KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Drought: What a Hosepipe Ban Allows and How to Check an Exemption in England

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Drought: What a Hosepipe Ban Allows and How to Check an Exemption in England

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Search interest in drought in the United Kingdom raises a practical question for households in England. If a water company announces a hosepipe ban, can you still water new turf, clean a slippery path or top up a pond? The answer depends on the activity, how the water is supplied and the terms of the applicable notice. Some uses fall outside the statutory categories. Other uses can be permitted under a local exception, sometimes only if you meet conditions set by the supplier. A notice published for another area is a poor guide to what applies at your address.

This article explains the temporary water-use restrictions that a water company can impose under the law applicable in England. It gives a method of general application for reading a proposed or operative notice, checking a claimed exception and keeping a record of any representation or request. The examples are hypothetical. They cover ordinary household activities and show why the same piece of equipment can yield different answers depending on what the water is used for. If you are looking at a notice for a particular property, the first things to find are the area it covers, the date it takes effect and the exact wording that addresses your proposed use.

By Hassan Kohen, a lawyer at the Paris Bar.

I. Establish what the notice restricts at your address

A. Check the supply, the area and the effective date

Section 76 of the Water Industry Act 1991 allows a water undertaker to prohibit specified uses of water supplied through its supply system if it thinks that it is experiencing, or may experience, a serious shortage of water for distribution. An undertaker is the company with the statutory water supply function. The Flood and Water Management Act 2010, section 36, substituted the modern framework for temporary bans. The commencement notes to section 76 show that the substituted provisions came into force on 1 October 2010 insofar as they were not already in force. Use the current version of the 1991 Act when identifying the power and the categories it covers.

Section 76 sets a list of uses that can be restricted and requires the prohibition to state its starting date and area. That area can be all or only part of the territory served by the supplier. Identify who supplies water to the specific address, then check how the notice describes the boundary. A postcode list, map or description in the notice may matter more than the name of the nearest town. A supplier can cover several areas without imposing identical restrictions in all of them. The address of a property you manage, a second home or a rented allotment may require its own check.

Look at the version of the notice and the dates on it. Under section 76B, the supplier must give notice of the prohibition and its terms before the period for which it is to apply, both on its website and in at least two newspapers circulating in the affected area. The notice must give details of how to make representations about the proposal. A variation is treated as a prohibition for the purposes of this procedure. Revocation also requires notices and cannot take effect before at least one of the prescribed notices of revocation has been given. Look for a dated variation or revocation before relying on a copy you saved earlier.

An undated overview sometimes appears next to a dated notice. Use the overview to find the document, then record the exact language of the notice and any change to it. A page explaining how a ban would work is different from a notice that specifies when restrictions apply at an address. If the page says a restriction is due to begin next week, write down both the start date and any separate date for representations. Check whether a newer notice affects only a certain use or the entire scheme. A relaxation for a particular activity may leave the rest of the notice in force.

The same method helps if you are deciding whether to accept a quotation for garden work during a proposed ban. Give the installer the notice for your property and ask what water source and method the quotation assumes. An estimate based on a hose connected to your outdoor tap may need revision if that use is prohibited when the work takes place. Agreeing a date or paying for materials does not determine whether the later act of watering fits an exception. It can, however, give you dated evidence of the installation if the local terms distinguish existing work from work begun after a specified date.

B. Identify the activity and follow the water through the equipment

Section 76A permits restrictions for particular users, times or circumstances, with absolute or conditional exceptions. It also authorises definitions and exclusions by order. The Water Use (Temporary Bans) Order 2010 came into force on 1 October 2010 and defines how the statutory categories apply. Start by describing the act in everyday terms. For instance, spraying a lawn, filling a paddling pool and rinsing a vehicle are different uses, even if all three involve the same tap. Then match the description to the statutory category and see whether the notice includes it.

Article 3 of the Order addresses an easy mistake. In relation to the statutory purposes, using a hosepipe includes drawing relevant water from a container through a hose and applying it. It also includes filling or partly filling a container with relevant water by hose and then applying the water. Pouring the contents of a bucket by hand does not remove the earlier hose use from that definition. At the same time, Article 3 excludes from the defined relevant water any water supplied before the use in question was prohibited. If relying on stored water, establish where it came from and when it entered the container. A butt that held stored water on the starting date may have been topped up since.

A hose connected to a tank containing only collected rainwater raises a different source question from a hose drawing from a tank replenished by mains supply. The section 76 power concerns water supplied through the undertaker’s supply system. A label on the tank gives limited assurance if there is a mains top-up, a shared connection or uncertainty about what water was used. Draw a simple route from the source to the activity, including any container, hose and pump. If more than one source is possible, check how the equipment was actually set up and used on the relevant date. Avoid treating assumptions about the design of the system as evidence of what it delivered.

A hand-held container filled directly from a tap involves no hose at that step. For a restricted category framed around hosepipe use, that difference matters. For a category framed around the activity itself, check its specific wording. Filling or maintaining a domestic swimming or paddling pool appears in section 76(2)(e) without a general hosepipe qualifier. Article 8 of the Order excludes, among other cases, filling or maintaining such a pool using a hand-held container filled directly from a tap. The route from the tap to the container still matters. A container partly filled with a hose does not satisfy that particular description merely because you carry it for the final step.

For garden watering, Article 4 includes lawns, allotment gardens, parks and other green space in the category. It excludes specified uses and settings, including commercial growing land within the terms of the provision and certain plants under cover. Article 6 separately addresses plants on domestic or other non-commercial premises that are in an outdoor pot or in the ground under cover. Moving a container into a greenhouse therefore does not settle the question. The relevant restriction may simply apply under a different category. The useful comparison is between the facts, the Order and the notice, in that sequence.

Suppose two residents share an outside tap and a water butt. One draws only collected rainwater from a second, disconnected barrel. The other uses the shared butt, which has a hose inlet and has been replenished since the ban started. An image of either person holding a watering can leaves the source and the filling method unresolved. A dated record of which container was used and how it was filled answers those questions. Conversely, for a notice that restricts filling a domestic pool, evidence of the container alone is incomplete. Article 8 also asks how the hand-held container was filled. Record the steps in order so that each fact can be checked against the right provision.

Different residential and commercial arrangements can put similar-looking activities into different categories. If a gardener is paid to water a client’s domestic lawn, the payment alone does not make the lawn land used for commercial growing within Article 4. Equally, if a car is cleaned at home, the statutory definition of a private motor vehicle in Article 5 depends on the type of vehicle, not just where it is parked. A contractor’s assurances are worth testing against the terms for the address and use. If the contractor relies on a particular exception, ask for the wording and record the facts said to bring the work within it.

II. Check the exception and protect your position

A. Distinguish a statutory exclusion from a local exception

A statutory exclusion changes whether the activity falls within a category that a supplier can restrict under section 76. A local exception can permit an activity that does fall within a listed category and is covered by the notice. Keep the two in separate parts of your notes. For a statutory exclusion, identify the article of the Order and the facts that satisfy it. For a local exception, identify the clause in the current notice, the users or uses it covers, any time limit and any requirement to obtain consent. Reading the two texts separately helps avoid treating a local concession as a nationally available permission.

Consider new turf. A lawn falls within the garden category under Article 4 and the Order does not create a general exclusion for newly laid turf. If the notice prohibits garden watering with a hose, anyone relying on a new-turf exception should therefore locate the local clause and check its conditions. If the clause specifies a period after laying, note what the period runs from and keep the delivery or installation record. If it prescribes a method or hours, check both. If the terms require approval, ask what counts as approval and keep the response. A general statement from the installer about what is customary cannot supply a missing exception.

A similar issue arises with drip irrigation. A device marketed as efficient may still use a hose or be connected to mains water by a hose. Describe its route and how the water reaches the plants. If the notice gives an exception for a particular system, the equipment and its operation need to match the wording. Check the individual conditions instead of relying on the product description. For example, an exception written for a system operating through a timer does not necessarily cover a manually controlled arrangement with the same emitters. That example illustrates how to read conditional terms. It does not establish that any notice grants an exception for a timer.

Health or safety exclusions require attention to the particular statutory category. Under Article 2, health or safety reasons include removing or minimising a human or animal health or safety risk and preventing or controlling the spread of agents of disease. Article 13 excludes hosepipe cleaning of paths or patios for health or safety reasons from that category. Articles 12 and 14 contain corresponding provisions for the uses they describe. If a shared path has become slippery, record the specific hazard, where people need to walk and the work needed to address it. Routine cleaning for appearance and work to remove an identifiable hazard can look similar from the street. A brief, contemporaneous note helps explain why the work was done and which area was treated.

Ponds need their own check. Article 10 excludes from the domestic pond category the filling or maintenance of a domestic pond in which fish or other aquatic animals are being reared or kept in captivity. Article 11 separately excludes an ornamental fountain in or near a fish pond where its purpose is to supply enough oxygen to keep the fish healthy. If a property contains a pond and a decorative feature nearby, look at the function of each and how the feature operates. The presence of fish in one does not automatically settle the status of every other water feature on the property. Article 8 provides separate exclusions for domestic pools, including pools in which fish or other aquatic animals are being reared or kept in captivity.

An outdoor tap may be used for two jobs on the same day. If a statutory exclusion applies to the first job, apply the same analysis anew to the second. For example, the reason for cleaning a dangerous part of a path does not determine whether you can later use the hose to wash the car. A short record of the particular job, equipment, water source and date is more informative than a description of the whole visit as necessary work. If the water company’s notice requires a particular record for an exception, follow that requirement. The general record is useful in addition to it.

This guide concerns rules in England. The firm’s English-language overview of its legal practice in France describes its work in that separate jurisdiction.

B. Use the representations process and keep a record of any charge issue

If the notice is still at the proposal stage, use the method it gives for representations under section 76B. Send a focused explanation while that procedure is open. Identify the address or area, the proposed restricted use and the clause you want the supplier to reconsider. Describe the practical impact, the alternative methods considered and any limit you could work with. For example, if the problem is a shared area accessed by residents, explain the specific use, who maintains it and why a narrower restriction would meet the concern. Attach the part of a plan or evidence that bears on the request. If the company has published separate procedures for representations and exception requests, make clear which you are submitting.

When an operative notice is unclear, put the question in terms the supplier can answer. A useful request gives the property’s location, the exact activity, the water source, the method of application and the clause you think may apply. Ask whether the clause covers that scenario and whether you need express permission. Keep the date and wording of any response and check it against the formal notice. If the reply describes restrictions in a different area or relies on a superseded version, ask for clarification before relying on it. A representation or request does not itself vary the notice. Section 76 gives the supplier the power to vary or revoke it and section 76B prescribes the related notice requirements.

There can also be a separate question about charges. Section 76(6) requires an undertaker that issues a prohibition to make arrangements for a reasonable reduction of charges made in respect of prohibited uses. The provision includes arrangements for repayment or credit where charges are paid in advance. Its wording concerns charges for the prohibited uses. To assess whether it matters to your bill, identify the specific charge, the period it covered and the activity to which it relates. Ask how the supplier’s arrangements apply and retain the bill and any response. A customer who paid a separately identified charge for a use covered by the notice has a different question from someone who wants a general reduction because garden watering was restricted.

There is no single calculation in section 76(6) for every household. Where a charge was paid in advance, record its start and end dates alongside the period during which the particular use was prohibited. Check whether the supplier has already applied a credit and what period that credit covers. If the invoice bundles several services, ask for a breakdown rather than assuming the whole bill corresponds to the restricted use. Keep the question about a reduction separate from any request to allow the activity. The former concerns charges for a prohibited use and the latter concerns the legal terms for carrying it out.

Section 76(5) makes contravention of an applicable prohibition an offence and sets the maximum fine on summary conviction by reference to level 3 on the standard scale. If an alleged breach is raised, preserve the notice applicable on the date, the address and any map or schedule, the terms of any exception and accurate evidence of how the water was supplied and used. Keep the supplier’s correspondence in date order. Start by establishing what is alleged: for example, whether it is ordinary garden watering, cleaning an outdoor surface or filling a domestic pool. The facts relevant to one category may say little about another. If the facts are uncertain, record that uncertainty and identify the material that can resolve it.

In a block of flats, distinguish the address to which the notice applies from the account on which the charge appears. An occupier who uses a communal garden may have no copy of the bill. The person managing the shared supply may be able to identify the charge and the dates for which it was paid. Obtain those facts before making a request for a credit. Where responsibility for an irrigation system is shared, record who operated it and which supply served it. That information can matter even if the water company sent the original notice to someone else.

A practical file can be short. Save the notice and any subsequent version, keep a photograph or map only where it establishes a relevant feature and attach any correspondence about the specific activity. Put the relevant date on each item. If the question is whether the supplier’s definition covers your part of a shared development, keep the part of the notice that sets the geographic boundary. If the issue is a conditional exception, keep the evidence tied to its particular condition. The point of the file is to show how the facts meet the rule in force for that place and time.

Conclusion

To check an English hosepipe ban, start with the notice for the address and the date. Identify the activity and follow the water from its source to the point of use. Read the provision in the Order that defines the activity, then look for any additional exception in the local terms. If the exception is conditional, check every condition and keep evidence that addresses it. Use the representations procedure for a proposed restriction and ask a specific written question if an operative notice is unclear. Keeping the dated notice alongside a short record of what you planned to do makes it easier to resolve a dispute about the ban, an exception or a charge.

📄 Official circular