KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Ben Delo Sued Interpol in Lyon Over His Deleted Red Notice: Why the Court Upheld Immunity

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Ben Delo Sued Interpol in Lyon Over His Deleted Red Notice: Why the Court Upheld Immunity

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 14 April 2026, the interim-relief judge of the Lyon judicial court dismissed the case a British cryptocurrency founder had brought against Interpol in the very city where the organisation has its seat. The claimant, BitMEX co-founder Ben Delo, had asked the French court to order Interpol to hand over all the personal data it still held on him, under a penalty of 500 euros per day of delay, after a United States red notice issued against him was lifted in 2021 but border stops kept happening — in Singapore in September 2024, in the United Kingdom in October 2024 and in the United Arab Emirates in April 2025, according to his submissions. The judge did not examine a single file: he held that Interpol enjoys immunity from jurisdiction in France, that none of the three narrow exceptions of the 2008 headquarters agreement applied, and that the existence of Interpol’s own independent files commission — which had answered late but had answered — meant the European right to a tribunal did not require setting that immunity aside. The claims were declared inadmissible, the claimant was ordered to pay the costs, and his claim for legal expenses was rejected. The ruling was given at first instance, so an appeal within fifteen days remained open. As his name fills British headlines this week — a £20 million High Court claim filed against the BitMEX operator was reported on 13 October 2026, and his £36 million donation to Reform UK is a matter of public record — the Lyon decision deserves a wider audience: it is the clearest recent statement by a French court of what happens when a foreign national tries to sue Interpol itself before the courts of its host country, and why that road almost always ends at the immunity wall. The analysis below is general in scope: it describes the checks and remedies available in any comparable situation and does not describe the personal situation of the claimant, about which this article makes no finding.

I. A deleted Interpol red notice that keeps stopping travellers at borders: what happened after the American case ended

Everything in the Lyon case starts in the United States, with the prosecution of a cryptocurrency derivatives platform, and continues long after the American file was closed. Understanding that chronology matters, because the Lyon judge’s answer turns on it: the red notice was genuinely deleted, the American authorities themselves asked for its deletion, and yet the traveller kept being stopped. That gap — between deletion in Lyon and persistence in national computers — is the real subject of part I.

A. From the 2020 American charges to the 2022 guilty plea: how a red notice is born, lifted, and supposed to die

The Lyon decision records that the claimant, a British citizen and co-founder of the BitMEX cryptocurrency derivatives platform, was prosecuted in the United States from 1 October 2020, when the American Department of Justice opened criminal proceedings against the platform’s three co-founders on the ground that BitMEX did not comply with the American Bank Secrecy Act for lack of an anti-money-laundering programme. In that framework, the American authorities had Interpol publish a red notice against him — that is, in the words used by the court, a request addressed to law-enforcement services worldwide to locate a person and provisionally arrest him pending extradition. The American proceedings then followed their course: on 24 February 2022, the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York announced that Arthur Hayes and Benjamin Delo, founders and executives of what it called a purportedly offshore cryptocurrency derivatives exchange, had pleaded guilty to violating the Bank Secrecy Act by wilfully failing to establish, implement and maintain an anti-money-laundering programme at BitMEX, each agreeing under the plea deals to pay a $10 million criminal fine. The pleas were entered before United States District Judge John G. Koeltl. Meanwhile, and this is the turning point of the whole story, the United States had already asked Interpol to switch the notice off: the decision notes that on 1 April 2021 the United States prosecutor’s office notified the claimant’s American counsel that the source country was lifting its request for publication of a red notice against him. A red notice requested by Washington, withdrawn at Washington’s own request, deleted from Interpol’s files in 2021 at the American authorities’ request — on paper, the file was dead. Anyone advising a client in this position would regard deletion by the source country as the decisive event, because Interpol’s system is built on the principle that the country that requested publication controls its fate: when the source withdraws, the General Secretariat deletes. The Lyon file confirms that this deletion genuinely happened; the Commission for the Control of Interpol’s Files later stated in writing that the red notice concerning the claimant had been deleted from Interpol’s files in 2021 at the request of the American authorities. For a foreign national reading this in London, Dubai or Singapore, the lesson of this first act looks reassuring: win or settle the underlying case, get the source country to withdraw, and Interpol deletes. It is the second act that destroys the reassurance. A deletion recorded in Lyon does not automatically propagate to every national database that once ingested the notice, and border police do not query Lyon in real time — they query their own systems. That is why the same decision that records the 2021 deletion also records stops in three countries in 2024 and 2025, and why the claimant turned, in November 2024, to the only body that can tell him what Lyon still holds: the files commission.

B. Stopped in Singapore, London and Dubai after deletion: why a withdrawn notice survives in national police computers

Before the Lyon judge, the claimant’s counsel explained that his client had been stopped several times during international travel after the red notice had been lifted by the American authorities — in Singapore in September 2024, in the United Kingdom in October 2024 and in the United Arab Emirates in April 2025. The court records these assertions as submissions, not as established facts, and that caution matters: no finding of wrongful arrest is made anywhere in the decision, no official source has established any intrusion or damage, and the contracts signed by the parties take precedence over any general analysis. But the pattern described is instantly recognisable to any practitioner of cross-border criminal law, and it has a precise technical explanation. An Interpol red notice is not an international arrest warrant enforceable as such; it is a voluntary cooperation signal, and each member country decides what legal effect to give it in its own system. When a notice circulates, national central bureaus copy its content into their own wanted-persons and border-control databases. When Interpol deletes the notice in Lyon, member countries are expected to update their national bases — but nothing in the system forces simultaneity, and stale copies persist. The Lyon decision itself illustrates the mechanism working as designed, only slowly: in its message of 23 September 2025, the files commission stated that the claimant was no longer the subject of any notice or decision, that the red notice had been deleted in 2021 at the American authorities’ request, and — significantly — that contact had been taken with the authorities of the countries in which the claimant had been subjected to border checks so as to remind them of the deletion of his data and urge them to update their national databases accordingly. In other words, even after deletion, enforcement depends on each country refreshing its own files, and the traveller discovers the gap at the airport. This is the first practical lesson of the case for any reader with an Interpol past: deletion in Lyon is necessary but not sufficient, and the months or years that follow must be spent verifying, country by country, that national mirrors have been purged. The claimant’s next step was the logical one — asking Lyon directly what it still held on him — and it is that request, and the fourteen months of silence and partial answers that followed, that led to the référé action. On 6 November 2024 he filed a request for access to his personal data processed in Interpol’s information system, under article 29 of the Statute of the Commission for the Control of Interpol’s Files; the commission acknowledged receipt and confirmed admissibility by email on 15 November 2024. What followed reads like a textbook illustration of an access right honoured in principle and starved in practice: a follow-up on 24 March 2025 after the commission’s own four-month deadline had expired without a reply; an 18 April 2025 response invoking a large volume of requests and inviting patience; a formal notice on 23 April 2025 to answer before 30 April; a further follow-up on 8 May 2025; then, on 23 September 2025, the substantive response described above; and finally, on 21 November 2025, a message stating that after verification no personal data concerning the claimant appeared in Interpol’s criminal files, so the request was now without object — while the claimant’s French counsel, by registered letter of 13 October 2025, had maintained the request for immediate access. Fourteen months between request and final answer, against a rule that Interpol itself states publicly: which explains in substance that access requests are generally decided within four months of the admissibility confirmation, with a written decision sent to the applicant, as its official guidance puts it. Faced with that record, the claimant’s lawyers chose the fastest French procedural weapon available: a référé before the president of the judicial court of the organisation’s home city, seeking preservation measures for an imminent harm and the cessation of what they characterised as a manifestly unlawful disturbance. Readers unfamiliar with French urgent procedure should note that this was a plausible, even elegant, strategy — and part II explains why it collided with a wall that no urgency can move.

II. Suing Interpol in the city where it sits: why the Lyon judge upheld the organisation’s immunity

The writ was served on 9 September 2025 by a court commissioner’s report, and the hearing took place on 9 February 2026, with the decision deferred first to 16 March and then to 14 April. As article 484 of the Code of Civil Procedure recalls, “L’ordonnance de référé est une décision provisoire rendue à la demande d’une partie, l’autre présente ou appelée, dans les cas où la loi confère à un juge qui n’est pas saisi du principal le pouvoir d’ordonner immédiatement les mesures nécessaires” — provisional by design, and powerless against a defendant the court has no jurisdiction over. Interpol never appeared: service was recorded as an assignment “à étude”, the instrument having been refused. The claimant, invoking the rule of article 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure that “L’action est ouverte à tous ceux qui ont un intérêt légitime au succès ou au rejet d’une prétention”, asked the interim-relief judge to declare him admissible and well-founded, to hold that the conduct of Interpol’s files commission created a risk of imminent harm, to hold that the commission’s violation of its own statute generated a manifestly unlawful disturbance, and consequently to order Interpol to grant him access to all of his personal data in its possession, under a penalty of 500 euros per day of delay, with the court retaining the power to assess that penalty — a liquidation governed, for any penalty, by article L131-4 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures, under which “Le taux de l’astreinte définitive ne peut jamais être modifié lors de sa liquidation” — plus costs. In support, counsel argued that the jurisdictional immunity enjoyed by Interpol, an international organisation, had to yield to the right to a tribunal flowing from article 6, paragraph 1, of the European Convention on Human Rights — the provision under which everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law, (article 6, paragraph 1 of the Convention), in the version of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms as amended by Protocol No. 15 — invoking the European Court of Human Rights judgments of 18 February 1999 in the cases brought against Germany. The judge’s answer is a model of the French method on international-organisation immunity: immunity first, exceptions strictly construed, and the European right to a tribunal channelled through a single, demanding test. Only the judge decides, and here the judge kept the door shut.

A. Immunity is the rule in France: the 2008 headquarters agreement and its three exhaustively listed exceptions

Under French law, Interpol’s immunity does not come from courtesy; it comes from a treaty-level bargain that exchanged a permanent seat on French soil for freedom from unilateral judicial interference. Article 2 of Interpol’s own statute gives the organisation its mission — ensuring and developing the widest possible mutual assistance between criminal police authorities, and establishing institutions capable of contributing to the prevention and punishment of ordinary crime — and article 5 of the agreement between the Government of the French Republic and Interpol on the organisation’s seat in France, signed at Lyon on 14 April 2008 and at Paris on 24 April 2008, and approved in France by Law No. 2009-411 of 16 April 2009 authorising approval of that agreement, provides the shield. Published in France by Decree No. 2009-1098 of 4 September 2009, its article 5 states the rule in one sentence and then exhausts the exceptions: immunity from jurisdiction applies save for express contractual waiver, civil claims for motor-vehicle damage, and counterclaims to proceedings the organisation itself brought, with a second paragraph allowing the organisation expressly to waive its immunity in a particular case. Three cases, no more: an express contractual waiver, a motor-vehicle civil claim, a counterclaim to proceedings the organisation itself started — plus an express ad hoc waiver, which Interpol, not having appeared, plainly had not granted. None of them covers a data-access claim brought by a former red-notice subject, however urgent the travel plans behind it. The Lyon judge therefore stated the principle without hesitation: Interpol is an international organisation benefiting as a matter of principle from immunity from jurisdiction in France. Procedurally, that immunity operates as a plea in bar — what French procedure calls a fin de non-recevoir, defined by article 122 of the Code of Civil Procedure as “Constitue une fin de non-recevoir tout moyen qui tend à faire déclarer l’adversaire irrecevable en sa demande, sans examen au fond, pour défaut de droit d’agir”. The protection also reaches enforcement: article 6 of the same headquarters agreement shields the organisation’s property and assets, wherever located and by whomever held, from seizure, confiscation, requisition, expropriation and any other administrative or judicial constraint. The consequence is radical and often misunderstood by foreign litigants: once immunity is established and no exception applies, the judge declares the claims inadmissible without any examination of the merits — no ruling on whether data remains, no ruling on whether the files commission breached its deadlines, no ruling on whether the border stops were linked to surviving data. This is exactly what happened in Lyon, and it explains the shape of the operative part of the decision, which finds immunity, declares the penalty-backed access order inadmissible, declares inadmissible the request for proof of definitive deletion by a court commissioner’s report or any other irrefutable means, rejects the claim for legal costs, and orders the claimant to pay the costs. The only escape route the claimant invoked was therefore the European one: that immunity as applied here would violate the right to a tribunal. French courts take that argument seriously — they have a precise test for it — but as the next section shows, the test is built to protect immunities, not to dissolve them, whenever the organisation offers a genuine internal remedy.

B. The only way through immunity: the right to a tribunal, the Strasbourg test, and why an independent files commission was enough

The doctrinal frame comes from Strasbourg, not Paris. On 18 February 1999 the European Court of Human Rights gave its two leading judgments on the immunity of international organisations, Waite and Kennedy v. Germany (application No. 26083/94) and Beer and Regan v. Germany, both concerning employment disputes with the European Space Agency. Their teaching, faithfully echoed by the Lyon judge, is that granting immunity to international organisations is legitimate in principle — the decision restates the Strasbourg rationale that such privileges and immunities are indispensable to the proper working of those organisations, free from unilateral interference by any single government — but that the immunity must not empty the right to a tribunal of its substance: where the persons concerned have reasonable alternative means to protect their rights effectively, notably an independent internal tribunal, the restriction on access to a court pursues a legitimate aim and remains proportionate. The Lyon decision applies that test step by step. First, it identifies the alternative remedy: a files commission established under article 36 of Interpol’s statute, independent, whose purpose includes examining requests for access to data, and for rectification or erasure of data processed in the organisation’s information system, and ruling on those requests, under articles 3 and 4 of its own statute. Second, it verifies that the claimant actually used it: he filed his access request on 6 November 2024, the commission acknowledged receipt and confirmed admissibility on 15 November 2024, exchanges followed through 2025, and the commission ultimately answered — on 23 September 2025 with the deletion confirmation and the outreach to the countries of the border checks, then on 21 November 2025 with the statement that, after verification, no personal data concerning him appeared in Interpol’s criminal files and the request was therefore without object. Third, it weighs the admitted defect — the commission had not ruled within the four-month period set by article 40 of its statute — against the outcome: given the need to protect Interpol’s cross-border crime-fighting mission, the existence of an independent body open to individual access requests, and the effectiveness — late but real — of that mechanism, there was no ground to set Interpol’s jurisdictional immunity aside under article 6, paragraph 1, of the European Convention on Human Rights. Late but real effectiveness: that single finding is the whole ball game for future claimants. A delay of ten months beyond the statutory period, repeated follow-ups, a formal notice — none of it was enough to convert an available and eventually functioning remedy into the absence of a remedy. The claims were therefore declared inadmissible, the losing claimant was ordered to pay the costs, and his application for a contribution to legal expenses was rejected, the judge recalling the rule of article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure under which “Le juge condamne la partie tenue aux dépens ou qui perd son procès à payer” the other side a sum for expenses not included in the costs. Three practical consequences follow for any foreign national contemplating the same Lyon strategy. First, the interim-relief judge was the right judge but the wrong target: French urgent procedure gives the president of the judicial court broad powers — under article 835 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the judge “peuvent toujours, même en présence d’une contestation sérieuse, prescrire en référé les mesures conservatoires ou de remise en état qui s’imposent, soit pour prévenir un dommage imminent, soit pour faire cesser un trouble manifestement illicite”, and article L131-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures confirms that “Tout juge peut, même d’office, ordonner une astreinte pour assurer l’exécution de sa décision” — but those powers presuppose a defendant subject to the court’s jurisdiction, and immunity removes the defendant before urgency is even examined. Second, the files-commission route, slow as it is, is not optional scenery: it is the remedy Strasbourg looks at, so a claimant must exhaust it meticulously, keep every acknowledgment of receipt, diary the four-month deadline from the admissibility confirmation, and build the paper trail of delay — because only a remedy shown to be unavailable or systematically ineffective could reopen the article 6 door. Third, the parallel national track must never be neglected: since stale national copies are what stop travellers, simultaneous requests to the data-protection authorities and border agencies of each country of transit, asking for confirmation of updating after Interpol’s deletion, do more for the next journey than any Lyon writ. Readers facing extradition or surrender proceedings connected with an old notice will find the broader French framework — investigating-chamber review, bars to surrender, and the defences that actually succeed — set out in this firm’s analysis of extradition procedure before the French investigating chamber. And those following the British dimension of the underlying business story should keep it in its proper conditional frame: on 13 October 2026 The Guardian reported that the BitMEX operator, HDR Global Trading Limited, is facing a £20 million claim alleging that the company sold unsuitable financial products in the UK, with the claimant contending that the platform offered crypto derivatives to British investors without Financial Conduct Authority approval and contending that under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 such contracts are void — allegations the court has not determined, reported here solely to explain why the name is in the news, and which change nothing to the Lyon immunity analysis. The ordonnance itself was given at first instance and, like all interim-relief orders, “peut être frappée d’appel”, as article 490 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides, with a fifteen-day time limit — “Le délai d’appel ou d’opposition est de quinze jours” — so the immunity wall described here stands subject to whatever a higher court may one day say, and only a higher court can move it.

Conclusion

The Lyon ruling of 14 April 2026 leaves a clear, two-line map for anyone whose past includes an Interpol file. First, deletion by the source country ends the Interpol file but does not empty the national mirrors: the traveller’s work then moves, country by country, to border and data-protection authorities, because it is the stale national copy — not the Lyon database — that triggers the airport stop. Second, suing the organisation at its seat almost always fails at the threshold: immunity under the headquarters agreement is the rule, its exceptions are exhaustive and irrelevant to data claims, and the European right to a tribunal is satisfied, even after long delay, by an independent files commission that eventually answers. Late but real effectiveness keeps the immunity intact, and the unsuccessful claimant pays the costs. For lawyers, the file is a lesson in sequencing: exhaust the commission remedy with a documented paper trail, run the national deletion requests in parallel, and treat the référé as a complement — never the centrepiece — of the strategy. And for readers tempted to read the outcome as an absolution of anyone’s conduct, the decision says the opposite of that: it decides nothing on the merits, establishes no wrongdoing and no exoneration, records no officially confirmed intrusion or damage, and leaves every contract and every pending claim exactly where it found them. Immunity is a shield against the forum, not a judgment on the facts — and only the competent judge, seized of the right defendant, can give that judgment.

📄 Official circular