On 13 October 2026, The Guardian reported under the headline Britons travelling to Europe told not to apply for delayed Etias visa waiver that British holidaymakers should ignore a flood of websites selling the forthcoming European travel authorisation. The warning comes from ABTA, the British travel association, whose director of public affairs warns that ETIAS, which had been due to start this year, is back on hold and should only be introduced once the EES is fully operational and working properly.
The facts behind the warning matter far beyond Britain. The report explains that non-EU citizens, including British travellers as well as visa-exempt visitors from the United States, Australia and Canada, will in future need a EUR 20 electronic waiver, about GBP 17, to enter the Schengen zone under the European travel information and authorisation system (ETIAS). Yet that system is still suspended, European authorities believe that more than 150 websites already offer ETIAS services, even though only the single official site will ever be the legitimate application channel once the system goes live, and ABTA’s blunt advice to travellers is blunt: in his words, nobody can or should apply for an ETIAS now.
This article explains, from the standpoint of a French lawyer practising before the Paris courts, what actually happens today when a visa-exempt traveller – British, American, Canadian or Australian – is stopped at the French border, why the forthcoming ETIAS will change only part of that picture, and which remedies exist in French law to challenge a refusal of entry, leave the airport waiting zone, and recover money paid to copycat websites. It is written for international readers who land at Paris-Charles de Gaulle, Nice or Lyon, take the Eurostar at London St Pancras, or board a ferry at Dover, where French border checks take place before embarkation. French statutory texts are quoted in the original language with an English explanation, so that readers and their advisers can rely on the exact wording.
I. Why British, American, Canadian and Australian travellers are still turned away at the French border while ETIAS is suspended
A. What the French border police check before refusing you entry: documents, means of subsistence, alerts and the future ETIAS
France applies the common Schengen entry rules through its own statute, the Code de l’entree et du sejour des etrangers et du droit d’asile (CESEDA). The starting point is Article L311-1 of the CESEDA, which provides: “Pour entrer en France, tout étranger doit être muni : 1° Sauf s’il est exempté de cette obligation, des visas exigés par les conventions internationales et par l’article 6, paragraphe 1, points a et b, du règlement (UE) 2016/399 du Parlement européen et du Conseil du 9 mars 2016 concernant un code de l’Union relatif au régime de franchissement des frontières par les personnes (code frontières Schengen) ; 2° Sous réserve des conventions internationales, et de l’article 6, paragraphe 1, point c, du code frontières Schengen, du justificatif d’hébergement prévu à l’article L. 313-1 , s’il est requis, et des autres documents prévus par décret en Conseil d’Etat relatifs à l’objet et aux conditions de son séjour et à ses moyens d’existence, à la prise en charge par un opérateur d’assurance agréé des dépenses médicales et hospitalières, y compris d’aide sociale, résultant de soins qu’il pourrait engager en France, ainsi qu’aux garanties de son rapatriement ; 3° Des documents nécessaires à l’exercice d’une activité professionnelle s’il se propose d’en exercer une.” In plain English, a visa-exempt visitor must still be able to show a valid passport, the purpose of the stay, accommodation, sufficient funds, medical insurance covering hospital costs, and a credible prospect of going home. Since the United Kingdom left the European Union, ABTA reminds British travellers that border guards may ask questions linked to the Schengen Borders Code, for example about where they are staying, and that the new electronic systems make these questions more systematic rather than occasional.
Where one of those conditions is missing, the statute lists three situations in which entry must be refused. Article L311-2 of the CESEDA states: “Un étranger ne satisfait pas aux conditions d’entrée sur le territoire français lorsqu’il se trouve dans les situations suivantes : 1° Sa présence en France constituerait une menace pour l’ordre public ; 2° Il fait l’objet d’un signalement aux fins de non-admission sur le territoire français introduit dans le système d’information Schengen, conformément au règlement (UE) n° 2018/1861 du Parlement européen et du Conseil du 28 novembre 2018 sur l’établissement, le fonctionnement et l’utilisation du système d’information Schengen (SIS) dans le domaine des vérifications aux frontières, modifiant la convention d’application de l’accord de Schengen et modifiant et abrogeant le règlement (CE) n° 1987/2006 ; 3° Il fait l’objet d’une peine d’interdiction judiciaire du territoire, d’une décision d’expulsion, d’une interdiction de retour sur le territoire français, d’une interdiction de circulation sur le territoire français ou d’une interdiction administrative du territoire.” Each of these three branches produces its own kind of dispute. A finding of threat to public order often rests on criminal history or on intelligence notes the traveller has never seen. A Schengen Information System alert can result from a mistaken identity, a name close to a wanted person’s, or an alert entered by another Member State that France is bound to honour at the border. An entry ban pronounced after an earlier overstay or an earlier removal order follows the traveller for years and resurfaces at the worst possible moment, in the arrivals hall.
When the border police consider that one of those situations applies, they issue a refusal. Article L332-1 of the CESEDA provides: “L’étranger qui ne satisfait pas aux conditions d’admission prévues au titre I peut faire l’objet d’une décision de refus d’entrée, sans préjudice des dispositions particulières relatives au droit d’asile et à la protection internationale ou à la délivrance de visas de long séjour.” The final words matter: a person who expresses a fear of persecution cannot simply be put on the next plane. The asylum channel suspends removal while the claim is examined, and the French Office for the Protection of Refugees and Stateless Persons intervenes within the procedure. Refusal decisions at Schengen borders follow the standard form set by Regulation (EU) 2016/399, the Schengen Borders Code, and the person concerned receives a written, reasoned decision indicating the available remedies. That document is the single most important paper of the whole case: every later challenge, administrative or judicial, starts from its exact wording, its date and time, and the box the officer ticked.
Two European regulations frame the present confusion. Regulation (EU) 2017/2226 created the Entry/Exit System (EES), which replaces passport stamping with biometric registration – facial image and fingerprints – and computes the 90-days-in-any-180-days rule automatically. ABTA confirms that the EES officially became fully operational on 10 April 2026, while noting that practice still varies between crossing points. Regulation (EU) 2018/1240 created ETIAS, the EUR 20 travel authorisation valid for three years for visa-exempt nationals, with refusal, annulment and revocation decisions subject to appeal in the Member State that adopts them; the the EU’s official ETIAS rights pages confirm a right to appeal before the courts of the Member State concerned, as provided by Regulation (EU) 2018/1240. But the official EU ETIAS website is explicit about the present position: ETIAS is currently not in operation and no travel-authorisation applications are being collected. ABTA echoes the point: the EU still plans to introduce ETIAS but has confirmed no launch date, and nobody can currently apply. Any website that accepts money today for an ETIAS authorisation is therefore selling something that does not exist yet, and any traveller refused entry this autumn is refused under the current documentary and SIS-based rules, not for want of an ETIAS.
B. Fingerprints, queues and the waiting zone: what a refusal looks like once the border system flags you
For travellers, the refusal unfolds in a predictable sequence. The officer takes the passport to the booth, the EES terminal records biometrics, questions are asked about the address of the stay, the return ticket and the funds available, and the file is checked against the Schengen Information System and national databases. When the answer is negative, the traveller is notified of the refusal in writing and is generally not free to walk into France: the airline that carried the passenger is expected to take them back, and the traveller waits under supervision for the return flight. Where return is not immediate – no seat, night-time arrival, onward-connection dispute, or an asylum request made at the border – French law provides a dedicated holding regime rather than an informal wait on a bench.
Article L341-1 of the CESEDA provides: “L’étranger qui arrive en France par la voie ferroviaire, maritime ou aérienne et qui n’est pas autorisé à entrer sur le territoire français peut être placé dans une zone d’attente située dans une gare ferroviaire ouverte au trafic international figurant sur une liste définie par voie réglementaire, dans un port ou à proximité du lieu de débarquement ou dans un aéroport, pendant le temps strictement nécessaire à son départ. Peut également être placé en zone d’attente l’étranger qui se trouve en transit dans une gare, un port ou un aéroport si l’entreprise de transport qui devait l’acheminer dans le pays de destination ultérieure refuse de l’embarquer ou si les autorités du pays de destination lui ont refusé l’entrée et l’ont renvoyé en France. Il en est de même lorsqu’il est manifeste qu’un étranger appartient à un groupe d’au moins dix étrangers venant d’arriver en France en dehors d’un point de passage frontalier, en un même lieu ou sur un ensemble de lieux distants d’au plus dix kilomètres.” The provision therefore covers the classic air-arrival case at Roissy or Nice, the rail and sea cases, and the transit passenger whom the next carrier or the next State sends back to France.
The placement itself is strictly framed. Article L341-2 of the CESEDA states: “Le placement en zone d’attente est prononcé pour une durée qui ne peut excéder quatre-vingt-seize heures par une décision écrite et motivée d’un agent relevant d’une catégorie fixée par voie réglementaire. Cette décision est inscrite sur un registre mentionnant l’état civil de l’intéressé et la date et l’heure auxquelles la décision de placement lui a été notifiée. Elle est portée sans délai à la connaissance du procureur de la République.” Four days is therefore the administrative maximum, the decision must be written and reasoned, the civil status and the exact time of notification go on a register, and the public prosecutor is informed without delay. These formalities are not bureaucratic decoration: each missing element – an unwritten decision, a wrong time, a prosecutor never informed – is a ground the judge examines when the administration asks for more time.
Life inside the zone is governed by a short list of immediately enforceable rights. Article L343-1 of the CESEDA provides: “L’étranger placé en zone d’attente est informé, dans les meilleurs délais, qu’il peut demander l’assistance d’un interprète et d’un médecin, communiquer avec un conseil ou toute personne de son choix et quitter à tout moment la zone d’attente pour toute destination située hors de France. Il est également informé des droits qu’il est susceptible d’exercer en matière de demande d’asile. Ces informations lui sont communiquées dans une langue qu’il comprend. Mention en est faite sur le registre mentionné au second alinéa de l’article L. 341-2 , qui est émargé par l’intéressé. En cas de placement simultané en zone d’attente d’un nombre important d’étrangers, la notification des droits mentionnés au premier alinéa s’effectue dans les meilleurs délais, compte tenu du nombre d’agents de l’autorité administrative et d’interprètes disponibles. De même, dans ces mêmes circonstances particulières, les droits notifiés s’exercent dans les meilleurs délais.” An interpreter, a doctor, a lawyer or any person of the traveller’s choice, the right to leave at any moment for any destination outside France, and information about asylum – all communicated in a language the person understands, with the register signed. In practice, the first phone call should go to a lawyer admitted in France, because the lawyer can reach the zone, obtain the refusal decision, verify the register, and prepare the two parallel actions described below.
Beyond ninety-six hours, only a judge can authorise continued holding. Article L342-1 of the CESEDA provides: “Le maintien en zone d’attente au-delà de quatre-vingt-seize heures à compter de la décision de placement initiale peut être autorisé, par le magistrat du siège du tribunal judiciaire statuant sur l’exercice effectif des droits reconnus à l’étranger, pour une durée qui ne peut être supérieure à huit jours.” The judicial magistrate does not retry the border police’s assessment of visas or alerts; they verify that the rights listed above were effectively respected and that the administration moves the file forward. A recent illustration is the order of the Bobigny judicial court of 26 January 2025, RG 25/00634, concerning a Beninese traveller refused entry on 22 January 2025, who applied for asylum the same evening and was refused entry on asylum grounds the next day. The court recalled that, under Article L332-1, a foreigner who does not satisfy the admission conditions may be refused entry, noted that the placement had been pronounced for four days by written decision, observed that removal was suspended while proceedings were pending and that the person offered no guarantee of return, and authorised eight more days in the airport waiting zone. The case shows the three questions the judge asks every time: was the initial placement formally correct, were the rights effective, and is there any realistic prospect of imminent departure.
Two practical features of autumn 2026 deserve emphasis. First, queues and biometric teething problems do not suspend the law. The Guardian reports that the EES is in full operation, but border authorities have been told that the EU will not penalise them for continuing to suspend the system at entry points when queues grow, and that industry surveys found that only 46% of visitors to Europe underwent full checks, half of whom waited less than 30 minutes, with only 13% queuing for an hour. A lighter check at one crossing does not prevent a full check at the next, and the data recorded – entries, exits, refusals – follows the traveller across the Schengen area. Second, many British travellers meet the French border without leaving Britain. ABTA explains that at Dover and on international trains from London St Pancras and Folkestone both the British and French borders sit side by side at these locations, so EES enrolment and any refusal take place on UK soil. Being refused at St Pancras before boarding is legally a French refusal of entry, with the same written decision and the same remedies as a refusal at Roissy.
II. How to challenge a French refusal of entry and recover money lost to copycat ETIAS websites
A. Which judge to seize within hours: leaving the waiting zone and suspending the refusal
The most counter-intuitive feature of French law for common-law readers is that two different judges share the case, and neither does the other’s job. The judicial judge (the magistrate of the tribunal judiciaire, then the First President of the Court of Appeal) controls the deprivation of liberty in the waiting zone. The administrative judge (the administrative tribunal, then the administrative court of appeal and the Conseil d’Etat) controls the legality of the refusal of entry itself. Confusing the two wastes the few hours available.
The division of labour was restated in an order of the Paris Court of Appeal of 5 December 2025, RG 25/06748, concerning a Colombian traveller whose continued holding the Bobigny judge had refused while ordering the administration to return all personal belongings including passport and travel documents. On the Interior Ministry’s appeal, the appellate court recalled: “En application d’une jurisprudence constante, le juge judiciaire, saisi d’une demande de prolongation du maintien en zone d’attente d’une personne à laquelle l’entrée sur le territoire national a été refusé n’est pas compétent pour apprécier la légalité des décisions administratives de refus d’admission sur le territoire et de placement en zone d’attente – en particulier les motifs retenus par l’administration à cette fin (2e Civ., 7 juin 2001, pourvoi n° 99-50.053).” A reference to the Court of Cassation’s Second Civil Chamber anchors the point: even when the refusal looks plainly wrong, the liberty judge cannot annul it. The same order recalls the statutory test for extension under Articles L342-1 and L342-10: Article L342-10 of the CESEDA provides that “L’existence de garanties de représentation de l’étranger n’est pas à elle seule susceptible de justifier le refus de prolongation de son maintien en zone d’attente.” A return ticket and a hotel booking help, but alone they do not compel release; the argument must be built on defective notification, unexercised rights, or the absence of diligent removal efforts.
Attacking the refusal itself belongs to the administrative court, and speed is everything. Two emergency applications exist side by side. Article L521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice provides: “Quand une décision administrative, même de rejet, fait l’objet d’une requête en annulation ou en réformation, le juge des référés, saisi d’une demande en ce sens, peut ordonner la suspension de l’exécution de cette décision, ou de certains de ses effets, lorsque l’urgence le justifie et qu’il est fait état d’un moyen propre à créer, en l’état de l’instruction, un doute sérieux quant à la légalité de la décision. Lorsque la suspension est prononcée, il est statué sur la requête en annulation ou en réformation de la décision dans les meilleurs délais.” – urgency plus a serious doubt about legality. Article L521-2 of the same Code governs the liberté summary procedure: “Saisi d’une demande en ce sens justifiée par l’urgence, le juge des référés peut ordonner toutes mesures nécessaires à la sauvegarde d’une liberté fondamentale à laquelle une personne morale de droit public ou un organisme de droit privé chargé de la gestion d’un service public aurait porté, dans l’exercice d’un de ses pouvoirs, une atteinte grave et manifestement illégale. Le juge des référés se prononce dans un délai de quarante-huit heures.” Forty-eight hours for a ruling, a grave and manifestly unlawful interference with a fundamental freedom as the test, and any necessary safeguard measure as the outcome. In waiting-zone practice, counsel files the annulment action and the emergency suspension together, serves the exact refusal form, adds the travel file – return ticket, accommodation proof, bank statements, insurance, professional ties at home – and, where an SIS alert is involved, any evidence of mistaken identity or of an alert that should have been deleted. When the alert comes from another Member State, the French judge cannot delete it directly, but an unlawful enforcement of it in France can still be suspended, and the underlying State must be asked to re-examine the entry.
Meanwhile, the liberty track runs on its own clock. The standard notification, as given in the Bobigny order of 26 January 2025 (RG 25/00634), states that the extension order “est susceptible d’appel devant le premier président de la cour d’appel de Paris dans un délai de 24 heures à compter de la présente ordonnance”, and that appeal does not suspend enforcement. Twenty-four hours, a reasoned statement transmitted by any means to the foreigners’ service registry, no suspensive effect: counsel must therefore prepare the appeal at the hearing itself, not after reading the order at the office. If the judge refuses the extension, the traveller must be released from the zone; release is not admission, and the person remains under a refusal decision, but it restores the ability to organise the defence, contact family, and arrange an orderly departure or a properly filed asylum claim rather than a night-time escort to a plane. Readers familiar with entry-ban litigation will find a comparable French logic in how France handles entry bans imposed on foreign nationals and the remedies available before its own courts, where the same distinction between the measure and the deprivation of liberty structures the whole defence.
B. After the return flight: annulment, damages and claims against the unofficial ETIAS websites
Once the traveller is back in London, New York, Toronto or Sydney, the file is not closed. The refusal of entry can still be challenged on the merits before the administrative tribunal, which may annul it for defective reasoning, factual error, or misapplication of the SIS rules. An annulment matters even when the holiday is lost: it clears the computer trail that would otherwise trigger a fresh refusal at the next trip, it supports a later visa application by neutralising the earlier motive, and it opens the question of compensation for a detention and a removal without lawful basis. State liability for a faulty refusal follows the ordinary public-law route before the same administrative court, with the refusal file, the waiting-zone register, the proof of rights notification in a language understood, and the airline and hotel invoices as the natural exhibits. The deadlines for these actions are short and run from notification of the decision, which is why the copy of the refusal form obtained at the airport, photographed page by page before boarding the return flight, often decides the outcome months later.
The second dispute concerns the websites that sold the phantom ETIAS. The Guardian’s account of the Frontex findings can be summarised as follows: third-party sites expose travellers to risks ranging from data-protection breaches and identity theft to extortionate fees, and some unofficial sites give inaccurate guidance on who needs an ETIAS while copying the look of the official website and using deceptively similar domain names. ABTA’s spokesman adds the consumer warning that anyone using these sites stands to lose money and to put personal data at risk. Three French-law tools respond. First, criminal law: Article 313-1 of the Criminal Code defines the offence – “L’escroquerie est le fait, soit par l’usage d’un faux nom ou d’une fausse qualité, soit par l’abus d’une qualité vraie, soit par l’emploi de manoeuvres frauduleuses, de tromper une personne physique ou morale et de la déterminer ainsi, à son préjudice ou au préjudice d’un tiers, à remettre des fonds, des valeurs ou un bien quelconque, à fournir un service ou à consentir un acte opérant obligation ou décharge.” – and sets the penalty: “L’escroquerie est punie de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 375 000 euros d’amende.” A site that presents itself as the official channel, copies the European Union’s visual identity, and takes EUR 20 or more for an authorisation it cannot deliver fits the statutory description of deceit by fraudulent manoeuvre, and a criminal complaint allows the victim to join the proceedings as a civil party. Second, civil liability: Article 1240 of the Civil Code provides that “Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer.” The undelivered service, the inflated fee, and the exposure of passport data are each recoverable heads of loss once fault, damage and causation are shown. Third, the payment channel: card payments for undelivered services can be contested through the card issuer’s chargeback procedure, in parallel with reports to the consumer-protection authorities and to the data-protection authority where passport copies or biometric data were uploaded.
Travellers should keep a simple discipline from the moment a trip to France is booked. First, never apply for an ETIAS anywhere today: the only trustworthy source is the official EU ETIAS website, which states that no applications are collected, and ABTA confirms that only one official site will ever be legitimate. Second, travel with a border-ready file: passport valid well beyond the return date, return or onward ticket, accommodation address for every night, recent bank statements, travel medical insurance, and, for business trips, the invitation letter and professional documents required by Article L311-1. Third, if stopped, stay calm, state an asylum fear immediately and explicitly if one exists, ask for the written refusal and for a lawyer at once, note the exact time, photograph every page of every document, and keep boarding passes and receipts. Fourth, from the waiting zone, have counsel verify the register, the interpreter, and the prosecutor’s notification, and file the administrative emergency application alongside the liberty-track defence rather than waiting for the return flight. Fifth, once home, preserve everything – screenshots of any ETIAS website used, payment confirmations, the refusal form, the airline rebooking – and have the refusal reviewed on the merits, because an unchallenged refusal keeps producing effects at every future Schengen crossing, including once ETIAS application screening begins.
One forward-looking point closes this section. When ETIAS finally launches, its refusals, annulments and revocations will carry their own appeal deadlines running from notification, before the courts of the Member State that decided. A traveller refused an authorisation on the basis of an SIS alert, a lost passport recorded as stolen, or a risk assessment they cannot see will face the same structural difficulty as today’s refused entrant: a short clock, a file partly composed of data they have never seen, and a need to act in a foreign language before a foreign court. Building the reflexes now – written decisions, registered deadlines, counsel on the first day – is the best preparation for the ETIAS era.
Conclusion
ETIAS is delayed, the copycat market is thriving, and the French border continues to operate under the current documentary and alert-based rules. A refusal of entry at Paris, Nice, Dover or St Pancras is a written administrative decision governed by Articles L311-1, L311-2 and L332-1 of the CESEDA; holding beyond the first hours passes through the waiting-zone regime of Articles L341-1, L341-2, L342-1 and L343-1 under the control of the judicial judge; and the refusal itself is fought before the administrative judge through emergency suspension and liberté applications under Articles L521-1 and L521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice. Money paid to unofficial ETIAS websites is recoverable through the fraud and civil-liability provisions of Articles 313-1 of the Criminal Code and 1240 of the Civil Code, alongside payment disputes and regulatory reports. The Guardian’s story of 13 October 2026 will fade within days, but the method it illustrates – check the official source, keep the written decision, count the hours, seize the right judge first – will still decide, long after ETIAS finally opens, whether a refused traveller spends the night in an airport hotel or in a waiting zone, and whether the next trip to France begins at the arrivals gate or at the court registry.