KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU Extends Russia Hybrid Sanctions Until 9 October 2027: Frozen Assets in France and How to Challenge a Listing

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU Extends Russia Hybrid Sanctions Until 9 October 2027: Frozen Assets in France and How to Challenge a Listing

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 8 October 2026 the Council of the European Union prolonged one of its newest and least understood sanctions regimes for another year. The decision extends individual restrictive measures against persons and entities held responsible for Russia’s destabilising actions abroad, including foreign information manipulation and interference, until 9 October 2027. The announcement matters far beyond Brussels meeting rooms. It keeps in place asset freezes on 80 individuals and 20 entities, a Union-wide prohibition on making funds or economic resources available to them, and travel bans for listed natural persons. For anyone who holds accounts, property, contracts or family interests in France while appearing on, doing business with, or seeking payment from a listed person, the renewal resets the clock on enforcement by French banks, the reach of French creditor action, and the deadlines for asking a judge to intervene. This analysis explains what the Council actually decided, what a freeze means day to day in France, why even a creditor with a final judgment cannot simply seize frozen money in Paris, and which two doors remain open: a release authorisation from the French Treasury for basic needs or asset preservation, and an annulment action before the EU courts in Luxembourg.

I. What the Council decided on 8 October 2026 and who remains listed

A. How long will the EU freeze last and which conduct does it target?

According to the Council press release of 8 October 2026, the Council decision of 8 October 2026 prolonging the regime by one year until 9 October 2027, issued in a context of continued and intensified hybrid operations, including information manipulation and interference targeting the Union, its Member States and partners, as described in the Council press release of 8 October 2026. The legal framework itself was created on 8 October 2024 to target actions and policies of the government of the Russian Federation said to undermine the fundamental values of the Union and its Member States, their security, stability, independence and integrity, and it also covers hybrid operations directed at third countries and international organisations. The consolidated legal base is Decision (CFSP) 2024/2643 concerning restrictive measures in view of Russia’s destabilising activities (consolidated text dated 13 July 2026, referenced from the Council press release). Readers who follow the broader Russia sanctions architecture will find useful context in the companion analysis of the parallel Russia listings regime and its French challenge routes, EU sanctions listings and how to challenge a freeze from France, which describes the same enforcement chain of EU regulation, French bank freeze, and Luxembourg review.

The figures published with the renewal are precise. The Council states that 80 individuals and 20 entities currently listed under the regime, according to the Council press release of 8 October 2026 and recalls that listed persons face an asset freeze combined with a Union-wide ban on making funds or economic resources available to them, as recalled in the Council press release of 8 October 2026, with natural persons additionally subject to a travel ban barring entry into or transit through EU territory. In European Council language, the June 2026 conclusions had already condemned recent hybrid attacks against the Union and its Member States and called for stronger resilience, preparedness, protection of critical infrastructure, and deterrence. The October renewal therefore does three things at once. It confirms the political assessment that the threat persists. It preserves every existing listing without requiring a fresh designation decision for each name. And it pushes the next review deadline to October 2027, which means that any delisting request, factual correction, or court action filed now will be examined against a regime the Council has just reaffirmed rather than a regime winding down.

Three practical consequences follow for people in France. First, the freeze has direct effect. An EU regulation imposing restrictive measures applies as written in every Member State and does not need a French transposition decree to bind a Paris bank, insurer, notary, or employer. French authorities implement and penalise, but the prohibition itself comes from Luxembourg and Brussels. Second, the scope is deliberately wide. Funds means cash, deposits, securities, claims, and payment instruments. Economic resources means any asset, tangible or intangible, movable or immovable, that could be used to obtain funds, goods, or services, including real estate, corporate shares, crypto-assets held through a custodian, and even contractual rights. Third, the prohibition on making available catches indirect routes. Paying rent to a listed landlord through a relative, routing salary through an unlisted company controlled by a listed person, or releasing escrowed deal proceeds to a designated buyer can each breach the regulation even when the listed name never appears on the transfer order. The Court of Justice has repeatedly held that circumvention and making available indirectly fall inside the ban, and French compliance teams read those judgments as instructions to block first and ask questions later.

The hybrid label itself deserves attention because it differs from the older sectoral Russia packages. The 2024 framework does not sanction an economic sector as such. It sanctions destabilising actions abroad attributed to the Russian state, expressly including information manipulation and interference, cyber-enabled disruption, sabotage risks to critical infrastructure, and support networks that enable such operations. That design explains why listings can mix alleged operatives, facilitators, media and technology entities, and financial intermediaries. It also explains why the statement of reasons for each listing matters so much in court. The General Court does not review foreign policy wisdom. It reviews whether the Council stated specific, concrete reasons linking the applicant to the listing criterion, disclosed the evidence in sufficient time, and respected rights of defence, effective judicial protection, and proportionality. A renewal that merely extends the regime does not cure a defective individual statement of reasons, and a reaffirmed political context does not dispense the Council from proving the individual link when challenged.

B. What does an EU asset freeze and funds ban block in daily life?

An asset freeze immobilises everything the listed person owns, holds, or controls within the Union. Bank balances stay visible but untouchable. Securities cannot be sold. Rental income accrues but cannot be distributed. Insurance surrender values, pension compartments, and business current accounts are caught in the same way. The parallel prohibition on making funds or economic resources available means that no one else in the Union may voluntarily transfer value to the listed person either, whether by paying a debt, advancing a loan, delivering goods on credit, or providing services for which the listed person would normally pay. Humanitarian, medical, and basic-needs exceptions exist in the texts but they operate by prior authorisation, not by self-assessment. A bank that releases money on the strength of a plausible hardship letter, without the competent authority’s written permission, exposes itself to regulatory sanction and criminal risk.

In France that competent authority for most releases is the Directorate General of the Treasury, acting under powers set out in the Monetary and Financial Code. Article L. 562-3 of that Code, which mirrors EU and UN designations into domestic enforcement language, provides that “Le ministre chargé de l’économie peut décider, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques” over assets belonging to, owned, held or controlled by persons designated under resolutions adopted under Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter or acts adopted under Article 29 of the Treaty on European Union or Article 75 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. The older terrorism-focused track in Article L. 562-2 of the Monetary and Financial Code uses joint economy and interior minister decisions for comparable freezes, which shows the consistent French method: a ministerial decision, published by extract in the Journal officiel, immediately enforceable, renewable, and opposable to third parties. Article L. 562-9 of the Monetary and Financial Code confirms that ministerial freeze decisions are enforceable from publication, while Article L. 562-10 of the Monetary and Financial Code states in full that “Les mesures prises en vertu du présent chapitre sont opposables à tout tiers qui peut invoquer un droit sur les fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l’objet d’une mesure de gel, y compris lorsque ce droit est né antérieurement auxdites mesures.” In plain terms, arriving earlier does not beat the freeze. A prior pledge, assignment, or invoice does not by itself unlock frozen money.

The compliance burden then falls on the private sector. Article L. 562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code opens with the words “Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre” and lists everyone bound in France, from individuals on national territory to banks, insurers, and other entities named in Article L. 561-2, including French-headquartered groups for their foreign branches and foreign groups for their French activity, plus public bodies managing public services or social protection funds. Article L. 562-4-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code adds the organisational duty: regulated persons must build internal procedures for applying freezes, bans on making available, and anti-circumvention, and must enforce them in foreign branches, while French parent groups must define group-wide procedures applied by their French entities and foreign outposts. For an international reader, the message is that a Paris compliance officer who blocks a transfer to a listed person is not exercising discretion. That officer is performing a statutory duty whose breach can trigger administrative sanctions from the French Prudential Supervision and Resolution Authority for banks and insurers, alongside potential criminal exposure for wilful violation of restrictive measures.

Day-to-day examples make the abstraction concrete. A listed shareholder cannot receive dividends from a French company even if the general meeting validly declared them. A listed tenant cannot pay Paris rent from frozen funds without authorisation, and the landlord cannot accept payment routed through an unlisted intermediary if the economic benefit still reaches the listed person. A French employer cannot pay salary arrears to a listed employee. A notary cannot distribute sale proceeds to a listed seller on completion day. In each case the funds stay frozen in place or the transaction is refused, the institution files its report to the Treasury, and the parties are told to seek an authorisation or a court remedy rather than to improvise a workaround. Workarounds are precisely what the anti-circumvention rule punishes.

II. Frozen money in France: what creditors cannot seize and which remedies still work

A. Can a creditor with a judgment seize frozen assets held in Paris?

The short answer under current French case law is no, not without prior Treasury authorisation, even with an enforceable title. The Cour de cassation restated the rule in the Libyan frozen-assets line of cases that every Paris enforcement practitioner now cites. In its 7 September 2022 judgments, recalled at length in the 1 October 2026 ruling, the Court held that no enforcement measure may proceed against frozen funds or economic resources where the effect would be to remove them from the debtor’s estate or even to grant the pursuing creditor a mere right of preference, without prior authorisation from the Treasury director as the designated national authority. The 1 October 2026 decision, Second Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation, 1 October 2026, appeal No. 24-10.958, concerning an award creditor of the Libyan state attempting enforcement in France against assets held in the name of the Libyan Investment Authority, restates that “ne peut être diligentée, sur des fonds ou des ressources économiques gelés, aucune mesure d’exécution qui aurait pour effet, non seulement de les faire sortir du patrimoine du débiteur, mais aussi de conférer au créancier poursuivant un simple droit de préférence, sans une autorisation préalable du directeur du Trésor”. The companion ruling Second Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation, 5 February 2026, appeal No. 23-15.936 applies the same logic to an earlier seizure attempt against the same institution, confirming that the solution is structural rather than tied to one procedural posture.

The reasoning combines European primacy with enforcement effectiveness. The Court reads the EU regulation’s freeze and no-movement logic as incompatible with any national enforcement step that would alter allocation of frozen value among creditors, because allowing one diligent creditor to jump the queue would fragment a Union-wide immobilisation decided for foreign-policy reasons. The designated national authority filter therefore serves as the single gate. The Treasury checks compatibility with the regulation, with the underlying Council decision, and with public-order safeguards before any release. Paris enforcement judges have internalised the sequence: absent the Treasury letter, the seizure is lifted or the authorisation to seize is withdrawn, even where the underlying award or judgment is final and even where the debtor state itself was duly served. The 1 October 2026 judgment adds a standing point worth noting for third parties. The listed holder itself must be able to learn of and contest a seizure over funds it holds, particularly on qualification as an emanation of the debtor state or on unseizability due to a European freeze, especially where it is itself designated. That passage protects designated entities procedurally without loosening the substantive freeze.

The older landmark behind this architecture remains the Assembly plenary ruling in the Bank Sepah matter, Assemblée plénière of the Cour de cassation, 10 July 2020, appeals Nos. 18-18.542 and 18-21.814. The case arose from Iranian nuclear-related restrictive measures, where “la position commune 2007/140/PESC du Conseil du 27 février 2007 a prévu certaines mesures restrictives à l’encontre de l’Iran, et notamment le gel des fonds et des ressources économiques des personnes, des entités et des organismes” involved in enrichment, reprocessing, heavy water, or delivery systems. The plenary formation stayed proceedings and referred questions to the Court of Justice on the interplay between sovereign immunity from execution, EU asset freezes, and creditor enforcement, illustrating how French courts treat sanctions freezes as a distinct layer on top of immunity law rather than as a mere factual obstacle. For hybrid-regime readers, the parallel is direct. Whether the underlying programme is nuclear proliferation, Libyan state assets, or Russian destabilising operations, the French enforcement answer follows the same grammar: freeze first, Treasury gate second, judge third.

Creditors sometimes ask whether they can at least obtain a protective attachment to secure rank for the day sanctions lift. French law distinguishes conservatory measures from execution measures, but the Court’s formula deliberately covers any step conferring even a simple preference right. A conservatory attachment that would create such a preference over frozen funds without Treasury approval therefore faces the same objection. The safer creditor strategy in Paris is to seek exequatur or recognition of the foreign judgment or award, interrupt limitation, document the claim, request Treasury authorisation where the regulation allows a derogation for pre-existing judicial liens in narrow cases, and otherwise wait for delisting, licensing, or a political change while preserving priority by lawful means that do not move frozen value. Attempting to force payment through set-off, netting, or assignment of a frozen claim to an unlisted vehicle risks recharacterisation as circumvention.

B. How can a listed person unblock basic needs money or challenge the listing itself?

Two remedies coexist and they must not be confused. The first is administrative and humanitarian. It leaves the listing intact but asks the Treasury to release specific sums for defined uses. Article L. 562-11 of the Monetary and Financial Code allows the economy minister, alone or jointly with the interior minister depending on the freeze track, to authorise release and making available of part of frozen funds where use is compatible with public order and, for EU or UN tracks, with the decisions and acts behind the freeze. Authorisations can be granted on the authority’s own motion or on request by the designated person or by a third party claiming a right over frozen funds, and they are granted where the designated person shows either particular material needs for personal or family life, or an activity compatible with public order for legal persons, or decisions needed to preserve the estate. In EU practice this covers food, rent, medicines, insurance, reasonable legal fees, and estate-preservation costs, subject to caps, direct payment to providers, and reporting. Article L. 562-3-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code handles the urgent United Nations bridge of ten working days before the EU implementing regulation arrives, confirming that French law thinks in layers of time: immediate UN immobilisation, then EU regulation, then renewable national implementation.

Applications succeed when they are documented like a social-benefits file rather than argued like a sanctions appeal. Bank statements proving the freeze, lease and utility bills, medical certificates, school invoices, payroll for essential staff of a frozen company, and fee agreements with itemised legal work all help. Requests should identify exact accounts, exact payees, exact amounts, and exact periods, and should propose payment directly to landlords, hospitals, or counsel rather than cash to the applicant. The Treasury typically consults, sets conditions, and issues a reasoned decision that the bank can execute without fear. Refusals can be challenged before the administrative judge in Paris, but the judge reviews legality and manifest error rather than re-deciding foreign policy. Parallel EU-level derogation routes in the specific hybrid regulation must be checked alongside the Code, because the regulation’s own humanitarian and legal-fee articles sometimes impose additional notification to other Member States or waiting periods before release.

The second remedy attacks the listing itself before the EU courts and, if needed, through a French preliminary channel. An individual listing decision can be challenged by direct action for annulment before the General Court in Luxembourg within two months of notification or publication, plus time for distance, on grounds including lack of adequate statement of reasons, error of assessment, breach of rights of defence and effective judicial protection, and disproportionality. Applicants should immediately request access to the file, the evidence summary, and any open-source material the Council relied upon, then file a focused plea showing either mistaken identity or role, stale facts, reliance on unverified press cuttings without corroboration, or failure to consider exculpatory material such as resignation, divestment, or cessation of the relevant function. Interim relief suspending the freeze pending judgment is theoretically available but rarely granted in sanctions cases because the judge balances urgency and the balance of interests against the public-interest purpose of the freeze. Appeals on points of law lie to the Court of Justice. French courts cannot annul an EU listing, but a Paris judge faced with a serious question of validity of the EU act can stay proceedings and refer to Luxembourg, as the plenary formation did in the Bank Sepah sequence, which remains the textbook illustration of cooperation between the French supreme court and the EU judge.

Timing after the October 2026 renewal requires care. The renewal itself is a reviewable act for persons already listed, but the two-month clock for each applicant runs from proper communication of the act affecting them, not from press coverage. Designated persons should therefore calendar from the Official Journal publication and the Council notification letter, diary the file-access request within days, and prepare the annulment application while the Treasury release track covers immediate living costs. Companies in the 20-entity cohort should additionally map control chains, because EU law freezes assets owned or controlled by listed persons and prohibits making available through non-listed intermediaries. Voluntary restructuring after designation, such as transferring shares to relatives or creating new holding layers, will be read as circumvention unless pre-authorised. Proactive steps that courts view more favourably include freezing distribution, suspending voting rights of the listed holder, appointing independent management, segregating frozen accounts, and logging every compliance decision for later disclosure to the judge.

For non-listed counterparties, employees, and family members in France, the renewal confirms that ordinary life must be reorganised around authorisations rather than around informal arrangements. Employers should seek guidance before paying wages into frozen accounts. Landlords should not accept cash substitutes that mask the listed beneficiary. Divorcing spouses, heirs, and business partners should ask the enforcement judge and the Treasury how to partition unlisted shares without making value available to the listed person. Each of these situations has a lawful path, but each path passes through paperwork, waiting time, and reasoned decisions rather than through private ingenuity.

Conclusion

The Council’s 8 October 2026 renewal until 9 October 2027 keeps the hybrid-activities regime at full strength, with 80 individuals and 20 entities frozen, Union-wide bans on making funds available, and travel restrictions to match. In France that European decision lands in a mature enforcement system where banks freeze without delay, prior rights do not defeat the freeze, creditors need Treasury approval before any enforcement over frozen value, and the Cour de cassation enforces that sequence strictly. The two useful remedies remain a documented Treasury authorisation for basic needs and estate preservation, and a focused annulment action in Luxembourg attacking the individual statement of reasons and evidence. Anyone affected should preserve the Official Journal references and Council letter, segregate frozen accounts, avoid indirect transfers, file the Treasury request for immediate needs, and calendar the annulment deadline without waiting for the next annual review.

📄 Official circular