KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Paris Apartment Tax Bill Just Arrived: How Americans Compute the French Taxe Fonciere, Claim Exemptions, and Challenge Errors

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Paris Apartment Tax Bill Just Arrived: How Americans Compute the French Taxe Fonciere, Claim Exemptions, and Challenge Errors

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Every autumn, American owners of Paris apartments open the same envelope in their online tax account: the taxe foncière bill for the year. The amount often comes as a shock, especially when it arrives a few weeks after the taxe d’habitation on second homes. The two taxes look alike, they arrive in the same season, and they are paid to the same tax office, but they are two completely different taxes, computed under different articles, with different exemptions and different ways to challenge them. A companion guide on this site explains the second-home surcharge on the taxe d’habitation in detail, and the present article deals exclusively with the other bill: the taxe foncière on built properties, known in French as the taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties. In plain terms, this is the annual French property tax that every owner of a Paris apartment pays simply for owning it on January 1, whether the owner lives in the apartment, rents it out, leaves it empty, or resides full time in California, Texas, or New York. It applies to nonresidents exactly as it applies to residents: there is no residence condition, only an ownership condition. This article explains, in order, who owes the tax and from which date, how the administration computes the amount line by line, which exemptions and relief an American owner can realistically claim, and how to file a formal challenge before the legal deadline with the best chance of success. Every rule below is tied to the exact article of the tax code or the exact court decision that states it, with links to the official texts, because a tax bill is only worth challenging when the challenge rests on verifiable law.

I. How the French property tax on your Paris apartment is computed and who really pays it

A. Who owes the taxe foncière on January 1, and what happens when you buy or sell during the year

The starting point is short and absolute. Article 1380 of the Code général des impôts provides: “La taxe foncière est établie annuellement sur les propriétés bâties sises en France à l’exception de celles qui en sont expressément exonérées par les dispositions du présent code.” In everyday English: the tax is assessed every year on built properties located in France, except those the code expressly exempts. Three consequences follow for an American reader. First, the only thing that matters is ownership of a built property in France. American citizenship, American residence, and the absence of a French tax household change nothing: a pied-à-terre in the 7th arrondissement owned from abroad is taxed exactly like the apartment of a Parisian neighbor. Second, the owner on the decisive date owes the whole year, and the usufructuary, meaning the person who holds a legal right to use the property and collect its income while someone else holds bare ownership, owes it instead of the bare owner when such a split exists. The official English-language guidance confirms that the tax is due from the owner or the usufructuary of a built property, as explained on the service-public page for the taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties. Third, there is no pro-rating by the tax office when an apartment changes hands during the year.

The decisive date is January 1. The Conseil d’État recalls the rule in these terms: “La taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties, la taxe foncière sur les propriétés non bâties et la taxe d’habitation sont établies pour l’année entière d’après les faits existants au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition”, which is the wording of article 1415 of the tax code as quoted in Conseil d’État, 9th and 10th chambers combined, 5 June 2020, no. 423066. In practice, if you sell your Paris apartment on March 15, you remain the taxpayer for the entire year, and if you buy on December 20, the seller pays the whole year and you pay nothing for that year. The tax office never splits the bill between buyer and seller. Any sharing of the cost is a private matter for the sale paperwork handled by the notaire, the French public officer who authenticates the deed, and it is generally settled in the closing statement on a time-apportioned basis. Keep the distinction clear: the January 1 owner is the only person the administration can pursue, and the private reimbursement between the parties does not bind the tax office.

Two frequent confusions must be cleared at once. The taxe foncière is not the taxe d’habitation. Since the reform of the residence tax, the taxe d’habitation on second homes, called in French the taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires, is due for furnished premises kept as a dwelling other than the main home, as article 1407 of the tax code states: “La taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires est due pour tous les locaux meublés conformément à leur destination d’habitation autre qu’à titre principal”. An American who keeps a Paris pied-à-terre while living in the United States will generally receive both bills, each with its own base, its own rate, and its own exemptions. Do not mix the arguments: what defeats one bill rarely defeats the other. Readers who received the second-home bill should read the guide to the second-home surcharge and how to challenge it alongside this article. The second confusion concerns the household waste collection tax, the taxe d’enlèvement des ordures ménagères, universally abbreviated TEOM. It appears on the same notice as the taxe foncière, but it is a separate levy with its own rules. The official guidance notes that the same notice also carries the household waste collection tax (TEOM), a separate levy with its own rules. It adds that the owner must pay both even if the dwelling is rented out, while the TEOM can be passed on to the tenant as part of the recoverable charges, as explained on the same service-public page. When you rent out your Paris apartment, the TEOM line is the tenant’s economic burden; the taxe foncière line stays yours.

B. How the bill is computed from the valeur locative cadastrale, and how to read each line

The computation looks technical, but it follows a short chain with only three links: a rental value set by the administration, a 50 percent allowance, and local rates voted each year. Article 1388 of the tax code gives the formula: “La taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties est établie d’après la valeur locative cadastrale de ces propriétés déterminée conformément aux principes définis par les articles 1494 à 1508 et 1516 à 1518 B et sous déduction de 50 % de son montant en considération des frais de gestion, d’assurances, d’amortissement, d’entretien et de réparation.” In plain English: the tax starts from the valeur locative cadastrale, the cadastral rental value, which is the administration’s estimate of the annual rent the property could theoretically produce, then subtracts half of that amount as a flat allowance for management, insurance, depreciation, maintenance, and repair costs. The remaining half is the taxable base, and each local authority, the commune and the intercommunal body, multiplies that base by the rate it votes each year. The method for challenging inflated valuations is documented step by step on the economy ministry page on the calculation method and reductions, which also recalls that the tax is established for the whole year based on the situation on January 1.

The cadastral rental value deserves a closer look, because it is where most successful challenges are won. For residential property, these values were originally set by reference to rental levels of the 1970s and are updated each year by national revaluation coefficients, with the commune able to record new construction, changes in use, and changes in physical characteristics or surroundings under article 1517 of the tax code, whose official text is published on Legifrance. Two apartments in the same Paris building can therefore carry very different cadastral values depending on their recorded surface area, their fixtures, and their classification. The Conseil d’État polices exactly these details. In Conseil d’État, 9th chamber, 30 June 2023, no. 461560, a taxpayer disputed the cadastral value of commercial premises in Guadeloupe, and the court first recalled the article 1388 formula word for word before annulling the lower judgment for mishandling the evidence: the full decision is published on Legifrance. Two lessons from that ruling matter directly for a Paris apartment owner. First, the comparison must be done on the correct figures: a cadastral value of 63,444 euros becomes, after revaluation coefficients and the 50 percent allowance, a taxable value far above what the raw figure suggests, and the judges check the arithmetic. Second, precise evidence wins: the court refused to hold unsigned corrective declarations against the taxpayer, and held that the architect’s measured drawings supplied by the taxpayer “étaient d’une précision suffisante pour vérifier l’exactitude des surfaces retenues pour l’établissement des impositions en litige”, meaning they were precise enough to verify the surface areas used for the assessment. For an American owner, the message is concrete: if the surface area on the notice looks wrong, commission measured drawings from an architecte, keep them, and attach them to the claim, because courts accept that kind of proof.

A simplified numerical example shows how the lines of the notice fit together. Suppose the cadastral rental value of a two-room apartment in Paris is set at 12,000 euros for the year. The 50 percent allowance removes 6,000 euros, leaving a taxable base of 6,000 euros. If the combined local rates voted for the year amount, purely for illustration, to 30 percent, the taxe foncière comes to 1,800 euros before any relief, to which the TEOM is added on its own line. This is an illustration only, not the Paris rate for any particular year: rates are voted annually by each commune, and the owner should check the rate actually applied on the notice and compare it with the rates published for the commune through the official tool for consulting local direct-tax rates. The computation chain to verify is therefore always the same: the cadastral value, the revaluation coefficient for the year, the 50 percent allowance, and the voted rates. An error at any link reduces or increases the final bill, and each link can be challenged separately.

II. How Americans lower the bill or challenge it: exemptions, vacancy relief, and the formal claim

A. Which exemptions and relief actually help an American owner: new buildings, older owners, and empty apartments

Exemptions from the taxe foncière are narrow, and each one has strict conditions, which is exactly why they must be read in the code rather than guessed from summaries. The most useful exemption for buyers of new apartments is the two-year relief for new construction. Article 1383 of the tax code provides: “Les constructions nouvelles, reconstructions et additions de construction à usage d’habitation sont exonérées de la taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties durant les deux années qui suivent celle de leur achèvement.” In plain terms, a newly built residential property is exempt for the two calendar years following the year of completion. But the same article lets the commune limit or remove this exemption for its own share by a formal délibération, and the intercommunal body can remove it for its share as well. The Conseil d’État has confirmed how far that local power goes. In Conseil d’État, 8th chamber, 8 November 2019, no. 431028, published on Legifrance, a commune had voted to eliminate the temporary exemption for new dwellings, and the court held: “Il résulte de la lettre même de ces dispositions qu’une commune ou un groupement de communes à fiscalité propre, lorsqu’ils décident de supprimer l’exonération temporaire de taxe foncière bénéficiant aux logements neufs au titre des deux années suivant celle de leur achèvement, peuvent opter entre une suppression totale et une suppression préservant le cas d’immeubles financés dans le cadre de la politique publique d’aide au logement.” In other words, the commune may choose between a total removal and a removal that preserves buildings financed with state-assisted housing loans. For an American buying a new apartment in Paris or the inner suburbs, the practical lesson is strict: never assume the two-year exemption applies, always check the commune’s délibération for the year of completion, and file the completion declaration with the tax office within 90 days of finishing the works, because without that declaration the exemption machinery does not start. The official English guidance confirms the yearly rhythm of exemption paperwork: the owner sends the declaration and supporting documents by 31 December each year for the exemption to apply the following year, as stated on the service-public page.

The exemptions tied to age and modest income exist, but they help a narrower group. Article 1390 of the tax code exempts holders of the old-age solidarity allowance and the supplementary disability allowance from the tax on their main home, with a phase-out over the following years, and the official text is published on Legifrance. Article 1391 of the tax code exempts taxpayers over seventy-five on January 1 of the tax year for the dwelling they live in, provided the prior year’s income does not exceed the ceiling set by reference to article 1417, with the same phase-out design, and the official text is published on Legifrance. Because both provisions concern the main home and modest income, they will rarely help an American who keeps a Paris second home while earning American-level income, but they can matter for an American retiree who has moved full time into a modest Paris apartment and lives within the income ceiling. The conditions are cumulative and checked year by year, so eligibility must be re-verified for each tax year rather than assumed from a prior year.

The relief that matters most for empty Paris apartments is the vacancy discharge, called dégrèvement pour vacance, under article 1389 of the tax code, whose official text is published on Legifrance. It allows a reduction of the tax when a dwelling normally intended for rental stands vacant, or when business premises the owner uses are left unexploited, starting on the first day of the month after the vacancy begins and running until the last day of the month in which it ends. The statute states the test as a triple condition: “Le dégrèvement est subordonné à la triple condition que la vacance ou l’inexploitation soit indépendante de la volonté du contribuable, qu’elle ait une durée de trois mois au moins et qu’elle affecte soit la totalité de l’immeuble, soit une partie susceptible de location ou d’exploitation séparée.” The Conseil d’État gave this provision its teeth in the decision of 5 June 2020, no. 423066, cited above and published on Legifrance. First, the court defined the independence test: “Ces dispositions subordonnent le dégrèvement de la taxe foncière sur les propriétés bâties à la condition, notamment, que la vacance de l’immeuble normalement destiné à la location soit indépendante de la volonté du propriétaire, le caractère involontaire de la vacance s’appréciant eu égard aux circonstances dans lesquelles cette vacance est intervenue et aux démarches accomplies par le propriétaire, selon les possibilités qui lui étaient offertes, en fait comme en droit, pour la prévenir ou y mettre fin.” Involuntariness is therefore judged on the facts: what happened, and what the owner concretely did, within what was factually and legally possible, to prevent or end the vacancy. In that case the owner, living in Créteil with a rented house in the provinces, had instructed a letting agent as soon as notice to quit arrived, renewed the mandate twice while lowering the asking rent below the local average, and finally listed the property for sale when the mortgage payments became uncovered. Second, the court held that listing the property for sale does not destroy the claim: “la seule circonstance qu’un bien demeurant effectivement proposé à la location soit mis en vente n’est pas de nature à priver le contribuable du bénéfice du dégrèvement prévu au I de l’article 1389 du code général des impôts.” An owner who keeps the apartment genuinely available for rent while also trying to sell it remains eligible, and the lower court was wrong to treat the sale mandate as proof that the dwelling was no longer intended for rental. Third, the court corrected the period calculation: “la taxe est dégrevée du premier jour du mois suivant celui du début de la vacance jusqu’au dernier jour du mois au cours duquel la vacance a pris fin”, so relief runs month by month and the taxpayer in that case was in any event entitled to it for January through June 2014. For an American owner stuck with an empty Paris apartment between tenants or during a long renovation, the file to build starts on day one: dated letting mandates, rent reductions in writing, advertisements, refusals or absence of applicants, and any sale mandate kept alongside, not instead of, the rental effort. Money follows paper, and this case shows exactly which paper counts.

B. How to challenge the bill before December 31 of the following year, and what Paris owners must prepare

Every challenge to a taxe foncière bill runs against the same clock, and missing it ends the case before it starts. For local direct taxes, which include the taxe foncière, article R*196-2 of the Livre des procédures fiscales provides: “Pour être recevables, les réclamations relatives aux impôts directs locaux et aux taxes annexes doivent être présentées à l’administration des impôts au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle, selon le cas : a) De la mise en recouvrement du rôle, de la notification d’un avis de mise en recouvrement ou de l’émission d’un titre de perception”, with further starting points for specific events set out in the same article. In plain English: the formal claim, called a réclamation, must reach the tax administration no later than December 31 of the year after the tax year. For the 2026 bill, that means December 31, 2027. The official English guidance says the same thing in practical terms: the claim is filed once the notice is received and no later than 31 December of the following year, as stated on the service-public page. Do not confuse this outer deadline with the payment deadline: the bill must be paid first. The same page warns: the tax must still be paid by the deadline even when a claim is filed Paying under protest preserves the claim; refusing to pay triggers late penalties and enforcement while the challenge is pending. Owners who face a cash-flow problem can ask for a stay of payment, the sursis de paiement, alongside the claim, through the procedure described on the service-public claims page.

The claim itself is filed with the tax office shown on the notice, most conveniently today through the secure messaging system of the personal account on impots.gouv.fr, and it must state precisely what is wrong and what is asked. Vague complaints about the tax being too high go nowhere. The winning files mirror the case law above: for a surface-area error, attach the architect’s measured drawings and identify the lots concerned, because the Conseil d’État in the 30 June 2023 decision accepted exactly that kind of proof and annulled the judgment that had brushed it aside; for a vacancy claim, attach the dated letting mandates, the rent reductions, and the chronology of the empty months, because the 5 June 2020 decision turns entirely on documented effort; for a new-build exemption refused on the ground of a communal délibération, attach the completion declaration and the text of the délibération, because the 8 November 2019 decision turns on what the commune actually voted. If the administration rejects the claim in whole or in part, the decision can be taken to the administrative court of the place of taxation, which for a Paris apartment means the Paris administrative court circuit, within the time limit stated in the rejection. Paris owners should also remember the local specifics: Paris votes its own rates each year, Paris délibérations govern the fate of the new-build exemption for its share, and inner-suburb communes in the Île-de-France each have their own délibérations and their own rate histories, so a rule verified for Paris intra-muros must be re-verified for Boulogne-Billancourt, Saint-Denis, or Issy-les-Moulineaux. The rate-comparison tool linked above and the délibérations published by each commune are the two local sources to check before writing a single line of the claim.

One last question comes up in every American file: what does the France-United States tax treaty change? Less than owners hope, and the boundary is worth stating precisely. The treaty’s article 2 lists, for France, the taxes within its scope, and the official BOFiP commentary on the American treaty explains: article 2 covers, for France, taxes such as income tax, corporation tax, payroll tax, and the former solidarity wealth tax, with the full analysis published on the BOFiP page for the France-United States treaty, whose treaty text was published by decree no. 96-222 of 15 March 1996, available through the Journal officiel publication of the treaty (decree no. 96-222 of 15 March 1996). The treaty therefore organizes relief for income and wealth taxes; the taxe foncière, a local property tax, is computed, billed, and challenged under domestic French rules, and its exemptions and deadlines are the ones set out in this article, not in the treaty. Whether the amount paid can be deducted or credited on the American return is a separate United States question, governed by American rules and caps, which the owner should put in writing to the American preparer with a copy of the French notice attached. Owners whose Paris holdings also approach wealth-tax territory should keep the two files consistent: the cadastral values, surface areas, and ownership dates used here will reappear in the wealth-tax file, and the method for that parallel computation is set out in the guide to computing the French wealth tax and challenging the bill.

Conclusion

The taxe foncière rewards owners who read the notice line by line and punishes those who pay it as a lump sum. Check the January 1 ownership, verify the cadastral rental value and the surface areas behind it, confirm the voted rates, test every exemption against the exact communal délibération, document any vacancy from the first month, and file the formal claim no later than December 31 of the following year while paying the bill first. Each of these steps rests on a verifiable article or a published court decision linked above. Handled this way, the autumn bill stops being a surprise and becomes a file: measurable, challengeable, and decided under rules an American owner can actually use.

📄 Official circular