KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Electric Vehicle: What If a Used EV Battery Falls Short of the Dealer’s Advertised Health?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Electric Vehicle: What If a Used EV Battery Falls Short of the Dealer’s Advertised Health?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

“Electric vehicle” is being searched in the United Kingdom. For a buyer in England and Wales, one practical question is what happens if a dealer sells a used electric car with a specific battery-health figure and the car appears to fall short. A dashboard showing fewer miles than expected is a reason to look closer. The stronger evidence is a dated comparison between what the dealer said about that particular vehicle and a measurement of the same characteristic on that vehicle.

This article gives general information on the law in England and Wales as at 18 November 2026. It concerns a straightforward purchase from a dealer by an individual buying mainly for personal use. The examples are hypothetical. It explains how to distinguish an advertised condition from a driving-range estimate, what to ask a technician to record, and when the consumer may be able to reject the car, require a repair or replacement, or seek a price reduction. The outcome depends on the terms, the condition of the car and the evidence. The dates of delivery, any request for remedial work and any clear notice of rejection can change which remedy is still available.

I. Establish what the dealer sold and what the test shows

A. Identify the battery claim that formed part of the sale

Section 2 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 defines a trader by reference to purposes relating to a trade, business, craft or profession. A consumer is an individual acting wholly or mainly outside such purposes. This distinction matters if an online listing displays a motor dealer’s name but the paperwork identifies someone else as the seller. Keep the order form, invoice and proof of payment and establish who contracted to supply the car. The approach below concerns an ordinary dealer sale under the current Act. The 2015 commencement order brought the relevant provisions into force on 1 October 2015 and made transitional provision for earlier contracts. A purchase from a genuine private seller or a transaction involving a separate finance agreement calls for a separate analysis of the contract and the right party to address.

Save the dealer’s listing as it stood before you agreed to buy. Useful records include the images, stock reference, description, date, and any documents in which the dealer explained its battery test. Keep the complete message thread if someone answered a question about the battery over email or chat. You want to be able to show which figure applied to the car in the order form and whether the figure was presented as a measured condition, an estimate, or an illustration. Retain any amended listing and note when you first received it. If the dealer sent a new figure before you signed, your reply and the final paperwork can show how the two versions were dealt with.

Section 11 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 treats a contract to supply goods by description as including a term that the goods will match that description. Selecting or inspecting the particular car is compatible with a supply by description. The section also gives contractual effect to specified information about the main characteristics of the goods supplied by the trader. A change to information covered by that rule requires express agreement. A vehicle-specific statement identifying the traction battery’s health can therefore matter if it forms part of the description or is covered by the rule on information about main characteristics. Its wording, context and connection to the car determine how it can be used.

Consider a dealer who lists a particular used car as having 92% traction battery health, sends a report identified to that car and repeats the figure on the sales order. Compare that with a brochure describing a model’s published range when new under specified test conditions. The buyer in the first example can point to a particular vehicle, a stated measurement and a sales document. The brochure in the second example may explain how the buyer formed an expectation, but the new-car range figure alone does not show that the dealer agreed that the used car would achieve that distance on the buyer’s regular route. The wording of the listing and the basis of the figures matter more than the size of a difference between two numbers.

Section 9 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 also treats the contract as including a term that the goods are of satisfactory quality. The standard is what a reasonable person would consider satisfactory, taking account of the description, price where relevant and other relevant circumstances. The condition, fitness for ordinary purposes and durability of the goods can matter. Age, mileage and price are part of the analysis for a used car, as is any evidence about the battery’s condition. A quality complaint can exist even if the dealer gave no battery percentage. The issue is whether the condition fell below the statutory standard for that car in its circumstances.

Public statements about specific characteristics made by the trader, producer or their representatives, including advertising, can count in assessing quality. Section 9 provides exceptions if the trader shows, for example, that a statement was publicly withdrawn or corrected before the contract, or that it could not have influenced the consumer’s decision. Section 9 also excludes a defect specifically drawn to the consumer’s attention before the contract, or a defect that the consumer’s pre-contract examination ought to have revealed if the consumer examined the goods. Compare a signed document expressly identifying an already reduced battery capacity with a general line that a used car may show wear. If an inspection is in dispute, write down what was actually inspected and what information the car displayed. That helps establish whether the particular condition ought to have been apparent.

B. Compare like with like and document the point of delivery

Before commissioning a report, ask what the dealer’s percentage measures. A battery’s current state of charge describes how full it is at that moment. A figure presented as its state of health may instead compare its present capacity with a stated reference capacity. A dashboard’s predicted distance is another measurement. If the label in the advert says only battery at 92%, ask whether the dealer was referring to charge level at the time of inspection or an assessment of long-term capacity. Two reports may use different definitions of reference capacity, give access to different signals or record data under different conditions. Record those differences so a specialist can explain whether the figures can properly be compared.

An independent report is most useful when it identifies the particular vehicle and tells the reader exactly what the test did. Ask the tester to record the vehicle identifier, test date, mileage, method, units and source of the reference figure. If there is a tolerance or a reason another test method could produce a different reading, ask for that to be stated. Send the original dealer report and ask whether it used the same basis. A conclusion that relies on available battery-management data should say which data were read. A capacity measurement should distinguish the figure actually measured from any figure extrapolated. The question for a dispute is whether the two reports show a difference in the same characteristic on the same car.

Take a car advertised with 92% battery health that is tested shortly after delivery. A report giving 76% under a comparable method, tied to the vehicle identifier and accompanied by a written account of test conditions, provides a clearer basis for a complaint than a photograph of the dashboard after one cold journey. The difference is 16 percentage points. The figures alone still leave questions about how the baseline was calculated, the test’s margin of error and whether any relevant change occurred between delivery and the examination. If the dealer suggests that its report belongs to a different vehicle or that one test was performed before a software update, ask for the underlying record and dates. Verify the explanation against the test reports before treating either figure as conclusive.

Retain the handover record, date of delivery, odometer reading, any warning messages and the first dated record of the concern. Note any repair, impact or other change since handover that could bear on the diagnosis. If the car went back twice, identify the mileage and reported symptom at each visit. Ask for a diagnostic printout before any proposed work changes the information available. The point is to demonstrate the condition relied on and when it became observable. A long account of disappointing trips can hide what the dealer and technician need to compare. A one-page chronology with attached originals is often more useful.

A dispute can involve both a mismatch with the description and an issue of satisfactory quality. Consider keeping a short line for each. For description, identify the dealer’s vehicle-specific claim, where it appeared and the contrary measurement. For quality, identify what the testing found, how materially it affects use or durability, and what that means given the car’s age, price and mileage. If you knew of a different battery issue before buying, record precisely what was disclosed. Doing so helps distinguish that issue from a problem revealed only by the later test. This also makes it easier to see what further evidence the dealer’s reply calls for.

The rules here concern an English or Welsh consumer sale. The firm’s English-language overview of its legal practice in Paris provides information about the firm in its own jurisdiction.

II. Choose the remedy and keep track of the dates

A. Understand short-term rejection and the effect of agreeing to work

Section 19 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 sets out remedies for goods that breach the statutory terms on quality or description. These include the short-term right to reject, repair or replacement and, in the circumstances set out below, a price reduction or final rejection. First identify which term was breached and whether the condition existed at delivery. Keep the contract and measurements together when explaining the breach. A request that simply says the car does fewer miles will give the dealer less to investigate than one identifying the contractual battery claim and the measurement said to disprove it.

Under section 22 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, the ordinary short-term period is 30 days beginning the first day after the relevant conditions have all been met. For a straightforward purchase where ownership passes when the car is delivered and the trader has no further contractual action to take to enable its use, the day after delivery is day one. Where ownership and delivery take place on different dates, check both. Where the trader must take a step to enable use, the statutory calculation also takes account of the notification that the step has been completed. Record the dates rather than counting from the day the defect was diagnosed or the day the advertisement first appeared.

Under section 20 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, rejection requires a sufficiently clear indication to the trader that the consumer rejects the goods and treats the contract as ended. A complaint or request for a diagnostic appointment may leave it unclear which right the buyer is exercising. A written notice can identify the car and delivery date, specify the condition relied on, state the right being exercised and explain how the car can be made available for collection. Keep evidence of when the trader received it. If the buyer and dealer arrange for the buyer to return the car, keep that agreement. The section generally puts reasonable return costs on the trader, with an exception for costs arising from the consumer returning the goods in person to the place where they took physical possession.

Section 20 generally requires a refund without undue delay and within 14 days beginning on the day the trader agrees that the consumer is entitled to it. Keep the date of the agreement and any confirmation of the amount. In a straightforward cash purchase, subject to any applicable statutory qualification, the starting point is the money paid under that contract. The rules on a part exchange can depend on whether what was transferred can be returned or substituted. If the dealer’s offer combines a refund and a different transaction, identify separately what is being returned under the original contract and what would be paid or transferred under any new agreement.

If a consumer requests or agrees to a repair or replacement during the short-term period, section 22 stops the clock for the statutory waiting period. That period starts on the day of the request or agreement and ends when the buyer receives the goods supplied in response. If those goods still fail to conform, the deadline is the later of seven days after the waiting period ends or the original deadline extended by the waiting period. Keep the messages that show what you agreed. An appointment to obtain a diagnosis and an agreement to have the trader repair the car can have different consequences. If both parties understand that the car is going in solely for inspection, a short written record of that understanding makes the chronology easier to assess.

The six-month presumption in section 19 is important for the repair, replacement, price-reduction and final-rejection routes it specifies. If the goods do not conform at a point within six months beginning with delivery, they are treated as having failed to conform at delivery unless conformity at delivery is established or the presumption is incompatible with the nature of the goods or the way in which they fail to conform. The buyer still needs evidence identifying a failure to conform. The presumption does not apply to the short-term right to reject under section 19(3)(a). If the short-term issue is contested, a report made close to handover and the original advert can help demonstrate why the condition was already present at delivery.

B. Test the dealer’s proposed fix and assess the refund basis

Section 23 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires the trader, where the consumer can require repair or replacement, to carry this out within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience to the consumer and at the trader’s necessary cost. A remedy cannot be required if it is impossible or disproportionate compared with the other remedy. The comparison considers the value of conforming goods, the significance of the failure and whether the other remedy can be performed without significant inconvenience. In practice, if the dealer proposes a software intervention or battery work, ask what the intervention will change and how the result will be tested. A repair under this section must bring the goods into conformity.

A clear work order tells you whether the trader intends to fix the battery condition or merely investigate the instrument reading. It should identify the work, expected timing and arrangements for collecting and returning the vehicle. Keep dates when parts are ordered, when the trader gives a new estimate and when the car is available again. If the problem affects ordinary transport, keep a practical record of the disruption, including the number of days without the car and what alternatives the dealer made available. Whether a delay is reasonable or an inconvenience significant depends in part on the nature of the goods and the purpose for which they were bought. A detailed record explains the effect of delay more clearly than a general objection to waiting.

Section 24 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 allows a price reduction or final rejection in specified circumstances, including where the goods still fail to conform after one repair or replacement, where neither remedy can be required under section 23(3), or where the trader breaches the obligation to repair or replace within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. Where both remedies are available, the consumer chooses one. For example, if the trader returns the car after an agreed repair and a comparable test still shows the same material mismatch, keep the work order, return date and both measurements. If the trader carried out inspection only, the same records will help establish whether the statutory condition concerning a repair or replacement has actually been met.

A price reduction may make sense if the buyer can use the car and prefers to retain it at an appropriate price. In that case the difference between the value of a car matching the description and the value of the one supplied can give the parties a basis for discussion. A comparable listing with the same age, mileage and equipment, a reliable condition report and an itemised repair estimate can help. Each answers a different question. A percentage-point shortfall in capacity does not translate directly into a percentage discount on the entire purchase price. If you use a repair estimate, identify whether its proposed work would restore the condition described and what is included in the quoted figure.

On final rejection, section 24 permits a deduction to account for use, subject to the rules in that section. An ordinary road-going electric car falls within the motor vehicle exception to the usual rule against such deductions in the first six months. The definition for Great Britain refers to the Road Traffic Act 1988, section 185. The question is what use the buyer actually had. Ask the dealer to explain the proposed deduction by reference to the period and nature of that use and the evidence on which it relies. Section 24 excludes a deduction for a period when the consumer had the car only because the trader failed to collect it at an agreed time. Keep the agreed collection date and any notice postponing it.

Write the final chronology in the order events happened. Identify the description, the date the car and ownership passed to you, the first measurement, what you asked the dealer to do and what it actually did. Add the date a remedy was exercised and the exact items still in dispute. If you received a revised offer, check whether it addresses the condition, the relevant right and the proposed calculation. The same measurements may support several possible remedies at the outset. The correspondence and dates show which one remains available when a decision has to be made.

Conclusion

A used electric car battery dispute in England and Wales turns on the evidence of what was agreed, what condition the vehicle was in and when the buyer acted. Preserve the listing and match its claim to a test of the same battery characteristic. Build the chronology from delivery, any request for remedial work and any notice of rejection. The short-term period, the six-month presumption for specified remedies and the possible allowance for use on final rejection serve different purposes. A clear record lets the buyer identify the right remedy and explain the amount in dispute.

📄 Official circular