You are an American citizen, you are not married, and you and your partner are about to buy a house in France together. Perhaps it is a stone farmhouse in the Dordogne, a village house in Provence, or an apartment in Paris. One question matters more than the price, the renovation budget, or the view: if one of you dies, what happens to the other? Under French law, the answer is blunt. An unmarried partner, called a concubin or concubine, inherits nothing automatically. The children, parents, or siblings of the partner who died take the house share, and the survivor can be forced to sell and leave. This article explains, in plain English, the four legal tools American couples actually use to prevent that outcome: buying in indivision (co-ownership) with a tailor-made co-ownership agreement, adding a tontine clause (a survivorship pact written into the purchase deed), signing a PACS (the French registered partnership, pacte civil de solidarité), and writing separate wills. Each tool is presented with the exact French statute behind it, what it costs in French death tax, how the French courts have recently applied it, and what paperwork the American survivor must handle on the United States side.
I. Buying the house together: default co-ownership and the clause that keeps the survivor housed
A. Indivision: the default regime when two unmarried Americans buy together
When two people who are not married buy a French house together and the deed says nothing special, French law places them in indivision. Indivision is the French form of co-ownership in which each buyer owns an undivided share, typically one half each, and no physical part of the house belongs to either of them alone. Everything about this regime flows from one short article of the Civil Code. Article 815 of the Civil Code states, word for word: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” In English: no one can be forced to stay in co-ownership, and a partition, meaning a division or a court-ordered sale with sharing of the proceeds, can always be demanded unless a court decision or an agreement says otherwise. That single sentence is both the protection and the danger of indivision. It protects you because no one, neither your partner nor your partner’s family, can lock you into co-ownership forever. It endangers the survivor because after one partner dies, the deceased partner’s heirs step into the deceased’s shoes and any of them can demand the partition, which in practice means forcing the sale of the house at public auction, a procedure called licitation, if nobody agrees on a buyout price.
The first practical decision is the size of each share, and Americans should treat this step with the seriousness of a tax filing. The purchase deed, signed before a notaire (the French public officer who authenticates real estate transfers and settles estates), can record unequal shares, for example 60 percent and 40 percent, when one partner contributes more of the purchase price. If the deed simply says one half each, that 50-50 split is presumed. Later claims that “I actually paid more” are extremely hard to prove without contemporaneous bank transfers showing who funded what, so each partner should wire their contribution from their own account and keep the records. The share size matters twice: it fixes your ownership while you both live, and after a death it fixes the portion of the house that falls into the deceased partner’s estate and is taxed in the hands of whoever receives it.
Day-to-day life in indivision follows rules that surprise many Americans used to joint tenancy. Each co-owner may use and enjoy the house as long as that use is compatible with the rights of the other, a principle set by Article 815-9 of the Civil Code, and routine management decisions can be taken by co-owners holding at least two thirds of the shares under Article 815-3 of the Civil Code, which allows that majority to carry out acts of administration, appoint a manager, and sell shared furniture. But selling, mortgaging, or leasing the house itself requires the agreement of all co-owners. And if one partner wants to sell only their own share to an outsider, the other partner holds a right of first refusal: Article 815-14 of the Civil Code requires the seller to notify the other co-owners of the price and conditions so they can step in and buy the share themselves. The official English-language guidance of the French administration on co-ownership between heirs, which describes the same mechanisms, is available on service-public.fr.
Couples who want stability can sign a convention d’indivision, a written co-ownership agreement that freezes the right to force a partition for a fixed period. Article 1873-1 of the Civil Code allows people who hold rights over shared property to sign agreements organizing how they exercise those rights, and Article 1873-3 of the Civil Code provides that such an agreement can run for a fixed term of up to five years, renewable by express decision, with partition available before the term only for serious cause, or for an indefinite term with partition available with notice. A five-year renewable agreement gives the couple breathing room, but it never protects the survivor after a death the way a tontine clause does, because the heirs of the deceased partner inherit the share and the agreement binds them only within its limits. In short, plain indivision, even improved by an agreement, organizes life together but does not transfer anything at death. For the transfer itself, couples turn to the tontine, the PACS, the will, or a combination of the three.
B. The tontine clause: how the survivor becomes the sole owner from day one
The tontine, also called a pacte tontinier or clause d’accroissement, is a survivorship pact that the notaire inserts directly into the purchase deed. Its legal fiction is striking: when the first of the two buyers dies, that buyer is deemed never to have bought at all, and the survivor is treated as having been the sole owner of the whole house since the original purchase. The heirs of the partner who died have no rights over the house whatsoever, because legally the house never entered the deceased’s estate. The French notarial profession describes this mechanism in detail on notaires.fr, noting that at the death of one buyer, the predeceased person is declared never to have purchased and only the surviving buyer is considered the owner from the beginning.
That dramatic effect comes with strict conditions, because French law treats the tontine as an aleatory contract, a gamble on who outlives whom. As the notarial profession warns, all buyers must each finance part of the property and must have a comparable life expectancy. If those conditions are missing, for example where an 80-year-old and a 30-year-old contribute wildly unequal amounts, the tontine can be reclassified as a disguised gift, a donation déguisée, which reopens the whole transfer to claims by the deceased’s heirs. This is not a theoretical risk. In a decision of 1 July 2026, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, appeal number 24-15.452, dealt with exactly this kind of attack: heirs asked the courts to reclassify a pacte tontinier contained in a 1998 sale deed as a gift and to revoke that gift, and the Court quashed the appeal court’s ruling for deciding the dispute on the basis of a contested private agreement without ordering the handwriting verification the heirs had demanded. The lesson for American buyers is concrete: fund your share with traceable money, keep the contributions balanced enough to reflect a genuine shared purchase, and expect that children from a prior relationship may one day hire a French lawyer to argue the tontine was really a gift that ate into their reserved inheritance share. The full decisions of the Court of Cassation are published in the official Bulletin, cited above by chamber, date, and appeal number.
During the couple’s lifetime, the tontine has a rigidity that Americans must weigh carefully. Unlike ordinary indivision, where Article 815 lets any co-owner force a partition at any time, the tontine buyers cannot go to court to force a division or a sale. As the notarial profession explains, unanimity is required for every decision, and if the buyers no longer get along or wish to separate, they must agree to sell the home together or agree that one buys out the other’s interest. The old maxim that no one must stay in co-ownership simply does not apply. A tontine between partners whose relationship might not last can therefore become a trap: neither can force an exit, and the survivor-takes-all effect still hangs over the property.
One more recent warning matters for couples who buy through a French property company, the société civile immobilière known as a SCI. On 9 April 2026, the Third Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, appeal number 25-12.992, ruled on a tontine clause written into the bylaws of a family SCI formed by two former unmarried partners. The Court held, and these are its exact words: “La clause de tontine ou d’accroissement stipulée dans les statuts d’une société civile est celle qui attribue au dernier survivant, de manière rétroactive, la propriété des parts incluses dans le pacte tontinier.” In English: a tontine or accrual clause in the bylaws of a civil company is one that gives the last survivor, retroactively, ownership of the shares covered by the tontine pact. The Court added that when such a clause covers all of the company’s shares, it concentrates them in a single hand upon death, retroactively to the company’s formation, which contradicts the rule that a company must be formed by two or more persons, and therefore the clause voids the entire company. For American couples, the message is clear: a tontine belongs in the purchase deed of the house itself, drafted by the notaire, and it must never be pasted across all the shares of an SCI without specialist structuring, or the whole company can collapse.
II. When one partner dies: inheritance rights, French death tax, and the American paperwork
A. Who inherits: no rights without a will, and why one joint will for two is void
Start from the default rule, because everything else is an exception to it. Article 731 of the Civil Code provides that an estate passes by law to the relatives and the surviving spouse of the deceased. An unmarried partner is neither a relative nor a spouse, so an unmarried partner inherits nothing. The deceased partner’s half of the house goes to their children first, or to their parents and siblings if there are no children, and those heirs can then demand the partition and forced sale described above. Many Americans assume that years of life together, joint bank accounts, or being named as a beneficiary on a United States account create some French inheritance right. They do not. Only three things give the surviving partner a claim on the French house: a tontine clause that kept the house out of the estate entirely, a marriage or a PACS combined with a will, or a will standing alone.
The PACS deserves a careful explanation because Americans often mistake it for a marriage. Article 515-1 of the Civil Code defines it, word for word, as follows: “Un pacte civil de solidarité est un contrat conclu par deux personnes physiques majeures, de sexe différent ou de même sexe, pour organiser leur vie commune.” In English: a civil solidarity pact is a contract signed by two adults, of different or the same sex, to organize their life together. It is a contract, not a marriage, and its property effects are limited. Unless the partners agree otherwise, each keeps ownership and control of their own property under Article 515-5 of the Civil Code, and crucially, a PACS partner is not an heir. The administration’s English-language page on the death of a PACS partner confirms the point on service-public.fr: without a will, the surviving partner receives nothing from the estate. What the PACS does change is the tax bill, as explained below, and it gives the survivor narrow housing rights, but the house share itself passes to the blood heirs unless a will says otherwise. Couples who want the full protection of marriage, including the surviving spouse’s reserved inheritance options, should compare the two regimes before buying; readers who are already married will find the spouse’s choices between full ownership of one quarter and lifelong use of the whole estate explained in our guide to what the American surviving spouse inherits from a French house.
The will is therefore the indispensable document, and French law defines it simply. Article 895 of the Civil Code states: “Le testament est un acte par lequel le testateur dispose, pour le temps où il n’existera plus, de tout ou partie de ses biens ou de ses droits et qu’il peut révoquer.” In English: a will is an act by which the testator disposes, for the time when they will no longer exist, of all or part of their property or rights, and which they may revoke. Two features of that definition decide the fate of many American couples. First, a will covers only what the testator is legally permitted to give away. Article 912 of the Civil Code explains the boundary, word for word: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” In English: the reserved share is the portion of the estate the law guarantees, clear of charges, to certain heirs called reserved heirs if they accept the succession, and the disposable portion is whatever is not reserved and could be transferred by gift. In practice, a partner with children can leave the surviving partner only the disposable portion, while a childless partner can leave everything. Americans with children from a prior relationship must have the notaire compute these fractions before relying on a will, because a will that ignores the reserved share will be cut back after death.
Second, each partner must write their own separate will, because one shared will for two people is void. Article 968 of the Civil Code states: “Un testament ne pourra être fait dans le même acte par deux ou plusieurs personnes soit au profit d’un tiers, soit à titre de disposition réciproque ou mutuelle.” In English: a will may not be made in the same instrument by two or more persons, whether for the benefit of a third party or as a reciprocal gift between them. The Court of Cassation enforces this prohibition strictly, even against couples who acted in good faith. On 4 July 2018, the First Civil Chamber, appeal number 17-22.934, rejected the claim of a surviving PACS partner whose late companion had signed a joint handwritten document leaving each other everything they had bought in co-ownership. The Court recalled, in its own words, that Article 968 prohibits joint wills and requires last wishes to be recorded in a unilateral act, in order to preserve freedom of testation and the ability to revoke, then held that the disputed document, signed by two people leaving each other all their property, could not count as a will. The survivor’s arguments based on privacy, family life, and property rights changed nothing. For American couples, the practical rule could not be simpler: never sign a single “mirror will” together, even if a well-meaning adviser suggests it. Each partner signs a separate handwritten will, each dated and fully written out by hand, or better, each partner has the French notaire draw up an authenticated will, and each will is registered so the survivor’s notaire can find it. Americans who already live in France and hold property in several countries should also coordinate the French will with their overall estate plan, including the choice of American law allowed by the European Succession Regulation, a mechanism described in our guide to choosing United States law in a will for a French house.
B. French death tax on the survivor and the American reporting that follows
Whoever receives the deceased partner’s share of the French house pays French transfer tax on it, and the rate depends entirely on the legal bond between the two partners. The scale starts from the rate tables of Article 777 of the General Tax Code, which sets the progressive rates for gratuitous transfers, but three situations matter in practice. First, the married spouse and the PACS partner pay nothing. Article 796-0 bis of the General Tax Code states, in full: “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” In English: the surviving spouse and the partner bound to the deceased by a civil solidarity pact are exempt from death transfer duties. This exemption, in force since 2007, is the single strongest tax reason for an American couple buying in France to sign a PACS if they will not marry: the same house share passing under a will costs the PACS survivor zero in French death tax. Second, the unmarried partner with no PACS faces the heaviest rate in French succession law. The notarial profession confirms that between concubins, the survivor pays 60 percent on the share received, after a token abatement of only 1,594 euros. On a 200,000 euro half-share, that is roughly 119,000 euros of tax, a figure that shocks most Americans and explains why advisers push unmarried buyers toward the tontine, the PACS, or both. Third, the tontine itself is taxed, but under its own dedicated rule. Article 754 A of the General Tax Code provides, word for word: “Les biens recueillis en vertu d’une clause insérée dans un contrat d’acquisition en commun selon laquelle la part du ou des premiers décédés reviendra aux survivants de telle sorte que le dernier vivant sera considéré comme seul propriétaire de la totalité des biens sont, au point de vue fiscal, réputés transmis à titre gratuit à chacun des bénéficiaires de l’accroissement. Cette disposition ne s’applique pas à l’habitation principale commune à deux acquéreurs lorsque celle-ci a une valeur globale inférieure à 76 000 €, sauf si le bénéficiaire opte pour l’application des droits de mutation par décès.” In English: property received under a clause in a joint purchase contract giving the first to die’s share to the survivors so that the last living person is deemed sole owner of everything is treated for tax purposes as transferred gratuitously to each person who benefits, except that this does not apply to the couple’s shared main home worth less than 76,000 euros in total, unless the beneficiary opts for death duties instead. In plain terms, the tontine survivor is taxed like someone who received a gift, at the rate matching their relationship with the deceased, which means zero for a married or PACSed survivor and 60 percent for a mere concubin, with one narrow escape: a modest shared main home under 76,000 euros is taxed only at the standard buyer-side transfer rate, capped by law at 5.81 percent, as the notarial profession explains.
The American side of the paperwork starts the moment the survivor receives the French house share, and it runs on United States rules that apply to citizens wherever they live. The Internal Revenue Service requires United States persons to report large gifts and bequests received from foreign persons, and its official guidance states the current line clearly: for gifts or bequests from a nonresident alien or a foreign estate, reporting is required only if the total received from that person or estate during the tax year exceeds 100,000 dollars, with each gift above 5,000 dollars identified separately, as published on irs.gov with the return itself described on the Form 3520 page. A French house share inherited or received through a tontine will almost always cross that threshold, so the American survivor should expect to file Form 3520, Annual Return To Report Transactions With Foreign Trusts and Receipt of Certain Foreign Gifts, separately from the income tax return. That filing is informational, not an extra tax, but the penalties for missing it are severe, which is why the French notaire’s settlement statement, the attestation immobilière proving the transfer, and a certified valuation of the house at the date of death should be sent to the American tax preparer as soon as the succession opens. Beyond reporting, the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide gifts and estates under its own thresholds and exemptions, and the interaction with the French tax already paid must be analyzed return by return, so the survivor needs coordinated advice from the French notaire settling the estate and a United States tax professional, ideally before signing anything that characterizes the transfer one way or the other.
A final practical checklist brings the whole structure together. Before signing the purchase deed, decide the shares and wire each contribution separately so the funding trail is clean. Ask the notaire to draft the tontine clause only if both partners contribute meaningfully and understand the lifetime unanimity lock-in, and never extend a tontine across all the shares of a property company. Sign a PACS if marriage is not planned, because the PACS alone converts a potential 60 percent death-tax bill into a full exemption. Write two separate wills, never one joint document, have them drawn up or checked by the notaire, and register them so they can be found. Keep every deed, PACS certificate, will reference, and bank slip with the house file, and give copies to the person who would handle your affairs. These steps cost a fraction of the house price, and each of them answers, in advance, the question the survivor would otherwise face alone: do I still have a home?
Conclusion
An unmarried American couple buying a house in France chooses, whether they realize it or not, between two futures for the survivor. Without planning, the default rules apply: indivision ownership that any heir can force to a sale, no inheritance rights for the partner, a will that can only give away the disposable portion, and a 60 percent death-tax rate on whatever the survivor receives. With planning, the same couple builds a layered shield: a co-ownership agreement that organizes daily life, a tontine clause that keeps the house out of the estate, a PACS that wipes out the French death tax, separate wills that carry out whatever the tontine and the PACS do not cover, and clean funding records plus timely American tax reporting that keep the survivor safe on both sides of the Atlantic. None of these tools works in isolation as well as they work together, and each of them must be drafted for your exact family situation, because children, prior marriages, and property owned elsewhere change every calculation. Bring this article to the notaire before you sign the purchase deed, walk through each scenario of death in turn, and leave the appointment with every document signed, registered, and filed where the survivor will find it.