KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Ex Refuses to Sign: Who Decides School, Health, Passport and Travel for Your Child in France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Ex Refuses to Sign: Who Decides School, Health, Passport and Travel for Your Child in France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your former partner has just refused to sign your child’s school registration, blocked the passport application, or said no to a planned trip abroad. You live in France, parental authority is joint, and every decision seems to require a signature you will never get. This guide explains, for English-speaking parents in France, which everyday decisions one parent can take alone, which ones truly need both signatures, and how the family judge settles the disagreement when dialogue is impossible.

French law starts from a simple principle: separation changes nothing about parental authority. Article 373-2 of the Civil Code states: “La séparation des parents est sans incidence sur les règles de dévolution de l’exercice de l’autorité parentale.” (Separation has no effect on the rules governing how parental authority is exercised.) In practice, the parent who refuses to sign is not automatically punished, and the parent who wants to move forward cannot simply bypass the other. Everything depends on whether the decision counts as a routine matter or an important one, and, for travel documents and departures from France, on a set of specific administrative and judicial locks. The pages below walk through school, health, identity papers and travel in that order, then explain the exact path before the juge aux affaires familiales, the family court judge universally known by its initials JAF, including what happened in three recent Court of Cassation rulings from 2025 and 2026 that directly concern expatriate families.

I. My Ex Refuses to Sign: Which School, Health and Daily Decisions Need Both Parents in France

A. Routine decisions one parent takes alone and important decisions that need both signatures

Parental authority, called autorité parentale, is defined by article 371-1 of the Civil Code as follows: “L’autorité parentale est un ensemble de droits et de devoirs ayant pour finalité l’intérêt de l’enfant.” (Parental authority is a set of rights and duties whose purpose is the best interests of the child.) When parents live apart but exercise this authority jointly, daily life would be paralysed if every small choice required two signatures. French law therefore presumes agreement for routine matters. Article 372-2 provides: “A l’égard des tiers de bonne foi, chacun des parents est réputé agir avec l’accord de l’autre, quand il fait seul un acte usuel de l’autorité parentale relativement à la personne de l’enfant.” (Towards third parties acting in good faith, each parent is deemed to act with the agreement of the other when performing alone a routine act of parental authority concerning the child.)

A routine act, known as an acte usuel, covers the ordinary steps of daily life: renewing school canteen registration, signing a permission slip for a school outing, taking a feverish child to the paediatrician, or buying glasses with a standard prescription. Schools, doctors and administrations rely on this presumption every day, which is why one signature is normally enough for these steps. An important act, called an acte grave or acte non usuel, is a decision that shapes the child’s life in a lasting way, and it requires the agreement of both parents whenever authority is joint. Courts consistently place the following in the important category: the first enrolment in a school or a change of school, a change of educational path, a surgical operation under general anaesthetic, a long-term or irreversible medical treatment, vaccinations where the parents openly disagree, the first issuance of a passport or identity card, and any departure abroad that the other parent opposes.

The borderline is where most expatriate disputes arise. Re-enrolling a child in the same school for the next year is routine, but moving the child from a French public collège to an international school, a bilingual programme or a school abroad is important and needs both parents. A standard dental check-up is routine, while orthodontic treatment lasting two years, with a heavy cost and medical consequences, is treated as important by most family judges. A general practitioner visit is routine, but a decision about psychotherapy, an operation, or treatment abroad requires joint agreement. When the other parent has stated a written refusal, the third party is no longer in good faith if it proceeds on one signature alone: a school that enrols a child knowing that one parent objects, or an administration that issues a document despite a recorded objection, exposes itself to a court challenge. That is why your first reflex should always be to put the refusal in writing, keep the emails and messages, and ask the school or the doctor for a written statement of what they require before moving the file forward.

A common mistake is to believe that the parent with whom the child mainly lives decides everything. Residence and authority are two different things. Even when the child’s main residence is fixed with the mother, the father keeps the full exercise of joint authority, and vice versa. The parent who does not have daily residence keeps the right and the duty to supervise the child’s upbringing and must be informed of important choices. Only a court decision granting exclusive exercise of authority to one parent changes this balance, and judges grant it sparingly, only when the child’s interest commands it, as article 373-2-1 states: “Si l’intérêt de l’enfant le commande, le juge peut confier l’exercice de l’autorité parentale à l’un des deux parents.” (Where the child’s interest so requires, the judge may entrust the exercise of parental authority to one of the two parents.) For parents who suffer a systematic blockade on every topic, rather than a disagreement on one identified decision, the remedy is different and heavier, and it is described in our guide on how to obtain exclusive parental authority in France.

B. Passport, identity card and holidays abroad: the papers your ex can block and the locks you can use

Identity papers concentrate every difficulty. In France, a minor’s passport or national identity card is applied for by a legal representative, and the application declares the child’s parentage and residence. In practice, prefectures and town halls ask for proof that the applying parent exercises parental authority, and when the other parent has lodged a written objection, the file stalls. The same parent can also go further and file an opposition to the child’s departure from France, known as opposition à la sortie du territoire or OST: a fast administrative procedure, handled by the prefecture or, in Paris, by the préfecture de police, that blocks the child’s exit for a limited period when there is an imminent risk of removal. The official service-public guide on parental conflict over a child’s departure explains both the OST and the judicial route in detail (see the service-public fiche on parental conflict over a minor leaving the country).

A separate document matters for ordinary holidays: the autorisation de sortie du territoire, abbreviated AST. Since 2017, a minor who travels abroad without a parent holding parental authority must carry this form, signed by one holder of authority, together with a copy of that parent’s identity document. The AST is not stamped by any administration; it is a private form, but airlines and border police check it systematically. When your child travels with you and you hold joint authority, you do not need the AST, unless a court order or a registered objection says otherwise. When the child travels with grandparents, a new partner, a school group or an airline unaccompanied-minor service, the AST signed by either parent is enough, and a former partner who refuses to sign it can paralyse the trip.

The heavy lock is the judicial exit ban, called interdiction de sortie du territoire or IST. The family judge may order it to protect the child’s ties with both parents. Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code provides: “Le juge peut prendre les mesures permettant de garantir la continuité et l’effectivité du maintien des liens de l’enfant avec chacun de ses parents.” (The judge may take measures to guarantee the continuity and effectiveness of the child’s ties with each of his or her parents.) It continues: “Il peut notamment ordonner l’interdiction de sortie de l’enfant du territoire français sans l’autorisation des deux parents.” (The judge may in particular order a ban on the child leaving French territory without the authorisation of both parents.) Once ordered, the ban is entered in the wanted-persons file, the fichier des personnes recherchées, by the public prosecutor, and border police enforce it at every airport and border crossing. An IST lasts until the child comes of age unless the judge lifts or narrows it, and it blocks both parents equally, including the parent who requested it, for every trip, holidays included.

That symmetry was softened by a landmark ruling that every binational family should know. On 1 July 2026, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in decision pourvoi no 25-21.064, arrêt no 506, concerning a French father and an Australian-American mother with two children in alternating residence, held that a general exit ban interferes with private and family life and the right to travel and must remain necessary and proportionate. The Court stated: “Il en résulte qu’elle peut être limitée, le cas échéant, au seul parent susceptible de porter atteinte à la continuité et l’effectivité du maintien des liens de l’enfant avec l’autre parent.” (It follows that the ban may be limited, where appropriate, to the parent liable to undermine the continuity and effectiveness of the child’s ties with the other parent.) Concretely, if only one parent presents a genuine risk of wrongful removal, the judge can now aim the ban at that parent alone and leave the other parent able to travel with the child. If you are subject to a general ban that predates this ruling, or if you need a ban targeted at a former partner who threatens to leave, this decision is the reference to place at the centre of your application, and it also supports a request to lift or narrow an existing ban when circumstances have changed.

Do not confuse these judicial tools with the criminal route. If your former partner has already taken the child abroad without your consent, the file becomes an international abduction case under the 1980 Hague Convention, with emergency return proceedings, and you should read our guide on the Hague return order when your ex has taken your child from France. If you plan to leave France with your child after a separation, different authorisation rules apply, described in our guide on leaving France with your child and the judge’s authorisation.

II. Asking the Family Judge to Decide: JAF Authorisation, the Child’s Voice and What Paris Expects

A. Seizing the JAF, what the judge weighs, and how your child is heard

When one identified decision is blocked, the competent judge is the JAF of the tribunal judiciaire of the child’s residence. Article 373-2-8 of the Civil Code opens this door widely: “Le juge peut également être saisi par l’un des parents ou le ministère public, qui peut lui-même être saisi par un tiers, parent ou non, à l’effet de statuer sur les modalités d’exercice de l’autorité parentale et sur la contribution à l’entretien et à l’éducation de l’enfant.” (The judge may also be seised by either parent or by the public prosecutor, who may himself be seised by a third party, relative or not, to rule on the terms of exercise of parental authority and on the contribution to the child’s maintenance and upbringing.) You do not need to file for divorce or to reopen the whole custody arrangement to ask for one authorisation: a petition focused on the blocked decision, school enrolment, a passport application, a defined holiday trip, a medical treatment, is enough. Representation by a lawyer is mandatory before the JAF, and in genuine urgency, a school year starting in September, an operation scheduled next month, flights already booked, your lawyer can request an accelerated hearing date rather than the ordinary timetable.

The judge does not rubber-stamp the first parent who files. Article 373-2-11 lists what the court must weigh: “Lorsqu’il se prononce sur les modalités d’exercice de l’autorité parentale, le juge prend notamment en considération : 1° La pratique que les parents avaient précédemment suivie ou les accords qu’ils avaient pu antérieurement conclure ; 2° Les sentiments exprimés par l’enfant mineur dans les conditions prévues à l’article 388-1 ; 3° L’aptitude de chacun des parents à assumer ses devoirs et respecter les droits de l’autre ;” (When ruling on the terms of exercise of parental authority, the judge takes into consideration, in particular: 1. the practice the parents previously followed or agreements they previously reached; 2. the feelings expressed by the minor child under the conditions set out in article 388-1; 3. the aptitude of each parent to assume his or her duties and respect the rights of the other.) The list continues with expert opinions, social enquiries, and any physical or psychological pressure or violence by one parent against the other. Three points deserve emphasis for expatriate parents. First, past practice counts: if both parents always chose bilingual schooling, or always spent August in the same country, the parent defending continuity starts ahead. Second, your attitude counts as much as your arguments: a parent who informs, proposes alternatives and documents every step looks very different from a parent who enrols the child in secret or books non-refundable flights before any agreement. Third, pressure and disparagement backfire: messages threatening the other parent, or involving the child in the conflict, are routinely quoted in judgments and weigh against their author.

Your child’s voice has a defined place in this process. Article 388-1 of the Civil Code provides that a minor capable of discernment may be heard by the judge in any proceedings concerning him or her, and adds: “Cette audition est de droit lorsque le mineur en fait la demande.” (This hearing is a matter of right where the minor so requests.) The hearing, called audition de l’enfant, is not testimony under oath: the child is heard alone or with a lawyer or a trusted adult, the hearing does not make the child a party to the case, since “L’audition du mineur ne lui confère pas la qualité de partie à la procédure.” (Hearing the minor does not confer the status of party to the proceedings.) In practice, judges hear children from around seven or eight years old when they are mature enough, with growing weight given to teenagers, particularly on school choice and holidays. A teenager’s reasoned wish to join an international section or to spend holidays with grandparents abroad will not decide the case alone, but a judge who ignores it must explain why. Prepare your child honestly: the judge will ask what the child wants, not which parent is right, and any sign of coaching damages the parent suspected of it. Our guide on the child’s hearing and the enforcement of custody and visitation describes this audition step by step.

A practical file wins these cases. Assemble the family record book or the child’s birth certificate, the current court orders or the divorce agreement, the written refusal of the other parent with dates, and, for each decision, one independent proof of the child’s interest: a letter from the school confirming the requested place and the registration deadline, a medical certificate describing the treatment and its timing, the prefecture receipt or the passport tracking slip showing the blocked application, flight or booking confirmations for the trip, and, for travel cases, a detailed return plan with dates, address abroad and school calendar showing no missed classes beyond reason. Add proof that you sought agreement first: dated letters proposing precise dates, cost sharing and catch-up contact time for the other parent. Judges reward the parent who builds solutions and penalise the parent who builds obstacles, and legal aid, called aide juridictionnelle, can cover fees for eligible households, with victim-support associations and the maison de justice et du droit network offering orientation regardless of income.

B. Health and school: what judges can authorise, what they cannot delegate, and how Paris handles these cases

Health disputes follow a strict logic that a March 2025 ruling clarified for the whole country. The Paris Court of Appeal had authorised a mother, exercising joint authority with the father, to take alone medical decisions involving necessity or emergency, after first seeking the father’s view, where he failed to reply or objected without legitimate reason and without efficient counter-proposals. The Court of Cassation quashed that arrangement. In pourvoi no 22-20.631, arrêt no 138 of 5 March 2025, it held: “En statuant ainsi, alors qu’elle avait constaté que les parents exerçaient en commun l’autorité parentale, la cour d’appel, qui a délégué à la mère son pouvoir de trancher les éventuels conflits d’autorité parentale relativement à certaines décisions concernant la santé de l’enfant, a méconnu l’étendue de ses pouvoirs et violé les textes susvisés.” (In ruling as it did, when it had found that the parents exercised parental authority jointly, the Court of Appeal, which delegated to the mother its own power to resolve possible parental-authority conflicts over certain decisions concerning the child’s health, misconceived the extent of its powers and breached the cited provisions.) The message is blunt: the judge cannot give one parent a blank authorisation to decide all future health disagreements alone. Each blocked health decision must come back before the judge, who authorises or refuses it on its own merits. For expatriate parents, the consequence is practical. Do not ask the JAF for a general power to decide health matters in the other parent’s place; you will lose on this point even if the rest of your case is strong. Ask instead for authorisation of the identified treatment, supported by a medical certificate, with a second medical opinion if the other parent disputes necessity, and propose a review clause for the next stage of treatment.

School disputes are the most frequent cases in family courts each September. The pattern repeats: one parent enrols the child without telling the other, or one parent refuses the school the other has chosen. Judges apply the same criteria as above, with two specifics. Continuity of schooling carries heavy weight: a child settled in a school, with friends, results and activities, will rarely be moved mid-cycle for a parent’s preference alone, particularly where the requesting parent offers no new element since the last order. The parent who enrols unilaterally starts with a handicap, because the enrolment disregards joint authority and the aptitude criterion penalises disrespect for the other parent’s rights. If the school year is about to start and one parent blocks every option, the judge can authorise enrolment in a named school for the coming year, fix who signs the papers, and order the blocking parent to cooperate, with a penalty payment, called astreinte, for non-compliance. Where parents disagree on language paths, French track against international section, German bilingual class against English, judges look at the child’s results, the teachers’ opinions, the languages spoken at home, and the coherence of the plan with the child’s future residence. An expatriate family that documents the child’s bilingual progress and obtains a written opinion from the current school stands far stronger than a family arguing in abstract terms about which language matters more.

Paris adds its own practical layer that English-speaking residents should know. Cases are heard by the family chamber of the tribunal judiciaire de Paris, located at Porte de Clichy, where the JAF sits with heavy caseloads and strict filing requirements through a lawyer. For passport blockades, the Paris prefecture de police handles OST requests, and its online procedure expects the judgment or agreement, proof of authority, the written refusal, and any evidence of travel risk such as tickets or messages. Mediation has become a standard step: the Paris JAF regularly orders family mediation, called médiation familiale, before deciding contested parental cases, and a parent who refuses mediation without reason may find the judge drawing conclusions about attitude. Our guide on JAF-ordered family mediation, its cost and the effect of refusal explains how to approach it. None of this replaces the core principle recalled by a third recent ruling: exclusive authority remains the exception. On 10 September 2025, in pourvoi no 23-15.309, arrêt no 542, the Court of Cassation quashed a decision granting a mother exclusive authority based mainly on criminal proceedings against the father, holding: “En se déterminant ainsi, sans examiner si, au regard des circonstances particulières de la cause, l’intérêt de l’enfant, apprécié de manière concrète, commandait que l’exercice de l’autorité parentale soit confié à la mère seule, la cour d’appel a privé sa décision de base légale.” (In ruling as it did, without examining whether, given the particular circumstances of the case, the child’s interest, assessed concretely, required that exercise of parental authority be entrusted to the mother alone, the Court of Appeal deprived its decision of legal basis.) The lesson for blocked parents is symmetrical: do not frame a single refusal over school, a passport or a trip as a request for exclusive authority, because the judge will reject the excess; frame it as a request for one defined authorisation, reasoned by the child’s interest and documented piece by piece. The broader framework of joint authority after separation is set out on the official service-public page on the exercise of parental authority and the page on identity papers for minors, and the firm’s family practice in Paris is presented at family lawyers in Paris.

Conclusion

A former partner who refuses every signature does not hold an absolute veto, but neither can you act alone on important matters. Routine daily steps remain possible on one signature under the presumption of agreement; first school enrolments, changes of school path, significant medical decisions, passports and departures from France require both parents or the family judge. The JAF decides disagreement by disagreement, listening to the child, weighing past practice and each parent’s attitude, and authorising the defined step the child’s interest supports. Recent case law has sharpened both edges of this system: exit bans can now be targeted at the parent who truly presents a risk, while judges may no longer hand one parent a general power to settle future health disputes alone. Build your file in that spirit, one decision, one proof and one proposal at a time, seek agreement in writing before seizing the court, and ask the judge for the precise authorisation your child needs now rather than a broad victory over the other parent. That focused approach is what Paris family judges reward, and it is what gets school places secured, treatments started and passports issued before the opportunity passes.

📄 Official circular