On November 8, 2026, a magnitude 5.7 earthquake struck central Japan, injuring more than 20 people and disrupting travel in the affected region, according to reports published the same day. For Americans holding tickets to or from Japan, the immediate questions are practical: if the airline cancels the flight, is the money returned automatically, and if the trip is only delayed or rerouted, who pays for the hotel nights, the missed connections, and the ruined itinerary? United States federal law answers most of these questions, but the answer depends on which rule you invoke. The Department of Transportation (DOT) states that passengers are entitled to refunds when the airline cancels or significantly changes a flight; a separate federal regulation describes automatic cash refunds; a 2025 federal appellate decision sent that regulation back to DOT for more public comment while leaving it stayed; and for international itineraries, the Montreal Convention supplies the exclusive legal framework for delay damages, with a strict two-year filing clock. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about any carrier’s situation. It walks through each layer in the order a stranded traveler should use them.
I. Your Flight to Japan Is Canceled or Severely Delayed: What Federal Law Says About a Refund
A canceled transpacific flight triggers the strongest passenger protection in the federal scheme, but that protection has a procedural history every claimant should understand before demanding money. The DOT’s public guidance, the text of the refund regulation, and the Fifth Circuit’s 2025 decision on that regulation fit together as follows.
A. DOT says canceled means refundable, and the regulation describes automatic cash refunds
The DOT’s aviation consumer protection page states the baseline rule directly: a consumer is entitled to a refund when the airline has “cancelled a flight, regardless of the reason, and the consumer chooses not to travel or accept travel credits, vouchers, or other forms of compensation offered by the airline”. The same page extends the entitlement to significantly delayed or changed flights when the passenger declines the airline’s alternative, and it defines a significant change for international itineraries to include an earlier departure or later arrival of 6 hours or more, a change of origin or destination airport, added connections, or an involuntary downgrade. DOT also requires airlines to notify passengers of cancellations, significant changes, and the right to a refund through the notification method the passenger chose. Read the DOT refunds page here: What Airline Passengers Need to Know About DOT’s refund rules.
The regulation behind that guidance, 14 C.F.R. § 260.6, goes further and describes automatic refunds. Its operative sentence provides: “A full refund of the airfare, including any taxes and ancillary fees, is due to a consumer” in three situations: the flight is canceled and no alternative or compensation is offered; the consumer rejects the delayed or changed flight, the rebooking, or the voucher offered instead; or the consumer does not respond to such an offer and the flight departs without them. The provision covers tickets on scheduled flights to, from, or within the United States, which includes United States-Japan itineraries, and it obligates the carrier that is the merchant of record. Full regulatory text is here: 14 C.F.R. § 260.6, refunding fare for flights cancelled or significantly delayed or changed by carriers.
Before treating that regulation as the final word, travelers should know what happened to it in court. In Airlines for America v. DOT, 127 F.4th 563 (5th Cir. Jan. 28, 2025), a coalition of airlines challenged the 2024 rule in the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit that created these automatic-refund and fee-disclosure requirements. The Fifth Circuit held that DOT does hold substantive rulemaking power: “We conclude that DOT has the power to make rules under § 41712 and that this power is not inconsistent with the major questions or nondelegation doctrines.” The reference is to 49 U.S.C. § 41712, the federal statute barring unfair or deceptive practices in air transportation. But the court found a procedural defect: DOT had relied on a cost-benefit study, the Rupp study, that had no antecedent in the rulemaking record, without giving the airlines a chance to comment on it. The remedy matters enormously for passengers: the court did not vacate the rule, and it expressly ordered that “The current Rule shall remain stayed until the matters required above are met.” That means DOT must complete the additional round of comment first. In short, the court upheld DOT’s power to write rules under 49 U.S.C. § 41712, then remanded the 2024 refund rule for another round of public comment and ordered that the current rule remain stayed until DOT completes that step. The decision is docketed as No. 24-60231 and appears on CourtListener under the truncated title Airlines for Amer v. Dept of Trans.
What has DOT done since? On December 5, 2025, the Department published a notification of enforcement discretion stating that it would pause, until June 30, 2026, enforcement of the refund requirements for one narrow situation only: flights renumbered after purchase but operated without any significant change or delay as defined in the regulation. The document explains: “The Department is taking this interim step of pausing enforcement of its refund requirements under these specific limited circumstances while it engages in a new rulemaking to consider whether to modify the definition of cancelled flight through rulemaking.” Read the notice here: Notification of enforcement discretion, 90 FR 55999 (Dec. 5, 2025). The carve-out is deliberately narrow, and its premise is that the surrounding refund requirements otherwise stand. That courts still invoke the Fifth Circuit decision was confirmed in August 2025, when a magistrate judge of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas cited Airlines for America v. DOT for its statement of the Administrative Procedure Act’s notice-and-comment requirement while recommending dismissal in an unrelated screening case, Ebem v. Bondi, No. 1:24-cv-00148-H-BU (N.D. Tex. Aug. 5, 2025), docket 1:24-cv-00148-H-BU, decided August 5, 2025: the observed application is that later courts quote the decision’s procedural analysis, not that they reopen the refund merits. The recommendation cites Airlines for America, 127 F.4th 563, on APA notice-and-comment duties in an unrelated immigration matter. The full recommendation is here: Findings, conclusions, and recommendation in Ebem v. Bondi.
The practical consequence for a traveler whose Japan flight is canceled today is straightforward. Demand a cash refund to the original form of payment in writing, decline any voucher or credit you do not affirmatively want, and keep the cancellation notice and every rebooking offer. If the airline refuses, file a complaint with DOT’s aviation consumer protection office and preserve the paper trail, because DOT’s published position remains that a passenger who declines the alternative is entitled to the refund. Do not accept the position that a schedule change of a few minutes eliminates the right: measure your new itinerary against the 6-hour international threshold and the added-connection and airport-change criteria above.
B. Your contract of carriage still decides the details, and an arbitration clause can move your claim out of court
Federal rules set the floor, but the airline’s contract of carriage sets the mechanics: how to request the refund, which fare differences are returned, and where disputes are heard. Two 2024 decisions show why reading that contract, including the fine print of any third-party booking site, is not optional.
In Herrera v. Cathay Pacific Airways Limited, 94 F.4th 1083 (9th Cir. 2024), decided March 11, 2024 and amended June 14, 2024, docket No. 21-16083, a couple who bought Cathay Pacific international tickets through the third-party vendor ASAP Tickets sued the airline for breach of contract after it canceled their return flight and did not refund them. The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the district court’s denial of the airline’s motion to compel arbitration. Applying California law, the court held that a non-signatory may enforce an arbitration clause under equitable estoppel when the claims against it are intimately intertwined with the third party’s contract, and it reviewed that equitable-estoppel ruling de novo. The court also rejected the argument that 14 C.F.R. § 253.10 barred the motion: that provision, by its plain language, regulates choice-of-forum clauses, and nothing in it prohibits an airline from enforcing an arbitration agreement between passengers and a third party when applicable law permits it. Because the passengers’ allegation that the airline breached its General Conditions of Carriage depended on the vendor transaction, the panel remanded with instructions to stay the action pending arbitration, following the Supreme Court’s intervening holding that a court must stay rather than dismiss when arbitration is required and a stay is requested. In the court’s own logic, the Herreras’ breach-of-contract claim against the airline was intimately intertwined with the online vendor’s Terms and Conditions, so the vendor’s arbitration clause could be enforced against them even though the airline never signed that contract.
That holding has already traveled. In Franklin v. Cleo AI Inc., No. 1:24-cv-00146-JMC (D. Md. July 19, 2024), a magistrate judge of the United States District Court for the District of Maryland quoted Herrera, 94 F.4th at 1087-88, for the California equitable-estoppel test allowing a non-signatory to enforce an arbitration provision, then denied the defendant’s arbitration motion because, unlike in Herrera, the plaintiffs’ claims did not hinge on the third party’s contract. Decided July 19, 2024, the order shows the observed application directly: courts apply Herrera‘s intertwined-claims test case by case rather than sending every travel dispute to arbitration. The order quotes Herrera, 94 F.4th at 1087-88, for the equitable-estoppel test, then refuses arbitration on these facts. Read it here: Memorandum opinion and order in Franklin v. Cleo AI Inc.. A related federal safeguard worth knowing is the regulation Herrera construed: 14 C.F.R. § 253.10 provides that “No carrier may impose any contract of carriage provision containing a choice-of-forum clause that attempts to preclude a passenger” from suing in any court of competent jurisdiction, including a court where the passenger resides if the carrier does business there. Arbitration clauses and forum clauses are different instruments, and Herrera is precisely about that difference.
The second 2024 lesson concerns what a contract claim can recover. In Clegg v. American Airlines, Inc., 2024 ME 82 (Me. Dec. 31, 2024), the Maine Supreme Judicial Court reviewed claims by passengers who said the airline precluded their travel without explanation. The court cited the preemption rule of Morales v. Trans World Airlines, Inc., 504 U.S. 374, 383 (1992), then held that a breach-of-contract claim enforcing the airline’s own Conditions of Carriage is not preempted when it simply holds the parties to their agreement, while state fraud and unfair-practice claims were preempted. Recovery, however, was confined to the contract’s terms: a refund of the ticket and extras, with no consequential damages, attorney fees, or costs. The Maine Supreme Judicial Court cited Morales, 504 U.S. 374, 383, then vacated summary judgment in part so the passengers could pursue a contract claim limited to the ticket refund in American’s Conditions of Carriage. The opinion cites Morales, 504 U.S. 374, 383, on preemption, then preserves only the contract refund claim. Full opinion here: Clegg v. American Airlines, 2024 ME 82.
For the Japan traveler, the checklist from this section is concrete. First, locate the operating carrier’s contract of carriage and read its involuntary-refund clause before you call. Second, if you booked through an online travel agency, read that vendor’s terms too, and look specifically for an arbitration clause and a class-action waiver, because Herrera shows the airline may be able to invoke them. Third, frame any claim as enforcement of the contract’s own refund promise, the way the surviving claim in Clegg was framed, rather than as a free-floating fairness complaint.
II. Stuck, Rerouted, or Out of Pocket: Delay Damages, Deadlines, and State-Law Limits
Cancellation is only one scenario. Earthquakes more often produce the messy middle: flights that operate hours late, connections that collapse in Tokyo or Osaka, and nights the passenger pays for out of pocket. On international itineraries, a treaty rather than state law governs what follows.
A. The Montreal Convention controls delay claims on United States-Japan itineraries, with a hard two-year clock
The Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, concluded at Montreal in 1999 and in force for the United States, applies to all international carriage between member states, which includes tickets between the United States and Japan. Three of its articles do most of the work for stranded passengers. Article 19 provides: “The carrier is liable for damage occasioned by delay in the carriage by air of passengers, baggage or cargo. Nevertheless, the carrier shall not be liable for damage occasioned by delay if it proves that it and its servants and agents took all measures that could reasonably be required to avoid the damage or that it was impossible for it or them to take such measures.” Article 29 makes the Convention the exclusive path: “any action for damages, however founded, whether under this Convention or in contract or in tort or otherwise, can only be brought subject to the conditions and such limits of liability as are set out in this Convention”; the same article adds that “punitive, exemplary or any other non-compensatory damages shall not be recoverable.” Read the full treaty text on the State Department archive here: Montreal Convention text, United States Department of State archive. Congress’s treaty file is here: Senate Treaty Document 106-45, Convention for International Carriage by Air.
The deadline is the provision travelers most often learn too late. Article 35, paragraph 1 extinguishes the right to damages unless suit is brought within two years, “reckoned from the date of arrival at the destination, or from […] the date on which the aircraft ought to have arrived, or from the date on which the […] carriage stopped” (Article 35, paragraph 1). The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit applied exactly that rule in Cohen v. American Airlines, Inc., 13 F.4th 240 (2d Cir. 2021), decided September 10, 2021, docket No. 20-3426-cv. A passenger sued over an incident aboard a December 2015 flight from Paris, France, to Dallas, Texas; the district court dismissed the suit as time-barred under the Convention, and the court of appeals affirmed, holding that Montreal Convention provisions may be interpreted in line with Warsaw Convention precedent and that willful-misconduct arguments cannot circumvent the two-year limit. Because the Montreal Convention covers the claim, its two-year statute of limitation applies, and the court affirmed dismissal of a passenger’s suit filed more than two years after the international flight at issue.
Later courts keep applying Cohen‘s framework well beyond passenger cases. In WE CBD, LLC v. Planet Nine Private Air, LLC, No. 23-1707 (4th Cir. July 26, 2024), decided July 26, 2024, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit held that the Montreal Convention preempted state-law claims over an air-cargo shipment of hemp destroyed in transit, affirming summary judgment for the carrier. The court cited Cohen, 13 F.4th at 244, for the rule that Warsaw Convention precedent guides Montreal Convention questions, and Cohen, 13 F.4th at 246, for the rule that Article 29 makes the Convention the exclusive remedy for claims within its scope. The court cited Cohen, 13 F.4th at 244, for the Warsaw-guides-Montreal principle and Cohen, 13 F.4th at 246, for Article 29 exclusivity while affirming summary judgment for the carrier. Read the decision here: Published opinion in WE CBD, LLC v. Planet Nine Private Air, LLC. The lesson for Japan travelers is calendar-driven: the two years run from when the aircraft arrived, should have arrived, or when carriage stopped, not from when you finish negotiating with the airline. A complaint letter does not toll the treaty clock. If a delay caused provable out-of-pocket loss, such as a nonrefundable hotel night in Kyoto or a rebooked domestic connection, document the loss, mitigate it reasonably, and get legal advice well before the second anniversary of the disrupted flight, because Article 19’s “all measures” defense means the carrier will argue the earthquake, not its operations, caused your loss.
B. State consumer lawsuits face federal preemption, so use the federal channels first
Passengers whose refund demands stall often ask whether a state consumer-protection or small-claims action will succeed where the airline’s process failed. The Supreme Court of the United States constrained that route for more than three decades. In Morales v. Trans World Airlines, Inc., 504 U.S. 374 (1992), decided June 1, 1992, docket No. 90-1604, the Court held that the Airline Deregulation Act preempts state enforcement of laws relating to airline rates, routes, or services. The practical meaning, confirmed repeatedly since, is that the Airline Deregulation Act preempts state enforcement actions and lawsuits that seek to regulate airline rates, routes, or services, which pushes most refund disputes into federal rules and the contract itself. A 2026 Fifth Circuit decision shows how broadly courts still read Morales, even outside aviation. In Exxon Mobil Corporation, No. 25-60108 (5th Cir. July 21, 2026), decided July 21, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit vacated an agency recording rule and set aside the related citation and penalty, holding the mandate exceeded the rulemaking authority Congress granted. The opinion quotes Morales v. Trans World Airlines, Inc., 504 U.S. 374, 384 (1992) for the canon that the specific governs the general. Read the decision here: Opinion in Exxon Mobil Corporation, No. 25-60108. The modern version of the preemption clause sits at 49 U.S.C. § 41713(b)(1), the provision the Maine court applied in Clegg when it threw out the passengers’ fraud and unfair-practice counts while preserving the contract claim. State small-claims courts still hear contract claims framed the Clegg way, but a complaint dressed as a state consumer-protection action over the airline’s refund policy will usually meet a preemption defense.
That leaves three federal or federally supervised channels, in order. First, the DOT complaint: file with the agency’s aviation consumer protection office, attach the cancellation notice, the refund request, and the airline’s response, and reference the DOT refund guidance and, where applicable, 14 C.F.R. § 260.6. DOT complaints create the enforcement record the agency uses to spot patterns, and airlines answer them. Second, the contract route: sue, if needed, on the contract of carriage itself for the ticket refund, within the remedies that contract allows, mindful of any arbitration clause flagged by the Herrera analysis and of the two-year treaty clock for international delay damages flagged by Cohen. Third, the credit-card fallback: if you paid by credit card and the airline will not return money owed for services never provided, federal billing-error rules give you a structured dispute path. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains: “To protect your rights you must also send a written billing error notice to the card company within 60 calendar days after the charge appeared on your statement.” After receiving the notice, the company must acknowledge within 30 days and resolve the dispute with written reasons. Read the Bureau’s instructions here: How do I dispute a charge on my credit card bill, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Treat the chargeback as the last resort, not the first move: card issuers expect you to have sought the refund from the merchant first, and an arbitration clause in your ticket or vendor terms can complicate parallel proceedings.
Conclusion
A Japan earthquake disrupts itineraries, but it does not suspend the legal framework. When the airline cancels, DOT’s published position and the refund regulation point toward a cash refund for the passenger who declines alternatives, subject to the post-remand procedure the Fifth Circuit ordered. When the flight is delayed or rerouted, the Montreal Convention supplies both the delay-damages standard and the exclusive, two-year path for pursuing them. And throughout, the contract of carriage, including any third-party vendor’s arbitration clause, shapes where and how the dispute is heard, while federal preemption keeps most claims out of state consumer-protection law. Check the cancellation notice against the 6-hour international threshold, demand the refund in writing, file the DOT complaint if refused, calendar the treaty’s two-year date, and dispute the card charge within 60 days only after the airline route is documented.