You live in Texas, you own a small apartment in Lyon that you rent out unfurnished, and every September a letter from the French tax office lands in your inbox. This year the numbers look wrong. On top of the French income tax on your rent, a second line takes another 17.2 percent, labeled prélèvements sociaux, the French social levies. Your Dutch neighbor, who owns the identical apartment on the floor above and also lives off rental income, pays only 7.5 percent on the same rent. Nobody at the dinner party can explain why, your American accountant stares at the French notice and asks whether any of it can be credited back home, and the notaire who handled your purchase has already closed the file. This article answers the three questions every American landlord and seller in France eventually asks: what exactly France takes on French rental income and on the sale of French property, why an American affiliated only with the United States Social Security system pays the full 17.2 percent while a European-affiliated owner pays 7.5 percent, and what concrete steps can recover money that was wrongly charged, in France and on the American tax return. French statutes and court decisions are quoted word for word, with links to the official texts, and every French term is explained the first time it appears.
I. My French rental was just hit with 17.2 percent social charges: what I actually owe as an American
France taxes you twice on the same French rental income and twice on the gain when you sell. The first layer is income tax. The second layer, the one that shocks Americans, is a set of social levies that apply even though you will never see a French doctor under the French health system and will never draw a French pension. Understanding the two layers separately is the only way to check your bill, because each layer has its own base, its own rate, and its own holding-period reductions.
A. How much France takes on my rent and my sale: the 9.2, 0.5, and 7.5 breakdown
Start with the vocabulary, because the French notice never translates itself. The prélèvements sociaux are social levies on investment and property income. They bundle three charges. The CSG, short for contribution sociale généralisée, is the general social contribution, charged at 9.2 percent on rental income and property gains. The CRDS, short for contribution pour le remboursement de la dette sociale, is the contribution that repays the historic deficit of the French social security system, charged at 0.5 percent. The prélèvement de solidarité, the solidarity levy, is charged at 7.5 percent. Add them up, 9.2 plus 0.5 plus 7.5, and you get the 17.2 percent total that the official service-public.fr tables display for rental income from unfurnished property and for real-estate gains, with the line TOTAL 17,2 percent printed under each table. The same page states the scope directly: When your tax home is outside France, some of your French-source income remains subject to the social levies, notably revenus fonciers, the legal category covering rent from unfurnished lettings, and plus-values immobilières, gains on the sale of real estate.
The legal base for the CSG on these amounts is article L. 136-6 of the Social Security Code, which provides: “Les personnes physiques fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B du code général des impôts sont assujetties à une contribution sur les revenus du patrimoine assise sur le montant net retenu pour l’établissement de l’impôt sur le revenu”, and then lists “Des revenus fonciers” and “Des plus-values, gains en capital et profits soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu”. In plain terms, the contribution attaches to the net amount used for income tax, so management fees, insurance, and loan interest that reduce your taxable rental income reduce the social base by the same stroke. The collection of the CSG on property income is organized by article 1600-0 C of the General Tax Code, which states: “La contribution sociale généralisée sur les revenus du patrimoine est établie, contrôlée et recouvrée conformément aux dispositions de l’article L. 136-6 du code de la sécurité sociale.” The CRDS on the same base is organized by article 1600-0 G of the General Tax Code: “La contribution pour le remboursement de la dette sociale assise sur les revenus du patrimoine est établie, contrôlée et recouvrée conformément à l’ article 15 de l’ordonnance n° 96-50 du 24 janvier 1996 relative au remboursement de la dette sociale.” The 7.5 percent solidarity levy is created by article 235 ter of the General Tax Code, whose first paragraph reads: “I.-Il est institué : 1° Un prélèvement de solidarité sur les revenus du patrimoine mentionnés à l’ article L. 136-6 du code de la sécurité sociale ; 2° Un prélèvement de solidarité sur les produits de placement mentionnés à l’article L. 136-7 du même code.” Its rate paragraph is one sentence: “III.-Le taux des prélèvements de solidarité mentionnés au I est fixé à 7,5 %.”
Take a concrete rental example. You collect 18,000 euros of net rental income in a year from the Lyon apartment, after deductible charges, and you live full time in Austin. Your French income tax on that rent cannot fall below the nonresident minimum of article 197 A of the General Tax Code, which provides that “l’impôt ne peut, en ce cas, être inférieur à un montant calculé en appliquant un taux de 20 % à la fraction du revenu net imposable inférieure ou égale à la limite supérieure de la deuxième tranche du barème de l’impôt sur le revenu et un taux de 30 % à la fraction supérieure à cette limite”. On 18,000 euros, the 20 percent minimum gives 3,600 euros of French income tax. The social levies add 17.2 percent of 18,000, which is 3,096 euros, split as 1,656 euros of CSG, 90 euros of CRDS, and 1,350 euros of solidarity levy. Your total French bill on 18,000 euros of rent is therefore 6,696 euros before any American tax, which is why the social layer deserves as much attention as the income tax itself. If you filed your French return on time, the nonresident tax office sends the specific bill automaticallythe nonresident tax office sends you between August and September the assessment notice for your social levies, which details the calculation, the total, and the payment methods. That notice, the avis d’imposition, is the document you must check line by line, because every refund procedure in this article starts from it.
Now take a sale. You bought a studio in Bordeaux for 300,000 euros, you sell it twelve years later for 360,000 euros, and for this example assume 22,500 euros of allowable purchase costs computed by your notaire, leaving a net taxable gain of 37,500 euros. French law taxes that gain under article 150 U of the General Tax Code: “les plus-values réalisées par les personnes physiques ou les sociétés ou groupements qui relèvent des articles 8 à 8 ter”, and taxes sales for consideration of built or unbuilt property or related rights as income “lors de la cession à titre onéreux de biens immobiliers bâtis ou non bâtis ou de droits relatifs à ces biens, sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 V à 150 VH”. Because you live outside France, the gain is collected through the withholding mechanism of article 244 bis A of the General Tax Code: “les plus-values, telles que définies aux e bis et e ter du I de l’article 164 B”, when realized by the listed persons and entities on the listed property, “réalisées par les personnes et organismes mentionnés au 2 du I lors de la cession des biens ou droits mentionnés au 3 sont soumises à un prélèvement selon les taux fixés au III bis”. The scope of French-source gains is set by article 164 B of the General Tax Code, which treats gains on real estate located in France as French-source income. The official tax commentary sets the individual rate at 19 percent of the gain after the holding-period reduction described below.
The holding period changes both layers, and this is where sellers save or lose thousands. The official BOFiP commentary applies a different scale and pace to the holding-period reduction depending on whether it reduces the income-tax base or the social-levies base. For income tax, the reduction runs 6 percent per year of ownership beyond the fifth year through the twenty-first, plus 4 percent for the twenty-second year, with full income-tax exemption beyond twenty-two years of ownership. For the social levies, the reduction is much slower: 1.65 percent per year beyond the fifth through the twenty-first year, 1.60 percent for the twenty-second year, and 9 percent per year after that, with full exemption from the social levies only beyond thirty years. Apply this to the Bordeaux example with twelve years of ownership. The income-tax reduction is 6 percent times seven years, years six through twelve, which is 42 percent. The taxable base for the 19 percent levy is therefore 37,500 times 58 percent, which is 21,750 euros, and the income-tax layer is 4,132.50 euros. The social-levies reduction is 1.65 percent times seven, which is 11.55 percent. The social base is 37,500 times 88.45 percent, which is 33,168.75 euros, and 17.2 percent of that is 5,705.03 euros. Your total French bill on the sale is about 9,837.53 euros, of which the social layer is the larger half. Hold the same apartment twenty-five years and the income-tax layer is zero while the social layer still bites; only after thirty years do both disappear. For nonresident sellers the administration taxes the gain through the social levies on investment products. The statute behind that rule is article L. 136-7, I bis, of the Social Security Code: “Sont également soumises à la contribution les plus-values imposées au prélèvement mentionné à l’article 244 bis A du code général des impôts lorsqu’elles sont réalisées, directement ou indirectement, par des personnes physiques.”
B. Why Americans pay the full 17.2 while my Dutch neighbor pays only 7.5: de Ruyter, Jahin, and the third-country rule
The difference between your bill and your Dutch neighbor’s bill has nothing to do with nationality and everything to do with social security affiliation. European Union law forbids making a person pay social charges to two countries at once. In 2015 the Court of Justice of the European Union held, in the case called de Ruyter, case C-623/13 decided on 26 February 2015, that French levies on investment income which help fund compulsory French social security schemes fall inside European social security coordination, even though they are assessed on property income rather than wages. In substance, the Court held that such investment-income levies show a direct and relevant link with the social security branches covered by the coordination regulation whenever they help finance compulsory schemes, and therefore fall within that regulation even when assessed on property income regardless of any professional activity. Because. Because the CSG and the CRDS fund French social protection, a person already affiliated with the social security system of another European Union or European Economic Area state, or Switzerland, cannot be charged them a second time by France. France therefore exempts such persons from the CSG and the CRDS and applies only the 7.5 percent solidarity levy in that case, treating it differently because it flows to the State budget rather than to social security financing. The service-public.fr page repeats the same 7.5 percent rule for owners affiliated with a compulsory social security scheme of an EEA country other than France or of Switzerland.
An American affiliated only with the United States Social Security system is on the other side of that line. The United States is a third country for this purpose, meaning a country outside the European Union, the European Economic Area, and Switzerland, and the single-legislation principle of the European regulations does not cover a person affiliated in a third country. The clearest judicial statement comes from a case strikingly close to yours: on 19 May 2020 the Paris administrative court of appeal decided case 19PA01723, concerning a French national living in Shanghai and then Taiwan who had sold two Paris buildings and asked for discharge of the social levies on his gains. The court recalled that the Court of Justice held in de Ruyter that “une personne relevant d’un régime de sécurité sociale d’un État membre de l’Union européenne autre que la France, d’un État membre de l’Espace économique européen ou de la Suisse ne peut être soumise aux prélèvements sur les revenus du capital prévus par la législation française qui entrent dans le champ du règlement du 29 avril 2004”, and added immediately: “En revanche, ce règlement ne fait pas obstacle à ce qu’une personne affiliée à la sécurité sociale dans un État tiers à l’Union européenne autre que la Suisse ou les États membres de l’Espace économique européen soit soumise à ces mêmes prélèvements.” The court found it established that the seller “relevait en 2014 d’un régime d’assurance sociale à Hong Kong, et n’était affilié à aucun régime de sécurité sociale en France ou dans un État membre de l’Union européenne, de l’Espace économique européen ou en Suisse”, and concluded: “Il ne peut, dès lors, utilement se prévaloir du principe d’unicité d’affiliation et de cotisation au régime de sécurité sociale.” Substitute Medicare and Social Security taxes paid in the United States for the Hong Kong affiliation and the reasoning applies point for point to an American owner.
The same decision (CAA Paris 19PA01723) closes the two escape routes taxpayers tried next. First, the solidarity levy itself: the court recalled that the Conseil d’État, in decision 395065 of 18 October 2017, had held that none of the funds financed by the solidarity levy fell within the European coordination regulation, so that “l’application du prélèvement de solidarité à la plus-value de cession en litige ne méconnaît ni le principe d’unicité de législation posé par l’article 11 du règlement (CE) n° 883/2004 du Parlement européen et du Conseil du 29 avril 2004, ni le principe prohibant les doubles cotisations qui en découle”. Second, free movement of capital: the court recalled that in Jahin, case C-45/17 decided on 18 January 2018, the Court of Justice accepted that the difference in treatment between European-affiliated and third-country-affiliated persons could be justified by “la différence de situation objective” between them, and concluded that “la circonstance qu’une personne affiliée à un régime de sécurité sociale d’un État tiers à l’Union européenne, autre que les États membres de l’Espace économique européen ou la Suisse, soit soumise, comme les personnes affiliées à la sécurité sociale en France, aux prélèvements sur les revenus du capital prévus par la législation française, ne constitue pas une restriction aux mouvements de capitaux en provenance ou à destination des pays tiers interdite par l’article 63 du Traité sur le fonctionnement de l’Union européenne”. The claim was rejected in full: “Article 1er : La requête de M. B… est rejetée.” An American who pays only United States Social Security taxes should therefore expect the full 17.2 percent, and should treat internet promises of a general American refund as unreliable.
Run the comparison on the Bordeaux sale to feel the gap. Your Dutch neighbor sells an identical studio with the identical 33,168.75 euro social base after twelve years, but as a person affiliated with the Dutch social security system he owes only the 7.5 percent solidarity levy, which is 2,487.66 euros. You owe 5,705.03 euros. The difference, 3,217.37 euros on a modest gain, is the price of third-country affiliation, and it is perfectly legal under current case law. The comparison also shows why the France-United States tax treaty does not fix the problem. The treaty signed on 31 August 1994, published in France by decree 96-222 of 15 March 1996, lists the taxes it covers in its article 2: for France, “l’impôt sur le revenu”, “l’impôt sur les sociétés”, “la taxe sur les salaires” and “l’impôt de solidarité sur la fortune”. Social levies are nowhere in that list, and for the United States the treaty covers federal income taxes “à l’exclusion des prélèvements de sécurité sociale”, excluding social security levies. The treaty gives France the right to tax your French rent and your French property gain, since article 6 gives the country where the property sits the right to tax rental income from it, and article 13 gives that same country the right to tax gains from selling it. But its double-tax relief operates only between the income taxes it covers, so the 17.2 percent stays outside the treaty machinery. If your situation touches both French property taxation and your residence status, the companion explainer on when an American becomes a French tax resident and how the treaty tie-breaker works sets out the residence side, while the guides to renting a French house unfurnished as an American and to selling a French house as an American detail the income-tax layers that sit next to the social charges explained here.
II. How do I challenge the bill and what does the IRS give me back
Knowing the rule is only half the work. The other half is procedural: most overpayments of French social levies are recovered not by arguing grand principles but by filing the right paper, with the right proof, before the right deadline, and then by treating the American return correctly. This part walks through both tracks in the order you should handle them.
A. How do I claim a refund from the French tax office: deadlines, letter, and proof
Begin with the document, not the theory. Pull out the avis d’imposition for the social levies, the assessment notice the nonresident office sent you between August and September, and check three things: the net base, the rate applied, and your affiliation box. The administration’s own tables say an owner affiliated with a European Economic Area or Swiss compulsory scheme owes 7.5 percent only, while “Autres cas”, the other cases, pay the full table ending in TOTAL 17,2 percent. If you are an American who also works in, say, Germany or the Netherlands and pays into that country’s compulsory social security, yet your notice charges 17.2 percent, you are looking at the single most winnable refund case in this whole area: a European-affiliated owner wrongly processed at the third-country rate. If you are affiliated only with the United States system, the case law above says the 17.2 percent stands, and your effort is better spent checking the base and the holding reduction, or moving to the American track, than relitigating de Ruyter.
The vehicle for the claim is the réclamation contentieuse, the formal tax complaint that asks the administration to discharge or reduce an assessment. The deadline is strict and short enough to miss while you are corresponding with your accountant. The complaint must reach the tax office before December 31 of the second year following the year the tax was formally assessed, the mise en recouvrement shown on your notice. Concretely, a social-levy assessment issued in 2026 can be challenged until 31 December 2028, the same illustration the administration itself gives for income tax assessed in 2026. File through your secure personal messaging on the tax website, the messagerie sécurisée, which creates a dated record, or by tracked mail to the nonresident individuals office, and keep the filing receipt. Nonresidents are directed to the Service des impôts des particuliers non résidents, reachable by telephone at +33 (0) 1 72 95 20 42, Monday to Friday from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m., and through the secure messaging in your online account.
What you attach decides the outcome. For the European-affiliation case, attach the assessment notice, a copy of your French tax return for the year, and proof of your affiliation with the European or Swiss compulsory scheme covering the income year, such as the portable document or certificate from that country’s institution, plus proof that you were not simultaneously under a compulsory French scheme. Ask expressly for discharge of the CSG and the CRDS with reduction of the bill to the 7.5 percent solidarity levy, citing article L. 136-7, I ter, of the Social Security Code and article 235 ter of the General Tax Code. For a base or rate error, attach the lease schedule or the notaire’s computation of the gain, show the correct net base or the correct number of holding years with the BOFiP allowance scale, and ask for the arithmetic correction with late-payment interest if the refund arrives late. If the office rejects the claim or stays silent, a lawyer can carry the dispute to the administrative court, where decisions like the Paris 19PA01723 ruling show judges applying the affiliation test document by document. One practical warning from that same case: the taxpayer there also asked for interest on late repayment, and the court refused that interest claim precisely because no live dispute about it existed on paper before the judge, recalling the late-payment interest rule of article L. 208 of the tax procedure code. Ask for moratory interest in the initial complaint itself, expressly and with the amount or the computation, so the claim exists on paper from day one rather than appearing for the first time before the judge.
B. Can I credit French social charges on my US return: the treaty, the IRS, and the math
The American side starts from a rule Americans often forget: the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income, so your Lyon rent and your Bordeaux gain are declarable in Washington even though France taxed them first. The treaty then divides the work. France, as the country where the property sits, may tax the rent and the gain, and the United States must relieve the resulting double taxation on the income taxes covered. Treaty article 24 provides that the United States grants its citizens and residents a credit against American income tax for French income tax paid by or for them. Note the exact object of that credit under the treaty wording: French income tax, and only that. The 20 percent minimum on your rent and the 19 percent levy on your gain fit that description. The 17.2 percent of social levies does not, because the treaty never listed those levies among the covered taxes. So the treaty itself gives you a credit path for the income-tax layer and stays silent on the social layer, which is governed instead by the domestic American foreign tax credit rules.
Those domestic rules are where the good news sits, and it comes straight from the Internal Revenue Service. The general American rule admits only income-type taxes to the foreign tax credit, while the published list of non-creditable taxes covers social security taxes paid to a country with which the United States holds a social security agreement. For years this raised the question whether the French CSG and CRDS, which help fund French social protection, were blocked as social security taxes. In 2019 the two countries settled the point through diplomatic communications, recorded on the IRS page in its section devoted to the French CSG and CRDS: the two levies are not social taxes covered by the Franco-American social security agreement, so the IRS will not challenge foreign tax credits for CSG and CRDS payments on that ground. The same page explains that individual taxpayers who paid these taxes without claiming them may file amended returns, generally within ten years from the day after the regular return due date, by flagging the French CSG/CRDS procedure on Forms 1040-X filed with accompanying Forms 1116. In practice, your American preparer claims the French income tax and the CSG plus CRDS portions through Form 1116, the form that computes the foreign tax credit, subject to the usual credit limitation that caps the credit at the American tax attributable to the same income.
Two cautions keep this honest. First, the IRS statement names the CSG and the CRDS and says nothing about the 7.5 percent solidarity levy, which is a newer charge allocated to the State budget rather than to social security. Whether your preparer can include that 7.5 percent in the same Form 1116 credit, deduct it, or must leave it unrelieved is a question for a United States tax professional on your exact facts, and you should get the answer in writing before amending. Second, the credit never exceeds the American tax on the same income, and currency conversion, the timing difference between the French assessment year and the American reporting year, and the interaction with depreciation on a furnished letting can all move the final number. Apply the method to the Lyon rental: 18,000 euros of net rent bears 3,600 euros of French income tax plus 1,656 euros of CSG and 90 euros of CRDS that the IRS will not challenge, a total potentially creditable pool of 5,346 euros against the American tax on that rent, with the 1,350 euros of solidarity levy flagged for your preparer’s opinion. On the Bordeaux sale, the 4,132.50 euros of French levy plus the CSG and CRDS slice of the 5,705.03 euros of social charges enter the same analysis, with the solidarity slice flagged the same way. Do not let anyone tell you the whole 17.2 percent automatically comes back as a dollar-for-dollar credit, and do not let anyone tell you none of it can ever be claimed. The verified position sits between those slogans: income tax plus CSG and CRDS go on Form 1116, the solidarity levy needs a written opinion, and the ten-year amended-return window means past years can still be fixed.
Conclusion
An American who rents or sells French property pays two French layers on the same income: income tax, with the 20 percent nonresident minimum on rent and the 19 percent levy on gains, and social levies of 17.2 percent split into 9.2 percent CSG, 0.5 percent CRDS, and 7.5 percent solidarity levy. A neighbor affiliated with a European or Swiss social security system legally pays only the 7.5 percent, because European coordination forbids double social charges and the solidarity levy alone flows to the State budget. An American affiliated only with the United States system pays the full 17.2 percent, as the Paris court confirmed for a third-country-affiliated seller in 2020, and the tax treaty does not change that result because it covers only income taxes. The practical path is therefore threefold: check the French assessment for affiliation, base, and holding years; file a formal complaint before December 31 of the second year after assessment with the affiliation proof or the corrected computation attached; and have an American preparer claim the French income tax with the CSG and CRDS on Form 1116, getting a written opinion on the solidarity slice and using the ten-year window for older years. Work the steps in that order and the 17.2 percent stops being a shock and becomes a number you can verify, challenge where it is wrong, and partly recover at home.