For the tens of thousands of British nationals who live in France under the Withdrawal Agreement, the summer of 2026 has brought an uncomfortable reality. The five-year cartes de séjour (residence cards) issued in 2020 and 2021 under the Withdrawal Agreement are expiring in waves, and the préfectures are struggling with the resulting flood of renewal applications. Applicants across the country report that their online dossiers sit in a queue for months without any decision, that average processing times have grown from one or two months to four months — and six in more complex cases — and that some applicants have waited six months or more before receiving their new card, in the meantime travelling to the United Kingdom on expired cards and struggling with employers, banks and border checks. This article explains, for English-speaking readers, what the Withdrawal Agreement actually protects, what a récépissé (receipt acknowledging the application) and an attestation de prolongation d’instruction (extension-of-review certificate) really do, why the silence of the préfecture after four months creates a décision implicite de rejet (implied refusal decision) even when the administration is still working on the file, and how to challenge a refusal — express or implied — before the French administrative courts, step by step and deadline by deadline. If your renewal is blocked and a deadline is approaching, an immigration lawyer in Paris can review your file and act quickly; see our overview of what an immigration lawyer in Paris can do for your residence permit case.
I. The Withdrawal Agreement Status: Permanent Residence and the Ten-Year “Séjour Permanent” Card
A. Five Years of Lawful Residence and a Card Delivered de Plein Droit
The rights of British nationals in France rest on the Agreement on the withdrawal of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland from the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community of 17 October 2019 (the Withdrawal Agreement), which has been part of French law since 1 February 2020, and on the Décret n° 2020-1417 of 19 November 2020, the French decree implementing the Withdrawal Agreement for entry, residence, professional activity and social rights. The cornerstone is Article 15(1) of the Withdrawal Agreement, as applied by the administrative courts: “Les citoyens de l’Union et les ressortissants du Royaume-Uni, ainsi que les membres de leur famille respective, qui ont séjourné légalement dans l’État d’accueil conformément au droit de l’Union pendant une période ininterrompue de cinq ans ou pendant la période indiquée à l’Article 17 de la directive 2004/38/CE, acquièrent le droit de séjourner de manière permanente dans l’État d’accueil” — Union citizens and United Kingdom nationals who have resided lawfully in the host state under EU law for an uninterrupted period of five years acquire the right to reside there permanently. In practice, most British nationals who were already living in France before the end of the transition period on 31 December 2020 had long since completed the five years needed, and therefore hold permanent residence rights that do not depend on any card: the card is, technically, only proof of a status that exists independently of it.
That is precisely why the French decree creates a specific document. Article 21 of the decree provides that “un titre de séjour d’une durée de validité de dix ans portant la mention « Séjour permanent – Article 50 TUE/Article 18(1) Accord de retrait du Royaume-Uni de l’UE » est délivré de plein droit” — a ten-year residence document bearing the mention “Permanent residence – Article 50 TEU / Article 18(1) of the Withdrawal Agreement” is issued as of right — to British nationals who either held a permanent residence card before 1 January 2021 or who have resided in France for five years under the conditions of Articles 13 to 19 of the decree. The courts have applied this strictly in the applicant’s favour. In CAA Toulouse, 23 July 2026, n° 24TL01660, a young British national born in 2000 and living in France since the age of one had been refused the card by the prefect of the Gard on the ground that his criminal record made him a threat to a fundamental interest of French society. The administrative court of appeal rejected the prefect’s appeal and upheld the first-instance judgment that had annulled the refusal and ordered the prefect to issue the “Séjour permanent” card within two months: the offences had all been committed before 1 January 2021, more than three years had passed without any new offence, and the young man lived with his mother, was in a relationship with a French national and had worked since November 2020. The case illustrates both that the ten-year permanent card is the default outcome for qualifying British nationals and that the prefecture carries a heavy burden when it wants to refuse it.
Article 18(1) of the Withdrawal Agreement allows the host state to require that beneficiaries apply for a new residence status and a document attesting to it — which is what France did. This is why the card is renewed rather than re-acquired: the decree provides that the permanent card is “renouvelé de plein droit” — renewed as of right — unless the applicant’s presence constitutes a threat to public order, as CAA Bordeaux, 26 February 2026, n° 25BX01572 recalls. Renewal is therefore not a discretionary administrative favour: it is the normal, automatic outcome for a British national who continues to reside in France. The practical consequence for the thousands of expiring cards in 2026 is simple: a delay in processing does not extinguish the underlying right, and an eventual refusal must be grounded on one of the narrow legal grounds examined below, not on backlogs or staffing problems at the préfecture. If the prefecture’s silence or inaction is what blocks your renewal, the legal levers described in the second part of this article apply; for guidance on the underlying renewal procedure itself, an immigration lawyer in Paris can explain what your specific situation requires.
B. The Limits: Public Order, the 1 July 2021 Deadline and the Individual Assessment
Permanent residence under the Withdrawal Agreement is not absolute. Two categories of restrictions matter in practice. First, Article 28 of the decree allows entry and the delivery of residence documents to be refused “si la présence du demandeur constitue une menace pour l’ordre public” — if the applicant’s presence constitutes a threat to public order — and, where the conduct at issue predates 1 January 2021, the refusal requires that the conduct represent “une menace réelle, actuelle et suffisamment grave pour un intérêt fondamental de la société” — a real, current and sufficiently serious threat to a fundamental interest of society. The courts police this threshold closely. The administrative authority “ne saurait se fonder sur la seule existence d’une infraction à la loi” — cannot rely on the mere existence of an offence — and must examine all the circumstances of the case, including the length of residence, the family and economic situation and the degree of integration, as CAA Toulouse, 23 July 2026, n° 24TL01660 restates. The same standard applied in CAA Paris, 3 October 2023, n° 23PA00821: a British national who had lived in France for thirty-four years since the age of three had been refused the Withdrawal Agreement card on the strength of several mentions in the police records file (the TAJ), but — as the court noted, “il n’est pas contesté que M. C… n’a fait l’objet d’aucune condamnation pour ces faits” — it was undisputed that he had never been convicted for those facts. The court annulled the refusal and ordered the prefect to deliver the requested card within two months. Mentions in police records are not convictions, and a refusal based on them alone cannot stand.
The second restriction concerns time. Article 8 of the decree required British nationals who were already resident in France before 1 January 2021 to file their application for the card by 1 July 2021. Late applications are possible only where the applicant can show “motifs légitimes” — legitimate reasons — for missing the deadline. CAA Bordeaux, 26 February 2026, n° 25BX01572 illustrates both sides of this rule. A British national born in Montserrat who had lived in France since 1987 applied only in February 2022, more than seven months after the deadline, and was refused the permanent card as late. The court upheld that part of the refusal, holding that the fact of having obtained a mere filing receipt did not amount to acceptance of the late application, and that illiteracy and correspondence from the family allowance office did not constitute legitimate reasons. But the same case shows the safety net: because the applicant had lived in France for most of his life, was well integrated in his village, worked as a carpenter and no longer had any real ties to Montserrat — a small island partly uninhabitable since the Soufrière Hills volcano — the court found that the refusal to grant him a carte de séjour portant la mention « vie privée et familiale » (private and family life card) breached Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. It annulled the refusal, ordered the prefecture to issue the card within two months and ordered the deletion of his Schengen Information System alert within fifteen days. The lesson for British applicants: the Withdrawal Agreement route is the primary one, but a refusal does not necessarily exhaust the possibilities, and the private and family life route can repair the damage — including the SIS alert that a refused British national may have attracted.
Conversely, the courts do not protect every applicant. CAA Douai, 18 March 2026, n° 25DA01495 concerned a British national, in France since the age of eleven, who had accumulated seven criminal convictions between 2022 and 2024 for drug trafficking, driving without a licence and endangerment, and who had been imprisoned from October 2024 to June 2025. The prefect of the Nord had refused the ten-year permanent card, issued an obligation de quitter le territoire français (OQTF — an order to leave French territory) without any voluntary-departure period and imposed a one-year re-entry ban. The court upheld all of it: his presence constituted “une menace pour l’ordre public” — a threat to public order — and the refusal of a voluntary-departure period was legal under Article L. 612-1 of the CESEDA (which grants a thirty-day voluntary-departure period as a rule) read together with Article L. 612-2, which allows the administration to refuse that period when the behaviour of the foreign national constitutes a threat to public order. The comparison between this case and the Toulouse and Paris cases is instructive: what separates a lawful refusal from an unlawful one is not the existence of a criminal past, but its timing, its gravity and its current character, assessed individually. A British applicant facing a refusal on public-order grounds should therefore gather the full evidence of his or her personal situation — length of residence, family ties, work, integration — because the courts weigh exactly those elements.
II. Renewing Your Card in 2026: Delays, the Récépissé and the Implied Refusal After Four Months
A. The Provisional Documents: Récépissé and Attestation de Prolongation d’Instruction
When you file a renewal application, the law protects your position while the file is being examined. Article L. 431-3 of the CESEDA (the French Immigration and Asylum Code) provides that “La détention d’un document provisoire délivré à l’occasion d’une demande de titre de séjour, d’une attestation de demande d’asile ou d’une autorisation provisoire de séjour autorise la présence de l’étranger en France sans préjuger de la décision définitive qui sera prise au regard de son droit au séjour” — holding a provisional document issued in connection with a residence permit application authorises the foreign national’s presence in France without prejudging the final decision on the right to reside. For applications filed at the counter, Article R. 431-12 of the CESEDA provides that “L’étranger admis à souscrire une demande de délivrance ou de renouvellement de titre de séjour se voit remettre un récépissé qui autorise sa présence sur le territoire pour la durée qu’il précise” — the foreign national admitted to file an application is given a récépissé (receipt) authorising his or her presence for the period it specifies. For applications filed online — which is how most prefectures now process renewals, including for British nationals through the Démarches Simplifiées portals and the ANEF platform — Article R. 431-15-1 of the CESEDA governs the parallel instrument: the online filing produces a mere filing acknowledgement that does not prove lawful residence, but “Lorsque l’instruction d’une demande complète et déposée dans le respect des délais mentionnés à l’article R. 431-5 se poursuit au-delà de la date de validité du document de séjour détenu, le préfet est tenu de mettre à la disposition du demandeur via le téléservice mentionné au premier alinéa une attestation de prolongation de l’instruction de sa demande dont la durée de validité ne peut être supérieure à trois mois” — where the review of a complete application filed within the required deadlines continues beyond the validity date of the document held, the prefect is required to make available an attestation de prolongation de l’instruction (extension-of-review certificate) valid for no more than three months, which, together with the expired card, allows the holder to prove lawful residence. That certificate is renewed as long as the prefect has not decided. These are the two documents that make life possible during the 2026 backlog: one for counter applications, one for online applications.
Here, however, comes the trap that the summer 2026 backlog has made salient. Holding a récépissé or an attestation de prolongation d’instruction proves that you are lawfully present — but it does not prevent time from running against you. Article R. 432-1 of the CESEDA states the fundamental rule: “Le silence gardé par l’autorité administrative sur les demandes de titres de séjour vaut décision implicite de rejet” — the silence kept by the administrative authority on residence permit applications is an implied refusal decision. Article R. 432-2 of the CESEDA fixes the period: “La décision implicite de rejet mentionnée à l’article R.* 432-1 naît au terme d’un délai de quatre mois” — the implied refusal is born after a period of four months. In other words, once a complete application is registered, the prefecture has four months to decide; if it says nothing, the application is deemed refused, whatever the internal state of the file.
The highest administrative court has made clear that the provisional documents change nothing. In its avis (advisory opinion) of 6 May 2025, n° 499904, rendered on preliminary questions from the administrative tribunal of Grenoble, the Conseil d’État answered precisely the question that every applicant stuck in the 2026 backlog is asking: does the fact that the prefecture keeps issuing or renewing the récépissé or the attestation de prolongation mean that no implied refusal has arisen? The answer is no. The Conseil d’État held that “La circonstance qu’un étranger se soit vu délivrer ou renouveler un récépissé ou une attestation de prolongation de l’instruction pour une durée supérieure au délai mentionné au point 3 ou postérieurement à l’expiration de ce délai ne fait pas obstacle à la naissance ou au maintien de la décision implicite de refus née du silence gardé par l’administration au terme ce délai” — the fact that the foreign national was issued or had renewed a receipt or an extension-of-review certificate for a period exceeding the four-month deadline, or after that deadline expired, does not prevent the birth or the persistence of the implied refusal arising from the administration’s silence at the end of that period. The administrative courts of appeal have applied the ruling. In CAA Paris, 10 July 2026, n° 25PA05283, an Algerian national held extension-of-review certificates valid from 12 December 2024 to 11 March 2025 and then from 18 September 2025 to 17 December 2025, yet the court confirmed that “La circonstance que M. B… a été convoqué à un rendez-vous le 21 mai 2024 dans les services de la préfecture n’a pas eu d’incidence sur l’écoulement de ce délai de quatre mois” — neither the appointment nor the successive certificates had any effect on the running of the four-month period — and that the implied refusal born at the end of it lawfully grounded an OQTF. Two consequences follow for British applicants. First, a récépissé or certificate is evidence of lawful presence, not evidence of a pending application that “doesn’t count” against the deadline: mark the four-month anniversary in your calendar. Second, an implied refusal is a real decision: it must be challenged in time, or it becomes final and can itself ground a removal order under Article L. 611-1 of the CESEDA, whose 3° covers the foreign national who “s’est vu refuser la délivrance d’un titre de séjour, le renouvellement du titre de séjour” — has been refused the delivery or the renewal of a residence permit. There is one important caveat, however: the four-month clock only starts when the application has actually been registered as complete. In CAA Versailles, 9 September 2025, n° 23VE02878, the court held that an application filed by post where personal attendance at the counter was required, and which had never been examined for completeness, did not trigger the deadline at all, so that no implied refusal had come into existence: “le silence gardé par l’administration sur une demande de titre irrégulièrement présentée par voie postale, en méconnaissance de la règle de comparution personnelle en préfecture, ne pouvait pas faire naître une décision faisant grief” — silence on an improperly filed application cannot give rise to a decision capable of being challenged. This is the precise reason why you must keep the proof that your online dossier was accepted and marked “sous instruction” (under review): if the prefecture later claims the application was never complete, that proof is what starts the four-month clock and, with it, your right to challenge the silence.
B. Challenging the Implied Refusal and the Express Refusal: Courts, Deadlines and Practical Steps
The first step is to verify what decision exists. If the prefecture has said nothing for four months after a complete application was registered, an implied refusal was born; if it has sent a letter, you have an express refusal. Both are individual administrative decisions that may be challenged. The practical course, in order, is the following.
First, an informal recours gracieux (appeal to the prefect) or recours hiérarchique (appeal to the Interior Minister) may be lodged within two months of the decision; it interrupts the two-month time limit for judicial review and often produces a re-examination of the file, which in the context of the 2026 backlogs can be the quickest way to obtain the card when the underlying right is clear. Where the application was actually complete and the delay is purely administrative, a reminder in the form of a lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception (recorded delivery letter) is a reasonable first move, as the experience of many applicants reported in the anglophone press shows. Second, an action for annulment (recours pour excès de pouvoir) may be brought before the tribunal administratif (administrative court) of your department within two months of the implied refusal — that is, within two months of the expiry of the four-month period — or of the express refusal, or of the rejection of the informal appeal. Legal representation is not compulsory for this action, but the quality of the file matters: the applicant must prove the completion of five years of residence under the Withdrawal Agreement, the timely filing of the application and, where relevant, the absence of any real, current and serious threat. Third, where the applicant clearly satisfies all the conditions, the court will not stop at annulling the refusal: under the powers conferred by Article L. 911-1 of the Code of administrative justice, it will order the prefecture to deliver the card within a fixed period, generally two months, as was done in CAA Toulouse, 23 July 2026, n° 24TL01660 and CAA Paris, 3 October 2023, n° 23PA00821, and may order the deletion of any SIS alert, as in CAA Bordeaux, 26 February 2026, n° 25BX01572.
Urgent situations require the juge des référés (emergency judge). Where the refusal, express or implied, is accompanied by an OQTF, the removal order and the refusal must be challenged together, within the same time limits, and the annulment of the refusal normally entails the annulment of the removal order. Where the delay of the prefecture causes an imminent and serious harm — loss of a job, loss of health coverage, inability to travel — an application to the emergency judge under Article L. 521-2 of the Code of administrative justice (the référé-liberté, which must be decided within forty-eight hours) can order the prefecture to issue a récépissé or to re-examine the file, and such orders have in practice been backed by coercive fines (astreintes) of up to one hundred euros per day of delay. The courts have also confirmed that a refusal of renewal cannot be treated as a fresh examination of the merits where the underlying right is clear: in the Toulouse case, the prefecture’s appeal was dismissed and the two-month injunction confirmed, illustrating that the courts will make the administration comply rather than leave the applicant in limbo. It is worth repeating that, under the Withdrawal Agreement, British nationals who obtained permanent residence have acquired a status that “n’est perdu” — is lost — only after five consecutive years outside France; the card is proof of that status, not the status itself. But proof is what the border, the employer and the bank ask for, and an expired card with no récépissé is precisely the situation that the 2026 backlog has created for some applicants. If you are in that situation, act before the four-month deadline: keep every acknowledgement, screenshot every portal status, and do not let the implied refusal become final. A lawyer specialising in French immigration law can assess your file, lodge the informal appeal or file the judicial action in time, and, where necessary, go before the emergency judge.
Conclusion
The 2026 wave of Withdrawal Agreement card renewals has collided with overloaded prefectures, and many British nationals in France are now waiting months with only a récépissé or an attestation de prolongation d’instruction — or with nothing at all. The legal framework, however, remains protective. Permanent residence under Article 15 of the Withdrawal Agreement is acquired by five years of lawful residence and is not lost with the expiry of a card; the ten-year “Séjour permanent” card is delivered de plein droit and renewed as of right; and a refusal requires a genuine legal ground — a real, current and sufficiently serious threat to a fundamental interest of society, assessed individually, or a late application without legitimate reasons. On procedure, the rules are now clear after the Conseil d’État‘s advisory opinion of 6 May 2025 (n° 499904): silence after four months is an implied refusal, whatever documents the prefecture has issued in the meantime, and that implied refusal must be challenged within two months, by informal appeal and then before the tribunal administratif, or both will become final. The courts have consistently backed their annulments with injunctions to deliver the card within two months, and the emergency judge exists for the urgent cases. The message for applicants is practical: file early, keep the proof of registration, note the four-month anniversary, and treat every silence as a decision that must be answered in time.