KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Your Paris Second Home Got a Taxe d’Habitation Bill: Why Americans Pay It, the 60% Surcharge, and How to Fight It

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Your Paris Second Home Got a Taxe d’Habitation Bill: Why Americans Pay It, the 60% Surcharge, and How to Fight It

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You live in Austin, you spend three weeks a year in the two-bedroom apartment you bought near Canal Saint-Martin, and you just opened your online account with the French tax administration to find an avis d’imposition, a tax assessment, for something you thought had disappeared years ago: the taxe d’habitation, the French residence tax. The amount looks nothing like the small local bill a Parisian friend once showed you, because a second line on the statement inflates it: the Paris surcharge on second homes. This guide explains, in plain English and with the exact French rules, why an American who barely uses a Paris apartment still owes this tax, how the 60 percent Paris increase works, why the United States France tax treaty does not absorb it, and how to pay it and challenge it without losing your rights. Every French term is translated the first time it appears, and every decisive rule is quoted word for word from the statute, the case law, or an official government page linked inline.

Start with the misunderstanding that costs Americans the most money. France did abolish the residence tax, but only for the home where you actually live. The official public-service site states that the tax on a main home has been gone since January 1, 2023, while adding in the same breath that if you own a second home, you still have to pay it. Your Paris apartment is, in French tax language, a residence secondaire, a secondary residence: any furnished unit that is not your main home. The statute says it plainly: “La taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires est due pour tous les locaux meublés conformément à leur destination d’habitation autre qu’à titre principal, y compris lorsqu’ils sont imposables à la cotisation foncière des entreprises. Toutefois, les locaux mentionnés au premier alinéa ne sont pas soumis à cette taxe lorsqu’ils font l’objet d’un usage exclusivement professionnel.” In other words, every furnished place kept for living that is not the main home is caught, even if it also bears business tax, unless it is used exclusively for professional purposes. Knowing that single sentence already prevents the two classic American mistakes: assuming the abolition covered every home, and assuming that renting the apartment out part of the year removes it from the tax.

This article follows one practical order. First, it identifies exactly who owes the tax on January 1 and why listing the apartment on a short-term rental platform does not save the owner, using two recent Council of State rulings. Second, it breaks down the Paris 60 percent increase and the reason the bilateral tax treaty gives no credit for it. Third, it walks through paying the bill from the United States and challenging it, with the three calendar dates that decide everything: July 1 for the occupancy declaration, the fall assessment, and December 31 of the following year for the formal complaint. If you bought through a company structure, read this together with the guide on buying through a French property company (SCI), because the company does not change the occupancy logic described below.

I. Why American owners still owe the taxe d’habitation on a Paris second home and how the 60 percent surcharge works

A. Who pays: the January 1 snapshot, furnished units, and the short-term rental trap two Council of State rulings closed

The tax is set for the whole year based on a single photograph taken on New Year’s Day. The official public-service page puts it this way: the second-home residence tax is set for the whole year based on the situation on January 1 of the tax year Everything flows from that sentence, which is linked here to the official tax-residence guidance. If you hold the apartment on January 1, you owe the full year’s tax even if you sell in February, even if you move your furniture out in March, and even if the apartment sits empty the rest of the year. Conversely, buying on January 2 means the seller, not you, bears that year’s bill. Americans used to a prorated American property tax calendar should reset their reflexes here: there is no proration, no partial year, and no closing-statement adjustment imposed by French law. The notaire handling your purchase may arrange a private reimbursement between buyer and seller, but that is a contractual courtesy, not a rule of the tax code.

The person named on the assessment is whoever has the use of the place, not necessarily the owner. Article 1408 of the tax code provides: “La taxe est établie au nom des personnes qui ont, à quelque titre que ce soit, la disposition ou la jouissance des locaux imposables.” Disposition ou jouissance means control or enjoyment in any capacity. In practice, the government site explains that the tax reaches the holder of a furnished unit that is not the main home but that can be occupied at any time, privately, whether as owner, tenant, or even a person housed for free, a furnished unit that is not your main home but that you can occupy at any time, privately, whether as owner, tenant, or even a person housed for free. So if you rent your Paris apartment year-round to a tenant under a standard lease, the tenant is the liable person and receives the bill. If you keep the keys, leave your furniture inside, and come and go as you please, you are the liable person even if you sleep there only twenty nights a year. The three words that matter most are furnished, private, and available: a furnished place (local meuble, a unit equipped for living), reserved for your private use, available to you whenever you want it.

The furnished condition deserves attention because Paris apartments sold to Americans are virtually always delivered and kept furnished, and the statute catches all of them. A bare, unfurnished unit is outside this tax; the moment beds, a kitchen setup, and basic furniture make it livable according to its residential purpose, it re-enters the scope. That is why stripping the apartment of furniture before January 1 is not a planning technique the administration accepts on its face: the test is whether the unit is furnished according to its residential purpose on January 1, and inspectors and tax offices look at the actual state of the premises, the utility contracts, and the rental listings, not at a single declaration. If the apartment genuinely serves only as offices, the exclusively professional use exception quoted in the introduction can apply, but a pied-a-terre with a bed and a shower that you also use for occasional remote work does not qualify.

Many American owners assume that putting the apartment on a vacation-rental platform for most of the year turns them into something other than the occupant and moves the tax onto the succession of short-stay guests. The Council of State, the highest administrative court, has now rejected that reasoning twice, in terms every Paris pied-a-terre owner should read. In a June 15, 2023 ruling (no. 468195) concerning an apartment rented furnished for short stays through several online platforms, the court restated the rule this way: “Il résulte de ces dispositions qu’est en principe redevable de la taxe d’habitation le locataire d’un local imposable au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition. Toutefois, par dérogation à ce principe, lorsqu’un logement meublé fait l’objet de locations saisonnières ou de courte durée, le propriétaire du bien est redevable de la taxe d’habitation dès lors qu’au 1er janvier de l’année de l’imposition, il peut être regardé comme entendant en conserver la disposition ou la jouissance une partie de l’année.” A seasonal or short-term rental does not transfer the tax to the passing guests; the owner stays liable whenever, on January 1, the facts show an intention to keep control or enjoyment of the unit for part of the year. Applying that test, the court approved the lower court which had relied on the fact that the unit was offered for short stays over periods the owners were free to accept or refuse, holding: “Cette circonstance permettant de regarder les intéressés comme entendant, au 1er janvier de l’année considérée, conserver la disposition ou la jouissance de leur logement au cours de cette année, le tribunal, qui a porté sur les faits de l’espèce une appréciation souveraine exempte de dénaturation, n’a, en statuant ainsi, pas commis d’erreur de droit.” Your freedom to accept or refuse each booking is exactly what proves you kept control.

Eighteen months later the court confirmed the doctrine even more firmly. In a December 23, 2024 ruling (no. 492174) about owners of three classified tourism lodgings marketed online, the lower court had granted relief on the ground that heavy short-term rental use proved the owners had not kept any personal use. The Council of State quashed that judgment for legal error: “En statuant ainsi, alors que de telles circonstances, caractérisées notamment par la latitude dont disposent les propriétaires d’accepter ou de refuser à leur gré au cours des différentes parties de l’année les propositions de courts séjours qui leur sont faites en réponse à leurs annonces, sont à l’inverse de nature à établir, ainsi qu’il est dit au point 2, qu’ils ont entendu dès le début de l’année conserver la disposition ou la jouissance de leurs biens, le tribunal administratif de Rennes a commis une erreur de droit.” Intensive platform activity, far from shielding the owner, demonstrates the very control that triggers liability. For an American who lists a Paris apartment while blocking off personal weeks, the message is blunt: the platform calendar is evidence against you, not for you, and the tax office can and does consult it.

There is one genuine exit for professional short-term operators, and its boundaries are narrow. The government site states: if you rent out furnished units that are or form part of your second home, the second-home tax is assessed in your name, unless those units are fitted out and reserved exclusively for rental If the furnished units are fitted out and reserved exclusively for rental, with no personal use ever, the owner escapes the second-home tax on those units. Exclusively means exclusively: a locked owner’s closet with personal belongings, a few personal nights between guests, or weeks blocked for family visits destroy the exception. Owners who genuinely never set foot in the unit should keep the proof of that exclusivity from day one, meaning platform calendars showing no owner stays, housekeeping invoices covering every turnover, and no personal objects on site, because the administration presumes personal availability and the owner in practice must show otherwise. Note also that this rental activity raises a separate set of Paris obligations on registration and change of use, described in the guide to Paris furnished-rental registration and change-of-use rules, and a separate income-tax and social-charge treatment for the rents, covered in the guide to French social charges on Paris rental income. Winning the residence-tax argument never settles the income-tax one.

B. How the tax is computed, why Paris adds 60 percent, and why the treaty gives no credit

The amount starts from the valeur locative cadastrale, the cadastral rental value: the theoretical annual rent the unit could produce, as recorded and updated by the administration. That value is multiplied by the local tax rate voted for second homes. The official site warns that you cannot reconstruct the bill yourself, because the computation combines the size and comfort elements of the unit, the updated cadastral value, and locally voted rates, and it invites owners who want an estimate to contact the property-tax office of the area. Two structural features then push Paris bills far above what Americans expect. First, a second home gets no base rebate. The City of Paris states it without ambiguity: a unit treated as a second home gets no base rebate The abatements that used to soften the old residence tax for main homes, for dependents, and for modest incomes do not apply here. Second, Paris votes the maximum surcharge the statute allows.

That surcharge is the majoration, the increase that councils in tight housing markets may add to the communal share of the second-home tax. Article 1407 ter of the tax code provides: “Dans les communes mentionnées au B du I de l’article 1406 bis, le conseil municipal peut, par une délibération prise dans les conditions prévues à l’article 1639 A bis, majorer d’un pourcentage compris entre 5 % et 60 % la part lui revenant de la cotisation de taxe d’habitation sur les résidences secondaires due au titre des logements meublés.” In the listed municipalities, the council may therefore raise its share of the bill by anywhere from 5 to 60 percent. Paris chose the ceiling. The City’s official tax page states: a 60 percent increase applies to the second-home residence-tax assessment It adds that the purpose is to push second-home owners to turn the unit back into a main home or to put it on the rental market for full-time occupancy, which is consistent with the acute housing shortage the capital invokes. For an American owner, the arithmetic is simple and painful: take the base second-home tax computed on the cadastral value, add 60 percent of the communal portion, and that is the Paris price of keeping a pied-a-terre.

The surcharge zone has also grown. It covers municipalities in continuous urban areas of more than 50,000 inhabitants with a marked imbalance between housing supply and demand, plus municipalities with a high proportion of dwellings that are not main homes, and the 2023 reform extended the list of covered municipalities, a decree the Council of State reviewed in its December 21, 2023 decision no. 488601 on the extended vacancy-tax and surcharge geography. The practical consequence for Americans is that the increase is not a Paris curiosity: second homes in Bordeaux, Lyon, Nice, the Basque coast, and many Alpine and coastal resorts can carry a voted increase too, each at the rate its own council chose within the 5 to 60 percent band. Always read the assessment itself rather than assuming the Paris rate travels with you.

The next American reflex is to reach for the bilateral treaty, and here disappointment awaits. The United States France tax treaty organizes relief from double taxation, but only for the taxes it covers. The French administration’s official commentary explains that, for France, the covered taxes are notably the income tax, the corporate tax, the payroll tax, and the former solidarity wealth tax, now replaced by the real-estate wealth tax. The second-home residence tax is a local occupancy tax assessed on the person who controls a furnished unit on January 1; it is neither an income tax nor a wealth tax within that treaty mechanism, so the treaty’s credit machinery does not absorb it. Budget for it as a final French cost of ownership, and have your American preparer confirm separately how the payment is treated on the United States side, because the treaty gives you no credit to claim for it in France. This is also why structuring the purchase through a French property company changes nothing on this point: the treaty analysis turns on the nature of the tax, not on the identity of the owner, and the occupancy test described above applies the same way.

One administrative duty shapes the bill before it even arrives, and Americans discover it too late. Article 1418 of the tax code requires every owner of residential premises to report the occupancy position each year: “A des fins de gestion des impositions prévues aux 1406 bis, 1407 et 1407 ter , les propriétaires de locaux affectés à l’habitation sont tenus de déclarer à l’administration fiscale, avant le 1er juillet de chaque année, les informations relatives à la nature de l’occupation de ces locaux, s’ils en réservent la jouissance, ou s’ils sont occupés par des tiers.” Before July 1 every year, the owner must therefore declare, for each unit, whether it is a main home, a second home, or vacant, and if a third party occupies it, identify that occupant with name, birth details, and related information, through the property section of the online account on impots.gouv.fr. The government site attaches a sting to this duty: a missing or inaccurate declaration exposes the owner to a 150 euro fine per unit concerned, and worse, the tax office then assesses the unit on the basis of whatever it believes the occupancy to be. For the American owner, the July declaration is the cheapest insurance available: declare the Paris apartment as a second home held at your disposition, or name the year-round tenant with exact identity details, and the assessment that follows will at least rest on correct facts.

II. How Americans pay the bill on time and challenge it without losing their rights

A. Declare the occupancy before July 1, read the fall assessment, and pay from the United States

Run the year in the order the administration does. In the first half of the year, file the occupancy declaration described above through the real-estate section of your online account, checking that the apartment appears under the correct address, the correct occupancy status, and, if rented year-round, the correct tenant identity. If you cannot file online, the government site directs owners to contact their tax office by letter or at the counter, and owners living in the United States should not wait until August to test whether their online access works: locked accounts, unlinked property references after a purchase, and unanswered secure messages are routine, and July 1 is a fixed reporting date, not a courtesy suggestion. Keep a dated copy of every declaration and every correction, because the declaration history is the first document the tax office opens when you later dispute the bill.

In the fall, the assessment arrives. The government site states: the tax notice arrives during the last quarter of the year During the last quarter of the year, you receive the tax notice, also visible in your online account. Read it the way a French litigator reads it: the occupancy status retained, the cadastral rental value used, the communal rate applied, the surcharge line if your municipality voted one, the total, the payment deadline, and the payment methods. The same official page confirms that the notice shows the calculation inputs, the amount due, the deadline, and the available means of payment. Pay by the stated deadline even if you intend to challenge the bill, because filing a complaint does not suspend collection. The government site is explicit: filing a complaint does not excuse payment of the tax Filing the challenge does not excuse payment. You may separately ask for a payment deferral, called a sursis de paiement, while the complaint is examined, but the request must be made; it is never automatic. Americans paying from a United States bank account should initiate the transfer with a wide margin before the deadline, verify which international payment channels the notice accepts, and keep the debit proof showing the French tax reference, because a late payment draws penalties that no later victory on the merits automatically erases.

Paris adds two local specifics worth building into your routine. First, the office that handles your file is the tax office of the place where the property sits: complaints go, in the words of the official guidance, to the individual tax office of the location of the second home, and Paris owners deal with the Paris service, not with the office of a French address they may no longer have. Second, Paris applies the full 60 percent increase with no base rebate, as shown above, so the amount to provision each fall is materially higher than the base tax alone. Owners who also earn rent from the apartment should keep this residence-tax file strictly separate from the rental-income file: the income tax and the social charges on the rents follow their own assessment, their own treaty analysis, and their own deadlines, and mixing the two files in a single complaint letter is the surest way to have the complaint declared inadmissible for targeting the wrong assessment. Finally, if the situation changes, meaning the year-round tenant leaves, the apartment is sold, or personal use ends, update the occupancy declaration before the next July 1 rather than hoping the administration notices. The administration taxes the facts as declared and observed; silence is read against the taxpayer.

Build one standing evidence folder for the apartment, updated every January. It should contain the title deed or the most recent property tax notice proving ownership, the January 1 occupancy proof for that year, meaning the lease in force with the year-round tenant or, for personal use, travel records, utility bills, and insurance showing availability, the July declaration receipt, the platform calendars and housekeeping invoices if the unit is rented short-term, and the fall assessment with the payment proof. This folder serves twice: it makes the July declaration accurate, and it becomes the exhibit bundle if you challenge the bill. American owners who manage from abroad through a caretaker should require the caretaker to send these documents unprompted each January, because reconstructing January occupancy in November, after the assessment arrives, is when cases are lost.

B. Claim the surcharge relief and file the challenge before December 31 of the following year

When the assessment is wrong, French law offers two distinct remedies, and they must not be confused: relief from the surcharge, called a degrevement, which cancels the increase while leaving the base tax due, and full discharge of the tax itself, which cancels the whole bill. The surcharge relief is the narrower and often the more valuable of the two for Paris owners, because the 60 percent increase dominates the bill. Article 1407 ter opens the door this way: “Sur réclamation présentée dans le délai prévu à l’article R. * 196-2 du livre des procédures fiscales et dans les formes prévues par ce même livre, bénéficient d’un dégrèvement de la majoration :” Those who file the complaint within the deadline set by article R. 196-2 of the tax procedure book, and in the forms that book requires, obtain relief from the increase in three situations. First, the dwelling near the workplace: persons forced by their professional activity to live somewhere other than the family main home, for the unit kept near the job. Second, the former main home of a person moved into long-term care: the unit that was the main home before admission to a qualifying care establishment. Third, the involuntary non-use case: persons who, for a reason beyond their control, cannot use the unit as a main home. The government site illustrates that third case with the classic example of a unit that cannot be lived in because works are needed to make it decently habitable. An American assigned by an employer to a Paris office while the family remains in Texas, an owner whose apartment was wrecked by a burst pipe and declared unfit pending structural works, or an heir who cannot occupy an estate unit locked inside an undivided inheritance dispute should each test their facts against these three doors, with documents rather than assertions: the employment contract and transfer letter, the care-home admission certificate, the contractor reports, the uninhabitability order, or the notarial certificate of the inheritance deadlock.

A companion protection covers owners who left their main home for residential care. Article 1414 B of the tax code exempts the former main home of persons durably housed in a qualifying establishment, stating: “L’exonération est accordée à compter de l’année qui suit celle de leur hébergement dans les établissements ou services mentionnés au premier alinéa du présent I.” The exemption runs from the year after admission. American families with an aging parent in France who enters a care home should therefore verify which unit the administration treats as the former main home, from which year the exemption starts, and whether the surcharge relief for the same situation has also been applied, because the exemption and the surcharge relief operate on different lines of the assessment and the administration does not always apply both spontaneously.

Full discharge of the tax is available when the occupancy facts retained by the administration are simply wrong: the unit was genuinely unfurnished on January 1, it was exclusively professional premises, it was the taxpayer’s actual main home, or the bill names the wrong person, for instance the owner when a year-round tenant held the unit on January 1. The two Council of State rulings discussed above draw the battle lines for the most common American dispute, the short-term rental case. After those rulings, arguing that Airbnb guests were the occupants is a losing argument; the winning arguments are that the unit was exclusively fitted out and reserved for rental with zero personal use, proven by complete calendars and turnover records, or that the assessment misstates the January 1 facts, proven by the lease, the inventory, and the utility history. Frame the complaint around the January 1 snapshot and the statutory words, disposition or enjoyment, rather than around fairness or the number of nights spent elsewhere, because the judge decides on those two words alone.

Procedure matters as much as substance, and the calendar is unforgiving. The complaint, called a reclamation, can be filed online through the secure messaging of your tax account, in person at the tax office, or by simple letter to the tax office of the place where the property sits; the official guidance lists all three channels and gives the office addresses through the tax-contact directory. Whatever the channel, the deadline is statutory. Article R. 196-2 of the tax procedure book provides: “Pour être recevables, les réclamations relatives aux impôts directs locaux et aux taxes annexes doivent être présentées à l’administration des impôts au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle, selon le cas : a) De la mise en recouvrement du rôle, de la notification d’un avis de mise en recouvrement ou de l’émission d’un titre de perception ;” Complaints about local direct taxes must reach the administration no later than December 31 of the year after the year of the collection notice, in the cases listed starting with the assessment roll. Concretely, the bill received in the fall of year N must be challenged no later than December 31 of year N plus 1, and that deadline covers both the base tax and the surcharge relief, since article 1407 ter expressly refers complaints to the same deadline. Missing it closes the administrative door permanently for that year’s bill, whatever the merits.

If the administration rejects the complaint expressly or stays silent, the dispute moves to the administrative court, the tribunal administratif of the place where the property sits, and a second deadline starts running. Article R. 421-1 of the administrative justice code provides: “La juridiction ne peut être saisie que par voie de recours formé contre une décision, et ce, dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée.” The court must be seized within two months of notification of the decision under attack. Count those two months from the express rejection, or from the implied rejection born of administrative silence, and file a complete brief the first time: the January 1 evidence, the declaration history, the assessment, the complaint and its proof of filing, and the legal grounds tied to the exact statutory words. Courts decide these cases on documents, and the owners who win are the ones whose folder, built back in January as recommended above, already contains everything.

Conclusion

The Paris second-home bill surprises Americans only once. The residence tax still applies in full to every furnished unit that is not a main home, the January 1 snapshot fixes liability for the entire year with no proration, short-term rental activity confirms rather than defeats the owner’s control under the Council of State’s 2023 and 2024 rulings, Paris adds the maximum 60 percent surcharge with no base rebate, and the bilateral treaty offers no credit for this local occupancy tax. The response is a yearly routine rather than a dispute: declare the true occupancy position before July 1, read the fall assessment against the January 1 facts, pay by the deadline while asking for a deferral if a complaint is filed, and challenge any error before December 31 of the following year with the surcharge relief of article 1407 ter tested first. Run that routine every year, keep the January evidence folder current, and the Paris apartment stays what it should be: an expensive pleasure, never an uncontrolled one.

📄 Official circular