You bought a stone house in the Dordogne, or an apartment in Paris, and your American will says everything goes to your spouse, or to your second wife, or to one child who needs it most. Then a French notaire tells you that your children from a first marriage can claw back a fixed share of the French property no matter what your will says. For Americans, this is usually the first shock of French succession law: the réserve héréditaire, or forced heirship, which reserves a fraction of your estate for your children and lets them act against gifts and bequests that eat into it.
This guide answers the question American owners ask next: can you choose American law in your will and escape the French forced share? Since August 17, 2015, the European Succession Regulation gives you a real tool, the professio juris, which lets a US national designate the law of his or her nationality to govern the whole succession. Used correctly, it can displace French forced heirship. But the tool has sharp edges: a 2021 French statute created a compensatory levy that lets children left with nothing take value back out of the French assets, and choosing American law changes nothing about French inheritance tax. What follows explains both halves of the problem, the civil-law half and the tax half, with the exact texts your notaire will apply.
I. What French forced heirship takes from an American estate, and what it leaves alone
French law starts from the idea that your children own a piece of your estate before you die. That idea has a name, a number, and a calculation method, and any American planning around a French house needs all three.
A. How American children compute their reserved share of your French house
The starting definition sits in Article 912 of the Civil Code: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” In plain English, the reserved share goes to protected heirs free of charges, and only the disposable portion is yours to give away by lifetime gift or will. Since a 2006 reform, only descendants, and in their absence a surviving spouse who is not divorced, count as protected heirs. Siblings, parents, unmarried partners, and friends are never forced heirs, which already answers one common American worry: if you have no children and no spouse, French law lets your will dispose of everything, because Article 916 of the Civil Code provides that “A défaut de descendant et de conjoint survivant non divorcé, les libéralités par actes entre vifs ou testamentaires pourront épuiser la totalité des biens.”
When children exist, the numbers are fixed by Article 913 of the Civil Code: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Read from the children’s side, one child is guaranteed half of the estate, two children together are guaranteed two-thirds, and three or more children together are guaranteed three-quarters. If there are no descendants but a surviving spouse who is not divorced, Article 914-1 of the Civil Code caps your freedom differently: “Les libéralités, par actes entre vifs ou par testament, ne pourront excéder les trois quarts des biens si, à défaut de descendant, le défunt laisse un conjoint survivant, non divorcé”, so the spouse’s guaranteed quarter is smaller than a child’s but still real.
Take a concrete American case. You die owning a French house worth 600,000 euros and 200,000 euros in accounts, with lifetime gifts of 100,000 euros already given to one child. The computation mass is 900,000 euros. With two children, the combined reserve is two-thirds, or 600,000 euros, meaning 300,000 euros per child, and the disposable portion is 300,000 euros. If your will leaves the whole house to your surviving spouse, each child can demand to be made whole up to 300,000 euros of value. The mechanics are set by Article 922 of the Civil Code: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.” Every lifetime gift is notionally pulled back into the pot, valued at death, so giving the house away early does not shrink the children’s claim. And since 2006, the remedy is money, not the walls themselves: Article 924 of the Civil Code states that “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent. Le paiement de l’indemnité par l’héritier réservataire se fait en moins prenant et en priorité par voie d’imputation sur ses droits dans la réserve.” The spouse keeps the house and pays compensation, which matters enormously when the French asset is a home nobody wants to sell.
Two practical consequences follow. First, reductions run against lifetime gifts as well as wills, starting with the most recent, so an American who deeds the French house to a new spouse while forgetting children of a first marriage has not solved anything. Second, the claim must be raised: heirs who accept an estate without checking the math can lose leverage, and limitation periods run, so children who suspect they were shortchanged should have the computation verified quickly rather than waiting years. French courts applied this system to French-situs real estate with great consistency under the old scission rule, under which immovables followed the law of their location; the Cour de cassation confirmed that logic as late as July 4, 2018, in a widely cited succession ruling (Cass. 1re civ., July 4, 2018, Nos. 17-16.515 and 17-16.522), holding French reserve rules applicable to immovables located in France. That decision belongs to the pre-Regulation world for deaths before August 2015, but it shows how seriously French judges protect the reserve when French land is involved.
B. The 2021 compensatory levy: when a foreign law gives your children nothing
For decades, the escape route looked simple: die domiciled in a US state, let American law govern the movables, and leave the children whatever the American will says, which can be nothing. Before 2021, French case law had essentially accepted that a foreign succession law ignoring the reserve did not by itself shock French international public policy, so children disinherited under that law had little recourse. Parliament reversed that outcome in Article 24 of Law No. 2021-1109 of August 24, 2021, which added a second paragraph to Article 913. The new text, still in force today, provides: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” The anchor to that paragraph sits here: Article 913 of the Civil Code.
Every word of that paragraph is a condition, so read it as a checklist. First, someone must anchor the family to Europe at death: either the deceased or at least one child is a national of a European Union member state or habitually resident there. A purely American family with no EU nationality and no habitual residence in the EU falls outside the levy, which is why Franco-American families are its main target. Second, the foreign law governing the succession must offer no reserve-like protective mechanism for children at all. American readers should pause here: many US states give a surviving spouse an elective share, but none gives children a forced share, so a succession governed by, say, Florida or Texas law normally meets this condition. Third, the levy can only be taken from assets located in France at the date of death, and only up to the amount of the French reserved rights. If the French house covers the shortfall, the child is made whole from it; if the French assets are worth less than the reserved share, the child absorbs the difference and cannot chase American assets with this tool.
Run the numbers on a Franco-American family. A French-American father dies habitually resident in California, leaves a Paris apartment worth 500,000 euros to his second wife by a will choosing California law, and leaves two children of a first marriage nothing. Combined reserve under French law: two-thirds of the whole computation mass. Suppose the worldwide mass is 900,000 euros, so the reserve is 600,000 euros, or 300,000 per child. California law gives them nothing, so each child can levy up to 300,000 euros against the Paris apartment, a total of 600,000 euros against a 500,000-euro asset. The apartment is entirely absorbed by the levy, and the wife keeps whatever American assets the will gives her. Change one fact, and the answer flips: if the father were solely American, the children solely American, and nobody habitually resident in the EU, the levy would be unavailable and the California will would stand undisturbed as far as French civil law is concerned. Tax would still apply, as Section II explains, but the forced share would not.
Three warnings round out the picture. The levy only helps children and those claiming through them, never a surviving spouse, charity, or friend. It attaches only to assets existing and located in France at death, so lifetime planning that moves value out of France can shrink its base, though every such move must be weighed against gift-tax costs and the fifteen-year recall rule discussed below. And it does not punish the foreign law or cancel the will; it simply tops up the children from the French assets, leaving the rest of the foreign-law distribution intact. Americans who want certainty therefore need the second half of this guide: choosing US law properly, and pricing the tax that survives the choice.
II. How an American validly opts for US law, and the tax bill that survives the choice
Choosing American law is possible, formal, and frequently botched. The Regulation rewards precision and punishes vague references, while the tax code ignores the choice entirely.
A. Writing a professio juris that actually works under Article 22
Since August 17, 2015, one European text governs which law applies to cross-border successions in every EU member state except Ireland and Denmark: Regulation (EU) No. 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of July 4, 2012, on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions and acceptance and enforcement of authentic instruments in matters of succession (CELEX:32012R0650), verified for this article against the official EUR-Lex text. Its default rule, stated in Article 21(1), is that the law of the state where the deceased had his or her habitual residence at death governs the succession as a whole. An American who retires to Provence and lives there for years will therefore die under French succession law by default, reserve included, unless he or she has chosen otherwise. The choice, called professio juris, is set out in Article 22(1): a person may choose as the law governing his or her succession as a whole the law of the state whose nationality he or she possesses at the time of making the choice or at the time of death. The same paragraph adds that a person holding several nationalities may choose the law of any of the states whose nationality he or she holds at either of those moments, which directly covers dual French-American nationals: they can validly choose American law, and by symmetry they could also choose French law expressly to lock in the reserve for their children.
Form is where wills fail. Article 22(2) requires the choice to be made expressly in a declaration in the form of a disposition of property upon death, or to be demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition. The safest practice is one express sentence naming the choice, the nationality, and the Regulation. A model clause, to be adapted to your state by counsel on both sides, reads as follows:
I am a national of the United States of America, and pursuant to Article 22 of EU Regulation No. 650/2012 I designate the law of the State of New York, my national law, to govern my succession as a whole.
Courts do accept implied choices demonstrated by the will’s terms, such as references to specific provisions of the national law, but litigating implication costs years and fees, while one express sentence costs nothing. Note the follow-on rules: the substantive validity of the act of choosing is governed by the chosen law itself, and any later modification or revocation must meet the formal requirements for modifying or revoking a will. A codicil that silently contradicts the choice, or a new will that forgets to repeat it, can reopen the whole fight.
Choosing American law means choosing one American law, not American law in general. Succession in the United States is state law, so the designation should name the state whose law is intended, ideally the state of domicile or the state whose courts and executors will administer the American assets. Coordinate the French and American instruments: a US will with the Article 22 clause covering worldwide assets, or a US will plus a French testament expressly incorporated, works better than two contradictory documents each claiming to be the last word. Have the French will drawn up or reviewed by a French notaire so its form satisfies French requirements for international wills and olographic wills, and register it with the French central wills file so it is found at death. Americans who already own French property and have only a US will should also confirm that the will’s executor powers and trust provisions will be understood by the French notaire settling the French assets, because a valid choice of law does not force French institutions to apply doctrines, such as certain trust mechanisms, that they cannot translate. Where a revocable living trust holds the American assets, the pour-over will should carry the Article 22 clause, and the trust itself should avoid dispositions that contradict the chosen succession law.
Know the limits before relying on the clause. The Regulation excludes renvoi when the deceased chose the law of a third state, so there is no bounce-back to French law through American conflicts rules. But the public-policy safety valve lets a court refuse a provision of the chosen law that is manifestly incompatible with the forum’s public policy, and French courts have historically read that safety valve narrowly in succession matters, which is precisely why Parliament built the compensatory levy as a statute rather than relying on public policy. Practically, this means the professio juris works best for families outside the levy’s anchor conditions, and works as a partial shield, not a full one, for Franco-American families with French-situs assets. One more American-side limit deserves a sentence: several US states protect the surviving spouse with an elective share, often around one-third, so a will that leaves everything to the children and nothing to the spouse can misfire under the very American law the testator chose. Choose the state deliberately, with advice on both sides of the Atlantic.
B. Why French inheritance tax still hits the French house and how the treaty softens it
Here is the point Americans misunderstand most: the choice of law governs who gets what, while tax follows its own rules and ignores the will’s professio juris entirely. France taxes the French house on its own terms. Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code provides that “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit” the movable and immovable property located in France, including French real estate held indirectly through companies, even “lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article précité.” In other words, an American domiciled in Texas who dies owning a house in Lyon leaves a taxable French succession as to that house. The declaration must be filed fast: Article 641 of the General Tax Code sets the filing deadline at “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine” and “D’une année, dans tous les autres cas,” so heirs of an American who dies in the United States generally have one year, with late interest and penalties running after that. General guidance on French succession procedure is published by the administration on service-public.fr, and the tax administration’s international documentation sits on impots.gouv.fr, but neither replaces the computation below.
The computation starts with allowances, then rates. Each child currently enjoys a 100,000-euro allowance on what he or she receives, because Article 779 of the General Tax Code provides that “il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.” Above the allowance, the parent-child scale runs from 5 percent to 45 percent in progressive bands. Unrelated beneficiaries face a flat 60 percent after a small allowance, and siblings face 35 to 45 percent, which is why the identity of the heir matters as much as the value of the house. Lifetime gifts interact through the recall rule in Article 784 of the General Tax Code: “La perception est effectuée en ajoutant à la valeur des biens compris dans la donation ou la déclaration de succession celle des biens qui ont fait l’objet de donations antérieures, à l’exception de celles passées depuis plus de quinze ans” Gifts made within fifteen years before death are added back to compute the applicable band and to net off allowances already used, so serial tax-free gifts of the allowance every few years no longer work; the clock is fifteen years, and the family should calendar it.
Double taxation is then relieved, not eliminated, by the estate and gift tax treaty signed by France and the United States on November 24, 1978, as amended. Its architecture is familiar: real estate is taxable in the state where it sits, so France taxes the French house first, and the United States, which taxes its citizens on worldwide assets, gives a credit for the French tax attributable to that property, within the limits and ordering rules of the treaty and the Internal Revenue Code. The practical file therefore has three layers: the French succession declaration and payment, the US Form 706 with the foreign tax credit, and proof that the same property bore both taxes so the credit attaches to the right dollars. Keep the French assessment, the notaire’s valuation evidence, and the exchange rate used, because the credit computation will ask for all three. Where the estate also holds French bank accounts or a French company, situs and treaty-credit questions multiply, and the companion guide on French inheritance tax, deadlines, and the treaty credit when an American parent dies owning a house in France walks through that filing sequence step by step.
End with the planning synthesis. A dual-national or US-only testator who wants American law to govern should sign an express Article 22 clause naming the state law, mirror it in the French testament, and register the will where it will be found. The same testator should separately price the French tax on the French house under Articles 750 ter, 779, and 784, calendar the one-year declaration deadline, and line up the treaty-credit paperwork for the American return. And a Franco-American testator with children to protect, or children to disinherit, must run the compensatory-levy math before assuming the clause settles everything: if the children end up with nothing under the chosen American law, the French house stands first in line to make them whole.
Conclusion
An American will can govern a French house, but only if it says so in the language the European Regulation requires, only within the boundaries France drew in 2021, and never for tax. The reserve gives one child half, two children two-thirds, and three or more children three-quarters of the computation mass, with lifetime gifts notionally returned to the pot and over-generous beneficiaries paying compensation in value rather than surrendering the walls. The professio juris of Article 22 lets a US national replace that system with the law of his or her state, provided the choice is express, state-specific, and consistently reflected in every testamentary instrument. The 2021 compensatory levy then claws back value from French-situs assets for children left with nothing under the foreign law, whenever the deceased or a child anchors the family to the European Union. And through all of it, French inheritance tax applies to the French property under Article 750 ter, with the 100,000-euro allowance per child, progressive rates, the fifteen-year gift recall, and a one-year filing deadline when death occurs abroad, softened afterward by the Franco-American treaty’s credit on the US return. Draft the clause, run the levy math, and price the tax in the same file: that is how an American owner keeps control of a French house without leaving the heirs a lawsuit.