Picture this. Two sisters from Houston buy a two-bedroom apartment in the 11th arrondissement, fifty-fifty, to keep a foothold in Paris. Two college friends from Chicago do the same in Montmartre. An unmarried American couple, not ready for a pacte civil de solidarité and wary of the tontine clause, buys in the Marais with unequal shares because one of them put down most of the deposit. A year later, the arrangement frays. One co-owner stops paying the charges de copropriété, the quarterly building bills. Or one moves into the apartment full-time and changes the locks. Or one wants to sell and the other refuses to answer the notaire’s letters from across the Atlantic. Every one of these American buyers signed a French purchase deed, and that deed placed them inside a legal regime most of them never read: l’indivision, the French form of co-ownership. This article explains, in plain English, the default rules that already govern your Paris co-ownership, the written five-year contract that lets you organize the bills, the manager and the exit, and the court doors that open when a co-owner blocks everything. All citations are to the statutes and decisions the French courts actually apply, quoted word for word.
I. The Default Rules That Already Govern Your Paris Co-Ownership
Under French law, co-ownership without a contract is not a blank page. The Civil Code supplies a full set of default rules at articles 815 and following, and they apply to your Paris apartment from the day the deed is signed, whether you come from Texas or the 11th arrondissement. Many American buyers assume the arrangement works like a tenancy in common back home, where each owner holds a separate transferable share and can do largely as they please. The French version is more collective and more supervised: the majority runs daily life, nobody can be locked in forever, the occupant pays for private use, and each owner’s creditors can force the whole thing to be divided.
A. How American Co-Owners Can Leave, and How Two-Thirds Run Daily Life
The starting point is the most liberating rule in French co-ownership law. Article 815 of the Civil Code provides: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” In English: no one may be forced to remain in co-ownership, and partition may always be demanded, unless a court or a contract has suspended it. For an American co-owner, this is the emergency exit that always exists in the background. If your sister or friend refuses to cooperate, you are never legally trapped; the only question is the procedure and the price of leaving.
Daily management, meanwhile, belongs to the qualified majority. Article 815-3 of the Civil Code provides: “Le ou les indivisaires titulaires d’au moins deux tiers des droits indivis peuvent, à cette majorité : 1° Effectuer les actes d’administration relatifs aux biens indivis”, including giving a general management mandate, selling movables to pay the co-ownership’s debts, and signing or renewing ordinary leases, with a duty to inform the other co-owners. The same article draws the hard line American co-owners must understand: “Toutefois, le consentement de tous les indivisaires est requis pour effectuer tout acte qui ne ressortit pas à l’exploitation normale des biens indivis et pour effectuer tout acte de disposition autre que ceux visés au 3°.” In English: acts outside normal operation, and acts disposing of the property, require everyone’s consent. So the two-thirds majority can hire the plumber, renew the tenant’s lease and pay the building bills, but it cannot sell the apartment or give it away without the missing co-owner’s agreement.
When unanimity is impossible and the majority wants out, the statute provides a court-supervised sale. Article 815-5-1 of the Civil Code provides: “l’aliénation d’un bien indivis peut être autorisée par le tribunal judiciaire, à la demande de l’un ou des indivisaires titulaires d’au moins deux tiers des droits indivis”, following a procedure run through the notaire. The co-owners holding two-thirds declare their intention to sell before a notaire, the notaire serves that intention on the others within one month, and if one of them objects or stays silent for three months after service, the notaire records it in official minutes. Then, the statute continues: “le tribunal judiciaire peut autoriser l’aliénation du bien indivis si celle-ci ne porte pas une atteinte excessive aux droits des autres indivisaires. Cette aliénation s’effectue par licitation.” In English: the court may authorize the sale if it does not excessively harm the other co-owners’ rights, and the sale takes place by licitation, the court-supervised auction between the co-owners or on the open market. For Americans, three features matter. First, this door opens at two-thirds, not unanimity: a 50/50 pair cannot use it against each other, but a 70/30 split, or two siblings against one, can. Second, the judge protects the minority through the excessive-harm test, so the procedure is a sale at a fair process, not a confiscation. Third, everything turns on proper service of the notaire’s notice, which is exactly where Americans living in the United States get into trouble, as the next section shows.
A practical American warning follows from these texts. If you hold 50 percent and your co-owner holds 50 percent, neither of you can force a court sale under article 815-5-1, and neither of you can sell the whole apartment alone. That symmetry is the single most common reason American co-ownerships freeze: each side waits for the other to give in. The way out of the freeze is either a negotiated buyout, a sale of your own share with the other co-owner’s preemption right, or a full judicial partition, each examined below. Readers facing a sibling who refuses every proposal will find the sibling-specific procedures, including forced sale and division of the price, in our guide for Americans exiting indivision when a sibling blocks the sale, and the deadlock variant for owners acting from the United States in our guide on breaking an indivision deadlock from America.
B. Who Pays the Bills, Who Lives There, and What the Occupant Owes
Money is where American co-ownerships most often break, and the default rules are precise. Any co-owner may use the apartment within its intended purpose, compatibly with the others’ rights, and a judge can provisionally settle disagreements. But private, exclusive use is never free. Article 815-9 of the Civil Code provides: “L’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité.” In English: the co-owner who uses or enjoys the property privately owes compensation to the others, unless the contract says otherwise. The sister who moves into the Paris apartment full-time while her brother pays half the mortgage from Houston owes him an occupation indemnity, month after month, and our detailed explanation of how that indemnity is computed and recovered is set out in our guide on occupation indemnity when a sibling lives free in the inherited Paris apartment.
Conservation expenses follow a different logic, and the Cour de cassation spelled it out in a decision every American co-owner should know. On 10 February 2021, the First Civil Chamber ruled in case number 19-20.957 on a villa held in indivision where one brother had paid the taxe d’habitation and occupied the house. The Court restated the rule of article 815-13, paragraph 1, under which a co-owner who improves the property is credited in equity according to the added value at partition or sale, and necessary conservation expenses paid from personal funds must likewise be credited even where they added no value. Applying that rule to the housing tax at stake, the Court quashed the Paris judgment: because the tax payment had preserved the building, the charges had to be shared in proportion to each co-owner’s share, with the harm of exclusive occupation compensated separately through the article 815-9 occupation indemnity (Cass. 1re civ., 10 February 2021, no. 19-20.957, §§ 10-12). The lesson for Americans is double. Keep every receipt for taxes, insurance and urgent repairs, because conservation spending is credited back to you at the final accounting. And never confuse that credit with free occupation: living there alone still generates an indemnity debt in the other direction. The full decision is published by the Cour de cassation under appeal number 19-20.957, First Civil Chamber, 10 February 2021, and it is worth showing to any co-owner who believes paying the bills buys the right to live there free.
Creditors add a final layer Americans rarely expect. Article 815-17 of the Civil Code provides: “Les créanciers personnels d’un indivisaire ne peuvent saisir sa part dans les biens indivis, meubles ou immeubles. Ils ont toutefois la faculté de provoquer le partage au nom de leur débiteur ou d’intervenir dans le partage provoqué par lui.” In English: a co-owner’s personal creditors cannot seize that person’s share directly, but they may force partition in the debtor’s place or join a partition already started. The other co-owners can stop that forced partition by paying the debt for the debtor, recovering the amount from the co-ownership assets. For American buyers, the consequence is concrete: your co-owner’s unpaid debts in France can drag your Paris apartment toward a court-ordered partition, and your defense is to pay and be reimbursed, not to claim the creditor has no rights. Before buying together, ask the hard questions about each other’s debts, and put the answers into the written convention described next.
II. The Written Convention That Locks In the Rules, and the Exits When It Fails
The default rules keep the building standing, but they do not tell two Americans who pays the electricity, who holds the keys, who manages the tenant, or how a share is sold. That is the job of the convention d’indivision, the co-ownership agreement provided by articles 1873-1 and following of the Civil Code. Signed before or after the purchase, ideally drawn up with the notaire who handles the deed, it replaces improvisation with written rules for up to five years at a time. It is the single most cost-effective document American co-buyers can sign, and the sections below show what it must contain and what happens when someone breaks it.
A. What the Five-Year Convention Must Contain to Be Valid
The convention is open to every form of co-ownership. Article 1873-1 of the Civil Code provides: “Ceux qui ont des droits à exercer sur des biens indivis, à titre de propriétaires, de nus-propriétaires ou d’usufruitiers peuvent passer des conventions relatives à l’exercice de ces droits.” In English: owners, bare owners and usufruct holders alike may sign agreements governing how they exercise their rights over co-owned property. Two Americans buying a Paris apartment together, whatever their shares, are therefore entitled to organize their co-ownership by contract from day one.
Form is strict, and the penalty is nullity. Article 1873-2 of the Civil Code provides: “A peine de nullité, la convention doit être établie par un écrit comportant la désignation des biens indivis et l’indication des quotes-parts appartenant à chaque indivisaire.” In English: on pain of nullity, the agreement must be in writing, identify the property, and state each person’s share. The same article adds that if the property includes buildings, the formalities of land registration apply, which means the convention should pass through the service de publicité foncière so that it binds future buyers of a share, not just the original signatories. An oral understanding over coffee in the Marais, however detailed, is worth nothing against these requirements. Put the apartment’s cadastral references, the exact shares, and every financial rule in a written, registered deed.
Duration is capped, and the cap shapes strategy. Article 1873-3 of the Civil Code provides: “La convention peut être conclue pour une durée déterminée qui ne saurait être supérieure à cinq ans.” In English: a fixed-term convention may not exceed five years. The article continues: “Le partage ne peut être provoqué avant le terme convenu qu’autant qu’il y en a de justes motifs.” In English: partition cannot be forced before the agreed end date except for legitimate reasons. The convention may also be open-ended, in which case partition can be demanded at any time as long as it is not in bad faith or at an improper moment, and a fixed-term convention can renew by tacit agreement. For American co-buyers, the five-year lock-in is the point: during the term, neither side can force a sale on a whim, which protects the partner who wants stability, while the legitimate-reasons exception keeps a door open against genuine misconduct such as persistent non-payment. Calendar the expiry date, because at the end of a fixed term without renewal, the co-ownership falls back under the default articles 815 and following, and the protection disappears.
Management should name a captain. Article 1873-5 of the Civil Code provides: “Les coïndivisaires peuvent nommer un ou plusieurs gérants, choisis ou non parmi eux.” In English: the co-owners may appoint one or more managers, chosen among themselves or outside. The article lets unanimous agreement set how the manager is appointed and removed, and adds the safety valve American co-owners need: “Dans tous les cas, la révocation peut être prononcée par le tribunal à la demande d’un indivisaire lorsque le gérant, par ses fautes de gestion, met en péril les intérêts de l’indivision.” In English: in every case, the court may remove the manager at any co-owner’s request when management faults endanger the co-ownership’s interests. Name the manager in the convention, define the powers precisely, require annual accounts with receipts, and remember that a manager who stops accounting can be removed by a judge. For co-owners living an ocean apart, appointing the Paris-based partner, or a professional, as gérant with a duty to report turns chaos into routine.
A well-drafted convention for two Americans typically contains six clauses. First, exact shares and proof of funding, so that the partner who paid more of the deposit can prove it years later and avoid any later claim that the imbalance was a gift. Second, a monthly budget rule: who pays the mortgage, the building charges, the taxes and the insurance, into which joint French account, by which date, with statements shared quarterly. Third, occupation rules: who may live there, for how long, and at what indemnity, echoing article 815-9. Fourth, rental rules: who decides on letting, how rents are split, and who files what, knowing that each co-owner is taxed on rental income according to personal tax status. Fifth, a sale procedure that goes beyond the statute: notice periods longer than the legal minimum, valuation by an agreed expert, and an internal preemption step before any outside buyer appears. Sixth, duration, renewal and the legitimate-reasons clause that lets a paying co-owner force the issue against one who stopped paying. None of this requires exotic drafting; it requires writing down, while everyone still agrees, what everyone will wish had been written once they disagree.
B. How to Sell Your Share, Buy Out the Other Half, or Ask the Court to Sell Everything
When cooperation ends, French law offers a ladder of exits, and each rung has its own formalities. The gentlest rung is selling your own share to an outsider, but the other co-owners hold a preemption right. Article 815-14 of the Civil Code requires the seller to notify the other co-owners, by formal extrajudicial act, of the price, the conditions and the identity of the proposed buyer. Then: “Tout indivisaire peut, dans le délai d’un mois qui suit cette notification, faire connaître au cédant, par acte extrajudiciaire, qu’il exerce un droit de préemption aux prix et conditions qui lui ont été notifiés.” In English: within one month after that notice, any co-owner may tell the seller, again by formal act, that the co-owner is preempting at the notified price and conditions. The preempting co-owner then has a two-month period from sending the reply to complete the sale, and a preemption declaration left unperformed after a formal demand lapses by operation of law. For Americans, the message is operational: find a real buyer at a real price, serve a proper notice through a commissaire de justice, the French enforcement officer, and the one-month clock does the work a shouting match never will. If several co-owners preempt, they share the portion in proportion to their existing shares unless the convention says otherwise.
The middle rung is the buyout, where one co-owner takes the other’s share and ends the co-ownership. The buyout’s legal effect is powerful because of the declaratory effect of partition. Article 883 of the Civil Code provides: “Chaque cohéritier est censé avoir succédé seul et immédiatement à tous les effets compris dans son lot, ou à lui échus sur licitation, et n’avoir jamais eu la propriété des autres effets de la succession.” In English: each sharer is deemed to have succeeded alone and immediately to everything in the share, or obtained through auction, and never to have owned the rest. Applied to a buyout, the buyer is treated as having always owned the whole apartment, which simplifies title and mortgage refinancing afterward. Price the buyout on a current valuation, settle the occupation indemnity and the expense accounts first, and have the notaire record every adjustment in the deed, because the final accounting between co-owners is where buyouts most often collapse.
The top rung is the court-ordered sale of the whole apartment, through the article 815-5-1 procedure or a full judicial partition ending in licitation. Here Americans face a procedural trap the Cour de cassation illustrated in the decision cited above. In case 19-20.957, one brother lived in Brazil and argued that the notaire’s notice of intent to sell had never been validly served on him abroad, so the whole auction procedure was void. The Cour de cassation first restated the protective principle that a cassation time limit does not run when service of the challenged decision was irregular under the service rules of articles 654 and following of the Code of Civil Procedure (Cass. 1re civ., 10 February 2021, no. 19-20.957, §§ 4-7). The principle generalizes: every step of a forced sale depends on service that actually reaches the person abroad, under the applicable international service rules, and defective service unwinds the procedure. An American co-owner who moved back to the United States without leaving a French address for service, or who ignores registered letters from a Paris notaire, does not make the procedure disappear; the co-owner makes it longer, more expensive, and more likely to end in surprise. Keep a valid service address in France, open the notaire’s letters, and answer within the stated time limits. Acting from America without flying over is entirely possible through a notarized power of attorney with apostille, as explained in our guide on signing the French deed from America, but the power of attorney must be prepared before the deadline, not after it expires.
A final American-specific checkpoint concerns money flows. When one co-owner has paid everything from a United States account for years, the paying side should keep bank statements proving each transfer, because at partition the accounts distinguish conservation spending, which is credited, from occupation, which generates an indemnity debt, exactly as the 2021 decision requires. When rental income was collected, each co-owner is taxed on a personal share of it, and American owners remain taxable in the United States on worldwide income, with the France-United States tax treaties organizing relief against double taxation. Coordinate the French sale or buyout deed with the American tax reporting for the same year, so the French price, the French deductions and the American figures tell one consistent story. And when the surviving spouse’s rights, rather than a living co-owner’s, are at stake, the applicable regime is different: see our guide on what the American surviving spouse gets and how to stay in the home.
Conclusion
Two Americans owning a Paris apartment together are never without rules and never without exits. The default regime already decides the essentials: no one can be forced to stay, two-thirds of the shares run daily management, exclusive occupation generates an indemnity, conservation spending is credited back in proportion to the shares, and a co-owner’s personal creditors can force partition rather than seize a share. The written convention improves on every one of these points for up to five years at a time: exact shares in a registered writing, a monthly payment discipline, a named manager removable by the court for misconduct, occupation and rental rules, and a sale procedure with real deadlines. And when agreement fails entirely, the ladder runs from selling a share with preemption, to buying out the other half with declaratory effect, to the court-authorized auction, with every step turning on service that genuinely reaches the person abroad. Audit which default rules govern you today, sign the convention while you still agree, keep the receipts for every euro spent on the apartment, and treat the notaire’s letters as the deadlines they are.