KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Bath and Body Works Advent Calendar: How to Check an Advertised Holiday Value in California

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Bath and Body Works Advent Calendar: How to Check an Advertised Holiday Value in California

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

According to the announcement published by Bath & Body Works, Inc. on November 3, 2026, the company is introducing a limited-edition holiday calendar containing twelve products, seven of which the announcement describes as exclusive to the calendar. The same announcement states a price of $50 and a value of more than $115, with a launch stated for November 16, 2026, in stores and online. Those figures pose a question that arises for almost every seasonal bundle: when a box that is not sold the rest of the year carries a stated total value well above its asking price, what does California law require that higher number to represent, and what can a shopper verify before paying? The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about Bath & Body Works’ situation. In California, the starting point is a statutory definition that measures advertised worth or value by prevailing market price rather than by any number a seller selects.

I. A bundle carries a value well above its price: what must that higher number represent in California?

A. California defines advertised value as prevailing market price, and federal guides ask whether a comparison price is bona fide

California law does not leave the word value in an advertisement to the advertiser’s own arithmetic. California Business and Professions Code section 17501 provides, for the article of the code that contains it, that “the worth or value of any thing advertised is the prevailing market price, wholesale if the offer is at wholesale, retail if the offer is at retail, at the time of publication of such advertisement in the locality wherein the advertisement is published.” Three elements in that sentence do practical work for a shopper. The comparison is to a market price, not to a wish or a future asking price. It is measured at the time the advertisement is published, so a price from a different season is a fact to be examined rather than assumed. And it is measured in the locality where the advertisement is published, so the first comparison to run is what the same thing actually costs where the offer reaches you, on the date you see it. For a bundle, that means asking what each line of the seller’s arithmetic prices: the item in the box, in the size and quantity in the box, offered in that place at that time.

The same California section supplies the related rule for a price described as a former price. Section 17501 provides that no price shall be advertised as a former price of an advertised thing unless the alleged former price was the prevailing market price, as the section defines it, within three months next immediately preceding the publication of the advertisement, or unless the date when the alleged former price did prevail is clearly, exactly and conspicuously stated in the advertisement. A shopper checking a striking-through price or a was price therefore has two clean questions. Was that higher price the prevailing market price within the three months before the advertisement appeared? If the seller relies on an earlier date instead, does the advertisement itself state that date clearly, exactly and conspicuously? A value total built from individual items raises the first kind of question item by item, even when the advertisement never uses the word former. Save the advertisement as published, with its date, because the statute measures both value and former price against the moment of publication.

California’s general false advertising provision sits behind the definition. California Business and Professions Code section 17500 makes it unlawful, in the circumstances it describes and including statements disseminated over the Internet, to make or disseminate a statement concerning property or a connected matter of fact that is untrue or misleading where that is known, or by the exercise of reasonable care should be known, to be untrue or misleading. The section also addresses a statement made as part of a plan or scheme with the intent not to sell the advertised property at the price stated, or as advertised. Read together, sections 17501 and 17500 separate two inquiries that shoppers often merge. Section 17501 tells you what value and former price mean when a California court applies that article. Section 17500 asks whether the particular statement, on its own facts, was untrue or misleading under the knowledge standard the statute states. A shopper’s screenshots should therefore capture both the number and the words around it, because value, worth, formerly and save do not all make the same representation, and the qualifying words printed with the number are part of the statement being assessed.

Federal guidance asks a closely related question in different words, and it should be identified for what it is: the Federal Trade Commission’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, not a California statute. Under the federal guide at 16 C.F.R. section 233.1, a reduction from the advertiser’s own former price rests on a legitimate basis for comparison if the former price is the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time. The same guide warns that where an artificial, inflated price was established to enable a subsequent offer of a large reduction, the bargain being advertised is a false one, and it adds that a former price is not necessarily fictitious merely because no sales at that price were made, provided the product was openly and actively offered at that price for a reasonably substantial period in the recent, regular course of business, honestly and in good faith. The guide is agency guidance about deceptive pricing at the federal level. Its usefulness to a shopper is the checklist it implies: was the higher price openly offered, recently, regularly and genuinely, or does it appear only as the denominator in a percentage calculation?

For a value total that aggregates other sellers’ prices or a retail value rather than the seller’s own former price, the companion federal guide is the closer text. At 16 C.F.R. section 233.2, the guide states that when goods are offered at prices lower than those charged by others for the same merchandise in the advertiser’s trade area, the advertised higher price must be based upon fact, and not be fictitious or misleading, and that the advertiser should be reasonably certain the higher price does not appreciably exceed the price at which substantial sales of the article are being made in the area. Its own illustration of the misleading version is a retailer who advertises a retail value drawn from a few small outlets when the larger outlets in and around the main shopping areas charge the seller’s own price or close to it. Translated to a seasonal box sold online and in stores, the practical check is to price the contents the way a person in the trade area could actually buy them on that date: same items, same sizes, same quantities, at prices really being charged then, rather than the highest price that can be found somewhere for something similar.

Exclusive contents deserve a separate line in that arithmetic, for a reason that follows from the definitions rather than from any suspicion about a particular seller. If an item exists only inside a bundle, in that size, there may be no separate prevailing market price for that item in that size on the publication date, and any value assigned to it has to rest on some stated basis instead: the price of a different size, the price of a comparable item, or the seller’s own estimate. California’s definition measures the worth or value of the thing advertised by prevailing market price, and the federal comparable-value guide requires the higher comparison price to be based on fact. Neither text, read alone, tells a shopper the single correct number for an exclusive miniature. What they do tell the shopper is which question to put to the seller and to keep in writing: for each item counted in the total, what price was used, for what size, charged where, and on what date? An answer that prices the contents as they are, in the locality and at the time of the offer, is verifiable against the market that day. An answer that cannot say what was priced leaves the total as an assertion, and the cases in the next section show why California courts have treated the buyer’s reliance on that assertion as a legally significant fact rather than a detail.

B. Receiving the product you wanted at the price charged does not, without more, defeat a California fictitious-price claim

The first defense a shopper is likely to hear is intuitive: you received the box, it contains what was listed, and you paid the price on the button, so nothing was lost even if the comparison value was wrong. California and federal appellate courts applying California law have rejected that argument as a complete answer at the pleading stage, on facts closely comparable to a holiday value claim. In Hinojos v. Kohl’s Corporation, 718 F.3d 1098 (9th Cir. 2013), the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided on May 21, 2013, an appeal by a shopper who alleged that he bought apparel and luggage he would not have purchased had he not been misled by advertisements stating that the merchandise was marked down from a fictitious original or regular price. The court quoted section 17501, held that a consumer has lost money or property, within the California standing requirements it discussed, where false advertisements induced him to buy a product he would not have purchased or to spend more than he otherwise would have spent, and reversed the dismissal of the unfair competition and false advertising claims and, for nearly identical reasons, of the Consumers Legal Remedies Act claims. For a holiday bundle buyer, the check is therefore not only whether the box arrived, but whether the stated value is what induced the purchase at that price.

That reasoning remains part of how federal courts discuss California consumer injury. In Lytle v. Nutramax Laboratories, Inc., No. 22-55744 (9th Cir. Apr. 22, 2024), the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided on April 22, 2024, a class-certification appeal concerning marketing statements for a pet health product, and it affirmed the district court’s grant of class certification on the reasoning before it. Lytle cited Hinojos in discussing paid-more and would-not-have-purchased theories of consumer injury under California law. The citation observed in that later opinion does not decide any bundle dispute, and it is not a complete statement of how every later court has treated the earlier case. It does show a recent appellate court using the same distinction that matters here: a buyer’s economic complaint can be framed either as a purchase that would not have happened at all without the statement, or as a price higher than the buyer would otherwise have paid, and the papers a buyer saves should make clear which of those, if either, describes the actual purchase.

A California appellate court reached the same pleading-stage result for online fictitious former prices, and it stated the seller’s argument and its answer in terms that map directly onto an internet holiday order. In Hansen v. Newegg.com Ams., Inc., 25 Cal. App. 5th 714, the California Court of Appeal decided on July 31, 2018, an appeal in which a shopper alleged that an electronics retailer’s website used fictitious former price information that misled customers into believing they were receiving merchandise at a discounted price, that he relied on that information in making two website purchases, and that he would not have made the purchases had he known the former price information was false. The retailer argued on demurrer that the shopper had received the benefit of his bargain because he obtained the products he wanted at the prices offered, and the trial court sustained the demurrer without leave to amend. The Court of Appeal reversed, reasoning through the material-misrepresentation analysis it drew from California Supreme Court authority and holding, on the allegations before it, that the standing requirements were satisfied. For an online holiday order, Hansen is why you should save the product page that showed the reference value before you pay, not only the receipt that shows the price charged.

Later California decisions continue to place that case inside the basic description of the unfair competition statute, even when they rule against the plaintiffs in front of them. In Suchard v. Sonoma Academy, No. A169841 (Cal. Ct. App. Mar. 21, 2025), the Court of Appeal of the State of California decided on March 21, 2025, an appeal by tuition payers whose demurrer-stage dismissal it affirmed in the published portion of the opinion because the students had received the education paid for, unaffected by the conduct alleged against others. Suchard cited Hansen in describing California’s unfair competition definition before holding that the tuition plaintiffs before it lacked the required loss of money or property. Read together, the two outcomes mark the boundary a shopper should keep in view. Alleging and documenting that a price statement caused this purchase, or caused more to be spent on it, is the kind of economic injury the fictitious-price cases treated as sufficient at the stages they addressed. A purchase in which the buyer received exactly the benefit paid for and cannot connect the statement to the decision to spend sits on the other side of the line the tuition case applied. Neither decision is a finding about any seller who was not a party to it.

Three procedural limits should be kept attached to those holdings so they are not read for more than they decided. First, the fictitious-price opinions discussed allegations at dismissal or demurrer; a court reversing a dismissal on standing grounds has not found that any price was in fact fictitious, and it has not awarded a refund. Second, the Hansen opinion itself noted that it addressed standing because the reasonable-consumer merits argument the seller had raised in the trial court was not before it on appeal; whether a particular advertisement would mislead a reasonable consumer remained a separate question. Third, the definition those cases enforced is California law. California Business and Professions Code section 17200 defines unfair competition, for the chapter that contains it, to “mean and include any unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue or misleading advertising and any act prohibited by” the false advertising chapter beginning at section 17500. A shopper outside California cannot assume that another state’s statute defines value, former price or consumer standing in the same words, and a shopper inside California still has to connect the definition, the statement actually published, and the purchase actually made. The next part turns to the two places where that connection is usually won or lost on paper: the limits printed next to the headline number, and the total that is finally charged.

II. The headline number checks out or it does not: what should a California shopper verify and preserve?

A. Undisclosed limits beside a discount, and mandatory charges added to a displayed price, are separate California problems

A value claim can be accurate as arithmetic and still present a different legal question if the conditions attached to the offer reach the shopper only at the moment of payment. California’s Consumers Legal Remedies Act lists the practices it makes unlawful in a consumer transaction at California Civil Code section 1770(a). Two of the listed practices speak directly to holiday pricing. Paragraph (9) makes it unlawful to advertise goods or services “with intent not to sell them as advertised.” Paragraph (13) makes it unlawful to make “false or misleading statements of fact concerning reasons for, existence of, or amounts of, price reductions.” A shopper comparing a bundle page with a checkout page should therefore record not only the two prices, but the promise each page actually made: whether the discount or value was stated for the whole box, for selected contents, for a limited quantity, for members only, or for a stated period, and whether any of those limits appeared with the number or only after the item was in the cart. The distinction between a limit disclosed with the claim and a limit learned at the register is the distinction one California appellate case was built on.

In Veera v. Banana Republic, LLC, 6 Cal. App. 5th 907, the California Court of Appeal decided on December 15, 2016, an appeal by shoppers who alleged that store window signs advertising a 40 percent off sale were false or misleading because they did not disclose that the discount applied only to certain items. According to the evidence the opinion summarizes, the shoppers selected items for purchase at the advertised discount and were told as the items were being rung up, for the first time, that the advertised discount did not apply to their chosen merchandise, and some completed purchases anyway. The trial court had granted summary judgment to the retailer on standing grounds. The Court of Appeal reversed, concluding that on the evidence presented the shoppers had raised a triable issue whether they lost money or property sufficient to qualify as economic injury and whether that injury was caused by the false advertising that was the basis of the claim, and its disposition reversed the judgment in favor of the retailer. For a shopper who reaches a register or a checkout page, Veera is why the exact limits printed next to a percentage or a value claim matter as much as the headline number.

A recent federal decision applying California law shows both the continued use of that case and the limit of stretching it to a different pricing theory. In Heilman v. Abercrombie & Fitch Co., No. 26-cv-02224-EMC (N.D. Cal. Jul. 29, 2026), the United States District Court Northern District of California decided on July 29, 2026, a motion to dismiss a putative class action alleging that a mandatory shipping and handling fee for certain online purchases was not included in the advertised price displayed to consumers. Heilman cited Veera in calling section 1770(a)(9) a bait-and-switch pricing prohibition, then dismissed the claim before it because no independent bait-and-switch theory was alleged apart from the mandatory-fee count. The order granted the motion to dismiss with leave to amend, which is a pleading-stage disposition and not a final finding that any pricing practice was lawful or unlawful. Its practical lesson for a bundle buyer is about separating theories before writing to anyone: an undisclosed limit on which items a discount covers, an asserted value that does not match prevailing market price, and a mandatory charge added to a displayed price are three different statements, each with its own statutory text, and a complaint or a refund request that merges them into one general charge of deception is weaker than one that identifies which statement is being challenged and on which page it appeared.

The displayed-price theory in that federal order comes from a third California paragraph that a holiday shopper should read before checkout, because it governs the total rather than the comparison. Section 1770(a)(29)(A) makes it unlawful to advertise, display or offer a price for a good or service that does not include all mandatory fees or charges other than two categories the paragraph itself excepts: taxes or fees imposed by a government on the transaction, and postage or carriage charges that will be reasonably and actually incurred to ship the physical good to the consumer. The Heilman order quoted that structure, including the two exceptions, and then addressed the parties’ dispute over the shipping and handling fee actually alleged there. For a seasonal box bought online, the check that follows from the statute’s own words is narrow and doable at the cart stage. Does the price first displayed include every charge the buyer cannot avoid paying to complete this purchase, apart from government taxes or fees and apart from postage or carriage within the paragraph’s exception? Is a charge presented as shipping in fact the carriage cost for this parcel, or does the cart add a further mandatory amount under another label after the displayed price has done its work? Save the cart page that shows each line, because a later argument about what was mandatory, what was a government charge and what was carriage cannot be reconstructed from the final total alone.

Put the three California theories in the order a shopper encounters them and the record to save becomes short. At the advertisement, capture the value or former-price claim with its date, its stated basis if one is given, and every limit printed with it; sections 17501, 17500 and 1770(a)(13) are the texts that frame that statement in California, and the federal guides at sections 233.1 and 233.2 frame the comparable federal questions. At selection, capture whether the items you chose are the items the claim covers, in the sizes the arithmetic assumes; that is the junction at which the shoppers in the window-sign case said the limit first reached them, and section 1770(a)(9) is the text the later federal order discussed in that connection. At payment, capture the full charge breakdown before you authorize it; that is where section 1770(a)(29)(A) and its two stated exceptions apply, and where a mandatory amount that was absent from the displayed price can still be refused rather than disputed after the fact. A shopper who has those three dated captures can describe a problem precisely. A shopper who has only a delivery box and a memory of a percentage usually cannot, however genuine the surprise was.

B. Run the arithmetic the statutes prescribe, then use the correction step California wrote into the Consumers Legal Remedies Act

The first verification can be completed on the day the offer appears, and it follows the definition rather than any general impression of a bargain. List every item counted in the stated total, with the size, weight or count actually in the box. Beside each item, write the price at which that item, in that size, could be bought on that date in the place where the advertisement reached you, starting with the seller’s own price for the identical item and then, where the seller does not sell it separately, the basis the seller states for the figure it used. Keep exclusive items on a separate line and mark them as exclusive, because the prevailing-market-price question for an item sold only inside the bundle cannot be answered by silently substituting the price of a larger size sold on its own. Where the claim is framed as a reduction from a former price, add the section 17501 date check: the higher price was the prevailing market price within the three months immediately before publication, or the advertisement clearly, exactly and conspicuously states the date when it did prevail. Where the claim is framed as a comparison with prices elsewhere, add the federal guide’s trade-area check at section 233.2: the higher price is one at which substantial sales of the same merchandise are being made in the area, not an isolated higher price with no real significance to local buyers.

The result of that exercise usually falls into one of three categories, and each calls for a different next step. If the itemized prices, in the sizes in the box and at the publication date, add up to the stated value on a basis the seller can identify, the comparison has survived the check the definition prescribes, and the remaining question is only whether the box is worth its asking price to you. If the total can be reached only by pricing a smaller item as though it were a larger one, by using a price from outside the three-month former-price window without stating its date, or by using a comparison price at which no substantial sales are being made in the trade area, you have identified the specific line of arithmetic to put to the seller, in the conditional terms the sources support: such a statement could be treated as a false or misleading statement of fact concerning the existence or amount of a price reduction under the California texts discussed above, and only a court can decide whether it was one on the full evidence. If the seller will not state the basis at all, you have still learned something decision-useful before paying, which is that the higher number cannot be verified against the market the statute points to, and the asking price should be judged without it.

Preserve the purchase record as though the reliance question in the appellate cases will one day be asked about this order, because that is the form in which it arises. The decisions that reversed dismissals did so for shoppers who alleged, in specific terms, that the price statement induced a purchase that would not otherwise have been made or caused more to be spent. A record that supports or undermines that connection is mundane: the advertisement and product page as they appeared before payment, with the date visible; the contents and sizes as listed that day; any per-item prices shown that day; the cart and the full charge breakdown; the confirmation and any later message changing a price, a contents list or a condition; and a contemporaneous note, written before any dispute, of whether the stated value is why this box was chosen over buying the items separately or not buying at all. Do not reconstruct the page from a later version of the site and do not describe a value as fictitious in correspondence as though that were already established. In the cases above, fictitious was the allegation the courts allowed to proceed at the stages they addressed, not a fact the appellate courts found.

If the arithmetic does not survive the check and the purchase has already been made, California wrote a correction step into one of the statutes involved, and its text should be followed for the claim it governs rather than paraphrased into a general waiting rule for every dispute. Under California Civil Code section 1782(a), thirty days or more prior to the commencement of an action for damages under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act title, the consumer shall notify the person alleged to have committed the practices declared unlawful by section 1770 of the particular alleged violations of section 1770, and demand that the person correct, repair, replace or otherwise rectify the goods or services alleged to be in violation. The same subdivision requires that the notice be in writing and be sent by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, to the place where the transaction occurred or to the person’s principal place of business within California. Section 1782(b) then provides, except as provided in subdivision (c), that no action for damages may be maintained under section 1780 if an appropriate correction, repair, replacement or other remedy is given, or agreed to be given within a reasonable time, to the consumer within thirty days after receipt of the notice. Section 1782(d) provides that an action for injunctive relief brought under the specific provisions of section 1770 may be commenced without compliance with subdivision (a), and it states the separate timing rule for later amending such a complaint to include a request for damages. Those sentences, and only those sentences, are the source for the timing in this paragraph; the article states no limitations period, accrual rule or tolling rule for any of the California claims discussed, because none of the texts read for it states one.

That correction notice is most useful when it is as specific as the arithmetic that produced it. Identify the transaction by date and amount, the exact statement challenged and the page or sign on which it appeared, the paragraph of section 1770 alleged to be violated, and the correction demanded, whether that is a refund of a stated amount, correction of the value statement, or another remedy the section’s words cover. Attach the itemized calculation showing the prevailing prices you found for the contents in their actual sizes on the publication date, so the seller can answer line by line rather than dispute your conclusion. Keep the mailed notice, the certified or registered mail receipt and the return receipt together, because section 1782(b) measures the correction period it describes from receipt of the notice. If the seller gives or agrees to give an appropriate correction within that framework, the statute states the consequence for a later damages action under section 1780, subject to subdivision (c). If it does not, the notice record is also the cleanest summary a court, an agency complaint handler or the seller’s own reviewer could ask for: statement, market check, purchase, demand, response or silence, each with its date.

Two cautions close the method. First, do not convert a federal guide into a California element or a California definition into a nationwide rule. Sections 233.1 and 233.2 are federal guides against deceptive pricing, useful here because they articulate, in operational terms, when a former-price or comparable-value comparison rests on a bona fide basis, and the California courts in the decisions above were applying California statutes to California transactions. A shopper in another state should read that state’s own deceptive practices statute for its definition of value, its standing requirement and any pre-suit notice it imposes, instead of assuming the California texts travel with a shipment. Second, do not let the size of a stated savings percentage substitute for the size of the loss being claimed. The appellate decisions treated the induced purchase, or the additional amount spent because of the statement, as the economic injury to be alleged and documented. For a holiday bundle, that means the practical amount in dispute is ordinarily measured by this purchase, at this price, against what the verified market arithmetic shows, and not by the most dramatic way of restating the advertisement’s own headline.

Conclusion

A seasonal value claim can be checked before it has to be believed. In California, section 17501 measures advertised worth or value by prevailing market price at the time and in the locality of publication, and it allows a former price only where that price prevailed within the immediately preceding three months or the advertisement clearly, exactly and conspicuously states the date when it did. The federal deceptive-pricing guides ask whether a former or comparable price was bona fide and based on fact in the trade area. The California fictitious-price decisions then explain why receiving the goods at the price charged does not end the inquiry where the shopper documents that the statement induced the purchase or a higher spend, while the window-sign and mandatory-fee decisions show why undisclosed limits and added charges must be identified as the distinct statements they are. Itemize the contents in their actual sizes, price them on the publication date, save the advertisement, the selection page and the full charge breakdown, and, for a Consumers Legal Remedies Act damages claim in California, use the written correction notice section 1782 prescribes. The headline number either survives that arithmetic or it does not, and the arithmetic is the part a shopper controls.

📄 Official circular