KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Insurance fraud: can you go to jail in the United States and what should you check before charges are filed?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Insurance fraud: can you go to jail in the United States and what should you check before charges are filed?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

In early November 2026, South Carolina investigators announced a seventh charge in an ongoing multi-county insurance fraud investigation, and American searches for “insurance fraud” climbed with it. The questions typed next to that query are blunt: how much jail time does insurance fraud carry, what counts as a crime rather than a paperwork mistake, and what should a person check before charges are filed. This article answers those questions for an American reader under federal law and the law of South Carolina, the state where the current cases are being charged.

The short answer is that insurance fraud can absolutely lead to prison. At the federal level, a false claim that travels by mail or wire exposes the sender to up to 20 years in prison per count under the mail and wire fraud statutes, and false health-care claims carry up to 10 years per count, more if a patient is hurt or killed. South Carolina grades the offense by the dollar amount involved, from a 30-day misdemeanor for very small first offenses up to a 10-year felony, plus mandatory restitution to the victim. Three recent court decisions show how judges draw the line: a 2025 United States Supreme Court decision confirming that fraud does not require the insurer to lose money, a February 2026 federal appeals decision affirming a 27-month sentence for more than a million dollars in false health-insurance bills, and a June 2026 federal appeals decision affirming the conviction of a former police chief who staged the theft of his own vehicle. The sections below explain the statutes, the holdings, and the practical checks that matter before a file ever reaches a prosecutor.

I. Can an insurance claim really send you to prison in the United States?

Yes. American law treats a deliberately false insurance claim as fraud, not as a billing dispute, once prosecutors can prove a scheme, a lie capable of influencing the insurer, and the required mental state. Both the federal government and each state can punish the same conduct, and the two systems often cooperate: local investigators build the file, and either a district attorney or a United States Attorney decides where to charge. Understanding which statute applies is the first step, because the maximum punishment, the elements, and the forum all depend on it.

A. What the federal statutes actually punish

The workhorse of federal fraud prosecution is the mail fraud statute, 18 U.S.C. section 1341. It punishes whoever, “having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud,” uses the mail or a private interstate carrier to carry it out. The punishment is severe: the offender “shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both.” Rising to a fine of up to $1,000,000 and up to 30 years when the fraud relates to a presidentially declared disaster or affects a financial institution. For insurance purposes, the key point is that the mailing does not need to contain the lie itself; premium notices, claim forms, reimbursement checks, and denial letters routinely travel by mail, and any of them can supply the federal element.

The companion provision is the wire fraud statute, 18 U.S.C. section 1343, which covers anyone who “transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire, radio, or television” any writing, signal, or sound to execute the scheme. The penalties mirror the mail statute: up to 20 years per count, or up to 30 years and a $1,000,000 fine where a disaster benefit or a financial institution is involved. Because almost every modern insurance claim moves through online portals, electronic funds transfers, or interstate phone calls, the wire statute reaches conduct that never touches a mailbox. In United States v. Filline, No. 25-50049 (5th Cir. June 1, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed a conviction for conspiracy to commit wire fraud where a former police chief arranged for his damaged vehicle to be destroyed, “falsely reporting it stolen, and pocketing the insurance proceeds.” The decision shows the practical pattern: the staged event plus the claim check’s interstate movement equals a federal felony, and the opinion closes with the holding “We AFFIRM Filline’s conviction.”

A third federal law speaks directly to the insurance business. 18 U.S.C. section 1033, titled Crimes by or affecting persons engaged in the business of insurance whose activities affect interstate commerce, punishes anyone in that business who makes a false filing meant to influence regulators, including anyone who “willfully and materially overvalues any land, property or security” with up to 10 years in prison, or up to 15 years where the falsehood jeopardized an insurer’s soundness and helped push it into conservation, rehabilitation, or liquidation. This provision polices the industry side of the market, while policyholder fraud is usually charged under the mail, wire, or health-care statutes.

Health-care claims have their own statute. 18 U.S.C. section 1347 provides that “Whoever knowingly and willfully executes, or attempts to execute, a scheme or artifice” to defraud any health-care benefit program, or to obtain its money or property by false pretenses in connection with health-care services, “shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 10 years, or both.” The maximum rises to 20 years where the violation results in serious bodily injury and to any term of years or life where it results in death. Notably, subsection (b) adds that a person “need not have actual knowledge” of the section itself, which means a defendant cannot escape by claiming never to have heard of the statute; the government must still prove the defendant acted knowingly and willfully in submitting the false claim itself. In United States v. Yoon, No. 24-1520 (1st Cir. Feb. 20, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit applied exactly this law where a licensed physical therapist had “submitted more than a million dollars in false health insurance claims” to private insurers for services never rendered, billing for sessions supposedly provided while he or the patient was out of town and creating treatment notes under another provider’s name. The jury convicted him on two counts of health-care fraud, and the district court imposed twenty-seven months’ imprisonment: “The district court sentenced Yoon to twenty-seven months’ imprisonment.” The appeals court left both the convictions and the sentence in place, stating “For the foregoing reasons, we affirm Yoon’s conviction and sentence.”

State law adds a second layer that is often the one actually charged. In South Carolina, section 38-55-540 of the South Carolina Code of Laws makes it a crime for a person to knowingly make a false statement or misrepresentation, or to assist, abet, solicit, or conspire with another to do so. The punishment climbs with the dollar amount of the economic advantage obtained: a first offense under $1,000 is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of $100 to $500 or up to 30 days in jail; $1,000 to $10,000 is a misdemeanor carrying $2,000 to $10,000 in fines or up to three years in prison; $10,000 to $50,000 is a felony carrying $10,000 to $50,000 or up to five years; and $50,000 or more is a felony carrying $20,000 to $100,000 or up to ten years. Any second or subsequent violation is a felony punishable by up to ten years regardless of amount. The statute adds that a convicted person “must be ordered by the court to make full restitution to a victim” plus any unpaid tax difference. The South Carolina Department of Insurance, the agency that investigates these cases, states plainly that “In South Carolina, insurance fraud is a felony” and that “Insurance fraud is not a victimless crime,” noting that the average adult resident pays about $1,184 a year in extra premiums to cover fraud costs. That page is agency guidance describing the state’s enforcement posture, not the statute itself, but it confirms where South Carolina investigators stand.

B. What judges require before a lie becomes a crime

Not every inaccurate claim is a crime, and three decisions explain where courts draw the line. The foundation is Neder v. United States, 527 U.S. 1 (1999), decided June 10, 1999, in which the Supreme Court of the United States held that “materiality is an element of the federal mail fraud, wire fraud, and bank fraud statutes.” In practical terms, the government must prove the false statement had a natural tendency to influence, or was capable of influencing, the decision of the insurer or other victim; a trivial inaccuracy on a form that could not have affected payment does not satisfy the statute. That holding has governed every federal fraud prosecution for more than twenty-five years, and it remains the first question a defense lawyer tests: was the lie the kind of statement that could actually move money. Decided in 1999, this opinion states the historic foundation of the materiality element rather than its latest formulation; the Supreme Court restated the same principle in a May 2025 decision discussed below.

On May 22, 2025, the Supreme Court of the United States revisited the boundaries of federal fraud in Kousisis v. United States, No. 23-909 (May 22, 2025). The defendants had won public painting contracts by falsely claiming a disadvantaged business would supply the paint, then performed the work themselves while the supposed supplier acted as a mere pass-through. They argued no fraud occurred because the transportation agency received the full economic benefit of its bargain. The Court rejected that defense and upheld the wire-fraud convictions, explaining that the fraudulent-inducement theory stands even where the victim suffers no net economic loss. The opinion states the governing principle directly: materiality of falsehood is an element of, and thus a limit on, the federal fraud statutes (citing Neder v. United States, 527 U.S. 1, at 25). For insurance, the application is immediate and was confirmed by the Court’s citation of Neder: an insured who secures payment or coverage through a materially false statement commits fraud even if the insurer later argues it would have paid anyway, or even if the money is eventually returned. Getting the benefit of the bargain after lying to get it is no defense.

The two 2026 federal appeals decisions apply these rules to fact patterns close to the reader’s situation. In Yoon, the First Circuit, on February 20, 2026, rejected the argument that the false bills were merely negligent work by an overworked and disorganized therapist, because the record showed he knew insurers were already questioning his billing: a private insurer had investigated his practices in 2015 and required proof of services before further payment, and licensing authorities in another state had investigated him years earlier. Awareness of those investigations proved the “knowingly and willfully” mental state that section 1347 demands. In Filline, the Fifth Circuit, on June 1, 2026, held that conspiracy needs no written agreement: “circumstantial evidence is evidence,” pointing to strained finances, repeated requests to get rid of the vehicle, recruitment of a relative with a criminal history, coordinated access, destruction by fire, a false theft report, the insurance claim, and later concealment. Viewed together, a rational jury could find an agreement beyond a reasonable doubt. The lesson for anyone under scrutiny is symmetrical: prosecutors prove intent through the paper trail around the claim, and the absence of a confession or an eyewitness changes nothing.

II. From the claim to the sentence: how these cases are really decided

Most insurance fraud files never start with handcuffs. They start with a flag inside the insurer’s payment system, a referral to a state fraud bureau, or parallel state and federal investigators comparing notes. The South Carolina cases in the news followed that path: local reporting describes charges filed county by county as investigators worked through a network of allegedly false claims. Knowing how that machinery works tells a reader exactly what to check and preserve long before any charging decision.

A. How an investigation becomes a prosecution

The Yoon prosecution shows the typical paper trail. Before any indictment, a private insurer investigated the therapist’s billing in 2015 and responded by demanding proof that billed services were actually rendered. That business response later became trial evidence of knowledge: once an insurer has told a provider, in writing, that its bills look wrong, later bills following the same pattern look deliberate rather than careless. The court also allowed evidence that the therapist knew of an earlier licensing investigation in another state, again limited to what it proved about his awareness. The practical check is therefore straightforward. Any letter, audit request, prepayment review notice, or demand for records from an insurer should be treated as the moment the file changes character: from that point on, every new claim is created by someone the government can describe as on notice. Keep every such letter, log every phone call, and have any response reviewed before it goes out, because the response itself can become an exhibit.

The Filline prosecution shows the other half of the method. Nobody confessed to an agreement, and nobody needed to: the court listed mutually reinforcing layers of circumstantial proof, including documented financial strain of about $30,000 in credit-card debt plus delinquent mortgage and car payments, text messages asking a mechanic to take the vehicle and burn it, repeated requests to an employee to get rid of it, recruitment of a relative willing to do criminal work, coordinated access to the vehicle, destruction by fire, a false theft report to local police, the insurance claim, and later concealment. Each layer was individually modest; together they proved the agreement. Anyone tempted to think a staged loss is safe because only trusted people know should understand this paragraph: investigators reconstruct staged events through phone records, financial records, access logs, and inconsistent statements, and American courts instruct juries that this kind of proof can sustain a conviction. Deleting messages or coordinating stories after the fact adds obstruction and concealment to the file rather than subtracting risk.

Forum matters as much as proof. Federal prosecutors take cases where the mail or wires cross state lines, where the dollar amounts justify federal resources, or where a scheme touches a federal program. State prosecutors take the great bulk of ordinary false-claim cases under statutes like South Carolina’s section 38-55-540, and state fraud bureaus, such as the South Carolina Department of Insurance’s fraud division, exist precisely to feed those cases. A reader should therefore check both exposures rather than assuming a small claim stays small: a single false claim can violate state law where it was filed and federal law if any wire or mailing carried it, and related counts can be stacked across a scheme. The Yoon file, spanning November 2014 to November 2018, produced multiple counts from one course of conduct, and the Filline file combined conspiracy with the underlying fraud objective. Counting exposure per claim, not per scheme, is how prosecutors think, and it is how a reader should think when deciding whether to correct a filing.

Two cautions belong here because they change decisions. First, as the Supreme Court confirmed in Kousisis on May 22, 2025, paying the money back after the lie does not undo the crime: the defendants performed the contracts and the agency got its bridges painted, yet the wire-fraud convictions stood because the contracts were induced by materially false pretenses. Restitution may reduce the sentence, and in South Carolina the court must order it, but it is not an acquittal. Second, as the First Circuit confirmed in Yoon on February 20, 2026, being disorganized, overworked, or unfamiliar with billing software is a weak defense once the record shows warnings were received and ignored; the statute asks what the defendant knew and intended, proved through documents, not through self-description. The check that follows from both holdings is the same: correct a questionable claim in writing before investigators arrive, preserve the correction, and do not create new statements, new bills, or new explanations that a jury could read as consciousness of guilt.

B. How the punishment is actually fixed

Once convicted, the sentence turns largely on money. Under the federal sentencing guidelines provision applied in Yoon, section 2B1.1 of the Guidelines Manual (November 2025), the central concept is loss, and the Commission’s official primer states the rule plainly: the guidelines define loss as the “greater of actual or intended loss,” with the court required to make only a reasonable estimate from the available information and permitted to subtract certain credits. In practice this means the sentence is driven not by what the defendant pocketed but by the larger of what victims actually lost and what the scheme aimed to take, before credits. The Yoon opinion quotes the same rule for fraud cases generally: loss is the “higher of either actual or intended loss” in fraud cases generally, citing section 2B1.1. That choice of the higher figure explains how a billing scheme becomes a multi-year sentence: each false bill adds to intended loss even where the insurer caught it and never paid.

The Yoon numbers make the mechanism concrete. The district court set the total offense level at twenty, which with the lowest criminal-history category produced a recommended range of thirty-three to forty-one months in prison, and then imposed twenty-seven months, below the range. The appeals court affirmed after rejecting challenges to two guideline enhancements, including the loss calculation and an abuse-of-trust enhancement reflecting that the defendant had exploited his professional position. Two lessons follow. First, the loss table converts dollars directly into offense levels, so early, accurate accounting of the amount at issue is the single most important sentencing task; every bill the defense can legitimately exclude from loss lowers the range. Second, professional status cuts against the defendant: clinicians, agents, adjusters, and anyone else the system trusts with billing receive enhancements for abusing that trust, a point the Fifth Circuit’s Filline decision echoes in substance, where the defendant’s position as a police chief framed the entire prosecution narrative.

South Carolina’s statute works differently but points the same way: punishment follows the dollar figure, and the court has no discretion to skip repayment. A first offense under $1,000 stays a misdemeanor with at most 30 days; $1,000 to $10,000 remains a misdemeanor but allows up to three years; $10,000 to $50,000 becomes a felony with up to five years; $50,000 or more becomes a felony with up to ten years and fines of $20,000 to $100,000; and any repeat violation is a felony with up to ten years regardless of amount. On top of the fine-or-prison alternatives, which the judge selects within those bands, the statute commands full restitution to the victim and payment of any tax shortfall the fraud created. The state agency’s public guidance reinforces the message that these are not paper penalties: fraud is charged as a felony, it raises every resident’s premiums by roughly $1,184 a year, and suspected fraud can be reported to the fraud division for investigation. A reader measuring personal exposure should therefore total every claim in the suspected course of conduct, locate the total on the statutory scale, add the mandatory restitution figure, and understand that each additional claim can add both a new count and a higher loss number.

One final structural point decides many files: federal and state sentences for the same scheme can interact, and related conduct outside the counts of conviction can still influence the guideline calculation through relevant-conduct rules. The Yoon court treated the full course of billing as the measure of loss, not merely the two counts of conviction, and affirmed enhancements the defendant contested on both factual and legal grounds. The First Circuit’s February 20, 2026 decision and the Fifth Circuit’s June 1, 2026 decision thus converge on a single warning: by the time a case reaches sentencing, the dispute is no longer whether something wrong happened but how much of it counts. That is why contemporaneous records, prompt written corrections, and an early realistic accounting of dollars matter more than any after-the-fact explanation.

Conclusion

Insurance fraud in the United States is punished as fraud first and as an insurance problem second. A materially false claim sent by mail or wire can draw up to 20 years in federal prison per count, false health-care claims up to 10 years or more, and South Carolina adds its own graduated scale from a 30-day misdemeanor to a 10-year felony with mandatory restitution. Courts require the lie to be material, as settled in 1999 and reaffirmed in 2025, but they do not require the insurer to have lost money, and they accept circumstantial proof of agreement and knowledge, as the 2026 appellate decisions confirm. The decisive variables are therefore ordinary and checkable: whether the statement could have influenced payment, whether warnings were received and kept, how many dollars the file totals, and whether corrections were made in writing before investigators closed the circle. Add those four numbers and those four dates together, and the exposure in any file becomes legible before charges decide it.

📄 Official circular