You did everything right under California law. Your revocable living trust holds the house in the Dordogne, your successor trustee is named, and your estate plan says exactly which child gets the property. Then you die, your children contact a French notaire, and the answer stops them cold: in France, the trust does not own the house. You still do. The French land registry still shows your name, French succession law still decides who inherits, and the French tax administration still sends its bill, with the trust treated as transparent. This article explains, for Americans who already placed a French house inside a United States living trust or who plan to do so, why France looks straight through the trust, how the house actually passes to the next generation, and which filings keep the family clear of penalties on both sides of the Atlantic. Part I describes the situation while the settlor is alive: who owns the house in French eyes, why the trustee cannot sell or mortgage it, and how French tax law prices the arrangement every year. Part II follows the house after death: which country’s law designates the heirs, how the forced share of children limits the trust’s instructions, and how the death taxes, deadlines, and American filings fit together.
I. France Does Not Recognize Your Living Trust: What That Means While You Are Alive
A. The Trustee Owns Nothing in France: Title, the Notaire, and the Land Registry
A revocable living trust is a creature of American state law. The person who creates it, called the settlor or grantor, transfers assets to a trustee who manages them for beneficiaries, often the settlor during life and the children after death. Because the trust can be revoked and amended at any time, the settlor keeps full control, avoids probate in the United States, and organizes the transmission of the estate without court involvement. None of that machinery exists in French domestic law. The only arrangement French law knows that resembles a trust is the fiducie, a narrowly defined institution introduced in 2007. The Civil Code defines it in these terms: “La fiducie est l’opération par laquelle un ou plusieurs constituants transfèrent des biens, des droits ou des sûretés, ou un ensemble de biens, de droits ou de sûretés, présents ou futurs, à un ou plusieurs fiduciaires qui, les tenant séparés de leur patrimoine propre, agissent dans un but déterminé au profit d’un ou plusieurs bénéficiaires.” And the next article adds a strict condition: “La fiducie est établie par la loi ou par contrat. Elle doit être expresse.” A California declaration of trust is neither a French statute nor a French fiducie contract, so it cannot transfer ownership of a French immovable in the eyes of the French land registry, known as the publicité foncière.
French tax law confirms this reading by defining the foreign trust as something seen from the outside, never as an owner. The General Tax Code states: “on entend par trust l’ensemble des relations juridiques créées dans le droit d’un Etat autre que la France par une personne qui a la qualité de constituant, par acte entre vifs ou à cause de mort, en vue d’y placer des biens ou droits, sous le contrôle d’un administrateur, dans l’intérêt d’un ou de plusieurs bénéficiaires ou pour la réalisation d’un objectif déterminé.” The vocabulary matters. France speaks of a constituant, the person who set up the arrangement, an administrateur, the foreign trustee, and bénéficiaires. It never says the trustee becomes the owner of the French house. For the land registry, the owner remains the person whose name appears on the last French notarial deed, usually the American buyer. A deed signed in California purporting to convey the Dordogne house from yourself as an individual to yourself as trustee of your living trust has no effect in France. Only a deed drawn up by a French notaire, a public officer with a monopoly on conveyancing, can transfer or encumber a French immovable and be recorded.
The practical consequences arrive faster than most families expect. When the successor trustee flies to France with the trust instrument, translated and apostilled, and asks the notaire to sell the house and distribute the proceeds, the notaire refuses, because the trustee is a stranger to the title. The sale can only be signed by the persons French law designates as owners or their heirs, which means opening a French succession file instead of executing the trust’s instructions. The same wall blocks refinancing: a French bank will not register a mortgage, called a hypothèque, on instructions from a foreign trustee, since the borrower of record must be the titled owner who appears before the notaire. Even renting out the property can create friction, because leases, insurance policies, and property tax notices all run in the name of the individual owner. Some families try to repair the situation by signing a French deed that transfers the house to the trustee, but that transfer is itself a taxable conveyance between two persons the tax administration treats as distinct, with registration duties to pay and no guarantee that the trust will be respected afterward. The cleaner approach is usually the reverse: accept that the house stays in your personal name under French law, coordinate the American trust with a French will, and organize the tax filings described below, rather than fighting the registry.
One related misunderstanding concerns powers of attorney. An American trust often contains broad powers authorizing the trustee to act on all assets. A French notaire will not accept those clauses as a substitute for a power of attorney drawn up for the specific transaction, in the form French practice requires, and legalized for use in France. If the owner cannot travel, the family needs a dedicated procuration established for the sale, not the trust instrument. Readers facing that exact situation find the step-by-step mechanics in our guide to signing a French house transaction from the United States with a procuration and an apostille, which remains fully applicable when a trust is in the background.
B. The Tax System Sees Through the Trust: Yearly Filing, the Annual Levy, and the 2026 Oscar II Ruling
French tax law treats the trust as transparent: it looks past the trustee and taxes the individuals behind the arrangement. The cornerstone is the article that governs transfers of trust assets at death and by gift. It provides: “La transmission par donation ou succession de biens ou droits placés dans un trust ainsi que des produits qui y sont capitalisés est, pour la valeur vénale nette des biens, droits ou produits concernés à la date de la transmission, soumise aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit en fonction du lien de parenté existant entre le constituant et le bénéficiaire.” In plain terms, when trust property moves, France levies its transfer taxes, called droits de mutation à titre gratuit, by looking at the family relationship between the settlor and the beneficiary, exactly as if the trust did not exist. A house passing from an American parent to American children through a living trust is taxed like a direct parent-to-child transmission, with the same allowances and rates, and the valuation is the net market value at the date of the transfer. The territorial scope is deliberately wide. A second article provides that the tax reaches trust assets and capitalized income whether the property sits inside or outside France when the deceased or donor was fiscally domiciled in France, and reaches French-situs property, including trust property, even when the deceased or donor was domiciled abroad: “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit” An American domiciled in the United States who holds a French house through a living trust therefore falls squarely inside French taxation on the French property.
During the settlor’s lifetime, a separate yearly charge applies. The Code provides: “Les personnes physiques constituants ou bénéficiaires d’un trust défini à l’article 792-0 bis sont soumises à un prélèvement fixé au tarif le plus élevé mentionné au 1 de l’article 977.” This prélèvement, a special levy on trust assets, is assessed on the net market value of the property placed in the trust, and the same article organizes its declaration: “La consistance et la valeur des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 placés dans le trust sont déclarées et le prélèvement est acquitté et versé au comptable public compétent par l’administrateur du trust au plus tard le 15 juin de chaque année.” The trustee, as administrateur, must therefore file and pay by June 15 each year. Relief exists only in narrow cases, notably where the assets were already included in the settlor’s or a beneficiary’s real-estate wealth tax base and properly declared there. A revocable living trust holding a French second home rarely qualifies, because the family usually declared nothing in France at all, assuming the American structure covered them. Years of unfiled June declarations then accumulate, with penalties and interest running behind them, and the tax administration may go after the trustee, the settlor, or the beneficiaries, who can be held jointly liable.
A February 2026 decision of the Cour de cassation shows how aggressively the administration pursues these cases and how little comfort tax treaties provide. In that case, a French resident had set up a Canadian-law trust named Oscar II back in 1986, holding financial assets that were never declared for wealth-tax purposes. The administration assessed the special trust levy for the years 2012 through 2015 against the trustee, who sought discharge by invoking the 1975 tax convention between France and Canada, arguing that taxing the same assets in both countries violated the treaty. The Paris court of appeal agreed and discharged the assessments. The Cour de cassation, commercial chamber, quashed that ruling on February 11, 2026, appeal number 23-14.305, holding that the lower court had ruled “sans rechercher, comme il lui incombait, si la Convention s’appliquait au prélèvement sur les trusts prévu à l’article 990 J du code général des impôts, et, en particulier, si ce prélèvement, institué après la date de la signature de la Convention, constituait un impôt de nature identique ou analogue à ceux qu’elle vise”. The lesson for American families is direct. A levy created after a treaty was signed is not automatically covered by that treaty, and a court cannot neutralize the French trust levy by waving a convention without proving, article by article, that the levy is an identical or similar tax within the treaty’s scope. The 1978 estate and gift tax convention between the United States and France, whose official text is published by the French tax administration (convention with the United States on successions and gifts, analyzed in the administration’s official commentary at BOI-INT-CVB-USA-20), must be examined the same way, provision by provision, rather than assumed to erase the French charges. Families who counted on the treaty to protect an undeclared trust structure should have the analysis redone on the actual treaty language before the administration does it for them.
The same article that taxes trust transfers also warns that silence has a price at death. Where the trustee fails to pay and to file the detailed valuation return, and the trustee answers to the law of a non-cooperative jurisdiction or a state with no mutual recovery assistance, the Code states that “les bénéficiaires du trust sont solidairement responsables du paiement des droits et tenus de déposer la déclaration.” The children who thought they were passive beneficiaries can thus become jointly liable for the duties with an obligation to file the return themselves. An American trustee administering a living trust from California or Delaware is not in a blacklisted jurisdiction, but the mechanism illustrates the philosophy of the entire regime: the administration always finds a person within reach. The practical program follows from these texts. Identify the French house as trust property in the yearly filings, have the trustee declare and pay the levy each June or document precisely why an exemption applies, keep valuations that can support the net market value used, and never assume that an American revocable trust, which the Internal Revenue Service disregards for income tax while the settlor lives, is disregarded in France. It is the opposite: France sees the people, taxes the people, and holds the people liable.
II. When the Settlor Dies: How the French House Actually Passes and Gets Taxed
A. Which Law Designates the Heirs: the European Regulation, the American Will, and the Protected Share of the Children
At death, the first question is which country’s succession law governs the French house. Since August 2015, the answer across the European Union, including France, comes from the European Succession Regulation number 650/2012, presented for the public on the European Union official Your Europe page on planning a cross-border inheritance. The file is usually handled by the authority, often a court or a notaire, in the EU country where the deceased last lived, and that authority in most cases applies its own national law. An American who retired to the Dordogne and lived there year-round will therefore usually see French law govern the whole succession, including the house, unless the deceased chose otherwise. The EU rules offer one controlled exit: a person may elect in their will the law of a country whose nationality they hold, whether or not that country belongs to the EU. An American citizen can thus designate the law of a United States state to govern the succession. That election, called professio juris, is examined in detail in our companion guide on choosing United States law in an American will covering a French house, which serves as the reference for this cluster and should be read alongside this article. The election is particularly useful for keeping one coherent law across American and French assets, but families must understand exactly what it can and cannot do, because French law protects children in ways American law does not.
That protection is the réserve héréditaire, the forced share. The Civil Code defines it as follows: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” The protected heirs are the children, and the Code fixes their minimum portions arithmetically: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” With one child, half the estate is untouchable; with two children, two thirds; with three or more, three quarters. Only the remainder, called the quotité disponible or disposable portion, can be assigned at will. A living trust that leaves the entire French house to one child, or to a surviving spouse, or to a charity, while other children receive nothing, collides head-on with these fractions whenever French law governs or whenever the corrective described next applies.
The corrective is recent and aimed precisely at American-style planning. Since the law of August 24, 2021, when the deceased or at least one child was, at death, a national of a European Union member state or habitually resident there, and the foreign law governing the succession provides no forced-share mechanism for children, each child may take a compensatory levy on property located in France. The Code states that “chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” Consider the common case: an American settlor with two children places the Dordogne house in a living trust for the elder child alone and elects American state law in the will. If one of the children lives in France, or holds French nationality alongside American nationality, the disadvantaged child can claim a top-up directly against the French house up to the French forced share, regardless of what the trust and the elected American law say. The mechanism is capped at French forced-share rights and attaches only to assets situated in France at death, but the French house is exactly that kind of asset. Families who believed the trust plus a choice-of-law clause had locked the distribution discover that the French statute reopens it.
Even without that corrective, excess gifts are clawed back in value. The Code provides: “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” The remedy is an indemnity, normally paid by taking less from the rest of the estate, rather than a return of the house itself, which means the child who received the house through the trust may keep it but owe brothers and sisters a quantified sum. The trustee’s distribution plan should therefore be built with these fractions in mind from the start: count the children, compute the disposable portion, verify whether any child has the European connection that triggers the compensatory levy, and draft the French will consistently with the trust instead of against it. Where the settlor wants to favor one heir, the lawful tools are equalization payments organized during life, life insurance arranged under the correct contract, and a will that uses the disposable portion openly, not a trust clause that ignores the forced share and fails at the notaire’s office.
B. The Tax Bill and the Paperwork: French Death Duties, the Treaty Credit, Deadlines, and the American Filings
The death of the settlor triggers two parallel tracks that the family must run at the same time: the French succession settlement conducted by the notaire, and the American tax and trust-administration track conducted by the successor trustee. On the French side, the notaire opens the file, identifies the heirs under the applicable law analyzed above, draws up the deed of notoriety establishing who inherits, and prepares the detailed estate return, called the déclaration de succession. The Code sets strict filing clocks: “Les délais pour l’enregistrement des déclarations que les héritiers, donataires ou légataires ont à souscrire des biens à eux échus ou transmis par décès sont : De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.” An American who died in France leaves six months; one who died in the United States leaves twelve. Interest for late filing runs automatically, and the notaire cannot close the file and release clear title to the buyers or the heirs until the return is filed and the duties paid, which is why starting the French file in the first weeks matters more than any other single decision.
The duties themselves follow the trust-specific rules. Where the transfer qualifies as a gift or an inheritance from the settlor to the beneficiary, the tax is computed on the net market value at the date of transmission according to the kinship between settlor and beneficiary, so children of the settlor use the parent-child scale with its allowance. Where neither characterization fits, for example where assets linger in the trust after the settlor’s death without entering the probate estate, the Code taxes determined shares by kinship and taxes any undetermined remainder at the top rate of the scale for unrelated persons, with the trustee responsible for filing the detailed valuation return and paying within the succession deadlines. Because the French house sits in France, it is taxable in France even though the settlor was an American domiciled in America, under the territorial rule quoted in Part I. The 1978 convention between France and the United States on estates and gifts then decides how double taxation is relieved: each country keeps defined taxing rights over defined assets, and the taxes paid in one country generate a credit against the taxes due in the other within the limits the treaty sets. Claiming that credit is a paperwork exercise with real deadlines on each side, so the family should have the notaire’s French assessment and the American estate’s computations prepared on compatible valuations rather than discovering a mismatch a year later. The treaty text and the official commentary cited in Part I are the working documents; treaty relief is never automatic and must be affirmatively claimed with proof of payment.
On the American side, the successor trustee administers the trust according to its terms for the American assets, while remembering that the French house follows the French track. Three filings commonly arise. First, the trust’s distributions to beneficiaries and any termination of the revocable trust at death can trigger information reporting to the Internal Revenue Service on transactions with trusts, made on Form 3520, the annual return reporting transactions with foreign trusts, where the instructions determine who files and by when. Second, if the estate is large enough to raise United States estate tax questions, the executor considers Form 706, the United States estate tax return, on which the treaty credit for French duties paid may be taken. Third, the heirs who receive foreign gifts or bequests above the reporting threshold report them under the same information-return regime. These American obligations run on American deadlines that do not pause while the French notaire works, so the family needs advisers on both sides exchanging numbers early: the French net market value at death, the French duties assessed, and the dollar conversion used, so that each return tells the same story. Beneficiaries should also keep the trustee’s statements, the French deed of notoriety, the filed French return with its proof of payment, and the yearly trust levy receipts together, because either administration can ask, years later, how the same house was described on each side of the ocean.
Two practical sequences cover most families. Where the trust holds only the French house plus American accounts, the efficient order is: secure the death certificate with an apostille for use in France, open the French succession file with a notaire immediately so the six or twelve-month clock is managed, have the successor trustee pause any distribution of the house until the notaire confirms who French law designates as heirs, align the French will’s choice-of-law clause with the trust, file the yearly French trust declarations up to the year of death, pay the succession duties, claim the treaty credit in the United States, and only then transfer or sell the property under the notaire’s supervision. Where the family instead wants the trust to control everything and skip France, there is no lawful shortcut: the house cannot leave the French system, the trustee cannot convey it, and every month of delay adds interest. Families that accept the two-track process early regularly settle within the year; families that fight it spend the year arguing with the registry and pay the same duties with penalties added.
Conclusion
A United States living trust is an excellent instrument for American assets and a transparent one for French assets. France does not treat the trustee as owner, taxes the settlor and beneficiaries directly through yearly and death-time charges, protects children through the forced share with a compensatory levy that reaches French houses even under elected American law, and enforces filing clocks of six and twelve months that wait for no foreign procedure. The families who succeed are those who stop asking the trust to do France’s work: they keep title in a form the land registry understands, write a French will that cooperates with the trust and the European regulation, keep the trustee’s yearly declarations current, open the notaire’s file within weeks of death, and coordinate the French assessment with the American returns so the treaty credit is captured. Handled that way, the Dordogne house passes on the settlor’s terms to the extent French law permits, the taxes are paid once with credit on the other side, and the children inherit an asset rather than a dispute.