Since 1 January 2026, foreign nationals applying for a multi-year residence permit, a 10-year resident card, or French naturalization must pass a mandatory civic exam known as the examen civique. This multiple-choice test, introduced as part of the broader reform of the contrat dintégration républicaine (CIR, Republican Integration Contract), marks a significant departure from the earlier system under which civic knowledge was assessed informally during a prefecture interview. The reform imposes a uniform, nationwide standard: a written questionnaire with a fixed pass threshold. For English-speaking expatriates, employees, students, and long-term residents who have built their lives in France, understanding the scope and stakes of this exam has become essential to avoiding delays, refusals, or even an obligation to leave French territory.
This article provides a detailed legal and practical overview of the civic exam regime: its legislative foundations in the Code de lentrée et du séjour des étrangers et du droit dasile (CESEDA), the precise thresholds and formats applicable to each residence category, the consequences of failure, and the avenues available to challenge an unfavourable administrative decision. Every proposition is anchored in the applicable legislation and in recent rulings of the French administrative courts, which have already begun to define the contours of the new requirements.
I. The Legal Framework of Republican Integration in France
A. From the Integration Contract (CIR) to the Civic Exam
The concept of intégration républicaine (republican integration) has been a central pillar of French immigration law for over two decades. Article L. 413-7 of the CESEDA now provides that the first issuance of a multi-year residence card, a 10-year resident card bearing the mention “résident de longue durée-UE” (long-term EU resident), or a permanent resident card “est subordonnée à lintégration républicaine de létranger dans la société française, appréciée en particulier au regard du résultat obtenu à lexamen mentionné au sixième alinéa de larticle L. 413-3, qui doit être supérieur à un seuil fixé par décret, et de sa connaissance de la langue française” (is conditional upon the foreign nationals republican integration into French society, assessed in particular by reference to the result obtained in the exam mentioned in the sixth paragraph of Article L. 413-3, which must exceed a threshold set by decree, and to his or her knowledge of the French language).
The legal architecture of this obligation is set out in Articles L. 413-2 and L. 413-3 of the CESEDA. Article L. 413-2 establishes the parcours personnalisé dintégration républicaine (personalised republican integration pathway) for first-time arrivals and young residents aged 16 to 18 who intend to settle durably in France. Under this provision, the foreign national concludes a contrat dintégration républicaine (CIR) with the State, by which he or she undertakes to follow prescribed training and support programmes. Article L. 413-3 specifies the content of this pathway, which includes, at Article L. 413-3(1°), “la formation civique prescrite par lEtat, relative aux valeurs, aux principes, et aux institutions de la République, à lexercice des droits et devoirs liés à la vie en France ainsi quà lorganisation, lhistoire et la culture de la société française” (civic training prescribed by the State, relating to the values, principles and institutions of the Republic, the exercise of rights and duties associated with life in France, and the organisation, history and culture of French society).
The decisive innovation introduced by the 2026 reform lies in the sixth paragraph of Article L. 413-3, which provides that “la formation civique mentionnée au 1° donne lieu à un examen. Létranger peut se représenter à cet examen, à sa demande et à tout moment, lorsquil a obtenu un résultat inférieur aux seuils mentionnés au premier alinéa de larticle L. 413-7 et au 2° de larticle L. 433-4” (the civic training referred to in 1° gives rise to an exam. The foreign national may retake this exam at his or her request and at any time, if he or she has obtained a result below the thresholds mentioned in the first paragraph of Article L. 413-7 and in Article L. 433-4(2°)). This provision transforms what was once a largely discretionary administrative assessment into a standardised, verifiable criterion.
The regulatory details implementing this legislative framework are set out in several ministerial orders (arrêtés) and in the regulatory part of the CESEDA. Article R. 413-12 defines the scope of civic training, covering “les institutions françaises, les principes de la République, notamment ceux que létranger sengage à respecter dans le cadre du contrat dengagement visé à larticle L. 412-7, lEtat de droit, les libertés fondamentales, la sûreté des personnes et des biens, lexercice de la citoyenneté, des droits et devoirs liés à la vie en France, lhistoire les principales caractéristiques géographiques de la France et la culture de la société française, ainsi que les grandes étapes de la construction européenne” (French institutions, the principles of the Republic, particularly those the foreign national undertakes to respect under the commitment contract referred to in Article L. 412-7, the rule of law, fundamental freedoms, the safety of persons and property, the exercise of citizenship, the rights and duties associated with life in France, the history, main geographical features and culture of French society, and the major stages of European construction). Article R. 413-12-1 specifies that the civic exam “prend la forme dun questionnaire à choix multiples portant principalement sur les principes et les valeurs de la République, les droits et devoirs liés à la vie en France, lhistoire, la géographie, la culture et le système institutionnel et politique de la France” (takes the form of a multiple-choice questionnaire covering principally the principles and values of the Republic, the rights and duties associated with life in France, the history, geography, culture and institutional and political system of France).
These provisions were applied and interpreted in a significant ruling of the Administrative Court of Appeal of Nancy (Cour administrative dappel de Nancy) dated 27 January 2026, no. 25NC00716, in which the court ordered the prefect of Bas-Rhin to issue a 10-year résident de longue durée-UE card to a Cameroonian national, subject to the condition that the applicant produce an attestation of success in the civic exam. The court held that “la délivrance à M. B… dune carte de résident portant la mention “résident de longue durée-UE” implique toutefois que le préfet saisisse pour avis la maire de Strasbourg (…) Elle implique également, depuis le 1er janvier 2026, que M. B… présente lattestation de sa réussite à lexamen civique” (the issuance to Mr B. of a resident card bearing the mention “long-term EU resident” implies, however, that the prefect seek the opinion of the Mayor of Strasbourg (…) It also implies, since 1 January 2026, that Mr B. produce an attestation of success in the civic exam). This judgment confirms the non-waivable character of the civic exam requirement for the issuance of a carte de résident de longue durée-UE.
Relatedly, applicants for any residence document must also sign the contrat dengagement au respect des principes de la République provided for in Article L. 412-7 of the CESEDA, by which the foreign national undertakes to “respecter la liberté personnelle, la liberté dexpression et de conscience, légalité entre les femmes et les hommes, la dignité de la personne humaine, la devise et les symboles de la République au sens de larticle 2 de la Constitution, lintégrité territoriale” (respect personal freedom, freedom of expression and conscience, equality between women and men, the dignity of the human person, the motto and symbols of the Republic within the meaning of Article 2 of the Constitution, and territorial integrity). As noted by the CAA Nancy in the same decision, Article R. 412-1 requires the applicant to produce a signed copy of this contract with each application for a residence document, emphasising that the contract is now a procedural prerequisite for any grant of a residence title.
B. When the Civic Exam Becomes Mandatory: The 2026 Thresholds
The obligation to pass the civic exam applies at two distinct levels, depending on the residence document sought.
First, the multi-year residence card (carte de séjour pluriannuelle). Article L. 433-4 of the CESEDA, which governs the issuance of multi-year cards, incorporates the civic exam result as a condition of renewal or first issuance. The CAA Nancy decision of 27 January 2026 notes that Article R. 413-12-1 of the CESEDA creates two versions of the exam: one bearing the mention “carte de résident” required for the 10-year card, and another for the multi-year card. The exam for a multi-year card covers the same substantive programme but the pass threshold differs.
Second, the 10-year resident card (carte de résident or carte de résident de longue durée-UE). Under Article L. 413-7, the first issuance of this card is subject to “lintégration républicaine de létranger dans la société française, appréciée en particulier au regard du résultat obtenu à lexamen mentionné au sixième alinéa de larticle L. 413-3” (the foreign nationals republican integration into French society, assessed in particular by reference to the result obtained in the exam mentioned in the sixth paragraph of Article L. 413-3). Article D. 413-12-2 of the CESEDA fixes the pass threshold at “80 % de bonnes réponses au questionnaire à choix multiples” (80% of correct answers to the multiple-choice questionnaire). This is a high bar: a candidate who answers fewer than 80% of the questions correctly will fail and must retake the exam before the card can be issued.
The practical implications of this threshold were illustrated by the CAA Nancy in its January 2026 ruling. Although the applicant in that case, Mr B., had satisfied all other conditions for the 10-year card—five years of regular residence (reduced to three for Cameroonian nationals under the 1994 Franco-Cameroonian Convention), stable resources equal to or above the minimum wage, and health insurance—the court explicitly conditioned the grant of the card on his presentation of “lattestation de sa réussite à lexamen civique” (the attestation of his success in the civic exam). The judge cannot dispense with this requirement.
Third, French naturalization. Although the civic exam as a formal written test is primarily a CESEDA requirement, the substantive standard of civic knowledge required for naturalization tracks the same substantive expectations. Article 21-24 of the Code civil provides that “Nul ne peut être naturalisé sil ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française, notamment par une connaissance suffisante, selon sa condition, de la langue, de lhistoire, de la culture et de la société françaises, dont le niveau et les modalités dévaluation sont fixés par décret en Conseil dEtat, et des droits et devoirs conférés par la nationalité française ainsi que par ladhésion aux principes et aux valeurs essentiels de la République” (No person may be naturalised unless he or she demonstrates assimilation into the French community, in particular through sufficient knowledge, according to his or her condition, of the language, history, culture and society of France, the level and assessment modalities of which are fixed by decree of the Conseil dEtat, and of the rights and duties conferred by French nationality, as well as adherence to the essential principles and values of the Republic). The naturalization process retains the individual interview (entretien dassimilation) as its core verification mechanism, but the body of knowledge tested aligns closely with the CESEDA civic exam programme.
In addition to the civic exam, the foreign national must demonstrate a French language proficiency of at least level B1 of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) for a 10-year resident card, pursuant to Article R. 413-15 of the CESEDA as amended by the arrêté of 22 December 2025. For a multi-year card, the required level is A2. The language requirement is cumulative with the civic exam requirement; satisfying one does not excuse the applicant from the other. The CAA Bordeaux illustrated this in its decision of 24 September 2024, no. 24BX00308, where it upheld the refusal of a 10-year resident card to a Turkish national who, despite thirteen years of regular residence, had “transmis aucun document justifiant de sa connaissance de la langue française” (provided no document evidencing her knowledge of the French language) and therefore failed to satisfy the integration condition.
II. Practical Aspects: Preparing, Taking, and Contesting the Civic Exam
A. Content, Format, and the 80% Passing Requirement
The civic exam is administered by organisations approved (agréés) by the Minister responsible for the reception and integration of foreign nationals. The exam consists of a multiple-choice questionnaire covering four principal domains, as defined by Article R. 413-12 of the CESEDA and specified by the arrêté of 10 October 2025 on the programme, tests and organisational modalities of the civic exam:
(a) French institutions and republican principles: the Constitution of the Fifth Republic, the separation of powers, the role of the President, the Government and Parliament, the principle of laïcité (secularism), the motto Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité, national symbols (the tricolor flag, the national anthem La Marseillaise, Marianne), and fundamental rights and freedoms.
(b) Rights and duties of citizens and residents: voting rights, the distinction between civil and criminal law, the organisation of the judicial system, the distinction between administrative and judicial courts, the obligations of tax payment, compulsory schooling, and the responsibilities of parents.
(c) History, geography and culture of France: major historical events (the French Revolution of 1789, the two World Wars, the foundation of the Fifth Republic in 1958), the role of key historical figures, the geography of metropolitan and overseas France, the major stages of European construction, and basic elements of French cultural heritage.
(d) French society and daily life: access to employment and training, the healthcare system, the education system, housing, parental responsibilities, childcare, and civic and associative life.
The pass threshold is 80% correct answers for the exam bearing the mention “carte de résident,” as set by Article D. 413-12-2. The candidate may retake the exam “à sa demande et à tout moment” (at his or her request and at any time), without limitation on the number of attempts. The French Ministry of the Interior makes available on its website an online presentation of the exam under the heading “Examen civique pour une première demande de titre de séjour pluriannuel.”
For naturalization applicants, although the process does not pass through a formal written QCM, the livret du citoyen (citizens booklet), the content of which is approved by ministerial order, serves as the reference document for the assimilation interview conducted at the prefecture. Article 37 of Decree no. 93-1362 of 30 December 1993 specifies the domains of knowledge expected: “a) Aux grands repères de lhistoire de France ; b) Aux principes, symboles et institutions de la République ; c) A lexercice de la citoyenneté française ; d) A la place de la France dans lEurope et dans le monde” (a) The major landmarks of French history; b) The principles, symbols and institutions of the Republic; c) The exercise of French citizenship; d) The place of France in Europe and in the world). The Administrative Court of Appeal of Nantes confirmed the legal force of these criteria in its decision of 12 November 2025, no. 24NT02287, where it upheld the refusal of naturalization to an Algerian national who, during his assimilation interview, “na été en mesure de citer ni la devise, ni de symboles de la République française” (was unable to cite either the motto or the symbols of the French Republic) and “a également indiqué ne pas être en mesure de définir la notion de démocratie et de laïcité, ni dexpliquer les devoirs des citoyens” (also indicated that he was unable to define the concepts of democracy and secularism, nor to explain the duties of citizens).
The case law shows that French administrative courts give substantial deference to the administrations assessment of a candidates civic knowledge. In a decision of 10 January 2023, no. 21NT02591, the CAA Nantes upheld a naturalization refusal where a Tunisian national, despite ten years of residence, “na pas été en mesure de citer un personnage important de lhistoire de France, les dates des deux guerres mondiales, le nom du premier ministre, lâge de scolarité obligatoire en France et de définir les principes de fraternité, de laïcité et de démocratie” (was unable to name an important figure in French history, the dates of both world wars, the name of the Prime Minister, the age of compulsory schooling in France, and to define the principles of fraternity, secularism and democracy). The court held that the minister enjoys “un large pouvoir dappréciation” (a broad discretionary power) in assessing a candidates assimilation, and that the gaps identified were sufficient to justify the refusal.
Similarly, in a decision of 19 September 2025, no. 24NT01854, the CAA Nantes confirmed the rejection of a naturalization application by an Ivorian national who, during his interview, “na pas su mentionner, notamment, les symboles de la République, indiquer les dates dinstauration de la Vème République ou de création de lUnion européenne ni citer un philosophe des Lumières ou un auteur de théâtre français” (was unable to mention the symbols of the Republic, to indicate the dates of the establishment of the Fifth Republic or the creation of the European Union, nor to name a philosopher of the Enlightenment or a French playwright). The court specifically rejected the argument that the questions were excessively demanding, noting that “les questions posées ne présentent pas un degré de complexité élevé” (the questions asked were not of a high degree of complexity).
In a further decision of 2 December 2025, no. 24NT03244, the same court addressed a Portuguese national who had resided in France for twenty-six years but “na notamment pas été en mesure dexpliquer les évènements liés au 14 juillet 1789, à la Révolution française et ne connaissait pas Louis XVI. De plus, lintéressé ignorait les dates de la Seconde Guerre mondiale et les évènements liés au 8 mai 1945” (was not in a position to explain the events linked to 14 July 1789 and the French Revolution and did not know Louis XVI. Moreover, the applicant was unaware of the dates of the Second World War and the events linked to 8 May 1945). The court held that these lacunae justified the refusal, regardless of the applicants length of residence and professional integration. These decisions underscore that neither length of residence, nor family ties, nor professional success can compensate for a demonstrable gap in civic knowledge.
For those seeking guidance on the broader French immigration system, the process is set within a comprehensive legal framework that our firm addresses at Kohen Avocats – Immigration Lawyer Paris.
B. What Happens If You Fail: Remedies, Appeals, and Administrative Litigation
A failure of the civic exam does not, by itself, automatically trigger a removal order. The candidate may retake the exam “à sa demande et à tout moment” (at his or her request and at any time), as provided by Article L. 413-3, paragraph 6. The practical consequence of a failed exam is that the administration cannot issue the residence card or multi-year card for which the exam is a legal prerequisite. The applicant remains in a precarious administrative situation: his or her existing residence document may expire while the civic exam requirement remains unsatisfied, potentially triggering the issuance of a récépissé (receipt) or an attestation de prolongation de linstruction (certificate of extension of processing) pending the retake.
If the administration refuses a residence document on the ground that the civic exam result is below the statutory threshold, or on the ground that the applicant has not produced the required attestation, the decision may be challenged before the administrative court (tribunal administratif) by way of an action en annulation pour excès de pouvoir (action for annulment on grounds of excess of power). The time limit for bringing such an action is two months from notification of the refusal decision. The applicant should, before filing a judicial appeal, consider lodging a recours gracieux (informal appeal to the prefect) or a recours hiérarchique (hierarchical appeal to the Minister of the Interior), which interrupts the two-month limitation period.
Challenges based on the merits of the civic knowledge assessment are difficult to sustain. The administrative judge exercises only a limited review (contrôle restreint) of the administrations appraisal of a candidates civic knowledge and integration. The CAA Nantes, in its decision of 12 November 2025 (no. 24NT02287), stated that “le ministre a pu, eu égard au large pouvoir dappréciation dont il dispose pour apprécier lopportunité daccorder la nationalité française au ressortissant étranger qui la sollicite, rejeter la demande de naturalisation de M. A… pour le motif mentionné” (the minister was able, having regard to the broad discretionary power he enjoys in assessing whether it is appropriate to grant French nationality to the foreign national who requests it, to reject Mr A.s naturalisation application for the stated reason). The judge will only intervene if the administration has committed a manifest error of appreciation (erreur manifeste dappréciation)—a high threshold met only when the facts in the file are fundamentally incompatible with the conclusion reached.
Certain procedural defects, however, can lead to annulment. The CAA Bordeaux, in its decision of 5 June 2024, no. 23BX02897, examined a case in which the prefect had refused a 10-year resident card to a Ukrainian national for failure to produce a DELF A2 language certificate. The applicant subsequently produced the certificate with her informal appeal. The court allowed a substitution of grounds, finding that although the applicant did satisfy the language requirement, she did not meet the condition of five years of uninterrupted legal residence, as she had a gap in her residence status between September 2017 and July 2018. The decision illustrates that an applicant who rectifies a documentary deficiency may still face refusal on another, legally valid ground.
Where the administration has failed to observe procedural guarantees—for example, by not seeking the opinion of the mayor under Article L. 413-7, or by failing to make the civic exam available through an approved centre—the applicant may argue a violation of the general principles of administrative procedure. However, the CAA Nancy held, in its judgment of 27 January 2026, that the failure to seek the mayors opinion at the pre-decision stage, while irregular, does not by itself render the refusal decision unlawful; the regularity of the procedure is assessed at the date of the judges ruling, and the judge may prescribe the consultation as an injunctive measure rather than annulling the refusal on that sole ground.
For naturalization applicants, the procedural pathway is slightly different. The candidate must first lodge a recours administratif préalable obligatoire (mandatory prior administrative appeal, RAPO) with the Minister of the Interior within two months of the prefectural refusal decision, pursuant to Article 45 of Decree no. 93-1362 of 30 December 1993. Only after the ministers decision (or after two months of silence, constituting an implicit refusal) may the candidate bring an action before the tribunal administratif de Nantes, which has exclusive jurisdiction over naturalization disputes. The CAA Nantes, in its decision of 19 September 2025 (no. 24NT01854), confirmed that the ministers decision on the RAPO “sest substituée à la décision du préfet” (substituted the prefects decision), so that only the ministerial decision may be challenged in court.
Beyond the civic exam itself, the administration may refuse a residence card to any foreign national whose presence constitutes a threat to public order (menace pour lordre public), as provided by Article L. 314-3 of the CESEDA in its pre-2024 codification, now reflected in the current code. The CAA Nantes, in its decision of 23 June 2023, no. 22NT03357, upheld a refusal where the applicant had been convicted of a serious sexual offence, finding that the gravity of the offence justified treating his presence as a threat to public order even many years after the conviction. The public order exception is independent from the civic exam requirement: a candidate who passes the exam may still be refused on public order grounds, and conversely, a candidate who fails the exam cannot rely on a clean criminal record to obtain the card.
For foreign nationals navigating these complexities, it may be advisable to seek legal advice at the earliest stage. The requirements for each residence category are distinct, and the interaction between the civic exam, the language test, and the other substantive conditions can give rise to procedural pitfalls that are difficult to identify without professional assistance. At Kohen Avocats, our immigration law team assists English-speaking clients throughout the residence application process, from the preparation of the application file to the representation before the French administrative courts.
Conclusion
The introduction of the mandatory civic exam on 1 January 2026 represents a structural shift in French immigration law. The exam transforms the assessment of republican integration from a discretionary administrative appraisal into a standardised, verifiable criterion, applicable to all foreign nationals seeking a multi-year residence card, a 10-year resident card, or French naturalization. The 80% pass threshold set by Article D. 413-12-2 is demanding, and the administrative judge accords a broad margin of appreciation to the administration in assessing a candidates knowledge of French history, institutions, values, and society.
The case law examined in this article demonstrates that French courts consistently uphold refusals based on insufficient civic knowledge, even where the applicant has resided in France for many years, is professionally integrated, and has French family members. The preparation for the civic exam—whether in its formal QCM version under the CESEDA or in the context of a naturalisation assimilation interview—requires a systematic study of the livret du citoyen and a genuine understanding of the republican principles and institutions that the exam is designed to test.
For English-speaking residents of France, the civic exam adds a layer of complexity to what is already a demanding administrative process. The exam is administered in French, and the substantive content assumes familiarity with concepts—laïcité, the constitutional architecture of the Fifth Republic, the major landmarks of French history—that may not be intuitive for those educated outside the French system. Early preparation, careful documentation, and, where necessary, timely legal advice are essential to ensuring that the civic exam does not become an insurmountable obstacle on the path to a secure residence status in France.