Your father died in Ohio three years ago owning a stone house in the Dordogne he bought in the 1990s. France already taxed the inheritance itself: the notaire, the French public legal officer who alone settles estates containing French real estate, filed the déclaration de succession, applied the allowances heir by heir, and collected the droits de succession. If that first phase is still ahead of you, read first how an American parent’s death with a house in France is taxed and how the 1978 treaty credit works at that stage (My American Parent Died Owning a House in France), and what the settlement itself costs (what the notaire charges an American heir). This guide starts where those stop: you and your siblings now own the house, you live in Texas, and you want to sell it. Two tax systems will price that sale, in a strict order. France taxes the gain first, under its own capital-gains rules for non-residents, and the notaire withholds the French bill at the closing table. America taxes the same gain second, but gives you a new cost basis stepped up to the value at death and a credit for the French income tax you paid, under the 1994 income tax treaty. Between those two endpoints sit four traps that cost American sellers real money: a holding period that restarts at death instead of continuing the parent’s ownership, a main-home exemption that almost never fits an inherited house, social charges that do not behave like income tax on the American return, and a basis-consistency rule that ties your American figures to the French valuation. Here is the sequence in the order you will actually meet it, with the governing statutes, two court decisions on exactly these points, and the filing steps from the United States.
Vocabulary first, because every French term below is explained once and then used in its French form. Plus-value immobilière is the French capital gain on real estate. Prix d’acquisition is the acquisition price, the starting value France subtracts from the sale price. Valeur vénale réelle is the fair market value. Abattement pour durée de détention is the holding-period discount that shrinks the taxable gain year by year. Prélèvements sociaux are French social charges, a second levy added on top of the income tax on the gain. Représentant fiscal is the accredited French tax representative a non-resident seller must appoint in some cases. On the American side, basis is your tax cost in the property, and step-up is the rule that resets that cost to the value at death.
I. What France Takes When an American Sells an Inherited House
France does not need you to live in France, to be French, or to have signed anything in France to tax this sale. One question controls everything: is the building on French soil? If yes, France taxes the gain, and it collects through the notaire before the money ever reaches your American account. The surprises for American sellers all flow from three follow-ups: which value France treats as your starting price, how the holding clock turns that gain down over time, and which rate and procedure apply to a seller living in Texas. Take them in order, because each step feeds the next.
A. The Price France Starts From: The Death Value, Not Your Parent’s Purchase Price
Your first instinct will be wrong, and it is the most expensive mistake in this whole procedure. You will want to compute the gain from what your father paid in the 1990s. France refuses that starting point. For property received by inheritance, the official guidance of the French administration explains that where a property was received by gift or succession, the acquisition price is the value used to compute the gift or inheritance tax at death. In plain English, your acquisition price is the value used to compute the inheritance tax at death. The gain France taxes is the sale price minus that death value, nothing earlier.
That death value itself comes from a statute you already met during the succession. Article 761 of the General Tax Code (Code général des impôts, France’s tax code, usually shortened to CGI) provides that for inheritance tax purposes, buildings “Pour la liquidation des droits de mutations à titre gratuit, les immeubles, quelle que soit leur nature, sont estimés d’après leur valeur vénale réelle à la date de la transmission, d’après la déclaration détaillée et estimative des parties, sans distraction des charges, sauf, en ce qui concerne celles-ci, ce qui est dit aux articles 767 et suivants .” — they are valued at their real fair market value on the date of transfer, as declared in detail by the parties, without deducting liabilities, subject only to the debt rules of the articles that follow. So the valuation the notaire placed on the Dordogne house in the succession return — ideally supported by an appraisal or comparable sales, because the tax office can challenge an understated valeur vénale — becomes the floor of your later capital-gains computation. Keep that return and its valuation evidence: three years later, at the sale, you will need to prove the starting figure, and the buyer’s notaire will ask for it.
Two adjustments can raise that starting price in your favor. First, the purchase costs your succession bore that relate to the property (transfer duties paid at death are not added, but later capital improvements are) can increase the acquisition price if you hold the invoices — keep every work bill from the day you inherit. Second, if the succession return itself is still open to correction, fixing an undervaluation there changes both the inheritance tax and the later gain, so the two phases must be reasoned together, never in isolation. The perimeter rule behind all of this sits in article 750 ter of the same code: where the deceased was not fiscally domiciled in France, France still taxes “2° Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France, et notamment les fonds publics français, parts d’intérêts, biens ou droits composant un trust défini à l’ article 792-0 bis et produits qui y sont capitalisés, créances et valeurs mobilières françaises, lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article précité.” — movable and immovable property located in France, held directly or indirectly. Your father’s Ohio domicile never shielded the Dordogne house, at death or at resale.
Take a concrete case. The house is valued at 420,000 euros in the succession return. Three years later you sell it for 470,000 euros. The gross gain is 50,000 euros. No holding discount applies yet, as the next section explains, so the taxable gain is the full 50,000 euros. At the rates set out below, the French bill is 9,500 euros of income tax and 8,600 euros of social charges, 18,100 euros in total, withheld at closing. Every euro of that computation depends on the 420,000-euro starting figure — which is why the succession valuation is the first document your file needs.
B. The Clock That Shrinks the Bill: Holding Discounts, Rates, and the Non-Resident Procedure
France then reduces the gain according to how long the property was held — and here comes the second trap. The holding period does not continue your father’s ownership since the 1990s. The administration’s official doctrine explains that the acquisition date starts the holding clock, and its table sets that start, for transfers at death, at the date the succession opens. The clock restarts at death. Sell three years after inheriting and you hold a three-year property in French tax law, even if the family owned it for thirty. Plan a sale accordingly: time heals this tax, but only time counted from the death.
The discount schedule itself is public and mechanical. The official guidance sets a yearly discount running from the sixth through the twenty-first year of holding, at six percent per year for income tax and one point six five percent per year for social charges, with full income-tax exemption once a property has been held more than twenty-two years and full social-charges exemption after thirty years. Apply it to a longer hold: sell twelve years after the death and seven discount years have run (years six through twelve), cutting the income-tax base by 42 percent and the social-charges base by 11.55 percent. Sell within the first five years and there is no discount at all. Note the asymmetry that matters for Americans: the income-tax discount finishes at twenty-two years while the social-charges discount runs to thirty, so a house held twenty-five years can be exempt from French income tax yet still bear social charges.
After discounts, the rates are flat and the same for you as for a French resident. The administration taxes the discounted gain at a flat nineteen percent of income tax plus seventeen point two percent of social charges. The 19 percent rate sits in article 200 B of the Tax Code: “Les plus-values réalisées dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 U à 150 UC sont imposées au taux forfaitaire de 19 %.” Add a surtax of 2 to 6 percent when the taxable gain exceeds 50,000 euros, and a full exemption when the sale price itself does not exceed 15,000 euros. The scope of the whole regime is article 150 U, which makes gains on sales for consideration of built or unbuilt real estate subject to income tax under the conditions of articles 150 V to 150 VH, while its paragraph II opens with the exemption: “1° Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession ;”
Because you live in Texas, the levy runs through a special non-resident channel, and a 2022 decision of the Conseil d’État, France’s supreme administrative court, confirms exactly where its floor sits. Article 244 bis A provides that “2. Sont soumis au prélèvement mentionné au 1 : a) Les personnes physiques qui ne sont pas fiscalement domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B ;” — individuals not fiscally domiciled in France fall under the withholding levy. In CE, 23 June 2022, No. 445785, a Swiss national living in Monaco challenged the levy on a Nice property, arguing European free movement of capital barred even the 19 percent. The court rejected the claim, holding that European Union law “faisait seulement obstacle à un prélèvement excédant le taux de 19 % applicable, en vertu des dispositions de l’article 200 B du code général des impôts, aux plus-values de même nature réalisées par les résidents” — EU law only bars a levy exceeding the 19 percent rate that residents pay. For an American seller the lesson is blunt: the 19 percent is a floor, not a ceiling to litigate away, and the historic higher non-resident rate survives only to the extent it matches what residents pay.
Your domicile classification still matters, because it sets the perimeter. Article 4 B treats as fiscally domiciled in France persons described as “Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal ;” — holders of their household or principal place of residence in France — as well as persons who carry on a professional activity in France that is more than accessory, or who center their economic interests there. A Texan heir who never moved fails all three tests and stays non-resident: France taxes the house but nothing else. An heir who relocated to France and centered family life there becomes French-domiciled, and then worldwide assets enter the picture at death — which is why the family should fix domicile before the succession return, not at the sale.
The main-home exemption will tempt you; it almost never fits. The statute exempts only property that is the seller’s main home on the day of sale, and the courts test real occupation with bills and tax notices. In CAA Paris, 21 February 2018, No. 17PA00527, sellers who had occupied a Paris flat for only eight and a half months kept the exemption — but only because electricity consumption, taxe d’habitation bills, and insurance proved “leur résidence effective à l’adresse en cause,” and the court stressed that the exemption covers sales of property that is the sellers main home on the day of sale. An heir who never lived in the Dordogne house cannot pass that test by moving in for the sale alone without genuine, documented occupation, and a house let to tenants or left vacant fails it outright. Do not claim this exemption on an inherited second home you never occupied: the administration challenges it by proposition de rectification, and the file you would need — utility bills, tax notices, real daily life — is a file you do not have.
Procedure at closing is mercifully simple because the notaire does it. The official guidance lists the steps: the selling notaire handles the tax formalities, computes the taxable gain and the tax, draws up return form 2048-IMM, and pays the tax to the land-registration office where the property sits. The money is withheld from the price, so budget net proceeds after the 19 percent, the 17.2 percent, and any surtax. One extra formality hits non-residents: A non-resident whose gain is taxable must appoint an accredited tax representative who guarantees the tax. You are excused from appointing one where the sale price does not exceed 150,000 euros or the gain is fully exempt by holding time — two more reasons the valuation and the clock matter before you sign anything.
II. What America Takes and How the Treaty Prevents Double Tax
America taxes you on worldwide income, so the Dordogne gain lands on your American return too. But the American computation starts from a different, friendlier number than the French one, and the 1994 income tax treaty between France and the United States then credits the French income tax against the American bill. The order is fixed: France first at closing, America second at filing season, credit claimed on the American return with French proof attached. Get the American basis right and isolate the creditable French tax, and the same euros are not taxed twice at full rates.
A. The American Gain: A Stepped-Up Basis That Erases the Parent’s Years
American law gives heirs the mirror image of the French restart rule, and it usually helps. The Internal Revenue Service explains in Publication 551 that the basis of inherited property is generally its fair market value at the date of the individual’s death, with alternate-valuation-date and special-use farm values applying where the estate chose them. Your basis is the fair market value at death — the same 420,000 euros in our example — not what your father paid in the 1990s. If the executor chose alternate valuation for estate-tax purposes, the alternate-date value controls instead, and special-use farm valuation chosen on the estate return also carries over. The American gain is therefore the dollar sale price minus the dollar value at death, converted at the proper rates with proof kept for each figure.
Two refinements decide real dollars. First, if no estate-tax value was ever reported to you on a Schedule A, the IRS accepts a practical fallback measured from the appraised value at the date of death used for inheritance or transmission tax purposes — which points straight back to the French succession valuation and appraisal you preserved in Part I. The French valeur vénale and the American basis are two legal languages describing one economic number, and consistency between them is now an explicit duty: “Section 1014(f), implemented by final regulations published as T.D. 9991, requires the heir’s basis to stay consistent with the value finally determined for estate tax purposes. Do not report 420,000 euros to the French notaire and a different, lower dollar figure to the IRS without a documented reason such as exchange-rate method or a valuation the estate return actually used.
What you cannot use is the main-home exclusion. American law excludes gain on a principal residence only where you owned and lived in it, and an heir who never occupied the Dordogne house meets neither test. Equally, American gift rules do not help: had your father given you the house during his life instead of leaving it at death, your basis would generally have carried over from his, preserving thirty years of appreciation in the taxable gain. Death, paradoxically, is the better basis event — one more reason the succession and the sale must be planned as a single sequence. Improvements you paid for after inheriting add to basis on both sides if invoiced and traceable, so the same work bills serve twice.
B. The Treaty Credit: France May Tax First, America Credits Second
The treaty divides the gain the way the two computations assume. Article 13, paragraph 1 of the 1994 Convention lets the state where real estate sits tax gains on its disposal. France, where the house sits, may therefore tax the gain under its own rules — exactly what the notaire did at closing. The article even anticipates indirect holdings, covering shares and similar rights in companies whose assets are at least half French real estate, so holding the house through a property company does not escape the French bite. America, where you are resident, may also tax the gain under its worldwide system. Double taxation is then relieved on the American side.
The relief sits in Article 24, paragraph 1(a)(i), under which the United States allows its citizens and residents a credit against American income tax for French income tax paid, within the limits of American law. Read each element as a condition. The credit goes against American income tax: the 19 percent French income-tax portion is its natural object. It is limited by American law: the credit cannot exceed the American tax attributable to the same gain, so a French bill heavier than the American tax on that gain leaves uncredited excess, and timing differences between the French closing year and the American filing year must be tracked. And it covers French income tax paid: the 17.2 percent prélèvements sociaux are social charges assessed under a different logic — the French guidance itself presents them as a separate levy added to the income tax — so your American preparer must split the French bill and credit only the income-tax portion through the proper channel, rather than assuming the whole 36.2 percent crosses the Atlantic. Claim the credit on the foreign-tax-credit form of the American return with the notaire’s 2048-IMM computation, the payment proof from the land-registration office, and the exchange rates used.
Remember what this treaty is not. The 1994 Convention governs income and gains; the 1978 Convention between France and the United States governs successions and gifts and controlled the inheritance phase you already closed, with its own credit for French succession duties against American estate tax. Each treaty covers its own tax, each return claims its own credit, and neither credit crosses into the other’s field. The full treaty texts are public: the English text through the IRS treaty file and the French conventions through the tax administration’s conventions page, so every quote above can be checked against the source before you file.
Sequence the filings in practice. At the French closing, the notaire computes, files, and pays; collect the 2048-IMM computation, the proof of payment, the deed showing the price, and the succession valuation showing the starting value. At American filing season, report the sale as a capital transaction with the stepped-up dollar basis, compute the American tax, claim the Article 24 credit for the French income tax within the American limitation, and keep the French documents with the return’s workpapers for the years the limitation or an audit can reach. If the estate was large enough to have owed American estate tax, coordinate the estate return’s valuation with the heir’s basis from the start, because the consistency rule now polices the gap. Done in this order, the two countries each take their lawful share once, and the Dordogne house becomes dollars without a second full tax.
Conclusion
Selling an inherited French house from America is a two-tax, two-treaty operation with a fixed order: France prices the gain from the death value, discounts it only for years counted since the succession opened, taxes it at 19 percent plus 17.2 percent through the notaire at closing, and America then taxes the same gain from a stepped-up basis while crediting the French income tax under Article 24 of the 1994 Convention. The file that wins is assembled at the succession, not at the sale: the valuation that sets both the French starting price and the American basis, the invoices that raise it, the calendar that discounts it, and the French payment proofs that fund the American credit. Hold those four pieces together and the house your father kept becomes the inheritance he intended, taxed once on each side and never twice.