Your mother owned a stone house outside Sarlat. She passed away last spring, and the French notaire has just written to you and your two siblings in Ohio and Texas: the three of you now own the house together. None of you lives in France. One of you wants to sell immediately, one wants to keep the house for summers, and the third wants their share bought out but cannot agree on a price. Meanwhile the taxe foncière bill has arrived, the roof needs work, and the notaire is asking for instructions.
This situation has a name in French law: indivision, the default co-ownership that arises between heirs the moment the estate opens. It is the subject of an official explanatory page on service-public.fr, Succession: indivision entre les héritiers, and it behaves very differently from the joint ownership Americans know at home. No sibling can be forced to stay in it, but while it lasts, almost every important decision requires everyone to agree, and getting out through a buyout or a court-ordered sale follows strict procedural steps with tax consequences in both France and the United States.
This guide explains, for an American reader with no French legal background, how the indivision works day to day, how each sibling can use the house or leave the arrangement, and how a buyout, an amicable partition, or a forced auction is taxed on each side of the Atlantic. French terms are translated at first use. Every decisive French rule below is quoted from the statute or decision that states it, with a link to the official text.
I. What French Indivision Means When American Siblings Inherit Together
When a person dies owning property in France, the heirs become co-owners of each estate asset automatically. There is no deed to sign and no American-style probate proceeding that transfers title first: the indivision begins by operation of law at death, and each heir owns an undivided share — say one-third each — of the whole house rather than any specific room or floor. The French notaire (notaire, a public officer who settles successions) then establishes who the heirs are, what the estate contains, and what each share represents. Two companion guides on this site walk through the surrounding process: what the notaire charges an American heir and how to check the bill, and how forced heirship and the European choice of American law shape who inherits. This article focuses on what happens next, once the siblings own the house together.
A. How the Indivision Starts and Who Gets to Decide Anything
The starting point is freedom, stated in the first article of the chapter. Article 815 of the Civil Code provides: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” (Article 815, Code civil, Légifrance). In plain English: nobody can be forced to remain a co-owner, and any co-owner can demand partition at any time, unless a court or an agreement has temporarily frozen that right. That single sentence is the leverage behind every negotiation between siblings: the brother who wants out can always, in the last resort, force the exit.
But while the indivision lasts, decision-making is deliberately rigid. French law sorts every decision into three buckets, and each bucket has its own majority rule. First, purely protective steps are open to everyone acting alone. Article 815-2 of the Civil Code states: “Tout indivisaire peut prendre les mesures nécessaires à la conservation des biens indivis même si elles ne présentent pas un caractère d’urgence.” (Article 815-2, Code civil, Légifrance). Any sibling can therefore hire a roofer to stop a leak, change the locks after a break-in, or pay the home-insurance premium, and can require the others to contribute to necessary spending. Where genuine urgency exists, the presiding judge of the judicial court can go further: “Le président du tribunal judiciaire peut prescrire ou autoriser toutes les mesures urgentes que requiert l’intérêt commun.” (Article 815-6, Code civil, Légifrance).
Second, day-to-day management belongs to a qualified majority. Article 815-3 of the Civil Code provides: “Le ou les indivisaires titulaires d’au moins deux tiers des droits indivis peuvent, à cette majorité : 1° Effectuer les actes d’administration relatifs aux biens indivis” (Article 815-3, Code civil, Légifrance), a list that continues with general management mandates, the sale of jointly owned movable property to pay the indivision’s debts, and the signing or renewal of ordinary leases, with a duty to inform the other co-owners. With three equal siblings, any two of you together reach two-thirds and can therefore re-let the house for the summer season, appoint a local property manager, or sell the old furniture to pay the property tax. The same article draws a hard line on the other side: “Toutefois, le consentement de tous les indivisaires est requis pour effectuer tout acte qui ne ressortit pas à l’exploitation normale des biens indivis et pour effectuer tout acte de disposition autre que ceux visés au 3°.” Selling the house itself, mortgaging it, or giving a long commercial lease over it requires unanimity: one sibling’s refusal blocks the sale, which is exactly why exits must go through the buyout and partition mechanisms described in Part II.
Two practical consequences follow for Americans. First, a sibling who silently handles everything for years is not necessarily seizing control: the statute adds that “Si un indivisaire prend en main la gestion des biens indivis, au su des autres et néanmoins sans opposition de leur part, il est censé avoir reçu un mandat tacite, couvrant les actes d’administration mais non les actes de disposition ni la conclusion ou le renouvellement des baux.” Day-to-day management may be tacitly accepted, but a sale never is. Second, distance does not dilute anyone’s veto. The sister in Texas who never answers emails still holds one-third of every disposition decision, and the brother in Lyon cannot sell the house over her head. When deadlock sets in, the answer is not to act alone — acts taken without the required consent are unenforceable against the others — but to trigger one of the exit routes below.
Creditors have their own limited doorway into the picture. Article 815-17 of the Civil Code draws the boundary this way: “Les créanciers personnels d’un indivisaire ne peuvent saisir sa part dans les biens indivis, meubles ou immeubles.” (Article 815-17, Code civil, Légifrance). A sibling’s personal creditor cannot seize that sibling’s undivided share directly; instead, the statute continues, such creditors may force partition in their debtor’s name or intervene in an ongoing partition, while the other co-owners can stop that forced action by paying the debt for the debtor. For American families this matters when one sibling carries heavy debts: the creditor cannot grab the French house, but it can force the family toward the partition table.
B. Living With It: Using the House, Paying the Bills, and Selling Your Share to an Outsider
Every co-owner may use the house, but nobody may monopolize it for free. Article 815-9 of the Civil Code states: “Chaque indivisaire peut user et jouir des biens indivis conformément à leur destination, dans la mesure compatible avec le droit des autres indivisaires et avec l’effet des actes régulièrement passés au cours de l’indivision.” (Article 815-9, Code civil, Légifrance). Each sibling can stay in the house consistently with its residential purpose and with everyone else’s equal right. The price of exclusivity is explicit in the same article: “L’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité.” The sibling who lives in the Sarlat house year-round while the other two never visit owes the indivision a compensatory payment, usually called the indemnité d’occupation, unless the family agrees otherwise. American families should fix that amount in writing early — by reference to local rental value — because years of silent exclusive occupation followed by a retroactive claim are a classic source of litigation.
Money the house earns belongs to everyone together. Article 815-10 of the Civil Code provides: “Les fruits et les revenus des biens indivis accroissent à l’indivision, à défaut de partage provisionnel ou de tout autre accord établissant la jouissance divise.” (Article 815-10, Code civil, Légifrance). Summer rental income, in other words, falls into the common pot and is divided by shares, minus common expenses, unless the siblings agree on a different split. Claims about that income expire on a strict clock: “Aucune recherche relative aux fruits et revenus ne sera, toutefois, recevable plus de cinq ans après la date à laquelle ils ont été perçus ou auraient pu l’être.” A sibling who managed the rentals cannot be asked to account for income collected more than five years ago, so the family should settle rental accounts annually rather than reconstructing a decade of Airbnb statements at partition time. Each annual accounting should be kept with the French tax filings, because the same rental income must also be reported in France and in the United States, as Part II explains.
The most explosive move is selling your share to a stranger. French law does not forbid it, but it gives the remaining siblings a right of first refusal that is policed severely. Article 815-14 of the Civil Code states: “L’indivisaire qui entend céder, à titre onéreux, à une personne étrangère à l’indivision, tout ou partie de ses droits dans les biens indivis ou dans un ou plusieurs de ces biens est tenu de notifier par acte extrajudiciaire aux autres indivisaires le prix et les conditions de la cession projetée ainsi que les nom, domicile et profession de la personne qui se propose d’acquérir.” (Article 815-14, Code civil, Légifrance). The notice must travel through a formal extrajudicial act — in practice a bailiff’s writ (commissaire de justice) — and must name the buyer and state the price and terms. Each notified sibling then has a short statutory window to step into the deal: “Tout indivisaire peut, dans le délai d’un mois qui suit cette notification, faire connaître au cédant, par acte extrajudiciaire, qu’il exerce un droit de préemption aux prix et conditions qui lui ont été notifiés.” Miss that one-month deadline, counted from the formal notice, and the preemption right for that sale is lost, so siblings who receive such a notice should see a French lawyer within days, not weeks.
The courts apply this notification duty literally. In a 2009 ruling the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held: “Attendu qu’à peine de nullité de la cession, l’indivisaire qui entend céder, à titre onéreux, à une personne étrangère à l’indivision, tout ou partie de ses droits dans les biens indivis est tenu de notifier aux autres indivisaires le nom, le domicile et la profession de la personne qui se propose d’acquérir” (Cass. 1re civ., 28 Jan. 2009, No. 07-18.120). In that case co-owners had notified a preliminary sale agreement that let the named buyers substitute “any natural or legal person,” then sold to a property company substituted for the original buyers; the Court quashed the appeal judgment and voided the sale, because the true buyer’s identity had never been notified. An older Third Civil Chamber decision makes the complementary point that the formality protects the family circle rather than the market: where all co-owners genuinely act together to sell the whole property to a third party, the litigation turned on whether concerted action removes the need for notice (Cass. 3e civ., 21 Dec. 1988, No. 87-17.078). The lesson for American siblings is symmetrical: never accept a vague notice that hides the buyer’s identity, and never try to slip a share to an outside investor through a substitution clause without fresh formal notice. A sale concluded in breach of the duty can be annulled, leaving everyone — including the outsider — back at square one with legal costs.
II. Getting Out: Buyout, Court Sale, Partition, and the Tax Bill on Both Sides
Three doors lead out of the indivision, and the family should try them in order: a negotiated buyout recorded by the notaire, a preferential award of the house to one heir with compensation to the others, and finally a court-ordered process ending in a public auction. Each door has its own tax stamp in France and its own reporting line in the United States. The notaire handling the succession normally drafts the first two; the third belongs to the judge. What follows maps each route with its costs so the siblings can compare them on paper before positions harden.
A. The Three Exits: Negotiated Buyout, Preferential Award, and Court-Ordered Licitation
The cleanest exit is the amicable one: one or two siblings buy out the other’s share, or all agree to sell the house together and split the price. A buyout between co-owners is a partition in miniature, and French partition follows a value rule. Article 826 of the Civil Code states: “L’égalité dans le partage est une égalité en valeur.” (Article 826, Code civil, Légifrance). Each person must receive value equal to their rights, and “Si la consistance de la masse ne permet pas de former des lots d’égale valeur, leur inégalité se compense par une soulte.” The soulte — the equalizing cash payment — is the heart of every sibling buyout: if the house is worth 300,000 euros and two siblings keep it while the third leaves, the departing sibling’s one-third is 100,000 euros, paid as soulte, possibly with a payment schedule secured by a lien if the notaire structures it that way. Because the transfer ends the indivision for that share, it also benefits from the declaratory effect of partition in Article 883 of the Civil Code: “Chaque cohéritier est censé avoir succédé seul et immédiatement à tous les effets compris dans son lot, ou à lui échus sur licitation, et n’avoir jamais eu la propriété des autres effets de la succession.” (Article 883, Code civil, Légifrance). The sibling who takes the house is deemed to have owned it alone since the death, which simplifies the chain of title and, as tax advisers confirm file by file, the later computation of gain on resale.
When one sibling has a special tie to the house, the law offers a middle path: the preferential award (attribution préférentielle). Article 831-2 of the Civil Code provides: “Le conjoint survivant ou tout héritier copropriétaire peut également demander l’attribution préférentielle : 1° De la propriété ou du droit au bail du local qui lui sert effectivement d’habitation, s’il y avait sa résidence à l’époque du décès, et du mobilier le garnissant” (Article 831-2, Code civil, Légifrance). The sibling who actually lived in the house at the death — for example the daughter who moved back to care for the parent — can ask the court to award her the dwelling, paying a soulte to the others, even over their objection. Courts examine the facts of occupation closely rather than rubber-stamping the request. In a 2018 divorce-context ruling on the same article, the First Civil Chamber quashed an appeal decision that had rejected a preferential-award claim based only on where the claimant lived when divorce proceedings began: “Qu’en se déterminant ainsi, sans rechercher, comme elle y était invitée, si Mme X… n’avait pas été contrainte de quitter le domicile conjugal pour échapper aux violences que son époux lui faisait subir, la cour d’appel a privé sa décision de base légale” (Cass. 1re civ., 15 May 2018, No. 17-16.858). The method travels to successions: judges look at real, continuous occupation and the reasons for any absence, so the sibling claiming the award should gather utility bills, tax notices, neighbor statements, and proof of caregiving from the period around the death.
If no agreement is possible, the court takes over, and the siblings should understand that delaying tactics have statutory limits. First, a dissenting co-owner can ask the court to freeze partition briefly: “A la demande d’un indivisaire, le tribunal peut surseoir au partage pour deux années au plus si sa réalisation immédiate risque de porter atteinte à la valeur des biens indivis” (Article 820, Code civil, Légifrance). That two-year stay, counted from the court’s decision, protects value — for instance where a depressed local market would force a fire sale — but it only postpones the outcome. Second, co-owners holding at least two-thirds can ask the court to authorize a private sale of the property even over a minority holdout: “Sauf en cas de démembrement de la propriété du bien ou si l’un des indivisaires se trouve dans l’un des cas prévus à l’article 836, l’aliénation d’un bien indivis peut être autorisée par le tribunal judiciaire, à la demande de l’un ou des indivisaires titulaires d’au moins deux tiers des droits indivis” (Article 815-5-1, Code civil, Légifrance). With three equal siblings, two aligned siblings can therefore seek judicial permission to sell, leaving the third to contest the price rather than block the principle. Third, where even that fails, the court orders the classic ending: the licitation, a public auction of the house with the proceeds divided. A 2020 First Civil Chamber ruling illustrates the machinery in motion, ordering “l’ouverture des opérations de comptes, liquidation et partage des intérêts patrimoniaux” together with “la vente sur licitation aux enchères publiques à la barre du tribunal de leur bien immobilier indivis” (Cass. 1re civ., 2 Sept. 2020, No. 19-11.315). Auctions typically yield less than private sales and generate additional costs, which is why French practitioners treat licitation as the threat that brings everyone back to the negotiating table rather than as a goal.
A house occupied by a surviving parent complicates every exit and must be checked before any partition arithmetic begins. The surviving spouse may hold a lifetime right to live in the home (droit viager d’habitation) or a usufruct over the estate, either of which burdens the property regardless of the children’s indivision. The official partition guide on service-public.fr, Partage des biens de la succession, maps these surrounding rights, and the economics ministry’s explainer Succession: qu’est-ce que l’indivision ? summarizes the regime in plain language. American siblings should therefore ask the notaire, at the first meeting, whether the surviving parent holds any lifetime housing right or usufruct, because a house encumbered that way cannot simply be sold vacant, and any buyout price must reflect the encumbrance.
B. The Double Tax Bill: French Partition Duty, French Capital Gains, and the American Return
France taxes the exit itself, separately from any profit. Article 746 of the General Tax Code states: “Les partages de biens meubles et immeubles entre copropriétaires, cohéritiers et coassociés, à quelque titre que ce soit, pourvu qu’il en soit justifié, sont assujettis à un droit d’enregistrement ou à une taxe de publicité foncière de 2,50 %.” (Article 746, Code général des impôts, Légifrance). In practice the published rate applied to successoral partitions has been lowered by later finance acts, so the family should ask the notaire for the exact rate applicable at the signing date; the mechanism, however, is constant: the buyout or partition deed triggers a proportional duty on the value of the property shared, plus the notaire’s own regulated fees and the land-registry publication tax. A buyout that ignores this duty in its price arithmetic understates the true cost of keeping the house, sometimes by several thousand euros on an ordinary provincial home.
The succession itself runs on its own filing clock, and missing it costs interest and penalties. Article 641 of the General Tax Code sets the period for filing the estate declaration: “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.” (Article 641, Code général des impôts, Légifrance). Where the deceased died in metropolitan France, the heirs file within six months of the death; where the death occurred anywhere else — including the United States — the period is one year from the death. American siblings dealing with a parent who died in Florida or California therefore work within that one-year window, counted from the date of death, during which the notaire values the house, computes each heir’s French inheritance tax under the parent-child scale, and applies the 1978 France-United States estate and gift tax treaty, whose consolidated text the tax administration publishes online (France-U.S. estate and gift tax treaty of 24 November 1978, consolidated version; see also the administration’s treaty commentary at BOFiP INT – Convention fiscale entre la France et les États-Unis). The treaty credit mechanism prevents the same house from bearing full death tax in both countries, but it requires coordinated filings: the French declaration first, then the American estate return claiming the credit, each within its own national deadline.
Which country’s succession law even governs the house is the first question the notaire settles, and Americans often find the answer surprising. In a cross-border estate the applicable law turns on where the deceased habitually lived and on whether the will validly chose the law of the deceased’s nationality for the whole succession, and the notaire establishes both points before computing anyone’s share. The official settlement guide on service-public.fr, Règlement d’une succession, walks through that determination process and points readers to the European reference portal for the succession law of each EU country. An American who retired to France and died habitually resident there generally leaves French law — including forced heirship — applicable to the French house unless a valid choice of American law was made in a will. Conversely, an American who always lived in the United States but owned a vacation home in France leaves the French house under the law designated by those cross-border rules. Siblings who discover this late sometimes learn that the will they considered purely American actually selected U.S. law for the French property — or failed to do so — and the whole partition arithmetic changes.
On resale, France taxes the gain under its real-estate capital-gains regime. The governing provision is Article 150 U of the General Tax Code (Article 150 U, Code général des impôts, Légifrance), which defines taxable gains on the sale of buildings and land with a series of statutory exemptions, including the well-known full exemption for the seller’s main home. Siblings who inherited a vacation home that was never anyone’s main residence should assume the gain is taxable in France, computed from the value declared in the succession as the cost basis, with taper relief for holding period applied exactly as the statute schedules it, plus social levies. Because the declaratory effect of Article 883 treats the sibling who receives the house on partition as owner since the death, the holding period for that sibling’s later resale runs from the death rather than from the partition deed, a detail the notaire confirms in each file and one more reason to keep the succession valuation evidence.
The American side then adds three layers: income exclusion for the inheritance itself, basis rules on later sale, and the foreign tax credit. Under long-standing American rules, property acquired from a decedent is generally excluded from the heir’s gross income, and the heir’s basis in the property is generally its fair market value at the death — the famous basis step-up — as the Internal Revenue Service explains in its guidance on gifts and inheritances. When the siblings later sell the French house, the United States taxes the gain from that stepped-up basis, and French tax already paid on the same gain can generally be credited against the American tax under the foreign-tax-credit rules described by the IRS in its foreign tax credit guidance, within the limits and baskets those rules impose. Rental income earned while the indivision lasts is reported in both countries each year — France taxes real-estate income from French soil first, and the United States taxes its residents’ worldwide income with a credit for the French tax — a cycle the IRS addresses in Publication 54 guidance for Americans abroad. The practical discipline is therefore simple: keep one shared folder with the French declarations, the American returns, and proof of every euro of French tax paid, because every credit claimed in the United States must be documented.
Two final compliance points close the file. First, American heirs with signature authority over a French estate bank account, or a share in one, must check their annual American foreign-account reporting — the FBAR and Form 8938 regimes — and the parallel French reporting of foreign accounts, well before partition distributes the cash. Second, none of the French deadlines described here — the one-month preemption window running from formal notice, the five-year limit on fruits-and-income claims running from collection, the two-year maximum stay of partition, or the six- and twelve-month succession filing periods running from the death — pauses while the siblings negotiate informally. A family that talks for a year without writing anything down can lose rights on all four clocks at once, which is why the notaire’s first letter should be answered with a written family timetable, not with good intentions.
Conclusion
An inherited French house shared between American siblings is manageable, but only on French terms. The indivision gives everyone a veto over selling while guaranteeing that anyone can force the exit; the buyout with its equalizing soulte, the preferential award for the sibling who truly lived there, and the court-ordered auction form a ladder of escalating cost and bitterness, with the negotiated partition always cheapest. France taxes the partition deed, the succession, and any later gain, while the United States layers its basis, reporting, and foreign-credit rules on top, with the 1978 treaty preventing double death tax for families that file in the right order. Siblings who commission an early valuation, fix the occupation payment in writing, calendar every deadline from the formal notice or the death, and let the notaire draft the exit before resentment hardens will spend their inheritance on the house, not on procedure. Those who drift, letting one sibling occupy the house rent-free while another quietly negotiates with an outside buyer, will discover that French law already wrote the ending: partition, at public auction if necessary, with costs shared by all.