KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Son Won’t Let Me See My Grandchildren: Grandparents’ Contact Rights in France (Expats Guide 2026)

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Son Won’t Let Me See My Grandchildren: Grandparents’ Contact Rights in France (Expats Guide 2026)

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your son or daughter lives in France, your grandchildren are growing up in Paris, Lyon or Bordeaux, and suddenly the door closes: your calls go unanswered, the school holidays you used to share disappear, and the other parent tells you that your presence disturbs the children. If you live abroad, in London, New York, Madrid or elsewhere, the distance makes the silence heavier, and you may wonder whether French law gives you any real remedy or whether parents decide everything alone. French law answers clearly, and its answer surprises many foreign families: contact with grandparents is framed as the child’s own right, not as a favour granted by the parents. A grandmother who had never met her twin granddaughters obtained court-ordered visits from the French supreme court in 2019, and the courts apply the same logic today to grandfathers phoning from abroad, to grandmothers flying in from another continent, and even to step-parents and former partners who raised the child. This guide explains, in plain English with every French term translated, when French judges grant visits and overnight stays to grandparents, how the procedure before the family judge works from the first mediation attempt to the enforceable order, what parents argue to block contact and why those arguments usually fail, and what happens when the children move to another city or another country. Every decisive rule below is quoted word for word from its official source, with an English translation in parentheses.

Before you go before the family judge, have your own case reviewed by a family lawyer in Paris who works in English with expatriate and international parents.

I. Blocked From Seeing Your Grandchildren in France: The Child’s Right to Contact and How to Enforce It

A. The Rule That Decides Everything: Your Grandchild’s Own Right to See You

Most foreign grandparents arrive with the wrong mental picture. In several American states, grandparents must prove exceptional circumstances or parental unfitness before a court will even hear them, because the starting point is the parents’ constitutional right to raise their children as they wish. France starts from the opposite end. Article 371-4 of the Civil Code provides: “L’enfant a le droit d’entretenir des relations personnelles avec ses ascendants. Seul l’intérêt de l’enfant peut faire obstacle à l’exercice de ce droit.” (The child has the right to maintain personal relations with his or her ascendants. Only the child’s best interests may stand in the way of the exercise of that right.) Read that sentence twice, because it structures every case: the right belongs to the child, the grandparents are its natural beneficiaries, and the parents who oppose contact carry the practical burden of showing that contact would harm the child. A simple disagreement between adults, however deep, is not enough.

This framing has three immediate consequences for your situation. First, it does not matter whether the parents live together or are separated, whether they are married, bound by a civil partnership, or unmarried, and whether you are the paternal or maternal grandparent. The official public-service page states that the minor child’s right to maintain personal relations with grandparents applies whether the parents live together or separately, and it can take the form of a right of visit, called droit de visite, short meetings without overnight stays, or a right of accommodation, called droit d’hébergement, where the child stays with you, including holiday periods. Second, it does not matter that you live abroad. A grandmother in Manchester or a grandfather in Los Angeles holds exactly the same legal position as grandparents living on the next street in the 15th arrondissement of Paris; distance changes the practical arrangements, never the existence of the right. Third, the parents’ authority over the child, called autorité parentale, parental authority, does not swallow this right. Article 372 of the Civil Code recalls that “Les père et mère exercent en commun l’autorité parentale.” (The father and mother exercise parental authority jointly.) Joint authority means the parents decide together about the child’s life, but Article 371-4 sits beside that authority as an independent guarantee for the child: the parents manage, the child keeps a protected bond with the wider family, and only the child’s own interest can sever it.

The leading decision on grandparents makes the principle concrete, and its facts resemble many expatriate disputes. In a ruling of 13 June 2019, appeal number 18-12.389, published in the bulletins of the First Civil Chamber, a maternal grandmother asked for contact with her twin granddaughters, aged six, whom she had in practice never met because of a severe conflict with her own daughter, the children’s mother. The parents fought the request on every front: they argued that no affectionate bond could possibly exist at a distance with such young children, that dragging the girls to a neutral meeting place to see a stranger would itself harm them, and that the grandmother lacked the physical capacity to look after six-year-old twins for a whole day. The Cour de cassation, the French supreme court for civil matters, which quashes decisions that misapply the law, rejected all three objections. It restated the governing sentence: “aux termes de l’article 371-4 du code civil, l’enfant a le droit d’entretenir des relations personnelles avec ses ascendants et seul l’intérêt de l’enfant peut faire obstacle à l’exercice de ce droit” (under the terms of Article 371-4 of the Civil Code, the child has the right to maintain personal relations with his or her ascendants and only the child’s best interests may stand in the way of the exercise of that right). The appeal court’s findings justified the order: despite the conflict, the grandmother had built a link through regular thoughtful gestures, her place beside the little girls was established, she had always preserved the unity of the siblings, and it was in the children’s interest to enjoy a relationship with their grandmother just as their half-brother did. Visits were organised progressively, in a mediated setting, without overnight stays at first. For a grandparent reading this from abroad, the message is direct: never having met the child and living far away do not defeat your case where you can show steady commitment, and the judge builds contact step by step rather than refusing it outright.

The same article protects people beyond blood grandparents, which matters enormously in recomposed expatriate families. The second paragraph of Article 371-4 adds: “Si tel est l’intérêt de l’enfant, le juge aux affaires familiales fixe les modalités des relations entre l’enfant et un tiers, parent ou non, en particulier lorsque ce tiers a résidé de manière stable avec lui et l’un de ses parents, a pourvu à son éducation, à son entretien ou à son installation, et a noué avec lui des liens affectifs durables.” (If it is in the child’s interest, the family court judge sets the terms of the relations between the child and a third party, related or not, in particular where that third party has lived stably with the child and one of his or her parents, has provided for the child’s upbringing, maintenance or establishment, and has formed lasting emotional bonds with the child.) A stepfather who raised his wife’s daughter for years before the divorce, a former same-sex partner who shared the early years of the child’s life, or a beloved aunt who lived with the family can therefore apply on the same legal foundation. The conditions are cumulative in spirit: stable shared residence, a real contribution to daily life, and durable affection. Our guide on child custody and parental authority in France for expats explains how the family judge allocates residence and authority between the parents themselves, which is the necessary background before any third party asks for a place beside them.

B. How to Obtain Visits and Overnight Stays: Mediation First, Then the Family Judge

French procedure expects you to try agreement before litigation, and judges notice when you do. The official public-service page recommends attempting family mediation, called médiation familiale, conducted by a neutral trained mediator, to rebuild ties and reach a written agreement; that agreement can then be submitted to the family judge for homologation, the judicial approval that gives a private agreement enforceable force, meaning it can be executed with the help of public authority if needed. For grandparents living abroad, mediation can now happen by video link, and arriving before the judge with a mediation certificate showing that you proposed dialogue and the parents refused it strengthens your file considerably. Keep every message: invitations to mediate, proposed dates, unanswered emails, and any written refusal. A grandparent who can show six months of polite, documented attempts looks very different from one who sues without warning.

When dialogue fails, the competent court is the juge aux affaires familiales, the family court judge universally shortened to JAF, sitting at the tribunal judiciaire, the general civil court, of the place where the child habitually lives. The public-service guidance is explicit: grandparents must seise that judge by assignation, the formal summons served by a commissaire de justice, the sworn officer formerly called huissier de justice who delivers court papers. Habitual residence means the child’s real, stable home, so if your grandchildren live in Paris you will litigate in Paris even if you yourself live in Chicago or Sydney, and you will need a French lawyer, an avocat, to represent you; representation is compulsory before the tribunal judiciaire in this type of case. Practical points for files prepared from abroad: every foreign document must be translated by a traducteur assermenté, a sworn certified translator whose stamp French judges trust, and civil-status documents generally need an apostille or legalisation depending on the issuing country, so start translations early because a file that arrives incomplete is adjourned and an adjournment costs months. Grandparents and parents of modest means can apply for aide juridictionnelle, the French legal-aid scheme that covers all or part of lawyers’ fees subject to income thresholds, and the judge decides the case solely, in the statutory words, according to the child’s best interests.

What the judge can order is flexible and deliberately gradual. The standard outcome is a calendar of visits, then overnight stays, then shares of school holidays, with video calls in between where distance makes frequent travel impossible. Where the relationship must be rebuilt from zero, French judges regularly begin with visits in a neutral supervised setting, and the 2019 twins decision confirms the method: progressive contact without accommodation rights at first, expanding as trust returns. A useful precision comes from the same ruling’s second holding on procedure. The parents had argued that the appeal court exceeded its powers by ordering visits in a mediated setting without fixing every detail itself and by leaving practical arrangements to the meeting-place staff. The supreme court answered: “l’article 371-4 du code civil ne précise pas les modalités selon lesquelles le droit de visite et d’hébergement des grands-parents peut s’exercer” (Article 371-4 of the Civil Code does not specify the arrangements under which grandparents’ rights of visit and accommodation are to be exercised). The strict rule of Article 1180-5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which requires the judge ordering parental visits in a meeting place to fix the measure’s duration and determine the periodicity and duration of meetings, since it states that the judge “fixe la durée de la mesure et détermine la périodicité et la durée des rencontres” (fixes the duration of the measure and determines the periodicity and duration of the meetings), applies only to parents under Articles 373-2-1 and 373-2-9 of the Civil Code, not to grandparents. For grandparents, the court must still fix the duration of the measure, the place and the periodicity of meetings, but the day-to-day scheduling can be left to the supervised centre. Do not therefore attack a grandparent-visitation order as unlawful merely because the timetable’s fine print was set by the centre: that argument has already been tried and rejected.

Orders must be obeyed, and French law gives the judge teeth. A parent who ignores a grandparent-visitation order faces the same enforcement machinery as for custody orders: the judge can attach an astreinte, a daily financial penalty for each day or each missed visit without compliance, and persistent obstruction can be referred to the public prosecutor. If the children’s other parent supports your application, ask them to intervene voluntarily in the proceedings; a united front of one parent plus the grandparents carries obvious weight. Either side can appeal the JAF decision within one month, and the appeal court re-examines both facts and law, so treat the first hearing as decisive but keep your evidence organised for a second round. Grandparents sometimes ask whether they can obtain contact with only one of them where the couple is divided: yes, the judge may authorise relations with a single grandparent where the other’s behaviour does not serve the child’s interests, so a grandfather should not abandon his own case because his wife’s conduct is criticised, and vice versa.

II. When Contact Is Refused or the Children Move Away: Defences, the Child’s Voice and Cross-Border Cases

A. Conflict Between Adults Is Not Enough: What Parents Argue and What Actually Persuades the Judge

Parents who block contact return to the same handful of arguments, and you should know exactly how judges test each one. The first argument is the conflict itself: relations with the grandparents are so poisoned that any contact would disturb the child. French courts reject that reasoning as a reflex. The public-service page states the rule plainly: a conflict, even an old one, between the parents and the grandparents does not necessarily justify refusing relations; the conflict must spill over onto the child, harm the child’s psychological and emotional balance, or make a healthy relationship impossible. In the 2019 twins case the mother-grandmother conflict was total, the grandmother had never seen the children, yet contact was ordered because the file showed commitment on one side and no proven harm to the children on the other. If you are the grandparent, document your composure: never criticise the parents in front of the children, never use the children as messengers, and bring proof of every calm, regular gesture, gifts, letters, video calls, trips made for birthdays. If you are a parent genuinely worried about a grandparent’s influence, general hostility will not suffice either: you must prove concrete rebound effects on the child, school reports noting anxiety after visits, medical certificates, or testimony from neutral professionals.

The second argument is the child’s own refusal: the child says they do not want to see the grandparents. French law hears the child but does not hand the child the decision. Article 388-1 of the Civil Code provides: “Dans toute procédure le concernant, le mineur capable de discernement peut, sans préjudice des dispositions prévoyant son intervention ou son consentement, être entendu par le juge ou, lorsque son intérêt le commande, par la personne désignée par le juge à cet effet. Cette audition est de droit lorsque le mineur en fait la demande.” (In any proceedings concerning him or her, a minor capable of discernment may, without prejudice to provisions providing for his or her involvement or consent, be heard by the judge or, where his or her interest so requires, by the person appointed by the judge for that purpose. That hearing is a matter of right where the minor so requests.) The same article adds the essential limit: “L’audition du mineur ne lui confère pas la qualité de partie à la procédure.” (The hearing of the minor does not confer the status of party to the proceedings.) In practice the JAF orders an audition de l’enfant, a hearing of the child, often conducted by the judge alone in chambers, sometimes with a lawyer for the child, and weighs what the child says against age, maturity and possible parental influence. An eight-year-old’s stated refusal, expressed in the middle of a loyalty conflict, is treated very differently from a teenager’s settled, reasoned position. Grandparents should never coach the child or promise rewards for kind words to the judge; experienced family judges detect rehearsed statements immediately, and the discovery poisons the whole file.

The third line of defence concerns third parties rather than grandparents, and a recent supreme-court ruling sets the exact test. On 30 April 2025, appeal number 23-11.544, the First Civil Chamber decided the case of a woman who had shared a civil partnership, a PACS, with the child’s mother, had taken part in the joint parental project including assisted reproduction abroad, had lived with the child for two and a half years, and was even called the child’s social mother, before the couple separated and the mother cut contact. The appeal court had ended all visits, citing extreme rivalry between the former partners, the eight-year-old’s refusal, and the child’s interest in not reawakening conflicts. The Cour de cassation upheld that outcome but, crucially, restated the method every judge must follow in third-party cases, borrowing it from the European Court of Human Rights in Callamand v. France of 7 April 2022, application number 19511/16. First the court recalled the European guarantee: “Toute personne a droit au respect de sa vie privée et familiale, de son domicile et de sa correspondance.” (Everyone has the right to respect for his or her private and family life, home and correspondence.) Then it restated the domestic rule: where a person who lived stably with the child applies under the second paragraph of Article 371-4, and rejecting the claim would radically end the relationship, “il appartient au juge, lorsqu’il est saisi de conclusions en ce sens, de mettre en balance les intérêts éventuellement concurrents. Il doit, notamment, montrer par son raisonnement que les préoccupations relatives à l’intérêt supérieur de l’enfant sont d’une telle importance par rapport à l’intérêt du demandeur à au moins maintenir un contact avec celui-ci, qu’il est justifié, au titre de l’article 8 de la Convention européenne de sauvegarde des droits de l’homme et des libertés fondamentales, de rejeter intégralement cette demande.” (it is for the judge, where seised of submissions to that effect, to balance the competing interests. The judge must show, in particular, through reasoning that the concerns relating to the child’s best interests are of such importance compared with the applicant’s interest in at least maintaining contact with the child that a complete rejection of the application is justified under Article 8 of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms.) The appeal court had performed that balancing exercise, weighing the joint parental project and early bonds against the documented rivalry, the social inquiry describing the child’s anxiety, and the weakening of ties, so the rejection stood. For step-parents and former partners in expatriate families, the lesson is precise: your strongest assets are proof of stable cohabitation, daily caregiving and lasting affection, and your greatest danger is feeding the conflict, because a judge who sees you attacking the legal parent will conclude that even minimal contact reopens the wound.

B. Children Who Move Cities or Countries: Acting Fast, Video Calls and Enforcing the Order

The most painful grandparent cases involve a move: after a separation, one parent relocates with the children to another French city or to another country, and the grandparents’ monthly visits collapse overnight. French law anticipates exactly this scenario. Article 373-2 of the Civil Code states: “Tout changement de résidence de l’un des parents, dès lors qu’il modifie les modalités d’exercice de l’autorité parentale, doit faire l’objet d’une information préalable et en temps utile de l’autre parent. En cas de désaccord, le parent le plus diligent saisit le juge aux affaires familiales qui statue selon ce qu’exige l’intérêt de l’enfant.” (Any change of residence of one of the parents, where it alters the arrangements for exercising parental authority, must be notified in advance and in good time to the other parent. In case of disagreement, the most diligent parent seises the family court judge, who rules according to what the child’s best interests require.) That duty of prior notice is owed between the parents, and grandparents are not parties to it, but its breach is powerful evidence in your file: a parent who moves the children secretly, without telling even the other parent, looks like a parent who organises the children’s isolation, and judges draw the inference. If you hear that a move is planned, act before the removal van leaves. A grandparent who already holds a visitation order can ask the JAF to adjust it urgently and to prohibit the move’s effects on contact until a full hearing; a grandparent with no order yet should file immediately, because courts decide on the situation as it stands at the hearing date, and a move completed months earlier with the children now settled elsewhere is far harder to undo. Our guide on leaving France with a child after separation details the authorisation procedure between the parents themselves, which is the parallel battle often running alongside yours.

When the children live abroad or you do, the judge adapts contact to distance instead of cancelling it. Typical orders combine longer holiday blocks, often two or three weeks in summer plus a share of Christmas, with regular video calls on fixed evenings, and allocate travel costs expressly, since a Paris to New York or Paris to Tel Aviv return flight several times a year is a real budget. Propose a concrete schedule yourself rather than waiting for the judge to invent one: dates, flight cost sharing, who collects the child at the airport, where the child sleeps, health-insurance coverage during stays, and a video-call ritual the child can rely on. Where grandparents fear that a stay abroad will turn into retention, the French court can order safeguards such as surrender of the child’s passport to a trusted third party between stays; the mirror situation is explained in our guide on recovering a child’s passport and travel rights through the JAF. And where a parent simply pockets the order and refuses every visit, enforcement runs through the French system regardless of where you live: penalty payments accumulate per missed visit, the file can be sent to the prosecutor, and a French enforceable order can later support recognition steps abroad through the applicable treaties.

If your grandchildren live in Paris or elsewhere in Ile-de-France, a few local realities shape your case. Jurisdiction follows the child: Paris cases go before the family judges of the Paris tribunal judiciaire, while the inner suburbs fall to Nanterre, Bobigny and Créteil, all of which handle heavy international caseloads and therefore insist on complete files with sworn translations of every foreign document. Timelines are realistic but not instant: an agreement homologation can be granted within weeks, a contested summons typically takes several months to reach a full hearing, and interim contact can sometimes be ordered faster where a bond is fading week by week. Build your bundle from day one as if the hearing were next month: proof of your bond with the child from birth to today, photographs, travel records, messages, evidence of regular financial or practical help, the mediation attempt and its outcome, and a one-page chronology tying every claim to a document. In our experience before these courts, the grandparent whose file lets the judge verify the bond in minutes is the grandparent whose proposed calendar survives.

Conclusion

French law gives grandparents and the adults who raised the child a genuine, enforceable place: contact is the child’s own right under Article 371-4, only the child’s best interests can block it, conflict between adults is never enough on its own, the child’s voice is heard without deciding the case, third parties who lived with and cared for the child benefit from a structured European balancing test, and moves within France or abroad call for fast action rather than resignation. The cases that succeed share the same profile: early mediation attempted and documented, a file proving steady affection rather than sporadic demands, concrete proposals adapted to distance, and absolute restraint toward the parents in front of the children. If the door has just closed, do not let months of silence accumulate, because every hearing judges the situation as it stands and settled estrangement is your worst enemy. Assemble your proof now, propose mediation in writing, and take advice before positions harden: in contact litigation, the best-prepared file almost always sets the calendar.

📄 Official circular