KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can an American Use a French SCI to Own a Family Home?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can an American Use a French SCI to Own a Family Home?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

An American can participate in a French société civile immobilière (SCI), a French civil real-estate company, to buy and hold a family home. The SCI becomes the registered owner of the property, while the family members own shares in the company. That separation can make long-term management, financing and succession easier, but it does not make the house invisible to French or U.S. tax authorities, and it does not create limited liability in the way an American may expect from an LLC.

The right question is therefore not simply whether an American may own an SCI. The practical questions are: who will own the shares, who will manage the company, how will relatives occupy the house, what happens if a shareholder dies or wants out, and how will the arrangement be classified on a U.S. return? This guide explains those questions for an American family considering a French residence or second home. It is about settled-life property planning, not visa or immigration procedure. The legal rules below should be checked against the family’s nationality, tax residence, marital status, financing and intended use before the deed or articles of association are signed.

I. How does a French SCI work when an American family buys a home?

A. What does an SCI own, and what do the family members actually own?

A French SCI is not an English translation of an American trust, corporation or limited liability company. It is a civil company whose object is normally the acquisition, ownership, management and, in appropriate cases, leasing of real estate. The starting point is Article 1832 of the French Civil Code, which describes a company as a contract in which persons contribute property or work to a common enterprise and share its benefit or economy. The official wording begins: La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes. A conventional family SCI therefore has at least two shareholders, although French company law recognizes limited cases in which a company can be formed by one person.

Article 1845 of the French Civil Code defines the civil character of the company. In the wording verified for this article, Ont le caractère civil toutes les sociétés to which the law has not given another character because of their form, nature or object. A family SCI that buys one home and keeps it available to its shareholders is ordinarily designed around that civil purpose. Regular furnished rentals, hotel-like activity or a commercial operation can change the analysis and, in some circumstances, expose the SCI to corporate tax.

The most important ownership point is that the SCI, not the individual shareholders, signs the purchase deed and becomes the owner registered in the French land records. The family members receive shares. Those shares establish voting rights, rights to distributions, rights to information and an economic interest in the company. They do not give each shareholder a separate deed to a bedroom, floor or percentage of the house. A 40 percent shareholder does not own 40 percent of the kitchen. The shareholders own an interest in the legal person that owns the whole property.

That distinction can be useful for a family. The articles of association, or statuts, can organize who manages the property, how expenses are funded, how an adult child joins the group and what approvals are required before a sale or mortgage. It can also make a future transfer of shares more manageable than transferring the home itself, although the transfer is still a legal and tax event. The structure must be drafted in French and filed through the French registration system. A U.S. family normally has to assemble identity documents, civil-status records, powers of attorney, proof of address and, where required, sworn or certified French translations. The notary and the bank may ask for additional evidence of source of funds and beneficial ownership.

Before closing, the family should decide how the home will be occupied. A shareholder may occupy it under a written occupation agreement, a lease, or a right stated in the articles, depending on the facts. A casual family understanding is weak evidence when a marriage ends, a shareholder is incapacitated or one branch of the family disputes the arrangement. The agreement should address utilities, insurance, repairs, renovation approvals, local taxes, bookings, guests, pets, short-term rentals and the date on which occupation ends.

This point also matters between spouses. In a decision of 14 March 2018, first civil chamber, Cour de cassation, pourvoi no. 17-16.482, the court examined the protection of the family home where the property belonged to an SCI. The decision states that the protection applied only on the condition that the spouse-shareholder was authorized to occupy the property, using the words que celui-ci soit autorisé à occuper le bien. The court treated a shareholder’s status alone as insufficient where there was no lease, habitation right or agreement making the home available. A family SCI should therefore document occupation before a dispute arises.

The same reasoning prevents a common misunderstanding: putting a home in an SCI does not automatically make the other spouse’s rights stronger or weaker. The answer depends on the ownership of the shares, the matrimonial regime, the articles, the occupation agreement and the act that is being challenged. If the home is intended to be the couple’s residence, the notary should coordinate the company documents with the marriage and property documents. If it is a vacation home used by several households, the articles should say how calendars, expenses and disagreements are handled.

B. Who controls the SCI, and where do the risks sit?

Management is usually entrusted to a gérant, meaning the manager of the SCI. The manager may be a French resident, an American shareholder or another trusted person, subject to the company’s articles and the practical requirements of the bank, notary and tax administration. The manager should have a clear mandate for ordinary maintenance, insurance, utilities and tax filings, while major decisions should require a collective vote. The family should also name a replacement manager and define how a manager is removed if trust breaks down.

Article 1849 of the French Civil Code is central to third-party risk. It provides that, in dealings with outsiders, the manager binds the company for acts falling within the corporate purpose. The official text adds that statutory limits on the manager’s powers are not enforceable against third parties. In practical language, a private family rule saying “the manager may never sign a loan” may not protect the family against a lender who reasonably relies on an act within the SCI’s purpose. The articles and the banking mandate should therefore be drafted together, and the family should monitor the manager rather than rely on an undisclosed restriction.

Shareholders also do not receive a complete liability shield. Under Article 1857 of the French Civil Code, shareholders are indefinitely liable to third parties for the SCI’s debts in proportion to their share of the capital at the relevant date. The words verified in the official text are les associés répondent indéfiniment des dettes sociales. This is not the same as joint and several liability for the entire debt, but it is materially different from assuming that only the SCI’s assets are at risk.

Article 1858 adds an important procedural protection: a creditor must first pursue the legal person unsuccessfully before pursuing a shareholder. That rule does not erase the underlying liability. It means that the creditor normally starts with the SCI, then may proceed against the shareholders in proportion to their interests if the company cannot pay. In addition, a bank financing a family home may ask the shareholders for personal guarantees, a mortgage over other assets or proof of U.S. income. The family should read the loan guarantee independently from the SCI documents.

Good articles deal with deadlock before the first disagreement. They should set voting thresholds for a sale, refinancing, major renovations, a change from personal use to rental use, the appointment of a manager, a shareholder loan and a new shareholder. They should establish a valuation method for shares, a notice period, a mediation step and a route to court if no agreement is possible. They should also define what happens if an American shareholder moves to another state, loses capacity, divorces, becomes subject to a creditor claim or stops paying his or her share of expenses.

Share transfers are not as frictionless as transfers of publicly traded stock. Under Article 1861 of the French Civil Code, the default rule is that shares require the approval of all shareholders, although the articles can set a different majority or waive approval for certain family transfers. The official provision says: Les parts sociales ne peuvent être cédées qu’avec l’agrément de tous les associés. The articles should address transfers to a spouse, children, trusts, estates, a former spouse and a family holding entity rather than leaving the default to govern accidentally.

Article 1865 requires a share transfer to be recorded in writing and made opposable to the company and third parties through the required formalities. The exact rule begins: La cession de parts sociales doit être constatée par écrit. Because the law in force from 27 June 2026 added Article 1865-1, a transfer of shares in a real-estate-dominant legal person may also require an authentic instrument, an instrument countersigned by a lawyer, or an instrument prepared by an authorized accountant, subject to the text’s conditions. The notary or lawyer should confirm the required form on the date of the transfer; a family should not rely on an old template.

Death is another reason families consider an SCI, but it is not a shortcut around inheritance law. Article 1870 of the Civil Code states that the company normally continues with the deceased shareholder’s heirs or legatees unless the articles require approval or provide for continuation with other people. The text begins: La société n’est pas dissoute par le décès d’un associé. If heirs are not admitted as shareholders, Article 1870-1 gives them a claim to the value of the deceased person’s shares. The articles should be coordinated with a will, any choice-of-law planning, French forced-heirship rules and the family’s U.S. estate plan.

A sensible pre-signing file should contain the draft articles, a share table, the occupation agreement, the management and voting rules, the financing plan, a death and incapacity plan, a transfer schedule, an insurance schedule and a U.S. tax classification memo. It should also identify the existing property plan that the SCI will complement rather than duplicate. For a broader purchase process, the family can use this related French property checklist for an American buyer, while keeping the SCI-specific governance analysis separate.

II. What French and U.S. tax rules apply to an American-owned SCI?

A. How is the SCI taxed in France during ownership and sale?

The first French tax choice is whether the SCI remains in the ordinary income-tax regime or becomes subject to French corporate income tax, known as impôt sur les sociétés or IS. The choice should follow the actual use of the property. A family home used by shareholders is not the same as an SCI operating furnished holiday rentals or a commercial property business. The family should prepare a written use forecast before selecting the tax regime.

For an SCI that rents an unfurnished property and is not subject to IS, the French tax administration explains that the SCI files form 2072 while each shareholder reports his or her share of the result. The official SCI guidance from impots.gouv.fr states that, for an unfurnished rental, the partners are taxed according to their share of the SCI’s result. The result can be taxable even when cash is retained in the SCI to pay a mortgage or future repairs. A U.S. shareholder should therefore distinguish accounting cash, French taxable income and U.S. taxable income.

The statutory framework appears in Article 8 of the French General Tax Code, which includes members of certain civil companies in the pass-through rules when the statutory conditions are met. The French word quote-part means the portion attributed to a shareholder under the shareholding or applicable rights. That portion can require a French filing even if the property is held for the family and there is no distribution. A nonresident American may also have to deal with a French tax representative, a French bank account, local tax notices and document retention.

Furnished rental activity requires special care. The current impots.gouv.fr guidance for an SCI holding a furnished property treats furnished letting as a commercial activity and explains that the SCI files form 2065 and is subject to IS in the circumstances described. A family that occasionally lets the home to paying guests should obtain a current tax analysis before advertising it. A conclusion based on “we only rent it for a few weeks” may be wrong if the activity, services or receipts cross the relevant line.

Some civil companies can elect for the corporate regime. Article 239 of the General Tax Code provides the election framework and states that the option must generally be notified before the end of the third month of the relevant financial year. Article 206 of the General Tax Code sets out the corporate-tax rules and the treatment of civil companies carrying on commercial activity. An IS election can bring accounting and depreciation effects, but it can also produce a very different result when the home is sold or when cash is distributed. It should never be selected simply because an American expects “corporate” ownership to be more protective.

French local and wealth taxes remain separate questions. The SCI may owe or pass through the economic burden of taxe foncière, the annual property tax, and a family using the property may face taxe d’habitation rules depending on the property and use. A nonresident can also be liable for French wealth tax, called impôt sur la fortune immobilière or IFI, when the statutory threshold and valuation rules are met. The French tax administration explains on its nonresident IFI page that a person resident outside France can be taxed on French real estate and on the portion of company shares representing French real-estate rights. Holding the home through an SCI does not make that value disappear.

Exit planning must compare an SCI selling the property with shareholders selling their shares. For a property sale in the pass-through regime, Article 150 U of the General Tax Code applies the real-estate capital-gain rules to individuals and entities falling within the relevant provisions, including groups covered by Articles 8 to 8 ter. The French tax administration’s explanation of an SCI sale likewise says that the gain is calculated at the SCI level but taxed to the shareholders according to their interests in the relevant conditions.

A share sale is not the same transaction. A French SCI whose assets are mainly French real estate may be a real-estate-dominant legal person for transfer-tax purposes. Article 726 of the General Tax Code sets a 5 percent registration-duty rate for transfers of interests in such a person, subject to the statutory calculation and exceptions. The French nonresident service also identifies a 5 percent rate for transfers of interests in a real-estate-dominant legal person on its share-transfer filing page. The price, debt, valuation, timing and whether the family sells the property or the shares can change the result.

For a nonresident American, the French tax file should be modeled in euros and then translated into dollars for U.S. reporting. Currency movements can create a U.S. gain or loss even when the French calculation is stable. A home that is used personally may also qualify for a French residence-related exemption only if all legal conditions are satisfied; the existence of an SCI does not guarantee it. The notary, French accountant and U.S. tax preparer should agree on the transaction being reported before the sale agreement is signed.

B. What does the France–U.S. tax treaty and U.S. reporting add?

The France–U.S. income tax convention does not turn a French SCI into an American entity. It allocates taxing rights after the entity and the income have been classified under each country’s rules. The official treaty text is available through the IRS France tax treaty documents page, including the income-tax convention text.

Article 6 of the convention addresses income from real property. It provides that income from real property situated in a contracting state “may be taxed in that State.” Article 13 addresses capital gains and provides that gains from the alienation of real property situated in a contracting state may be taxed in that state. These provisions make it unsurprising that France can tax rent or a gain connected with French real estate. They do not decide whether a payment is rent, a dividend, a partnership allocation, a shareholder benefit or a gain on shares. That characterization still depends on the SCI’s French status and its U.S. classification.

The treaty also contains a specific rule for an ownership interest that gives a resident the enjoyment of real property held by a company. Article 6 recognizes that income derived from direct use, letting or another form of that right may be taxed in the state where the property is situated to the extent that domestic law would tax it. This is one reason an occupation agreement matters. The family should record whether the American shareholder pays rent, receives a taxable benefit, contributes to expenses or holds a contractual right of use.

For U.S. purposes, the SCI’s French legal label is not enough. The IRS explains that certain business entities can be classified for federal tax purposes as a partnership, a corporation or, for a single owner, a disregarded entity under the check-the-box framework. The relevant IRS classification guidance should be read with the entity’s articles, number of members, liability features, election history and actual operation. An American should obtain a written U.S. classification conclusion before filing the first return, not copy the treatment of another French family’s SCI.

That classification drives information reporting. The IRS states in its Form 8938 questions and answers that foreign real estate held directly is generally not itself a specified foreign financial asset, but an interest in a foreign corporation or partnership that owns the real estate can be reportable if the applicable threshold is exceeded. The same page lists an interest in a foreign partnership among the examples. In plain language, direct ownership of a French home and ownership of shares in an SCI can produce different U.S. reporting even when the family lives in the same house.

If the SCI is treated as a foreign partnership for U.S. purposes, a U.S. person may have a Form 8865 obligation. The IRS explains on its Form 8865 page that the form reports, among other matters, controlled foreign partnerships, certain transfers to a foreign partnership and acquisitions or dispositions of partnership interests. The filing threshold depends on the category of filer, ownership and transactions. The family should keep capital contributions, shareholder loans, distributions and share transfers in a format that a U.S. preparer can use.

If the SCI is classified as a foreign corporation, different forms and ownership thresholds may apply. The IRS describes Form 5471 as the information return used by certain U.S. citizens and residents who are officers, directors or shareholders in certain foreign corporations. The official Form 5471 page is a starting point, not a conclusion that every SCI must file it. The answer depends on the U.S. classification and the family’s ownership and control.

FATCA and FBAR are separate from the French company’s annual French filing. If the SCI maintains a French bank account, the family must analyze who has a financial interest in or signature authority over that account. FinCEN states on its FBAR purpose page that a U.S. person generally files an FBAR when the aggregate value of reportable foreign financial accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time in the calendar year. The exact application to an SCI account depends on the account holder, the U.S. person’s role and the applicable exceptions. Form 8938 and FBAR are not interchangeable.

The PFIC rules also require disciplined classification. The IRS describes a PFIC as a foreign corporation meeting an income test or an asset test, with the thresholds generally based on passive income and passive assets, in its Form 8621-A instructions. A French SCI is not automatically a PFIC merely because it is foreign or because it owns a home. If it is classified as a partnership, PFIC analysis is not the starting point. If it is classified as a corporation and its activity or assets raise the statutory tests, the question must be analyzed on the actual facts. This is why a French mutual fund analysis should not be copied into an SCI file.

Finally, the SCI’s shares can become part of a cross-border estate. French succession rules may govern the shares or the French property depending on the deceased person’s residence, nationality, a valid choice of law and the applicable European and treaty framework. French forced-heirship rights may protect certain children in situations where a U.S. estate plan would use a different approach. A transfer of shares during life can also be a French gift, a U.S. gift, a reportable foreign transfer or all three, depending on the parties and classification. The family should coordinate its French will, any U.S. revocable trust, beneficiary designations, marital agreement and SCI articles before making a gift or changing share percentages.

A practical U.S.–France closing file should therefore answer seven questions in writing:

  • Who owns each share, and who is the beneficial owner if a nominee, trust or holding company is involved?
  • Is the SCI’s U.S. classification a partnership, corporation, disregarded entity or another treatment, and was any election filed?
  • Who may occupy the home, under which written agreement, and who pays each category of expense?
  • Who is the manager, what acts require a vote, and what happens if the family is deadlocked?
  • What French returns, local taxes, IFI analysis and capital-gain reporting are expected?
  • Which U.S. forms may apply, including Form 8938, Form 8865, Form 5471, FBAR or a PFIC form, and why?
  • What happens on death, divorce, incapacity, a forced sale, a shareholder’s withdrawal or the eventual sale of the home?

These answers should be consistent. It is dangerous, for example, to draft French articles that describe a shareholder’s right to occupy the house while telling the U.S. preparer that the shareholder has no economic interest, or to report the SCI as a partnership in the United States while the French books and loan documents treat it as a commercial corporation. The documents may be written in different languages, but the facts must tell the same story.

Conclusion

Yes, an American can use a French SCI to own a family home, and the structure can be valuable when several relatives need a durable ownership and management framework. Its benefits come from organized share ownership, written occupation rights, tailored governance and planned succession. Its costs are equally real: shareholders can have unlimited liability, transfers require formalities, French tax continues to apply to French real estate, and U.S. reporting depends on the SCI’s federal classification rather than its French name.

The safe sequence is to define the family’s use of the home, model a direct purchase against an SCI purchase, draft the articles and occupation agreement, obtain the notary’s title and financing review, classify the entity for U.S. tax purposes, and then coordinate the estate plan. If the family will rent the property, sell shares, make gifts or place the shares in a trust or holding company, the tax and reporting analysis should be refreshed before the transaction. An SCI is a legal tool for a family plan; it is not a substitute for the plan.

We can review the French SCI structure, the purchase documents, the occupation rights and the cross-border risks before you sign.

📄 Official circular