When an American who owns a house in France dies, two tax systems wake up on the same morning. France taxes the house because it stands on French soil, and in some cases it taxes far more than the house. The United States taxes the same person because American citizens and domiciliaries remain within the American estate tax net wherever they live and wherever their property sits. The result, without a treaty, would be the same euro of value taxed twice. That treaty exists: the convention signed at Washington on November 24, 1978 between France and the United States for the avoidance of double taxation on estates and gifts, as amended, whose consolidated version the French tax administration publishes on its official site. This article explains, for the American family dealing with a French house after a death, what France takes and on what legal basis, what the United States takes on its side, and exactly how the treaty credit moves the French payment across the Atlantic so the family does not pay twice. Every French legal term is translated at first use, every decisive rule is tied to the official text that states it, and the article closes with the practical filing sequence that keeps both administrations satisfied.
I. What France Takes When an American Dies Owning French Property
A. Which Deaths France Taxes and Which Law Divides the House
French inheritance tax, called droits de succession, does not depend on the passport of the deceased. It depends on two connecting factors set out in article 750 ter of the General Tax Code. If the deceased had his or her tax domicile (domicile fiscal) in France, France taxes movable and immovable property located in France or outside France. If the deceased did not have his or her tax domicile in France, France still taxes the movable and immovable property located in France, held directly or indirectly. The Cour de cassation restates the rule this way: “Selon ce texte, sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B et ceux reçus par l’héritier, le donataire ou le légataire qui a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de cet article” (Cass. com., November 18, 2020, appeal no. 18-14.242). For the American reader, the consequence is direct. An American who retired to the Dordogne and became a French tax resident leaves a worldwide estate exposed to French succession tax, including American bank accounts and securities. An American who never left Texas but kept a vacation apartment in Nice leaves at minimum that apartment exposed to French tax. And there is a third branch to the rule that American families often miss: even where neither the deceased nor the property appears French at first glance, assets received by an heir who has his or her tax domicile in France can fall within French tax.
Tax domicile itself is defined by article 4 B of the General Tax Code, which treats as domiciled in France persons who have their household (foyer) or principal place of stay in France, persons who carry on a professional activity in France unless it is merely ancillary, and persons whose center of economic interests is in France. A retired American living year-round in France with a French home, French bank accounts, and daily life organized around France will normally meet the first test. A consultant who spends most nights of the year in France will normally meet it as well. The classification is factual, made year by year, and it can differ from the immigration notion of residence and from the American notion of domicile. Where the deceased was a French tax domiciliary, the notaire (the French public officer who settles successions, a very different figure from an American notary public) will ask for a full worldwide picture of the assets, not only the French house, because the French return must cover everything.
Before any tax computation comes a prior question: which country’s law decides who gets the house. Since August 17, 2015, that question is answered inside the European Union by Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on succession, whose Article 4 the Cour de cassation sets out and applies in the decision discussed in the next paragraph. The default connecting factor is the habitual residence of the deceased at death: the courts of the Member State where the deceased was habitually resident decide the whole succession, and that law normally governs the whole estate. An American who lived permanently in France therefore normally has his or her succession governed by French law, including the French forced share described below. The Regulation also allows a person to choose, in a will, the law of his or her nationality to govern the succession, a tool practitioners call professio juris. An American can designate American law in a French will, and the effects of that choice on the forced share are analyzed in detail in our guide on choosing United States law in a French will to manage forced heirship. The choice of law governs who inherits; it does not govern who taxes. Tax follows the tax connecting factors and the treaty, whatever law divides the property.
Habitual residence is where American families most often misjudge their position. The Cour de cassation, in a case that itself involved an American death, held that the authority in charge of the succession must carry out “une évaluation d’ensemble des circonstances de la vie du défunt au cours des années précédant son décès et au moment de son décès, prenant en compte tous les éléments de fait pertinents, notamment la durée et la régularité de la présence du défunt dans l’État concerné ainsi que les conditions et les raisons de cette présence”, and that the habitual residence thus identified must reveal a close and stable connection with the State concerned (Cass. 1st civ., May 29, 2019, appeal no. 18-13.383). In that case the deceased had died in New York, one daughter argued that his habitual residence had been in Paris and sued her siblings in France for a court-ordered partition, and the French courts declined jurisdiction; the Cour de cassation rejected her appeal. Owning a Paris apartment, keeping a French bank account, or spending summers in France does not by itself make France the habitual residence. Duration and regularity of presence, the reasons for that presence, family and social ties, and where daily life was actually organized all count. A family that assumes French courts will necessarily handle the succession because a house sits in France, or assumes American courts will handle it because everyone is American, can lose months before the competent forum is settled. Pin down habitual residence first, because it dictates the applicable inheritance law, while the French house remains taxable in France either way.
Where French law governs, the American will meets the French forced share, called réserve héréditaire. Article 912 of the Civil Code defines it as follows: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” The reserved heirs are the children, and failing children, the surviving spouse. Article 913 of the Civil Code fixes the disposable share (quotité disponible, the part the deceased could give away by gift or will): “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” A will written in Florida that leaves the entire French house to the surviving spouse, disinheriting two children, cannot hold as written against French forced heirship if French law applies: each child is entitled to claim the shortfall through the reduction action (action en réduction), on which our guide explains how an American child reclaims a forced share left to someone else. Conversely, where American law governs by a valid choice and American law allows full disinheritance, French law offers a safety net added in 2021: where the deceased or at least one of the children was, at death, a national of a European Union Member State or habitually resident there, and the applicable foreign law provides no forced-share mechanism protecting children, each child may take a compensatory levy (prélèvement compensatoire) on property located in France, under the same article 913, which states the condition as follows: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès”. For Franco-American families, where one child holds French nationality or lives in France, this provision can reopen a succession that American law had closed.
One American planning tool needs a blunt warning: the revocable living trust. Many Americans hold their French house, or the shares of the property company that holds it, through a living trust created in the United States, believing the house has left their estate. France does not see it that way. Article 750 ter expressly reaches property and rights forming part of a trust as defined in article 792-0 bis of the General Tax Code, and the Cour de cassation held, on the visa of article 750 ter, that the taxable event (fait générateur) of transfer duties is the transfer of ownership, which, for property placed in a trust, operates through the distribution of the trust assets to the final beneficiary when the trust closes, a date that can come after the death of the settlor (Cass. com., November 18, 2020, appeal no. 18-14.242, published in the Bulletin). In plain terms, putting the French house in an American trust neither removes it from French succession tax nor accelerates anything: the tax attaches when value actually passes to the beneficiary. Trustees and successor trustees should tell the French notaire about the trust immediately, with the trust instrument and any amendments, so the French return characterizes the transmission correctly instead of the administration recharacterizing it later with penalties.
B. The French Tax Bill in Practice: Filing, Rates, Allowances, and a Worked Example
France collects its tax through a return called the déclaration de succession, prepared in practice by the notaire and signed by the heirs. The filing deadline is short and it is stated exactly by article 641 of the General Tax Code: “Les délais pour l’enregistrement des déclarations que les héritiers, donataires ou légataires ont à souscrire des biens à eux échus ou transmis par décès sont : De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.” An American who dies in France leaves six months; an American who dies in the United States leaves one year. The administration’s own guide to the declaration, its supporting documents, and payment is published on service-public.fr, and the notaire’s fee mechanics for exactly this situation are broken down in our guide to what the notaire charges an American heir and how to check the bill. Families should count the deadline from the date of death, not from the date they receive the American death certificate or the date the French notaire opens the file, and should instruct the notaire in the first weeks: obtaining an American death certificate with an apostille, having it translated by a sworn translator, and gathering twelve months of account statements takes longer from across the Atlantic than anyone expects. Missing the deadline does not merely delay matters. Article 1727 of the General Tax Code provides that “Toute créance de nature fiscale, dont l’établissement ou le recouvrement incombe aux administrations fiscales, qui n’a pas été acquittée dans le délai légal donne lieu au versement d’un intérêt de retard. A cet intérêt s’ajoutent, le cas échéant, les sanctions prévues au présent code.” Late interest runs on top of the duties, and statutory penalties can be added, so the return should be filed even if a valuation point is still being discussed, with corrections made afterward, rather than filed late as a whole.
The tax itself is computed heir by heir, on each heir’s net share, after a personal allowance called an abattement. The rate scale in the direct line (parents to children) is set by article 777 of the General Tax Code, which taxes the net share in slices: 5 percent up to 8,072 euros, 10 percent from 8,072 to 12,109 euros, 15 percent from 12,109 to 15,932 euros, 20 percent from 15,932 to 552,324 euros, then 30, 40, and 45 percent on the higher slices. Before those rates apply, article 779 of the General Tax Code grants “un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation”, meaning each living child, or the representatives of a predeceased or renouncing child, subtracts 100,000 euros from his or her share first. The surviving spouse, married or bound by a civil solidarity pact (pacte civil de solidarité, the French registered partnership known as PACS), pays nothing at all: article 796-0 bis of the General Tax Code states that “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” An American widow who inherits the French house from her husband therefore owes no French succession duty on her share, whatever its size, though the children’s shares remain taxable and her own later succession will be a separate taxable event. Our guide to what the American surviving spouse receives and how to stay in the home walks through the choice between full ownership and usufruct that usually accompanies this exemption. One more structural rule shapes every computation: gifts the deceased made during life are pulled back into the base. Article 784 of the General Tax Code requires the parties to disclose earlier gifts and provides that “La perception est effectuée en ajoutant à la valeur des biens compris dans la donation ou la déclaration de succession celle des biens qui ont fait l’objet de donations antérieures, à l’exception de celles passées depuis plus de quinze ans”, with earlier gifts counted in the highest slices of the progressive scale. An American parent who gave 100,000 euros to a child ten years before dying with a French house cannot treat that allowance as renewed: the earlier gift consumes the abatement and pushes the succession share into higher slices.
A worked example makes the burden concrete. Take an American father, widowed, French tax resident, who dies in France leaving a Nice apartment worth 600,000 euros and two children, with no gifts in the prior fifteen years and no debts to deduct for simplicity. Each child’s share is 300,000 euros. Each subtracts the 100,000 euro allowance, leaving 200,000 euros taxable. Applying the article 777 slices: 5 percent of 8,072 euros is 403.60 euros; 10 percent of the 4,037 euros between 8,072 and 12,109 is 403.70 euros; 15 percent of the 3,823 euros between 12,109 and 15,932 is 573.45 euros; 20 percent of the remaining 184,068 euros is 36,813.60 euros. Each child owes about 38,194 euros, roughly 76,400 euros for the family on a 600,000 euro apartment, before any notaire fees. Change one fact and the answer changes sharply. If the father had instead left everything to his second wife, she would owe zero under article 796-0 bis, but any child entitled under the forced share could still claim the monetary equivalent of the reserve against her. If the father had died in Florida as a nonresident of France, the same apartment would still be taxed in France under the second branch of article 750 ter, with a one-year filing deadline instead of six months. If the apartment had been held through a French property company (société civile immobilière) whose shares the father owned, the shares representing French real estate fall within the same French tax net, and the treaty itself treats shares in a company whose assets are at least half real estate as real estate. Families should therefore never assume that an American will, an American trust, or an American company wrapper has moved the French house outside French tax: compute on the assumption that France taxes it, then use the treaty to neutralize the second bill.
II. What America Takes and How the 1978 Treaty Prevents Paying Twice
A. The American Side of the Same Death: Citizenship, Worldwide Taxation, and Paperwork
The United States taxes estates on a fundamentally different connecting factor from France: citizenship and domicile rather than the location of each asset. A United States citizen who dies domiciled in France remains subject to the American federal estate tax on worldwide assets, including the French house that France has just taxed. A person who was neither a citizen nor a domiciliary of the United States is generally exposed to American estate tax only on property situated in the United States. The Internal Revenue Service describes the federal estate tax, its filing thresholds, and its procedures on its official estate tax page, which is the starting point for the American side of every Franco-American succession. The treaty confirms this architecture in its first article, applying to successions of persons domiciled in France at death and to successions of persons subject to United States tax by reason of domicile there or American citizenship: the consolidated convention is published by the French tax administration at impots.gouv.fr and commented article by article in the official tax doctrine at BOFiP-Impôts.
Two features of the American side surprise French-trained minds every time. First, the federal exemption (the amount a person can leave exempt from American estate tax, called the unified credit in the statute) is large and it moves: Congress changes the figure regularly, and it is indexed, so no article can safely print a number that will still be right at the future date of death. Verify the exemption for the year of death on the IRS page before concluding that no American return is due, and remember that even where no tax is due, a return may still be needed to claim treaty benefits, to elect portability of a deceased spouse’s unused exemption, or to start limitation periods. Second, the marital deduction, which in a purely domestic American succession lets everything pass to a citizen spouse with no immediate tax, is restricted where the surviving spouse is not a United States citizen. Franco-American couples, where a French wife inherits from an American husband or the reverse, should ask their American preparer early how the non-citizen spouse rules apply to their situation, because the answer changes the value of lifetime planning such as qualified domestic trusts. Neither point is a reason to panic; both are reasons to keep an American tax preparer in the loop from the first month rather than discovering the American filing obligation after the French deadline has already run.
Paperwork runs in both directions and it is the most common source of delay. The French notaire will require the American death certificate with an apostille (the international authentication attached under the Hague Convention), a sworn French translation, proof of the marital regime and any American will with its probate documents, and statements for American accounts where the deceased was French tax domiciled. The American preparer will require the French acte de notoriété (the notarial certificate identifying the heirs), the filed French declaration, and the French tax notices and receipts proving payment, because the treaty credit is documented with foreign tax receipts, not with estimates. Start the French file first: its six- or twelve-month deadline is the shorter fuse, and the French payment receipts it produces are the exhibits the American return needs. Heirs who discover that the French duties exceed the liquid funds available should know that renunciation (renonciation) of the succession before the court registry remains possible within the option period, a path described in our guide to renouncing a French inheritance from America, but renunciation must be weighed against the American side too, since disclaiming in France while accepting benefits in the United States can produce inconsistent positions in the two files.
B. The Treaty Mechanics: France Taxes the House, America Credits the French Tax
The 1978 convention divides taxing rights asset by asset and then neutralizes overlaps with credits. Its cornerstone for real estate is Article 5 of the convention, under which real property may be taxed by the State where it is situated. The French house is therefore always taxable in France, whether the deceased was American, French, resident, or nonresident, and the treaty expressly extends the notion of real property to shares and interests in a company whose assets consist, directly or through interposed entities, of at least half real estate situated in one of the two States, with those shares deemed situated where the property sits. An American who holds the Nice apartment through a French property company or an American limited liability company is not outside Article 5: the treaty looks through the wrapper to the bricks. Business property of a permanent establishment and tangible movable property have their own situs articles in the convention, but for the family home the rule is one sentence long and admits no planning around it.
Where the deceased was domiciled in France, the convention gives France the wide base and the United States the credit obligation in mirror form. On the French side, Article 12 of the convention gives France the wide base: France taxes the whole succession, including property that is taxable in the United States under the convention, and then allows against that tax a deduction equal to the American tax paid on property taxable in the United States on the same occasion, capped at the fraction of French tax attributable to that property. On the American side, the same article provides that where each State taxes property that France may tax under its real-property, permanent-establishment, or tangible-property articles, the United States allows a credit equal to the French tax levied on that property, with the total of all American credits capped at the fraction of the United States tax relating to that property. The convention adds a special American credit where the deceased held American citizenship but is treated as domiciled in France, and a computed unified credit for the estate of a non-citizen domiciled in France that owns American-situs property. The French administration’s official commentary on the convention, including the effect of the December 2004 amending protocol, is published at BOFiP-Impôts INT-CVB-USA.
Translated into a filing sequence for the family of an American who dies owning a French house, the mechanics work as follows. First, the French declaration is filed and the French duties are paid within the six- or twelve-month deadline of article 641, because the French clock runs fastest and French late interest accrues regardless of what the American return will later show. Second, the American estate return reports the worldwide estate, including the French house, computes the tentative American tax, and claims the treaty credit for the French duties paid on the French-situs property, attaching the French notices and proof of payment. Because each credit is capped at the tax of the crediting State attributable to the same property, the family effectively pays, on the French house, the higher of the two national bills, not the sum. If French duties on the house exceed the American tax attributable to it, the excess French tax is simply unrelieved cost, not a refundable American credit; if the American tax is higher, the family pays France in full and the balance to the Internal Revenue Service. Currency conversion follows each administration’s own rules for the relevant date, so the euro-to-dollar rate used for the French payment receipt and the rate used on the American return can differ, and both figures should be kept with their supporting documents. Where the deceased owned American-situs assets as well, such as United States securities or real estate, the mirror French deduction for American tax paid operates in the French return, and the two files must use consistent valuations for the same assets to avoid one administration reopening the other’s numbers.
Three boundary situations deserve explicit mention because American families encounter them constantly. Gifts made before death are covered by the same convention, which applies to donations as well as successions, so an American parent who deeds the French house to a child during life faces French gift tax under the same situs rule of Article 5, with the same fifteen-year prior-gift aggregation of article 784 running inside the French computation. Property acquired during marriage raises the question of community property: the convention contains a specific article on community property and the marital deduction, amended by the 2004 protocol, whose application to Franco-American couples with property in both countries belongs in the notaire’s file from the start, since the characterization of the house as community or separate property changes each spouse’s taxable share. Finally, domicile mismatches, where France considers the deceased domiciled in France under article 4 B while the United States considers the same person domiciled in the United States, are resolved by the convention’s domicile article before any credit is computed; the family should not assume that winning domicile in one country eliminates tax in the other, because for the French house the situs rule taxes in France regardless of where domicile lands.
Conclusion
An American death with a French house produces two lawful tax bills and one treaty mechanism that stops them from stacking. France taxes the house in every case under article 750 ter, taxes everything where the deceased was a French tax domiciliary, and demands its return within six months of a death in France or one year otherwise. French rates, allowances, the spouse exemption, and the fifteen-year gift aggregation decide the French number, and a 600,000 euro apartment passing to two children costs each of them roughly 38,000 euros before fees. The United States taxes the citizen’s worldwide estate on its side, subject to its exemption for the year of death, and the 1978 convention assigns the French house to France under Article 5 while obliging the United States to credit the French tax against the American tax on the same property under Article 12, each credit capped at the tax attributable to that property. The family’s task is therefore sequential and documentary: establish habitual residence and applicable inheritance law without assuming the house decides the forum, disclose trusts and earlier gifts to the notaire, file and pay in France inside the article 641 deadline, and carry the French receipts into the American return to claim the treaty credit. Handled in that order, the two systems interlock instead of colliding, and the French house passes to the next generation taxed once, at the higher of the two national rates, rather than twice.