On 16 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union in Luxembourg handed Russian singer Polina Gagarina a victory that is both real and brutally limited. In Case T-460/24, Gagarina v Council, the Court annulled the two 2025 acts that kept her on the EU sanctions list, ruling that the Council had failed to show she was still doing anything sanctionable. Yet the same judgment upheld her original 2024 listing and her September 2024 renewal, accepted that performing at state propaganda concerts can legally count as supporting the undermining of Ukraine, and left her current listing intact because the Council had already renewed it again in March 2026. Commentators were quick to spot the tension: as one analysis published the day after the ruling put it, the judgment represents a new and important staging post in the fast-growing EU sanctions case law, but warns that beneath the annulment lies a more troubling message, namely that the EU can sanction an artist for what she performs and where she performs it. For anyone living with frozen accounts, blocked property or a paralysed business in France, this ruling is the most practical sanctions decision of the year. It shows exactly where the Council’s files go stale, which evidence wins in Luxembourg, and what a lawyer in Paris must file, and when, to turn a renewal into an annulment.
I. Why the General Court kept the 2024 listing but struck down the 2025 renewals
A. What the Council proved: state concerts, propaganda events and two listing criteria
Polina Sergeevna Gagarina, a Russian national residing in Moscow, was added to the EU sanctions lists on 24 June 2026 by Council Decision (CFSP) 2024/1738 of 24 June 2024 (OJ L, 2024/1738) and its implementing regulation, adopted under the EU’s Ukraine territorial-integrity regime, Decision 2014/145/CFSP of 17 March 2014 (OJ L 78, p. 16) and Regulation (EU) No 269/2014. Her application for annulment, brought under Article 263 TFEU and lodged on 3 September 2024, attacked four successive waves of measures: the initial June 2024 listing, the September 2024 renewal, the March 2025 renewal and the September 2025 renewal. The case was heard on 21 January 2026 and decided by the Fourth Chamber, with Judge Jočienė as rapporteur, the language of the case being English.
The listing reasons are worth quoting in full, because every sanctions challenge in Luxembourg stands or falls on these few lines. The Council described the applicant as a Russian singer, actress, songwriter and model who performs regularly at state propaganda events, for instance to celebrate the unlawful annexation of four Ukrainian regions or the anniversary of the annexation of Crimea, and concluded that she thereby supports actions undermining the territorial integrity of Ukraine. It added that since the start of the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine she had earned significant revenue through frequent participation in state-sponsored propaganda events and programmes, and therefore benefits from the Government of the Russian Federation, which it holds responsible for the annexation of Crimea and the destabilisation of Ukraine. The first paragraph targets criterion (a) of the listing regime, the second targets criterion (d).
Those criteria come from Article 2(1) of the amended Decision 2014/145, which the judgment recalls word for word. Under point (a), funds are frozen for natural persons who are responsible for, support or implement actions or policies undermining or threatening the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence of Ukraine, stability or security in Ukraine, or obstructing the work of international organisations in Ukraine. Under point (d), the freeze hits natural or legal persons, entities or bodies that support, materially or financially, or benefit from the Russian decision-makers responsible for the annexation of Crimea or the destabilisation of Ukraine. The EU legislature deliberately widened these criteria in 2022, and the Court treats them as autonomous concepts of EU law: “support” does not require the listed person to have pulled a trigger or signed a decree. Singing, on the right stage, at the state’s invitation, for the state’s narrative, can qualify.
For the 2024 acts, the Council’s file held up. On 16 August 2024 it had sent Gagarina its first evidence file, document WK 7217/2024 INIT, and that file contained nine press articles and publications from 2022 to 2024. The judgment walks through them one by one. A VKontakte post of 11 January 2024 showed her organising a Christmas party at the Mandryka central military hospital for participants in the special military operation, as Moscow calls the war. A Regnum article of 20 March 2022 reported a charity concert she gave with Nikolai Baskov for refugees from the self-proclaimed Donetsk and Luhansk republics. A Meduza article of 14 November 2022 recalled that she had liked, days after the February 2022 invasion, a social media post presenting the invasion as a peacekeeping operation undertaken in self-defence, and performed at the Luzhniki Stadium concert for the Crimea annexation anniversary. Another Meduza piece of 29 September 2023 listed her among the artists who regularly take part in such events at the Red Square concert entitled One Country, One Family, One Russia, marking the annexation of Ukrainian territories. A February 2024 publication placed her among Vladimir Putin’s declared supporters for the presidential election, alongside the patriotic singer Shaman. The Court found this body of material sufficiently specific, precise and consistent to justify the initial listing and its first renewal: the conduct was recent, repeated and directly connected to the reasons stated. The lesson for listed persons is stark. Press clippings, social media likes, concert posters and state television footage are admissible evidence in Luxembourg, and a pattern of public performances can satisfy a listing criterion without any confidential intelligence.
Gagarina raised four pleas against these acts, alleging defective reasoning and breach of effective judicial protection, manifest error of assessment with breach of legal certainty, breach of proportionality and fundamental rights, and breach of freedom of expression and freedom of the arts. All of them failed for the 2024 measures. The statement of reasons identified the conduct, the dates and the criterion, so she knew what case she had to answer. The interference with her property and her artistic expression pursued the legitimate aims of peace and international security, and the freeze, which preserves ownership while blocking use, was held proportionate. Artists reading this judgment should understand the point clearly: the Court did not deny that performing is expression. It held that expression used as a cog in state propaganda may lawfully attract restrictive measures. That is the troubling message the commentators flagged, and it is now settled case law.
B. Where the file went stale: no 2025 conduct and the annulment of the March and September 2025 renewals
The turning point of the case concerns the two 2025 renewals: Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/528 of 14 March 2025 (OJ L, 2025/528) with its implementing regulation, and Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 of 12 September 2025 (OJ L, 2025/1895) with its own implementing regulation. Gagarina’s argument was disarmingly simple: the Council was relying on no event from 2025 at all, which showed that the alleged conduct lacked regularity and significance. The Council answered that its second evidence file proved her conduct had continued beyond 2022 and 2023 and that her situation had not changed.
The Court began by restating the renewal rule that now governs every relisting in this regime. The Council is not prohibited from relying on the same evidence that justified the initial listing or an earlier renewal, provided that the reasons for listing remain unchanged and the context has not changed in a way that makes that evidence out of date, a context that covers both the situation of the country concerned and the particular situation of the listed person. It added, citing the Court of Justice’s March 2025 ruling in Shuvalov v Council, C-271/24 P, that older material may still be used to show continuity between a person’s past situation and present situation, despite the passage of time and in light of all the circumstances specific to each case. This is the passage Council lawyers will quote in every future case, and challengers must read it with care: age alone does not kill evidence, but age combined with silence can.
That combination is exactly what sank the 2025 renewals. The Court found that the most recent state propaganda event at which the applicant had performed was the concert of 18 March 2024, and that the evidence files mentioned no other propaganda event she was said to have joined after that date. As a result, the evidence did not show that her conduct was still regular when those acts were adopted, and in particular that she was still performing regularly at state propaganda events at that time, so it did not substantiate the reasons given for the March 2025 and September 2025 acts. The Council had also failed to show that regular participation between 2022 and 2024 was, by itself, enough to consider that she still supported sanctionable actions a year or more later. The conclusion follows in the judgment’s driest and most consequential sentence: the Council had not presented a body of evidence sufficiently specific, precise and consistent to establish that the applicant still satisfied criterion (a) when those acts were adopted. The second plea was therefore upheld, the Court annulled the March and September 2025 acts in so far as they concerned her, and it expressly declined to rule on the remaining pleas or on a fifth plea alleging procedural irregularities specific to the September 2025 acts.
The operative part of the judgment deserves quotation because it shows both the win and its boundaries: the Court annulled Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/528 of 14 March 2025 and its implementing regulation, together with Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 of 12 September 2025 and its implementing regulation, in so far as they concerned Ms Polina Sergeevna Gagarina, then dismissed the action as to the remainder and ordered the Council and Ms Gagarina each to bear their own costs. Annulment for one period is not delisting. The Court spelled out that the annulment covers only the window from 16 March 2025 to 15 March 2026, because by Council Decision (CFSP) 2026/696 of 14 March 2026 (OJ L, 2026/696) the Council had already maintained her name until 15 September 2026, and the annulment granted does not extend to that 2026 decision, which the action did not cover. The Council’s fallback request to preserve the temporal effects of the annulled acts was rejected as devoid of purpose, by analogy with the October 2025 Gutseriev v Council, T-233/24 ruling, precisely because fresh measures were already in force. In plain terms: she won the battle over 2025 and remains listed in 2026. A new action is needed against the new act, and the clock for it is already running.
II. How to challenge an EU freeze from France after Gagarina
A. Which court, which deadline and which evidence: Article 263 TFEU and the French Treasury freeze
The first question clients in Paris ask is where their case actually lives. An EU listing lives in Luxembourg, not in Paris. Only the General Court can annul the Council decisions and regulations that freeze funds across the Union, through the direct action Gagarina herself used, an Article 263 TFEU application seeking annulment of the contested acts in so far as they concerned her. That action is subject to a short, strict time limit running from publication or notification of each act, and each renewal is a separate act that needs its own challenge or its own statement in modification of an existing action. Gagarina’s lawyers modified their application three times, in November 2024 and in April and November 2025, to catch each successive renewal. Anyone who waits for the “final” decision before suing will find there is no final decision: the list rolls forward every six months, and each roll is a new lawsuit or an extension of the current one. The September 2026 listing now in force will lapse in turn, and the file must be ready before it does.
The second question is what the freeze concretely does in France. EU regulations apply directly, so a bank in Paris, a notary handling a sale, or an insurer holding a life policy must block the funds without waiting for any French decree. French law then organises enforcement around that direct effect. Article L. 562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code empowers the Minister for the Economy to order, for six months renewable, the freezing of funds belonging to persons designated under resolutions adopted within the framework of Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter or acts taken under Article 29 of the Treaty on European Union or Article 75 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which is exactly the legal pedigree of the Russia sanctions. Article L. 562-4 of the same Code obliges every person on national territory, and every institution concerned, to apply the freeze measures and the prohibitions on making funds available immediately and to inform the Minister for the Economy without delay. Article L. 562-5 then prohibits making funds or economic resources available, directly or indirectly, to listed persons or using them for their benefit. A separate national track exists for terrorism designations under Article L. 562-2, ordered jointly by the economy and interior ministers, which shows how France layers its own freezes on top of UN, EU and domestic lists.
The Code defines the target broadly: Article L. 562-1 of the same Code treats as funds the financial assets and economic benefits of every kind, from cash, deposits and payment funds to securities, claims, interest, dividends and credit operations. Transparency is organised through a national register of frozen persons kept by the Minister for the Economy, fed by publications in the French and EU Official Journals, while Article L. 562-4-1 requires institutions to maintain internal organisation and procedures for implementing freezes and the ban on circumvention, applied even in branches outside national territory, with Article R. 562-1 demanding sufficient staffing, training and information access. Article R. 562-3 details the reporting to the Minister: frozen funds, every credit to a frozen account, and any transaction suspected of breaching a freeze or a making-available ban.
In practice, the file is managed through the Treasury’s financial-sanctions teleservice at sanctionsfinancieres.dgtresor.gouv.fr, where banks declare frozen assets and listed persons request authorisations for essential expenditure. A client who discovers a blocked transfer should therefore act on two fronts at once: the Luxembourg annulment action against the EU act, and the Paris compliance file with the bank and the Treasury to keep daily life, legal fees and business preservation funded through derogations while the court case runs.
The third question is what evidence Luxembourg wants. Gagarina and the companion judgment delivered the same day in Trotsenko v Council, T-459/24, read together, give a complete answer. Trotsenko claimed he had sold his Russian assets and was no longer the businessman described in his listing reasons, but he produced no transfer contract, no price, no payment proof and no corporate records, so the Court dismissed his action: assertions without documents are worth nothing. Gagarina won for the opposite reason: the Council asserted continuing regular conduct but produced no 2025 event, so the assertion collapsed. The two rulings form a single rule. The party who documents wins, whether it is the Council with dated, sourced exhibits or the applicant with dated, verifiable proof that the conduct stopped. For a person listed for business links, that means complete sale files with independent valuation, payment trails and register entries. For a person listed for public support, speeches or performances, that means a dated record of withdrawal: cancelled appearances, public distancing, verifiable absence from state events over a sustained period. And because the Court assesses each renewal on its own evidence, the file must be updated at every six-month roll, not assembled once and left to age like the Council’s press clippings.
B. What Paris practitioners file at each renewal: observations, derogations and damages
A serious challenge follows a calendar, and Gagarina shows why each date matters. When the Council notifies a renewal or publishes it in the Official Journal, the listed person should immediately request the evidence file, as Gagarina did in August 2024 when she asked the Council to send her the complete file behind the restrictive measures taken against her, and then submit observations before the next renewal round. Observations are not a courtesy step. They force the Council to confront exculpatory documents, they create the paper trail the judges will later read, and they sometimes secure a delisting without any court action, as recent Council removals of business figures from the Russia list demonstrate: see our earlier coverage of successful challenges. Where observations fail, the annulment action must be filed within the deadline against each contested act, with statements in modification added as renewals arrive, exactly as her counsel did three times. Interim relief suspending the freeze pending judgment is theoretically available but granted only exceptionally, so the realistic strategy pairs the main action with derogation requests in France for basic needs, legal representation and the preservation of frozen businesses, keeping the client solvent through years of procedure.
The remedies beyond annulment deserve honest presentation. Annulment operates retrospectively for the annulled period but does not automatically erase later renewals, as paragraphs 152 to 154 of the judgment demonstrate with unusual clarity. A damages action for unlawful listing is possible but difficult, requiring proof of a sufficiently serious breach and quantifiable loss. The more accessible victories are often administrative: corrected bank records, released payments for authorised purposes, unfrozen rental income applied to property charges, or a business placed under authorised management rather than left to rot. Each of these steps requires French-language filings with institutions that apply Article L. 562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code daily, and each benefits from the Luxembourg case law that defines what the Council must prove. This is also where comparisons with neighbouring cases sharpen advice. The September 2026 ruling upholding Roman Abramovich’s listing, analysed in our analysis of the September 2026 Abramovich ruling, shows that vast, well-documented fortunes with enduring Russian nexus survive challenges even with elite counsel. Gagarina shows the mirror image: a file built on public appearances goes stale the moment the appearances stop being documented. Between the oligarch who cannot unspool his empire and the artist who can show a blank calendar, Luxembourg now draws a visible line.
Fundamental rights complete the picture but should not be oversold. Gagarina’s pleas based on proportionality, property, freedom of expression and freedom of the arts all failed for the 2024 measures, and Article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights on effective judicial protection was satisfied because the reasons given let her mount a defence, which she then partly won. Article 11 of the Charter protects expression and the arts, but the Court accepts limitations serving international security where they are proportionate, and a targeted asset freeze with derogation mechanisms passes that test. The practical consequence is that rights arguments support a challenge but rarely carry it alone. They frame the file, they reinforce a manifest-error plea, and they matter most at the margins, for example where a listing reason is vaguely worded or the evidence intrudes deeply into private life. The core of the case remains factual: what did the person do, when, documented by whom, and does the Council have anything dated after the last renewal.
Conclusion
The General Court’s judgment of 16 September 2026 in Gagarina v Council changes the sanctions landscape in a precise, usable way. It confirms that the Council may list an artist for performing at state propaganda events, that press and social-media evidence can lawfully support a listing, and that renewals may reuse earlier material where the reasons and the context are unchanged. It holds, with equal force, that a renewal without fresh conduct is vulnerable: the most recent documented event dated from 18 March 2024, nothing followed it, and the 2025 relistings were therefore annulled for lack of a sufficiently specific, precise and consistent body of evidence. The applicant stays listed under the March 2026 renewal, the annulment covers only March 2025 to March 2026, and each side bears its own costs. For listed persons with assets, accounts or companies in France, the method is now written down: request the file at once, answer each renewal with dated proof, keep the Treasury derogation track alive in Paris, and bring the Luxembourg action with complete, independent, verifiable evidence, because as Gagarina and Trotsenko together prove, sanctions litigation rewards files, not indignation.