You bought an apartment in Paris, you live in Texas, California, or Florida, and one evening the question lands on the kitchen table: if something happens to you, who gets the Paris apartment, under which country’s law, and does the piece of paper you signed with your American estate attorney count for anything in France? For an American owner, that question is more urgent than it looks. France applies its own connecting rules to the apartment itself, because the building stands on French soil, while the European Succession Regulation lets you choose the law that governs your estate as a whole, provided you write that choice down in the right form before you die. Get the paperwork right and your Paris apartment passes the way you intended, with one court logic from the notaire’s office to the tax return. Get it wrong and your children may discover, after your death, that a holographic will kept in a desk drawer in Houston was never found, or that a choice of American law written in English does not do what you thought it did to French forced heirship. If your main question is whether American law can set aside French forced heirship for your children, start with our companion guide on how US citizens choose American law for a French house and what forced heirship still takes; the present guide focuses on the instrument itself, writing, registering, and executing a will that works in Paris. This guide explains, for an American reader with no French legal background, how to write a French will that actually works: which law applies to your Paris apartment and how to choose it, what French forced heirship still takes off the table, whether to handwrite your will or dictate it to a French notaire, and how to make sure your heirs find the document and pay the right tax on each side of the Atlantic.
I. Which Law Decides Who Gets Your Paris Apartment, and Can You Choose It Yourself?
A. As an American living in the United States, can you choose the law that governs your Paris apartment?
The starting point surprises many American owners: when you die, the default rule in Europe does not look at your passport. It looks at where you actually lived. Article 21 of European Union Regulation No. 650/2012, the text that harmonized succession conflicts across most of the European Union, makes the law of the country where the deceased had his or her habitual residence at the time of death the default law for the whole estate, including the Paris apartment. In plain English, the law of the country of your habitual residence at death governs your whole estate. For an American who lives full time in Dallas and keeps a second home in the 7th arrondissement, the default law is therefore the law of Texas, not the law of France, even for the French bricks and mortar. That single sentence explains why your American estate plan cannot be ignored in Paris, and also why it cannot simply be trusted to work there without adaptation.
But the same European regulation gives you a way out, and it is the most important planning tool in this entire guide. Article 22 of Regulation No. 650/2012, headed choice of law, lets any person designate the law of a state whose nationality he or she holds, either at the time of the choice or at the time of death, to govern the whole succession. For an American citizen, that means you can designate American law, or French law, to govern your entire succession, and because most American owners who buy in Paris hold only American nationality, the practical choice is binary: Texas law, or French law, for everything, including the apartment. Holders of dual French-American nationality get a wider menu, since a person with several nationalities may choose the law of any state whose nationality he or she holds.
That choice comes with three warnings, and each of them has bitten real families. First, the choice must be written down in a legally recognized form. The regulation requires the choice to be made expressly, in a declaration that takes the form of a testamentary disposition, or to follow from the terms of such a disposition. An oral statement to your children, a letter to your accountant, or a clause buried in a revocable living trust that no French notaire ever sees does not satisfy that requirement. The choice has to appear expressly in a testamentary disposition, which is why the vehicle for the choice matters as much as the choice itself, as explained in Part II below. Second, the choice covers the succession as a whole. You cannot pick French law for the Paris apartment and Texas law for the Houston house within the European system; the designation is unitary, and any splitting has to be managed through the interaction of the two countries’ rules, not through the European choice alone. Third, choosing American law does not evict French courts or the French notaire from the process. The Paris apartment still sits in Paris, the transfer still passes through a French notaire, and French taxes still apply to French real estate, as explained in the final section.
The power of a written choice is not theoretical. On February 20, 2025, the Paris judicial court decided the case of a French national who had lived in Virginia, in the United States, owned an apartment in France, and left a will dated October 21, 2015 choosing French law. The court opened its reasoning with the exact rule: “Aux termes de l’article 22 .1 du règlement européen n°650/2012 applicable depuis le 17 août 2015, une personne peut choisir comme loi régissant l’ensemble de sa succession la loi de l’État dont elle possède la nationalité au moment où elle fait ce choix ou au moment de son décès.” It then verified that the deceased, though domiciled in Virginia at death, held French nationality and owned a French apartment, declared itself competent, and applied French law to the estate. The judgment, indexed under case number 24/54953 on the official Cour de cassation decisions portal (Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, February 20, 2025, RG 24/54953), is the mirror image of your situation with the nationalities reversed: an American domiciled in America who writes “I choose American law” in a valid will gets the symmetrical result, American law applied by the French side to the estate as a whole. The same judgment also shows what happens when families disagree about the will’s meaning: the court appointed a professional estate administrator, because French Civil Code article 813-1 provides: “Le juge peut désigner toute personne qualifiée, physique ou morale, en qualité de mandataire successoral, à l’effet d’administrer provisoirement la succession en raison de l’inertie, de la carence ou de la faute d’un ou de plusieurs héritiers dans cette administration, de leur mésentente, d’une opposition d’intérêts entre eux ou de la complexité de la situation successorale.” (Civil Code, Article 813-1, Légifrance) A clear, professionally drafted will is what keeps your children out of that procedure.
Two further court landmarks complete the picture. When the deceased lived outside Europe altogether, French courts can still take the whole case if the deceased was French and left property in France. The First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation held in a November 18, 2020 decision on appeal number 19-15.438 that “lorsque la résidence habituelle du défunt au moment du décès n’est pas située dans un Etat membre, les juridictions de l’Etat membre dans lequel sont situés des biens successoraux sont néanmoins compétentes pour statuer sur l’ensemble de la succession dans la mesure où le défunt possédait la nationalité de cet Etat membre au moment du décès” (Cass. 1re civ., November 18, 2020, No. 19-15.438). After a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union, which answered on April 7, 2022 in case C-645/20, the Cour de cassation confirmed the outcome on September 21, 2022 (Cass. 1re civ., September 21, 2022, No. 19-15.438). For an American owner, the practical reading is straightforward: if you keep French nationality alongside American nationality, or if your children who inherit are French, the Paris court is available to settle the entire succession, not just the apartment. And for successions that opened before the regulation started applying on August 17, 2015, the old French conflicts rules still govern; the Cour de cassation recalled them on April 14, 2021: “Selon ces principes, les tribunaux français sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession mobilière lorsque le défunt avait son domicile en France. Ils sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession immobilière pour les immeubles situés en France” (Cass. 1re civ., April 14, 2021, No. 19-24.773). That sentence matters if you are settling the estate of a parent who died years ago under the old system, and your notaire will tell you which set of rules your file falls under.
B. Does French forced heirship still limit what you can leave, even if you choose American law?
Here is the question every American owner asks next, and the honest answer has two layers. French domestic law reserves a slice of every estate for the children, and no will can take that slice away when French law governs. French Civil Code article 912 defines the mechanism: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” (Civil Code, Article 912, Légifrance) In American terms, the réserve is a forced share for children and the quotité disponible is the disposable remainder. Only the children are protected in this way; since a 2001 reform, a surviving spouse is no longer a forced heir when children survive, though the spouse keeps strong protection through other devices, including a full choice between ownership shares and a life interest in the home, described in our companion guide for American surviving spouses facing the usufruct-or-ownership choice. The size of the forced share is arithmetic. Article 913 of the Civil Code provides: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” (Civil Code, Article 913, Légifrance) One child means half the estate is reserved and half is disposable; two children mean two thirds reserved and one third disposable; three or more children mean three quarters reserved and one quarter disposable. If your plan gives everything to your spouse, a charity, or one favored child, and French law governs, the disadvantaged children can sue to claw back the excess through the action for reduction, computed on a reconstructed mass of all property owned at death plus lifetime gifts, fictitiously brought back into the mass. Article 922 of the Civil Code describes that computation: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.” (Civil Code, Article 922, Légifrance) Lifetime gifts to one child therefore do not escape the accounting; they are notionally added back before the shares are measured.
The second layer is what happens when you validly choose American law, for example the law of Texas, which knows no forced heirship. The choice is effective: the European regulation makes the chosen law govern the succession as a whole, so a Texas-law will that leaves the Paris apartment entirely to your spouse is not automatically rewritten by the French reserve. But the French legislature added a safety net in 2021 for children cut out by a foreign law with no protective mechanism. The second paragraph of article 913, in force since November 1, 2021, provides: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” (Civil Code, Article 913, second paragraph, Légifrance) In practice, that compensatory levy lets a qualifying child take from the French-situated assets, including the Paris apartment or its sale price, enough to restore the French forced share. Note the trigger conditions carefully: at least the deceased or one child must be a European Union national or habitually resident in the Union, and the foreign law must offer no reserved-share mechanism at all. A purely American family, with no French or European nationality and no habitual residence in Europe, falls outside the levy, and the American-law will then operates in France without a forced-share correction. A mixed family, where one child lives in Paris or holds French nationality through a French parent, falls squarely inside it, and the will must be drafted with that levy priced in from the start.
That distinction drives the entire drafting strategy. If nobody in the family carries European nationality or residence, a clear choice of American law plus a carefully drawn American will, mirrored by a French will for the Paris property, usually achieves your wishes without interference. If any child is French or lives in France, pretending the reserve does not exist is the most expensive mistake in the file: the will should instead work inside the disposable portion, use gifts structured within the quotité disponible, and document lifetime advances so the notaire can compute the article 922 mass without a fight. Either way, the decision must be made deliberately, in writing, now, because after death the connecting factors become fixed and the children litigate over whichever version of the facts helps them. The will you write this year is the instrument that locks in the favorable version.
II. How Do You Write, Register, and Pay For a French Will From Across the Atlantic?
A. Should you handwrite your will or dictate it to a French notaire?
French law starts from a simple definition. Article 895 of the Civil Code states: “Le testament est un acte par lequel le testateur dispose, pour le temps où il n’existera plus, de tout ou partie de ses biens ou de ses droits et qu’il peut révoquer.” (Civil Code, Article 895, Légifrance) A will covers all or part of your property and rights, and you can revoke it at any time before death, which means updating your French will after a birth, a divorce, or the sale of the apartment is always possible and should be treated as routine maintenance. From that definition flow three usable forms, and only three. Theologians of American estate planning sometimes assume a typed, witnessed, English-language document signed before two neighbors works everywhere; in France, it does not, unless it happens to satisfy one of the three French forms or the formal-validity rules of the law of another connected country, a gamble no careful owner takes with a seven-figure apartment.
The first form is the holographic will, the testament olographe, written entirely by your own hand. Article 970 sets three conditions and only three: “Le testament olographe ne sera point valable s’il n’est écrit en entier, daté et signé de la main du testateur : il n’est assujetti à aucune autre forme.” (Civil Code, Article 970, Légifrance) Entirely handwritten, precisely dated with day, month, and year, and signed: no witnesses required, no notaire required, no typing allowed for even a single word. The official service-public guide confirms the details that matter to Americans: the document must never be typed on a computer, even in part; it may be written in a foreign language, so English is permitted; each member of a couple must write a separate will, because one joint document for two spouses is prohibited; and a notaire’s advice before writing is recommended to avoid ambiguity that breeds lawsuits (service-public.fr, Faire un testament). The holographic will costs nothing to make, which is its attraction and its danger. American owners defeat their own wills in predictable ways: typing the body and handwriting only the signature, dating it “December 2025” without a day, signing with an illegible flourish that later experts cannot attribute, or storing the only copy in a safe-deposit box nobody knows about. Every one of those defects has produced litigation in which the will was thrown out and the intestacy rules divided the apartment among heirs the deceased never intended to favor.
The second form is the authentic will, the testament authentique, dictated to a French notaire. Article 971 provides: “Le testament par acte public est reçu par deux notaires ou par un notaire assisté de deux témoins.” (Civil Code, Article 971, Légifrance) You dictate your wishes, the notaire writes them down, reads the text back to you, and everyone signs. The service-public guide adds the practical points: witnesses cannot be your relatives, your legatees, or the notaire’s clerks; if you do not speak French and the notaire does not understand your language, an interpreter assists you; and recognition of a child inside a will requires this authentic form (service-public.fr, Faire un testament). For an American owner, the authentic will has decisive advantages that justify the notaire’s fee: the notaire checks your capacity and identity, keeps the original in the office archives, registers the will’s existence in the national wills file, and produces a document French banks, insurers, and the land registry accept without a handwriting expert. The third form, the mystic will handed to the notaire in a sealed envelope before two witnesses, is rarely used because the procedure is complex, and it offers no advantage over dictation for a standard apartment file.
Whichever form you choose, the content should do five jobs in plain language. First, state the choice of law expressly, naming the state whose law you elect for the whole succession, for example the law of Texas, or French law if that is your decision after the analysis in Part I. Second, dispose of the Paris apartment precisely, by its address and land-registry references from your deed of purchase, and name substitute beneficiaries in case the first-named legatee dies before you. Third, if you want one person to receive everything the disposable portion allows, use a universal legacy: article 1003 of the Civil Code provides that “Le legs universel est la disposition testamentaire par laquelle le testateur donne à une ou plusieurs personnes l’universalité des biens qu’il laissera à son décès.” (Civil Code, Article 1003, Légifrance) Fourth, name an executor if you want a trusted person to carry out your wishes, and coordinate that appointment with your American executor so the two mandates do not collide. Fifth, revoke or confirm prior wills explicitly so the French notaire does not have to reconcile a 2012 Houston will, a 2019 Paris holographic note, and the new document. After death, a holographic or mystic will cannot simply be acted upon; article 1007 requires that “Tout testament olographe ou mystique sera, avant d’être mis à exécution, déposé entre les mains d’un notaire. Le testament sera ouvert s’il est cacheté.” (Civil Code, Article 1007, Légifrance) The notaire draws up a formal report of the opening and condition of the will, keeps both with the office records, and, in a rule with a real deadline attached, “Dans le mois qui suivra la date du procès-verbal, le notaire adressera une expédition de celui-ci et une copie figurée du testament au greffier du tribunal judiciaire du lieu d’ouverture de la succession,” (Civil Code, Article 1007, Légifrance) where any interested party may then object within the following month. An authentic will skips that entire deposit-and-report stage, which is one more reason Paris practitioners steer American owners toward dictation when the estate is large enough to justify it. And whoever receives a legacy short of the whole estate should expect one more formality: article 1011 provides that “Les légataires à titre universel seront tenus de demander la délivrance aux héritiers auxquels une quotité des biens est réservée par la loi ; à leur défaut, aux légataires universels et, à défaut de ceux-ci, aux héritiers appelés dans l’ordre établi au titre ” Des successions “.” (Civil Code, Article 1011, Légifrance) In practice, your legatee asks the forced heirs, or the universal legatee, for delivery of the gift, a step the notaire orchestrates as part of settling the file.
B. How do your heirs find the will in Paris, and what tax applies on each side of the ocean?
A perfect will that nobody finds is worthless, and this is where American families lose Paris apartments to delay, cost, and sometimes permanent confusion. France solves the problem with a single national registry: the fichier central des dispositions de dernières volontés, the FCDDV, run by the notarial profession, in which any notaire holding your will records its existence, not its contents. The service-public guide states the rule plainly: anyone can query the file, and when the succession is handled by a notaire, the notaire makes the inquiry as a matter of routine (service-public.fr, Fichier central des dispositions de dernières volontés). If death occurs abroad, the embassy or consulate can also query it. The query requires a death certificate, original or certified copy, and costs 18 euros in metropolitan France and 15 euros from abroad. For an American owner, the lesson is operational: have the will drawn up or at least deposited with a French notaire who registers it in the FCDDV, tell your children the name of that notaire, and keep a copy of the deposit receipt with your American estate papers. Our walkthrough of the reverse situation, when an American parent dies and no will can be found, shows how the FCDDV search, proof of foreign wills, and claims from the United States actually proceed in practice, and it is worth reading alongside this guide before you finalize your own file. Families who skip registration discover at the worst moment that a will exists somewhere in a Paris apartment whose keys are with a neighbor on vacation, while the six-figure succession clock is already running.
The Paris dimension deserves its own paragraph, because the capital concentrates both the competent institutions and the practical traps. If your apartment is in Paris, the opening of the succession will typically run through a Paris notaire and, in case of dispute, the Paris judicial court, whose judges apply the European regulation daily, as the February 2025 decision quoted above demonstrates. Paris notaires routinely receive American clients by video conference for preparatory work, take instructions in English with a sworn interpreter where needed, and coordinate the French file with your American attorney so the two wills use consistent names, consistent choice-of-law clauses, and consistent beneficiary designations. Three Paris-specific habits protect the file: first, deposit the original will with the Paris notaire rather than carrying it back to the United States, so registration in the FCDDV is immediate and the document cannot be lost in a move; second, ask the notaire to list the apartment with its exact cadastral and lot references, because Paris co-owned buildings identify units by lot numbers that American descriptions never mention; third, if relations among heirs are tense or the will’s interpretation is debatable, expect the Paris court to appoint an independent estate administrator under article 813-1 rather than letting one heir control the apartment, and budget for that supervision. None of this requires you to fly to Paris for every signature: remote signing through powers of attorney and apostilled documents is standard practice, and the mechanics are detailed in the fee-and-procedure companion to this guide, which explains what a French notaire charges an American heir and how to check each line of the bill.
Finally, the tax layer, where two countries tax and a treaty divides the work. On the French side, real estate located in France is taxed in France under domestic law, and the notaire computes and collects the succession duties from the heirs according to their kinship with the deceased, before the land registry will record the new ownership. On the American side, the worldwide estate of a United States citizen remains within the scope of the federal estate tax, with its high exemption threshold, and any French tax paid on the Paris apartment generally supports a credit against the American tax on the same property. The instrument that prevents the same euro of value from being taxed twice without relief is the France-United States estate and gift tax treaty signed on November 24, 1978, as amended, whose administrative commentary is published by the French tax administration (BOFiP, Convention fiscale France–États-Unis en matière de successions et de donations, consolidated text available from the tax administration at impots.gouv.fr). The treaty’s architecture follows the standard pattern: immovable property is taxable in the country where it stands, so France taxes the Paris apartment first, and the United States then allows its own rules, including the treaty credit, to operate on top. Two planning consequences follow. First, lifetime gifts of French property use the same treaty framework, so a gift of the apartment to your children now, within the disposable portion, can fix the taxable value at today’s price and start the kinship-based allowances working earlier, a strategy to model with figures before choosing between gift and bequest. Second, keep the paper trail the treaty assumes: French notarial deeds, proof of French tax paid, and valuations at the date of death, translated where necessary, because the American credit claim lives or dies on documents the Internal Revenue Service can verify. Owners who hold the apartment through a company, an American revocable trust, or a French SCI face an additional classification layer on both sides, and that structure should be reviewed before the will is signed, not after, since the will’s choice of law governs the succession while the entity’s tax treatment follows its own rules.
Conclusion
An American who owns a Paris apartment does not need two contradictory estate plans; the owner needs one strategy expressed in two coordinated documents. The European regulation lets you choose a single governing law, French forced heirship sets the boundary you cannot cross when French law applies and prices the compensatory levy when a European-connected child meets a foreign law with no reserve, and the French will, holographic or authentic, is the instrument that makes the choice enforceable, locatable, and executable in Paris. Write the choice of law expressly, dispose of the apartment by its exact designation with substitute beneficiaries, deposit the will with a French notaire who registers it in the national wills file, tell your heirs where it is, and align the American papers so no clause contradicts another. Done this year, that file turns a transatlantic succession from a court-supervised reconstruction into an administrative routine; left unwritten, it leaves your children to prove your intentions to a Paris judge who never met you.