KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
France Protests Today: Hurt by a Police Weapon at a Demonstration — Compensation and Criminal Complaints Under French Law (2026 Guide)

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

France Protests Today: Hurt by a Police Weapon at a Demonstration — Compensation and Criminal Complaints Under French Law (2026 Guide)

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On the morning of Monday 5 October 2026, during student blockades that closed hundreds of schools across France, a 15-year-old boy lost a hand near a secondary school in Lens, in the Pas-de-Calais. The prefect of the département described a very serious incident after a company of CRS riot police — the Compagnies républicaines de sécurité, the national police units deployed for crowd control — was sent to the scene. A regional newspaper reported that the teenager had picked up a police stun grenade. The public prosecutor has asked the IGPN — the Inspection générale de la Police nationale, the police watchdog — to investigate so that, in the prosecutor’s words, all light can be shed on what happened. The boy’s life is not in danger, and his school has moved to distance learning with a support unit for pupils.

In Britain, searches for “france protests” surged past 20,000 with growth above 1,000 percent on the same day, with readers asking what the protests are about, where they are happening and what the news means. The underlying questions are practical: when French police break up a demonstration, what force are they allowed to use, what happens when a weapon injures someone who was demonstrating — or simply passing by — and how does the injured person obtain compensation? This guide answers those questions under French law as it stands, using the exact texts and recent court decisions. It is written for anyone who demonstrates, travels or studies in France, including British visitors caught near a protest.

Two warnings before starting. First, the facts of the Lens incident are still under investigation: no officer has been found responsible for anything, and this article presumes nothing about individual guilt. Second, this article describes mechanisms, not the teenager: a minor is entitled to reinforced protection, and nothing here identifies him.

I. What the police may and may not do at a French demonstration

A. France protests today: dispersal, warnings and the absolute-necessity rule

French law starts from a simple principle: a gathering, even an unlawful one, is dispersed with words before it is dispersed with force. Article L211-9 of the Code de la sécurité intérieure, the internal security code, provides that a crowd “peut être dissipé par la force publique après deux sommations de se disperser demeurées sans effet” (may be dispersed by the public force after two warnings to disperse have gone unheeded). An attroupement is the legal term for a crowd or gathering on the public highway that is likely to disturb public order. The warnings, called sommations, must be issued by a designated authority wearing the insignia of office — the préfet, the mayor, or a judicial police officer — and in a manner that genuinely informs participants of the obligation to disperse immediately.

The same Article L211-9 sets the only exception: “Toutefois, les représentants de la force publique appelés en vue de dissiper un attroupement peuvent faire directement usage de la force si des violences ou voies de fait sont exercées contre eux ou s’ils ne peuvent défendre autrement le terrain qu’ils occupent” (members of the public force called to disperse a crowd may use force directly where violence is committed against them or where they cannot otherwise defend the ground they occupy). In Lens, the prefect stated that students threw stones, fireworks and mortars at local officers before the CRS company was deployed — the precise factual setting in which this exception is argued about before the courts. Whether the exception applied on that morning is for the IGPN investigation and, if seized, the courts to decide, not for commentary to prejudge.

Beyond dispersal, every use of force must satisfy two cumulative conditions restated in Article R211-13 of the same code: “L’emploi de la force par les représentants de la force publique n’est possible que si les circonstances le rendent absolument nécessaire au maintien de l’ordre public dans les conditions définies par l’article L. 211-9. La force déployée doit être proportionnée au trouble à faire cesser et son emploi doit prendre fin lorsque celui-ci a cessé” (force may be used only where circumstances render it absolutely necessary to maintain public order; the force deployed must be proportionate to the disturbance to be ended, and its use must cease once the disturbance has ceased). Absolute necessity, proportionality, and cessation once the disorder ends: these three words decide almost every case about injuries at demonstrations.

The same triple requirement binds each individual officer. Article R434-18 of the code, taken from the police code of ethics, states: “Le policier ou le gendarme emploie la force dans le cadre fixé par la loi, seulement lorsque c’est nécessaire, et de façon proportionnée au but à atteindre ou à la gravité de la menace, selon le cas. Il ne fait usage des armes qu’en cas d’absolue nécessité et dans le cadre des dispositions législatives applicables à son propre statut” (officers use force only where necessary and proportionately; they use weapons only in cases of absolute necessity). Weapons — whether a defence-ball launcher (LBD), a tear-gas grenade launcher or a stun grenade — are therefore never routine crowd-management tools. Each shot, each throw, must be absolutely necessary at the moment it happens.

For a British reader planning to be in France during a day of action, the practical consequence is straightforward. You may lawfully watch or join a peaceful demonstration: Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights guarantees to everyone the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association, including trade-union rights. Restrictions are allowed only where prescribed by law and necessary in a democratic society for national security, public safety, the prevention of disorder or crime and similar legitimate aims. But once officers issue the sommations to disperse, remaining on the spot exposes you to lawful force — and, as French courts repeat, to arguments about your own imprudence if you stay beside a violent group. Leaving at the warnings is both the legal obligation and the safest decision.

B. France student protests: when an officer faces criminal proceedings, and why victims rarely obtain a trial

When a police weapon injures someone, two judicial tracks open in theory: punishing the officer and compensating the victim. The criminal track starts with an obvious obstacle. Article 122-4 of the Criminal Code provides: “N’est pas pénalement responsable la personne qui accomplit un acte prescrit ou autorisé par des dispositions législatives ou réglementaires. N’est pas pénalement responsable la personne qui accomplit un acte commandé par l’autorité légitime, sauf si cet acte est manifestement illégal” (no criminal liability for acts prescribed or authorised by statute or regulation, or ordered by lawful authority unless manifestly unlawful). An officer who fires within the framework of Articles L211-9 and R211-13 benefits from this justification. The criminal judge must then answer one question: at the exact second of the shot, was the use of the weapon absolutely necessary and strictly proportionate?

The Court of Cassation gave a full-scale illustration on 5 February 2025 (appeal no. 23-81.356), in a case every lawyer practising police-liability work now cites. The facts, as recorded by the court, were these: “Le 28 avril 2016, en marge d’une manifestation, M. [X] [Z] a reçu un projectile, entraînant la perte de la vision de l’oeil gauche” (on 28 April 2016, on the margins of a demonstration, the victim received a projectile that cost him the sight of his left eye). The projectile came from a defence-ball launcher. The victim, who was not among the violent demonstrators, complained of aggravated voluntary violence causing mutilation by a person holding public authority, and challenged the confirmation of a no-case order. The criminal chamber rejected the appeal. It endorsed the investigating chamber’s findings that “le policier se trouvait dans l’absolue nécessité de faire cesser les tirs de fusée” (the officer had to stop the flare firing), that “un lanceur de balles de défense n’étant pas une arme létale, son action pour contrer l’action d’un homme qui tire des fusées incendiaires apparaît constituer un usage proportionné de la force” (using a non-lethal launcher against a man firing incendiary flares was proportionate), and that the file established “le caractère absolument nécessaire et proportionné de l’usage d’un lanceur de balles de défense” (the use of the launcher was absolutely necessary and proportionate). The shot had been fired at 36.35 metres, within the weapon’s 40-metre range; the victim stood near the flare-thrower and wore a mask against tear gas, which the judges said could cause confusion.

This decision teaches victims and their families a hard lesson. Criminal judges assess necessity from the officer’s position in a confused, violent scene, accept a margin of error about the target, and apply the justification of Article 122-4 generously where flares, mortars or stones are flying. A no-case order confirmed on these grounds does not declare that the injury was acceptable; it declares that criminal punishment of the officer is not legally available. The victim’s compensation then depends on the civil and administrative tracks, which obey different rules — and which succeed where criminal complaints fail.

Two aggravating factors matter for the Lens case without prejudging it. First, the victim is fifteen. The Criminal Code raises penalties for violence against a child under fifteen: Article 222-12 punishes the base offence with “cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 euros d’amende lorsqu’elle est commise : 1° Sur un mineur de quinze ans” (five years’ imprisonment and a 75,000 euro fine where committed against a child under fifteen). Second, mutilation-level injuries belong to the most serious category of bodily harm. Qualification will depend on the medical findings and on the investigation, but the youth of the victim structurally aggravates any criminal qualification retained.

Parents sometimes ask whether they should wait for the criminal case before claiming money. The answer is no. Compensation for the injury does not require identifying, prosecuting or convicting the officer who fired or threw. It runs against the State, before the administrative courts, under rules described in the second part — and it can be pursued in parallel with the criminal complaint, as the victim of the 2016 LBD shot did.

II. How an injured person obtains compensation in France

A. France protests compensation: two State-liability routes that need no criminal conviction

French administrative law offers the injured person two distinct routes against the State, and the victim may plead both. The first is liability without fault for dangerous weapons. In a judgment of 16 April 2025 (no. 23LY01806), the Lyon administrative court of appeal restated the rule in these terms: “la responsabilité sans faute de l’Etat est engagée du fait des risques exceptionnels pour les personnes et les biens qui découlent de l’usage d’armes ou engins dangereux” (the State incurs no-fault liability for the exceptional risks that dangerous weapons or devices create for persons and property). A defence-ball launcher counts as such a dangerous weapon, and the same reasoning covers explosive or deafening grenades used for crowd control. Under this regime the victim does not have to prove any fault by any officer. Three elements suffice: a dangerous weapon used in a law-enforcement operation, a causal link between that weapon and the injury, and, for a bystander, the status of third party to the operation.

The Lyon judgment of April 2025 also shows where claims fail: causation. The claimant’s eye injury was medically described as fully compatible with a defence-ball round, but a ballistic reconstruction showed the round fell 17.6 metres short of where he stood, and the Lyon court of appeal concluded: “à défaut de lien entre l’usage du lanceur de balles de défense et sa blessure, le requérant n’est pas fondé à soutenir que la responsabilité sans faute de l’Etat est engagée” (without a proven link between the weapon and the wound, no compensation on that ground). For the Lens family, the lesson is forensic, not legal: keep every fragment, photograph the scene, secure CCTV and witness details immediately, and obtain an early medico-legal assessment linking the wound to the weapon. Liability without fault is generous on fault and strict on proof.

The second route is Article L211-10 of the internal security code, which makes the State answerable for crowd violence itself: “L’Etat est civilement responsable des dégâts et dommages résultant des crimes et délits commis, à force ouverte ou par violence, par des attroupements ou rassemblements armés ou non armés, soit contre les personnes, soit contre les biens” (the State is civilly liable for harm resulting from crimes and offences committed openly or by violence by armed or unarmed crowds, against persons or property). On 25 March 2025 (no. 23BX01086), the Bordeaux administrative court of appeal applied this text to a woman struck in the neck by a projectile during the 8 December 2018 gilets-jaunes demonstrations: her injuries “sont de ceux qui sont susceptibles d’ouvrir droit à réparation en application des dispositions précitées de l’article L. 211-10 du code de la sécurité intérieure et que cet incident est de nature à engager la responsabilité de l’État à l’égard de la requérante” (her injuries could give a right to compensation under Article L211-10 and engage the liability of the State towards her). In its operative part the Bordeaux court ruled: “La somme de 4 029,75 euros que l’État a été condamné à verser à Mme B… par l’article premier du jugement n° 2004349 du 21 février 2023 du tribunal administratif de Bordeaux est portée à 4 779,75 euros” (the 4,029.75 euros awarded at first instance were raised to 4,779.75 euros). Modest, because her injuries were modest — but the principle travels to grave injuries.

For grave injuries, the figures change scale. In the Bellecour case in Lyon — a defence-ball round fired during a 15 July 2018 crowd-control operation — the administrative court had awarded 72,900 euros. The Conseil d’État, ruling on 27 November 2025 (nos. 505727 and 508932), recorded that “le tribunal administratif a fait droit à sa demande à hauteur de 72 900 euros” (the administrative court had granted 72,900 euros). The court of appeal had annulled that judgment, and the Conseil d’État partially admitted the victim’s appeal while staying enforcement of the appeal judgment. The final amount in that case remains contested, but the order of magnitude for a serious eye injury with permanent effects is public: several tens of thousands of euros, assessed head by head — temporary functional deficit, suffering endured, aesthetic harm, permanent effects, professional impact, assistance by a third party, and, for parents of a minor, their own moral harm.

One defence recurs in every State pleading: the victim’s own fault. In Bordeaux, the ministry argued that the claimant had walked knowingly towards a violent gathering after warnings, seeking total exoneration. The court examines this argument closely but requires proof: bystanders who can show they were passing through, warnings they could not hear, or absence of any alternative route keep their full rights. In Lens, the prefect’s account — projectiles thrown before the CRS deployment — will feed exactly this debate. Demonstrators who throw stones or mortars, and anyone who picks up an unexploded grenade, should expect the State to plead contributory fault. Picking up any police munition is also physically dangerous beyond any legal debate: stun and tear-gas grenades can function with delay or explode on handling, as the day’s events tragically recall.

Procedure has its own traps. A money claim against the State must begin with a prior demand to the administration — typically the Ministry of the Interior — and Article R421-1 of the administrative justice code warns: “La juridiction ne peut être saisie que par voie de recours formé contre une décision, et ce, dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée. Lorsque la requête tend au paiement d’une somme d’argent, elle n’est recevable qu’après l’intervention de la décision prise par l’administration sur une demande préalablement formée devant elle” (appeals go only against a decision, within two months of its notification or publication; a money claim is admissible only after the administration has ruled on a prior claim). In practice: send the prior claim quickly, calendar the two-month appeal period from the express or implied refusal, and do not let the criminal investigation — which can last years — lull you into missing the administrative deadlines. Where liability is not seriously disputable, the urgent-applications judge may order an advance: “Le juge des référés peut, même en l’absence d’une demande au fond, accorder une provision au créancier qui l’a saisi lorsque l’existence de l’obligation n’est pas sérieusement contestable” (the interim-relief judge may award an advance payment even without substantive proceedings, where the obligation is not seriously disputable). Families facing amputation, prostheses and months of care should ask for this provision early rather than waiting years for the final judgment.

B. What to do in the days after the injury: evidence, complaint and help for British visitors

The first hours decide the case more than the first hearing. Anyone injured at or near a demonstration — and the parents of an injured minor — should work through the following steps in order. First, medical evidence: emergency care, then a detailed medical certificate describing every wound, and, for lasting effects, a medico-legal assessment of total incapacity for work (ITT), which drives both criminal qualification and compensation scales. Second, physical evidence: keep torn clothing, fragments, photographs of the scene and of the injuries day by day, and the details of witnesses and CCTV cameras nearby. Third, a written account made within days: where you stood, when the warnings were given and whether you heard them, what the crowd and the officers did, and the exact sequence of the shot or explosion. Memories fade; the State’s file, built by the IGPN and the prefecture, will be precise.

Fourth, the criminal complaint. Any victim may set the public prosecution in motion: Article 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states “Cette action peut aussi être mise en mouvement par la partie lésée, dans les conditions déterminées par le présent code” (the injured party may also set a prosecution in motion, under the conditions laid down by the Code). The civil claim for damages belongs to the victim personally: Article 2 provides “L’action civile en réparation du dommage causé par un crime, un délit ou une contravention appartient à tous ceux qui ont personnellement souffert du dommage directement causé par l’infraction” (the civil action for compensation belongs to all those who have personally suffered harm directly caused by the offence). File first with the prosecutor or a police service, then, if the prosecutor declines to prosecute or three months pass without answer, escalate: “Toute personne qui se prétend lésée par un crime ou un délit peut en portant plainte se constituer partie civile devant le juge d’instruction” (any person claiming to have been harmed by a felony or misdemeanour may, by lodging a complaint, become a civil party before the investigating judge), knowing that “Toutefois, la plainte avec constitution de partie civile n’est recevable qu’à condition que la personne justifie soit que le procureur de la République lui a fait connaître, à la suite d’une plainte déposée devant lui ou un service de police judiciaire, qu’il n’engagera pas lui-même des poursuites, soit qu’un délai de trois mois s’est écoulé depuis qu’elle a déposé plainte devant ce magistrat, contre récépissé ou par lettre recommandée avec demande d’avis de réception” (a civil-party complaint needs either a prosecutor’s refusal to prosecute or three months elapsed since the initial complaint). Becoming a partie civile — a civil party to the criminal proceedings — gives access to the file and the right to request investigative acts. For a minor, the parents file on the child’s behalf alongside their own personal claim for their moral harm.

Fifth, report outside the chain of command. The IGPN investigates the officers; the Défenseur des droits — the Defender of Rights, the independent constitutional authority — receives complaints about the conduct of security forces and can investigate the ethics of the operation. Seizing both costs nothing and creates parallel records that the administrative judge later reads. Keep copies of everything sent and every receipt.

Sixth, for British visitors specifically, organise care and support across the Channel. Emergency treatment in a French public hospital is given regardless of nationality; the GHIC card simplifies billing for medically necessary state care during a stay. On return home, two European instruments continue to protect you. The EU victims’ rights directive requires Member States to give victims access to confidential victim-support services acting in their interests before, during and for an appropriate time after criminal proceedings. France operates such services in every département. And the European Convention on Human Rights remains enforceable against France before the Strasbourg court once domestic remedies are exhausted: Article 3 — no one may be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment — polices the unjustified use of dangerous weapons, while Article 11 protects the peaceful demonstrator. Strasbourg is a last resort after years of domestic proceedings, not a first step, but its existence shapes how French judges read necessity and proportionality.

Readers following the school-protest movement itself — the blockades, exclusions and disciplinary proceedings against pupils — will find that distinct subject treated in our companion guide on student protests in France: school blockade, exclusion and how parents can defend their child. This article covers the other side of the same events: bodily injury by a police weapon and the money claims that follow.

Conclusion

The Lens tragedy concentrates every difficulty of French protest-injury law in a single morning: a minor gravely wounded, a weapon whose handling is disputed, officers acting after projectiles were thrown, and an investigation entrusted to the police watchdog. The legal picture, however, is clearer than the factual one. Force at demonstrations is lawful only after warnings, only where absolutely necessary and only in proportion to the disorder. Officers benefit from a criminal justification that makes convictions rare, as the Court of Cassation’s 2025 LBD judgment confirms — but compensation does not depend on conviction. The State answers without fault for its dangerous weapons and civilly for crowd damage, with awards ranging from a few thousand euros for light injuries to tens of thousands for mutilation, subject to proof of causation and to debate about the victim’s own conduct. The deadlines are short and the evidence perishable: medical certificates, a prior claim to the administration, a criminal complaint that can become a civil-party petition after three months, reports to the IGPN and the Defender of Rights, and, where liability is clear, an early application for an advance payment. Anyone injured — pupil, passer-by or British visitor — should start that chain in the first days, while the traces are still fresh.

📄 Official circular