Kohen Avocats — Criminal defence
Procedural irregularities lawyer in Paris: having acts annulled
Police custody (garde à vue), searches, acts of a judicial investigation: the firm reviews the proceedings for procedural irregularities and checks the time limits and the conditions for an application to annul.
An upcoming hearing or a recent notification? Send us the date and the documents you have so that the deadlines can be checked.
Procedural nullities · Paris
Have your case file reviewed
Send your summons and the official records you have to our criminal defence firm in Paris, stating the stage of the case and the next deadline.
Case file
acts, rights
and deadlines
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16th
How to review and raise procedural nullities
Criminal defence · Paris 16th
Having the proceedings reviewed by a criminal defence lawyer
- Paris Bar
- Procedural nullities
- Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France)
- Case file analysis
A late notification, a disputed search or a formality of the judicial investigation that was not observed calls for a precise review. The lawyer measures each act against its legal framework, checks who is entitled to challenge it and identifies the harm done to the interests of the person concerned. The distinction between an irregularity and an annulment rests in particular on Articles 171 and 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure (Code de procédure pénale).
Kohen Avocats reviews police investigation and judicial investigation files, prepares applications and raises pleas of procedural nullity (nullités de procédure) before the criminal courts of Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France). The first task is to rebuild the chronology and check the deadlines. An application to the investigating chamber (chambre de l'instruction) and a plea before the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel) follow different rules (Article 173 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). You can send your summons and the documents you have, or call the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Official profile in the French National Bar Council (CNB) directory of lawyersOffice at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Examine the acts
Official records (procès-verbaux), notifications, authorisations, interviews: a chronological reading of the file.
Check the time limits
Dates of placement under formal investigation (mise en examen), examinations, notice of the end of the investigation and hearing: drawing up the relevant timetable.
Define the application
Identify the acts challenged, the right protected, the prejudice (grief) and the scope of the annulment sought.
Irregularity, standing and prejudice
A procedural irregularity is not always enough to have an act annulled
Article 171 covers a breach of an essential formality (formalité substantielle) that harms the interests of the party concerned. Article 802 also imposes this condition for forms prescribed on pain of nullity (Article 171 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
The act
Which record or decision should be challenged?
The right
What safeguard does the formality protect?
The prejudice
What harm results from the irregularity?
The time limit
At what stage is the application still admissible?
Admissibility
Distinguishing interest from standing
Apart from public-policy nullities (nullités d'ordre public), the investigating chamber examines in turn the interest in obtaining annulment, the standing to seek it and the prejudice. Standing depends on the right or interest that the formality protects: it does not follow merely from a person's name appearing in the file (Cass. crim., 7 September 2021, No. 21-80.642, § 13 to 16).
Prejudice
Linking the harm to the irregularity
Being prosecuted on the basis of a piece of evidence does not, in itself, establish the required prejudice. You must explain what the breach of the rule itself caused. For certain failures, case law accepts that prejudice necessarily follows, in particular an unjustified delay in informing the public prosecutor (procureur de la République) during police custody (Article 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Cass. crim., 6 March 2024, No. 22-80.895). Public-policy nullities follow a separate regime; they must not be treated as covering every procedural error (Cass. crim., 7 September 2021, No. 21-80.642).
“The existence of prejudice is established where the irregularity itself has caused harm to the applicant, which cannot result solely from the applicant being implicated by the impugned act.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 7 September 2021, No. 21-80.642, § 16
The firm separates four questions when examining the file: the irregularity, the person entitled to challenge it, the harm alleged and the admissibility of the application. A favourable answer on one point does not remove the need to examine the others.
Police custody and searches
Which acts should be checked for procedural defects?
The framework of the investigation and the entries in the file determine the applicable rules. A search during a preliminary investigation (enquête préliminaire) is not assessed in the same way as a search during a flagrante delicto investigation (enquête de flagrance) (Article 76 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 56 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Police custody
Rights and supervision by the prosecutor
The public prosecutor must be informed from the start of police custody. The person must be informed of their rights immediately, in a language they understand (Article 63 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 63-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The review sets the arrest, the placement in custody, the notification of rights and the notice to the prosecution service side by side. In its judgment of 26 February 2025, the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) censured delays in notifying rights and informing the prosecutor that no insurmountable circumstance justified; the judgment does not set a tolerated number of minutes (Cass. crim., 26 February 2025, No. 24-82.146).
“In so deciding, when nothing in the proceedings establishes an insurmountable circumstance justifying the decision to delay notification of rights by forty-two minutes, and notification of the public prosecutor by forty-seven minutes, the court of appeal disregarded the meaning and scope of the above-mentioned provisions.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 26 February 2025, No. 24-82.146, § 11
Requests for a lawyer or a doctor, the steps taken and any decisions to derogate must also be examined. When the person asks for a lawyer's assistance during interviews, they cannot be questioned about the facts without the lawyer, unless they expressly waive this right or a statutory derogation applies, including a deferral of the lawyer's presence and an immediate interview authorised by the prosecutor (Article 63-3 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 63-3-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 63-4-2 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 63-4-2-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Searches
Identifying the framework and the authorisation
In a preliminary investigation, consent must be express and handwritten by the person concerned; if they cannot write, the official record must say so and record their consent. The liberty and custody judge (JLD) may authorise the search without consent in the cases set out in Article 76, in particular for an investigation into a serious crime (crime) or an offence (délit) punishable by at least three years' imprisonment where the needs of the investigation so require, or to search for certain assets liable to confiscation. The judge's decision must be in writing, give reasons and specify the offence and the address (Article 76 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). In a flagrante delicto investigation, the absence of consent does not, on its own, make the search void (Article 56 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
The rules on presence, representation and signature must also be checked, as well as the start time: under the ordinary rules, a search may not begin before six o'clock in the morning or after nine o'clock in the evening, subject to the exceptions provided by law (Article 57 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 59 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Judicial police officer (OPJ) supervision
An irregularity that must be linked to prejudice
A judicial police agent may carry out a search during a preliminary investigation under the supervision of a judicial police officer (OPJ). That supervision must be apparent from the file. The Court of Cassation nevertheless dismissed a challenge where the person relied only on the prosecution brought against them and did not dispute the presence of the item found: the irregularity in the supervision was not enough to establish their prejudice (Cass. crim., 7 December 2021, No. 20-82.733, § 8 to 14, Article 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The Court states: “The existence of the prejudice required by this provision is established where the irregularity itself has caused the applicant harm, which cannot result solely from the applicant being implicated by the impugned act” (our translation) (same judgment).
As regards notice to the prosecutor, the Court reiterates that “any delay in carrying out this obligation, not justified by insurmountable circumstances, necessarily causes prejudice to the interests of that person.” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 6 March 2024, No. 22-80.895, § 7). The times and the explanations recorded in the file must be read together.
Application to the investigating chamber
During a judicial investigation, act in the proper form and on time
The investigating judge, the public prosecutor, the parties and the assisted witness (témoin assisté) may apply to the investigating chamber for annulment. The procedure differs depending on who makes the application (Article 170 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 173 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Article 173 · form
A reasoned application, declared at the registry
The party or the assisted witness submits a reasoned application, sends a copy to the investigating judge and makes a declaration at the chamber's registry (greffe). The copy and the declaration are required on pain of inadmissibility. The provision allows a registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt where the applicant or their lawyer does not reside within the court's area, and a declaration to the head of the prison for a detained person under formal investigation (Article 173 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Article 173-1 · deadlines
Six months, with precise starting points
For a person placed under formal investigation (mis en examen), grounds concerning acts carried out before the first appearance, or that appearance itself, must be raised within six months of notification of the formal investigation. The provision also covers acts preceding later examinations and acts that have been notified. The assisted witness and the civil party (partie civile) are covered from their hearings. An exception applies where it was impossible to know of the ground (Article 173-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Article 175 · end of the investigation
Do not wait for the six months to run out
1 month
if the person under formal investigation is detained
3 months
in other cases
From the date on which the notice of the end of the investigation (avis de fin d'information) is sent, applications for annulment must be filed within the one-month or three-month period laid down in Article 175, subject to any existing bars to admissibility. This time limit also applies to applications by the assisted witness. It does not revive a ground that is already time-barred (Article 175 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Raising every ground
Raise the known grounds in the proceedings referred to the chamber
When proceedings are referred to the chamber under Article 173, all grounds of nullity concerning the proceedings referred to it must be put before it. A ground left out can no longer be relied on, unless it was impossible to know of it. This rule concerns applications to the investigating chamber; it is not a general time limit applicable to every criminal hearing (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Documents added to the file late may reveal a ground that could not be known until then. The judgment of 11 March 2025 reiterates that “such inadmissibility cannot be held against that person where they could not have known of those grounds.” (our translation) It annulled an order declaring the application inadmissible in that situation: it neither annulled the challenged prosecutor's submission (réquisitoire) nor created a new automatic six-month period (Cass. crim., 11 March 2025, No. 24-85.220).
Criminal court hearing and appeal
Raise the plea before any defence on the merits
As at 13 October 2026, Article 385 requires pleas of nullity (exceptions de nullité) to be raised before any defence on the merits. The way the case was brought before the court determines which grounds it can examine (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Without a prior judicial investigation
Challenging the earlier proceedings
Before the defence on the merits
- Identify the acts being challenged and present the challenge before arguing the merits of the charge.
- This rule also applies to immediate appearance trials, known as comparution immédiate (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
- Consent to be tried immediately is obtained in the lawyer's presence; a refusal leads to an adjournment (Article 397 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 397-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
After a judicial investigation
Check which nullity pleas are barred and the exceptions
Committal changes the review
- Once final, the committal order (ordonnance de renvoi) bars challenges based on procedural defects, except those the parties could not have known (Article 179 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
- The court retains the options provided by Article 385, in particular for grounds that the party could not have known before the investigation was closed.
- Failure to comply with the conditions of Article 175 also makes it possible, in the case provided for by Article 385, to raise nullities before the court (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
On appeal
Renewing a plea already raised
On an appeal by the prosecution (ministère public), a plea of nullity upheld by the criminal court must be raised again by the defendant before any defence on the merits, even if they are only the respondent (intimé). In the case decided on 15 April 2026, the defendant was absent and not represented: the court of appeal could not uphold the annulment of its own motion (Cass. crim., 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977).
Plea raised for the first time
An appeal does not automatically reopen grounds left out
A plea not raised before the defence on the merits at first instance cannot, in principle, be kept back for the appeal. An exception exists where the defendant, tried in absentia (par défaut), put forward no defence at first instance: they may raise nullities for the first time on appeal, before any defence on the merits (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 512 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Cass. crim., 20 December 2023, No. 21-87.233).
“It follows from the first two of these provisions that a defendant who, having been summoned through the public prosecutor's office and tried in absentia, did not defend themselves at first instance may raise pleas based on the nullity of the proceedings for the first time on appeal.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 20 December 2023, No. 21-87.233, § 12
“such pleas cannot be raised by the criminal courts of their own motion.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977, § 5
This rule concerns the criminal courts. The investigating chamber, by contrast, has the power to review the proceedings of its own motion, subject to the statutory admissibility conditions (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 206 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Scope of the application and preparing the file
Which acts are removed, and which documents should you gather?
The nullity of one act does not automatically entail the nullity of the whole proceedings. The investigating chamber determines the scope of the annulment, which may be total or partial (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 206 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Subsequent acts
Establishing the link with the irregular act
The application must explain which acts stem from the defective acts. A mere sequence of dates is not enough to justify annulling everything that follows. In its judgment of 14 November 2019, the Court of Cassation censured a refusal to extend the annulment to acts that stemmed from the annulled police custody (Cass. crim., 14 November 2019, No. 19-83.285). The firm examines subsequent interviews, seizures and investigative steps separately.
“It follows from the last two provisions that when the investigating chamber annuls an act of the proceedings, it must also annul all acts of the subsequent proceedings that stem from the defective acts.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 14 November 2019, No. 19-83.285, § 10
Removal from the file
Excluding annulled acts and struck-out passages
Annulled acts are removed from the investigation file and filed at the registry of the court of appeal. Partly annulled acts are struck out (cancellés), after a certified true copy has been made and kept at the registry. No information may be drawn from them against the parties, on pain of disciplinary proceedings for lawyers and members of the judiciary (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Read
Cross-check the official records against the documents they refer to.
Date
Build a chronology and note each relevant notification.
Characterise
Identify the right protected and the prejudice to be argued.
Define the scope
Specify the acts and passages whose annulment is sought.
- Summons, notice of hearing and case reference.
- Available official records, with times and signatures.
- Notices of formal investigation, examinations and acts notified.
- Notice of the end of the investigation and proof of the date it was sent.
- Search authorisations, consent and decisions of the JLD.
- Earlier applications, written submissions, decisions and any notice of appeal.
- Your own chronology and documents explaining the harm alleged.
During a judicial investigation, access to the file and the issuing of copies follow the arrangements in Article 114 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure. The list above prepares the work; it does not replace consulting the case file.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions on procedural irregularities
What are the most common procedural irregularities in police custody?
The points to examine are the notification of rights, informing the public prosecutor, the conditions for any extension and the exercise of the rights to a lawyer or a doctor. This list describes useful checks; it is not a statistical ranking. The prosecutor must be informed from the start of the measure and the rights must be notified immediately, in a language the person understands (Article 63 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 63-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
A delay not justified by an insurmountable circumstance can be grounds for annulment. The judgment of 26 February 2025 held that late notifications were unlawful in the circumstances of that case; it does not set any tolerance threshold (Cass. crim., 26 February 2025, No. 24-82.146). The times and explanations in the file must be compared, then the rules on prejudice and the scope of the application examined. The annulment of police custody does not, by itself, mean that the whole case disappears (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
Is a search carried out without my consent void?
Not necessarily: you first need to identify the legal framework of the operation. In a preliminary investigation, Article 76 requires express consent, handwritten by the person. If they cannot write, the official record must say so and record their consent. The liberty and custody judge (JLD) may also authorise a search without consent, by a written and reasoned decision, in the cases and under the conditions laid down in that provision (Article 76 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
In a flagrante delicto investigation, the absence of consent is not enough to make the search irregular (Article 56 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The conditions of presence or representation, the signatures and the time of the search, among other things, still need to be checked (Article 57 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 59 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The challenge must then take account of the right protected, your standing and the prejudice. The mere fact that an item found is used to prosecute you does not necessarily establish that prejudice (Article 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Cass. crim., 7 December 2021, No. 20-82.733).
What is the “prejudice” (grief) required by law?
Prejudice (grief) is the harm that the irregularity has done to the interests of the person concerned. Article 802 lays down this condition for breaches of forms prescribed on pain of nullity and of essential formalities (Article 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The harm must therefore be linked to the rule that was breached, rather than simply noting that the act contains unfavourable evidence.
The Court of Cassation distinguishes the interest in obtaining annulment, the standing to rely on the formality and the prejudice resulting from its breach (Cass. crim., 7 September 2021, No. 21-80.642). Some irregularities necessarily cause prejudice, such as an unjustified delay in informing the prosecutor during police custody (Cass. crim., 6 March 2024, No. 22-80.895). Public-policy nullities must also be distinguished. The lawyer identifies the applicable regime before preparing, where necessary, an argument supported by the documents.
What is the time limit for raising a nullity during a judicial investigation?
For a person placed under formal investigation, Article 173-1 sets six months from notification of the formal investigation for acts preceding the first appearance and for that appearance itself. It also covers acts preceding each later examination and acts that have been notified. The assisted witness and the civil party are covered from their hearings. A ground that could not have been known benefits from an exception (Article 173-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
This is not the only time limit to check. The notice of the end of the investigation opens a period for filing an application of one month if the person under formal investigation is detained, or three months in other cases, without reviving grounds that are already inadmissible (Article 175 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). An application to the chamber also requires the known grounds concerning the proceedings referred to it to be raised (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The timetable must therefore be built from all the notifications.
How do you apply to the investigating chamber?
A party or the assisted witness applies to it by a reasoned application. A copy must be sent to the investigating judge, on pain of inadmissibility. The application must also be the subject of a declaration at the registry of the investigating chamber, recorded, dated and signed under the conditions set by the provision (Article 173 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). A simple letter to the investigating judge does not replace these formalities.
Article 173 provides specific arrangements where the applicant or their lawyer does not reside within the court's area, and for a detained person under formal investigation. In principle it excludes this route for acts that can be appealed, subject to the exception it mentions. The acts challenged must be identified, the grounds set out and the time limits checked. Known grounds concerning the proceedings referred to the chamber must be put before it, except those that could not have been known (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
What happens to annulled acts?
In the investigation file, annulled acts or documents are removed and filed at the registry of the court of appeal. If the annulment is partial, the passages concerned are struck out, after a certified true copy has been made and kept at the registry. Article 174 prohibits drawing any information from them against the parties and provides for disciplinary proceedings against lawyers and members of the judiciary who breach this prohibition (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
The decision must also set the scope of the annulment. It may concern the act alone or extend to later acts, depending on how far they depend on the defective act (Article 206 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Cass. crim., 14 November 2019, No. 19-83.285). The operative part and the reasons of the decision must therefore be read: the annulment of one document does not mean that the whole investigation can be treated as wiped out.
Can the court annul the proceedings of its own motion?
Pleas of nullity concerning the earlier proceedings covered by Article 385 cannot be raised by the criminal courts of their own motion. The plea must be raised before any defence on the merits (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The Court of Cassation restated this rule on 15 April 2026, in a case where the court of appeal had upheld an annulment although the defendant, absent and not represented, had not renewed their plea (Cass. crim., 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977).
It would, however, be wrong to extend this answer to all criminal courts. The investigating chamber reviews the regularity of the proceedings referred to it and may raise a nullity of its own motion, subject to Articles 173-1, 174 and 175 (Article 206 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The distinction matters when preparing the defence: before the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel), you should not wait for the judge to formulate your plea.
If I obtain an annulment at first instance, does it stand on appeal?
Not if the prosecution appeals and the annulment decision is called into question again. The defendant must raise the plea again before the court of appeal, before any defence on the merits, even if they are only the respondent. That is the outcome of the judgment of 15 April 2026: the court of appeal could not, of its own motion, uphold the annulment obtained before the criminal court when the defendant did not appear and was not represented (Cass. crim., 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977).
The order of argument therefore remains essential, in accordance with Article 385, which applies on appeal through Article 512 (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 512 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Send the lawyer the judgment, the notice of appeal and the written submissions already filed. Preparation means restating the relevant grounds and their legal basis, rather than assuming that the benefit of the judgment will be kept without taking any step.
Can a nullity be raised for the first time on appeal?
In principle, a plea concerning the earlier proceedings must be raised before any defence on the merits before the criminal court. An appeal does not allow a ground that should have been raised at that stage to be kept back (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 512 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). This rule means the proceedings must be examined before the first hearing at which the merits will be argued.
There is, however, a verified exception: a defendant tried in absentia who put forward no defence at first instance may raise pleas based on the nullity of the earlier proceedings for the first time on appeal, before any defence on the merits (Cass. crim., 20 December 2023, No. 21-87.233). The nature of the judgment, the defendant's appearance and earlier written submissions must therefore be checked. Mere personal absence is not enough to conclude that this exception applies, particularly if a defence has already been presented.
Does the nullity of police custody bring down the whole case?
No, not automatically. Article 174 provides that the investigating chamber decides whether the annulment should be limited to all or part of the defective acts or extend to the subsequent proceedings (Article 174 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The scope therefore depends on the acts annulled and on their link with the other documents in the file.
The Court of Cassation requires subsequent acts that are annulled to stem from the defective acts: the mere fact that they came later is not enough (Cass. crim., 14 November 2019, No. 19-83.285). An interview, a seizure or an investigative step must be examined in its context, by asking whether it has an independent basis. The application specifies the documents concerned and explains the links relied on. The lawyer then checks what remains in the proceedings; no outcome on guilt can be inferred from the mere finding of an irregularity.
Is a minor procedural defect enough to annul an act?
The answer depends on the formality and its effects, rather than on whether the error looks minor or serious. Article 802 in principle requires harm to the interests of the party concerned, even where the form is prescribed on pain of nullity (Article 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). An error spotted in an official record is therefore not enough, on its own, to establish all the conditions for annulment.
A distinction must be drawn between public-policy nullities, breaches that necessarily cause prejudice and those for which harm must be shown. For the latter, the fact that the act implicates the person does not, by itself, amount to that harm (Cass. crim., 7 September 2021, No. 21-80.642). The review covers the purpose of the rule breached, the conditions in which the act was carried out and the practical consequences of the irregularity.
How much does a review of the proceedings cost?
The firm defines the assignment with you after identifying the documents available, the stage of the proceedings and the deadline. Reading the file, a written analysis and preparing an application do not involve the same work. What is requested must be specified: a review only, drafting a ground, or assistance when the court examines it.
Fees are set by agreement with the client. The written fee agreement specifies, in particular, the foreseeable work, the amount or the method for determining it and the expected expenses; the law provides for exceptions, including urgency, force majeure and certain work carried out under legal aid (Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971). Send the summons and the case reference so that the firm can define the scope of its work. No court outcome can be inferred from this review.
What is an “essential” formality (formalité substantielle)?
Article 171 provides for nullity where the breach of an essential formality of criminal procedure has harmed the interests of the party concerned (Article 171 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). To identify such a formality, you need to look at the purpose of the rule, rather than merely at how the document is presented. Article 802 distinguishes it from the forms that the law expressly prescribes on pain of nullity (Article 802 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
One example is the signature of the search record: the Court of Cassation notes that it serves to authenticate the actual presence of the items found and seized. It infers that any party may rely on a breach of this formality, without reserving that possibility to the holder of a right over the premises alone (Cass. crim., 7 September 2021, No. 21-80.642). This does not mean that every missing signature automatically leads to annulment: the other conditions must still be examined.
Can a nullity be raised in an immediate appearance trial?
Yes. An immediate appearance trial (comparution immédiate) does not remove the possibility of challenging the regularity of the proceedings. Pleas must be raised before any defence on the merits, under Article 385 (Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The file must therefore be read early enough to identify the acts challenged, the right breached and the prejudice to be argued.
The defendant can be tried the same day only with their consent, obtained in the presence of their lawyer (Article 397 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). If they do not consent to immediate trial, or if the case is not ready to be tried, the court adjourns it under the conditions of Article 397-1 (Article 397-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). An adjournment can be used to prepare the defence, but the pleas must be organised without starting with argument on the merits. No greater effectiveness of nullity pleas in this procedure can be promised.
Why have the proceedings reviewed by a criminal defence lawyer?
The review is not just a matter of spotting a missing entry. The applicable rule must be identified, the standing to rely on its breach checked, the prejudice assessed and the procedural route chosen. An application during a judicial investigation follows the formalities of Article 173; a plea before the criminal court must precede the defence on the merits (Article 173 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 385 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure).
The firm cross-checks the official records, authorisations and notifications, then sets out the deadlines and the acts whose annulment would be sought. Access to the investigation file follows the arrangements in Article 114 (Article 114 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). The analysis must also point out the limits of the ground and the documents that might remain. You thus receive an opinion on the possible challenge and the useful steps, without an identified irregularity being confused with an annulment already obtained.
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
Articles of the French Code of Criminal Procedure and Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971, checked in their version applicable on 13 October 2026.
See the Code of Criminal Procedure on Légifrance. The decisions cited can be accessed through the links in the text above.
Further reading
Law applicable as at 13 October 2026. Time limits must be checked against the dates of the acts and notifications in each case.
Have your criminal proceedings reviewed
Send the documents and decisions you have already received. The firm checks the deadlines, identifies the acts that can be challenged and prepares the next steps of the defence with you.