the clause after every major life event: naturalization, marriage, divorce, birth of a child, purchase of French property, or a move back to the United States. Habitual residence is assessed at death, so a return to Ohio can change the default law even without touching the will, and a stale clause naming the wrong state can create the very litigation it was meant to prevent. Keep the original will accessible and registered: a holographic will stored in a drawer that no one finds has the same practical value as no will at all, and the French wills file exists precisely to avoid that outcome. The Article 22 choice rewards precision and maintenance. Drafted expressly, in a formally valid will, with eyes open to public policy, the compensatory levy, and tax, it lets an American living in France decide under which law the French house passes. Drafted vaguely or left to inference, it invites the notaire to disregard it and the children to litigate it.
Conclusion
An American who settles in France does not lose control over the succession, but control is no longer automatic. Without action, Article 21 points to French law, Articles 912 and 913 reserve fixed shares for children, Article 922 pulls lifetime gifts back into the computation, and Articles 921 and 924 convert excess gifts into money claims that fall due at the worst moment. With action, Article 22 permits a United States citizen to choose American law for the whole succession through an express clause in a formally valid will, with the holographic and notarial forms of Articles 970 and 971 and the universal-legacy mechanics of Articles 1003 and 1006 shaping how the French house actually transfers. That choice remains bounded by the public-policy filter of Article 35, the compensatory levy of the second paragraph of Article 913, and a tax system that follows the property rather than the clause. The practical sequence is therefore short: confirm habitual residence, draft an express clause naming the American state, execute it in a form a French notaire cannot question, coordinate any American counterpart will, map levy and tax exposure on the French house, and calendar the Article 921 limitation periods. Families who complete these steps give the notaire a file that can be settled. Families who postpone them give their children a lawsuit.