An American citizen buys a small stone house in the Dordogne, or an apartment in Paris, lives between two countries for twenty years, and then dies. The family, often sitting in California or New York, discovers that two tax systems claim a share of the same house. France taxes the building because it stands on French soil. The United States taxes it again because the person who owned it was American. Without a treaty, the same walls would be taxed twice. With the right filings, they are not. The instrument that prevents that outcome is the estate and gift tax convention signed by France and the United States on November 24, 1978, amended since, which divides the right to tax between the two countries and then forces each side to give credit for tax paid to the other. This article explains, in order, what France takes and when, what the United States takes afterward, and how heirs file on both sides without paying twice or missing a deadline.
Three ideas organize everything that follows. First, France always has the first word on real estate located in France, whatever the nationality of the owner and whatever a foreign court has decided. Second, the treaty assigns each category of asset to one country or the other and builds a credit mechanism so the same value is never taxed twice. Third, the paperwork has an order and a clock: the French succession is declared first through a French notaire, and the American credit is claimed afterward with proof that the French tax was paid. Readers who want background on how an American can organize the transmission of French assets in advance can also read our explanation of how Americans can choose the law that governs their French will, which covers the choice-of-law side of the same problem.
I. France taxes the French house first: what the heirs owe and when they must declare it
When an American dies owning a house or an apartment in France, the French tax administration does not ask whether the owner lived in France, whether the heirs live in France, or whether an American probate court has already distributed the estate. It asks one question: is the building located in France. If the answer is yes, French death duties apply to it, and a French declaration must be filed. That territorial reflex is written into the tax code, confirmed by the courts, and enforced through strict filing deadlines that many American families discover too late.
A. Why France always has the first word on a house located in France
The starting point is a French tax lawyer’s reflex that Americans often find surprising: French death duties follow the building, not the passport. Article 750 ter of the French General Tax Code draws the map. When the deceased had their tax domicile in France, it provides that “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit : 1° Les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France,” which means the whole worldwide estate falls into the French return, “lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B” (article 750 ter, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance). When the deceased did not have their tax domicile in France, which is the ordinary case of an American who lived in the United States, the same article keeps France’s hand on the French soil: “2° Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France,” remain subject to French death duties even though the owner lived abroad. Shares in a company that holds the house can be caught too, since the statute reaches property held indirectly. In plain terms, an American who never set foot in France after buying the house still leaves a taxable French succession limited to the French assets, while an American who had become a French tax resident leaves a worldwide French succession.
Whether the deceased counts as domiciled in France for tax purposes is itself governed by article 4 B of the same code, which treats as French tax residents, among others, “Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal” alongside people who work in France or keep the center of their economic interests there (article 4 B, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance). An American retiree settled full-time in Sarlat therefore faces a wider French return than an American who merely summers there, even though both owe French tax on the house itself. The treaty then refines these domestic answers, as explained in the second part, but it never removes France’s grip on the building.
The courts add a second lock. French judges consider themselves the natural judges of French real estate in an estate, regardless of where the rest of the succession is litigated. The First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation put it plainly in a cross-border succession case: “les tribunaux français sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession mobilière lorsque le défunt avait son domicile en France. Ils sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession immobilière pour les immeubles situés en France” (Cour de cassation, 1re civ., 14 April 2021, no. 19-24.773, on Légifrance). That passage concerned a claim to reduce an excessive gift of French property, but the principle travels: the house is litigated in France, under French rules, even when the deceased lived abroad and even when a foreign probate is running in parallel. American heirs should therefore expect two tracks, a French one for the house and an American one for the rest, rather than one proceeding that settles everything.
The practical consequence is a filing duty with a short clock. The heirs must sign and register a French succession declaration, normally prepared by a French notaire, who values the house, computes the duties, and files with the tax office. Article 641 of the General Tax Code states the deadlines without ambiguity: “Les délais pour l’enregistrement des déclarations que les héritiers, donataires ou légataires ont à souscrire des biens à eux échus ou transmis par décès sont : De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas” (article 641, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance). An American who dies in the United States therefore leaves heirs a one-year window, not six months, but the window still runs from the day of death, and a family that waits for the American probate to finish before calling the notaire can easily file late. The public service portal confirms that a declaration is the default step and describes who must file and who is excused in small estates (Droits de succession, déclaration, on service-public.fr).
One more French formality catches Americans off guard. The declaration must state whether earlier gifts were made, because France adds them back into the computation. Article 784 requires the parties to disclose “dans tout acte constatant une transmission entre vifs à titre gratuit et dans toute déclaration de succession, s’il existe ou non des donations antérieures consenties à un titre et sous une forme quelconque par le donateur ou le défunt aux donataires, héritiers ou légataires” (article 784, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance). A house given to a child five years before death, or cash wired from a French account, must therefore be mentioned; silence is not an option, and the treaty does not waive this domestic reporting duty.
B. How much France takes: allowances, progressive rates, debts, and the forced share
Once the house is in the French return, three questions decide the bill: what allowance each heir subtracts, what rate applies to the rest, and which debts come off the top. The answers favor close family, punish no one for being American, and treat mortgages on the house more generously than unsecured American debts.
Each child of the deceased subtracts a personal allowance of 100,000 euros on their share. Article 779 provides that “il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation” (article 779, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance). The surviving spouse is fully exempt under a separate rule, and more distant relatives receive smaller allowances, which is why the family tree matters as much as the house value. Crucially for this article’s readers, the treaty extends equal treatment: for French tax computed on a succession left by a person who was an American citizen or domiciled in the United States, the same allowances and credits apply as if that person had been domiciled in France, as article 12, paragraph 4 of the 1978 convention states (consolidated text of the November 24, 1978 France-United States convention, on impots.gouv.fr). An American heir is therefore not taxed as a stranger; the same 100,000-euro allowance per child applies.
Above the allowance, article 777 taxes the net share at progressive rates set by statutory tables: “Les droits de mutation à titre gratuit sont fixés aux taux indiqués dans les tableaux ci-après, pour la part nette revenant à chaque ayant droit” with the direct-line table starting at 5 percent on the first slice up to 8,072 euros and climbing through higher brackets as the share grows (article 777, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance). A Paris apartment worth 600,000 euros left to one child thus produces a bill far above the entry rate, because most of the value falls into the upper brackets. The notaire’s computation applies the allowance first, then runs the progressive table on the remainder, heir by heir.
Debts reduce the taxable base, but not all debts equally. Under article 9, paragraph 1 of the convention, debts that are deductible under a state’s domestic law reduce the gross value of the assets taxable in that state, apportioned by the ratio of those assets to the worldwide estate wherever located (same consolidated treaty text).. A mortgage secured on the French house is the textbook deductible debt; an American student loan or credit-card balance is apportioned across the worldwide estate instead, so only a fraction shields the French house. Families should assemble the loan statements early, because the notaire needs them to compute the net value, and American lenders are slower than French ones to produce payoff letters.
A will cannot simply route around these rules. French law reserves a slice of every estate for the children, called the réserve héréditaire, which article 912 defines as “la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent” (article 912, Code civil, on Légifrance). Article 913 then fixes the fractions: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre” (article 913, Code civil, on Légifrance). An American with two children who leaves the whole Dordogne house to a new partner has therefore given away more than the one-third the law lets them freely dispose of, and the children can sue to be paid the shortfall. The surviving spouse, meanwhile, holds a statutory option when children survive: “Si l’époux prédécédé laisse des enfants ou descendants, le conjoint survivant recueille, à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens lorsque tous les enfants sont issus des deux époux” with a quarter in ownership when not all children are common (article 757, Code civil, on Légifrance). An American widow can thus choose to live in the house for life through the usufruct, which often matters more than owning a quarter of it outright.
One warning belongs here for Americans who hold French property through an American revocable living trust, a very common estate-planning tool in the United States. France does not think in trust terms; it taxes the transfer of ownership, and it picks the moment of that transfer itself. In a 2020 case about an American resident who had placed assets in a revocable trust, the Commercial Chamber of the Cour de cassation held that “le fait générateur des droits de mutation à titre gratuit est constitué par le transfert de propriété, qui, s’agissant de biens placés dans un trust, s’opère par l’effet de la distribution de l’actif du trust au bénéficiaire final, au jour de sa clôture, laquelle peut être postérieure au décès du constituant” (Cour de cassation, com., 18 November 2020, no. 18-14.242, on Légifrance). The tax fell not at the settlor’s death but when the trust wound up and distributed to the final beneficiaries. An American trustee who distributes French-taxable assets years after the death should therefore expect the French clock to start at distribution, and should keep the trust deed, because the notaire and the tax office will ask for it.
II. The United States taxes second: what the treaty shields and how the credit wipes out the double charge
France having taken its share on the house, the Internal Revenue Service looks at the same death through American glasses. A United States citizen is taxable on the worldwide estate wherever the assets sit, and a domiciled resident can be too. The 1978 convention does not exempt the French house from American tax; it does something more useful. It confirms that France may tax the house, limits what each country may tax beyond real estate, and then obliges the second country to credit the tax paid to the first, within caps. The result, when the filings are done in the right order, is a single combined burden equal to the higher of the two national taxes, not the sum of both.
A. What the treaty lets each country tax, and what it reserves for one side only
The treaty’s architecture is simple once the vocabulary is translated. Real estate belongs to the country where it sits. Article 5, paragraph 1 gives real estate to the country where it stands: such property is taxable by a contracting state where it is located (consolidated treaty text). A house in France is therefore taxable in France, period, and the United States must accommodate that French tax through the credit rather than deny it. The definition is deliberately wide: it follows the meaning real property has under the law of the situs state, expressly includes accessories, usufruct, and rights to exploit natural resources, and, importantly for American buyers who hold through companies, it also catches shares or interests in a company or entity whose assets consist, directly or through intermediaries, at least 50 percent of real estate, treating those shares as situated where the buildings stand. An American who owns the Paris apartment through a single-asset company does not escape French tax by interposing the company.
Everything that is not real estate, business property, or tangible movable property falls under a different rule that protects Americans more strongly. Article 8 provides that such assets, from company shares and written or unwritten debts to other intangibles and cash, are taxable by a contracting state only if the deceased or donor held that state’s citizenship or was domiciled there when the death or gift occurred, and only if that state taxes them under its own law (same text).. A French bank account or stock portfolio left by an American who was neither French-domiciled nor French is therefore taxable only in the United States, not in France; France keeps the house, America keeps the portfolio, and neither taxes what the treaty assigns to the other. Business assets and tangible movables have their own situs rules in articles 6 and 7, which readers with a French business or valuable furniture should have checked asset by asset.
When both countries claim the same person as domiciled, article 4 breaks the tie with a cascade Americans should read before moving: permanent home first, then the country of closest personal ties, then habitual presence, then citizenship, then mutual agreement between the tax authorities. A special American-friendly correction follows for citizens: a person who held only American citizenship, who would otherwise count as domiciled in both states, is deemed domiciled only in the United States where that person manifestly intended to keep a domicile there and had spent fewer than five of the previous seven years domiciled in the other state, with a parallel rule protecting employees posted abroad and their spouses (same text). with a parallel rule protecting employees posted abroad and their spouses (same text). An American executive assigned to Paris for three years who dies there, manifestly intending to return to Texas, therefore keeps a single American domicile under the treaty, which narrows France’s reach to the French-situs assets rather than the worldwide estate.
On the American side of the computation, two treaty favors deserve attention because they are frequently missed. First, the estate of a person who died domiciled in France without American citizenship receives a pro-rata unified credit under article 12, paragraph 3, computed from the share of the gross estate situated in the United States and never below the flat credit granted to nonresident non-citizens, provided the information needed to verify it is supplied. Second, a surviving spouse can benefit from a treaty marital deduction for property that would have qualified had the spouse been American, if the executor elects it and irrevocably waives the domestic qualified-domestic-trust route, with the deduction capped at the applicable exclusion amount. Charitable gifts are covered too: a bequest to a qualifying nonprofit organized in one state is honored by the other state as if the charity had been created there, provided the charity holds tax-exempt status and works exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, literary, educational, or cultural purposes with substantial public support. And the treaty reassures everyone with a ceiling clause: it cannot increase the amount of tax either state levies under its own domestic law. The convention can only reduce or reallocate tax, never invent a heavier one.
B. Claiming the credit in the right order, within the five-year clock
The credit is where double taxation actually dies, and it works in both directions under article 12. Start with France. When the deceased was domiciled in France, France taxes the whole estate including assets taxable in America under the treaty, then grants against that tax a deduction equal to the American tax paid on the same occasion for the same assets, capped at the French-tax share attributable to those assets. Mirror-image relief runs the other way for the American return: When both states tax assets that France may tax under articles 5, 6, or 7, the United States grants a credit equal to the French tax on those assets, again capped at the American-tax share on the same property, and a broader credit applies when the deceased, an American citizen, counted as French-domiciled under article 4 (same consolidated text). again capped at the American-tax share on the same property, and a broader credit applies when the deceased, an American citizen, counted as French-domiciled under article 4 (same consolidated text). In the standard case, an American who lived in the United States and left a French house plus American assets, the sequence is therefore: pay France on the house, then subtract every dollar of that French tax, within the cap, from the American estate tax computed on the same house.
The paperwork follows the money. The French succession is settled first: the notaire values the property, applies the allowances, files the declaration within the six-month or one-year deadline of article 641, and pays the duties, producing the assessment notices that prove payment. Only then can the American side be closed cleanly, because the United States credits the French tax actually levied on the same assets. The executor files the federal estate return, reports the French house, computes the American tax, and claims the treaty credit with the French assessments attached; the Internal Revenue Service publishes guidance for estates with foreign connections, including a dedicated page for estate taxes affecting nonresidents and non-citizens (frequently asked questions on estate taxes for nonresidents, on irs.gov). Families should keep both files consistent, same valuation date logic, same ownership fractions, same debts, because a French assessment that describes a different property share than the American return invites questions on both sides of the Atlantic.
The deadline that kills the most credits is not the French declaration deadline but the treaty’s own clock for asking for treaty relief. Article 13, paragraph 1 requires every treaty-based claim for credit or refund to be filed before the longest of the listed deadlines: the domestic refund deadline, or a treaty floor of five years running from the death or from the gift (same consolidated text). An heir who pays the French duties, files the American return without the credit, and only hires a specialist six years later may find the treaty door closed even though each domestic return was timely. Diarize five years from death as the absolute backstop, and file the credit claim as soon as the French assessment exists rather than at the last minute.
Three practical pitfalls complete the picture. First, valuation mismatches: the French notaire values the house under French methods while the American return uses fair market value, and a gap between the two changes the capped credit; a single appraisal usable on both sides, dated correctly, prevents the dispute. Second, the trust trap described in the first part: an American living trust that still holds assets at distribution can trigger the French tax years after the death, which means the American credit computation must be revisited rather than treated as closed. Third, the convention has been amended since 1978, so advisors should work from the consolidated text rather than a 1978-only printout (consolidated text of the November 24, 1978 France-United States convention, on impots.gouv.fr).
Conclusion
An American who dies owning a house in France leaves a succession in two countries, but the two systems interlock instead of stacking. France taxes the building because it stands in France, under article 750 ter, through a notaire declaration due within six months of a death in France or one year otherwise, with a 100,000-euro allowance per child, progressive rates, deductible debts, and a forced share that limits what any will can redirect. The United States taxes the worldwide estate of its citizens but must give credit for the French tax on the house under article 12 of the 1978 convention, whose situs, domicile, debt, charity, marital, and credit rules decide precisely which country taxes what and how the second bill is reduced by the first. The families who pay twice are almost always the ones who file in the wrong order or file late: settle France first, keep the assessments, claim the American credit with proof of payment, and never let five years pass before asking for treaty relief. Done in that order, the French house costs its heirs one full tax, not two.