You bought a stone house in the Dordogne fifteen years ago for 180,000 euros, spent summers there with your kids, and now a buyer offers 340,000 euros. Your first question is how much of that price you actually keep. Your second question is whether the IRS will tax you again on the same profit back home. French lawyers call the profit on a sale a plus-value immobilière, literally an increase in real-estate value, and France taxes it before the money ever leaves the closing table. The closing itself is handled by a notaire, a public officer who drafts the deed, computes the tax, and sends it to the Treasury from the sale price. The United States then taxes the same gain as part of your worldwide income, but the tax treaty between the two countries converts the French payment into a credit against your American bill. This article walks through the French computation step by step, the exemptions American sellers most often misunderstand, the American side of the equation, and the signing-day paperwork that protects your credit. Two recent French court decisions show what goes wrong when the acquisition price is miscalculated or an exemption is assumed instead of verified, and both ended with the notaire in court.
I. How Much Tax Will France Take When I Sell My French House?
France starts from a simple principle: gains on buildings and land sold for payment are subject to income tax under a dedicated set of rules. Article 150 U of the French Tax Code states that “les plus-values réalisées par les personnes physiques ou les sociétés ou groupements qui relèvent des articles 8 à 8 ter , lors de la cession à titre onéreux de biens immobiliers bâtis ou non bâtis ou de droits relatifs à ces biens, sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 V à 150 VH .” (CGI, art. 150 U). As an American living in the United States, you fall into the nonresident track of that same system: article 164 B of the Tax Code expressly lists French-source real-estate income among taxable items, opening with “Sont considérés comme revenus de source française : a. Les revenus d’immeubles sis en France ou de droits relatifs à ces immeubles” (CGI, art. 164 B). The treaty can soften this, and it does, but it never removes France’s first right to tax a house standing on French soil.
A. How Does France Compute My Taxable Gain and Apply the 19 Percent Levy?
The starting point is the gross gain, and the statute defines it in one sentence: “La plus ou moins-value brute réalisée lors de la cession de biens ou droits mentionnés aux articles 150 U à 150 UC est égale à la différence entre le prix de cession et le prix d’acquisition par le cédant” (CGI, art. 150 V). Sale price minus purchase price. Everything that follows adjusts one of those two numbers, and each adjustment is money, so each one deserves evidence.
On the purchase side, the price you paid is increased by what you spent to acquire and improve the property. The tax administration’s official doctrine allows acquisition costs to be counted either at their documented amount or as a flat-rate 7.5 percent of the purchase price (BOI-RFPI-PVI-20-10-20-20). Improvement works follow the same logic: documented invoices count in full, or you may claim a flat 15 percent of the purchase price provided you sell more than five years after acquisition (BOI-RFPI-PVI-20-10-20-20). Keep every contractor invoice, every receipt for materials, and the original purchase deed, because the flat percentages are fallbacks, and real documented costs often beat them. Note the trap hidden in that rule: only works you paid for and can prove count, so a kitchen remodeled without invoices adds nothing to your acquisition price.
Once the gross gain is set, France applies a holding-period discount, called the abattement pour durée de détention, and it works on two different clocks. For income tax purposes, the holding-period discount runs at 6 percent for each year of ownership beyond the fifth through the twenty-first, plus 4 percent for the twenty-second year, so that full income-tax exemption is reached after twenty-two years of ownership (BOI-RFPI-PVI-20-20). For social charges, the discount runs slower: 1.65 percent per year beyond the fifth through the twenty-first, 1.60 percent for the twenty-second year, then 9 percent per year beyond the twenty-second, with full exemption only after thirty years (BOI-RFPI-PVI-20-20). A house held fourteen years therefore leaves part of the gain taxable: the income-tax discount covers nine years at 6 percent, or 54 percent, while the social-charges discount covers nine years at 1.65 percent, under 15 percent.
The rate applied to the discounted gain is where your nonresident status matters most. Article 244 bis A of the Tax Code provides that “Sous réserve des conventions internationales, les plus-values, telles que définies aux e bis et e ter du I de l’article 164 B , réalisées par les personnes et organismes mentionnés au 2 du I lors de la cession des biens ou droits mentionnés au 3 sont soumises à un prélèvement selon les taux fixés au III bis.” (CGI, art. 244 bis A). The persons concerned expressly include “Les personnes physiques qui ne sont pas fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B” (CGI, art. 244 bis A), which is your situation if your tax home is in the United States. And the rate for individuals is fixed: “les personnes physiques, les associés personnes physiques de sociétés, groupements ou organismes dont les bénéfices sont imposés au nom des associés et les porteurs de parts, personnes physiques, de fonds de placement immobilier mentionnés à l’article 239 nonies sont soumis au prélèvement au taux de 19 %” (CGI, art. 244 bis A). Nineteen percent on the discounted gain, collected through a withholding-style levy, the prélèvement, at the time of sale.
Your tax home, or domicile fiscal, is itself defined by statute. Article 4 B of the Tax Code treats as French tax residents persons “qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal” and those who carry on a professional activity in France otherwise than incidentally (CGI, art. 4 B). Living year-round in Texas or California with your family and work there places you outside that definition, which is exactly what pushes you into the 244 bis A levy instead of the progressive resident scale.
Two further layers sit on top of the 19 percent. First, social charges, the prélèvements sociaux, apply at a combined 17.2 percent on their own discounted base. The Social Security Code frames the charge broadly: “Les personnes physiques fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B du code général des impôts sont assujetties à une contribution sur les revenus du patrimoine”, expressly covering “Des plus-values, gains en capital et profits soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu” (CSS, art. L. 136-6), and nonresidents selling French property pay their equivalent share through the sale levy mechanism. The administration’s published examples apply the 17.2 percent rate to the discounted social-charges base computed on the same principles (BOI-RFPI-PVI-20-20). Second, large gains trigger a surtax on high real-estate gains. Article 1609 nonies G of the Tax Code states that “Il est institué une taxe sur les plus-values réalisées dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 U et 150 UB à 150 UD par les personnes physiques” and that “La taxe est due à raison des plus-values imposables d’un montant supérieur à 50 000 €” (CGI, art. 1609 nonies G). The surtax scale runs from 2 percent on gains just above 50,000 euros up to 6 percent beyond 260,000 euros, with smoothing formulas at each bracket threshold (CGI, art. 1609 nonies G). Take a concrete case: a 160,000-euro taxable gain after discounts produces 30,400 euros at 19 percent, roughly 27,500 euros of social charges at 17.2 percent on its own base, plus a 4 percent surtax band amount, before any treaty credit enters the picture on the American side.
One structural point protects sellers and buyers alike: under French civil law, “La vente est une convention par laquelle l’un s’oblige à livrer une chose, et l’autre à la payer. Elle peut être faite par acte authentique ou sous seing privé” (C. civ., art. 1582), and “Elle est parfaite entre les parties, et la propriété est acquise de droit à l’acheteur à l’égard du vendeur, dès qu’on est convenu de la chose et du prix, quoique la chose n’ait pas encore été livrée ni le prix payé” (C. civ., art. 1583). Your preliminary contract, the compromis de vente, already binds you once price and property are agreed, which is why the tax computation must be settled before you sign it, not discovered at the final deed.
B. Which French Exemptions Can an American Seller Still Claim?
The most valuable exemption is also the simplest: the sale of your main home is fully exempt. Article 150 U excludes from tax buildings “Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession” (CGI, art. 150 U). If the French house was genuinely your primary residence on the day of sale, no gain tax arises at all. The difficulty for Americans is proof of that status when you also keep a home in the United States: utility bills, tax filings, school enrollments, and physical presence all weigh in, and the exemption is judged on the facts of that single day. A vacation home used six weeks a year never qualifies, however long you owned it.
A second, narrower exemption helps people who left France recently. The nonresident levy does not apply to “la cession de l’immeuble qui constituait la résidence principale en France du cédant à la date du transfert de son domicile fiscal hors de France” when the new home is in an EU state or a cooperating state bound to France by assistance conventions (CGI, art. 244 bis A). The statute grants this only on a double condition: “la cession soit réalisée au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle du transfert par le cédant de son domicile fiscal hors de France et que l’immeuble n’ait pas été mis à la disposition de tiers, à titre gratuit ou onéreux, entre ce transfert et la cession” (CGI, art. 244 bis A). Sell within roughly a year after moving back to the United States, leave the house empty in the meantime, and the gain can escape French tax entirely. Rent it out for even a month in between, or sell two years later, and the door closes. Because the provision targets EU and convention partners, an American seller should have the notaire confirm in writing that the United States qualifies under the current assistance framework before relying on it.
A third exemption, the first-sale reinvestment rule, is the one that traps nonresidents most often, and a Paris appeals court just illustrated why. Article 150 U allows a seller who never owned a main home to reinvest the price into one within twenty-four months, but the benefit is reserved to French tax residents. In a July 2023 decision, the Versailles Court of Appeal described a file in which “La déclaration de plus-value établie par M. [X] à la demande de la SCI a mentionné un prix de cession de 460 000 euros, la différence de 400 000 euros correspondant au montant que les associés souhaitaient réinvestir dans l’acquisition d’une résidence principale en France afin de bénéficier de l’exonération fiscale prévue à l’article 150 U, II, 1 bis, du code général des impôts” (CA Versailles, 25 July 2023, RG 21/03288). The problem surfaced at the closing table: “Lors de la signature de la vente, le notaire des acquéreurs a toutefois relevé que cette exonération fiscale n’était pas applicable, faute pour les associés de la SCI d’avoir la qualité de résidents fiscaux en France” (CA Versailles, 25 July 2023, RG 21/03288). The taxable gain jumped from 54,027 to 102,496 euros, the sellers sued their notaire for the lost chance to walk away, and the court dismissed everything, recalling that “La perte de chance s’analyse comme la perte certaine d’une éventualité favorable” and finding the alleged chance purely hypothetical since the sellers were already bound by their offer (CA Versailles, 25 July 2023, RG 21/03288). The operative part is blunt: the court “INFIRME le jugement en toutes ses dispositions” and “REJETTE les demandes d’indemnisation et de capitalisation des intérêts de la SCI Nicolas Mathieu” (CA Versailles, 25 July 2023, RG 21/03288). The lesson for an American seller is direct: never assume a reinvestment plan exempts you, because nonresidents are outside that provision by definition.
A March 2024 Paris decision shows the mirror image, where the exemption existed but the paperwork killed it. A couple who sold land and house, then built their main home within two years, asked the tax office to refund 16,012 euros of gain tax. The administration refused because the deed “ne mentionnait pas trois des conditions prévues par l’article 150 VG du code général des impôts”, namely the identity of the beneficiary, the rights over the price, the reinvested fraction, and the exempted gain amount (CA Paris, 19 March 2024, RG 21/01462). The sellers sued the notaire who drafted the 2016 deed, and this time the court held that “la SCP Christine Adriani-Ricq et Maxime Sonneville a commis une faute de nature à engager sa responsabilité civile professionnelle”, awarding 8,806 euros in damages plus 4,000 euros in costs (CA Paris, 19 March 2024, RG 21/01462). Read together, the two rulings draw a clean line: in Versailles the exemption was legally unavailable to nonresidents and no lawsuit could create it, while in Paris the exemption was available but the missing deed recitals destroyed it. In both cases the tax treatment was decided by words written, or not written, in the sale deed. If you bought through a French property company, the mechanics differ again, as explained in our guide to buying a French house through an SCI and what the company changes for taxes, sale, and passing it to your kids.
II. Will the IRS Tax the Same Sale and How Do I Avoid Paying Twice?
Yes, the United States taxes the sale too. American citizens and residents report their worldwide income, and a French house is not invisible to the IRS because it stands abroad. That sounds like double taxation, and without a treaty it would be. With the treaty, the sequence is orderly: France taxes first as the country where the property sits, and the United States credits the French tax against the American tax on the same profit. The credit is not automatic, it is not always complete, and it depends on paperwork you assemble in France, which is why this second part starts with the treaty text and ends at the signing table.
A. How Does the US-France Treaty Turn French Tax Into an American Credit?
The treaty gives France the first word. Article 13 on capital gains gives the country where the property sits the right to tax gains from selling real estate located there (France-US Convention of 31 August 1994, Art. 13(1), published by Decree 96-222 of 15 March 1996). Gains from selling real estate located in one treaty country are taxable in that country. Your Dordogne house sits in France, so France taxes the gain under the 19 percent levy, social charges, and possible surtax described above, and the treaty blesses that priority rather than limiting it.
The United States then gives relief through a credit. Article 24 on eliminating double taxation provides that the United States grants its citizens and residents a credit against American income tax for French income tax paid by or for them (France-US Convention, Art. 24(2)(a)). The French income tax you paid on the sale becomes a dollar-for-dollar credit against the federal income tax computed on the same gain. The treaty even anticipates the French side of the mirror for dual situations: for income covered by Article 13(1) received from the United States, the French credit equals the US tax paid under the treaty, capped at the corresponding French tax on the same income (France-US Convention, Art. 24(1)(a)(iii)). Both directions cap the credit at the home country’s own tax on the same income, which is the standard architecture of foreign tax credits worldwide.
Before reaching the credit, compute the American gain under American rules, because it will differ from the French one. The IRS allows an exclusion of up to 250,000 dollars of gain on the sale of a main home, or up to 500,000 dollars for a joint return filed with a spouse (IRS Topic 701, Sale of Your Home). Qualification requires time: the ownership test is met by owning the home for at least 24 months out of the 5 years before the sale, and a parallel use test requires occupying it as a residence for at least 24 months of the previous 5 years (IRS Topic 701). A French vacation home fails the use test by definition, so the full American gain stays taxable and the French credit offsets it. A French house that was your main home for years before you moved back to the United States may partly or fully escape American tax through the exclusion, which shrinks the credit you need. Your American cost basis also converts currencies at historical rates: the euros you paid in 2010 and the euros you receive in 2026 translate into dollars at different exchange rates, so a modest euro gain can become a larger dollar gain, or the reverse. Track both conversions from the original purchase documents, because the IRS computes everything in dollars.
Three practical limits deserve attention. First, the credit cannot exceed the American tax attributable to the same gain, so if the French effective rate on your sale runs higher than your American rate, the excess French tax does not produce a refund from the IRS; it may carry to other years under standard carryover mechanics your CPA will map. Second, the credit covers income tax, which means you must separate, within your French bill, the income-tax component from social charges and surtaxes that follow different American classifications. Third, your state may not follow the federal lead: several states offer no foreign tax credit at all, so a California or New York return can still sting on the same profit. None of these points defeats the treaty design, but each one explains why sellers who assume the credit is total discover a residual bill.
B. What Happens at the Signing Table and Which Papers Protect My Credit?
In France the tax is not paid months later with an annual return; it is settled out of the price itself while everyone is still seated around the table. The notaire draws up the capital-gains computation, withholds the levy, social charges, and any surtax from the funds, and remits them to the Treasury with the deed formalities. Because the sale is already binding once price and property are agreed, the computation must be validated before the preliminary contract, not after. Ask the notaire for a written simulation with your exact purchase price, documented costs, works, holding period, and resulting discounts before you sign the compromis, and have any claimed exemption confirmed in the same note with its statutory conditions spelled out. The Paris case above is the cautionary tale: an exemption that existed on paper died because the deed lacked the required recitals, and only a lawsuit against the notaire recovered part of the loss.
Five documents protect both the French computation and the American credit, so treat them as one file. First, the original purchase deed and any inheritance or gift instrument that set your acquisition price, because everything flows from that number. Second, all invoices for construction, renovation, and acquisition costs, since documented amounts replace the flat percentages and usually exceed them. Third, the notaire’s detailed computation sheet and the official receipt for the levy paid, because the IRS credit requires proof of a foreign income tax actually paid, not merely assessed. Fourth, the final closing statement showing the price allocation, withheld taxes, and net proceeds wired to you, which reconciles the euro amounts with your bank records. Fifth, the French tax notices or certificates issued after registration, which close the loop if either administration asks questions later. Keep this file for as long as both countries can audit the transaction, and give your American CPA the French assessment with a certified translation of its key lines rather than a summary.
Mind the calendar as well. The French levy is paid in the year of sale, while your American credit is claimed on the return for the year the gain is recognized, and exchange-rate movements between the euro payment date and the dollar reporting date create small gaps the standard rules allocate mechanically. High-value sales can also involve an accredited tax representative, the représentant fiscal, a specialist who guarantees the nonresident’s payment to the Treasury; our colleagues track that procedure, its 150,000-euro threshold, and its penalties in their guide to selling French property as a nonresident. Finally, if the property sits in a company or was once placed in an American living trust, flag it months ahead: entities change who the seller is for French purposes, and France ignores the American revocable trust, as our analysis of parents who put a French house in a living trust explains. The treaty credit still works, but the computation path and the names on the forms must match the French characterization, not the American label.
Conclusion
Selling a French house as an American follows a fixed order. France computes the gain from sale price minus documented acquisition cost, discounts it for holding period on two clocks, twenty-two years for income tax and thirty for social charges, then levies 19 percent plus 17.2 percent social charges with a surtax above 50,000 euros of taxable gain. Exemptions exist but each carries strict conditions: the main-home shield on the day of sale, the roughly one-year window after leaving France with no tenants in between, and a reinvestment rule that nonresidents cannot use, as one appeals court confirmed while another punished a notaire for botching the deed recitals. The United States then taxes the same profit in dollars, softened by the main-home exclusion when the house truly was your home, and credits the French income tax against the federal bill under Article 24 of the treaty. Assemble the simulation before the preliminary contract, verify every exemption in writing, and keep the complete payment file for your American return. The double tax you feared becomes, with that discipline, a single coordinated bill.