If you are an American married to a French citizen, the answer to “what do I inherit if my spouse dies?” is not found in one rule. French succession law, the couple’s matrimonial property regime, the deceased person’s habitual residence, any valid choice of law, and the France–U.S. estate-tax treaty can all change the result. The surviving spouse may receive a quarter in full ownership, a lifetime usufruct over the estate, a protected right to remain in the family home, or the entire succession. A will or a donation entre époux (a marital gift that takes effect at death) may expand those choices, but it does not eliminate the need to check which law governs the estate. French inheritance-tax exemption for a surviving spouse also does not mean that no declaration, notarial deed, U.S. estate-tax filing, or foreign-account report is required. This guide separates the civil-law rights from the tax and reporting questions so an American spouse can identify the urgent decisions, preserve evidence, and give the French notary and U.S. adviser a consistent file.
I. What does an American surviving spouse inherit from a French spouse?
A. Which law governs a French-American succession and who qualifies as the surviving spouse?
Nationality alone does not answer the succession question. The first task is to identify the law governing the estate as a whole. For a succession handled in France, Regulation (EU) No. 650/2012 is the starting point. Article 21 generally points to the law of the deceased person’s habitual residence at the time of death. “Habitual residence” is a factual connection, not simply a visa, a mailing address, or the place where a tax return was filed. A long-term home, family life, work, health care, property management, and the centre of day-to-day life may all matter.
The regulation is also universal. Its Article 20 means that the law designated by the regulation may be the law of a non-EU country. An American spouse should therefore not assume that a French apartment automatically makes every part of the estate French. If the deceased was habitually resident in France, French succession rules will often govern. If the deceased was habitually resident in the United States, the applicable law may instead be the law designated by the regulation, conflict-of-laws rules, and any relevant U.S. state-law analysis, while French formalities and French taxation may still affect French real estate.
Article 22 provides a separate planning tool: a person may choose the law of a country whose nationality that person holds to govern the succession as a whole. The choice must be express in a disposition on death, such as a will, or must clearly result from its terms. The official English text of Articles 20 to 23 is available in Regulation (EU) No. 650/2012 on EUR-Lex. A clause that merely says “my American assets pass under my American will” may not be a properly drafted choice for the succession as a whole. The notary must review the exact wording, the person’s nationality at the relevant time, and the date of the instrument.
That choice-of-law analysis is separate from the matrimonial property regime. The regime determines what already belongs to the surviving spouse before the succession is calculated. For example, a home may be jointly owned, community property, or owned by only one spouse. The succession then concerns the deceased spouse’s share, not property that the survivor already owns. An American marriage certificate, a French marriage certificate, a prenuptial agreement, a U.S. marital agreement, deeds, bank statements, and prior gifts should be assembled together. A French notary may need certified civil-status documents, evidence of the applicable law, and a reliable translation before accepting the proposed analysis.
French law calls the eligible spouse the conjoint successible, meaning the spouse who has a legal call to inherit. Article 732 of the French Civil Code states: “Est conjoint successible le conjoint survivant non divorcé.” In English, the surviving spouse must not be divorced. Separation in fact does not have the same effect as a final divorce, but a divorce judgment, a pending divorce, a separation agreement, or a foreign dissolution must be checked carefully for recognition and timing. A PACS partner is a different legal category: a PACS partner is not automatically a French heir in the same way as a spouse. The distinction is important even though a PACS partner, like a surviving spouse, benefits from a French inheritance-tax exemption. For the separate PACS analysis, see our guide on an American partner inheriting from a French PACS partner.
Article 756 of the Civil Code confirms that the surviving spouse may be called to the succession alone or in competition with the deceased’s parents. The spouse’s American nationality does not reduce these statutory rights once French law is the law governing the succession. Conversely, simply being married to a French national does not guarantee that French statutory shares govern if a valid choice of another succession law applies. This is why the notary’s first questions should concern habitual residence, nationality, the will, the date of marriage, the matrimonial property regime, and the family tree.
Finally, the surviving spouse’s civil-law share is not the same thing as the spouse’s tax domicile or U.S. citizenship. A U.S. citizen remains potentially subject to U.S. worldwide estate-tax and reporting rules. A person can be a French civil-law heir, a French tax resident, a U.S. citizen, and a beneficiary of a U.S. estate at the same time. Each status answers a different question and must be documented rather than assumed.
B. What does the American spouse receive with children, parents, or no descendants?
The central French rule depends first on whether the deceased left children or other descendants, and whether every child is a child of both spouses. The legal vocabulary is precise. Usufruit is a right to use property and receive its income, while nue-propriété is bare ownership: the children may own the underlying asset but cannot use it in the same way while the usufruct lasts. Pleine propriété means full ownership. These concepts are not interchangeable with an American life estate, a probate “elective share,” or a trust interest, even when the economic result may look similar.
When the deceased leaves children or descendants, Article 757 of the Civil Code gives the surviving spouse a statutory option if all the children are common children: the spouse may choose the usufruct of all existing assets or full ownership of one quarter. The text says: “le conjoint survivant recueille, à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart”. In practical terms, the survivor may preserve use of the family assets while the children hold the bare ownership, or may take a smaller share in full ownership.
If even one child is not a child of both spouses, the statutory choice is narrower. The surviving spouse receives one quarter in full ownership. This is the classic “child from a first marriage” problem. The result may be changed by a will or a marital gift within the limits of the French reserved-heirship rules, but the stepchild or child from the prior relationship cannot simply be ignored. The notary must trace every child, including a deceased child’s descendants, adoption status, renunciation, and any dispute about parentage.
If there are no children or descendants but the deceased’s father and mother are alive, Article 757-1 of the Civil Code gives the surviving spouse one half. The other half is divided into one quarter for the father and one quarter for the mother. If one parent has already died, the share that would have gone to that parent goes to the surviving spouse. This is a sharp difference from the common American assumption that a spouse necessarily takes everything when there are no children.
If there are no children or descendants and neither parent is alive, Article 757-2 of the Civil Code provides that the surviving spouse receives the entire succession. There is, however, a specific family-return rule. Under Article 757-3, certain assets received by the deceased from ascendants by inheritance or gift and still existing in the estate can return in part to the deceased’s siblings or their descendants when there are no descendants. A French apartment inherited from a parent and still identifiable in the estate can therefore require a more careful title and family-history review than an ordinary bank balance.
The share is calculated from more than the bank account balance on the day of death. Article 758-5 of the Civil Code requires a notional calculation that brings certain lifetime gifts back into the calculation of the surviving spouse’s full-ownership rights. It also protects reserved shares and rights of return. A gift of a French property made years earlier, a transfer to a child, a gift to a U.S. trust, or a family loan that was later forgiven can change the calculation even if the asset no longer appears in the deceased’s estate.
Prior benefits to the spouse also matter. Under Article 758-6 of the Civil Code, gifts and other benefits received from the deceased are taken into account against the spouse’s succession rights, subject to the statutory limits. The file should therefore include prior deeds, transfers, life-insurance designations, and any marital gift. A U.S. beneficiary designation is not automatically treated as a French succession gift, but it may affect the overall asset and tax analysis.
A will or donation entre époux can give the spouse a broader choice. Article 1094-1 of the Civil Code allows, when there are children or descendants, a choice between the disposable share in full ownership, one quarter in full ownership plus three quarters in usufruct, or usufruct over the entire estate. The English reader should not interpret “disposable share” as a free power to disinherit children. French réserve héréditaire, or reserved heirship, protects qualifying descendants. The will must also be valid under the law governing its form and substance. A U.S. will can be relevant, but it should be coordinated with the French notary before a death occurs.
The choice between usufruct and full ownership is an economic choice, not a ceremonial formality. Usufruct may protect a survivor who needs to live in a home or receive rent, but it can complicate a later sale, refinancing, reinvestment, and the children’s consent. Full ownership of one quarter may give greater liquidity but leave the spouse exposed if the main home or investment portfolio is worth less than expected. The correct choice depends on the survivor’s age, income, health, housing needs, family relationships, the location of the assets, and the U.S. tax consequences.
II. Can the American spouse keep the French home and reduce cross-border tax?
A. Can the surviving spouse keep the French home, and what must be done within one year?
French law gives the surviving spouse a housing protection that is distinct from the share of ownership. If, at the time of death, the spouse actually occupied as a principal residence a home owned by the couple or wholly dependent on the estate, Articles 763 to 766 of the Civil Code provide a temporary and potentially lifelong right. Article 763 gives one year of free enjoyment of the home and its furniture. The statute describes these rights as direct effects of marriage, not succession rights, and makes the one-year protection mandatory.
Article 764 can then give the spouse a lifelong right of habitation in the home and a right to use the furniture, unless the deceased excluded the right in the legally required form. The official text provides that the spouse who effectively occupied the home as a principal residence has these rights “jusqu’à son décès”. The right is a right to live in and use the property; it is not automatically full ownership and does not allow the survivor to treat the children’s bare ownership as if it did not exist. If the home was owned half by each spouse, the survivor’s existing half and the deceased’s estate share must be separated in the title analysis.
The one-year clock is a real procedural risk. Article 765-1 of the Civil Code states: “Le conjoint dispose d’un an à partir du décès pour manifester sa volonté de bénéficier de ces droits d’habitation et d’usage.” The safest practice is to notify the notary in writing, identify the exact property, state that it was the principal residence at the date of death, and request that the election be recorded in the succession file before the anniversary of the death. Do not rely only on continued occupation or on a casual email to a family member.
The Cour de cassation has made the evidence issue concrete. In First Civil Chamber, February 13, 2019, no. 18-10.171, the court recalled that the surviving spouse has one year and that the intention may be tacit, but it examined whether earlier documents clearly expressed the intention. The decision includes the exact formulation: “cette manifestation de volonté peut être tacite”. The lesson is not that silence is safe. It is that a clear act, such as a succession declaration or a document expressly claiming the right, may prove the election if the surrounding facts are consistent.
In First Civil Chamber, March 2, 2022, no. 20-16.674, the court stated the stricter rule: “Si cette manifestation de volonté peut être tacite, elle ne peut résulter du seul maintien dans les lieux.” In English, simply remaining in the home does not, by itself, prove the election. This is especially important for an American spouse who spends part of the year in the United States, uses the French home as a second home, or is dealing with a notary remotely. Evidence of principal residence at death and a timely written election should be preserved.
A second decision, First Civil Chamber, October 24, 2012, no. 11-17.094, explains that a judge dealing with the practical exercise of indivision rights cannot use an expedited proceeding to decide the existence of the surviving spouse’s statutory habitation right. The case concerned a spouse and children from a prior relationship and applied Articles 764 and 815-9. For an American survivor, the point is practical: a conflict over occupancy, an occupation indemnity, or the sale of a house may require the right court and the right procedural track. A notary’s proposed settlement should not be signed before the housing right has been identified.
The right may be excluded only under strict formal conditions. Article 764 refers to the deceased’s contrary intention expressed in the conditions of Article 971. A handwritten U.S. note, an unsigned draft, or a generic estate plan should not be assumed to remove a French housing right. The notary must check whether the testament is authentic, whether it contains the required exclusion, whether the relevant law recognizes it, and whether it was made before the death. A survivor should also preserve proof of utility bills, local registration, insurance, school or medical ties, and other evidence showing actual principal occupation where that fact is contested.
Housing protection is not a substitute for planning. Before a death, the couple should decide whether the survivor needs an outright share, a usufruct, a lifetime housing right, a power to sell and reinvest, or liquidity instead of a right in kind. A French notary can coordinate the will, the marital gift, the matrimonial regime, and the title to the property. If the property is held through an SCI, a U.S. trust, or another entity, the analysis changes because the estate may contain shares rather than a direct ownership interest in the home.
B. How do French inheritance tax, the France–U.S. treaty, and U.S. reporting interact?
The good news for a surviving spouse is that French inheritance tax generally does not apply to the spouse’s share. Article 796-0 bis of the French General Tax Code states: “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” The exemption applies to the surviving spouse regardless of whether that spouse is American, French, resident in France, or resident in the United States. It does not mean that the estate can skip the notarial inventory, the ownership deed, the civil-status proof, or every tax declaration.
The French tax administration explains that a succession declaration is normally due within six months when the death occurs in metropolitan France and within twelve months when the death occurs abroad. The official explanation, When must income and succession declarations be filed after a death?, also lists limited cases in which a spouse may be exempt from filing based on the value and composition of the estate. A French house, a notarial property deed, a will, a prior gift, or a cross-border estate can require professional handling even when the spouse owes no French inheritance tax. Ask the notary to confirm both the filing requirement and the deadline in writing.
The France–U.S. succession and gift tax convention is separate from the French Civil Code. The official consolidated text is the France–U.S. convention on estates and gifts, signed in 1978 and amended by the 2004 protocol. Article 1 describes the estates and gifts covered by the convention, including estates subject to U.S. taxation because of domicile or American citizenship. Article 5 addresses real estate: French real estate is generally within the taxing authority of the state where it is located. Article 8 addresses other property, subject to the convention’s domicile and citizenship rules.
Article 11 is particularly important for a married American. For French tax purposes, certain property acquired for value during the marriage and transferred to the spouse may be treated as community property unless the spouses expressly chose another regime. The same article contains a possible U.S. marital deduction for qualifying property transferred to a surviving spouse who is not a U.S. citizen. The deduction is conditional: the deceased and survivor must satisfy the treaty’s domicile and citizenship requirements, and the executor must make the required election and irrevocably waive other U.S. marital-deduction benefits within the relevant U.S. filing deadline. It is not a blanket exemption that appears automatically because the beneficiary is a spouse.
The Treasury Department’s official technical explanation describes the protocol’s marital-deduction mechanism and warns that the election must be made on a U.S. federal estate-tax return by the deadline for a qualified domestic trust election. It also explains the credit rules that relieve double taxation. The technical explanation is available from the U.S. Treasury Department. An American spouse should give the U.S. estate lawyer the French inventory, the notary’s valuation, the French tax position, the marital agreement, and the exact terms of the will. A French inheritance-tax exemption does not decide whether a U.S. estate-tax return or treaty election is required.
The treaty also does not replace U.S. information reporting. If the survivor receives or controls a French bank account, brokerage account, assurance-vie contract, or foreign estate interest, the U.S. reporting analysis must be performed independently. FinCEN explains that a U.S. person generally files an FBAR when the aggregate maximum value of foreign financial accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time during the calendar year; the official rule appears on FinCEN’s FBAR purpose page. The IRS separately explains Form 8938 for specified foreign financial assets and addresses an interest in a foreign estate in its Form 8938 questions and answers. An inherited French apartment is not itself a foreign bank account, but rent, sale proceeds, French accounts, securities, and estate interests can create separate U.S. questions.
Do not treat an inheritance as ordinary income without checking the asset and the U.S. rule that applies to it. The receipt of property, later rental income, later sale proceeds, interest on a French account, and distributions from an assurance-vie or trust may have different U.S. consequences. A French usufruct can also create valuation and reporting issues that are different from full ownership. The French tax administration notes that the usufruct and bare ownership of real estate can be allocated for certain wealth-tax purposes, and its official explanation of IFI treatment of usufruit and bare ownership should be read together with the particular succession documents.
A practical cross-border file should contain at least the following:
- the French and U.S. marriage certificates, divorce judgments if any, and complete civil-status records for both spouses;
- the deceased person’s passports, proof of nationality, residence history, tax residence evidence, and any choice-of-law clause;
- the original will, any donation entre époux, marital agreement, beneficiary designations, trust instruments, and prior gifts;
- French deeds, mortgage statements, property-tax records, bank statements, insurance policies, and evidence of the home’s actual principal residence;
- the family tree, including children from earlier relationships, adopted children, deceased children, and possible reserved heirs;
- valuations and debt statements as of the date of death, plus any U.S. Form 706, QDOT, treaty-election, FBAR, or Form 8938 advice;
- a written record of the spouse’s choice under Article 757, the request for the housing right, and every communication with the notary before the one-year deadline.
The most common errors are administrative rather than theoretical. A survivor signs a French deed without identifying the choice between usufruct and full ownership; assumes that a U.S. will automatically controls the French home; waits past the one-year housing deadline; treats the French spouse exemption as a filing exemption; or reports a French account without coordinating the estate’s date-of-death valuation. Each error can be expensive to repair after the family has distributed assets or sold the home.
For an American survivor who is outside France, the first communication should be a structured instruction to the French notary: identify the governing law, freeze any distribution that could prejudice the spouse’s election, preserve the housing claim, and request the inventory and valuation. The U.S. adviser should receive the same documents rather than a translated summary prepared from memory. If the estate includes a French home and a U.S. estate, the French civil-law decision and the U.S. tax decision should be made together, but by advisers applying their respective rules.
Conclusion
An American surviving spouse can have substantial rights in a French succession, but those rights depend on the governing succession law, the existence and parentage of children, the deceased’s parents, the matrimonial property regime, the will, and the evidence preserved after death. Under French law, the spouse may receive a usufruct, one quarter in full ownership, half, or the whole estate in the ordinary cases described above. The spouse may also have a temporary and lifelong housing right, but the claim must be documented and the one-year election deadline must be respected. French inheritance-tax exemption is valuable, yet it does not answer the U.S. estate-tax, treaty, FBAR, Form 8938, valuation, or filing questions. A French notary and a U.S. cross-border tax adviser should review the same complete file before the survivor chooses an option or signs a distribution deed.