KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Abramovich Loses Again in Luxembourg: Why the EU General Court Upheld His Sanctions Listing on 9 September 2026 — and What It Means in France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Abramovich Loses Again in Luxembourg: Why the EU General Court Upheld His Sanctions Listing on 9 September 2026 — and What It Means in France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 9 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union in Luxembourg dismissed the third sanctions challenge brought by Roman Abramovich and upheld the renewal of the European Union’s asset freeze and travel ban against him. The judgment in case T-358/25, announced in Press Release No 124/26, rejects every line of the oligarch’s attack on the two 2025 renewal packages and confirms that the leading-businessperson listing criterion, the evidentiary use of his Evraz and Norilsk Nickel holdings, and the Council’s six-month rollover method all comply with EU law, including the Charter of Fundamental Rights. The ruling lands exactly one week after this firm reported the opposite outcome for two other Russian billionaires: as analysed in our report on the delisting of Usmanov and Fridman, the Council can and does remove names when the file no longer supports the listing. Abramovich shows the mirror image: when the economic footprint remains, Luxembourg upholds the freeze even against an applicant holding the passport of an EU Member State. For readers in France, where banks apply the freeze daily, where frozen villas and accounts sit within the jurisdiction of the Paris courts, and where listed persons instruct counsel to seek living expenses, legal fees and ultimately delisting, the judgment is a practical manual. It states what evidence keeps a name on the list, which arguments Luxembourg has now rejected three times, and which narrow doors, derogation requests and a fresh annulment action filed on time, remain open. This analysis reconstructs the 9 September ruling from the Court’s own release, sets it against the September 2026 sanctions docket, and translates it into the French procedural roadmap: immediate bank freeze, prohibited dealings, ministerial authorisations, and the Luxembourg-only path to annulment.

I. The 9 September 2026 judgment in Abramovich v Council (T-358/25): what Luxembourg actually decided

A. Two renewal packages challenged after two earlier defeats: Decisions 2025/528 and 2025/1895 under review

Mr Abramovich is described by the Court as a businessman holding Russian, Israeli and Portuguese nationality who is, in particular, the majority shareholder of the Evraz parent company, one of the leading Russian steel and mining groups. That three-passport profile matters, because the Portuguese nationality makes him a citizen of the European Union, and part of his case turned on the restriction of an EU citizen’s movement. The sanctions history is long. After Russia’s full-scale attack on Ukraine of 24 February 2022, the Council froze the funds of, and banned from EU entry and transit, leading businesspersons active in economic sectors treated as a substantial source of revenue for the Russian Government. Abramovich was listed in 2022, challenged that listing, and lost: by its judgments of 20 December 2023 and 10 September 2025, the General Court dismissed those actions, in cases T-313/22 and T-1105/23. The new case concerns what happened next. After receiving the observations submitted by Mr Abramovich, the Council adopted new acts extending the measures, first to 15 September 2025 and then to 15 March 2026. The first extension rests on Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/528 of 14 March 2025 amending Decision 2014/145/CFSP and on Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/527 of 14 March 2025 implementing Regulation (EU) No 269/2014. The second rests on Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 of 12 September 2025 and Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1894 of 12 September 2025. Abramovich then adapted his action to seek, first, annulment of those latter acts and, second, compensation for the non-material harm he claimed the adoption of those acts caused him. The 9 September 2026 judgment dismisses the action in full and upholds the Council’s acts, including on the damages claim. Three procedural points in the release deserve attention from practitioners. First, the Court rejects the argument that the measures were adopted de facto by the Council working parties responsible for preparatory work: the Council had merely used that preparatory work to inform its own decision on the contested measures, and involving those bodies to simplify the final decision that working-party involvement did not amount to giving up or delegating its decision-making power. Working-party process complaints, in other words, do not invalidate a renewal. Second, the listing criterion itself comes from the June 2023 reform package, Council Decision (CFSP) 2023/1094 of 5 June 2023 and Council Regulation (EU) 2023/1089 of 5 June 2023 amending the Ukraine territorial-integrity regime, and the Court treats that criterion as falling within the Council’s broad discretion. Third, the judgment confirms the rhythm of the regime: listings are reviewed and rolled over roughly every six months, each rollover is a separately challengeable act, and each challenge restarts the evidentiary debate on the applicant’s current economic weight. A listed person with French assets therefore faces not one freeze decision but a chain of them, and a failed challenge to one link does not prevent a differently evidenced challenge to the next, as the Usmanov and Fridman delistings demonstrate. The contrast is instructive and should be read together with our analysis of the RT France asset-freeze litigation, where the fight concerned entities and propaganda financing rather than an individual’s industrial holdings, and with our report on the Bank of Russia’s September 2026 action against the EU anti-enforcement mechanism, which attacks the sanctions architecture from the sovereign side while Abramovich attacks it from the individual side. Luxembourg is thus deciding the same war of freezes on three fronts at once: the central bank, the listed billionaire, and the media apparatus.

B. Why the freeze stays: Evraz, Norilsk Nickel and a criterion the Court calls objective, precise and proportionate

The core of the judgment is the validation of the designation criterion. The Court holds that the criteria for applying the measures are objective, sufficiently precise and proportionate in nature. The reasoning has two branches. First, they aim specifically at leading businesspersons operating in Russia, against a background where the main economic operators have close ties to the State. Second, they target cover persons active in sectors generating significant revenue for the Russian Government, defined as activities of more than negligible importance capable of funding that government’s actions and policies. The release adds that this proportionality assessment is reinforced by the periodic review, as the underlying factual context had not changed, and by the fact that the applicant had suggested no less restrictive alternative capable of achieving the objectives pursued. Applied to Abramovich, the test is satisfied by the scale of his holdings. The listing flowed from applying those criteria, given the scale of his capital holdings, not from any wish to exploit his public fame, as he had argued. The notoriety defence, that a famous name was picked for signal value, is therefore dead for this file: the Court anchors the listing in capital, not celebrity. The capital in question is identified with unusual precision. He is in fact the majority shareholder of Evraz, parent of one of Russia’s leading steel and mining groups, and also holds shares in Norilsk Nickel, one of the world’s foremost palladium producers and a major refined-nickel player, with those steel and mining activities constituting a substantial source of revenue for the Russian Government. Two factual findings close off the standard escape routes. According to the Evraz annual report for 2021, revenues from steel represent 66.3% of the group’s annual revenue, which quantifies the substantial-revenue-source finding instead of leaving it as an assertion. And the Court found that the applicant had not shown that selling his Evraz shares was impossible, which answers the argument, recurrent in delisting files, that the applicant is a passive holder who cannot exit. A Paris lawyer reading this passage should understand exactly what a future delisting file must contain: dated proof of genuine disposal, of loss of control, or of sectoral exit, not press statements of intent. Mere difficulty in selling, without proof of impossibility pursued in good faith, does not move the Court. The fundamental-rights chapter of the judgment will interest every EU-nationality listed person. The Court finds that the measures satisfy EU law, including the Charter of Fundamental Rights, as regards restrictions on fundamental rights and freedoms such as the movement of EU citizens, because those restrictions rest on legislation that clearly and precisely defines the scope of those restrictions. The measures, the Court continues, safeguard the essence of intra-EU movement because they include derogation mechanisms and periodic review, and they are proportionate and suitable for the goal of promoting a peaceful settlement of the crisis in Ukraine. Portuguese nationality, in short, does not shield a leading businessperson from a travel ban whose legal basis is precise, whose exemptions exist, and whose necessity is reviewed every six months. The damages claim fails with the annulment claim, since the illegality that would have grounded compensation was not established. One neighbouring signal from the same docket sharpens the lesson. As sanctions coverage in early September 2026 noted, the Court also ruled that the autocratic character of the Russian state does not by itself prove Moscow’s direct control over individual firms, a reminder that Luxembourg examines economic control concretely, file by file, rather than by presumption. Abramovich loses on that concrete examination because his shareholdings are documented, majority-level, and lodged in revenue-heavy sectors; a differently structured file, with minority stakes, genuine divestiture, or sectors outside the revenue perimeter, can produce the opposite result. That is precisely what happened for the applicants discussed in our delisting report, and it is why each renewal round deserves a fresh evidentiary strategy rather than a repetition of the previous pleadings.

II. Challenging an EU freeze from France: derogations, timelines and the Luxembourg-only annulment route

A. What the freeze means day to day on French territory: banks, bans on making funds available and published real-estate freezes

EU restrictive measures apply directly in France, and French statute organises their daily enforcement. The hinge is Article L. 562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code, under which “Le ministre chargé de l’économie peut décider, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques : 1° Qui appartiennent à, sont possédés, détenus ou contrôlés par des personnes physiques ou morales, ou toute autre entité qui commettent, tentent de commettre, facilitent ou financent des actions sanctionnées ou prohibées par les résolutions adoptées dans le cadre du chapitre VII de la charte des Nations unies ou les actes pris en application de l’article 29 du traité sur l’Union européenne ou de l’article 75 du traité sur le fonctionnement de l’Union européenne, y participent ou qui sont désignées sur le fondement de ces résolutions ou ces actes”. The reference to Article 29 TEU and Article 75 TFEU is the bridge between the Luxembourg listing and the Paris freeze: the EU act designates, the French order relays, and the bank executes. The circle of persons bound to execute is deliberately vast. Article L. 562-4 of the same Code provides that “Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre” a list covering every individual on national territory, the entities subject to anti-money-laundering duties defined in Article L. 561-2, companies operating in France including branches of foreign firms, and public bodies, with an express extension to French companies’ activities abroad. The same article obliges them to inform the Minister for the Economy immediately, and Article R. 562-1 requires obliged entities to maintain internal organisation and procedures capable of applying freezes and making-available bans without delay, scaled to their size and activity. In practice, a Paris bank that detects an Abramovich-type name therefore freezes first and asks questions later, because the statute imposes immediacy, not prior adversarial debate. The content of the freeze is defined by Article L. 562-5: “Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel”. Payments of dividends on frozen shareholdings, provision of services to frozen companies, rental income routed to a listed landlord, all fall within that ban unless a derogation covers them. Real estate receives its own publicity: Article L. 562-8 allows freeze decisions and bans to be published at the land registry or the livre foncier of the property’s location at the Economy Minister’s request, so that a frozen villa on the Côte d’Azur or a Paris apartment cannot be quietly sold or mortgaged. Definitions sit in Article L. 562-1, while the neighbouring national-freeze track in Article L. 562-2, decided jointly by the Economy and Interior Ministers for terrorism-related funds, shows the two-track architecture: EU and UN designations flow through L. 562-3, domestic terrorism designations through L. 562-2, and both converge on the same banker duties. Three consequences follow for counsel in Paris. First, no French court action can lift an EU listing as such; the listing is an EU act, and the French judge applies it. The fight for annulment belongs in Luxembourg, while the fight in France concerns the national relay measures, access authorisations, and the civil consequences of the freeze on contracts, dividends and corporate governance. Second, any transaction touching frozen assets without authorisation aggravates the file: it exposes the counterparty to liability and it undermines the listed person’s later claim to be a cooperative, good-faith applicant. Third, documentation starts on day one: every blocked transfer, every bank notification, every request for authorisation and every ministerial reply builds the record that Luxembourg will later read when it examines proportionality, derogations actually sought, and cooperation. The Abramovich judgment rewards files, not narratives: the Court counted share certificates, revenue percentages and the absence of disposal evidence, and it dismissed the notoriety story for lack of proof.

B. The two clocks that matter: ministerial authorisations for daily life and the two-month action in Luxembourg

The first clock runs in Paris and Bercy. Article L. 562-11 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides that “Le ministre chargé de l’économie peut autoriser le déblocage et la mise à disposition d’une partie des fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l’objet d’une mesure de gel en vertu des articles L. 562-3”, among others, “ou d’un acte pris en application de l’article 29 du traité sur l’Union européenne ou de l’article 75 du traité sur le fonctionnement de l’Union européenne, si leur utilisation est compatible avec la sauvegarde de l’ordre public et avec les décisions et les actes à l’origine de la décision de gel”. These authorisations may be granted on the ministers’ own initiative or on request “à la demande de toute personne physique ou morale ou autre entité visée par cette décision ou de tout tiers pouvant exciper d’un droit sur les fonds et ressources économiques ayant fait l’objet d’une décision de gel”, and they are granted where the listed person shows either particular material needs of personal or family life, for an individual, or compatible activity and asset preservation. In the EU sanctions context this national channel mirrors the derogations written into Regulation 269/2014 itself, for basic needs, legal fees, and extraordinary expenses subject to prior notification or approval procedures, and the General Court in Abramovich expressly relied on the existence of those safety valves: the travel and funds restrictions respect the essence of movement rights because they include derogation mechanisms and periodic review. Counsel should therefore treat the derogation request as a substantive file, not a formality: itemised monthly budget, school and medical proofs, counsel fee agreements, corporate preservation costs, bank attestations of the frozen balances, and a precise legal citation of the derogation ground invoked. A refusal can itself be challenged, and a pattern of well-documented requests followed by reasoned refusals strengthens a later proportionality argument in Luxembourg. The second clock runs in Luxembourg and it is merciless. An action for annulment against each renewal act must be brought before the General Court within two months of notification or publication, extended by the ten-day distance period, and the Court’s own release recalls the sequel: An appeal confined to points of law lies to the Court of Justice against the General Court’s decision within two months and ten days of its notification. Miss the first deadline and the renewal becomes unchallengeable; win or lose, the appeal lies only on law, not on a re-weighing of the Evraz spreadsheets. Because the Council renews roughly every six months, the calendar is a permanent compliance task: observations to the Council before each rollover, preservation of disposal evidence, updated corporate records, and a draft annulment ready to file. The Abramovich sequence also teaches what not to plead a fourth time. The working-parties delegation theory has now failed; the notoriety theory has now failed three times; the abstract Charter frontal assault has failed where derogations and reviews exist. What succeeded elsewhere, and remains the only proven exit, is the concrete evidentiary route: show that the holdings that justified the listing are gone, that control has genuinely passed, or that the sectoral link has snapped, and invite the Council to draw the consequence at the next review before asking the Court to do so. The Usmanov and Fridman delistings followed that logic, and the September 2026 docket shows the Court applying it symmetrically, upholding where majority industrial holdings persist, releasing where the file no longer supports the criterion. For a listed person with French links, the operational checklist is therefore short and dated: freeze mapped across every French bank, insurer and custodian; land-registry publications checked; derogation requests filed and calendared; observations lodged with the Council ahead of the March and September rollovers; annulment filed in Luxembourg within the two-month window; and an appeal lies only on points of law. Paris counsel coordinates the French half, Luxembourg counsel pleads the annulment, and neither half waits for the other.

Conclusion

The 9 September 2026 judgment in T-358/25 is the General Court’s clearest statement to date of what keeps a Russian businessperson on the EU sanctions list: documented majority holdings in revenue-heavy sectors, reviewed every six months, under a criterion the Court deems objective, precise and proportionate, with derogations and reviews answering the fundamental-rights objection and capital weight answering the notoriety complaint. Abramovich’s triple nationality, his Evraz majority, his Norilsk Nickel stake, the 66.3% steel share of group revenue, and his inability to prove that selling was impossible together made the listing, in the Court’s words, the application of the criteria rather than the exploitation of a famous name. The damages claim fell with the annulment claim, and any appeal lies within two months and ten days on points of law only. Read beside the Usmanov and Fridman delistings, the ruling completes the two-sided message of the September 2026 docket: the Council delists when the economic file empties and Luxembourg upholds when it does not. In France, the translation is immediate and statutory: immediate bank freeze under Article L. 562-4, total ban on making funds available under Article L. 562-5, land-registry publication under Article L. 562-8, and ministerial derogations under Article L. 562-11 for the needs the freeze does not intend to crush. No Paris pleading reopens the EU listing itself; only a timely Luxembourg action does. Listed persons, their banks and their counterparties should therefore run both clocks at once, the Bercy derogation file and the Luxembourg annulment calendar, and build the disposal evidence that alone has unlocked exits this month. Our firm follows each General Court sanctions ruling from Paris and acts before the French administration and courts, the General Court of the European Union and the enforcement judge in asset-freeze, derogation, delisting and cross-border enforcement matters.

📄 Official circular