KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Overboard in the Mediterranean: Rescue at Sea and How to Claim Compensation From France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Overboard in the Mediterranean: Rescue at Sea and How to Claim Compensation From France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

A 44-year-old woman spent almost a full day alone in the Ionian Sea, some 70 nautical miles from the nearest shore, wearing a lifebelt whose flashing light finally caught the eye of a freighter crew in the dark. She lived. The Greek Coast Guard brought her ashore at Katakolo, in the western Peloponnese, and she was taken to hospital in Pyrgos for observation and tests. Behind this rescue, reported by the Greek authorities on Sunday 11 October 2026, lies a tangle of legal questions that matter far beyond one passenger: who is legally required to turn a ship around and search, who pays for helicopters, patrol boats and diverted merchant ships, and what compensation can a victim — or a grieving family when the outcome is worse — actually claim from France?

The facts as officially reported are straightforward. Early on Friday, the Greek authorities were notified that a woman had fallen into the sea from a Bahamas-flagged cruise ship about 72 nautical miles south-west of Zakynthos. Two Coast Guard vessels, an Air Force helicopter and merchant ships in the wider area were mobilised. She was found in the early hours of Saturday after the crew of a freighter taking part in the large search operation spotted the flashing light on the lifebelt she was wearing. She was conscious and received first aid aboard the rescue vessel. According to the Coast Guard statement, there was no immediate information on how she fell into the water, nor on how she came to have a lifebelt. According to maritime-law press reports, the ship was sailing from Mykonos toward Naples when the alert was given, and the passenger, a 44-year-old citizen of El Salvador, may have been in the water for up to twenty hours.

This article explains, from the standpoint of French and European law, what happens after a passenger goes overboard in the Mediterranean. The first part covers the rescue itself: the master’s duty to assist, the coastal state’s search-and-rescue machine, and the immediate rights of everyone else on board when an itinerary collapses. The second part covers compensation: how to sue the carrier under the Athens Convention as incorporated into EU law, and why passengers who booked from France through a travel agency hold a second, often stronger card — the strict liability of the package organiser, recently reshaped by the French Court of Cassation in a cruise case decided on 9 July 2025. One caution runs through the whole analysis: at the time of writing, nobody knows why this passenger entered the water, and liability turns entirely on that answer.

I. Rescued Alive After a Day at Sea: Who Has to Search and Who Pays for the Rescue?

A. When a passenger disappears overboard, which ships must turn around and who coordinates the search?

The duty to rescue at sea is one of the oldest rules of international law, and it is written in blunt terms. Article 98 of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea requires every flag state to order its masters, so far as they can do so without serious danger to the ship, the crew or the passengers, to assist “any person found at sea” in danger and to proceed “with all possible speed” to rescue persons in distress. The same article requires every coastal state to maintain an “effective search and rescue service” for safety on and over the sea. Read the full official text on the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea site.

The Zakynthos operation is a textbook illustration. Once alerted, Greece — the coastal state — deployed two of its Coast Guard vessels and a military helicopter, and merchant ships transiting the Ionian Sea were enlisted in the search pattern. That is exactly how the system is designed to work: the ship from which the passenger fell begins the immediate search, nearby commercial vessels are diverted by the rescue coordination centre, and state assets take over the grid. A cruise ship that realises a passenger is missing will typically circle back over its track, as reportedly happened here for several hours, while the coastal state’s coordination centre builds a drift model from currents and wind to define where a person in a lifebelt could have floated overnight.

For the passengers still on board, a search that lasts hours or a full day usually destroys the itinerary: missed ports, a late arrival, sometimes a cancelled sailing. European law gives them direct rights. Regulation (EU) No 1177/2010 on the rights of passengers travelling by sea applies to cruises whose port of embarkation is situated in a Member State, which covers the standard Mediterranean cruise departing from Marseille, Barcelona, Genoa, Civitavecchia or Piraeus. Read the official text on EUR-Lex, Regulation 1177/2010. Its Article 17 requires carriers that expect a cruise departure to be cancelled or delayed “more than 90 minutes” to offer waiting passengers free snacks, meals or refreshments, and accommodation where an overnight stay becomes necessary. One precision matters and is often missed: the same scope article expressly excludes cruise passengers from Articles 18 and 19. In plain terms, cruise passengers keep the right to information, assistance and accommodation, but the rerouting-or-refund choice and the fixed delay compensation of those articles are reserved for point-to-point ferry services, not cruises. A family whose Greek-isles cruise loses two ports to a search operation therefore claims assistance and documents every expense, but should not expect the automatic price-percentage compensation that ferry passengers receive.

Running parallel to these duties is a criminal prohibition that French readers should know. Under Article 223-6, paragraph 2, of the French Criminal Code, “Sera puni des mêmes peines quiconque s’abstient volontairement de porter à une personne en péril l’assistance que, sans risque pour lui ou pour les tiers, il pouvait lui prêter soit par son action personnelle, soit en provoquant un secours” — five years’ imprisonment and a 75,000 euro fine. Read it on Légifrance, Article 223-6 du code pénal. The text targets anyone, including a master or crew member who would deliberately ignore a person in peril, provided rescue was possible without risk. It does not turn every unsuccessful search into a crime: where the crew searched for hours with the Coast Guard, no voluntary abstention can be characterised. But where cameras show that nobody watched the rails, that an alert took hours, or that a ship sailed on without stopping, prosecutors in the flag state — and in France where French criminal law can apply — will ask exactly the questions this article punishes.

B. Hospital, repatriation and the evidence that decides everything: what to do in the first days?

Survival is only the first chapter. The rescued passenger in this case was landed at Katakolo and transferred to the hospital at Pyrgos for observation and further tests, according to the Coast Guard statement. Hypothermia, swallowed seawater, cardiac strain and psychological shock after twenty hours alone at night are typical of such cases, and the medical file opened in those first hours will later become exhibit number one: it dates the injuries, links them to prolonged immersion, and records the victim’s first account. Anyone assisting a rescued relative should obtain the full hospital file immediately, in Greek with a certified translation, before memories fade and before the cruise company produces its own narrative.

The second file to secure is the ship’s. French courts give the vessel’s own papers exceptional weight. In a judgment of 18 September 2026 concerning a passenger injured while boarding a cruise ship’s tender, the Marseille civil court recalled that the logbook and the captain’s sea report “font foi jusqu’à preuve contraire” – they are taken as true unless the victim proves otherwise – and in that case they documented compliance with embarkation procedures and safety rules. In that case — Tribunal judiciaire de Marseille, 2nd Civil Chamber, 18 September 2026, RG 23/11500, M. O. v. Compagnie du Ponant — the logbook, the sea report, the embarkation video and the tender’s inspection certificate together defeated the claim, and the passenger was ordered to pay 2,000 euros under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The lesson cuts both ways: the ship’s documents can exonerate the carrier, but they can also condemn it, which is why the victim’s side must demand their preservation in writing within days — bridge log, man-overboard detection records, CCTV of the deck concerned, muster lists, medical bay records, and the names of the officers on watch. A French lawyer will pair that demand with a request for the carrier’s insurer details, exactly as the Marseille claimant’s counsel did by registered letter in June 2023, because the European carrier-liability regime requires passenger ships to carry compulsory insurance, and the insurer is the address that ultimately pays.

Repatriation and consular protection form the third track. The rescued woman is a Salvadoran national found by Greece; she will deal with the Salvadoran consular network and Greek hospitals. Had she been French, the French consulate in Athens would have been notified, and her European Health Insurance Card would have covered medically necessary care in a Greek public hospital on the same terms as Greek insured persons — with substantial out-of-pocket costs remaining for private care, medicalised repatriation and an accompanying person. Comprehensive travel insurance and the assistance clause of a premium bank card are what fill that gap in practice, and families should notify both within 48 hours: late notification is the standard ground on which assistance companies reduce their coverage. Keep every receipt, boarding pass, excursion ticket and the cruise contract itself; the contract identifies the carrier, the flag, the applicable terms — and, crucially for what follows, whether the cruise was bought as a package from a French seller.

The duty to rescue others at sea and the legal tools available when someone is saved or lost in Mediterranean waters are examined in detail in our analysis of the Djibouti shipwreck trial and the duty to rescue at sea under French law, which sets out how French courts treat smugglers, rescuers and states when lives are at stake off foreign coasts.

II. Claiming Compensation From France After a Passenger Goes Overboard in the Mediterranean

A. How do you sue the cruise carrier under the Athens Convention and EU Regulation 392/2009?

Start with the contract. Under Article L. 5421-1 of the French Transport Code, “Par le contrat de passage, l’armateur s’oblige à transporter par mer, sur un trajet défini, un voyageur qui s’oblige à acquitter le prix du passage”. Read it on Légifrance, Article L. 5421-1 du code des transports. French domestic law then provides, in Article L. 5421-3, that “L’accident corporel survenu en cours de voyage, ou pendant les opérations d’embarquement ou de débarquement, soit aux ports de départ ou de destination, soit aux ports d’escale, donne lieu à réparation de la part du transporteur, s’il est établi qu’il a contrevenu aux obligations prescrites par les dispositions de l’article L. 5421-2 ou qu’une faute a été commise par lui-même ou un de ses préposés”. Read it on Légifrance, Article L. 5421-3 du code des transports. But for an international voyage — and a cruise from one state to another always is — the international convention takes precedence. As the Marseille civil court held on 18 September 2026: the Athens Convention of 1974 on the carriage by sea of passengers, as amended by the 2002 Protocol, “s’applique prioritairement”, because the voyage connected two different states, France and Spain, both parties to the Convention.

Within the European Union, that Convention does not apply alone. EU Regulation No 392/2009 on the liability of carriers of passengers by sea makes it directly applicable Union law. Its Article 3 makes the Athens Convention – Articles 1 to 16 plus Articles 18, 20 and 21, reproduced in Annex I – the governing liability regime for passengers, luggage and vehicles, together with the IMO Guidelines, which the Regulation renders binding. Read the official text on EUR-Lex, Regulation 392/2009. Three consequences follow, and each is decisive for an overboard case.

First, the liability standard depends on what caused the fall. Where death or personal injury is caused by a “shipping incident” — shipwreck, capsizing, collision, grounding, explosion, fire or a defect of the ship — the carrier faces strict liability up to “250 000 units of account” per passenger for each distinct occasion, escaping only by proving war, hostilities, an exceptional and irresistible natural phenomenon, or a deliberate act of a third party; above that threshold it remains liable unless it proves the absence of fault or neglect on its part. A passenger who simply goes over the rail on a calm night, however, is generally not the victim of a “shipping incident”. The fallback rule then applies: for injury or death not caused by a shipping incident, the carrier is liable only where the incident was due to its “fault or neglect”, and the burden of proving that fault lies on the claimant. The Marseille judgment of September 2026 states the French judicial position in identical terms: the applicable frameworks “instituent un régime de responsabilité pour faute prouvée du transporteur maritime, soumis dans tous les cas à une obligation de sécurité de moyens”. In that case the passenger’s fall between the cruise ship and its tender was held to prove nothing against the carrier: a single fall among some fifty passengers embarking without difficulty, compliant procedures, favourable weather, a properly certified tender and negative alcohol tests meant the fault was not established, and the entire claim was dismissed.

Apply that reasoning to the Ionian Sea rescue and the stakes become clear. Because the authorities have released no information on how the woman entered the water or how she obtained a lifebelt, no liability conclusion can yet be drawn — and any lawyer who promises one is guessing. If railings were too low, poorly maintained or non-compliant, if deck lighting or CCTV surveillance was defective, if the crew was understaffed or the man-overboard alarm was raised hours late, the carrier’s fault could be established and the strict-liability tier might even apply if a ship defect is characterised. If, conversely, the passenger climbed the rail deliberately despite compliant safeguards — a hypothesis nothing currently confirms or excludes — the carrier would invoke the victim’s own act, and the claim would face the same fate as the dismissed Marseille action. Everything depends on the preserved evidence described in the first part: that is why the logbook, the videos and the insurer’s identity matter more than press speculation.

Second, time is brutally short. Article 16 of the Athens Convention provides that every damages action for passenger death, personal injury or luggage loss is time-barred after two years. French law says the same in Article L. 5421-6 of the Transport Code: “L’action en responsabilité contre le transporteur se prescrit par deux ans”. Read it on Légifrance, Article L. 5421-6 du code des transports. Two years from disembarkation — or from the date the passenger should have disembarked — is all a family gets, and the clock runs while the victim is still in hospital. A formal notice to the carrier and its insurer should go out within weeks, and proceedings must be filed well before the deadline, because courts apply it strictly.

Third, two protective mechanisms soften the wait. The carrier must make an advance payment where death or injury is caused by a shipping incident: Article 6 of Regulation 392/2009 requires an advance payment covering immediate economic needs within 15 days of identifying the person entitled, with a floor of EUR 21 000 where the passenger died. The same article specifies that such a payment “shall not constitute recognition of liability” and may be offset against later sums. And the overall ceiling is fixed by Article 7 of the Athens Convention: compensation for passenger death or personal injury is capped in all cases at 400 000 units of account per passenger for each distinct occasion. Note, finally, that Article 18 of the Convention voids pre-incident contractual terms that purport to exclude the carrier’s liability toward the passenger or impose a lower ceiling than the Convention. Ticket terms that claim to exclude the carrier’s liability for overboard injuries are worthless against this provision — a point worth checking on every cruise ticket, since such clauses still appear in fine print.

Two further French provisions frame the carrier’s exposure. Compensation for passenger death or injury is contained, under Article L. 5421-5 of the Transport Code, “dans les limites fixées par l’article 7 de la convention internationale sur la limitation de responsabilité en matière de créances maritimes”, the 1976 London Convention as amended — except where the damage results from the carrier’s personal act or omission “commis avec l’intention de provoquer un tel dommage ou commis témérairement et avec conscience qu’un tel dommage en résulterait probablement”. Read it on Légifrance, Article L. 5421-5 du code des transports. And where to sue from France? Both decisions cited in this article were heard by French courts for cruises touching France — Marseille for a Malaga-to-France sailing, Aix-en-Provence and then the Court of Cassation for a cruise sold in France by a French agency. In practice, a victim domiciled in France sues either the carrier where it is domiciled or has an establishment in France, or the French seller of the voyage — which leads to the second, often more powerful, French remedy.

B. Why does buying the cruise as a package from France change everything for the victim?

Most French holidaymakers do not contract directly with a foreign shipowner: they buy a cruise from a French travel agency, online platform or tour operator. That single fact triggers the strict liability of the package organiser under the Tourism Code. Article L. 211-16, paragraph I, provides: “Le professionnel qui vend un forfait touristique […] est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat, que ces services soient exécutés par lui-même ou par d’autres prestataires de services de voyage, sans préjudice de son droit de recours contre ceux-ci”. Read it on Légifrance, Article L. 211-16 du code du tourisme. The seller can only escape “en apportant la preuve que le dommage est imputable soit au voyageur, soit à un tiers étranger à la fourniture des services de voyage compris dans le contrat, soit à des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables”. The companion Article L. 211-17 adds that “Le voyageur a droit à des dommages et intérêts de la part de l’organisateur ou du détaillant pour tout préjudice subi en raison de la non-conformité des services fournis”. Read it on Légifrance, Article L. 211-17 du code du tourisme. Unlike the Athens Convention, no fault of the seller needs proving: the victim sues in France, in French, against a French company, and it is the professional who must prove the victim’s own fault, an outside third party, or truly unavoidable extraordinary circumstances.

The Court of Cassation reinforced this weapon on 9 July 2025 in a case that could hardly be closer to our subject: a package cruise aboard an Italian company’s ship, sold by a French agency, interrupted mid-voyage. In Cass. 1st Civil Chamber, 9 July 2025, appeal No. 24-10.077 (TMR International Consultant v. Costa Crociere), the Court first recalled that “en cas d’inexécution partielle des prestations en raison de circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables, tant l’agence de voyage que l’organisateur du voyage sont tenus de rembourser au voyageur la somme correspondant aux prestations qui n’ont pas été exécutées”. It then reversed its own case law on the internal répartition between professionals: “Il y a donc lieu de juger désormais que ce recours n’est pas soumis à l’exigence d’une faute”, so that “l’agence de voyage ayant désintéressé le voyageur peut obtenir de l’organisateur de voyage le remboursement des sommes que l’organisateur a reçues au titre de prestations qu’il devait assurer et qui n’ont pas été exécutées”. For the victim, the practical message is simple: sue the French seller, which cannot hide behind the foreign shipowner, and let the professionals settle accounts between themselves without any fault requirement slowing the victim’s own compensation.

Civil liability completes the picture. Article 1240 of the Civil Code states: “Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer”. Read it on Légifrance, Article 1240 du code civil. A shipowner whose rails, procedures or watchkeeping were defective answers on this general ground wherever the special maritime regimes leave a gap, and the criminal qualification of Article 223-6 for voluntary failure to assist can support a civil-party claim before the French criminal courts where French jurisdiction reaches the facts.

Concretely, a family in France facing an overboard drama in the Mediterranean should work through this checklist within the first month: obtain the hospital and repatriation files with translations; send the carrier and the French package seller a registered formal notice demanding preservation of the logbook, sea report, CCTV, man-overboard detection data and crew list; identify the carrier’s insurer and claim the advance payment where a shipping incident is arguable; notify travel insurance and bank-card assistance within their contractual deadlines; file the damages action well inside the two-year time bar of Article 16 of the Athens Convention and Article L. 5421-6; and sue the French package seller under Article L. 211-16 in parallel with any direct action against the foreign carrier, so that at least one solvent defendant stands before a French court. The Ionian Sea rescue ended, exceptionally, with a survivor pulled from the water by a freighter’s crew. Most overboard cases end with a missing person and a dispute about a railing — and those disputes are won or lost on evidence secured in the first days.

Conclusion

A woman fell from a Bahamas-flagged cruise ship 72 nautical miles south-west of Zakynthos and lived to be carried into Katakolo after almost a day in the water, saved by a lifebelt light and a freighter crew that was looking. International law required that search: every flag state must order its masters to assist persons in danger of being lost at sea, and every coastal state must maintain the rescue service Greece actually deployed. European law then structures what follows: assistance for delayed cruise passengers under Regulation 1177/2010, carrier liability under the Athens Convention as incorporated by Regulation 392/2009 — strict up to 250,000 units of account for shipping incidents, capped at 400,000, time-barred after two years, with advance payment within fifteen days — and, for cruises bought as packages from France, the strict liability of the French seller under Article L. 211-16 of the Tourism Code, freshly strengthened by the Court of Cassation’s cruise judgment of 9 July 2025. The Marseille dismissal of September 2026 sounds the necessary warning: without proven fault, even grievous injuries go uncompensated, and proof means the logbook, the videos and the insurer’s name secured within days. Because the cause of this fall remains officially unknown, no serious lawyer can yet say who owes what for that night in the Ionian Sea — but every family that books a Mediterranean cruise from France should know the three reflexes that decide such cases: preserve the evidence, meet the two-year deadline, and sue the French seller as well as the foreign carrier.

📄 Official circular