Your husband just died. He owned an apartment in Paris, or a stone house in the Dordogne, and his American will says everything goes to you. Then a French notaire tells you that the house cannot simply pass to you, that his children have locked-in rights no will can remove, and that you may end up owning only a share of the home you lived in together. This guide explains, step by step, what French law gives a surviving American spouse automatically, how a French will can protect you far better, and which two traps most often destroy US-style estate plans. You do not need any background in French law: every French term is explained the first time it appears, every decisive rule is quoted from the statute or the court decision that states it, and every link points to the official text so you or your attorney can check it.
The shock most Americans feel comes from one structural difference. In most US states, you can leave your property to anyone, including leaving everything to your spouse and nothing to your children. France does the opposite for the part of the estate governed by French law. Children are what French law calls reserved heirs, meaning the statute guarantees them a minimum slice of the estate, called the forced share. The rest, called the freely disposable portion, is the only part the deceased could give away by lifetime gift or by will. Article 912 of the Civil Code states the principle in these words: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent” (article 912 of the Civil Code). In plain English, the forced share is the slice of the inheritance that the law reserves, free of conditions, for certain heirs, called reserved heirs, if they accept the estate. A surviving spouse is only a reserved heir when there are no children: article 914-1 of the Civil Code provides that gifts and wills “ne pourront excéder les trois quarts des biens si, à défaut de descendant, le défunt laisse un conjoint survivant, non divorcé” (article 914-1 of the Civil Code), which means that without descendants, only three quarters can be given away and one quarter is locked in for the surviving husband or wife. With children, the children’s forced shares come first, and the spouse takes only what the rules described below allow, plus whatever a valid will adds within the free portion. That is why the will is not optional paperwork here: it is the main tool that decides whether you keep the home or merely co-own it with your stepchildren.
I. When your spouse dies owning a French house, what does French law give you with no will at all?
A. Do you have children together, or does your spouse have a child from an earlier relationship?
This single question changes everything, so answer it before anything else. Article 757 of the Civil Code gives the surviving spouse, when the deceased leaves children, a choice, but only in one family situation. The statute reads: “Si l’époux prédécédé laisse des enfants ou descendants, le conjoint survivant recueille, à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens lorsque tous les enfants sont issus des deux époux et la propriété du quart en présence d’un ou plusieurs enfants qui ne sont pas issus des deux époux” (article 757 of the Civil Code). An usufruct, called usufruit in French, is the right to use a property and collect its income for life without owning it outright: you can live in the house or rent it out and keep the rent, but you cannot sell it without the agreement of the bare owners, usually the children. Full ownership of one quarter, by contrast, means you own 25 percent of every estate asset outright and can sell or mortgage that share, but the children own the other 75 percent and can force a sale of an undivided property through a court partition if no agreement is reached. So when all the children are yours together, you choose: lifetime use of everything, or outright ownership of one quarter. That choice must be made deliberately, because each option pushes the family finances in a different direction, and the official guide of the French notaires warns that once an heir formally asks you to choose, silence for three months counts as choosing the lifetime usufruct.
When even one child is not yours together, the choice disappears, and this is the rule that devastates unprepared American spouses in second marriages. The Court of Cassation, France’s highest civil court, restated it word for word on March 5, 2025, in decision number 23-11.430: “Selon ce texte, si l’époux prédécédé laisse un ou plusieurs enfants qui ne sont pas issus des deux époux, le conjoint survivant recueille la propriété du quart des biens existants.” The surviving spouse receives outright ownership of one quarter of the existing assets, nothing more, with no option for lifetime use of everything. In that case the children, including a child from your spouse’s first marriage, take the other three quarters between them, and you co-own the French house with them. Read the full decision on the Court’s official site: Cass. 1re civ., March 5, 2025, No. 23-11.430. The statute behind it is article 757 of the Civil Code, and the French notaires confirm the same reading in English on their official site: with a child who is not the couple’s joint child, the survivor takes one quarter in ownership and has no choice (rights of the surviving spouse).
Behind both situations stands the children’s forced share, which caps what any will could ever redirect to you. Article 913 of the Civil Code sets the free portion by headcount: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Gifts and wills cannot exceed one half with one child, one third with two children, or one quarter with three or more children: the rest belongs to the children by force of law. With no descendants at all, the spouse’s own locked-in quarter under article 914-1 of the Civil Code plays the same blocking role against the deceased’s parents or siblings. The general principle sits in article 912 of the Civil Code, and the scale in article 913 of the Civil Code. Memorize the arithmetic before you plan: with two children, for example, two thirds of everything is untouchable, and only one third can be steered to you by will.
B. Can you stay in the house you shared? The one-year free stay and the lifetime right to live there
Even when the ownership math looks grim, French law gives the surviving spouse two concrete housing rights that operate on top of the inheritance shares, and the first one is automatic. For twelve months after the death, you may stay free of charge in the home that was your principal residence, with the furniture, and if you were renting that home, the rent for that year is charged to the estate, not to you. The French notaires describe it plainly: the survivor is entitled to the free use of the main-residence accommodation and its furniture for one year after the death. This right needs no will, no election, and no permission from the children. Use that year to breathe, to gather the paperwork listed at the end of this guide, and to decide calmly which long-term option to take, because the second housing right, unlike the first, must be actively claimed within that same year.
The second right is stronger and lasts far longer: unless your spouse took it away from you in a will made before a notaire, you hold until your own death a lifetime right to live in the home that was your principal residence at the time of death, plus a lifetime right to use the furniture in it. Article 764 of the Civil Code grants it in these terms: “le conjoint successible qui occupait effectivement, à l’époque du décès, à titre d’habitation principale, un logement appartenant aux époux ou dépendant totalement de la succession, a sur ce logement, jusqu’à son décès, un droit d’habitation et un droit d’usage sur le mobilier, compris dans la succession, le garnissant.” The surviving spouse who was actually living in the home as a principal residence holds over that home, until death, a right of habitation, plus a right of use over the furniture in it. Three practical points matter enormously. First, only a deprivation expressed in a notarial will counts: an American will, a letter, or a family agreement cannot strip this right, which is why the form of your spouse’s will matters as much as its content. Second, you must assert the right during the year after the death, so seeing a notaire quickly is not administrative zeal, it is how the right survives. Third, the value of this lifetime right counts against your inheritance share, but with a protective twist stated in article 765: if the right is worth more than your share, you keep the surplus and owe the estate nothing. Read article 764 of the Civil Code and article 765 of the Civil Code, and the notaires’ English explanation of both the one-year and the lifetime housing rights (rights of the surviving spouse).
Two complements complete the picture. When the estate is divided, the law favors awarding the house and its furniture to the surviving spouse outright, against compensation to the other heirs where needed: ask the notaire handling the partition about this preferential award, because remaining in the home as owner beats remaining in it as a lifetime occupant when it comes to future works, insurance, and resale. And if money is tight, know that the surviving spouse in need can claim a maintenance payment from the heirs, but that claim must be raised within the year of the death, another reason the first twelve months set the course of everything. None of these housing rights, however, changes who owns what: they protect your roof, not your title. Ownership is decided by the shares in section A plus the will in Part II, which is where an American spouse gains or loses the most.
II. How does a French will protect the surviving American spouse, and which two traps undo US-style plans?
A. How do you write a will that actually works in France and choose the law that governs the estate?
Start with form, because an invalid will protects no one. France recognizes two everyday will forms. The holographic will, or testament olographe, is valid only if entirely handwritten, dated, and signed by the testator’s own hand, with no other formality. Article 970 states the whole rule in one sentence: “Le testament olographe ne sera point valable s’il n’est écrit en entier, daté et signé de la main du testateur : il n’est assujetti à aucune autre forme.” A typed, printed, or computer-stored text with only a signature fails, and so does an undated page. The notarial will, or testament authentique, is received by two notaires or by one notaire with two witnesses, under article 971 of the Civil Code, and it is the form to prefer whenever you want to rearrange rights seriously, for example to deprive the lifetime housing right or to set a choice-of-law clause with full evidentiary weight. Read article 970 of the Civil Code before handwriting anything.
Then keep the original paper, because France checks handwriting against the original document, never against a scan. On March 26, 2025, the Court of Cassation quashed a decision that had validated a holographic will after comparing only a readable copy, holding: “Il résulte de ces textes que la vérification d’écriture doit être effectuée au vu de l’original de l’écrit contesté.” Handwriting verification must be performed against the original of the disputed document. For an American family spread across two continents, the lesson is blunt: a will stored only as a PDF on a laptop in Ohio invites a challenge your heirs cannot answer, while the signed original deposited with a French notaire or kept where the family can produce it closes that challenge down. Full decision: Cass. 1re civ., March 26, 2025, No. 23-14.430.
Next, decide what the will gives, staying inside the free portion. Between spouses, the Civil Code offers a special enlarged menu. Article 1094-1 allows a spouse who leaves children to give the other spouse either what could go to a stranger, meaning the ordinary free portion, or one quarter in full ownership plus the usufruct of the other three quarters, or the usufruct of everything. The statute’s own words: “il pourra disposer en faveur de l’autre époux, soit de la propriété de ce dont il pourrait disposer en faveur d’un étranger, soit d’un quart de ses biens en propriété et des trois autres quarts en usufruit, soit encore de la totalité de ses biens en usufruit seulement.” In practice, the middle option is the workhorse of French-American planning: you receive a solid quarter outright, which counts toward your article 757 rights, plus lifetime use and income over the rest, which keeps you in the house and preserves the children’s bare ownership for later. Ask a notaire to model all three options in dollars-and-cents terms before choosing, because the best option depends on the children’s ages, the rental value of the house, and your own resources. Source: article 1094-1 of the Civil Code.
Finally, state which law governs the succession, because for an American this clause decides whether the whole French forced-share machinery even applies. The European Succession Regulation, which governs cross-border estates in France, starts from habitual residence: under Article 21 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, the default law of the entire succession is the law of the State where the deceased had habitual residence at death. But Article 22 of the same Regulation lets each person elect the law of their nationality instead, and a person holding more than one nationality may elect the law of any of those States. An American living in France can therefore elect US law in the will, and an American living in the United States with a French house will often see US law apply through residence anyway, subject to French public-policy limits that courts construe narrowly. The election must appear expressly in a testamentary disposition or clearly follow from its terms, so write it as a sentence, not as an implication: name the nationality, name the law, sign and date. Where the deceased lived outside the European Union, French courts keep a jurisdictional safety net that Americans should know: when the deceased held French nationality and owned assets in France, French courts can rule on the whole succession under the Regulation’s subsidiary-jurisdiction rule, a point the Court of Cassation confirmed on September 21, 2022, in decision number Y 19-15.438, holding that “lorsque la résidence habituelle du défunt au moment du décès n’est pas située dans un État membre, les juridictions de l’État membre dans lequel sont situés des biens successoraux sont néanmoins compétentes pour statuer sur l’ensemble de la succession dans la mesure où le défunt possédait la nationalité de cet État membre au moment du décès” (Cass. 1re civ., September 21, 2022, No. 19-15.438). If no will exists at all and no election was ever made, your situation falls back on intestacy plus election analysis, which our companion guide on deaths without a French will walks through house by house: what happens when an American dies in France without a French will.
B. What are the two traps that undo American plans: the children’s compensatory levy and French death taxes on the house?
The first trap strikes when the will elects US law precisely to escape the forced share. Since the statute of August 24, 2021, article 913 of the Civil Code lets each child claw back protection from French assets when the applicable foreign law gives children no forced-share mechanism at all: where the deceased or at least one child is an EU national or EU resident at death and the foreign succession law provides no reserved-share device for children, each child or their heirs may take a compensatory levy, called prélèvement compensatoire, from the assets located in France so as to recover the French forced-share rights, within their limits. In short, electing the law of a US state that allows full disinheritance of children does not make the French house freely disposable if your children can invoke this levy against it. The mechanism has sharp edges and conditions, nationality or residence links, comparison of the two laws, valuation of French assets at death, and it is exactly the kind of clause that must be modeled before the will is signed, not litigated after. Read the full second paragraph of article 913 of the Civil Code, and note the symmetry the courts enforce on the money side: when a gift or will exceeds the free portion, the beneficiary does not return the house itself but pays the reserved heirs an indemnity, because article 924 provides that “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent” (article 924 of the Civil Code). The Court of Cassation drew the cross-border consequence on April 14, 2021, in decision number 19-24.773: a reduction action against the donee of French real estate seeks money, not the building, so it is movable in character and belongs before the courts of the deceased’s last domicile: “Il résulte de la combinaison des principes régissant les successions internationales et de l’article 924 du code civil que l’action en réduction exercée par les héritiers réservataires contre le donataire d’un immeuble, qui ne tend pas à la restitution en nature de l’immeuble mais au paiement d’une indemnité de réduction et présente, dès lors, un caractère mobilier, relève de la compétence des tribunaux du pays où le défunt avait son dernier domicile” (Cass. 1re civ., April 14, 2021, No. 19-24.773). For you, the message is practical: overshooting the free portion never silently works, it converts into a money debt owed to the children, enforceable across borders.
The second trap is tax, and it surprises Americans twice: once because France taxes the French house even when everyone lives in the United States, and once because the surviving spouse’s exemption does not extend to everyone. Start with territoriality. Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code taxes French-situated real estate, owned directly or through a company, even when the deceased had no French tax domicile: “Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France,” fall within French transfer duties when the deceased was not domiciled in France for tax purposes (article 750 ter of the General Tax Code). The Paris apartment is therefore in the French tax net regardless of Ohio wills, Florida probate, or US residence. The good news is targeted: transfers between spouses are fully exempt from French succession tax, so a house passing to the surviving husband or wife pays no French inheritance tax on that transfer, while transfers to children face the standard scale after a per-child allowance. The 1978 United States-France estate and gift tax treaty, as amended, then allocates taxing rights and offers a credit so the same value is not fully taxed twice; the treaty documents are published by the IRS (France tax treaty documents), and domicile proof under that treaty is often the decisive fight, as our guide on treaty domicile explains: how American families prove domicile under the US-France estate tax treaty. Do not confuse this treaty, which covers transfer taxes, with the income-tax treaty, and do not assume a step-up in basis travels: France has no step-up mechanism comparable to the American one, so keep purchase deeds, works invoices, and sale records for both countries’ computations.
The procedure then runs on rails, and missing a step costs money. A French notaire settles the estate: they verify the will, identify the heirs, compute the forced shares and the free portion, draft the deed of notoriety, and file the succession declaration with the French tax office. That declaration is due within six months of a death in metropolitan France and within one year in all other cases, under article 641 of the General Tax Code: “Les délais pour l’enregistrement des déclarations que les héritiers, donataires ou légataires ont à souscrire des biens à eux échus ou transmis par décès sont : De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas” (article 641 of the General Tax Code). Late filing triggers interest and penalties, so instruct the notaire in the first weeks, from abroad if needed through a power of attorney the notaire will accept. Assemble now, while the year of housing rights runs: the death certificate with apostille and sworn translation, the marriage certificate, children’s birth certificates, all wills and codicils with their originals, the house title deed, the latest property-tax notices, bank statements, and any lifetime gifts the deceased made, since gifts are notionally added back to compute the forced shares. If the family disagrees about the will’s validity, the children’s shares, or the house valuation, the original-paper rule and the money-only reduction rule above decide most fights before they start.
Conclusion
Keep five points on one page and act on them in order. First, identify your family box: children together means you choose between lifetime use of everything and outright ownership of one quarter, while a child from an earlier relationship locks you to one quarter in ownership with no usufruct option. Second, secure the roof immediately: the one-year free stay is automatic, but the lifetime right to live in the home must be claimed within the year, so see a notaire within weeks. Third, make the will do the heavy lifting inside the free portion, using the spouse-specific menu of one quarter plus lifetime use of the rest where it fits, in a notarial will wherever the stakes justify it, and keep the signed original where it can be produced. Fourth, write the choice-of-law sentence expressly, electing US nationality law only after modeling the children’s compensatory levy against the French house. Fifth, file the French succession declaration on time, claim the spouse exemption, coordinate the treaty credit with the US return, and never let a US-only plan pretend the Paris apartment follows US rules alone. Done in this order, French law stops feeling like a trap and starts working like what it is: a system that protects children absolutely, and protects spouses generously once you use its tools.