On 9 September 2026 in Luxembourg, the General Court of the European Union dismissed Roman Arkadyevich Abramovich’s latest challenge to the EU asset freeze and travel ban that have followed him since March 2022. In case T-358/25, First Chamber, ECLI:EU:T:2026:537, the Court rejected both the claim for annulment of the March 2025 and September 2025 renewal acts and the claim for non-material damages. Press release No 124/26, published the same day on the Curia site, summarised the outcome: the action is dismissed and the restrictive measures taken against him are upheld. The authentic French judgment is more precise than the press office. It does not treat him as a majority owner of Evraz. It records a holding of 28.64 per cent, describes him as the principal shareholder among a small group of large holders, and holds that this, together with steel and mining revenue feeding the Russian budget, was enough to keep him on the list.
That is the news. The legal question for anyone who banks, litigates or collects in France is different. An EU listing is not a slogan. Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 applies directly. French banks, notaries, insurers and ordinary residents must apply the freeze without delay under article L. 562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code. A creditor who tries to attach frozen funds in Paris without the Treasury’s green light will meet the same wall the Cour de cassation built in February 2026 in a Libyan freeze case. A listed person who tries to live through a foreign account can still commit a customs-grade offence under article L. 574-3. This article reads today’s judgment against that French machinery: what Luxembourg actually held, what remains open on appeal, and what a Paris file looks like the morning after.
I. Why did the EU General Court keep Abramovich frozen on 9 September 2026?
A. How was he listed, and what did case T-358/25 actually decide?
The judgment opens with identities, not mythology. The applicant is a citizen of Russian, Israeli and Portuguese nationality. He therefore holds an EU passport. That fact later became the sixth plea. It did not save him. The restrictive measures themselves date from 17 March 2014: Council Decision 2014/145/CFSP, adopted on the basis of Article 29 TEU, and Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014, adopted on the basis of Article 215(2) TFEU, both concerning restrictive measures in respect of actions undermining or threatening the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence of Ukraine. After 24 February 2022 the Council widened the designation criteria. On 15 March 2022, by Decision (CFSP) 2022/429 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/427, his name was added as number 879 to the annex of Decision 2014/145 and to Annex I of Regulation No 269/2014. He has been number 879 ever since.
This was not his first trip to Luxembourg. On 20 December 2023, in Abramovich v Council, T-313/22, ECLI:EU:T:2023:830, the General Court sitting in extended First Chamber had already rejected a challenge to the original listing and the first renewals. The operative part of that judgment dismissed the action and ordered him to pay the Council’s costs as well as his own. Paragraph 13 of today’s judgment records that the 2023 ruling was still under appeal when T-358/25 was decided. A second action, T-1105/23, attacking later renewals, was dismissed on 10 September 2025 (unpublished, ECLI:EU:T:2025:839), also under appeal. T-358/25 is therefore the third wave: an action lodged on 26 May 2025, adapted on 25 November 2025 after the September 2025 renewal, heard on 6 May 2026, and decided today against the March 2025 acts (Decision (CFSP) 2025/528 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/527) and the September 2025 acts (Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1894).
The legal hook is criterion (g), as rewritten on 5 June 2023 by Decision (CFSP) 2023/1094 and Regulation (EU) 2023/1089. Article 2(1)(g) of Decision 2014/145, as amended, freezes funds belonging to leading businesspersons engaged in economic activities in Russia, to members of their immediate family or other natural persons who benefit from them, or to businesspersons, legal persons, entities or bodies operating in economic sectors that provide a substantial source of revenue to the Government of the Russian Federation, which is responsible for the annexation of Crimea and the destabilisation of Ukraine. The Court calls this the modified criterion (g). The first limb is the influential-businessperson-active-in-Russia test. The third limb is the substantial-source-of-revenue test. The Council applied both to him. The statement of reasons reproduced in the judgment described him as a leading Russian businessman with long-standing close ties to President Vladimir Putin, and as one of the main shareholders of the Evraz steel group, one of Russia’s largest taxpayers.
Six pleas were run. The first alleged a defect of essential procedural requirements: that working parties had de facto adopted the measures instead of the Council. The Court refused that rewriting of the Treaties. It held that Article 14(3) of Regulation No 269/2014 refers to the Council as an institution, whose functioning is in practice ensured by preparatory bodies such as the COEST and RELEX working parties and Coreper, and not only to the Council in its ministerial formation. The fact that those bodies take part in the review does not mean that the Council surrenders its decision-making power or delegates it. The Court anchored that reading in Article 29 TEU, under which the Council adopts decisions that define the Union’s position on a particular geographical or thematic issue, and in Article 215(2) TFEU, under which the Council may adopt restrictive measures against natural or legal persons, groups or non-State entities when a CFSP decision so provides. On the facts, Coreper discussed the draft acts on 12 and 13 March 2025 and on 10 and 12 September 2025, and the Council formally adopted them by written procedure under Article 12 of its Rules of Procedure. The argument that staff had taken the decision therefore failed on both law and fact.
The fourth plea, error of assessment, is the one that will be quoted in every bank memo. The Court separates the two limbs of criterion (g). On influence and activity in Russia, the reason given was that, because he is a significant shareholder of Evraz, one of Russia’s largest taxpayers, he is regarded as a leading businessman carrying on activities in Russia. The notion of leading businesspersons looks to professional status, the scale of economic activity, the size of capital holdings or investments, corporate functions, or any other relevant economic criterion. An influential businessperson can be listed because of activity in Russia, whatever the sector of that activity. Then comes the figure the press release blurred. It is common ground between the parties that he holds 28.64 per cent of Evraz’s capital. He is one of its most important shareholders, because only three other shareholders hold more than 5 per cent, and given that stake he is the principal shareholder. That holding gives him the highest percentage of voting rights among the four main shareholders, who together hold 61.54 per cent of those rights, the rest of the capital being free float. Influence, in this case law, is not 50 per cent plus one share. It is economic weight.
On the third limb, the Court accepts that steel and mining are a substantial source of revenue for the Russian government. Evraz’s 2021 annual report, as recorded in the judgment, shows that steel brought in 12.5 billion US dollars, and that steel revenues in Russia, which rose 48.3 per cent between 2020 and 2021, represented 66.3 per cent of the group’s total revenues. The Court concluded that the Council had sufficiently established that the steel and mining sector in which the applicant is involved through Evraz provides a substantial source of revenue to the Russian government. The same bundle of indicia was extended to his holding in Norilsk Nickel. The Court then drew the line: the Council had not made an error of assessment in finding that the applicant met both the first and the third limbs of modified criterion (g) on the respective dates of the contested acts. The third plea, human dignity, and the second plea, illegality of criterion (g) itself, were rejected as well. The Court will not let a listed businessman convert a sanctions criterion into a personalised bill of attainder, nor will it strike the criterion because it uses a presumption of interdependence between leading Russian businesspeople and the State.
B. Can he still win on appeal, proportionality or his EU passport?
The fifth plea was proportionality, dressed as a practical impossibility. Abramovich argued that UK measures on Evraz, plus the attitude of Computershare and Euroclear, had locked him out of the shareholder register, so he could not sell, so the listing had become a permanent freeze, so it was no longer a temporary CFSP measure. The Court did not need to rewrite sanctions law to answer that. It asked for proof. It held that he had not produced sufficient material to establish an impossibility of disposing of his Evraz shares, in the absence in particular of essential documents or formal refusals from the entities mentioned. A 31 October 2024 opinion of Ian Forrester and Usman Tariq, and email traffic with Evraz and the UK Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation, were treated as insufficient to show an explicit and final refusal. The opinion referred to documents that were not annexed. The emails at most evidenced steps taken and requests for information that had received no formal reply. A sanctions defendant who says he cannot divest must prove a closed door, not a difficult corridor. The Court then held that the Council had carried out the required periodic review and that neither the general context nor his particular situation had changed so as to make the original evidence obsolete.
The sixth plea used the Portuguese passport. The argument was that Directive 2004/38 and the EU citizen’s right to move freely forbid a travel ban that is not based on personal conduct. The Court rejected the transplant. The right of free movement is not unconditional. Limitations arising from CFSP acts are not the same as the public-policy restrictions Member States may apply under Article 27 of Directive 2004/38. Article 40 TEU keeps those competences apart, so the limitations in Directive 2004/38, which are addressed to the Member States, cannot bind the Council in the CFSP. The Court then tested the restriction against Article 52(1) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights. The limitation is provided for by law because Decision 2014/145, based on Article 29 TEU, itself defines who may be banned. Articles 1 and 2 of that Decision set the categories, and Article 1(2) to (4), (6) and (6a) provide for derogations. The measures were therefore provided for by law within the meaning of the first sentence of Article 52(1) of the Charter. They also pursue a public-interest objective: increasing the cost of Russia’s actions against Ukraine and promoting a peaceful settlement, in line with Article 21(2)(b) and (c) TEU and with the Court of Justice’s judgment in Rosneft, C-72/15. An EU passport is not a sanctions exemption. It is a reason to check the Charter. The check was made. It failed.
Damages failed with the rest. Non-contractual liability under the second paragraph of Article 340 TFEU requires a sufficiently serious breach of a rule conferring rights on individuals, actual damage, and a causal link. Because the listing acts were not held unlawful, one of those cumulative conditions was missing and the Union’s liability could not be engaged. The result of the whole case is that the action must be dismissed in its entirety. The operative part, pronounced in public hearing in Luxembourg on 9 September 2026, is two lines: the action is dismissed, and Mr Roman Arkadyevich Abramovich shall bear his own costs and those incurred by the Council. The unofficial press note, which does not bind the Court, adds the standard appeal warning: a further appeal, limited to points of law, may be brought before the Court of Justice within two months and ten days of notification. That is the remaining Luxembourg track. It is not a stay. French banks do not wait for an appeal before applying Regulation No 269/2014.
Readers who followed the General Court’s 3 September 2026 ruling in Inter Rao Lietuva, where a corporate listing was struck down, should not confuse the two files. A company can win if the Council’s evidence does not match the criterion. A named individual with a documented 28.64 per cent stake in a Russian steel major, on a criterion that targets exactly that profile, is in a different evidential world. The Kesaev tobacco-foundation case decided on 2 September 2026 is closer in outcome — freeze upheld — but the facts are not interchangeable. Abramovich’s case is about criterion (g), Evraz, Norilsk Nickel, and an EU passport. It is not about a foundation structure. Anyone copying a sanctions-always-lose or sanctions-always-win headline from either judgment is not reading the operative part.
II. If Abramovich money sits in France, can you unfreeze it or get paid?
A. What must a French bank do the day Luxembourg upholds the freeze?
French law does not wait for a Paris court to domesticate an EU listing. Article L. 562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code is the operational command: « Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre et aux articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 et d’en informer immédiatement le ministre chargé de l’économie ». The duty binds every natural person on French territory, and the legal persons listed in the article, including those with a French seat for their foreign business and those with a foreign seat for their French business. The words sans délai are not a slogan. They are the statutory timetable. A Paris desk that waits for the appeal in T-358/25, or for a client letter explaining that the General Court overstated majority control, is already late.
The definitions sit in article L. 562-1. Funds include cash, deposits, financial instruments, claims, letters of credit and « Tout document attestant la détention de parts d’un fonds ou de ressources financières ». Economic resources are assets that are not funds but can be used to obtain funds, goods or services. The freeze of funds is defined as « toute action tendant à empêcher un changement de leur volume, montant, localisation, propriété, possession, nature, destination ou toute autre modification qui pourrait permettre leur utilisation, notamment la gestion de portefeuille ». That last phrase matters for wealth managers in the 8th arrondissement: portfolio management of frozen assets is itself a freeze issue, not a harmless back-office service.
The national power to freeze for UN and EU measures is article L. 562-3: the minister for the economy « peut décider, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques » belonging to persons who commit, facilitate or finance actions sanctioned by Chapter VII UN resolutions or by acts adopted under Article 29 TEU or Article 75 TFEU, or who are designated on the basis of those resolutions or acts. Abramovich’s EU listing is the second route: designation on the basis of a CFSP act. The national article exists so that France can also freeze on its own decision. It does not replace Regulation No 269/2014. Banks apply both. Article L. 562-5 then states the matching prohibition: it is forbidden « de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel ». Article L. 562-6 closes the obvious hole: it is forbidden to « participer, sciemment et volontairement, à des activités ayant pour objet ou pour effet de contourner les mesures prises en vertu du présent chapitre et des articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 ». Paying a listed person’s supplier, parking value in a relative’s account, or dressing a transfer as a loan to a non-listed vehicle is the statutory risk, not a clever structure.
Publication and publicity follow. Article L. 562-9 makes ministerial freeze decisions « exécutoires à compter de leur date de publication ». Article L. 562-8 lets the economy minister ask for the freeze to be published in the land registry or the livre foncier, and lets the interior minister register an opposition to any transfer of a vehicle registration certificate. A Paris apartment, a Neuilly house, a yacht in a French port: the freeze is not only a bank message. Good-faith operators are not left naked. Article L. 562-13 provides that « L’Etat est responsable des conséquences dommageables de la mise en œuvre de bonne foi, par les personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 , leurs dirigeants ou leurs préposés, des mesures de gel ou des interdictions prises en application du présent chapitre ». No professional sanction may be imposed on them for that good-faith implementation. The French bargain is severe and protective at once: apply immediately, tell the minister, and the State carries the civil cost of a bona fide freeze.
There is a humanitarian valve, not a commercial one. Article L. 562-11 allows the economy minister to authorise the unfreezing and making available of part of the frozen funds « si leur utilisation est compatible avec la sauvegarde de l’ordre public et avec les décisions et les actes à l’origine de la décision de gel ». The listed person, or a third party with a right over the assets, may apply. The statutory grounds are narrow: « besoins matériels particuliers intéressant sa vie personnelle ou familiale » for a natural person, or an activity compatible with public order for a legal person, or « décisions de nature à assurer la conservation de son patrimoine ». School fees and basic subsistence are the register. A request to unfreeze so that a creditor can be paid, or so that Evraz shares can be reshuffled, is not what the article describes. The Direction générale du Trésor in Paris is the practical addressee, as the Treasury’s own sanctions hub makes clear when it tells operators how to identify listed persons, how to check a transaction, and how to report suspected circumvention. That hub, and the dedicated Russia page, explain packages and FAQs. They do not analyse T-358/25. Today’s judgment is the missing piece: Luxembourg has now said, for the 2025 renewals, that the listing holds.
B. Can a creditor seize frozen funds, and what is the criminal risk of circumvention?
Creditors keep trying. On 5 February 2026 the Cour de cassation, Second Civil Chamber, in judgment No 121 F-B, pourvoi n° 23-15.936, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2026:C200121, published in the Bulletin, rejected an appeal by a Kuwaiti company that had obtained a Paris JEX order to attach sums held at Société Générale in the name of the Libyan Investment Authority. The LIA is frozen under a different regulation — Council Regulation (EU) 2016/44 — but the Court’s method is the one a French lawyer will apply by analogy to Regulation No 269/2014. The Court held that no enforcement measure may be pursued against frozen funds or economic resources if it would take them out of the debtor’s estate or even confer on the pursuing creditor « un simple droit de préférence », without prior authorisation from the director of the Treasury as the designated national authority. It then drew the consequence: « à défaut d’autorisation préalable du directeur du Trésor, aucune mesure de saisie-attribution, laquelle emporte, à concurrence des sommes pour lesquelles elle est pratiquée, attribution immédiate au profit du saisissant de la créance saisie disponible entre les mains du tiers et de ses accessoires, ne peut être autorisée ou validée par le juge de l’exécution ». That judge is seized on application under article L. 111-1-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures, which provides: « Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée ne peuvent être mises en œuvre sur un bien appartenant à un Etat étranger que sur autorisation préalable du juge par ordonnance rendue sur requête. » The Court added that the Sapin 2 prior authorisation of the JEX for measures against property of a foreign State « n’a pas fait disparaître l’exigence de l’autorisation administrative préalable du directeur du Trésor », and that « l’autorisation administrative doit précéder celle du juge de l’exécution ». Without a Trésor authorisation, the JEX could not allow the attachment of frozen assets. Abramovich is not a foreign State. Article L. 111-1-1 is therefore not the first key for his private assets. The first key is the EU freeze itself, which forbids making funds available. The LIA judgment shows what a Paris enforcement judge does when EU law has already frozen the account: no attachment, no preference, no sorting the licence later.
Nor does the freeze wipe the listed person’s debts as if by magic. On 10 July 2020 the Cour de cassation, sitting as a full court (Assemblée plénière), in arrêt n° 653 P+B+R+I, pourvois n° 18-18.542 and 18-21.814, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2020:PL00653, published in the Bulletin, dealt with Bank Sepah, an Iranian bank whose assets had been frozen under the UN and EU Iran regime. The bank argued force majeure and asked for statutory interest to stop running while it could not pay. The holding that still governs a listed debtor in Paris is: « Ne constitue pas un cas de force majeure pour celle qui le subit, faute d’extériorité, le gel des avoirs d’une personne ou d’une entité qui est frappée par cette mesure en raison de ses activités. » A freeze that is the legal consequence of the debtor’s own designation is not an external event. Interest can keep running. The same judgment referred questions to the Court of Justice on whether even a non-assigning security or conservatory attachment could be placed on frozen assets without prior national authorisation. The lesson for an Abramovich creditor is double and uncomfortable: you may still have a claim, with interest, but you may not help yourself to the frozen pot without the channel the EU regulation and the Trésor provide. That is the practical French reading of today’s Luxembourg dismissal, and it is the point a general page such as Village de la Justice’s discussion of asset freezes as a drastic but challengeable measure never reaches, because it discusses contestability in the abstract and does not have T-358/25 or the 2026 LIA attachment ruling on the table.
Criminal law is not a footnote. Article L. 574-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code, in force, punishes « de se soustraire aux obligations en résultant ou de faire obstacle à sa mise en oeuvre ». The penalties are those in paragraph 1 of article L. 542-1 of the Customs Code, and the customs rules on finding, prosecuting and punishing the offence are imported. On 29 November 2023 the Cour de cassation, Criminal Chamber, in pourvoi n° 22-85.867, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2023:CR01416, published in the Bulletin, reviewed convictions for « soustraction aux mesures de gel des avoirs » after ministerial orders under article L. 562-2. The underlying freeze there was the terrorism track, not the Russia track. The criminal article is the same. The Court recorded that four joint orders of the finance and interior ministers had frozen the defendants’ bank assets for successive six-month periods. It held that opening accounts in a foreign bank just after the first freeze period, in order to have funds available during the next freeze, « caractérise leur soustraction à la mesure de gel, la loi n’exigeant en outre aucune dissimulation ou manoeuvre ». It then added the sentence every listed person with a foreign account should read: « il ne saurait être déduit de ce que les établissements financiers étrangers n’étaient pas soumis à l’obligation d’appliquer les mesures de gel avant le 6 novembre 2020 que les personnes dont les avoirs avaient alors été gelés pouvaient, sans se rendre coupable du délit prévu par l’article L. 574-3, contourner ces mesures de gel en utilisant un compte bancaire au sein d’un tel établissement. » The Court quashed only the customs fine and confiscation against one defendant, for a sentencing defect. The finding of circumvention stood. A listed businessman who treats a foreign bank as a sandbox, or a French intermediary who helps him, is in L. 574-3 territory. The terrorism origin of that file does not make the criminal article inapplicable to an EU Russia freeze. Article L. 574-3 refers to the whole freeze chapter and to the persons listed in article L. 562-4.
Paris is where much of this is litigated. The LIA attachment was authorised, then retracted, by the juge de l’exécution of the tribunal judiciaire de Paris, then taken to the Paris Court of Appeal, then to the Cour de cassation. Bank Sepah’s enforcement fight also ran through the Paris Court of Appeal. The Direction générale du Trésor, which must authorise any dealing with frozen funds, sits in Paris. A file with a French account, a French notary, a French subsidiary or a French judgment debtor will be a Paris file even if the beneficial owner lives in Nemchinovo. The cabinet’s guide to contesting an international freeze in France remains the hub for the domestic procedure: ministerial licences under article L. 562-11, liability of good-faith operators under article L. 562-13, and the administrative track against a national freeze order. Today’s judgment does not rewrite that hub. It tells the listed person, and everyone who holds his money, that the EU listing of number 879 survived the 2025 renewals.
Conclusion
T-358/25 is a third consecutive General Court defeat for Roman Abramovich on the Ukraine listing, after T-313/22 in December 2023 and T-1105/23 in September 2025. The Court did not find that he owns Evraz outright. It found that 28.64 per cent, as the largest block among four major shareholders holding 61.54 per cent together, plus steel and mining revenue equal to 66.3 per cent of Evraz’s 2021 turnover, placed him inside both the influential-businessperson-active-in-Russia limb and the substantial-source-of-revenue limb of criterion (g). Working parties did not steal the Council’s decision. An EU passport did not oust the CFSP. An unproven story about Computershare and Euroclear did not turn the freeze into a disproportionate life sentence. Damages fell with the legality challenge. An appeal on points of law remains possible within two months and ten days of notification. It does not unlock French accounts.
In France the listing is already a bank instruction, a notarial red flag and, if someone tries to walk around it, a customs-linked offence. Article L. 562-4 requires immediate application. Articles L. 562-5 and L. 562-6 forbid making funds available and forbid circumvention. Article L. 574-3 punishes both the listed person and the French operator who obstructs the freeze. The Cour de cassation has held that a freeze is not force majeure for the person who is listed because of his activities, and that a Paris JEX may not validate an attachment of frozen funds without prior Trésor authorisation. Anyone who holds, claims, or is asked to move value connected to number 879 should treat 9 September 2026 as a compliance date, not a press cutting. The next useful document is not a comment on Chelsea Football Club. It is the licence file, the account freeze letter, or the appeal notice — each of them dated, numbered, and read against the judgment that was actually handed down.