Sunday evening comes, and your child does not. Your former partner was supposed to bring your son or daughter back at the end of the contact weekend, and instead you receive a message saying the child is staying, or no message at all. For English-speaking parents in France, this moment combines panic with confusion: which authority do you call first, does French law treat this as a crime, and what happens when one parent lives abroad or threatens to leave the country with the child? This guide answers those questions in order of urgency, with the exact French legal texts and recent court decisions that govern them.
A few French terms appear throughout, because every police officer, judge and official form uses them. The juge aux affaires familiales, shortened to JAF, is the family court judge who fixes and enforces arrangements for children. The droit de visite et d’hébergement is the right of contact and overnight stays granted to the parent with whom the child does not live. The non-représentation d’enfant is the criminal offence of wrongfully refusing to hand the child back to the person entitled to collect them. The astreinte is a daily financial penalty the judge attaches to an order to force compliance. The interdiction de sortie du territoire, often shortened to IST, is the court-ordered ban on taking the child out of France without both parents’ consent. Keep these words in mind: they appear on every complaint form and every court order.
I. Your Ex Keeps the Child After Contact: What French Criminal Law Says and What to Do First
French law treats a refusal to return a child very differently from a simple parenting disagreement. Keeping a child beyond the agreed time, or refusing to hand the child over at the start of your contact period, can constitute a criminal offence from the first unjustified refusal. Two criminal provisions cover the situation, and a September 2026 decision of the Cour de cassation draws the exact line between a punishable refusal and one the law tolerates. Acting quickly matters both for getting your child back and for preserving evidence.
A. Non-Représentation d’Enfant: the Offence, the Penalty, and the Line Drawn by the Cour de Cassation in September 2026
Article 227-5 of the Criminal Code states: « Le fait de refuser indûment de représenter un enfant mineur à la personne qui a le droit de le réclamer est puni d’un an d’emprisonnement et de 15 000 euros d’amende. » (Wrongfully refusing to hand over a minor child to the person entitled to claim the child is punished by one year of imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine.) Every word counts. The refusal must be indu, meaning wrongful or without lawful justification, and the person claiming the child must genuinely hold the right to collect them at that date and time under an enforceable title: a JAF judgment, a divorce settlement deposited with a notaire, or a court-approved parenting agreement. The English version of the official service-public.fr page on contact and overnight stays after separation confirms the mechanism in plain terms: if the other parent prevents you from exercising your rights, you can file a report with the police and lodge a criminal complaint, because that conduct constitutes the offence of non-représentation, punishable by one year of imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine.
A second provision covers the more serious scenario of taking the child away. Article 227-7 of the Criminal Code provides: « Le fait, par tout ascendant, de soustraire un enfant mineur des mains de ceux qui exercent l’autorité parentale ou auxquels il a été confié ou chez qui il a sa résidence habituelle, est puni d’un an d’emprisonnement et de 15 000 euros d’amende. » (The act, by any ascendant, of taking a minor child away from those who exercise parental authority, or to whom the child has been entrusted, or with whom the child habitually resides, is punished by one year of imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine.) This text matters in both directions: it punishes the parent who keeps the child, and it also means you must never respond by seizing the child back by force or taking the child abroad yourself, because that response can itself be prosecuted under the same article.
The decisive recent authority is a ruling of the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation dated 9 September 2026, appeal number 25-85.104, published as Criminal Chamber, 9 September 2026, No. 25-85.104. A mother had been convicted for failing to present her daughter to the father during two summer holiday periods in July and August 2022. The Cour de cassation quashed the conviction entirely, holding that the appeal judges had ruled « par des motifs impropres à caractériser le caractère indu du refus par la prévenue de représenter l’enfant, ainsi que le droit de l’autre parent de le réclamer » (on grounds incapable of establishing the wrongful character of the defendant’s refusal to present the child, or the other parent’s right to claim the child). The judgment explained that the father’s exercise of his contact right at those dates was late under the terms of the applicable JAF judgment, so that he was deemed to have waived it, and concluded: « il résulte des pièces de procédure que les faits poursuivis ne supposent aucune qualification pénale » (it follows from the case file that the acts prosecuted admit of no criminal qualification). The lesson for expat parents cuts both ways. If your former partner refuses to return the child, the complaint succeeds only if your right to collect the child at that precise time is clearly established by the court order: bring the judgment, highlight the exact dates and handover times, and show that you presented yourself or asked for the return. Conversely, if you are the parent accused of non-représentation, the details of the order are your first line of defence: a right exercised late, outside the fixed periods, or already waived may remove the criminal qualification altogether.
Practical steps in the first forty-eight hours follow directly from this framework. First, send a short written message asking for the immediate return of the child and keep a copy; it proves the refusal. Second, go to the police station or gendarmerie with the JAF judgment, the child’s identity documents, and the messages exchanged, and lodge a plainte (criminal complaint) for non-représentation d’enfant, not merely a main courante (a simple incident note that triggers no investigation). Third, record everything: dates, times, witnesses present at the missed handover, and any statement by the other parent about leaving France. Fourth, do not wait months before complaining: although article 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that « L’action publique des délits se prescrit par six années révolues à compter du jour où l’infraction a été commise » (Public prosecution of misdemeanours is time-barred six full years after the day the offence was committed), delay weakens both the criminal investigation and any parallel family court action, because judges read a late reaction as a sign the situation was tolerated.
B. When Keeping the Child Crosses a Border: Wrongful Retention Under the 1980 Hague Convention and EU Rules
A refusal to return a child becomes an international case as soon as the child is kept in a different country from the one of habitual residence, or when the parent who keeps the child threatens to leave France. The governing instrument is the Hague Convention of 25 October 1980 on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, whose full official text is published by the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH). The Convention covers both wrongful removal and wrongful retention: a retention counts as wrongful when it breaches rights of custody attributed under the law of the State where the child habitually resided immediately before, and those rights were actually being exercised. A parent who keeps the child in France after a holiday, in breach of a foreign custody order that was actually exercised, therefore faces a return action before the French courts, and the same logic protects you when your child is retained abroad.
The leading French authority on how return proceedings work is a decision of the First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation dated 10 July 2024, appeal number 24-12.156, published as First Civil Chamber, 10 July 2024, No. 24-12.156. The case concerned a Ukrainian mother who had settled in France with her five-year-old son without informing the Danish father. The Court recalled article 12, paragraphs 1 and 2, of the Convention word for word: « Lorsqu’un enfant a été déplacé ou retenu illicitement au sens de l’article 3 et qu’une période de moins d’un an s’est écoulée à partir du déplacement ou du non-retour au moment de l’introduction de la demande devant l’autorité judiciaire ou administrative de l’État contractant où se trouve l’enfant, l’autorité saisie ordonne son retour immédiat. » (Where a child has been wrongfully removed or retained within the meaning of article 3 and, at the date of the commencement of the proceedings before the judicial or administrative authority of the contracting State where the child is, a period of less than one year has elapsed from the date of the wrongful removal or retention, the authority concerned shall order the return of the child forthwith.) The second paragraph adds that even after one year, return must still be ordered « à moins qu’il ne soit établi que l’enfant s’est intégré dans son nouveau milieu » (unless it is demonstrated that the child is now settled in its new environment). The Court then stated the guiding principle: « Le principe est donc le retour de l’enfant dans l’État de sa résidence habituelle immédiatement avant le déplacement ou le non-retour illicite. » (The principle is therefore the return of the child to the State of its habitual residence immediately before the wrongful removal or retention.) In that case the return to Denmark was refused as an exception, because the five-year-old had never met his father and had never lived in Denmark, so ordering return there would not have restored any familiar environment. For most expat families the message is the reverse: where the child has a genuine, lived habitual residence in France or in the other parent’s country, the French judge orders return quickly, and the parent who retains the child must prove one of the narrow Convention exceptions, such as grave risk of physical or psychological harm or an intolerable situation.
Within the European Union, the Brussels II ter Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, reinforces and tightens this system between Member States: it strengthens the return mechanism, limits refusal grounds, and organises the enforcement of custody and contact orders across borders through directly enforceable decisions and certificates. For British families, Brexit changed the framework but did not remove it: the United Kingdom and France are both contracting States to the 1980 Hague Convention, so a retention in either direction still leads to a return action, but the automatic EU enforcement machinery no longer applies and each step takes longer. For American families, the 1980 Convention applies between France and the United States in the same way. In every cross-border retention, a separate request can be addressed to the Central Authority designated by France within the Ministry of Justice, which locates the child, encourages an amicable return, and helps launch court proceedings. If your former partner has threatened to leave France with the child or has already done so, mention that threat expressly in the criminal complaint and in every filing: it transforms the case from a domestic handover dispute into a wrongful retention case with international tools attached.
II. Getting Your Child Back Through the Family Judge: Enforcement Tools That Run Alongside the Criminal Complaint
The criminal complaint punishes, but it is the JAF who reorganises your family’s life and forces future compliance. French law gives the family judge an arsenal specifically designed for parents who obstruct contact: financial penalties that accumulate daily, a civil fine, police enforcement, travel bans, and ultimately a change of the child’s residence. These tools work in parallel with the criminal route, and the obstruction itself becomes evidence that reshapes custody. Binational families should activate them immediately rather than waiting for the outcome of the criminal investigation.
A. Astreinte, Civil Fine, Police Enforcement and Travel Bans: the JAF Toolbox Against Obstruction
The most effective day-to-day weapon is the astreinte, a sum of money per day of delay or per missed handover that pressures the obstructing parent into compliance. Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code provides that the judge « peut, même d’office, ordonner une astreinte pour assurer l’exécution de sa décision » (may, even of his own motion, order a penalty payment to ensure enforcement of his decision), and adds that he may attach such a penalty to a decision made by another judge or to a recorded parental agreement. Ask the JAF to add an astreinte to every contact order, with an amount high enough to hurt: a symbolic sum invites non-compliance, while a dissuasive daily amount concentrates minds. Once ordered, the astreinte is quantified and enforced through the enforcement judge, so keep a precise log of each missed handover with dates, messages and witnesses.
The same Article 373-2-6 adds a punitive layer for deliberate obstruction: « lorsqu’un parent fait délibérément obstacle de façon grave ou renouvelée à l’exécution de l’un des titres mentionnés aux 1° à 6° du I de l’article 373-2-2, le condamner au paiement d’une amende civile d’un montant qui ne peut excéder 10 000 €. » A parent who deliberately and gravely or repeatedly blocks enforcement of a custody order can therefore be ordered to pay a civil fine of up to 10,000 euros. Request this fine expressly when the retention repeats or when the other parent openly states they will not comply. It punishes past defiance while the astreinte secures future obedience, and the two can be combined.
Where the other parent simply ignores paper orders, the law authorises physical enforcement. Article 373-2 of the Civil Code recalls that « Chacun des père et mère doit maintenir des relations personnelles avec l’enfant et respecter les liens de celui-ci avec l’autre parent » (Each father and mother must maintain a personal relationship with the child and respect the child’s ties with the other parent), and provides that in exceptional cases, at the request of the interested person or of the JAF, the public prosecutor « peut requérir le concours de la force publique pour faire exécuter » a JAF decision or an enforceable parenting agreement (“may call upon police assistance to enforce” the order). This is not automatic: ask the JAF to include the authorisation, or apply to the prosecutor, and present the enforceable title. The same article imposes a parallel duty that helps expats anticipate trouble: any change of residence by a parent that alters how parental authority is exercised « doit faire l’objet d’une information préalable et en temps utile de l’autre parent » (must be notified to the other parent beforehand and in good time), and in case of disagreement the more diligent parent seizes the JAF, who rules in the child’s interests while reallocating travel costs. A former partner who moves without warning therefore breaches a statutory duty before any retention even occurs.
If leaving France is the threat, the travel ban is the emergency answer. Article 373-2-6 allows the JAF to « ordonner l’interdiction de sortie de l’enfant du territoire français sans l’autorisation des deux parents » (order that the child may not leave French territory without the authorisation of both parents), and this ban is entered in the wanted-persons file by the public prosecutor, which means border police see it. Request it as soon as retention is accompanied by any international signal: foreign passports held by one parent alone, one-way tickets, a leased flat given up, or family abroad presented as the new plan. For background on blocking a planned departure before it happens, our guide on stopping a co-parent from taking your child abroad from France sets out the preventive procedure in detail, and our guide to enforcing cross-border contact when your ex has moved abroad covers the mirror situation where distance, rather than retention, breaks the relationship.
B. Turning Obstruction Into a Custody Argument: How Retention Reshapes Residence, Handovers and Your File
Every unjustified retention is also evidence, and French custody law directs the judge to weigh it. Article 373-2-11 of the Civil Code lists what the JAF must consider when fixing how parental authority is exercised, including « L’aptitude de chacun des parents à assumer ses devoirs et respecter les droits de l’autre » (The ability of each parent to assume their duties and respect the rights of the other). A parent who keeps the child after contact demonstrates the opposite of that ability, and judges draw the consequence: repeated obstruction is one of the recognised paths toward transferring the child’s residence to the other parent or converting a residence arrangement into alternating residence. File a modification application on this basis rather than treating each retention as an isolated incident, because the pattern is what persuades. Article 373-2-13 of the Civil Code confirms that custody decisions and approved agreements « peuvent être modifiées ou complétées à tout moment par le juge » (may be modified or supplemented at any time by the judge) at the request of a parent, so no waiting period bars you.
Where handovers themselves have become conflictual or unsafe, the judge redesigns them instead of suspending contact. Article 373-2-9 of the Civil Code provides: « Lorsque l’intérêt de l’enfant le commande ou lorsque la remise directe de l’enfant à l’autre parent présente un danger pour l’un d’eux, le juge en organise les modalités pour qu’elle présente toutes les garanties nécessaires. » (Where the child’s interests so require, or where handing the child directly to the other parent presents a danger to either of them, the judge shall organise the arrangements so that they offer every necessary safeguard.) In practice this means handovers in a supervised contact centre (espace de rencontre), or with the assistance of a trusted third person or a qualified organisation. Propose this solution yourself when tensions run high: it protects you against false allegations, creates neutral records of each parent’s behaviour, and removes the other parent’s easiest pretext for refusing the next handover.
For Paris and Île-de-France families, three local points deserve attention. First, applications go to the JAF of the tribunal judiciaire of the child’s residence, which for Paris means the tribunal judiciaire de Paris, so check which court holds your file before filing and attach the full history of orders to avoid delays. Second, the Paris prosecutor’s office handles a heavy volume of non-représentation complaints: a file with the judgment, a chronological table of missed handovers, and numbered exhibits moves faster than a bare allegation, and following up through a lawyer keeps it alive. Third, supervised handover centres around Paris and the inner suburbs have waiting lists, so ask the JAF in the same hearing to designate a fallback trusted third person in case no centre place is immediately available. Across all these steps, keep one prohibition firmly in mind: never take the law into your own hands by collecting the child outside the fixed times or leaving France with the child without consent, because article 227-7 punishes that conduct symmetrically and a single impulsive act can destroy the custody argument your file was building.
Conclusion
A former partner who keeps your child after contact in France faces two converging pressures: criminal liability for non-représentation d’enfant, punishable by one year of imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine where the refusal is wrongful and your right to collect the child is clearly established, and family court enforcement through daily astreinte penalties, a civil fine of up to 10,000 euros, police-assisted enforcement and a ban on leaving French territory. The September 2026 criminal ruling shows that precision wins these cases: the exact dates in the court order decide whether a refusal is wrongful, so build every complaint and every JAF application on the text of your title. Where retention crosses a border, the 1980 Hague Convention makes immediate return to the State of habitual residence the principle, with only narrow exceptions, and EU rules tighten the mechanism further between Member States. Complain in writing within days, seize the JAF for enforcement and modification without waiting for the criminal outcome, request the travel ban at the first international signal, and turn each proven obstruction into documented evidence that the other parent cannot respect your rights. Speed, paper and precision decide these cases; hesitation and self-help lose them.