Your father lived in California, wrote a California will, and left everything to his second wife. You, his American child, receive nothing. Then you learn that he still owned an apartment in Paris. Can the law of California follow that apartment to Paris and disinherit you there too, or does French law give you a way to take your share from the French property? This question sits at the exact fault line between American testamentary liberty and the French forced share, and it has moved three times in ten years: first the Court of Cassation closed the main door in 2017, then Parliament opened a side door in 2021, and in June 2026 the European Commission pushed that side door half shut again. This guide explains, for an American reader with no French legal background, how a disinherited child can still claim money from French assets through the mechanism called the prélèvement compensatoire, the compensatory levy of Article 913 of the Civil Code, what conditions must be met, how the amount is computed, which time limits apply, and where the June 2026 European development leaves California estates in particular.
Two warnings before starting. First, this mechanism never rewrites the American will and never seizes assets located in the United States; it operates only on property situated in France on the day of death. Second, several computation questions remain genuinely debated among French practitioners, and only the notaire handling the succession and, if there is a dispute, the French court fix the final figure. What follows describes the verified rules and the honest limits of what the sources consulted for this article actually decide.
I. Why a California Will Can Disinherit You, and When France Lets You Answer
A. The California will stands: France will not tear it up to save you
Start with the hard part. A testator domiciled in California enjoys, under California law, a broad power to dispose of his property by will, including the power to leave a child nothing. When such a succession reaches a French court, the first question is which law governs, and the second is whether France will set that law aside in the name of French public policy. On both points, the answers favor the will, and they come from the highest French court in two decisions handed down on the same day, 27 September 2017, in the succession of the composer Maurice Jarre, who had organized his estate under California law.
On the applicable law, the European Succession Regulation, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, supplies the rule for successions opened since 17 August 2015. Its default rule, applied by the Court of Cassation in cross-border cases such as its 18 November 2020 decision on habitual residence under the Regulation, is that unless the deceased validly chose another law, the law of the country where he habitually lived at death governs the whole succession, including the Paris apartment. And the Regulation allows a choice, called professio juris, in favor of nationality: a person may designate the law of the state whose nationality he holds, whether at the time of the choice or at death, to govern the whole succession. An American living in California will therefore very often have his succession, French apartment included, governed by California law, either by habitual residence or by an express choice of American law in the will. Readers who want the full mechanics of that choice should read our companion explanation of how an American owner uses professio juris to choose the law of his Paris succession, which maps the habitual-residence test and the nationality choice step by step.
That designation of California law then faces the French public-policy challenge: surely, the disinherited children argued, a foreign law that lets a father leave his children nothing contradicts the essential principles of French law and must be discarded. The Court of Cassation answered no, twice, in First Civil Chamber decisions No. 16-17.198 and No. 16-13.151 of 27 September 2017. The published holding of the Jarre decision reads: Une loi étrangère désignée par la règle de conflit qui ignore la réserve héréditaire n’est pas en soi contraire à l’ordre public international français et ne peut être écartée que si son application concrète, au cas d’espèce, conduit à une situation incompatible avec les principes du droit français considérés comme essentiels. The companion Colombier decision holds in identical terms: Mais attendu qu’une loi étrangère désignée par la règle de conflit qui ignore la réserve héréditaire n’est pas en soi contraire à l’ordre public international français et ne peut être écartée que si son application concrète, au cas d’espèce, conduit à une situation incompatible avec les principes du droit français considérés comme essentiels. In the Jarre case itself, the court recorded that the applicable law was that of the State of California, which does not know the forced share, and it refused to discard it, noting in particular that it was not argued that applying California law would leave an heir in economic need.
The practical meaning for an American child is blunt. If your father was habitually resident in California, or validly chose American law, and his will leaves everything to his spouse, a French court will not annul the will, will not declare California law inapplicable in general, and will not recreate a French-style forced share out of public policy alone. The only public-policy opening the 2017 decisions preserve is concrete and narrow: a case-by-case showing that applying the foreign law produces, in the specific circumstances, a situation incompatible with principles of French law regarded as essential, with economic need or destitution as the paradigmatic example. A comfortable adult child who simply receives less, or nothing, while the stepmother inherits, does not fit that opening. For years after 2017, that was the end of the road for most disinherited children of California domiciliaries. Then Parliament built a different road that does not require attacking the foreign law at all.
B. The 2021 French answer: take your share from the assets located in France
Rather than asking courts to discard California law, the French Parliament created a levy that operates alongside it. The Law of 24 August 2021 added a third paragraph to Article 913 of the Civil Code, and the mechanism deserves to be read in full, because every word is a condition. The paragraph provides: Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci. In ordinary language, four cumulative conditions emerge, and each must be checked with documents, not assumptions.
First, the European anchor: at the moment of death, either the deceased or at least one of his children must be a national of a European Union member state or habitually resident in one. For an American family this condition is frequently met through the French side of the story, for example a child who lives in Paris, or a deceased who, though American, was habitually resident in France. But consider the mirror case carefully: an American father who lived and died in California, whose children all live in the United States and hold only American nationality, does not satisfy this anchor, and the levy is then unavailable. Nationality is proved by passport or certificate of nationality, habitual residence by the full circumstances of actual life, and the assessment is made strictly at the date of death, not at the date the will was signed.
Second, the foreign law applicable to the succession must allow no protective reserved mechanism for children at all. This is the condition on which everything now turns, and California is precisely the test case. California law knows no forced share for children; a testator may intentionally disinherit a child, and the pretermitted-heir statutes of California protect only children unintentionally omitted from the will, not children deliberately left nothing by a will that names the exclusion. Whether a court would characterize those omitted-heir statutes as a mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants for a deliberately disinherited child is a question the published decisions consulted for this article do not yet answer for California, and it must be presented to the court as an open question rather than asserted as settled. What is settled is the direction of travel at European level: in a June 2026 analysis of the European Commission’s pre-closure letter on complaints against France, the notarial research center CRIDON Nord-Est reports that under the Commission’s guidance a literal and restrictive reading prevails, the levy applies only where the normally applicable foreign law allows no protective reserved mechanism whatever, and the family-provision remedies of Anglo-Saxon systems, such as the English family provision, are treated as a functional equivalent that blocks the levy when English law governs. The same analysis concludes that most legal systems that ignore the forced share do know some child-protection device, so that the practical field of the levy could become narrow. An American child relying on California law should therefore build the file around the distinction the Commission’s reading invites: document that the disinheritance was intentional and complete, that no Californian device was available to the deliberately excluded child, and that the estate’s structure left no equivalent protection, while accepting that the characterization remains for the judge to decide. The CRIDON piece is dated 10 June 2026 and links the Commission’s letter itself, and it should be read by anyone filing a claim, because it signals how French courts may soon construe the key phrase; see the 10 June 2026 CRIDON Nord-Est analysis of the Commission’s pre-closure letter, published on the research center’s website.
Third, the levy attaches only to existing assets situated in France on the day of death. Bank accounts in California, a house in Texas, American securities: all are outside the levy. The Paris apartment, a French bank balance, French shares: all are inside. Gifts the deceased already gave away during his lifetime are not themselves seized, though, as Section II explains, they re-enter the computation fictitiously to measure the shortfall. Fourth, the levy is capped: the child is restored to the reserved rights French law grants, within the limit of those rights, and not a dollar or a euro beyond. The levy is compensation measured by French reserved shares, not an American-style damages award and not a second full inheritance.
Two judicial confirmations strengthen the mechanism while illustrating its boundaries. The Paris Court of Appeal, in a decision of 24 September 2025, expressly described the legislative history in these terms: la loi n° 2021-1109 du 24 août 2021 a introduit un troisième alinéa à l’article 913 du code civil, instituant un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens situés en France, lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants. The same court recalled that through this later statute the French legislature confirmed the importance of the reserved-share mechanism, including in successions governed by foreign law, treating it as necessary to the general interest, and on that ground it rejected an attempt to have Articles 912 and 913 set aside as contrary to Article 17 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights on property. The lesson is twofold: the levy has survived direct constitutional and European-rights attacks so far, but its battlefield has moved to statutory interpretation, above all the meaning of no protective reserved mechanism, where the Commission’s restrictive reading now weighs heavily.
II. How an American Child Actually Collects the Levy on a Paris Apartment
A. Doing the math: the reserved fraction, the fictitious mass, and the indemnity
French forced heirship starts from a vocabulary that has no American equivalent and must be learned first. Article 912 of the Civil Code defines the two halves of every succession calculation: La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités. The réserve is the slice the law keeps for protected heirs, today the children and, in the absence of children, the surviving spouse; the quotité disponible is everything else, the slice the deceased could give to anyone, including a second wife, by gift or will. The size of the children’s slice is fixed by the opening words of Article 913: one half of the property where the deceased leaves one child, one third where he leaves two children, one quarter where he leaves three or more. Note the related rule, in the same article, that a child who renounces the succession counts in the number of children only if he is represented or owes return of a gift under Article 845, a point that matters before any renunciation is signed, because renouncing to express contempt for the will can shrink the very fraction on which the levy is measured.
The computation then follows Article 922, which builds what practitioners call the fictitious mass: La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant. Debts are deducted, lifetime gifts are added back at their value on the day of death, and the reserved fraction is applied to that total. Where the gifts and legacies exceed the disposable slice, Article 924 converts the shortfall into money: Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent. The beneficiary pays an indemnity equal to the excess; the apartment need not be sold and cut in two.
Take a simplified illustration with explicit assumptions, not a prediction. Suppose the father leaves one child, a Paris apartment worth 600,000 euros, California accounts worth the equivalent of 700,000 euros, and no debts, and suppose the French-law reserved right of the single child is treated as one half of the reference mass. On a worldwide reference mass of 1,300,000 euros, the reserved right would be 650,000 euros and the child, having received nothing, would be short the full 650,000 euros; but the levy can attach only to the French assets, here 600,000 euros, so the levy would be capped in practice by the French property available. Change one assumption and the result moves: if lifetime gifts to the spouse re-enter the mass, the shortfall grows; if there are two children, the individual fraction shrinks to a share of one third; if debts encumber the apartment, the net mass falls. The illustration shows the mechanics, not your figure. In particular, the published sources consulted for this article do not settle whether the reference mass for the levy is computed worldwide or on French assets alone, and competing computations circulate among practitioners; present both measures in the file, claim the higher with reasons, and expect the court to choose. Honesty about that debate is worth more than a false exact number.
One strategic rule closes the computation. Article 845 provides: L’héritier qui renonce à la succession peut cependant retenir le don entre vifs ou réclamer le legs à lui fait jusqu’à concurrence de la portion disponible à moins que le disposant ait expressément exigé le rapport en cas de renonciation. A renunciation is therefore not a neutral gesture: it can forfeit standing, alter the headcount, and interact with gifts already received. An American child who is angry at the will should never renounce the French succession, or accept or disclaim any gift, before the notaire has modeled the effect on the levy. The order of operations is computation first, signatures second.
B. The procedure, the time limits, and the American tax side of the recovery
In practice the levy is raised inside the French settlement of the estate, the règlement de la succession, which for French real estate runs through a French notaire. The notaire draws up the deed of notoriety identifying the heirs, values the French assets, assembles the fictitious mass, and proposes the distribution. The law gives the notaire an active alerting role: Lorsque le notaire constate, lors du règlement de la succession, que les droits réservataires d’un héritier sont susceptibles d’être atteints par les libéralités effectuées par le défunt, il informe chaque héritier concerné et connu, individuellement et, le cas échéant, avant tout partage, de son droit de demander la réduction des libéralités qui excèdent la quotité disponible. An American child should therefore enter the notaire’s file early, with proof of filiation, the American will and its probate documents with apostille and sworn translation, evidence of the EU anchor at the date of death, and a memorandum explaining why California law offers no protective reserved mechanism to a deliberately excluded child. Waiting until the partage is signed and the apartment resold makes every remedy harder, even when the time limit has not yet run.
The time limit itself is stated by Article 921 of the Civil Code in terms that must be quoted exactly, because they contain three nested clocks: Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès. Concretely, and sticking strictly to what that sentence says: a five-year period runs from the opening of the succession, a two-year period runs from the day the heirs learned of the invasion of their reserved share, and no action can be brought more than ten years after death. Each phrase raises questions the quoted sentence does not answer, such as what counts as knowledge of the invasion for an heir living in California who never saw the French file, or how the two shorter periods combine in a cross-border case where the will surfaces late. The decisions consulted for this article do not settle those application questions, so the only safe conduct is to act as if the shortest period applied: instruct the notaire and, if needed, file within months of learning of the death and the will, and never let the file sleep. Standing, at least, is clear from the same article’s opening: only the protected heirs, their heirs and assigns may demand reduction, to the exclusion of donees, legatees, and the creditors of the deceased.
Two cross-border companions complete the file. On the American tax side, the estate-tax treaty between France and the United States and its official commentary organize which country taxes what and how double taxation is relieved; the treaty text is published by the French tax administration at the France-United States succession and gift tax convention, with the administration’s detailed guidance in the BOFIP commentary on the American convention. French-side liability on the Paris apartment and any levy received must be modeled together with the American federal estate-tax position, because the indemnity the child receives is itself an inheritance receipt that each system may characterize in its own way; the file should keep the French notaire’s valuation and the American probate inventory consistent with each other from day one. On the French administrative side, the public-service portal describes the standard settlement steps, heirs’ obligations, and the notaire’s deeds at the service-public page on settling a succession, which is the checklist to work through in parallel with the levy claim so that no ordinary formality, from the declaration of the estate to the publication at the land registry, is missed while the dispute over the reserved share runs its course.
Assemble the claim, then, as four bundles: filiation and standing; the EU anchor proved at the date of death; the California-law memorandum showing an intentional exclusion with no reserved device available to the excluded child, citing the Jarre description of California law and addressing the Commission’s 2026 functional-equivalence reading head-on; and the computation with both mass measures, debts deducted, translations and apostilles attached. That is the file that gives the levy its best chance, whether it ends in a negotiated indemnity before the notaire or in an action for reduction before the French court.
Conclusion
A California will that disinherits you is valid, and since the 2017 Jarre and Colombier decisions France will not set California law aside out of general principle. But validity is not the end of the story where French assets exist. Since the Law of 24 August 2021, Article 913, third paragraph, of the Civil Code lets each child take a compensatory levy on property situated in France, capped at the French reserved rights, where the deceased or a child is anchored in the European Union and the applicable foreign law offers children no protective reserved mechanism. The Paris Court of Appeal confirmed in September 2025 that this legislative choice stands as a matter of general interest, and the European Commission’s June 2026 intervention narrows rather than repeals it, pushing courts toward a restrictive reading in which genuine equivalents, such as English family provision, block the levy. For a deliberately disinherited child of a California domiciliary, the levy remains the serious path: it is measured by French fractions on a fictitious mass, converted into a money indemnity rather than a forced sale, raised through the French notaire within the nested periods of Article 921, and coordinated with the Franco-American tax treaty. Build the four-bundle file early, compute both mass measures, and let the court decide the open questions. The apartment in Paris may still carry the share that the will in California tried to erase.