Kohen Avocats · Paris law firm
—

Maître Hassan KOHEN assists English-speaking clients throughout France, including in urgent proceedings. Initial strategic review: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Attorney-client privilege · No commitment

Paris Bar Urgent defence & litigation Official CNB profile (avocat.fr)
Hassan Kohen, immigration lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney · Paris Bar

French Citizenship by Decree Refused or Adjourned? How to Appeal Before the Nantes Courts (2026 Guide)

Speak with a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Every year, thousands of foreign residents apply for French citizenship by decree, and every year a significant share of them receive a painful letter: the administration refuses the application outright or postpones it for two or more years. The disappointment is real, but a refusal or an adjournment is not the end of the road. French law organises a precise two-stage challenge: first a mandatory appeal to the minister in charge of naturalisations, then judicial review before the tribunal administratif de Nantes (Nantes administrative court), with a possible appeal to the Nantes court of appeal. Each stage has strict deadlines, and each rewards applicants who answer the exact ground stated in the decision rather than repeating their original file.

This guide explains, for English-speaking applicants, how to challenge a rejet (rejection) or an ajournement (adjournment) of a citizenship-by-decree application in 2026: what each decision means, how to write the mandatory ministerial appeal, what the Nantes judges actually check, and what recent rulings teach us about the grounds that succeed and the ones that fail. It is practical information, not a promise of any outcome: naturalisation remains a discretionary favour of the State, and the courts say so in nearly every ruling.

I. Rejection or Adjournment: Two Different Decisions With Different Consequences

A. Outright Rejection and the Multi-Year Adjournment

French citizenship acquired on application is governed by Article 21-15 of the Civil Code, which opens with an exception for one special statutory case, then provides that “l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger.” In plain English: becoming French this way means asking the State for a decree, and the State may say yes or no. The key word is “accordée”: naturalisation is granted, never owed. The minister carries out what the courts call an examen d’opportunité (opportunity assessment), weighing whether it is in the interest of France to make the applicant a citizen, and may lawfully rely on unfavourable information about the applicant’s behaviour.

Before any discretionary assessment, absolute legal bars apply. Article 21-27 of the Civil Code states: “Nul ne peut acquérir la nationalité française ou être réintégré dans cette nationalité s’il a été l’objet soit d’une condamnation pour crimes ou délits constituant une atteinte aux intérêts fondamentaux de la Nation ou un acte de terrorisme, soit, quelle que soit l’infraction considérée, s’il a été condamné à une peine égale ou supérieure à six mois d’emprisonnement, non assortie d’une mesure de sursis.” In other words, convictions for terrorism or offences against the fundamental interests of the Nation, any unsuspended prison sentence of six months or more, an expulsion order that has not been expressly lifted, a French territory ban (interdiction du territoire français) that has not been fully served, or residence in France that is irregular all make acquisition of nationality legally impossible. If one of these bars covers you, no appeal strategy can work until the obstacle itself is removed, and an experienced immigration lawyer in Paris will tell you so at the first meeting rather than bill you for a hopeless case.

Short of those absolute bars, the administration has two ways of saying no, set out in Article 44 of Decree No. 93-1362 of 30 December 1993: the préfet (prefect) may reject the application, or, in the words reproduced by the Nantes court, “Il peut également en prononcer l’ajournement en imposant un délai ou des conditions.” That is, he may also postpone the decision by imposing a waiting period or conditions. The minister has the mirror power at the appeal stage under Article 48 of the same decree. In practice, outright rejection (rejet) closes the file: you may apply again, but only once the stated obstacle has genuinely disappeared, and a fresh application filed the next month with an unchanged situation will fail again. Adjournment (ajournement), usually for two years, sets a clock: once the period expires or the conditions are met, you may file a new application, and the administration will examine whether the problem identified has actually been fixed.

The stated ground dictates everything that follows, so read the decision letter line by line. Recent Nantes case law shows how varied the grounds are. In one 2025 ruling, the minister relied on the applicant’s employment inside the Tunisian Foreign Bank, arguing that “l’emploi de M. A… au sein de la Tunisian Foreign Bank est de nature à caractériser un lien avec la Tunisie incompatible avec l’allégeance française” (CAA Nantes, 1 April 2025, No. 24NT00837), meaning the job was treated as evidence of a tie with Tunisia incompatible with allegiance to France. In another, the ground was recent driving without a licence after the applicant had lost all his licence points and been ordered to return the document, followed by a criminal fine (CAA Nantes, 12 September 2025, No. 24NT02593). In a third, decided in January 2026, the ground was purely economic: a part-time open-ended contract paying about 580 euros a month topped up with means-tested benefits, gaps without work between 2014 and 2019, and no declared income for 2015 to 2018 (CAA Nantes, 13 January 2026, No. 24NT03046). And in July 2026, a rejection was upheld where the applicant’s prefecture interview revealed gaps in civic knowledge and an imperfect understanding of freedom of expression under French law (CAA Nantes, 3 July 2026, No. 25NT02346). Four different profiles, four different battles: allegiance, criminal behaviour, professional insertion, civic assimilation. Your appeal must fight your battle, not a generic one.

B. The Mandatory Appeal to the Minister: Your First and Unavoidable Step

Whatever the prefect decided, your first challenge goes to the minister, never directly to a court. Article 45 of the 1993 decree provides that within two months of notification, decisions taken under Articles 43 and 44 may be appealed to the minister in charge of naturalisations, to the exclusion of any other administrative appeal, and that “Il constitue un préalable obligatoire à l’exercice d’un recours contentieux, à peine d’irrecevabilité de ce dernier, sauf pour les décisions de classement sans suite.” In English: this ministerial appeal is a mandatory prerequisite for any court action, on pain of inadmissibility of the court claim, except for decisions closing the file without examination (classement sans suite). Miss it, file it late, or send it to the wrong authority, and the court will throw out your case without ever looking at the merits. The two-month clock runs from the day you are notified of the prefect’s decision, so keep the envelope, the registered-mail slip, and any email notification: the date of notification is frequently disputed.

This recours auprès du ministre (appeal to the minister) has three features applicants often misunderstand. First, it is exclusive: you may not simultaneously petition the prefect for reconsideration (recours gracieux) or the prime minister’s office (recours hiérarchique) and expect those steps to protect your rights; only the minister’s review counts as the mandatory prerequisite. Second, you may be assisted or represented by any person of your choice, which includes a lawyer, and for files involving criminal records, complex careers, or fragile evidence, professional help at this stage is usually more valuable than at any later stage, because this is where the factual record is built. Third, the appeal must set out the reasons why a fresh examination is requested: a one-line letter saying “I disagree” wastes your only administrative shot. Go through the decision’s stated ground point by point, attach every new document that undermines it, and explain what has changed since the prefect decided.

Two practical warnings follow from the case law. First, watch what the minister actually does with your appeal, because his response reshapes the case. In a 2024 dispute, the applicant had challenged the minister’s implied rejection of his appeal against a prefectural adjournment, but the minister had in the meantime expressly confirmed the two-year postponement in a dated decision produced before the trial judges; the court of appeal held that the applicant had to be regarded as seeking annulment of that express decision, which had replaced the implied one (CAA Nantes, 18 June 2024, No. 23NT03798). The lesson: always ask the court to rule on the latest express decision, and update your claims if the minister answers during the proceedings. Second, if the minister rejects your appeal expressly or stays silent, do not waste ammunition attacking the rejection letter’s own flaws. As the Nantes court recalled, a challenge to the refusal issued on a gracious appeal “doit nécessairement être regardé comme étant dirigé, non pas tant contre le rejet du recours gracieux dont les vices propres ne peuvent être utilement contestés, que contre la décision initialement prise par l’autorité administrative” (CAA Nantes, 5 November 2019, No. 19NT01516). In English: the case is necessarily treated as directed not so much against the rejection of the further appeal, whose own defects cannot usefully be challenged, as against the decision originally taken by the administration. So keep your fire for the substance of the original refusal or adjournment.

Concretely, your ministerial appeal file should contain: a dated, signed letter identifying the contested decision by its date and reference, filed within two months of notification; a point-by-point answer to each stated ground; and documentary proof for every assertion. If the ground is professional insertion, add recent pay slips, the full-time open-ended contract, employer letters, and tax notices showing declared income. If the ground is old criminal history, add proof of rehabilitation, steady employment, family stability, and community ties since the events. If the ground is civic knowledge, show language diplomas, civic training certificates, and evidence of genuine integration efforts. Send everything by a traceable method and keep copies of the complete file: the same bundle will become the backbone of your court application if the minister says no.

II. Taking the Case to the Administrative Court in Nantes

A. What the Judge Actually Reviews: Manifest Error, Not a Second Interview

Once the minister has expressly rejected your appeal or has let it go unanswered, the dispute moves to court, and for nationality decisions taken by the minister that court is the tribunal administratif de Nantes. Every ruling discussed in this guide was decided either by that tribunal at first instance or by the Nantes court of appeal on appeal from it, which confirms where these cases live in practice. The contentious appeal must be filed within two months of the minister’s express decision; where the minister stays silent, an implied rejection arises after two months of silence and the two-month court deadline then starts running. Do not let the file sleep: unlike the prefectural stage, where delay merely postpones your plans, missing the court deadline kills the case definitively. If the minister answers late with an express decision while your court case is pending, update your claims to target that decision, as the 2024 adjournment case described above demonstrates.

Before the judge, adjust your expectations. Because naturalisation is discretionary, the court does not substitute its own assessment for the minister’s and does not grant citizenship itself. It checks for legal errors, procedural defects, wrong facts, and above all erreur manifeste d’appréciation (manifest error of assessment): was the minister’s conclusion so unreasonable, given the file, that no reasonable authority could have reached it? That is a deliberately demanding test, and most challenges fail it. In the January 2026 part-time work case, the court held that short fixed-term and part-time contracts “ne permettent pas de la regarder comme justifiant d’une insertion professionnelle pérenne, de nature à garantir son autonomie matérielle” (CAA Nantes, 13 January 2026, No. 24NT03046), meaning they did not show lasting professional integration capable of guaranteeing material self-sufficiency, and upheld the two-year adjournment despite the applicant’s long residence since 2007. In the driving-offence case, the court found that driving without a licence after losing all points, followed by a criminal fine, was recent serious misconduct at the date of the decision, and concluded that “malgré l’insertion professionnelle, sociale et familiale certaine et ancienne en France de M. B…, celui-ci n’est pas fondé à soutenir que la décision contestée d’ajournement à deux ans est entachée d’une erreur manifeste d’appréciation” (CAA Nantes, 12 September 2025, No. 24NT02593). In English: despite certain long-standing professional, social and family integration in France, the applicant could not claim the two-year adjournment was vitiated by manifest error. The message is blunt: solid integration does not neutralise a recent, serious blot on the file.

But the test is not unwinnable, and the 2024 adjournment case proves it. There, the minister had relied on a 2012 violent incident that ended with a rappel à la loi (formal warning recorded as an alternative to prosecution). The court of appeal confirmed the trial judges’ annulment, holding that “c’est à bon droit que les premiers juges ont considéré qu’en décidant, le 15 octobre 2020, d’ajourner la demande de naturalisation de l’intéressé, le ministre en charge des naturalisations avait commis une erreur manifeste d’appréciation” (CAA Nantes, 18 June 2024, No. 23NT03798). In English: the first judges were right to find that by postponing the application, the minister had committed a manifest error of assessment. Why did this applicant win where others lost? The judgment lists the winning combination explicitly: facts dating back to 2012 with no reoffending since, their isolated character, proven professional integration as a bus driver, and the uncontested context of the events. Old, isolated, followed by years of irreproachable conduct and real employment: that is the pattern that beats an adjournment based on criminal history. Note also what the court accepted along the way: the fact that an offence was never prosecuted does not prevent the minister from considering it, especially where proceedings ended in dismissal after a formal warning, since that warning as an alternative to prosecution suffices to establish authorship. Do not build your case on “I was never convicted”: build it on time passed, conduct since, and integration now.

The July 2026 civic-knowledge ruling adds a second winning-and-losing pattern worth studying. The applicant had given several correct answers at his prefecture interview in October 2021, which the minister himself acknowledged, but the interview report showed he could not give the origin of the national day, could not mention recent news items or major events in France since 2015, stated he did not know that the trial over the 13 November 2015 attacks had recently begun, had never heard of the Samuel Paty case, and gave answers revealing an imperfect understanding of freedom of expression inconsistent with French law. The court concluded that the minister, “en raison d’une connaissance insuffisante des éléments fondamentaux relatifs aux grands repères de l’histoire de la France et à une compréhension incomplète des principaux droits et devoirs liés à l’exercice de la citoyenneté française et pour ces seuls motifs”, had not committed a manifest error (CAA Nantes, 3 July 2026, No. 25NT02346). In English: for those reasons alone, based on insufficient knowledge of the fundamental features of French history and an incomplete understanding of the main rights and duties of French citizenship, the decision was lawful. Two lessons follow. First, partial success at the interview does not save you: some correct answers plus documented gaps still justifies refusal. Second, the interview report (compte-rendu d’entretien) is the decisive exhibit, so request access to your file, read that report, and address each recorded gap with fresh evidence such as civic training certificates and language diplomas before appealing.

B. Building a File That Answers the Exact Ground: Evidence, Deadlines and Realistic Outcomes

With the standard of review understood, the practical work begins. Map your evidence to the ground, ground by ground. Against a professional-insertion adjournment of the kind upheld in January 2026, the tribunal wants permanence and autonomy: a full-time open-ended contract held for a significant period, pay slips showing wages that cover your needs without means-tested top-ups, tax notices with declared income for every recent year, and employer attestations describing a stable position. A part-time contract signed a few months before the decision, combined with years of undeclared or absent income, is exactly the profile the courts let the minister reject. If your situation has genuinely improved since the decision, say so with dated documents and explain the trajectory; judges read career histories as a whole, from entry into France to the day they rule. Against a conduct-based ground, assemble the mirror file: proof of years without any incident, stable employment, family life, housing, tax compliance, and any community or associative involvement. Time plus irreproachable behaviour is the only argument the courts credit here, as the 2024 bus-driver case shows. Against a civic-assimilation ground, produce language diplomas at the required level, certificates from civic training, and concrete evidence of participation in French public life, while conceding nothing you cannot prove: if the interview report records specific gaps, fill each one rather than claiming the interview went well. Against an allegiance-type ground such as foreign employment, document the end of the problematic tie where possible, or demonstrate that the activity is purely private-sector work with no loyalty implications, supported by employer and tax evidence.

Procedure matters as much as substance. File the ministerial appeal within two months of notification by traceable means; calendar the minister’s two-month silence period; then file the court application within two months of the express or implied rejection. Name the correct defendant, attach the contested decisions in chronological order, and ask the court expressly for what it can give: annulment of the refusal or adjournment and, where useful, an order (injonction) directing the minister to re-examine the application within a stated time. Keep the request realistic. Courts do not order the administration to naturalise you: in the Tunisian Foreign Bank case, the trial court had annulled the refusal and ordered re-examination within two months, and the dispute on appeal concerned that re-examination framework, not an order to grant citizenship (CAA Nantes, 1 April 2025, No. 24NT00837). Where annulment is refused, related requests for injunctions and legal costs fall with it, as the 2019 gracious-appeal ruling confirms (CAA Nantes, 5 November 2019, No. 19NT01516). Ask for re-examination, not for a decree.

Finally, keep the parallel track in mind. An adjournment expires: when the two-year period ends, you may file a new application presenting the corrected situation, even while a court case about the old decision is still running. Sometimes the strongest strategy is sequential: appeal to protect your rights against the old decision, and simultaneously rebuild the file so the new application succeeds on its own merits. A refusal, by contrast, has no clock: reapply only when the obstacle is gone, with proof that it is gone, or the second refusal will be faster and harsher than the first. Throughout, remember that proceedings before the Nantes courts are written proceedings that move slowly, often over a year at first instance and longer on appeal, so use the waiting time to strengthen the underlying facts rather than merely waiting for a hearing date. Applicants who treat the appeal period as a time to accumulate pay slips, diplomas, and clean years consistently do better, in new applications and before judges alike, than applicants who treat it as dead time. For tailored advice on sequencing an appeal and a fresh application, a consultation with an immigration lawyer in Paris early in the two-month ministerial window is usually the highest-value step you can take.

Conclusion

A refused or adjourned citizenship-by-decree application is a setback with a defined remedy, not a final verdict. Identify whether you face a rejet or an ajournement, file a reasoned appeal to the minister within two months, then bring a focused case before the Nantes administrative court aimed at manifest error on the exact stated ground. Recent rulings draw the map clearly: old isolated misconduct followed by years of clean, employed life can overturn an adjournment, while recent offences, precarious part-time work with welfare top-ups, and documented civic-knowledge gaps at the prefecture interview will survive review. Match your evidence to your ground, respect every deadline, ask the judge for re-examination rather than for citizenship itself, and let the appeal period work for your file instead of against it.

📄 Official document

Our data comes from the Cour de cassation (Judilibre), the Conseil d'État, the DILA, the Court of Justice of the European Union and the European Court of Human Rights.

Legal database search

Find a decision, a text or an analysis

More than 100,000 decisions annotated by our artificial intelligence, indexed in real time.

    Search powered by Meilisearch on kohenavocats.com.

    What our clients say

    4,885 Google reviews
    Share your review
    Contact Mobile
    3 weeks ago

    Very satisfied! I would like to thank Maître Esther Cornu here, who managed to resolve a very complicated dispute in a divorce and family law matter...Thanks to Maître Cornu, a judgment was handed down in my favour even though it was far from a foregone conclusion...So I recommend this law firm

    Google review translated from French

    Claude Frasson
    3 weeks ago

    A precise and concrete analysis and an immediate response. Excellent.

    Google review translated from French

    Basel Alali
    3 weeks ago

    I highly recommend this lawyer for his professionalism, honesty, and transparency. He helped me successfully and guided me through the process with great care and expertise. What I particularly appreciated was his honest approach and the fact that he recommended practical, cost-effective options instead of immediately pushing for the most expensive solution. He genuinely focused on finding the right approach for my situation. I’m very grateful for his support and would definitely recommend him to anyone looking for a trustworthy and professional lawyer in France.

    beatrice lefevre
    3 weeks ago

    Thank you for this detailed, precise help, with a proposal at the end on whether or not to continue (very quick response as well)

    Google review translated from French

    Jean-pierre Steinmetz
    1 month ago

    Very good advice given by Maître Cornu during our meeting on 16 October.

    Google review translated from French

    John Roberts
    1 month ago

    Very professional and responsive service. The lawyer quickly and carefully checked the validity of my wife’s residence permit in light of a specific legal regime. His work gave us clarity, whereas the usual administrative procedures were long and ambiguous. I appreciated his efficiency and professionalism, and I recommend his services.

    Google review translated from French

    Jean-François PAPA
    1 month ago

    I would like to warmly thank Maître Esther Cornu for her professionalism, her availability and the quality of her support. In a case of particular importance for my professional future, she showed great responsiveness, rigour and a gift for explaining things, taking the time to answer my questions precisely and to explain the various legal steps to me. I particularly appreciate the clarity of her analyses, her seriousness and her commitment in following up my case. Many thanks to Maître Esther Cornu for listening and for her support. I highly recommend!

    Google review translated from French

    Sandra Imbert
    1 month ago

    A huge thank you to Maître Esther Cornu from Kohen Avocats for her support during a particularly difficult time. Her attentiveness, empathy, and humanity touched me deeply. She was able to answer my questions with clarity and sensitivity, while demonstrating great professionalism and fully respecting the confidentiality of the case. Beyond her professional qualities, I met a deeply humane lawyer whose support made a real difference. I sincerely recommend her.

    Google review translated from French

    Djamel Haddouche
    1 month ago

    I am facing a dispute with my employer, and the support provided by Maître Hassan COHEN as well as Maître Esther Cornu is excellent. The answers are clear and well-thought-out, they genuinely listen, and interactions are very pleasant. Thank you again, I highly recommend.

    Google review translated from French

    Nima Sdc
    1 month ago

    A law firm that is attentive to its clients. Maître Kohen and his team are very, very professional and truly master their field.

    Google review translated from French

    jules p
    1 month ago

    I highly recommend Cabinet Kohen, and particularly Maître Esther Cornu, who supported me throughout my case. She skillfully combined attentiveness and expertise to guide me through these difficult and stressful times. She was always available to answer all my questions with precision and responsiveness. Thanks to her preparation work, I was able to approach the situation with much greater peace of mind. Her kindness and humanity made me feel at ease throughout our exchanges. I am very grateful to her for her support and professionalism. You can trust her with your eyes closed.

    Google review translated from French

    Jocelyne Chassard
    2 months ago

    I have just spoken on the phone with Monsieur Chahdi from your law firm: I wanted to congratulate you on your online article regarding order no. 519225 of the Conseil d’État dated August 30, 2026. You clearly explained the content of this order, which does not grant prefectures a general blank check to replace a demonstration ban with a restrictive receipt modifying one or more circumstances of a demonstration, but which, in a specific case, held that the applicants had not sufficiently demonstrated a serious and disproportionate infringement on the fundamental freedom to publicly express opinions. As I told Mr. Chahdi, I am facing this restrictive receipt issue in Reims for a demonstration scheduled for tomorrow afternoon in front of the judicial court: the organizer has just filed an urgent fundamental freedom petition (référé-liberté) before the Châlons-en-Champagne Administrative Court. Monsieur Chahdi initially seemed surprised by the call from an 'ordinary citizen', but he listened to me and answered with courtesy.

    Google review translated from French

    Menah'em
    3 months ago

    I would like to express my gratitude to the Kohen Avocats law firm and especially to Maître Chahdi. From our very first phone call, Maître Chahdi was available, attentive, and offered remarkable advice. The firm's reception and follow-up reflect a very high level of standards and expertise. Many thanks to the entire team for their support and impeccable professionalism.

    Google review translated from French

    Мария Двирник
    3 weeks ago
    Moula Brahimi
    3 weeks ago

    Good experience. And good work, thank you for everything.

    Google review translated from French

    Faiza Traduction
    1 month ago
    Alain Arsaut
    1 month ago

    Saw Hassan on the TV news

    Google review translated from French

    TOULEIMAT HACHEM
    1 month ago
    emilie lepicard
    1 month ago
    إبراهيم عيسى
    1 month ago
    Monique Firmin
    2 months ago

    Excellent phone reception. Great professionalism.

    Google review translated from French

    Louna Sisi
    2 months ago

    Excellent

    Google review translated from French

    Sophie Lascar
    3 months ago
    Solal Gaillard
    3 months ago
    Preliminary case review

    Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

    Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

    • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
    • Personal reply within 24 working hours
    • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
    • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
    80 €TTC

    Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

    • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
    • Secure payment, no card details stored
    • Terms and fee agreement

    Cliquez or drag your files here
    All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

    Sending...

    Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
    Terms · Privacy policy.

    Free legal AI

    A question of French law? Ask Judith.

    Judith searches the French codes, the Constitution, the European Convention on Human Rights and the courts’ decisions, then shows you the texts and the passages of rulings that may answer your question, with their official source. Free, no account; she writes nothing for you. Questions and results are in French. Discover Judith, the firm’s free legal AI.

    Three searches a day. Your question is recorded and reviewed by the firm to improve the tool: do not enter names or sensitive information.