KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Selling Your French Second Home as an American: Capital-Gains Taper, Surtax, and the IRS Credit

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Selling Your French Second Home as an American: Capital-Gains Taper, Surtax, and the IRS Credit

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought a vacation apartment in Nice, a stone house in the Dordogne, or a small studio in Paris that was never your main home, and now you want to sell. The first question every American seller asks is whether France will take a cut, the second is how large that cut will be, and the third is whether the IRS will tax the same gain all over again. The short answers are yes, it depends mostly on how long you owned the place, and no, not twice, if you file the American return correctly. This article walks through the French computation the notaire (the French public officer who handles every real-estate closing) will run at your signing appointment, the three layers of French tax that can stack on a second home, and the American side: treaty situs rule, IRS reporting, and the foreign tax credit that prevents double taxation. A plus-value immobilière is simply the French term for a real-estate capital gain, the difference between your sale price and your adjusted purchase price. A résidence secondaire is any dwelling that is not your résidence principale, your main home on the day of the sale. That distinction controls everything, because France fully exempts the main home and taxes almost every other French property an American sells.

I. Will France Tax the Sale of My French Second Home, and How Much Will I Owe?

France taxes the sale of a French second home as a matter of principle and exempts only the main home as a matter of exception. Article 150 U of the French General Tax Code states the exemption for property that meets the test of Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession, meaning property that is the seller’s main home on the day of the sale. A vacation home, a pied-a-terre you use a few weeks a year, or a Paris studio you rent out while living in the United States never meets that test, so the gain falls squarely into the taxable category. French-source treatment is confirmed for nonresidents by article 164 B of the same code, which provides that Les plus-values mentionnées aux articles 150 U , 150 UB et 150 UC , lorsqu’elles sont relatives : 1° A des biens immobiliers situés en France ou à des droits relatifs à ces biens are considered French-source income, so living in New York or California does not move the gain outside French tax. One narrow escape hatch exists for very small sales: article 150 U also exempts sales where Dont le prix de cession est inférieur ou égal à 15 000 €., with the 15,000 euro ceiling assessed on the full ownership value of the property, so a garden shed sold separately for a few thousand euros may escape while a real apartment never will. The rest of this part explains how the taxable amount shrinks the longer you hold the property and which rates apply once the taxable base is set.

A. How France Computes Your Taxable Gain: Purchase Price, Deductible Costs, and the 22-Year and 30-Year Taper

The computation starts with a simple subtraction, sale price minus adjusted purchase price, but each side of that subtraction has French rules an American seller should know before signing anything. The sale price is the price written in the deed, reduced by the selling costs you can document such as agency commission paid by you. The purchase price is the price written in your original acquisition deed, and the administration lets you increase it with two flat-rate allowances that most American owners find generous. First, acquisition costs such as registration duties and notaire fees count for their documented amount or for a flat 7.5 percent of the purchase price. Second, construction, reconstruction, enlargement, and improvement work counts for its documented amount or for a flat 15 percent of the purchase price when you have owned the property for more than five years. The official service-public explainer confirms both allowances in these terms: acquisition costs for their justified amount or a flat 7.5 percent, and works for their justified amount or a 15 percent flat rate where the property has been held for more than five years, as set out on the official plus-value immobilière page. Keep every invoice anyway, because documented real costs beat the flat rates whenever you renovated seriously, and the flat 15 percent is lost entirely during the first five years of ownership.

Once the gross gain is set, France applies a holding-period allowance, called abattement pour durée de détention, that reduces the taxable base year by year and works differently for the income-tax base and the social-charges base. The official table published by the administration reads as follows: up to five years of ownership, zero allowance on both bases; from the sixth through the twenty-first year, 6 percent per year against the income-tax base and 1.65 percent per year against the social-charges base; for the completed twenty-second year, 4 percent against the income-tax base and 1.6 percent against the social-charges base; beyond the twenty-second year, full exemption from income tax with 9 percent per year continuing against the social-charges base; and beyond the thirtieth year, full exemption from social charges as well. The same official page states the two finish lines plainly: Vous êtes exonéré d’impôt sur la plus-value immobilière pour tout bien détenu depuis plus de 22 ans. And for the second finish line: La plus-value réalisée lors de la vente d’un bien détenu depuis plus de 30 ans est aussi exonérée de prélèvements sociaux. In plain English, after twenty-two years of ownership no French income tax remains on the gain, after thirty years no French social charges remain either, and between those dates only a shrinking social-charges base survives. The allowances apply per completed year counted from the acquisition date, so a sale signed a few weeks before an anniversary can cost real money, and timing the deed after the anniversary is one of the simplest lawful savings available.

A short numerical illustration shows how the two bases diverge. Take an American who bought a Nice studio for 200,000 euros nine years ago, added the 7.5 percent acquisition flat rate (15,000 euros) plus the 15 percent works flat rate (30,000 euros, ownership beyond five years), giving an adjusted base of 245,000 euros, and now sells for 350,000 euros. The gross gain is 105,000 euros. After nine years, the income-tax allowance is 6 percent times four years (years six through nine), equal to 24 percent, so the income-tax base is 79,800 euros. The social-charges allowance is 1.65 percent times four, equal to 6.6 percent, so the social-charges base is 98,070 euros. The same gain therefore produces two different taxable amounts, and each is then taxed at its own rate, which is the subject of the next section. American sellers sometimes ask whether they can deduct American selling costs, mortgage interest, or dollar-euro exchange losses in this French computation. The answer is no: only the French-law acquisition price plus French-law allowances and works enter the French base, exchange movements are invisible to the French computation, and mortgage interest never reduces a French private capital gain.

B. The Three Layers You Pay: 19 Percent Income Tax, 17.2 Percent Social Charges, and the Surtax Above 50,000 Euros

On the tapered bases just computed, France stacks up to three levies. The first layer is income tax at a flat 19 percent of the income-tax base for individuals. The second layer is social charges, called prélèvements sociaux, at a flat rate the administration states without ambiguity: Vous devez payer des prélèvements sociaux au taux de 17,2 %. These two layers alone take a combined 36.2 percent of their respective bases before any surtax, which surprises Americans used to preferential federal rates on long-term gains. The third layer is a high-value surtax created by article 1609 nonies G of the General Tax Code, which provides that La taxe est due à raison des plus-values imposables d’un montant supérieur à 50 000 €, assessed on the taxable gain after the holding allowance. The surtax scale runs from 2 percent on gains just above 50,000 euros up to 6 percent on gains above 260,000 euros, with smoothing at each bracket threshold so that crossing a threshold by one euro does not trigger the full bracket rate on the whole gain. Concretely, the scale charges 2 percent from 50,001 to 60,000 euros with smoothing, 2 percent from 60,001 to 100,000 euros, 3 percent from 100,001 to 110,000 euros with smoothing, 3 percent from 110,001 to 150,000 euros, 4 percent from 150,001 to 160,000 euros with smoothing, 4 percent from 160,001 to 200,000 euros, 5 percent from 200,001 to 210,000 euros with smoothing, 5 percent from 210,001 to 250,000 euros, 6 percent from 250,001 to 260,000 euros with smoothing, and 6 percent above 260,000 euros. The notaire computes this surtax on the same return as the main gain, so there is no separate filing to arrange.

Returning to the Nice studio example makes the stacking concrete. The income-tax base of 79,800 euros at 19 percent produces 15,162 euros of income tax. The social-charges base of 98,070 euros at 17.2 percent produces 16,868 euros of social charges. The taxable gain for surtax purposes is 79,800 euros, inside the 60,001 to 100,000 euro bracket at 2 percent, adding 1,596 euros. The French total at closing is therefore about 33,626 euros on a 105,000 euro gross gain, roughly one third, after only nine years of ownership. Hold the same studio thirteen more years, past the twenty-second anniversary, and the income-tax layer plus the surtax both fall to zero while only the social-charges layer survives on a heavily tapered base. That comparison explains why the holding period dominates every other planning variable for a French second home, and why American owners who can choose their sale year often wait for an anniversary. It also explains why the purchase-price adjustments matter so much: every euro of documented works or acquisition costs deducted at the start escapes all three layers at once.

II. How Do I File and Pay in France and America Without Paying Twice?

Knowing the amount is only half the task; the other half is the paperwork on two continents, and mistakes here are punished by penalties, interest, and in the worst cases litigation against the professionals who failed to warn. France collects its tax at the closing table through the notaire, while the United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide income and then grants relief for the French tax through the treaty and the foreign tax credit. The two systems interlock cleanly when each return reports the same sale, and they produce double taxation only when the American return omits the sale or claims the wrong relief. This part describes the French collection circuit first, including the special rules for sellers who live in America, then the American reporting chain from the treaty article down to the IRS forms.

A. The French Paper Trail: Notaire Collection, Tax Returns, and the Nonresident Levy

For a seller who lives in France, the circuit is centralized and almost automatic: the notaire who authenticates the deed computes the gain, applies the allowances, withholds the income tax, social charges, and any surtax from the sale proceeds, and pays the Treasury when the deed is registered. The seller does not file a separate capital-gains return later; the deed and its annexed capital-gains declaration carry the whole filing, and the net price the seller receives is already net of French tax. That convenience has a sharp edge, because the computation is frozen into an authenticated deed that is difficult to reopen, so errors in the purchase-price base, the works allowance, or the anniversary count become expensive to correct after signature. French courts hold the notaire to a demanding duty to advise on exactly these points. The Paris Court of Appeal ruled on 7 April 2026, case number 22/19262, that a notaire who failed to secure available allowances for his client a commis une faute en sa qualité de rédacteur d’acte, and it ordered the notaire and his firm to pay 17,100 euros for wasted fees plus 34,313 euros for the lost chance to obtain the allowances. A Bordeaux trial court reached the same lesson from the seller’s side on 18 March 2025, case number 23/00043, where a land sale had generated 84,158 euros of taxes the seller said she learned about too late to walk away: the court held the notaire liable for the missing tax advice and ordered payment, stating CONDAMNE Maître [J] [U] à payer à Mme [H] [I] la somme de 25.247 euros en réparation de la perte de chance subie du fait du manquement à l’obligation de conseil sur la fiscalité sur la plus value applicable à la cession de sa parcelle. American sellers should therefore arrive at the signing with their acquisition deed, works invoices, and holding-period count already checked, ask the notaire for the draft capital-gains computation days before closing, and never accept a verbal assurance that the allowances were applied.

For a seller who lives in the United States and is not a French tax resident, a parallel levy applies under article 244 bis A of the General Tax Code, and its mechanics deserve close attention because an accredited representative may be required. The article opens by providing that, subject to tax treaties, gains defined by article 164 B and realized by persons not domiciled in France on the sale of French real property are subject to a levy at the rates set further down, and the operative rate for individuals is then fixed in plain terms: les personnes physiques, les associés personnes physiques de sociétés, groupements ou organismes dont les bénéfices sont imposés au nom des associés et les porteurs de parts, personnes physiques, de fonds de placement immobilier mentionnés à l’article 239 nonies sont soumis au prélèvement au taux de 19 %. The taxable base follows the same allowance rules as for residents, including the holding-period taper, so a nonresident American keeps the benefit of years owned. Collection runs through the deed as well, with the statute providing that L’impôt dû en application du présent article est acquitté lors de l’enregistrement de l’acte ou, à défaut d’enregistrement, dans le mois suivant la cession, sous la responsabilité d’un représentant établi en France, accrédité par l’administration fiscale. In practice, the seller’s notaire usually arranges the accredited representative, the levy is paid out of the price, and the seller receives the net balance. Two reliefs can soften this levy and should be tested before every nonresident sale: the treaty between France and the United States, which governs who may tax, and the former-main-home relief that exempts, under strict timing and occupation conditions, the sale of the dwelling that was the seller’s French main home when tax residence moved abroad. Because the administration itself warns nonresidents that Si vous êtes non-résident, une convention fiscale internationale peut fixer des règles différentes. the treaty check is not optional decoration but part of the computation, and the American return is where that treaty check pays off.

B. The American Return: Reporting the Sale to the IRS and Claiming the French Tax as a Credit

The United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide income, so the French gain must appear on the American return even though France already taxed it, and the treaty then decides which country has the first right to tax and how the other country gives relief. The situs rule is short and decisive. Article 13, paragraph 1, of the France-United States income tax treaty, signed 31 August 1994, provides that Gains from the alienation of real property situated in a Contracting State may be taxed in that State. A French apartment is real property situated in France, so France may tax the gain, and the United States, which taxes the same gain under its worldwide principle, must relieve the resulting double taxation. The relief mechanism sits in Article 24, paragraph 1(a), under which the United States shall allow to a citizen or a resident of the United States as a credit against the United States income tax: (i) the French income tax paid by or on behalf of such citizen or resident; The practical chain therefore runs: report the worldwide gain to the IRS, compute the American tax, then claim the French income tax as a foreign tax credit that reduces the American tax dollar for dollar within the legal limits. The treaty text itself, with both articles, is published by the IRS at the link cited above, and the protocol history does not change this two-step logic.

On the forms, the sale is reported as a capital transaction in the year of the sale, with the French purchase price converted into dollars at the applicable exchange rates for acquisition and sale, and the credit is claimed on the dedicated foreign-tax-credit form. The IRS instructs individuals in these terms: File Form 1116, Foreign Tax Credit (Individual, Estate, or Trust), to claim the foreign tax credit if you are an individual, estate or trust, and you paid or accrued certain foreign taxes to a foreign country or U.S. possession. The credit is subject to its own limitation baskets, so the French income tax on the property gain offsets American tax on the same category of foreign-source income, and any excess credit mechanics follow the form instructions rather than intuition. One American-side trap needs emphasis: the celebrated home-sale exclusion does not help here. The IRS describes that exclusion as available on the main home, stating If you have a capital gain from the sale of your main home, you may qualify to exclude up to $250,000 of that gain from your income, or up to $500,000 of that gain if you file a joint return with your spouse. A French vacation home is not the main home, so no exclusion shelters the gain, and owners who split time between countries should keep the main-home file, with residence proofs, for the property that genuinely qualifies, a topic covered in the companion guide on selling a French main home as an American. A second American-side point favors careful filers: the French social-charges component has a documented IRS position. The IRS foreign-tax-credit page records that the IRS will not challenge foreign tax credits for CSG and CRDS payments on the basis that the Agreement on Social Security applies to those taxes. Because the 17.2 percent French social-charges bundle includes the CSG and CRDS alongside other levies, the exact creditable slice must be computed line by line on Form 1116 rather than assumed, and amended returns remain possible within the refund windows the same page describes. Sellers who discover an unclaimed credit after filing should therefore revisit the return instead of writing the French tax off as a dead cost.

Conclusion

A French second home sells under rules that reward patience and punish improvisation. France taxes the gain because the property is not the seller’s main home, shrinks the taxable base with a taper that zeroes out income tax after twenty-two years and social charges after thirty, then applies 19 percent income tax, 17.2 percent social charges, and a 2 to 6 percent surtax above 50,000 euros of taxable gain. The notaire collects the whole French bill at closing, French courts punish professionals who compute it wrong, and nonresident Americans pay through the 19 percent levy collected at registration with an accredited representative standing behind the payment. The United States taxes the same gain worldwide, lets France tax it first under the treaty’s real-property article, and relieves the overlap through the foreign tax credit claimed on Form 1116, with the main-home exclusion reserved for genuine main homes and a favorable IRS position available on the CSG and CRDS slice. An American who checks the acquisition base, counts the holding anniversary, reads the draft notaire computation before signing, and reports the sale on both returns keeps the French bill at its legal minimum and the American bill free of double tax.

📄 Official circular