KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Ex Refuses to Sell Our Flat After Divorce in France: How to Force the Sale, Split the Loan and Recover Your Share

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Ex Refuses to Sell Our Flat After Divorce in France: How to Force the Sale, Split the Loan and Recover Your Share

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You divorced in France, or you are about to, and one problem blocks everything else: your former spouse refuses to sell the flat you bought together. He or she keeps living there, or leaves it empty, refuses to sign the sale mandate with the estate agent, refuses to go to the notaire, or rejects every buyer without reason. Meanwhile the joint mortgage still runs every month, in both your names, and the bank keeps debiting your account. If you are an English-speaking expatriate in Paris or elsewhere in France, this situation feels like a trap with no exit. French law does provide an exit. No former spouse can block the sale of a jointly owned home forever, the family court judge can authorise the sale or order a forced auction, and the bank loan can be untangled even when one side refuses to cooperate. This guide explains, step by step and in plain English, how to force the sale of the flat, who pays the mortgage in the meantime, and how you recover your share of the money, with the exact legal texts and court decisions that govern each stage.

I. Your former spouse cannot block the sale forever: how French law ends post-divorce joint ownership

A. Nobody can be forced to stay in joint ownership: the notaire draws up the settlement and the family judge decides

When a French divorce is pronounced, the matrimonial property regime, known in French as the régime matrimonial, is liquidated, which means everything the couple owned together must be valued and divided. Most expatriate couples married without a marriage contract, so they fall under the default regime of community of property reduced to acquisitions, called communauté réduite aux acquêts: everything bought during the marriage belongs to both spouses equally, whatever share of the price each one paid. Once the divorce takes effect between the spouses, that community becomes a simple joint ownership called post-community indivision, or indivision post-communautaire. The flat is no longer a family home with special protection; it is an asset owned fifty-fifty, or in whatever proportions the purchase deed states, by two people who may now demand their share at any time.

The starting point of French law is a short and powerful sentence in Article 815 of the Civil Code: Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention. (No one may be forced to remain in joint ownership, and partition may always be demanded, unless a court or an agreement has ordered a stay of partition.) In ordinary language: your former spouse has no right to keep you locked in joint ownership against your will. You can always demand the division, called partage, and if no agreement is possible, you can ask the court to order it. The only exceptions are a judge-ordered stay, called maintien dans l’indivision, granted for serious reasons such as protecting young children who still live in the flat, or a written agreement between the former spouses to stay in joint ownership for a fixed period. Outside those narrow cases, a refusal to sell has no legal value and the court will override it.

In practice, the division begins before the notaire, the notaire, who is the public officer in charge of valuing the property, calculating what each spouse put in, and proposing how to split the lots. During the divorce proceedings, the family court judge, the juge aux affaires familiales, routinely appoints a notaire for exactly this task. The tenth power listed in Article 255 of the Civil Code allows the judge to order: Désigner un notaire en vue d’élaborer un projet de liquidation du régime matrimonial et de formation des lots à partager. (Appoint a notaire to draw up a draft liquidation of the matrimonial property regime and to form the lots to be shared.) The notaire summons both spouses, collects the bank statements, the loan offers, the purchase deed, and any proof of personal money invested, then sends a draft settlement, the projet de liquidation, to each side. When one spouse boycotts the appointments or refuses to send documents, the notaire records the obstruction in a formal report, the procès-verbal de carence, and that report becomes your best evidence before the judge that an amicable settlement is impossible.

If the notaire procedure fails because your former spouse refuses every proposal, the judge takes over the division directly. Article 267 of the Civil Code provides that: A défaut d’un règlement conventionnel par les époux, le juge statue sur leurs demandes de maintien dans l’indivision, d’attribution préférentielle et d’avance sur part de communauté ou de biens indivis. (Failing an agreed settlement between the spouses, the judge rules on their requests to remain in joint ownership, for preferential attribution, and for advance payment on their share of the community or jointly owned property.) The same article adds that the judge rules on liquidation and partition under Articles 1361 to 1378 of the Code of Civil Procedure once the remaining disagreements are shown by any means, typically by producing the joint declaration accepting a court-ordered partition or the draft drawn up by the appointed notaire. Concretely, your lawyer files a petition asking the family court to open the operations of account, liquidation and partition, to appoint or confirm the notaire, and, if needed, to order the sale of the flat. The judge can also decide, even without being asked, which matrimonial property regime applies to you, which matters greatly for binational couples who married abroad and are unsure whether French or foreign law governs their flat in Paris.

For couples with an international element, which regime applies to the flat is itself governed by European law. Since 29 January 2019, Council Regulation 2016/1103 on matrimonial property regimes, available on the official EUR-Lex site, designates the applicable law for spouses who did not choose one: in most cases the law of the country of their first common habitual residence after the wedding, or of their common nationality. If that analysis points to French law, the community rules described above apply to your Paris flat. If it points to another law, the French notaire still handles the conveyancing of the French property, but the shares are computed under the foreign regime. This is why your lawyer must identify the applicable regime at the very start: an ex-spouse who claims the flat is entirely his because he paid the deposit may be right under one regime and completely wrong under another. Our general guide on who keeps the flat and how assets are divided in a French divorce explains the regimes in detail and serves as the companion to this article.

Before ordering a sale, the judge always examines whether one spouse should keep the flat outright, which French law calls attribution préférentielle, preferential attribution. Either spouse can ask to be awarded the whole property against payment of a balancing sum, the soulte, to the other. For divorcing couples, Article 1476 of the Civil Code states that: Le partage de la communauté, pour tout ce qui concerne ses formes, le maintien de l’indivision et l’attribution préférentielle, la licitation des biens, les effets du partage, la garantie et les soultes, est soumis à toutes les règles qui sont établies au titre Des successions pour les partages entre cohéritiers. (The partition of the community, as regards its forms, continuation in joint ownership and preferential attribution, auction sale of property, effects of partition, warranty and balancing payments, is subject to all the rules laid down under Successions for partitions between co-heirs.) The same article adds a warning that matters for your case: for communities dissolved by divorce, preferential attribution is never automatic, and the court can order that the whole balancing sum be payable in cash immediately. So your former spouse cannot demand to keep the flat as a right; the judge weighs the interests of both sides, the housing needs of the children, and, above all, whether the spouse who wants the flat can actually pay you your share. If he or she cannot finance the buyout, the request for preferential attribution is rejected and the court moves to the sale.

The highest courts confirm this sequence. In a case where a husband sought partition of the post-community joint ownership and the wife requested preferential attribution of the home, the Commercial Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in its judgment of 10 July 2019, appeal number 18-16.867, approved the family judge for doing exactly what this article describes: le juge aux affaires familiales, saisi par M. T… d’une demande d’ouverture des opérations de compte, liquidation et partage de l’indivision, pouvait, en exécution du jugement de divorce et après avoir rejeté la demande d’attribution préférentielle du bien litigieux dont il était également saisi, ordonner sa licitation pour parvenir au partage de l’indivision (the family court judge, petitioned by Mr T for the opening of the operations of account, liquidation and partition of the joint ownership, could, in enforcement of the divorce judgment and after rejecting the request for preferential attribution of the disputed property of which he was also petitioned, order its auction sale in order to achieve partition of the joint ownership). Keep this decision in mind: it proves that a rejected buyout request leads naturally to a court-ordered sale, and that the obstructing spouse cannot appeal the outcome simply by repeating the same refusal.

B. How the court forces the sale when the flat cannot be split in two: auction, reserve price and the limits the judge must respect

When the judge concludes that the flat cannot be physically divided and that neither spouse can fairly keep it, the court orders the sale by public auction between the co-owners, a procedure called licitation. Article 1361 of the Code of Civil Procedure states the rule plainly: Le tribunal ordonne le partage, s’il peut avoir lieu, ou la vente par licitation si les conditions prévues à l’article 1378 sont réunies. (The court orders partition, where it can take place, or sale by auction where the conditions laid down in Article 1378 are met.) For a Paris apartment, partition in kind is physically impossible: you cannot cut a two-bedroom flat in half. The licitation therefore becomes the standard outcome, and it works as follows. The judgment sets a starting price, the mise à prix, usually based on an expert valuation or the notaire estimate, designates the notaire or a court officer to organise the sale, and orders advertising so that outside buyers can bid. The auction takes place at the court, historically described as à la barre du tribunal, and any person, including either former spouse, can bid. The price obtained replaces the flat in the joint estate and is then divided between you according to your rights, after repayment of the remaining mortgage and deduction of costs.

Your former spouse must understand one point clearly: refusing to cooperate does not stop the licitation. Article 815-3 of the Civil Code explains that co-owners holding at least two thirds of the shares can carry out administrative acts, but any act of disposal, which includes selling the property, requires the consent of all co-owners: Toutefois, le consentement de tous les indivisaires est requis pour effectuer tout acte qui ne ressortit pas à l’exploitation normale des biens indivis et pour effectuer tout acte de disposition autre que ceux visés au 3°. (However, the consent of all the co-owners is required to carry out any act falling outside the normal exploitation of the jointly owned property and to carry out any act of disposal other than those referred to in point 3.) Selling the flat is precisely such an act of disposal, so one refusal is enough to block a voluntary sale. That is exactly why the law provides the judicial route: when unanimity is impossible, the judge substitutes the court order for the missing consent. Going further, Article 815-5 of the Civil Code allows a co-owner to be authorised by the court to act alone where the refusal of the other endangers the common interest: Un indivisaire peut être autorisé par justice à passer seul un acte pour lequel le consentement d’un coïndivisaire serait nécessaire, si le refus de celui-ci met en péril l’intérêt commun. (A co-owner may be authorised by the court to carry out alone an act for which the consent of a fellow co-owner would be required, where the refusal of the latter jeopardises the common interest.) A spouse who lets the flat stand empty while the mortgage arrears accumulate, or who refuses urgent repairs, exposes the common asset to exactly that kind of danger, and the court can authorise you to sign alone for protective measures, renew a lease, or accept essential works.

The forced sale is nevertheless a measure of last resort, and the courts control it strictly. The First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation recalled the controlling principle in its judgment of 5 February 2025, appeal number 21-15.932, concerning an auction sale of jointly owned buildings: Il résulte de ce texte que la licitation des immeubles indivis ne doit être ordonnée que s’ils ne peuvent être facilement partagés en nature. (It follows from this text that the auction sale of jointly owned buildings may only be ordered where they cannot easily be shared in kind.) The Court added that by merely noting the absence of agreement between the co-owners, sans rechercher, comme il lui incombait, si les biens indivis étaient ou non commodément partageables en nature, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision. (without investigating, as it was required to do, whether or not the jointly owned property could conveniently be shared in kind, the court of appeal failed to give a legal basis for its decision.) For your Paris flat, this condition is satisfied almost by definition, since an apartment cannot be split, but your petition should still state it expressly and attach proof: the layout, the single land registry entry, and the notaire report confirming that physical partition is impossible. Doing so protects the judgment against an appeal by the obstructing spouse.

One more limit deserves attention because it traps many families: where the property carries a right of use, such as a usufruct, the judge cannot simply auction the full ownership against the will of the holder of that right. The First Civil Chamber stated the rule on 13 June 2019, appeal number 18-17.347: le juge ne peut, à la demande du créancier personnel d’un indivisaire, ordonner la vente de la pleine propriété d’un bien grevé d’usufruit contre la volonté de l’usufruitier (the judge may not, at the request of the personal creditor of a co-owner, order the sale of the full ownership of property burdened with a usufruct against the will of the usufructuary). Most divorcing couples own the flat in full ownership, so this limit rarely applies to them, but it matters when the flat was partly gifted with a retained usufruct by a parent, a frequent arrangement in French families. In that configuration your lawyer must ask for the sale of the bare ownership only, or negotiate the consent of the usufructuary, rather than requesting an order the court cannot legally make.

Practical consequences follow for your strategy. First, always go through the notaire stage and collect the written proof of obstruction before petitioning for licitation; judges order forced sales faster when the file shows a notaire report, dated refusals, and ignored summons. Second, ask the court to fix a realistic starting price with the possibility of lowering it if no bid comes, the baisse de mise à prix, because an overvalued flat that finds no buyer at auction wastes months and costs advertising fees. Third, consider bidding yourself at the auction or having a relative bid: nothing forbids a former spouse from buying the flat at licitation, and it is sometimes the cheapest way to keep a home you are attached to while paying your ex-spouse through the supervised distribution of the price. Fourth, remember that the auction costs, the notaire fees on the partition deed, and any capital gains tax are taken from the price before division, so pushing the sale forward quickly usually leaves more money for both sides than letting the dispute rot for years.

II. Who pays the loan in the meantime and how you recover your money once the flat is sold

A. The joint mortgage survives the divorce: why the bank can still chase you and how to get your name removed

The cruellest surprise for expatriates is that the divorce judgment changes nothing for the bank. When you borrowed together, you almost certainly signed as joint and several borrowers, described in French as co-emprunteurs solidaires. Each of you owes the whole monthly payment to the lender, and the bank may debit either account, or pursue either of you, for the full amount if the other stops paying. If your former spouse stays in the flat and stops paying, the bank will turn to you; if you stop paying to put pressure on your ex-spouse, the bank will turn to him or her, and both your credit histories in France will carry the missed payments. Neither the divorce decree nor the family judge can rewrite the loan contract against the will of the lender, because the bank is a third party to your marriage. Only the bank can release you, through a procedure called désolidarisation, removal of a co-borrower, and it grants that release only when the remaining borrower proves sufficient income, or when a solvent newcomer takes your place, or when the sale repays the loan in full.

Many clients ask whether they can simply stop paying their half of the loan until the ex-spouse agrees to sell. The answer is negative: as long as both names remain on the loan offer, each co-borrower remains liable for the whole debt toward the bank, and unpaid instalments trigger late interest, registration with the Banque de France incident file, and ultimately an acceleration clause allowing the bank to demand immediate repayment of the entire balance. The correct approach is the reverse: keep paying to protect your credit record, keep every proof of payment, and ask the family judge to settle the accounts between you later. Payments you make alone for a joint debt give rise to a claim, called a créance entre ex-époux, which the notaire records as a credit in your favour at partition. If your former spouse occupies the flat alone while you pay the loan from outside, two parallel claims arise: you can demand reimbursement of the instalments you covered beyond your share, and you can demand an occupation payment, the indemnité d’occupation, from the spouse who enjoys the home exclusively. The provisional measures of the divorce routinely set such an occupation payment under Article 255 of the Civil Code, which allows the judge to award one spouse the use of the home and household furniture while settling whether that use is paid for and, where the spouses agree, recording the amount of the occupation payment: the relevant passage authorises the judge to attribute la jouissance du logement et du mobilier du ménage (the use of the home and household furniture) to one of them. If the divorce order granted your ex-spouse use of the flat at no cost for a period, respect that period; once it expires, claim the monthly occupation payment without delay, because it is assessed on the rental value of the property and quickly reaches significant sums in Paris.

Obtaining the désolidarisation requires a targeted application to the bank, not a letter to the judge. Prepare a file with the divorce judgment, the notaire valuation of the flat, proof of the remaining balance, and, where the keeper of the flat seeks to keep it, his or her last three payslips, tax notice, and a new solo financing simulation showing that the remaining loan is sustainable on one income. Banks in Paris accept the release more readily when the loan-to-value ratio is comfortable and the remaining borrower has a stable French employment contract; they refuse it when the single income clearly cannot service the debt, which is precisely the situation where the sale becomes the only honest solution. If the bank refuses in writing, keep that refusal: it proves before the family judge that keeping the flat is financially impossible and that the licitation must be ordered. Where the loan includes a death and disability insurance, the assurance emprunteur, check whether each co-borrower is covered at one hundred percent or at fifty percent each, and maintain the premiums during the dispute, because a lapse in cover during the standoff would be an additional fault if misfortune strikes.

Two further practical points protect expatriates specifically. First, if you have left France, the bank will still debit the French direct debit and will still write to your last known French address; give the bank your address abroad in writing, keep a French account funded for the instalments, and mandate your lawyer to receive copies, so that no formal notice goes unanswered. Second, if the flat was bought before the wedding by one spouse with a loan taken in his or her sole name, the other spouse is not a borrower at all, and the dispute shifts from the loan to compensation for payments made toward a property belonging to the other, which is settled through rewards, the récompenses, examined in the next section. Identifying exactly who signed what, as borrower, as joint borrower, or as simple guarantor, the caution, is therefore the first document review your lawyer must perform, before any letter is sent to the bank or to the former spouse.

B. Recovering your share: rewards for personal money invested, the balancing payment, and the Paris procedure from valuation to cash

Once the sale price is known or the flat is awarded to one spouse, the notaire computes who is owed what, and this computation often matters more than the price itself. Under the community regime, money that belonged to one spouse before the wedding, or received by gift or inheritance during it, and that was poured into the joint flat, gives rise to a reward, called récompense, owed by the community to that spouse. Typical expatriate examples include the deposit paid from savings accumulated before moving to France, a gift from English-speaking parents used for the renovation, or an inheritance from abroad invested in the Paris apartment. Article 1469 of the Civil Code fixes the measure of that reward: La récompense est, en général, égale à la plus faible des deux sommes que représentent la dépense faite et le profit subsistant. (The reward is, as a general rule, equal to the lower of the two sums represented by the expenditure made and the surviving profit.) The same article refines the rule where borrowed value was used to acquire, preserve or improve an asset still present at liquidation: the reward cannot be less than the surviving profit. In plain terms, if you invested 60,000 euros of premarital savings and the flat gained value thanks to that investment, you recover at least the profit attributable to your money, sometimes more than the sum spent. Gather the bank transfers, the gift deeds, the inheritance documents with sworn translations, and the works invoices now: rewards are won or lost on paperwork, and foreign-language documents need certified French translations to be accepted by the notaire and the court.

Symmetrically, where community money repaid a personal loan of one spouse, or financed works on a property that spouse owned alone, the community holds a reward against that spouse, which reduces his or her final share. The notaire nets all these cross-claims, adds the occupation payments owed by the spouse who lived in the flat, deducts the mortgage instalments paid alone by the other, and arrives at the net share of each side. If one spouse keeps the flat, he or she pays the other a balancing sum, the soulte, equal to the difference; if the flat is sold, each receives the net balance by bank transfer after the notaire repays the bank and pays the taxes. Recall that for divorced couples preferential attribution is never automatic and the court may order the whole soulte payable in cash at once, which protects the spouse who leaves: you cannot be forced to accept payment of your share in ten yearly instalments from an ex-spouse whose solvency is doubtful. Where the keeper of the flat genuinely cannot pay cash, the judge will prefer the sale, which brings us back to the licitation described above.

Expatriates in Paris and the surrounding Île-de-France region should know the local procedure in concrete terms, because geography changes the practical handling even though the law is national. Jurisdiction lies with the family court judge of the judicial court, the tribunal judiciaire, of the place where the family home was situated or where the defendant lives; for a flat in Paris that means the Paris judicial court on the Île de la Cité, whose family chambers handle a heavy volume of international divorces every week. Valuations in Paris must reflect the micro-market of each district: an apartment in the 11th arrondissement and a house in Boulogne-Billancourt or Saint-Germain-en-Laye do not move at the same pace, and judges distrust valuations that ignore recent comparable sales in the same street. Instruct an agent or expert who works daily in the relevant district, ask for a written valuation with at least three comparable sales, and have the notaire cross-check it against the notarial databases. The auction itself, when ordered, follows the local tariff of advertising and court costs, and the judgment organises viewings of the occupied flat: if your former spouse refuses access to potential buyers or to the expert, the judge can order access under penalty, the astreinte, a daily fine for each day of refusal, which concentrates minds effectively.

Time limits deserve a frank presentation, because overly optimistic promises help nobody. An amicable settlement signed before cooperating notaires can close within three to six months of the divorce. A contested partition with an obstructing spouse typically takes twelve to twenty-four months from the petition to the final distribution of the price, depending on whether an expert valuation is ordered, whether the attribution request requires a financing assessment, and whether appeals are lodged. Our guide on how much a divorce costs in France and how long it takes gives the current ranges of fees and court delays for expatriates. The costs of the forced sale itself, advertising, auctioneer fees, and the notaire partition deed, are shared in proportion to your rights unless the judge charges them to the obstructing spouse for procedural misconduct, which courts do order when the obstruction is documented and blatant. Interest runs on the balancing sums from the date the partition becomes final, so every month of unjustified refusal increases the debt of the spouse who blocks.

One last cross-border warning closes the picture. Where the divorce itself was pronounced abroad, in London, New York, or elsewhere, and you now need to divide a flat located in France, the foreign judgment must be capable of producing effects in France before the French notaire and land registry will act on it. Divorces pronounced in another European Union Member State circulate under the Brussels II ter Regulation 2019/1111, while the law applicable to the divorce itself may have been designated under the Rome III Regulation 1259/2010, available on the official EUR-Lex site. Our guide on marrying in England and divorcing in France explains which court decides and which law applies when the couple straddles the Channel. If your situation combines a foreign divorce and a Paris flat, bring the foreign judgment with its apostille or legalisation and sworn translation to the first meeting: without an enforceable divorce title recognised in France, even the best licitation petition cannot proceed.

Conclusion

A former spouse who refuses to sell the Paris flat can delay the settlement, but cannot prevent it. French law states that no one remains in joint ownership against his will, the notaire documents the obstruction, and the family judge orders the partition, rejects an unfunded request to keep the flat, and directs the auction sale where the apartment cannot be split. The bank, for its part, remains outside the divorce: it must consent to remove your name from the loan, which it will do only against proof of solvency or full repayment from the sale price, so keep paying in the meantime and turn every instalment into a documented credit. Finally, the partition accounts reward the personal money you invested, charge the spouse who occupied the home alone, and convert your share into cash, either as an immediate balancing payment or as your portion of the auction price. The files that succeed are the files that are prepared early: purchase deed, loan offer, proof of personal contributions with translations, notaire correspondence, written bank refusal, and a realistic valuation. Assemble them now, and the procedure that looks like a deadlock today becomes a supervised sale with a fixed timetable tomorrow. Where children also live in the flat, coordinate the housing calendar with the custody arrangements described in our guide on child custody and residence in France, so that the sale timetable never harms their stability.

📄 Official circular