On 23 October 2026, The Times reported that HMRC is preparing to deduct money directly from the bank accounts of persistent tax debtors, and a day later The Telegraph described the same move as snooping powers used to raid bank accounts directly. Within hours, the query “hmrc bank account access powers” became one of the fastest-rising searches in the United Kingdom, with Google Trends recording volumes above 20,000 searches and growth of 1,000 percent in two days. The underlying policy is real, it is set out in an official HMRC briefing, and it matters far beyond Britain: the power targets bank accounts, and it can therefore touch British accounts held by people who now live in France, work between the two countries, or kept an account open after leaving the United Kingdom. This article explains, from a French lawyer’s perspective, what London can do to a bank account, what Paris can do in return to accounts held in France, and where the legal border between the two systems actually runs.
I. London has switched its direct bank-raid power back on: how HMRC direct recovery works and how to challenge it
A. Can HMRC really take money from my bank account without a court order?
Yes. The mechanism is called Direct Recovery of Debts, usually shortened to DRD. The official HMRC briefing states the principle directly: the policy allows HMRC to recover money owed by requiring banks and building societies to pay HMRC straight from a current or savings account, including Cash ISAs, held by a customer who owes HMRC money. The briefing adds that DRD can only be used subject to the safeguards detailed in that same document, which means the power exists but HMRC cannot simply help itself whenever it asserts a debt.
The legal basis goes back to the summer Finance Bill of 2015, adopted as section 51 of and Schedule 8 to the Finance Act of that year, as recalled by the House of Commons Library briefing on direct recovery of tax debts. The Commons Library briefing further records that HMRC reviewed the first years of operation and concluded that the intervention had met its policy objectives and helped collect £178 million of tax revenue over the period from April 2016 to December 2018. The power was then paused during the COVID-19 pandemic, having been used sparingly: the official briefing notes that the powers had been used only 19 times in two years before being paused during the COVID-19 pandemic. In the Spring Statement 2025 the government announced that HMRC would restart DRD, use resumed in September 2025 in what HMRC describes as a controlled test-and-learn phase, and wider rollout is scheduled from April 2026 onwards. The October 2026 press coverage therefore describes an existing power entering a much more active phase, not a power invented overnight.
The safeguards matter more than the headlines, because each one is a potential line of defence. First, DRD targets only a minority: HMRC describes the population concerned as debtors who can afford to pay but choose not to, out of £858.9 billion collected in 2024 to 2025, and states that it proceeds only against debtors whose debts are established, whose timetable for appeals has expired, and who have repeatedly ignored attempts to make contact. In practice, that sentence contains three cumulative filters: the debt must be established, the time limit for challenging the assessment must have expired, and the debtor must have repeatedly ignored HMRC’s attempts to make contact. Anyone who is still within an appeal window, who disputes the assessment through the proper channel, or who answers HMRC’s letters and agrees a way forward does not match the published target profile.
Second, the briefing guarantees a human step before any bank is approached where the debtor is an individual: it promises a guarantee that every individual debtor, other than a company or limited liability partnership, receives a face-to-face visit from HMRC agents before the debt is considered for recovery through DRD. That visit is the moment to identify yourself, confirm or contest the debt, discuss payment, and signal any vulnerability. Companies and limited liability partnerships do not usually receive the visit, but the briefing states that they still receive multiple opportunities to discuss and agree how the debt can be resolved before HMRC contacts their bank.
Third, the financial thresholds are published: HMRC will consider DRD only for debtors with tax and tax-credits debts above £1,000, and it commits to always leaving at least £5,000 across the customer’s accounts, so that money needed for wages, mortgages and essential business or household expenses is not frozen. The £5,000 floor is therefore a hard commitment in the published policy, and money needed for wages, mortgage payments and essential household or business expenses is expressly the reason for it. Fourth, nobody is expected to pay what they cannot pay: the briefing points to Time to Pay payment plans, and reports nine in ten plans completing successfully, with an online service allowing many debtors to set up their own plan. Finally, vulnerable customers are identified through a dedicated process and are not considered for DRD, with a dedicated support team offered to help them settle their debts another way.
B. I live in France and HMRC says I owe tax: how do I object and appeal?
The first point to understand is that the published DRD conditions turn on the debt and the account, not on the debtor’s postal address. The briefing speaks throughout of customers who owe HMRC money and of accounts held by those customers; it contains no residence condition. A British account held by someone who now lives in Lyon, Paris or Bordeaux is therefore not shielded by the move abroad as such. What protects the debtor is compliance with the process: answering correspondence, keeping the assessment under challenge while the appeal window runs, agreeing a Time to Pay plan where appropriate, and using the formal objection and appeal route the moment HMRC moves to freeze funds.
The objection procedure is sequential and time-sensitive. Once HMRC has put a hold on the relevant funds, the published process gives customers a 30-day period to object to HMRC, running from the moment HMRC confirms the hold. During that window the money stays with the bank and no funds are transferred; HMRC states that a decision on the objection will be made within 30 days. If HMRC rejects the objection, the debtor has a genuine judicial remedy: where an objection is rejected, the customer may appeal against HMRC’s decision to a county court on specified grounds, including hardship and third-party rights. The county court appeal is therefore the forum where the two most human arguments are heard: that taking the money would cause hardship, for example by leaving the debtor unable to pay wages, a mortgage or essential expenses despite the £5,000 floor, and that some of the money does not belong to the debtor at all, for example funds held for a client, an employer or a joint-account holder. HMRC also publishes statistics on the use of the power and on appeals, under the oversight of its Commissioners, which means the route is used in practice and not merely theoretical.
For a reader in France, the practical sequence is straightforward. Do not ignore HMRC correspondence, because repeated silence is one of the three published triggers for DRD. If the assessment is wrong, challenge it inside the appeal timetable, since only established debts past that timetable qualify. If the debt is genuine but unaffordable in one payment, ask for a Time to Pay plan early, before any hold is placed, and keep evidence of every payment and every exchange. If a hold is nevertheless notified, use the 30-day objection window immediately and in writing, setting out hardship with figures and third-party rights with documents. If the objection is rejected, prepare the county court appeal on those same specified grounds rather than relitigating the tax itself, because the court at that stage reviews the recovery decision, not the original assessment. Joint accounts deserve particular attention: gather statements and agreements showing whose money is whose before HMRC moves, since third-party rights are an express ground of appeal. Finally, keep in mind that asking for help early is part of the published system: the briefing invites anyone experiencing difficulty to contact HMRC as soon as possible, and the face-to-face visit for individuals is designed precisely as a last opportunity to resolve the debt before the bank is approached.
II. Your French bank accounts: what Paris can seize, and what London cannot do on its own
A. I owe tax in France: can the French tax office empty my French bank account?
France has its own direct bank-seizure instrument, and in some respects it is more mechanical than the British one. Debts collected by public accountants can be recovered through what the tax procedure code calls a saisie administrative à tiers détenteur, an administrative seizure served on the holder of the debtor’s money. Article L. 262 of the Livre des procédures fiscales provides that “L’avis de saisie administrative à tiers détenteur est notifié au redevable et au tiers détenteur”, so both the bank and the debtor receive the notice, and it adds a sanction that every debtor should know: “L’exemplaire qui est notifié au redevable comprend, sous peine de nullité, les délais et voies de recours.” A seizure notice served on the debtor that omits the time limits and remedies is therefore void, and that nullity is the first thing a Paris lawyer checks on the paper itself before anything else.
The effect of the French seizure is immediate and severe. The same article states that “La saisie administrative à tiers détenteur emporte l’effet d’attribution immédiate” under an immediate-attribution rule given effect through Article L. 211-2 of the enforcement proceedings code, under which the seizure produces, up to the sums claimed, immediate attribution to the seizing creditor of the seized claim held by the third party, with all its accessories. From the instant the bank receives the notice, the seized balance belongs to the creditor up to the amount claimed, and later seizures, even by preferential creditors, or the opening of insolvency proceedings, do not undo that attribution. The French system therefore leaves less room for negotiation after service than the British hold-and-object sequence: the challenge must be fast and formally perfect.
The challenge exists, but it is fenced in. Article L. 281 of the Livre des procédures fiscales sets the boundary at the outset: “Les contestations relatives au recouvrement ne peuvent pas remettre en cause le bien-fondé de la créance.” A dispute about enforcement cannot reopen the tax itself. What can be argued is, first, “Sur la régularité en la forme de l’acte”, meaning any formal defect such as the missing remedies notice that article L. 262 punishes with nullity, and second, apart from fines and criminal financial penalties, the obligation to pay, the amount of the debt taking payments into account, and whether the sum claimed is actually due. Appeals on formal regularity go to the enforcement judge: the article states that “Les recours contre les décisions prises par l’administration sur ces contestations sont portés dans le cas prévu au 1° devant le juge de l’exécution.” In Paris, that means the enforcement judge of the Paris judicial court, and the Paris and Île-de-France specifics belong here: the competent forum is local, the file must be lodged there, and the bank’s declaration of the account balance will be examined there.
Deadlines in this field are short and strictly applied, and the statute states them plainly. For the ordinary civil seizure that mirrors the tax seizure, article R. 211-11 of the enforcement proceedings code provides: “A peine d’irrecevabilité, les contestations relatives à la saisie sont formées dans le délai d’un mois à compter de la dénonciation de la saisie au débiteur.” One month from service on the debtor, on pain of inadmissibility, with same-day or next-working-day notice to the seizing bailiff. The Court of Cassation polices that calculation debtor by debtor: in its judgment of 4 June 2020, appeal no. 19-12.260, the Second Civil Chamber held that “lorsque le délai d’un mois pour former une contestation relative à une saisie-attribution expire normalement un samedi, un dimanche ou un jour férié ou chômé, il est prorogé jusqu’au premier jour ouvrable suivant”, applying article 642 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which states that “Le délai qui expirerait normalement un samedi, un dimanche ou un jour férié ou chômé est prorogé jusqu’au premier jour ouvrable suivant.” Counting the month therefore requires a calendar, not an estimate, and a debtor who files on the following Monday when the month ends on a Saturday is on time.
Two further French protections mirror the British £5,000 floor in spirit. Article L. 162-1 of the enforcement proceedings code provides that “Dans le délai de quinze jours ouvrables qui suit la saisie et pendant lequel les sommes laissées au compte sont indisponibles”, later operations with a date before the seizure can still adjust the balance, which is why statements from the days around the seizure must be preserved. And article L. 162-2 requires that “Le tiers saisi laisse à disposition du débiteur personne physique, dans la limite du solde créditeur du ou des comptes au jour de la saisie, une somme à caractère alimentaire d’un montant égal au montant forfaitaire, pour un allocataire seul, mentionné à l’article L. 262-2 du code de l’action sociale et des familles”, the French equivalent of a subsistence floor left automatically at the debtor’s disposal. Finally, the French administration generally knows where accounts are: article 1649 A of the General Tax Code requires declarants to report to the tax administration “l’ouverture et la clôture des comptes de toute nature ainsi que la location de coffres-forts”, and individuals resident or established in France “sont tenues de déclarer, en même temps que leur déclaration de revenus ou de résultats, les références des comptes ouverts, détenus, utilisés ou clos à l’étranger.” A British account kept open after a move to France must therefore be declared each year with the French tax return, and an undeclared foreign account creates its own exposure on top of any unpaid tax.
B. Can HMRC seize my French bank account directly from London?
No. Nothing in the published DRD framework gives HMRC a direct grip on an account held with a French bank in France. The power works by ordering banks and building societies to pay HMRC straight from the account, which presupposes institutions within HMRC’s reach, and the detailed safeguards speak of face-to-face visits, county court appeals and British account protections. A French bank with no British establishment is not part of that circuit. If the debt is British and the account is French, HMRC must therefore travel through the law of cross-border assistance, and that journey is narrower and slower than a domestic raid, especially since the United Kingdom left the European Union.
Inside the European Union, France operates a complete mutual-assistance circuit for tax claims. Article L. 283 A of the Livre des procédures fiscales defines its scope by membership: “l’Etat membre requérant s’entend de l’Etat membre de l’Union européenne qui formule une demande d’assistance et l’Etat membre requis de l’Etat membre de l’Union européenne auquel cette demande est adressée”. Under that article, “L’administration peut requérir des Etats membres de l’Union européenne et elle est tenue de leur prêter assistance en matière de recouvrement, de notification d’actes ou de décisions, y compris judiciaires, de prises de mesures conservatoires et d’échange de renseignements”, covering all taxes and duties, related penalties, administrative costs, interest and related charges. The definition does the decisive work for British debts: the requesting and requested States are States that are members of the European Union, and the United Kingdom, having left the Union, sits outside this particular circuit. A British tax claim can therefore no longer circulate between Paris and London through the European directive channel; it must use whatever bilateral and multilateral assistance instruments remain available, and each of those instruments has its own conditions, gateways and refusal grounds.
That the courts take cross-border enforcement formalities seriously, even inside the Union where the directive applies in full, is demonstrated by two of the most recent decisions of the Court of Cassation. On 16 April 2026, the Second Civil Chamber referred two cases to the Court of Justice of the European Union, appeal no. 22-10.198 concerning the Polish company Trans Pol Frigo and appeal no. 23-10.890 concerning the Polish company Tracpol, both opposed to the public accountant of the specialised recovery unit of the Vendée. In the first case, the court recorded that “la dénonciation de la saisie conservatoire à la société avait été effectuée selon les règles spéciales des articles L. 283 A et R. 283 A-10 du livre des procédures fiscales, qui constituent la transposition en droit interne de la directive 2010/24/EU du 16 mars 2010 et du règlement d’exécution n° 1189 du 18 novembre 2011”, then decided that the doubts about notifying a conservatory seizure through the assistance channel required Luxembourg’s answer, and formally “RENVOIE à la Cour de justice de l’Union européenne les questions suivantes”. If even a seizure served between two Member States, under a fully applicable directive, generates a reference to Luxembourg on the validity of the notification, a debtor facing a non-European requesting State should expect French judges to examine every procedural link with at least the same strictness: the enforceable instrument, the channel used, the language and content of the notice, and the remedy indicated on it.
The same lesson already runs through French domestic seizure litigation. Readers dealing with French back taxes after leaving the country will find the mechanics described in detail in the Court of Appeal of Versailles ruling on seizure of a former resident’s assets for a six-year-old French tax debt, which shows how French recovery follows the debtor’s assets rather than stopping at the border. For a reader in Paris or anywhere in Île-de-France, the resulting checklist is concrete. First, declare every foreign account every year with the French return, as article 1649 A requires, because an undeclared British account compounds the problem. Second, if HMRC asserts a debt, treat the British correspondence as seriously as a French seizure notice: answer it, challenge the assessment within its own timetable, or agree a Time to Pay plan before any hold. Third, if the dispute is French, serve the enforcement judge of the Paris judicial court within the applicable time limit, pleading formal defects such as a missing statement of remedies and proving payments that reduce the balance, since the merits of the tax cannot be reopened there. Fourth, if a British claim ever reaches a French bank through an assistance channel, demand the complete chain of instruments and check notification, language, amounts and remedies against the case law above before paying a euro. And throughout, preserve bank statements covering the seizure period on both sides of the Channel, because both systems adjust the seizable balance for operations already in flight.
Conclusion
The October 2026 headlines describe a genuine shift: HMRC’s power to require banks to pay tax debts directly, dormant since the pandemic, restarted in September 2025 and moves to wider rollout from April 2026, with debts above £1,000 in scope, a £5,000 floor left in the accounts, a face-to-face visit for individuals, a 30-day objection window and a county court appeal on hardship and third-party rights. None of that reaches directly into a French bank account, and the European assistance circuit that once connected London and Paris tax offices no longer carries British claims. But the two systems mirror each other uncomfortably: France’s administrative seizure attributes the seized balance immediately, gives the debtor one short month to challenge formal defects before the enforcement judge, and knows about foreign accounts through yearly declaration duties. For anyone living in France with British financial ties, the safe position is therefore the same on both sides of the Channel: declare every account, answer every letter, challenge assessments inside their own timetable, and treat any seizure notice, British or French, as a document whose every line, date and remedy must be verified at once.