KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Ex Refuses to Sell Our French Home After Divorce: How Expats Force the Sale and Recover Their Share

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Ex Refuses to Sell Our French Home After Divorce: How Expats Force the Sale and Recover Their Share

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The divorce is pronounced, the judgment is final, and still nothing moves. Your former husband or wife lives in the Paris flat or the house in the suburbs, refuses every estate agent, rejects every offer, and will not buy out your half either. Meanwhile the mortgage, the taxe foncière (French property tax), the building charges and the insurance keep coming out of your account, often from abroad, while you no longer even hold the keys. If you are an expatriate divorced in France, a binational couple living in Paris, or a foreigner whose marriage to a French national has just ended, this deadlock feels like a second divorce: the marriage is over but the money is still chained to someone who will not cooperate. French law has a complete answer to this situation, built for exactly this refusal. No former spouse can force you to remain a co-owner forever, the notary (notaire, the public officer who handles property transfers and estate divisions in France) has a formal route for recording the deadlock, and the family judge (juge aux affaires familiales, universally shortened to JAF) can order the sale at public auction, set the price, and make the blocking party pay. This guide explains the whole route in English, from the statutes as they stand to four recent decisions of the Court of Cassation (Court of Cassation, France’s supreme court for civil matters): what you still own the day after the divorce, who pays what while the flat sits unsold, how the forced sale works step by step, and how you recover your share, your expenses and part of your legal costs even if you now live outside France.

I. Divorced but still co-owners: what French law says about your home the day after the divorce

A. Your ex cannot block the split forever: co-ownership, partition, and the judge’s power to order the sale

The starting point surprises many common-law readers. In France, the divorce judgment ends the marriage but it does not automatically divide the property. What you owned together — typically under the default community regime (communauté réduite aux acquêts, the statutory regime that makes assets acquired during the marriage common) or whatever foreign matrimonial property regime (régime matrimonial, the set of rules governing ownership between spouses) applied to you — falls into a post-divorce joint ownership called post-community indivision (literally undivided co-ownership, where each former spouse owns a share of the whole rather than a defined half of the flat). You are divorced, yet you remain co-owners, and every decision about the home requires agreement. That is precisely why one stubborn former spouse can freeze everything for months or years. The way the property regimes themselves are divided is explained in the firm’s guide to division of assets, matrimonial regimes and the notaire’s liquidation, and the present guide takes over where that one stops: when agreement is impossible.

Against that freeze, the Civil Code gives you a weapon of remarkable simplicity. Article 815 of the Civil Code provides: « Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention. » (No one may be forced to remain in joint ownership, and partition may always be demanded, unless it has been postponed by judgment or agreement.) Read that sentence twice, because it decides your case. Your former spouse’s refusal is not a veto; it is merely the trigger for the court route. The only recognised postponements are a court-ordered stay or a written agreement to stay co-owners for a time — and a spouse who simply refuses to sell has signed no such agreement. From the moment the refusal is clear, you are entitled to demand partage (partition, the legal operation that ends the co-ownership and gives each person their share).

The divorce context changes nothing about that right; if anything, the Code organises it expressly. Article 1476 of the Civil Code states: « Le partage de la communauté, pour tout ce qui concerne ses formes, le maintien de l’indivision et l’attribution préférentielle, la licitation des biens, les effets du partage, la garantie et les soultes, est soumis à toutes les règles qui sont établies au titre ” Des successions ” pour les partages entre cohéritiers. » (Partition of the community property, for everything concerning its formalities, continuation of the joint ownership and preferential attribution, auction sale of the assets, effects of the partition, warranties and balancing payments, is subject to all the rules laid down in the Successions title for partitions between co-heirs.) In plain terms, the whole machinery of court-ordered partition — including the forced sale — applies directly to divorced couples dividing what was once community property. And the court route itself is written for refusals: Article 840 of the Civil Code sends the case to court « lorsque l’un des indivisaires refuse de consentir au partage amiable, s’il s’élève des contestations sur la manière d’y procéder ou de le terminer » (where one co-owner refuses to agree to an amicable partition, or where disputes arise over how to carry it out or complete it). A spouse who answers no offer, signs nothing and lets the file rot is the textbook case this article was written for.

At the end of that road sits the power you most need to know about: the judge can sell the home over your ex’s head. Partition between co-owners is decided by the court, and Article 841 of the Civil Code confirms the court’s arsenal in partition cases: « Il ordonne les licitations et statue sur les demandes relatives à la garantie des lots entre les copartageants et sur celles en nullité de partage ou en complément de part. » (It orders auction sales and rules on claims concerning warranty of the shares between the parties, and on claims for annulment of the partition or for a supplementary share.) Licitation is the French term for the court-ordered auction sale of a jointly owned asset that cannot be divided in kind — you cannot saw a Paris apartment in two, so the court sells it and divides the price. The Court of Cassation confirmed this power in a divorce setting: in a decision of 10 July 2019, pourvoi No 18-16.867, it approved a family judge who, and I quote the operative words, « pouvait, en exécution du jugement de divorce et après avoir rejeté la demande d’attribution préférentielle du bien litigieux dont il était également saisi, ordonner sa licitation pour parvenir au partage de l’indivision » (could, in enforcement of the divorce judgment and after rejecting the preferential attribution claim for the disputed property that was also before him, order its auction sale so as to achieve partition of the joint ownership) (Com., 10 July 2019, No 18-16.867). So the sequence your lawyer will describe is real and routinely applied: try agreement, record the deadlock, ask the court, and if the flat cannot go to one of you, the court sells it and splits the money.

B. Life in limbo: who lives in the flat, who pays the bills, and what the occupier owes you

While the sale is blocked, three questions burn your cash every month: who may stay in the home, who pays the mortgage and charges, and whether the one who stays owes anything to the one who left. French law answers all three, and each answer is money you can reclaim. First, occupation. The spouse who remained in the former family home often believes that staying put costs nothing once the divorce is final. That belief ended, in its bluntest form, through Article 815-9 of the Civil Code, whose second paragraph states: « L’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité. » (A co-owner who uses or enjoys the jointly owned asset privately owes compensation to the joint ownership, unless otherwise agreed.) The indemnité d’occupation (occupation compensation, a monthly sum the private occupier pays to the co-ownership) is not rent and not damages; it is the price of enjoying alone what belongs to two people, and it runs until the partition is complete.

Two very recent decisions of the First Civil Chamber (Première chambre civile, the division of the Court of Cassation that hears family and property cases) refined exactly when that compensation is owed, and expatriates should read both before writing any angry letter. On 30 April 2025, pourvoi No 23-16.963, the Court quashed a ruling that had ordered compensation merely because one co-owner lived alone in the flat, holding that « la circonstance que l’un des titulaires d’un droit de jouissance indivise occupe seul l’immeuble ne caractérise pas, en soi, une occupation privative, laquelle suppose en outre que son occupation exclue la même utilisation par son cotitulaire » (the fact that one holder of a joint right of enjoyment occupies the building alone does not, by itself, establish private occupation, which further requires that his occupation exclude the same use by his co-owner) (Civ. 1, 30 April 2025, No 23-16.963). In practice, if your ex changed the locks or simply made return impossible, the exclusion is easy to show; if you left voluntarily and never asked to come back, expect a fight on this point and gather your evidence early. Then, on 12 June 2025, pourvoi No 23-22.003 — a genuine post-divorce case, spouses married with no prenuptial agreement, the husband kept using the formerly common home after an order had granted him its use for payment — the Court confirmed that the compensation runs until the partition, but quashed the appeal ruling for ordering it « sans réserver l’hypothèse de la remise effective du bien à la disposition de l’indivision avant le partage » (without reserving the possibility that the property was effectively handed back to the joint ownership before the partition) (Civ. 1, 12 June 2025, No 23-22.003). The tactical lesson is symmetrical and precious: if you are the one locked out, document that you cannot use the home; if you are the occupier who wants to stop the meter running, hand the keys back formally — for instance by registered letter placing the property at the disposal of the indivision — rather than simply moving out in silence.

Second, the bills. The mortgage instalments, the property tax, the building charges and the insurance that you keep paying alone are not lost; they become claims inside the partition. Article 815-13 of the Civil Code provides: « Lorsqu’un indivisaire a amélioré à ses frais l’état d’un bien indivis, il doit lui en être tenu compte selon l’équité, eu égard à ce dont la valeur du bien se trouve augmentée au temps du partage ou de l’aliénation. Il doit lui être pareillement tenu compte des dépenses nécessaires qu’il a faites de ses deniers personnels pour la conservation desdits biens, encore qu’elles ne les aient point améliorés. » (Where a co-owner has improved a jointly owned asset at his own expense, this must be credited to him in fairness, having regard to the increase in the asset’s value at the time of partition or sale. Likewise he must be credited for necessary expenditure he made from his own funds to preserve the assets, even where it did not improve them.) Mortgage capital repayments that reduced the common debt, urgent roof repairs, insurance that kept the building covered: every euro is credited to you when the accounts are drawn up, supported by bank statements and invoices you should be collecting now, from abroad if necessary, month by month. Note the mirror rule at the end of the same article — the co-owner answers for damage his fault caused — so photograph the state of the flat whenever you can lawfully access it, and report any deterioration in writing.

Third, day-to-day control while the deadlock lasts. Many expatriates do not realise that a two-thirds majority of the ownership can already take routine steps: Article 815-3 of the Civil Code allows the co-owner or co-owners holding at least two thirds of the joint rights to carry out administrative acts, renew ordinary leases and sell joint movables to pay the debts of the co-ownership — but the consent of all co-owners remains required for any act outside normal exploitation of the assets and for any act of disposal. With a 50/50 split, which is the usual expatriate situation, that majority does not exist, so neither of you can sell, mortgage or give notice on the flat alone; but the article still matters because it shows the judge that the legislature expects blocked co-owners to come to court rather than act unilaterally. Do not try to force the outcome yourself: renting out the flat over your ex’s signature, changing the locks, or emptying the joint account to pay yourself back are the gestures that turn a winning partition file into a losing fault file, as the firm’s guide to urgent orders when a spouse empties accounts or sells behind your back explains for the period before the divorce is final.

II. Forcing the sale in France when your ex says no: from deadlock to cash in your account

A. The notaire, then the judge: deadlock report, partition writ, preferential award or auction

The forced sale is not a single court hearing; it is a corridor with three doors, and understanding the corridor is what turns years of stalemate into a scheduled auction date. Door one is the notaire. After the divorce, liquidation of the matrimonial property (liquidation du régime matrimonial, the accounting operation that lists the assets, values them, settles each spouse’s claims and proposes the split) normally goes through a notaire, often the one named in the divorce judgment. Your lawyer asks the notaire to attempt the amicable partition and, when your ex refuses to sign or to appear, to draw up the formal record of deadlock (procès-verbal de difficultés or de carence, the written statement that agreement proved impossible). That document is gold: it names the refuser, lists the disputed points, and opens the court door. If your divorce was by mutual consent without a judge (divorce par consentement mutuel sans juge, the French no-fault route where two lawyers and a notaire’s filing replace the hearing), the signed agreement normally already settles the flat — this guide is for everyone else, where consent has collapsed.

Door two is the writ. Your avocat (a lawyer admitted to a French bar, the only professional who can represent you before the court) serves an assignation en partage (a formal summons demanding judicial partition) before the tribunal judiciaire (the general civil court that absorbed the old family courts; in Paris it sits in the modern courthouse at Porte de Clichy, with the family chambers handling international files daily). Precision matters from the first page, because Article 1360 of the Code of Civil Procedure warns: « A peine d’irrecevabilité, l’assignation en partage contient un descriptif sommaire du patrimoine à partager et précise les intentions du demandeur quant à la répartition des biens ainsi que les diligences entreprises en vue de parvenir à un partage amiable. » (On pain of inadmissibility, the partition summons must contain a summary description of the estate to be shared and state the claimant’s intentions as to the distribution of the assets, together with the steps taken with a view to reaching an amicable partition.) A writ that merely says you want your money, without describing the flat, stating whether you seek attribution or sale, and proving you first tried agreement, can be thrown out before the merits are even examined. This is where expatriate files fail most often: foreign marriage certificates without certified translation, no valuation of the Paris flat, no record of the settlement attempts. Assemble all three before suing.

Door three is the judge’s choice, and it has exactly two exits. The court first asks whether one of you should keep the home through attribution préférentielle (preferential attribution, the mechanism by which the court allocates the whole asset to one co-owner against a cash balancing payment to the other). After divorce, that allocation is never automatic: Article 1476, second paragraph provides that « pour les communautés dissoutes par divorce, séparation de corps ou séparation de biens, l’attribution préférentielle n’est jamais de droit » (for communities dissolved by divorce, legal separation or separation of property, preferential attribution is never a matter of right). The judge weighs the interests on each side — children still housed there, ability to finance the balancing payment (soulte, the cash sum the one who keeps an asset pays to the other to balance the shares), professional use of the premises — and either spouse may apply. But the Court of Cassation polices the boundaries of this favour strictly in the debtor’s interest: on 7 February 2018, pourvoi No 16-26.892, it quashed an appeal court that had granted the husband the former family home and then ordered its amicable sale, failing that its auction, if he did not pay the balancing sum within six months, ruling « Vu l’article 1476, alinéa 2, du code civil » and holding that « ce texte ne prévoit aucune cause de déchéance du droit à l’attribution préférentielle qu’il institue au profit d’un époux, lorsque la communauté a été dissoute par divorce, séparation de corps ou séparation de biens » (this text provides for no forfeiture of the right to preferential attribution that it creates for a spouse, where the community was dissolved by divorce, legal separation or separation of property), adding « Qu’en statuant ainsi, la cour d’appel a violé le texte susvisé » (in ruling as it did, the appeal court violated the aforementioned text) (Civ. 1, 7 February 2018, No 16-26.892). The message cuts both ways and both sides should hear it: the keeper cannot be stripped of the attribution as a punishment for late payment, while the one who is bought out gets a court-set payment backed by the property itself.

Where neither spouse can or should keep the home — the classic expatriate case, with one party abroad and no financing for a buyout — the court orders the licitation. The judgment fixes the mechanics: a court-appointed notaire to run the operations, the starting price (mise à prix, the floor price below which the bidding starts), the conditions of sale, and usually sale by private treaty first (vente amiable, an ordinary sale on the market under court supervision) with auction at the bar of the court (adjudication à la barre du tribunal, the public auction held at the courthouse) as the fallback if no buyer meets the price. Article 1273 of the Code of Civil Procedure frames this: « Le tribunal détermine la mise à prix de chacun des biens à vendre et les conditions essentielles de la vente. Il peut préciser qu’à défaut d’enchères atteignant cette mise à prix, la vente pourra se faire sur une mise à prix inférieure qu’il fixe. » (The court sets the starting price of each asset to be sold and the essential conditions of the sale. It may specify that, failing bids reaching that starting price, the sale may proceed on a lower starting price which it sets.) Your leverage as the seller is therefore concrete and early: commission an independent valuation, propose a realistic starting price with evidence from recent sales in the arrondissement, and ask for staged reductions so the auction cannot stall forever. At any point before the hammer falls, both of you may still walk back through the amicable door: Article 842 of the Civil Code recalls that « A tout moment, les copartageants peuvent abandonner les voies judiciaires et poursuivre le partage à l’amiable si les conditions prévues pour un partage de cette nature sont réunies. » (At any time, the parties may abandon the court route and pursue an amicable partition if the conditions for such a partition are met.) Many Paris auctions never happen because the auction date concentrates minds — but only the party who filed can force that date to exist.

B. Your money, your costs, your borders: valuation date, balancing payment, expenses, fees, and acting from abroad

The sale price is only the beginning of the money. What you actually receive is your share of the net proceeds after the court settles four layers of accounts, and each layer is a place where expatriates win or lose thousands of euros. Layer one is the valuation date. Article 829 of the Civil Code provides: « En vue de leur répartition, les biens sont estimés à leur valeur à la date de la jouissance divise telle qu’elle est fixée par l’acte de partage, en tenant compte, s’il y a lieu, des charges les grevant. Cette date est la plus proche possible du partage. » (For distribution purposes, the assets are valued at their value on the date of divided enjoyment as fixed by the partition deed, taking into account, where applicable, the charges encumbering them. That date is as close as possible to the partition.) In a rising Paris market, the years your ex spent blocking the sale therefore work for you, not against you: the flat is valued near the partition, not at the divorce date, and the staller cannot pocket the appreciation. Conversely, if the market fell, the loss is shared — one more reason to file promptly rather than wait.

Layer two is the balancing payment. Whoever keeps an asset worth more than their share owes the other a soulte, and the default rule is unforgiving: Article 832-4 of the Civil Code states « Sauf accord amiable entre les copartageants, la soulte éventuellement due est payable comptant. » (Unless amicably agreed otherwise between the parties, any balancing payment due is payable in cash, immediately.) After divorce, Article 1476 even allows the court to order the whole sum payable at once. If your ex demands the flat but offers payment over ten years with no security, that is not the legal default, and your lawyer should say so firmly. Layer three is the expense account: every mortgage instalment, tax bill and repair you paid alone, credited under Article 815-13 as explained above, plus the occupation compensation your ex owes the indivision under Article 815-9, all set off against each other in the notaire’s final statement (décompte). Keep a single file — bank transfers with references, tax notices, invoices, the registered letter handing the property back or demanding access — because the partition account is arithmetic, and arithmetic rewards the organised.

Layer four is the cost of the fight itself. French courts rarely make the loser pay the winner’s full legal bill, but they routinely order a fixed contribution under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure — the three Cassation decisions cited in this guide themselves ordered 2,700 and 3,000 euros on that basis — and the notaire’s fees, the valuation costs and the auction expenses normally come out of the joint funds before the split, which means the blocking spouse effectively pays half of the procedure their refusal made necessary. Ask your lawyer to claim an Article 700 award expressly, quantified with invoices, and to seek that the costs of the partition burden the party whose obstruction caused them. It will not make you whole, but on a Paris file it regularly returns several thousand euros and, just as importantly, it prices future obstruction.

Two border questions complete the picture for expatriates. First, the divorce itself: if you divorced outside France, the French notaire and the land registry (service de publicité foncière, the office that records who owns French real estate) need a recognisable divorce before they touch the title. Divorces granted in another EU Member State are in principle recognised in France without a separate court validation under the EU divorce-recognition rules (Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, Brussels II ter, available on EUR-Lex), so bring the foreign decree with a certified French translation and, where applicable, the EU certificate that travels with it; decrees from outside the EU need closer checking by your lawyer before the notaire can act on them, so start that verification before the buyer’s offer arrives. Second, distance: you do not need to live in France to force the sale. The summons, the valuations and most of the procedure run through your avocat on a power of attorney (pouvoir), hearings before the JAF are handled by counsel, and the auction proceeds are held by the notaire or the court’s appointed sequestrator until the final split — which is also why appointing counsel early, while the file is still a refusal rather than a ruin, decides the outcome more than any single hearing.

In Paris and Île-de-France, the procedure has practical features worth anticipating. Valuations must speak the language of the Paris market — recent sales in the same arrondissement, surface in square metres under the loi Carrez measurement, deductions for occupancy and for any protected tenancy — because a starting price pitched from a foreign capital’s market will be cut down at the first hearing. Foreign documents arrive with an apostille or legalisation plus a translation by a traducteur assermenté (sworn translator), and foreign marriage certificates, divorce decrees and loan statements should be translated before filing, not after the judge asks. Timelines in the busy Paris and Nanterre family chambers run in months from writ to judgment, then further months for the supervised sale, which is why the occupation compensation and the expense account described above matter so much: they are the mechanism that makes delay expensive for the staller and neutral for you. Where children remain in the home, the judge weighs their schooling and stability before ordering sale or attribution, so coordinate this file with your custody arrangements rather than running the two on contradictory lines. And where the same breakup also produced a compensatory payment claim — the prestation compensatoire, the lump sum that offsets the disparity in living standards created by the divorce — handle the two tracks consistently, as the firm’s guide to claiming and fixing the compensatory payment explains, because a property windfall on one track always echoes on the other.

Conclusion

A former spouse who refuses to sell the French home after divorce holds a far weaker hand than the silence suggests. The marriage is over but the co-ownership continues, and French law refuses to let that continuation become a prison: Article 815 lets either party demand partition at any time, Article 840 sends refusals straight to court, and the judge can allocate the home to one of you against a cash balancing payment or sell it at auction and divide the price. While the deadlock lasts, the occupier pays compensation to the joint ownership and the payer of the bills builds a credit for every euro, with the Court of Cassation’s 2025 decisions drawing the exact line between mere solitary occupation and compensable private enjoyment. The procedure rewards the methodical — deadlock recorded by the notaire, a partition writ that states its case precisely, a realistic auction price supported by Paris comparables, and a complete expense file — and it punishes improvisation, from self-help lock changes to writs with no valuation. For expatriates, the decisive steps can all be taken from abroad through a French avocat: start the file while the refusal is fresh, keep every proof in one translated bundle, and let the auction date do the negotiating that years of messages never achieved.

📄 Official circular